Socio-economic factors affecting utilization of a rural Indian hospital

Factors affecting decisions to seek treatment for sick children in Kerala, India

The purpose of this study was to measure the effects of social and economic variables, disease-related variables, and child gender on the decisions of parents in Kerala, India, to seek care for their children and on their choice of providers in the allopathic vs. the alternative system. A case-control analysis was done using data from the Kerala section of the 1996 Indian National Family Health Survey, a cross-sectional survey of a probability sample of households conducted by trained interviewers with a close-ended questionnaire. Of the 469 children who were eligible for this study because they had at least one common symptom suggestive of acute respiratory illness or diarrhea during the 2 weeks before the interview, 78 (17%) did not receive medical care, while the remaining 391 (83%) received medical care. Of the 391 children who received medical care, 342 (88%) received allopathic medical care, and 48 (12%) received alternative medical care. In multivariable analyses, parents chose not to seek medical care for their children significantly more often when the illness was mild, the child had a specific diagnosis, the mother had previously made fewer antenatal visits, and the family had a higher economic status. When parents sought medical care for their children, care was sought significantly more often in the alternative provider system when the child was a boy, the family lived in a rural area, and the family had a lower social class. We conclude that, in Kerala, disease severity and economic status predict whether children with acute respiratory infection or diarrhea are taken to medical providers. In contrast, most studies of this issue carried out in other populations have identified economic status as the primary predictor of medical system utilization. Also in Kerala, the gender of the child did not influence whether or not the child was taken for treatment but did influence whether care was sought in the alternative or the allopathic system.

Postpartum health in a Dhaka slum

This study examines the health, nutritional status, and health care seeking behaviour of a community based sample of 122 postpartum women from an urban slum in Dhaka, Bangladesh. It describes a physically impoverished environment in which malnutrition is serious, and non-trivial morbid episodes as a consequence of childbirth are very common. Malnutrition was found to be widespread: about one-quarter of the study mothers were short in stature, measuring 145cm or less in height; over two-thirds of the women weighed <45 kg; and a similar proportion had a BMI of <20. Based on mid-upper arm circumference, an overwhelming majority (96%) suffered from some degree of malnutrition. During the first 6 weeks postpartum over three-quarters of the women reported a non-trivial illness. The frequency of reported illnesses was significantly associated with both increasing age and parity. Despite severe poverty, most of the women reporting illnesses (71%) received some form of health care from a wide range of western and traditional health care providers, with Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs) and unqualified western care providers being the most frequently utilised. This study highlights the plight of these women in a precarious environment and shows how their health is compromised by cultural and political constraints. We conclude that while the burden of postpartum morbidity is very high, the incorporation of traditional practitioners and unqualified western care providers into maternal health training programs, together with efforts to empower women, could be effective in improving the health status of mothers in this marginalised and fragmented community. To achieve this outcome, a clearly articulated and integrated approach to development in slum communities is required.

Low utilization of community health workers: results from a household interview survey in Burkina Faso

A representative household survey was carried out in order to study the utilization of community health workers (CHW) in relation to other sources of health care. We found three main results: (1) For mild diseases, villagers consulted their CHW only in 8.8% of mild diseases, in 69% the family remained the main provider of primary care. (2) In the case of serious diseases, which the CHW was supposed to identify and refer, the villagers bypassed the CHW in 96.5%. The professional health worker were consulted directly in the majority of serious disease. (3) Sick infants were not taken to the CHW for treatment. (4) No pattern of referral between professional and CHWs could be traced. Severity of disease and perceived effectiveness of the treatment were the most important determinants of health seeking behavior. Availability, distance, and cost of travel and drugs were important service related determinants. Individual and household characteristics such as income, ethnicity, and household size were only weakly associated with choice of curative care. Reasons for the low utilization of CHWs are outlined and policy implications discussed.