Voice change in the pediatric patient. A differential diagnosis

Clinical and surgical implications of intraoperative optical coherence tomography imaging for benign pediatric vocal fold lesions

INTRODUCTION

Benign vocal disorders in children include an extensive list of abnormalities creating a variety of debilitating levels of dysphonia. Precise delineation of the benign lesion type and margins may have significant public health implications in children. An innovative technology such as optical coherence tomography (OCT) is being explored to delineate pediatric benign laryngeal lesions. An accurate assessment of the subepithelial morphology may help towards tailoring more personalized therapeutic treatments. This study was established to highlight key morphological and optical features of benign pediatric laryngeal lesions using intraoperative OCT and to suggest clinical implications that arise from such optical imaging.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This in vivo study was performed at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary. Intraoperative imaging was performed on twenty-five pediatric patients ranging from 1 year to 16 years of age presenting hoarseness. Three-dimensional OCT images of benign laryngeal lesions or a subsite of the lesion were acquired.

RESULTS

High-resolution OCT images of 25 patients with benign laryngeal lesions such as nodules, cysts, Reinke's edema, vocalis sulcus, and papilloma revealed distinct and specific morphological differences with normal tissue. Nodules show a symmetrical superficial remodeling of the vocal fold epithelial layer and the basement membrane. Cysts have oval-like shape and are either superficial or deeply located in the lamina propria. Sulcus vocalis OCT imaging allows characterizing if the lesion is shallow or deep according to Ford's classification system. Reinke's edema of the mucosa can be observed and quantified, which may lead to suspicion on the underlying social and medical conditions. Finally, the ability to assess margins and depth of invasion of papilloma lesions is demonstrated, raising the possibility to use OCT with angiolytic lasers for patient-tailored treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

OCT imaging of benign pediatric vocal lesions is promising as it could improve preoperative decision-making and possibly peroperative imaging-guidance for patient-tailored treatments. An assessment of the optical contrast between healthy and abnormal tissue may help towards a more qualitative and quantitative approach to current standard care, especially when diagnosis remains unclear.

Describing pediatric dysphonia with nonlinear dynamic parameters

OBJECTIVE

Nonlinear dynamic analysis has emerged as a reliable and objective tool for assessing voice disorders. However, it has only been tested on adult populations. In the present study, nonlinear dynamic analysis was applied to normal and dysphonic pediatric populations with the goal of collecting normative data. Jitter analysis was also applied in order to compare nonlinear dynamic and perturbation measures. This study's findings will be useful in creating standards for the use of nonlinear dynamic analysis as a tool to describe dysphonia in the pediatric population.

METHODS

The study included 38 pediatric subjects (23 children with dysphonia and 15 without). Recordings of sustained vowels were obtained from each subject and underwent nonlinear dynamic analysis and percent jitter analysis. The resulting correlation dimension (D2) and percent jitter values were compared across the two groups using t-tests set at a significance level of p=0.05.

RESULTS

It was shown that D2 values covary with the presence of pathology in children. D2 values were significantly higher in dysphonic children than in normal children (p=0.002). Standard deviations indicated a higher level of variation in normal children's D2 values than in dysphonic children's D2 values. Jitter analysis showed markedly higher percent jitter in dysphonic children than in normal children (p=0.025) and large standard deviations for both groups.

CONCLUSION

This study indicates that nonlinear dynamic analysis could be a viable tool for the detection and assessment of dysphonia in children. Further investigations and more normative data are needed to create standards for using nonlinear dynamic parameters for the clinical evaluation of pediatric dysphonia.

The feasibility of rigid stroboscopy in children

OBJECTIVE

Voice disorders in children are common but ways of their analysis are limited. We conducted a prospective feasibility study of rigid stroboscopy in children.

METHODS

All children referred for voice analysis during the years 2002-2003 were evaluated including subjective perception of voice, voice recording, flexible or rigid laryngoscopy and stroboscopy. Children were prepared by an explanation and visual demonstration. Local anesthesia was introduced through inhalation of Lidocaine (2%) solution prior to examination. Stroboscopy was performed either by a 70 degrees rigid laryngoscope or by a 3.0 mm fiberoptic-flexible endoscope.

RESULTS

Forty-two children were analyzed. Rigid stroboscopy was feasible in 31 children of whom 7 were under 10 years of age. Short phonation time (7), gag reflex (6), impaired view due to high and posteriorly inclined epiglottis (4) were the main reasons of failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Standard telescopic stroboscopy can be safely and effectively implemented in the majority of children over 10 years of age.

Otologic and laryngologic manifestations of mucopolysaccharidoses after bone marrow transplantation

INTRODUCTION

Children with mucopolysaccharidosis have significant functional impairment of a number of systems because of deposition of glycosaminoglycans. The otolaryngologic system is affected, resulting in conductive and sensorineural hearing loss and voice abnormality.

METHOD

Eleven children who had undergone bone marrow transplantation had their hearing and voices assessed. Unmatched data from patients who had not undergone transplantation were collected for nonstatistical comparison.

RESULTS

The hearing loss in children who had undergone bone marrow transplantation was variable but on average was less severe than in the younger children who had not undergone transplantation. The incidence of otitis media with effusion was diminished in the transplanted group. Approximately half had normal voices.

DISCUSSION

Diminution of the progression of hearing loss and voice abnormality probably occurs in patients after treatment by bone marrow transplantation.

