Quadriceps Strength After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Compared With Uninjured Matched Controls: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Wearable technology identifies differences in change of direction kinetics and kinematics in soccer players with a history of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

PURPOSE

This study investigates change of direction (COD) performance and biomechanics using wearable technology in athletes with a history of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACL-R) compared to healthy controls.

METHODS

A within and between subjects' cross-sectional design was used. The sagittal plane kinematics of the hip, knee, and ankle during 90° side-step cutting were measured with inertial measurement units, while the vertical force was recorded with insoles in the players' boots. Twenty-six professional soccer players participated (mean age 22.7 ± 3.7 years, height 177.8 ± 5.1 cm, weight 69.4 ± 8.5 kg). Sixteen players were healthy controls, and 10 were in a full-time ACL-R rehabilitation programme, assessed 9 months post-surgery. Mixed model analysis and statistical parametric mapping were used to compare COD completion time, kinetics, and kinematics between limbs (involved vs. uninvolved) and groups (ACL-R vs. controls) during the penultimate and final foot contacts.

RESULTS

No significant differences in COD completion time were found between limbs (p = 0.52, d = 0.22) or groups (p = 0.65, d = 0.51). However, during the penultimate foot contact, the involved limb exhibited greater ankle dorsiflexion compared to the uninvolved and controls from 48% to 100% of stance (p = 0.002, d = 0.94-1.86), with lower vertical force production (p > 0.05, d = 0.81-0.95). During the plant step, lower knee flexion angles were noted compared to the uninvolved limb and controls from 2% to 69% of stance (p = 0.011, d = 1.26-1.31).

CONCLUSION

The findings suggest that soccer players with ACL-R can restore COD completion time at the time to return to sport. However, they used compensatory movement strategies on the involved side to achieve similar performance, and this must be considered from a rehabilitation standpoint.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Tale of quadriceps and hamstring muscle strength after ACL reconstruction: a systematic review with longitudinal and multivariate meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to investigate how knee extensor and flexor strength change over time after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR).

DESIGN

Systematic review with longitudinal meta-analysis.

DATA SOURCES

Medline, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane CENTRAL and SPORTDiscus to 28 February 2023.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

Studies of primary ACLR (n≥50), with mean participant age 18-40 years, reporting a quantitative measure of knee extensor or flexor strength were eligible. Muscle strength had to be reported for the ACL limb and compared with: (1) the contralateral limb (within-person); and/or (2) an uninjured control limb (between-person).

RESULTS

We included 232 studies of 34 220 participants. Knee extensor and flexor strength showed sharp initial improvement postoperatively before tailing off at approximately 12-18 months post surgery with minimal change thereafter. Knee extensor strength was reduced by more than 10% compared with the contralateral limb and approximately 20% compared with uninjured controls at 1 year for slow concentric, fast concentric and isometric contractions. Knee flexor strength showed smaller deficits but was still 5%-7% lower than the contralateral limb at 1 year for slow concentric, fast concentric and isometric contractions. Between-person comparisons showed larger deficits than within-person comparisons.

CONCLUSION

Knee extensor muscle strength is meaningfully reduced (>10%) at 1 year, with limited improvement after this time up to and beyond 5 years post surgery. Many people likely experience persistent and potentially long-term strength deficits after ACLR. Comparison within person (to the contralateral limb) likely underestimates strength deficits in contrast to uninjured controls.

Clinician Knowledge of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Rehabilitation Practices: A Preliminary Survey Study

CONTEXT

After completing rehabilitation, patients face a high risk of subsequent injury following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. It is important to identify potential barriers to patient success including clinician knowledge. The purpose of this study was to assess clinician knowledge of research related to anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction rehabilitation.

DESIGN

This was a survey study using snowball sampling.

METHODS

Survey development began with the creation of a construct map and contained varying levels of advanced concepts, level I indicating the most basic and level V the most complex. The survey was distributed to advertise to target population. A total of 60 participants (24 athletic trainers, 33 physical therapists, and 3 dual credentialed) completed the study.

RESULTS

Overall, participants displayed moderate to high levels of knowledge (79.7%-93.5% correct), apart from the implementation of motor learning principles.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinician knowledge may not be the primary barrier to patient success, but the implementation of this knowledge should be explored in relation to patient outcomes. Future research should examine a larger cohort to examine differences between clinician types.

Improved Quadriceps Torque Production With Optimized Biofeedback in Patients After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Hogg, JA, Barger, NB, Bruce, JR, White, CC, Myer, GD, and Diekfuss, JA. Improved quadriceps torque production with optimized biofeedback in patients after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Strength Cond Res XX(X): 000–000, 2024—Optimizing performance through intrinsic motivation and attention for learning: prevention rehabilitation exercise play (OPTIMAL PREP) training strategies incorporate motor learning principles to enhance movement acquisition and retention. We aimed to use OPTIMAL PREP biofeedback to evaluate its potential to improve quadriceps and hamstring torque production in patients with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACL-R). Thirteen subjects 23 ± 19 months post ACL-R completed 5 concentric quadriceps/hamstrings repetitions on an isokinetic dynamometer for each limb and counterbalanced condition at 60°·s−1. For the control condition, subjects were instructed to perform the exercise “as hard and fast as possible.” For the OPTIMAL PREP condition, subjects were additionally told that “Research shows that if you focus on moving the line on the screen (external focus) you will exhibit greater quadriceps output (enhanced expectancies)” and were given the choice of graphical representation for the biofeedback (autonomy support). Quadriceps and hamstrings peak torque, rate of force development, and torque-angle waveforms were analyzed with 2 × 2 RMANOVAs (a priori >0.06). The ACL-R limb demonstrated increased quadriceps peak torque in the OPTIMAL PREP condition than in the control condition ( = 0.13, interaction p = 0.21, pairwise Cohen's d = 0.63). Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction limb quadriceps deficits remained near terminal extension (14–45°; peak Cohen's d = 0.57, p < 0.001). For hamstrings peak torque, we observed moderate effects for condition (OPTIMAL PREP greater; = 0.10, p = 0.29) and limb (uninvolved greater; = 0.13, p = 0.22). Easily implementable OPTIMAL PREP training strategies improved ACL-R limb quadriceps torque production, resulting in between-limb parity. However, asymmetries still existed near terminal extension.

