Screening for Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy associated mitochondrial DNA mutations in patients with prominent optic neuritis

Clinical features of MS associated with Leber hereditary optic neuropathy mtDNA mutations

Objective:

To determine whether the association between multiple sclerosis (MS) and Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) (known as “Harding disease”) is a chance finding, or the 2 disorders are mechanistically linked.

Methods:

We performed a United Kingdom–wide prospective cohort study of prevalent cases of MS with LHON mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations. The new cases were compared with published cases, enabling a comprehensive clinical description. We also performed a meta-analysis of studies screening patients with MS for LHON mtDNA mutations to find evidence of a genetic association.

Results:

Twelve new patients were identified from 11 pedigrees, and 44 cases were identified in the literature. The combined cohort had the following characteristics: multiple episodes of visual loss, predominance for women, and lengthy time interval before the fellow eye is affected (average 1.66 years), which is very atypical of LHON; conversely, most patients presented without eye pain and had a poor visual prognosis, which is unusual for optic neuritis associated with MS. The number of UK cases of LHON-MS fell well within the range predicted by the chance occurrence of MS and the mtDNA mutations known to cause LHON. There was no association between LHON mtDNA mutations and MS in a meta-analysis of the published data.

Conclusions:

Although the co-occurrence of MS and LHON mtDNA mutations is likely to be due to chance, the resulting disorder has a distinct phenotype, implicating a mechanistic interaction. Patients with LHON-MS have a more aggressive course, and prognostication and treatment should be guarded.

Lack of mitochondrial DNA deletions in lesions of multiple sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To test if mitochondrial (mt)DNA deletions accumulate in brains of patients with multiple sclerosis (MS).

BACKGROUND

Previous studies demonstrated an accumulation of oxidative damage to mtDNA and decreased activity of mitochondrial enzymes in lesions of MS, where activated immune cells produce increased amounts of reactive oxygen species and nitric oxide. The unknown link between oxidative damage and decreased activity of mitochondrial enzymes may be the accumulation of deletions in mtDNA molecules. mtDNA deletions in the brain have been associated with neurodegeneration and aging.

METHODS

mtDNA deletions were quantified by using real-time PCR in laser-dissected, COX-positive and COX-negative single neuronal and glial cells from frozen postmortem brain tissue specimens including normal appearing gray (NAGM) and white matter (NAWM) regions and chronic active plaques of MS patients, and gray matter (GM) and white matter (WM) regions of age-matched controls. Three patients with advance Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases were included as positive controls. The proportion of deleted mtDNA molecules was correlated with pathology and age.

RESULTS

We detected no pathology-related accumulation of mtDNA deletions when comparisons were made among NAGM, NAWM, and plaque of MS brains, or between NAGM-GM and NAWM-WM of patients and age-matched controls. However, an accumulation of mtDNA deletions was noted in non-neurological controls beyond 60 years of age and in patients with Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. As expected, the rate of mtDNA deletions was higher in COX- than in COX+ cells.

CONCLUSION

While aging and neurodegeneration in PD and AD are associated with accumulation of COX- cells and mtDNA deletions, the pathology of MS is not.

Investigation of the role of mitochondrial DNA in multiple sclerosis susceptibility

Several lines of evidence suggest that mitochondrial genetic factors may influence susceptibility to multiple sclerosis. To explore this hypothesis further, we re-sequenced the mitochondrial genome (mtDNA) from 159 patients with multiple sclerosis and completed a haplogroup analysis including a further 835 patients and 1,506 controls. A trend towards over-representation of super-haplogroup U was the only evidence for association with mtDNA that we identified in these samples. In a parallel analysis of nuclear encoded mitochondrial genes, we also found a trend towards association with the complex I gene, NDUFS2. These results add to the evidence suggesting that variation in mtDNA and nuclear encoded mitochondrial genes may contribute to disease susceptibility in multiple sclerosis.