Hoarseness and gastroesophageal reflux in children

The importance of a hoarse voice or voice change in children has not been stressed in the literature in the same way as it has been in adults. We present 21 children who had been suffering from chronic hoarseness for more than three months and had on fibre-optic laryngoscopy findings suggestive of gastroesophageal reflux. None of them had complained of gastroesophageal symptoms. Twenty-four hour pH monitoring revealed that 13 (62 per cent) of these children had gastroesophageal reflux, seven (33 per cent) having gastroesophageal reflux more than three times the upper limit of normal. The pH graphs highlighted frequent refluxes, ranging from 0.4 to 37.4 refluxes per hour (median of 7.3 refluxes/hour). The majority of these refluxes occurred when the child was awake as opposed to asleep, with a median of 14.8 refluxes/hour and 0.9 refluxes/hour respectively (p = 0.0009). The refluxes were classically of short duration. This study suggests that gastroesophageal reflux plays a direct role in the pathogenesis of chronic laryngitis and hoarseness in children.

Voice disorders in children

Pediatric patients with voice or speech problems usually should receive a team assessment in which communication between the pediatrician or primary care physician, the otolaryngologist, and speech pathologist occurs. Although speech or voice problems may prompt an otolaryngologic evaluation, the voice or speech problem simply may be the manifestation or symptom of a larger or more complex disease process. Whether that is the case of hypernasal speech, eventually leading to the diagnosis of velocardiofacial syndrome, or bilateral vocal fold paralysis, eventually leading to the diagnosis of hydrocephalus, it is apparent that patients with speech or voice disorders may eventually require multidisciplinary evaluation. The outlook for children with speech and voice difficulties is better than ever. Recent equipment advances, such as flexible laryngoscopy, video stroboscopy, and nasometry, for detection, evaluation, and management of speech problems have created a better environment than ever existed for care of these problems. Much research is being performed in the area of pediatric voice and speech problems. The National Institute of Deafness and Communicative Disorders and the National Institute of Dental Research have funded and currently fund many projects in these areas. Many pediatric hospitals now have voice or speech disorder clinics in which multiple disciplines are brought together to evaluate children with these problems. Children benefit best when speech and voice problems are managed in an interdisciplinary setting when necessary and by professionals who have experience and training in these specialized pediatric problems. Given the local, professional, and national resources that are expended toward recognition and treatment of speech disorders in children, it is truly a tragedy when those resources cannot be brought to assist children with voice and speech problems. Although voice and speech problems usually are recognized by parents or concerned family members, this task may rest on the pediatrician or other primary caregiver.

The developing role of a paediatric voice clinic: a review of our experience

OBJECTIVE

We report our experience in developing a paediatric voice clinic within a tertiary otolaryngology department and describe the emerging role of this specialized clinic.

MATERIALS

Currently our referral base is divided between other otolaryngologists within our department who require voice assessment as part of the pre- or post-operative management of laryngeal disorders (e.g. cysts, webs, vocal fold palsies, laryngo-tracheal reconstruction) and other professionals within our hospital who require characterisation of voice within the broader task of defining medical conditions in which voice abnormalities exist (e.g. mucopolysaccharidoses, functional dysphonias).

METHODS

The patients were assessed by a team consisting of a paediatric laryngologist and a speech and language therapist. Each patient underwent a perceptual voice assessment and qualitative voice assessment using electrolaryngography. Direct visualisation was attempted and methods of and suitability for, such examination are discussed.

RESULTS

Our experience is reviewed and guidelines for the establishment of a paediatric voice clinic are presented.

Communicative disorders. The first year of life

Disorders of communication have high incidence and prevalence in the fetus, neonate, and infant, and optimal care is dependent on early recognition and intervention. This article reviews receptive disorders, expressive disorders, and their diagnoses.

Relations between voice range profiles and physiological and perceptual voice characteristics in ten-year-old children

Pitch and intensity range of 60 children were recorded and plotted in voice range profiles (VRPs). Different aspects were investigated: minimum phonation threshold, pitch range, and maximum dynamic range. Vocal fold status was determined via laryngoscopic examination. Ten percent of the children had vocal nodules, 23% glottal chinks. Seven voice experts listened to the voices recorded on two separate occasions and rated their properties along 16 parameters including hoarseness. Fourteen percent were rated as hoarse on both recordings and were thus classified as being chronically hoarse. Departures from normal in VRP characteristics were found for children suffering from chronic hoarseness, nodules, and glottal chinks. Children in general seem to have somewhat compressed VRP contours compared with adults, reflecting restricted dynamic vocal capabilities; however, children with mutational voices exhibited an approximation to adult upper VRP contours.

Some Common Myths About Voice Therapy

There are many concepts about voice therapy that are at best, misleading and at worst, incorrect. Through this review, it is hoped that some of these misconceptions will be resolved. Issues reviewed include developmental factors, iatrogenic voice disorders, breathing habits, optimum pitch, palate training, and etiology based on perceptual cues.

Lipoid proteinosis of the larynx: a cause of voice change in the infant and young child

Lipoid proteinosis is an autosomal recessive disorder that may display multiple systemic manifestations involving mucosal deposition of hyalin material. Skin and upper aerodigestive tract mucosal involvement predominate. In approximately two thirds of cases, voice change secondary to laryngeal involvement occurring at birth or early in infancy is the first manifestation of the disease.