Autograft Choice and Jumping Performance After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Comparative Study on Professional Athletes

Background

The extensor apparatus of the knee is of paramount importance in generating the torque needed for a countermovement jump (CMJ), especially in jumping athletes. In anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) procedures, graft harvesting from the extensor apparatus may dramatically affect extensor strength and jumping performance.

Hypothesis

The focused jump training of professional jumping athletes would increase the likelihood of restoring jumping performance after ACLR, despite the graft choice (autologous bone-patellar tendon-bone [BPTB] or hamstring [HS] tendon).

Study Design

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

A retrospective evaluation of prospectively collected data was carried out. Only professional athletes were included, and all surgical procedures were performed by a single experienced surgeon. Data collection considered the type of surgery, sports activity, and functional evaluation at 3 months after surgery. From the functional evaluation, data on single-leg hop (SLH) test, triple hop (TH) test, and CMJ were extracted. Limb symmetry index (LSI) for maximal voluntary isometric contraction of the quadriceps and for each of the jumping tests was calculated. Multiple analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models were used to assess mean differences among groups for the LSI in CMJ, SLH, and TH and estimate the effect of confounders.

Results

From a subsequent series of 208 athletes, 44 professional athletes were included for data collection. Of these, 26 were male and 18 were female. A jumping sport (basketball, volleyball) was played by 17 athletes, while a running sport (soccer, judo, rugby, tennis, ski) was performed by 27 athletes. The mean time from injury to surgery was 17.8 ± 14.5 days. At 90 days from surgery, the overall mean LSI for CMJ was 85.3% ± 8.9%, for SLH was 92.2% ± 6.4%, and for TH was 90.8% ± 6.1%. When ANCOVA was fitted using the interaction term with BPTB autograft and jumping sport, a nonsignificant effect on LSI for CMJ (P = .56), SLH (P = .72), and TH (P = .98) was observed.

Conclusion

The results of the present investigation on professional athletes showed that no difference occurred within the study cohort in overall jumping performance between jumping and running athletes undergoing ACLR either with BPTB or with HS tendon grafts. Although some evidence suggests that quadriceps strength may be dramatically affected by the harvesting of BPTB, the overall performance of the jump was not compromised.

Angle-Specific Analysis of Isokinetic Quadriceps and Hamstring Strength at 6 and 12 Months After Unilateral ACL Reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Quadriceps and hamstring strength deficits are related to the increased risk of reinjury after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR).

HYPOTHESIS

Knee angle-specific quadriceps and hamstring strength differences would be observed in patients with ACLR 6 and 12 months after surgery.

STUDY DESIGN

Case-series.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 4.

METHODS

A total of 23 postprimary unilateral ACLR patients followed-up at 6 and 12 months postoperatively and 25 controls were included. Isokinetic knee extension and flexion strength were evaluated at 60 deg/s from 20° to 90°. Statistical parametric mapping were performed to explore the angle-specific strength and the limb symmetry index (LSI).

RESULTS

At 6 months postoperatively, the reconstructed leg demonstrated lower knee extension and flexion strength than the contralateral (20°-77°, 24°-90°) (P < 0.01) and control legs (22°-90°, 40°-82°) (P < 0.01). From 6 months to 12 months, knee extension (60°-90°) and flexion (20°-79°) strength improved in the reconstructed leg (P < 0.05), while LSI remained unchanged (P > 0.02). At 12 months, knee extension strength differences persisted in the reconstructed leg compared with the contralateral (20°-81°) and controls (25°-63°) (P < 0.01). ACLR patients had lower LSI of knee extension strength at 6 (20°-59°) and 12 (24°-57°) months postoperatively than the controls (P < 0.02).

CONCLUSION

The reconstructed leg exhibited differences in knee extension strength compared with the contralateral and control legs. Although bilateral knee extension strength increased from 6 to 12 months postoperatively, LSI did not show improvement during this period.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Quadriceps restoration was observed only in knee flexion angles greater than 60° compared with controls. Future studies should investigate whether knee extension strength, especially in lower flexion angles, can be enhanced through rehabilitation programs. Furthermore, assessing the impact of this improvement on long-term outcomes and reinjury risk in ACLR patients is warranted.

Knee Extensor Torque Steadiness and Quadriceps Activation Variability in Collegiate Athletes 4, 6, and 12 Months After ACL Reconstruction

Background

Quadriceps performance after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is typically characterized by peak force/torque, but the ability to generate consistent knee extensor torque may be clinically meaningful.

Purpose/Hypothesis

The purpose of this study was to evaluate knee extensor torque steadiness and quadriceps activation variability in collegiate athletes 4 to 12 months after ACLR. It was hypothesized that between-limb asymmetries in torque steadiness and activation variability would be observed and that steadiness would be associated with activation variability and peak knee extensor torque symmetry.

Study Design

Case-control study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

A total of 30 National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I athletes completed maximal voluntary isometric contractions 4, 6, and 12 months after ACLR. Torque and surface electromyography of the superficial quadriceps were recorded. Torque steadiness was calculated as the mean difference between initial and low-pass filtered torque signals and was expressed as a percentage of peak torque. Quadriceps activation variability was calculated similarly and was expressed as a percentage of peak electromyography. Linear mixed models were used to assess change in torque steadiness and activation variability over time. Associations between torque steadiness of the operated limb, activation variability, and quadriceps strength symmetry were evaluated using the Spearman correlation coefficient.