Role of mitochondria in multiple sclerosis

This review presents inherited and acquired forms of mitochondrial dysfunction associated with oligodendrocytopathy and neurodegeneration in order to better understand the degenerative features of inflammatory demyelination. The recognition that various mitochondrial mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis leads to therapeutic considerations, re-emphasizing the importance of early neuroprotection in combination with the approved means of immune modulation.

Familial multiple sclerosis and other inherited disorders of the white matter

BACKGROUND

An objective demonstration of lesions disseminated in time and space remains the core of the last revision of diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis (MS), but this update is now empowered by a weighted use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), which results in an earlier and more unambiguous diagnosis ("MS," "not MS," or "possible MS"). Nevertheless, the exclusion of other entities still remains an integral element of the diagnostic process.

REVIEW SUMMARY

Exclusion of genetic disorders can be challenging in some cases with familial recurrence of MS, particularly when the transmission is mimicking a mendelian or a maternal pattern of inheritance. Vice versa, many forms of mendelian leukodystrophies and leukoencephalopathies present with juvenile or adult onset, progressive or relapsing-remitting courses, intrafamilial phenotypic heterogeneity and MRI signs of multifocal white matter (WM) pathology, features potentially leading to a temporary confusion with MS. With the recent availability of disease modifying medications in MS, the development of specific molecular therapies in inherited WM disorders, and the general recognition of the effectiveness of early treatments, the accuracy of initial diagnostic assessment has become critical.

CONCLUSION

Considering the importance of disease specific treatments, here we review the major characteristics of familial MS and some of the inheritable diseases of the WM. Although no direct genetic link between MS and these WM abnormalities is known, molecular data from the field of rare genetic disorders may also provide some experimental paradigms to a further exploration of MS.

Optic neuritis in multiple sclerosis

PURPOSE

To review the clinical features, natural history, potential pathogenic mechanisms, differential diagnosis, and management of optic neuritis in multiple sclerosis.

METHODS

Relevant literature regarding optic neuritis in multiple sclerosis from 1970 to the present was reviewed.

RESULTS

Optic neuritis is an acute inflammatory optic neuropathy. It is the most common type of optic neuropathy causing acute visual loss in young adults (peak age at 30-40 years), especially among women. Patients usually present with an acute reduction of visual acuity, orbital pain exacerbated by eye movements, dyschromatopsia, and an afferent papillary defect, with or without swelling of the optic nerve head. Visual field testing most often reveals central defects, but others, such as centrocecal, can also occur. Magnetic resonance image (MRI) scanning of the brain should be undertaken in all cases of acute optic neuritis for diagnostic and prognostic purposes. The brain lesions of multiple sclerosis are commonly seen as T2 ovoid high-signal white matter lesions on MRI scans of the brain located in perivenular regions perpendicular to ventricles with variable enhancement. For atypical presentations of optic neuritis, additional laboratory tests, such as cerebrospinal fluid analysis, serologic tests, and visual evoked potentials, prove to be useful in the diagnosis and subsequent management of the patient. The recommended treatment for optic neuritis is intravenous steroids, as shown in the Optic Neuritis Treatment Trial (ONTT).

CONCLUSION

Optic neuritis is often the initial presentation of multiple sclerosis. Recent advances in the understanding of the immune basis for multiple sclerosis has led to earlier and more effective treatment of this disease.

