Impaired culture generated cytotoxicity with preservation of spontaneous natural killer-cell activity in cartilage-hair hypoplasia

Immunologic and clinical features of 25 Amish patients with RMRP 70 A-->G cartilage hair hypoplasia

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia is a short limbed skeletal dysplasia associated with impairments in host-defense. To better understand the clinical heterogeneity of this disorder, we studied 25 Amish patients with homozygous mutations in RMRP (RMRP 70 A>G). Despite mutation homogeneity, eight (32%) patients had severe or recurrent infections, two (8%) of these children underwent bone-marrow transplantation for combined immunodeficiency, and the remainder were healthy. Features distinguishing patients who underwent bone marrow transplantation from others were shorter birth length, and lower serum IgG, undetectable serum IgA, and elevated circulating NK cells before 2 years of age. Irrespective of clinical phenotype, most patients had lymphopenia and reduced lymphocyte proliferation to mitogens in vitro. Our cohort analysis suggests that many patients with cartilage-hair hypoplasia are at risk for infection susceptibility particularly during the first 2 years of life. Gauging this risk is difficult, and thus careful monitoring of all patients with cartilage-hair hypoplasia is warranted.

Immunodeficiency as a component of recognizable syndromes

Immunodeficiency occurs in numerous genetic syndromes. While it is the dominant manifestation in primary immunodeficiencies, immune deficits may also be seen in a variety of other recognizable syndromes. Immunodeficiency has been reported in 64 such conditions, adding to the 45 recognized primary immunodeficiencies. These uncommon syndromes with immune defects can present with: (a) growth deficiency (11 syndromes with disproportionate or proportionate short stature), (b) specific organ system dysfunction (18 with gastrointestinal, dermatologic, or neurologic abnormalities), (c) inborn errors of metabolism (13), (d) miscellaneous anomalies (10), or (e) chromosome anomalies (12). In most of the disorders, only some of the affected patients have immune defects. However, in 27 syndromes, immunodeficiency is a constant finding. We briefly review the clinical manifestations of each syndrome and delineate the specific associated immune defects. In most syndromes, the connection between the immune and other defects is unknown. Recognition of these conditions involving both the immune and other organ systems may facilitate accurate diagnosis and management as well as yield information regarding genes critical for the development of the involved systems.

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia--clinical manifestations in 108 Finnish patients

Cartilage-hair hypoplasia is an autosomal recessive metaphyseal chondrodysplasia with short-limbed short stature, hypoplastic hair, and defective immunity and erythrogenesis. We have analysed the clinical outcome of 108 Finnish patients. Birth length was below -2.0 SD in 70% of the patients; the adult heights ranged from -11.4 SD to -5.2 SD. The sitting height percentage was increased in all but 4 patients. Six patients had normal hair. Increased ligamentous laxity was present in 95%, limited extension of the elbows in 92%, increased lumbar lordosis in 85%, thoracal deformity in 68%, genu varum in 63% and scoliosis in 21% of the patients. Defective cellular immunity had been observed in 88% and increased susceptibility to infections in 56% of the patients. Six patients had died of primary infections. The incidence of malignancies was 6%. Childhood anaemia had occurred in 79% of the patients. It was usually mild, but severe in 14 patients. Hirschsprung disease had been observed in 8, anal stenosis in 1 and oesophageal atresia in 1 patient. The intrafamilial variation of the syndrome was considerable as studied in 16 sibships.

Cartilage hair hypoplasia, metaphyseal chondrodysplasia type McKusick: description of seven patients and review of the literature

We describe 7 cases of cartilage hair hypoplasia (CHH) with emphasis on the clinical and immunological aspects. The literature on CHH is reviewed and symptoms in 63 non-Amish cases are summarized. In this autosomal recessive disorder the immunodeficiency, hair abnormalities, and severity of skeletal involvement show extremely variable expressivity, between and within families. Two of the 3 sib-pairs among our cases demonstrate the great difference in expression within one family. At adult age roentgenological abnormalities can be very mild, or even absent. An impairment in cell-mediated immunity is present in all of our cases and seems a consistent manifestation in CHH; however, sometimes it is very subtle and without clinical symptoms.

Cartilage hair hypoplasia: immunological aspects and their clinical implications

Cartilage hair hypoplasia (CHH) is an autosomal recessive form of short-limbed dwarfism prevalent among the Old Order Amish. Mild to moderately severe cellular immunodeficiency is associated with this disorder. Antibody synthesis is, however, normal in CHH. Individuals affected with CHH were found to have marked impairment of T-lymphocyte function due to an intrinsic defect in cell proliferation. Defective proliferation was also found in B cells and fibroblasts from CHH individuals suggesting that impaired T-cell function reflects a generalized defect in cell proliferation in this syndrome. Studies of cytotoxic mechanisms in CHH patients revealed that proliferation-dependent mechanisms (e.g., cell-mediated cytotoxicity and natural killer [NK]-like activity) were markedly impaired while proliferation-independent NK activity was normal. In spite of impairment of T-cell function, an increased incidence of malignancy was not observed in CHH patients. These observations suggest that NK activity is vital in host defense against malignancies and that marked impairment of T-cell-mediated immunity need not be associated with an increased susceptibility to malignancy if NK function is preserved.