Results

Limb-by-time interactions were detected for torque steadiness and activation variability (P < .001), with reductions (improvements) in limb steadiness and activation variability observed with increasing time since surgery. Between-limb differences in torque steadiness and activation variability were observed at 4 and 6 months postoperatively (P < .05). Significant associations between operated limb torque steadiness and quadriceps activation variability were observed at 4 months (P < .001) and 6 months (P < .01). Torque steadiness of the operated limb was associated with peak knee extensor torque symmetry at 4 months (r S = -0.49; P < .01) and 6 months (r S = -0.49; P < .01).

Conclusion

In collegiate athletes, impaired knee extensor torque steadiness of the operated limb and associated abnormal quadriceps activation patterns were observed 4 to 12 months after ACLR, and the consistency of knee extensor torque production was associated with greater quadriceps strength asymmetries, particularly 4 to 6 months after surgery. Operated limb torque steadiness and activation variability improved from 4 to 12 months after ACLR. Clinical assessment of knee extensor torque steadiness after ACLR may improve prognosis and specificity of rehabilitation efforts.

Strength of the Uninvolved Limb Following Return to Activity After ACL Injury: Implications for Symmetry as a Marker of Sufficient Strength

Background

Muscular strength deficits are common after ACL injury. While the Limb Symmetry Index (LSI), using the uninvolved limb as a reference, is widely used, negative strength adaptations may affect both limbs post-injury. It is uncertain how the strength of the uninvolved limb in those with an ACL injury compares to uninjured individuals, making it unclear whether it is appropriate as a benchmark for determining sufficient strength.

Purpose

To compare the strength of key lower extremity muscles of the uninvolved limb in those with history of ACL injury (ACL-I) to the dominant limb in individuals with no history of ACL injury (control).

Study Design

Cross-sectional study. Methods: A total of 5,727 military cadets were examined, with 82 females and 126 males in the ACL-I group and 2,146 females and 3,373 males in the control group. Maximum isometric strength was assessed for six muscle groups measured with a hand-held dynamometer. Separate two-way ANOVAs with limb and sex were performed for each muscle group.

Results

Significant main effects for limb were observed with the uninvolved limb in the ACL-I group displaying greater strength compared to the dominant limb in the control group for the quadriceps, hamstrings, and gluteus medius, but effect sizes were small (Cohen's d <0.25). Significant main effects for sex were observed with greater male muscular strength in all six muscle groups with small to large effect sizes (Cohen's d 0.49-1.46). No limb-by-sex interactions were observed.

Conclusions

There was no evidence of reduced strength in the uninvolved limb in those with a history of ACL injury compared to the dominant limb in those with no prior ACL injury. This finding suggests that, after clearance to return to activities, the uninvolved limb can be used as a standard for comparison of sufficient strength, including when using the LSI. Level of Evidence: Level 3.

Validity of a commercially available load cell dynamometer in measuring isometric knee extension torque in patients with knee disorders

OBJECTIVE

Assess the validity of hand-held dynamometry (HHD) and the Tindeq Progressor (TP) in assessing peak isometric knee extension torque and limb symmetry index (LSI) versus isokinetic dynamometer (IKD).

DESIGN

Prospective cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Laboratory.

PARTICIPANTS

31 individuals with unilateral knee disorders (21 female; 28.3 ± 11 years).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Peak isometric knee extension torque; Knee extension LSI.

RESULTS

Strong to almost perfect (p < 0.001) correlations (Cohen's Kappa k) with IKD were found for both devices for peak torque of the uninvolved limb (HHD [k = 0.84], TP [k = 0.91]) and involved limb (HHD [k = 0.93], TP [k = 0.98]). For LSI, moderate to strong (p < 0.001) correlations with IKD were found for HHD (k = 0.79) and TP (k = 0.89). Mean bias errors were equivalent for determining LSI (HHD = 0.02%; TP = 0.03%). Both HHD and TP were highly sensitive (96.2-100.0%) and specific (100.0%) at the 70% LSI threshold. TP showed higher sensitivity and specificity at the 90% LSI threshold.

CONCLUSION

HHD and TP are valid in measuring isometric knee extension torque with the reference standard IKD. TP showed superior validity in identifying LSI. TP also shows greater specificity in identifying the 90% LSI threshold.

No sign of weakness: a systematic review and meta-analysis of hip and calf muscle strength after anterior cruciate ligament injury

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to determine hip and lower-leg muscle strength in people after ACL injury compared with an uninjured control group (between people) and the uninjured contralateral limb (between limbs).

DESIGN

Systematic review with meta-analysis.

DATA SOURCES

MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane CENTRAL and SportDiscus to 28 February 2023.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

Primary ACL injury with mean age 18-40 years at time of injury. Studies had to measure hip and/or lower-leg muscle strength quantitatively (eg, dynamometer) and report muscle strength for the ACL-injured limb compared with: (i) an uninjured control group and/or (ii) the uninjured contralateral limb. Risk of bias was assessed according to Cochrane Collaboration domains.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight studies were included (n=23 measured strength ≤12 months post-ACL reconstruction). Most examined hip abduction (16 studies), hip extension (12 studies) and hip external rotation (7 studies) strength. We found no meaningful difference in muscle strength between people or between limbs for hip abduction, extension, internal rotation, flexion or ankle plantarflexion, dorsiflexion (estimates ranged from -9% to +9% of comparator). The only non-zero differences identified were in hip adduction (24% stronger on ACL limb (95% CI 8% to 42%)) and hip external rotation strength (12% deficit on ACL limb (95% CI 6% to 18%)) compared with uninjured controls at follow-ups >12 months, however both results stemmed from only two studies. Certainty of evidence was very low for all outcomes and comparisons, and drawn primarily from the first year post-ACL reconstruction.