The genetics of multiple sclerosis. A review

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is characterized by chronic inflammation and demyelination in the central nervous system (CNS). Although the etiology of MS is unknown, both genetic and environmental contributions to the pathogenesis are inferred from epidemiologic studies. Geographic distributions and epidemics of MS and data from migration studies provide evidence for some, thus far unidentified, environmental effects. The co-occurrence of MS with high and low frequencies in ethnic groups often sharing an environment, the increased recurrence rate in families, and the high concordance rate among identical twins point to inheritable determinants of susceptibility. Based on the autoimmune hypothesis of demyelination, genetic studies sought associations between MS and polymorphic alleles of candidate genes which regulate either the immune response or myelin production. The most consistent finding in case-control studies was the association with the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (also called human leukocyte antigen--HLA) class II, DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype. Studies on other gene products encoded within or close to the MHC complex on chromosome 6p21.3 (e.g., HLA DP, complement components, transporter proteins, tumor necrosis factor, and myelin-oligodendrocyte glycoprotein) resulted in conflicting observations in different patient populations. The potential contribution of polymorphic alleles within the genes of the T-cell receptor alpha beta chains, immunoglobulins, cytokines, and oligodendrocyte growth factors or their receptors to MS susceptibility either remains equivocal or is rejected. Studies on families with multiple affected members have revealed that MS is a complex trait, that the contribution of individual genes to susceptibility is probably small, and that differences are possible between familial and sporadic forms. The development of molecular and computer technologies have facilitated the performance of comprehensive genomic scans in multiplex families, which have confirmed the possible linkage of multiple loci to susceptibility, each with a minor contribution. Several provisional sites were reported, but only 6p21 (MHC complex), 5p14, and 17q22 were positive in more than one study. The British update demonstrated segregation among regions of interest depending on DR15 sharing, and excluded a gene of major effect from 95%, and one with a moderate effect from 65% of the genome. The extended study by the US collaboration group revealed that the MHC linkage was limited to families segregating HLA DR2 alleles, which suggested that linkage to the MHC is related to the HLA DR2 association, and that sporadic and familial MS share at least one common susceptibility marker. Further identification of MS susceptibility loci may involve additional family sets, more polymorphic markers, and the exploration of telomeric chromosomal regions. Data from these studies may further elucidate pathogenic mechanisms of MS.

Large scale screening of the mitochondrial DNA reveals no pathogenic mutations but a haplotype associated with multiple sclerosis in Caucasians

We report the first large-scale screening of mitochondrial (mt) DNA in 77 Caucasian patients with relapsing-remitting or secondary progressive form of multiple sclerosis (MS) and in 84 Caucasian controls by using the method of restriction site polymorphism and haplotype analysis. No pathogenic mtDNA mutation was found in association with MS. However, mtDNA haplotypes K* and J* defined by the simultaneous presence of Ddel restriction sites at nucleotides 10,394 and 14,798 of the mtDNA in haplogroups K and J showed association with MS at a P-value of 0.001. A relative increase of MS patients compared to controls either with the J* or with the K* haplotype (+10,394Ddel/+14,798Ddel in haplogroup J or K) also was detected (each with a P<0.05). No distinct phenotypic characteristics of MS were observed when clinical data of patients with haplotypes K* or J* were analyzed. In addition to previous complete sequencing in several MS patients, the population screening of mtDNA presented here suggests that mtDNA point mutations are not likely to be involved in the pathogenesis of typical forms of MS. However, the mitochondrial genetic background (haplotype K* and J*) may moderately contribute to MS susceptibility. The reported association between MS and Leber's hereditary optic nerve atrophy, a disease caused by mtDNA point mutations preferentially occurring in haplogroup J, may be at least in part related to the overlapping mitochondrial genetic background of the two diseases.

Inheritance of susceptibility to multiple sclerosis

In recent years, epidemiological evidence supporting the genetic basis of multiple sclerosis has been extended and whole-genome linkage screening has advanced the mapping of the involved genes. Understanding of the known HLA associations has also improved and many candidate genes have been studied.

Is the mitochondrial DNA involved in determining susceptibility to multiple sclerosis?

An increasing number of case reports on Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) associated mitochondrial (mt)DNA point mutations in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) raised the possibility that mitochondrial determinants may contribute to genetic susceptibility to MS. These observations prompted many laboratories including ours to perform comprehensive sequencing or large scale screening of the mtDNA in MS patients. Here we review the available data arguing for or against a mitochondrial hypothesis for MS. We conclude that pathogenic mtDNA point mutations are not associated with typical forms of this disease. A very small subgroup of MS patients, usually with prominent optic neuritis (PON), may carry pathogenic LHON mutations. This partial overlap between the two diseases may be related to the association of MS with a mtDNA haplotype (a set of mtDNA polymorphisms) within which pathogenic LHON mutations preferentially occur.