Long-term immunological reconstitution by peripheral blood leucocytes in severe combined immune deficiency disease: implications for the role of mature lymphocytes in histocompatible bone marrow transplantation

A 7 month old girl with severe combined immunodeficiency disease (SCID) received a single transfusion of peripheral blood leucocytes from her histocompatible grandfather in an attempt to achieve immunological reconstitution. There was rapid restoration of humoral and cellular immunity which has persisted undiminished over a 54 month follow-up period and the patient has remained free of any significant infections. Lymphocytes of donor karyotype were repeatedly demonstrated in the patient's peripheral blood. In contrast, no evidence of donor cell engraftment in her bone marrow could be obtained by karyotypic, antigenic or enzyme phenotypic analyses. These observations suggest that long term immunological reconstitution may be achieved solely by peripheral engraftment of mature lymphocytes. A review of the literature reveals that this mechanism of immunological reconstitution may not be uncommon following histocompatible bone marrow transplantation for treatment of SCID.

Late-onset rubella syndrome: coexistence of immune complex disease and defective cytotoxic effector cell function

We studied a classical case of late-onset rubella syndrome characterized by multi-organ disease and persistence of live rubella virus in spite of high titres of specific antirubella antibodies and presence of large amounts of circulating immune complexes. When first studied at the age of 5 months there was a low proportion of T8+ lymphocytes. Functional studies revealed decreased activity of K and NK cells as well as alloreactive direct cytotoxic cells (CTL). Removal of cell-bound immunoglobulin and immune complexes tended to improve K and NK cell function in vitro. Plasma exchange transfusions carried out at 9 months of age resulted in clinical improvement. Normalization of cytotoxic effector cell functions and cessation of viremia accompanied recovery from active disease. The results indicate that defective cytotoxic effector cell function is the primary cause for the defective virus elimination in this syndrome.

Natural cytotoxicity in immunodeficiency diseases: preservation of natural killer activity and the in vivo appearance of radioresistant killing

We studied spontaneous natural killer (NK) cell activity and radiation-resistant NK mediated cytotoxicity in four patients with clinically documented severe combined immune deficiency disease (SCID), and in one subject each with intestinal lymphangiectasia and cartilage-hair hypoplasia. We observed the preservation of spontaneous NK activity in all patients despite the presence of profound B- and T-lymphocytopenia and clinical immunodeficiency. NK activity was associated with relatively normal circulating numbers of OKM1+ lymphocytes, a population known to contain NK effectors. Spontaneous NK activity resistant to 3000 rad was increased in all patients, indicating the presence of activated natural killer cells in vivo. The concept of a chronically activated immune system in these patients was further supported by the presence of increased Ia positive T cells in all subjects tested, suggesting that radioresistant NK activity may be a useful parameter to measure when assessing in vivo immune activation. Our data, as well as that of others, supports the hypothesis that at least one population of NK cells is a distinct lineage arising at the differentiation level of myeloid and lymphoid stem cells in the bone marrow.

Intestinal lymphangiectasia and thymic hypoplasia

We have evaluated the immunological abnormalities present in a 6 year old patient with primary intestinal and generalized lymphangiectasia confirmed by intestinal, lung and lymph node biopsies. Lymphocyte loss through the gut was confirmed by the detection of lymphocytes in her stool. An increased enteric protein loss was suggested by hypoproteinaemia, peripheral oedema, and a very short half-life for i.v. immune serum globulin (3 days). Lymphocyte subpopulation analysis revealed a selective loss of T lymphocytes, with a proportionally increased loss of the OKT4 positive helper/inducer subpopulation. Functionally, there was a decrease in proliferative responses to some mitogens and to allogeneic cells, and a lack of T cell help for in vitro B lymphocyte differentiation into immunoglobulin secreting cells. Natural killer function was normal. In this patient, a concomitant thymic deficiency was documented by failure to identify thymic tissue on a thymus biopsy and by an absence or decrease of the serum thymic factor (thymulin) and thymosin alpha 1. No compensatory lymphopoiesis was detected in the bone marrow. In an attempt to increase T lymphocyte development, the patient was treated with thymosin fraction 5. Daily treatment with this preparation resulted in a transient clinical improvement which could not be sustained on a weekly thymosin treatment schedule. However, lymphocyte numbers did not increase during this treatment. The findings in this patient support the notion that T lymphocytes are needed to stimulate thymic epithelium. In situations of excessive loss of long lived T lymphocytes a secondary thymic atrophy may occur and further contribute to the development of a deficiency in cell-mediated immunity.