CONCLUSION

Our results do not show widespread or substantial muscle weakness of the hip and lower-leg muscles after ACL injury, contrasting deficits of 10%-20% commonly reported for knee extensors and flexors. As it is unclear if deficits in hip and lower-leg muscle strength resolve with appropriate rehabilitation or no postinjury or postoperative weakness occurs, individualised assessment should guide training of hip and lower-leg strength following ACL injury.

PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER

CRD42020216793.

Beware of the "Moving Target" - Uninvolved Limb Strength Increases to Exceed Preoperative Values During Rehabilitation After ACL Reconstruction in Male Professional and Recreational Athletes

OBJECTIVE: To describe the changes in quadriceps and hamstrings muscle strength in the uninvolved limb of male professional and recreational athletes during rehabilitation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) and compare to preoperative strength values. DESIGN: Prospective longitudinal study. METHODS: During rehabilitation, 665 participants who underwent unilateral ACLR performed a strength test preoperatively and every 6 weeks after surgery for up to 9 months. Isokinetic quadriceps and hamstrings strength of the uninvolved limb were measured at an angular velocity of 60°/s and normalized to body weight (N·m/kg). RESULTS: Quadriceps and hamstrings strength of the uninvolved limb gradually increased during rehabilitation until 6 months post-ACLR, and plateaued thereafter. Postoperative quadriceps' strength significantly exceeded preoperative values by 3 months for professional (2.99 N·m/kg; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 2.93, 3.04; P = .007) and by 6 months for recreational athletes (2.77 N·m/kg; 95% CI: 2.71, 2.83; P<.001), and hamstrings exceeded presurgery levels by 4.5 months (1.71 N·m/kg; 95% CI: 1.67, 1.74; P<.001 and 1.43 N·m/kg; 95% CI: 1.40, 1.46; P = .002, professional and recreational athletes respectively). CONCLUSION: In male professional and recreational athletes, uninvolved limb quadriceps and hamstrings strength gradually improved after ACLR, until 6 months after surgery. The uninvolved limb's strength may present as a "moving target" that requires consistent monitoring during rehabilitation. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2024;54(4):1-9. Epub 14 December 2023. doi:10.2519/jospt.2023.11961.

Quadriceps and Hamstrings Activation Peaks Earlier as Athletes Repeatedly Hop, but There are Differences Depending on ACL Reconstruction Technique

Background

After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction (ACLR) athletes face the challenge of regaining their previous competitive level while avoiding re-injury and early knee joint cartilage degeneration. Quadriceps and hamstrings strength reductions and neuromuscular alterations potentially related to risk of re-injury are present after ACLR and relate to deficits in muscle activation.

Design

Cross-sectional laboratory study.

Purpose

To examine quadriceps and hamstrings muscle activation during repeated hops in healthy pivoting-sport athletes and those who had undergone ACLR (bone-tendon-bone and semitendinosus graft) who had met functional criteria allowing return to training.

Methods

Surface electromyography (SEMG) was recorded from vastus medialis and lateralis and medial and lateral hamstrings bilaterally during 30 seconds' repeated hopping in male athletes on average eight months after ACLR surgery (5-12 months). All patients underwent hamstring (HS) (n=24) or bone-tendon-bone (BTB) reconstruction (n=20) and were compared to healthy controls (n=31). The SEMG signals were normalized to those obtained during maximal voluntary isometric contraction.

Results

A significant time shift in peak muscle activation (earlier) was seen for: vastus medialis and vastus lateralis activation in the control group, in the BTB group's healthy (but not injured) leg and both legs of the HS group. A significant time shift in peak muscle activation was seen for lateral hamstrings (earlier) in all but the BTB group's injured leg and the medial hamstrings in the control group only. Lower peak activation levels of the vastus lateralis (p\<0.001) and vastus medialis (p\<0.001) were observed in the injured compared to healthy legs and lower peak lateral hamstrings activity (p\<0.009) in the injured leg compared to control leg. Decline in medial hamstring peak activation (p\<0.022) was observed between 1st and 3rd phase of the hop cycle in all groups.

Conclusion

Repeated hop testing revealed quadriceps and hamstring activation differences within ACLR athletes, and compared to healthy controls, that would be missed with single hop tests.

Level of evidence

3.

Weaker Quadriceps Muscle Strength With a Quadriceps Tendon Graft Compared With a Patellar or Hamstring Tendon Graft at 7 Months After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Impaired quadriceps muscle strength after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is associated with worse clinical outcomes and a risk of reinjuries. Yet, we know little about quadriceps muscle strength in patients reconstructed with a quadriceps tendon (QT) graft, which is increasing in popularity worldwide.

PURPOSE

To describe and compare isokinetic quadriceps strength in patients undergoing ACLR with a QT, hamstring tendon (HT), or bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) autograft.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

We included patients with QT grafts (n = 104) and matched them to patients with HT (n = 104) and BPTB (n = 104) grafts based on age, sex, and associated meniscal surgery. Data were collected through clinical strength testing at a mean of 7 ± 1 months postoperatively. Isokinetic strength was measured at 90 deg/s, and quadriceps strength was expressed as the limb symmetry index (LSI) for peak torque, total work, torque at 30° of knee flexion, and time to peak torque.

RESULTS

Patients with QT grafts had the most impaired isokinetic quadriceps strength, with the LSI ranging between 67.5% and 75.1%, followed by those with BPTB grafts (74.4%-81.5%) and HT grafts (84.0%-89.0%). Patients with QT grafts had a significantly lower LSI for all variables compared with patients with HT grafts (mean difference: peak torque: -17.4% [95% CI, -21.7 to -13.2], P < .001; total work: -15.9% [95% CI, -20.6 to -11.1], P < .001; torque at 30° of knee flexion: -8.8% [95% CI, -14.7 to -2.9], P = .001; time to peak torque: -17.7% [95% CI, -25.8 to -9.6], P < .001). Compared with patients with BPTB grafts, patients with QT grafts had a significantly lower LSI for all variables (mean difference: peak torque: -6.9% [95% CI, -11.2 to -2.7], P < .001; total work: -7.7% [95% CI, -12.4 to -2.9], P < .001; torque at 30° of knee flexion: -6.3% [95% CI, -12.2 to -0.5], P = .03; time to peak torque: -8.8% [95% CI, -16.9 to -0.7], P = .03). None of the graft groups reached a mean LSI of >90% for peak torque (QT: 67.5% [95% CI, 64.8-70.1]; HT: 84.9% [95% CI, 82.4-87.4]; BPTB: 74.4% [95% CI, 72.0-76.9]).

CONCLUSION

At 7 months after ACLR, patients with QT grafts had significantly worse isokinetic quadriceps strength than patients with HT and BPTB grafts. None of the 3 graft groups reached a mean LSI of >90% in quadriceps strength.

Comparing Short-Term Knee-Related Quality of Life and Associated Clinical Outcomes Between Youth With and Without a Sport-Related Knee Injury

OBJECTIVE

To compare short-term changes in knee-related quality of life (QOL) and associated clinical outcomes between youth with and without a sport-related knee injury.

DESIGN

Prospective cohort study.

SETTING

Sport medicine and physiotherapy clinics.

PARTICIPANTS

Youth (11-19 years old) who sustained an intra-articular, sport-related knee injury in the past 4 months and uninjured youth of similar age, sex, and sport.

INDEPENDENT VARIABLE

Injury history.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Knee-related QOL (Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score, KOOS), knee extensor and flexor strength (dynamometry), physical activity (accelerometer), fat mass index (FMI; bioelectrical impedance), and kinesiophobia (Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia, TSK) were measured at baseline (within 4 months of injury) and at 6-month follow-up. Wilcoxon rank sum tests assessed between-group differences for all outcomes. Regression models assessed the association between injury history and outcome change (baseline to 6-month follow-up), considering sex. The influence of injury type, baseline values, and physiotherapy attendance was explored.

RESULTS

Participants' (93 injured youth, 73 uninjured control subjects) median age was 16 (range 11-20) years and 66% were female. Despite greater improvements in KOOS QOL scores (20; 95% confidence interval, 15-25), injured participants demonstrated deficits at 6-month follow-up (z = 9.3, P < 0.01) compared with control subjects, regardless of sex. Similar findings were observed for knee extensor and flexor strength and TSK scores but not for physical activity or FMI. Lower baseline values were associated with greater outcome changes in injured youth.

CONCLUSIONS

Youth have worse knee-related QOL, muscle strength, and kinesiophobia early after a sport-related knee injury than control subjects. Despite improvements, deficits persist 6 months later.

The association between knee muscle performance and clinical outcomes of knee function 1-4 years after a sport-related knee joint injury

OBJECTIVE

Estimate the association between index leg knee muscle strength and rate of torque development (RTD), and self-reported and performance-based (i.e., hop) knee function in persons 1-4 years after a sport-related knee joint injury.

METHODS

Data were collected at baseline of a clinical trial. Assessments included the Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score Sport & Recreation subscale (KOOSsport), 6-m timed hop (TH), and peak concentric isokinetic knee extensor and flexor torque and isometric RTD. Associations between peak torque and RTD with KOOSsport and TH were assessed using multivariable regression with nonlinear transformations.

RESULTS

53 participants (64.2% female) were included. Knee extensor peak torque was nonlinearly related to TH time, with a strong inverse relationship at lower torque values that changed as torque increased. Results were inconsistent for flexor peak torque, extensor RTD and flexor RTD, with inconsistencies in relationship shape and estimates of association between primary and sensitivity analyses. There was no association between strength/RTD and KOOSsport.

CONCLUSION

There was a nonlinear relationship between knee extensor strength and hop function, with lower strength being associated with a stronger relationship. As strength values increased, the relationship attenuated. Knee extensor and flexor strength, or RTD, were not associated with self-reported function.

Favorable Patient-Reported, Clinical, and Functional Outcomes 2 Years After ACL Repair and InternalBrace Augmentation Compared With ACL Reconstruction and Healthy Controls

BACKGROUND

Recently, interest in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) preservation and repair after proximal ACL tears has been resurrected. Although good clinical outcomes have been reported in the literature with adequate patient selection, to date detailed scientific evidence for the functional benefit of primary ACL repair with ligament augmentation is scarce.

PURPOSE

To compare patient-reported, clinical, and functional outcomes in patients 2 years after ACL repair and InternalBrace augmentation (ACL-IB) with age- and sex-matched patients 2 years after ACL reconstruction (ACL-R) and with matched healthy controls.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

In total, 29 patients 2 years after ACL-IB, 27 sex- and age- matched patients 2 years after ACL-R (hamstring autografts), and 29 matched healthy controls were included. Patient-reported outcomes were assessed using the International Knee Documentation Committee score, Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score, EQ-5D-5L, Tegner Activity Scale, and Anterior Cruciate Ligament Return to Sports after Injury scale. Surgery time was recorded. For clinical outcomes, range of motion and thigh and shank circumference were measured, and passive anterior translation was determined using the Rolimeter. Isokinetic muscle strength was measured using a Biodex dynamometer. The limb symmetry index (operated/contralateral or nondominant/dominant × 100), side-to-side differences (operated - contralateral, nondominant - dominant), and hamstring-quadriceps ratios were calculated for functional parameters. Failure and reoperation rates were not compared.

RESULTS

Two years after surgery, patients treated with ACL-IB showed good to excellent patient-reported outcomes comparable with those of patients after ACL-R. Surgery time, including concomitant surgeries, was significantly shorter in the ACL-IB group (mean, 81 minutes) compared with the ACL-R group (mean, 97 minutes) (P = .024). Isokinetic muscle strength was comparable between patient groups without significant differences in extensor and flexor strength or in hamstring-quadriceps ratios.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that ACL-IB achieves comparable patient-reported, clinical, and functional outcomes with ACL-R at 2 years postoperatively and, after careful patient selection, should be considered as a valuable early treatment alternative for proximal ACL tears.

REGISTRATION

NCT04429165 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).

Interlimb Asymmetry in Knee Extension Moment During Double-Leg Squatting Is Associated With Persistent Quadriceps Weakness After ACL Reconstruction

Background

Although double-leg squatting is less dynamic and places less demand on the quadriceps compared with landing tasks, the relationship between double-leg squatting biomechanics and persistent quadriceps weakness after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is unknown.

Purpose

To clarify the relationships between asymmetries in quadriceps strength and lower limb biomechanics during double-leg squatting >1 year after ACLR.

Study Design

Controlled laboratory study.

Methods

A total of 26 participants (5.5 ± 3.8 years after ACLR) were enrolled. The limb symmetry index (LSI) of isokinetic quadriceps strength was used to divide participants into the high-quadriceps (HQ) group (LSI ≥90%; n = 18) and the low-quadriceps (LQ) group (LSI <90%; n = 8). The knee, hip, and ankle extension moment (relative to body weight and support moment [sum of knee, hip, and ankle moments]) and vertical ground-reaction force during double-leg squatting were analyzed using 3-dimensional motion analysis. The association of quadriceps strength and biomechanical variables was tested using 2-way analysis of variance and univariate regression analysis.

Results

A significant group-by-limb interaction was found for the peak knee extension moment and the ratios of knee and hip extension moment to support moment (P < .001, P = .015 and P < .001, respectively). The LQ group showed a significantly smaller peak knee extension moment and knee to support moment ratio but a larger hip to support moment ratio in the involved limb than in the uninvolved limb (95% CIs: knee extension moment, -0.273 to -0.088 N·m/kg; knee to support moment ratio, -10.7% to -2.2%; hip to support moment ratio, 3.2% to 8.5%). No interlimb difference was found for the HQ group. The LSI of quadriceps strength was significantly associated with the LSI of peak knee extension moment (R² = 0.183), knee to support moment ratio (R² = 0.256), and hip to support moment ratio (R² = 0.233). The mean maximum isokinetic quadriceps strength and peak knee extension moment during squatting on the involved limb of the LQ group were 2.40 ± 0.39 and 0.90 ± 0.16 N·m/kg, respectively.

Conclusion

Asymmetrical biomechanics during double-leg squatting was associated with persistent quadriceps weakness after ACLR. The LQ group had reduced knee extensor moment on the involved side during squatting despite loading at approximately half the maximum strength.

Clinical Relevance

Quadriceps strengthening exercises, together with interventions to improve neuromuscular control, may reduce asymmetrical biomechanics during double-leg squatting.

Lower Patellofemoral Joint Contact Force During Side-Step Cutting After Return-to-Sports Clearance Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Low patellofemoral joint (PFJ) contact force has been associated with PFJ osteoarthritis. Quadriceps force and knee flexion angles, which are typically altered after an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), primarily influence PFJ contact forces. It is still inconclusive whether differences in PFJ contact forces are present during high knee flexion tasks such as side-step cutting after clearance to return to sports (RTS) after ACLR.

PURPOSE

To explore PFJ contact forces in the ACLR limb and compare them with those of the contralateral and control limbs during side-step cutting tasks after clearance to RTS.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

A total of 26 male athletes with ACLR who were previously cleared to RTS were matched with 23 healthy men serving as the control group. Three-dimensional motion capture and force plate data were collected while both groups performed anticipated side-step cutting tasks. Joint kinematics, kinetics, muscle forces, and PFJ contact forces were calculated using musculoskeletal modeling.

RESULTS

Peak PFJ force was lower in the ACLR limbs compared with the contralateral limbs (mean difference [MD], 5.89 body weight [BW]; 95% CI, 4.7-7.1 BW; P < .001) and the control limbs (MD, 4.44 BW; 95% CI, 2.1-6.8 BW; P < .001). During peak PFJ force, knee flexion angle was lower in ACLR limbs compared with the contralateral (MD, 4.88°; 95% CI, 3.0°-6.7°; P < .001) and control (MD, 6.01°; 95% CI, 2.0°-10.0°; P < .002) limbs. A lower quadriceps force compared with the contralateral (MD, 4.14 BW; 95% CI, 3.4-4.9 BW; P < .001) and control (MD, 2.83 BW; 95% CI, 1.4-4.3 BW; P < .001) limbs was also found.

CONCLUSION

Lower PFJ contact forces and a combination of quadriceps force deficits and smaller knee flexion angle were found in the ACLR compared with the contralateral and control limbs even after clearance to RTS.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Despite rehabilitation and subsequent clearance to RTS, differences in PFJ contact forces are present after ACLR. Current rehabilitation and RTS battery may not be effective and sensitive enough to identify and address these differences.

Beyond peak torque: Longitudinal analysis of angle-specific isokinetic knee torques in collegiate athletes post-ACLR

OBJECTIVES

To investigate changes in angle-specific knee extensor torque between limbs from 4 to 12 months post-anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction(ACLR) in Division I collegiate athletes at two different isokinetic velocities.

DESIGN

Case-series study.

SETTING

Laboratory-based.

PARTICIPANTS

Isokinetic knee flexion and extension assessments of 17 athletes (11 female) at 4, 8, and 12 months after ACLR with bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft were evaluated.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Angle-specific curve analyses were performed using statistical parametric mapping for torque data obtained between 14 and 101° at 60°/s and 240°/s velocities.

RESULTS

At 60°/s, knee extensor torque of the operated limb increased between 4 and 8 months (18-101°,p < 0.001), 4 and 12 months (28-101°,p < 0.001), and 8 and 12 months post-surgery (62-70°,p = 0.002, and 79-90°,p < 0.001). Knee extensor torque was lower in the operated limb compared to the non-operated limb at 4 (47-97°,p < 0.001) and 8 months (65-90°,p < 0.001) for 60°/s, at 4 (21-89°,p < 0.001) and 8 months (50-77°,p < 0.001) for 240°/s, with no between-limb differences at 12 months post-ACLR for both velocities.

CONCLUSIONS

Operated limb knee extensor torque increased throughout the majority of knee range of motion from 4 to 12 months post-ACLR at both isokinetic velocities, while non-operated limb torque only improved through a reduced arc of motion in greater knee flexion angles.

Isokinetic Muscle Strength in Elite Soccer Players 3 and 6 months After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

ABSTRACT

Milutinović, A, Jakovljević, V, Dabović, M, Faude, O, Radovanović, D, and Stojanović, E. Isokinetic muscle strength in elite soccer players 3 months and 6 months after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Strength Cond Res 37(4): e297-e304, 2023-The aim of this study was to evaluate interlimb symmetry in quadriceps and hamstring peak torque of elite soccer players at 3 months (stage 1) and 6 months (stage 2) after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Eight male professional soccer players competing at the highest level across different European countries, who had undergone ACL reconstruction, participated in this study. All patients underwent a supervised physiotherapy program after surgery. Data analyses included the use of separate two-way repeated-measures analyses of variance and effect sizes. Although knee extensor and flexor strength of the non-injured limb was found to be relatively unaltered ( g = -0.10 to 0.00) between stage 1 and stage 2, comparisons across time points revealed moderate improvements in quadriceps peak torque ( p = 0.01, g = 0.52), hamstring peak torque ( p = 0.07, g = 0.51), and hamstring:quadriceps (H/Q) ratio ( p = 0.03, g = -0.68) of the injured leg, as well as small-large improvements in the quadriceps ( p = 0.004, g = 1.24) and hamstring limb symmetry index (LSI) ( p = 0.056, g = 0.41). A time-dependent moderate-large asymmetry observed at stage 1 between the injured and noninjured leg in quadriceps peak torque ( p < 0.001, g = -1.83), hamstring peak torque ( p = 0.157, g = -0.67), and the H:Q ratio ( p = 0.06, g = 1.01), as well as between the hamstring and quadriceps LSI ( p = 0.03, g = -0.74) was eliminated at stage 2 ( g = -0.31 to 0.42). Our findings indicate the importance of supervised and comprehensive therapy, as well as strength screening to assist in recovery aimed at optimizing identified strength deficits following ACL reconstruction.

Harvesting a second graft from the extensor mechanism for revision ACL reconstruction does not delay return of quadriceps function

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether harvesting a second graft from the ipsilateral extensor mechanism adversely affects clinical outcomes in revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 34 patients undergoing revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with either quadriceps tendon (QT) autograft or bone-tendon-bone (BTB) autograft was conducted. Patients with two grafts (BTB+QT) from the extensor mechanism were matched based on age, laterality, and sex to patients who had primary reconstruction with hamstring (HS) autograft followed by revision with either BTB or QT autograft (HS+QT/BTB). Return of quadriceps function was assessed with time to return to jogging in a standardized rehab protocol or time to regain 80% quadriceps strength. Secondary outcomes included International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) and Marx scores at 12-month follow-up and return to sport.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in return to jogging or 80% quadriceps strength (HS 149.5 ± 38.2 days, BTB+QT 131.7 ± 40.1 days, n.s.), number able to return to sport (HS 62%, BTB+QT 93%, n.s.), months to return to sport (HS 10.6 ± 1.4, BTB+QT 10.5 ± 2.3, n.s.), return to pre-injury level of competition (HS 62%, BTB+QT 73%, n.s.), or IKDC (HS 77.2 ± 16.4, BTB+QT 74.8 ± 23.9, n.s.) and Marx scores (HS 9.2 ± 5.3, BTB+QT 8.0 ± 3.7, n.s.) at one-year follow-up.

CONCLUSION

The main finding of the present study was that outcomes for patients who underwent revision ACL reconstruction with a second extensor mechanism autograft were comparable to those seen for patients who underwent revision ACL reconstruction with extensor mechanism autograft after primary ACL reconstruction with hamstring autograft. By better understanding the consequences of harvesting a second graft from the extensor mechanism, surgeons can better decide what graft to use in revision ACL reconstruction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Measurement properties for muscle strength tests following anterior cruciate ligament and/or meniscus injury: What tests to use and where do we need to go? A systematic review with meta-analyses for the OPTIKNEE consensus

Objectives

Critically appraise and summarise the measurement properties of knee muscle strength tests after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and/or meniscus injury using the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments Risk of Bias checklist.

Design

Systematic review with meta-analyses. The modified Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation-guided assessment of evidence quality.

Data sources

Medline, Embase, CINAHL and SPORTSDiscus searched from inception to 5 May 2022.

Eligibility criteria for selecting studies

Studies evaluating knee extensor or flexor strength test reliability, measurement error, validity, responsiveness or interpretability in individuals with ACL and/or meniscus injuries with a mean injury age of ≤30 years.

Results

Thirty-six studies were included involving 31 different muscle strength tests (mode and equipment) in individuals following an ACL injury and/or an isolated meniscus injury. Strength tests were assessed for reliability (n=8), measurement error (n=7), construct validity (n=27) and criterion validity (n=7). Isokinetic concentric extensor and flexor strength tests were the best rated with sufficient intrarater reliability (very low evidence quality) and construct validity (moderate evidence quality). Isotonic extensor and flexor strength tests showed sufficient criterion validity, while isometric extensor strength tests had insufficient construct and criterion validity (high evidence quality).

Conclusion

Knee extensor and flexor strength tests of individuals with ACL and/or meniscus injury lack evidence supporting their measurement properties. There is an urgent need for high-quality studies on these measurement properties. Until then, isokinetic concentric strength tests are most recommended, with isotonic strength tests a good alternative.

Deficits in Contralateral Limb Strength Can Overestimate Limb Symmetry Index After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Purpose

To evaluate whether contralateral limb strength represents a dynamic, rather than static, data point after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACL-R).

Methods

Patients who underwent isolated ACL-R at a single institution were identified. Patients completed an institutional Lower-Extremity Assessment Protocol (LEAP) testing protocol at 6 and 9 months postoperatively. Extension strength and flexion strength of the ipsilateral and contralateral limbs and limb symmetry index (LSI) were compared between the 6- and 9-month testing outcomes. Subgroup analysis compared patients demonstrating less than or greater than 10% change in contralateral limb flexion and extension strength between 6 and 9 months postoperatively.

Results

A total of 144 subjects were included in this study. On average, contralateral limb flexion and extension strength increased 2-4% between 6 and 9 months postoperatively. However, the contralateral limb increased >10% from 6 to 9 months in extension and flexion strength in 35/144 (24.3%) and 55/144 (38.2%) of patients, respectively. The cohort with >10% change between 6 and 9 months had significantly weaker contralateral extension and flexion strength at 6 months compared to the cohort that demonstrated <10% change (extension: 2.00 vs 2.39; P < .001; flexion: 0.84 vs 1.08; P < .001), but similar ipsilateral limb performance. Therefore, the >10% change cohort had a significantly greater LSI at 6 months compared to the <10% change cohort (67.3% vs 59.4%; P = .006). No demographic or operative factors correlated with which patients demonstrated >10% flexion or extension strength changes of the contralateral limb.

Conclusion

A large percentage of patients demonstrate significant changes in their contralateral limb flexion and extension strength between 6 and 9 months postoperatively that result from an initial contralateral limb strength deficit. This may limit the utility of the contralateral limb as a control for comparison to the operative extremity during return to sport assessment.

Quadriceps muscle strength at 2 years following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is associated with tibiofemoral joint cartilage volume

PURPOSE

Quadriceps strength deficits following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) are linked to altered lower extremity biomechanics, tibiofemoral joint (TFJ) space narrowing and cartilage composition changes. It is unknown, however, if quadriceps strength is associated with cartilage volume in the early years following ACLR prior to the onset of posttraumatic osteoarthritis (OA) development. The purpose of this cross-sectional study was to examine the relationship between quadriceps muscle strength (peak and across the functional range of knee flexion) and cartilage volume at ~ 2 years following ACLR and determine the influence of concomitant meniscal pathology.

METHODS

The involved limb of 51 ACLR participants (31 isolated ACLR; 20 combined meniscal pathology) aged 18-40 years were tested at 2.4 ± 0.4 years post-surgery. Isokinetic knee extension torque generated in 10° intervals between 60° and 10° knee flexion (i.e. 60°-50°, 50°-40°, 40°-30°, 30°-20°, 20°-10°) together with peak extension torque were measured. Tibial and patellar cartilage volumes were measured using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The relationships between peak and angle-specific knee extension torque and MRI-derived cartilage volumes were evaluated using multiple linear regression.

RESULTS

In ACLR participants with and without meniscal pathology, higher knee extension torques at 60°-50° and 50°-40° knee flexion were negatively associated with medial tibial cartilage volume (p < 0.05). No significant associations were identified between peak concentric or angle-specific knee extension torques and patellar cartilage volume.

CONCLUSION

Higher quadriceps strength at knee flexion angles of 60°-40° was associated with lower cartilage volume on the medial tibia ~ 2 years following ACLR with and without concomitant meniscal injury. Regaining quadriceps strength across important functional ranges of knee flexion after ACLR may reduce the likelihood of developing early TFJ cartilage degenerative changes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Adolescent Quadriceps Tendon Rupture, an Early Complication After ACL Reconstruction: A Case Report

CASE

A healthy adolescent male patient initially presented with complete rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) after a plant-twist injury during a high school football game. Four weeks after ACL reconstruction with autograft bone-patella tendon-bone, the patient slipped and fell, sustaining hyperflexion of the knee, resulting in rupture of the ipsilateral quadriceps tendon.

CONCLUSION

Although this rare complication has previously been reported in the adult population, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first known report of an adolescent patient sustaining a quadriceps tendon rupture after ACL reconstruction.

Unilateral Maximal Isometric Hex Bar Pull Test: Within-Session Reliability and Lower Body Force Production in Male and Female Freeski Athletes

The aim of the study was to (1) assess the within-session reliability of a unilateral isometric hex bar pull (UIHBP) maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) test and, (2) determine unilateral isometric absolute peak force (PFabs) and relative peak force (PF) values in freeski athletes. Twenty-one male and eight female academy to national team freeskiers performed the novel UIHBP MVC task on a force plate and PFabs and relative PF were assessed (1000 Hz). Within-session measures of PFabs offered high reliability on left and right limbs for males (ICC = 0.91-0.94, CV = 2.6-2.2%) and females (ICC = 0.94-0.94, CV = 1.4-1.6%), while relative PF measures showed good to high reliability in both left and right limbs for males (ICC = 0.8-0.84, CV = 2.6-2.2%) and females (ICC = 0.92-0.90, CV = 1.4-1.7%). We observed significantly lower PFabs (p < 0.001) and relative PF (p < 0.001) in females compared to males. No statistical difference was found between left and right limbs in males and females in PFabs (p = 0.98) and relative PF measures (p = 0.93). The UIHBP MVC test appears to be a reliable method for assessing PFabs and relative PF in male and female freeski athletes.