Usefulness of SS18-SSX antibody as a diagnostic marker for pulmonary metastatic synovial sarcoma

Advances of SS18-SSX fusion gene in synovial sarcoma: Emerging novel functions and therapeutic potentials

Synovial sarcoma is a rare type of soft tissue sarcoma that primarily affects adolescents and young adults, featured by aggressive behavior and a high potential for metastasis. Genetically, synovial sarcoma is defined by the fusion oncogene SS18-SSX arising from the translocation of t(X;18)(p11;q11). SS18-SSX fusion gene is the major driver of the oncogenic event in synovial sarcoma. SS18-SSX fusion protein, while not containing any DNA-binding motifs, binds to the SWI/SNF (BAF) complex, a major epigenetic regulator, leading to the disruption of gene expression which results in tumor initiation and progression. Emerging studies on the molecular mechanisms of SS18-SSX associated signaling pathway hold promise for developments in diagnosis and treatments. Advanced diagnostic methods facilitate early and precise detection of the tumor, enabling disease monitoring and prognostic improvements. Treatment of synovial sarcoma typically comprises local surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy, while novel managements such as immunotherapy, targeted therapies and epigenetic modifiers are explored. This review focuses on the recent studies of SS18-SSX fusion gene, epigenetic landscape, signaling pathways, diagnostic techniques, and relevant therapeutic advances, aiming to inhibit the oncogenic processes and improve outcomes for patients with synovial sarcoma.

Functional Classification of Fusion Proteins in Sarcoma

Sarcomas comprise a heterogeneous group of malignant tumors of mesenchymal origin. More than 80 entities are associated with different mesenchymal lineages. Sarcomas with fibroblastic, muscle, bone, vascular, adipocytic, and other characteristics are distinguished. Nearly half of all entities contain specific chromosomal translocations that give rise to fusion proteins. These are mostly pathognomonic, and their detection by various molecular techniques supports histopathologic classification. Moreover, the fusion proteins act as oncogenic drivers, and their blockade represents a promising therapeutic approach. This review summarizes the current knowledge on fusion proteins in sarcoma. We categorize the different fusion proteins into functional classes, including kinases, epigenetic regulators, and transcription factors, and describe their mechanisms of action. Interestingly, while fusion proteins acting as transcription factors are found in all mesenchymal lineages, the others have a more restricted pattern. Most kinase-driven sarcomas belong to the fibroblastic/myofibroblastic lineage. Fusion proteins with an epigenetic function are mainly associated with sarcomas of unclear differentiation, suggesting that epigenetic dysregulation leads to a major change in cell identity. Comparison of mechanisms of action reveals recurrent functional modes, including antagonism of Polycomb activity by fusion proteins with epigenetic activity and recruitment of histone acetyltransferases by fusion transcription factors of the myogenic lineage. Finally, based on their biology, we describe potential approaches to block the activity of fusion proteins for therapeutic intervention. Overall, our work highlights differences as well as similarities in the biology of fusion proteins from different sarcomas and provides the basis for a functional classification.

Utility of Immunohistochemistry With Antibodies to SS18-SSX Chimeric Proteins and C-Terminus of SSX Protein for Synovial Sarcoma Differential Diagnosis

Synovial sarcoma is a relatively common soft tissue tumor characterized by highly specific t(X;18)(p11;q11) translocation resulting in the fusion of SS18 with members of SSX gene family. Typically, detection of SS18 locus rearrangement by fluorescence in situ hybridization or SS18 :: SSX fusion transcripts confirms the diagnosis. More recently, immunohistochemistry (IHC) for SS18-SSX chimeric protein (E9X9V) and C-terminus of SSX (E5A2C) showed high specificity and sensitivity for synovial sarcoma. This study screened a cohort of >1000 soft tissue and melanocytic tumors using IHC and E9X9V and E5A2C antibodies. Three percent (6/212) of synovial sarcomas were either negative for SS18-SSX or had scattered positive tumor cells (n=1). In these cases, targeted RNA next-generation sequencing detected variants of SS18 :: SSX chimeric transcripts. DNA methylation profiles of 2 such tumors matched with synovial sarcoma. A few nonsynovial sarcoma tumors (n=6) revealed either focal SS18-SSX positivity (n=1) or scattered positive tumor cells. However, targeted RNA next-generation sequencing failed to detect SS18 :: SSX transcripts in these cases. The nature of this immunopositivity remains elusive and may require single cell sequencing studies. All synovial sarcomas showed positive SSX IHC. However, a mosaic staining pattern or focal loss of expression was noticed in a few cases. Strong and diffuse SSX immunoreactivity was also seen in epithelioid sclerosing osteosarcoma harboring EWSR1 :: SSX1 fusion, while several sarcomas and melanocytic tumors including cellular blue nevus (5/7, 71%) revealed focal to diffuse, mostly weak to intermediate SSX staining. The SS18-SSX and SSX IHC is a useful tool for synovial sarcoma differential diagnosis, but unusual immunophenotype should trigger molecular genetic testing.

SS18-SSX Expression in a Contemporary Cohort of Primary Renal Synovial Sarcoma: A Multi-Institutional Experience of Fourteen Patients

Primary renal synovial sarcoma is a rare aggressive mesenchymal neoplasm of the kidney that accounts for less than 1% of renal sarcomas. Herein, we describe the clinicopathologic and molecular findings of 14 renal synovial sarcoma patients in one of the largest case series to date and to our knowledge, the only renal synovial sarcoma series to use novel SS18-SSX IHC. Clinicopathologic, IHC, molecular, management, and follow-up data were reviewed and analyzed. Macroscopically, the tumors had either homogeneous, tan-white, and solid (n = 10), variegated and solid (n = 3), or variegated and solid-cystic (n = 1) cut surfaces. Spindle cell (n = 10), round cell (n = 3), and round to epithelioid morphologies (n = 1) were observed. SS18-SSX IHC was positive in all 14 tumors (diffuse, n = 10; multifocal, n = 2; focal, n = 2). All the tumors harbored SS18::SSX1/2 gene rearrangement. Metastases to the liver, brain, and lung (n = 1); liver and bone (n = 1); liver and diaphragm (n = 1) were identified. Adjuvant chemotherapy was administered in 11/12 patients. Follow-up was available for 10 patients (time period range: 5 to 24 months). Four patients died of disease, and six patients are alive with no recurrence or metastasis. As SS18-SSX IHC showed an excellent concordance with the FISH results, this may reliably be used in the IHC panel of spindle/round cell sarcomas of the kidney and as a molecular surrogate for renal synovial sarcoma, particularly in a resource-limited setting. Also, the tumors with focal SS18-SSX expression had lower break apart signals in the FISH assay (19% and 23% in two tumors with focal SS18-SSX IHC positivity).

SS18-SSX Antibody: A Useful Tool to Save Time and Reduce Costs in Synovial Sarcoma Diagnosis. Proposal of a Novel Diagnostic Algorithm

Synovial sarcoma is a rare malignant mesenchymal neoplasm mostly affecting young adults, characterized by a specific translocation which results in the fusion of the SS18 gene on chromosome 18 with one of the three highly homologous SSX genes on chromosome X. Its morphological diagnosis, especially in monophasic or poorly differentiated variants, can be challenging because histological features often overlap with other malignant mesenchymal tumors. Until recently, the differential diagnosis mostly relied on the use of cytogenetic or molecular analyses to detect the specific t(X;18)(p11;q11) translocation, thus virtually restricting its correct identification to referral centers with a high histological and molecular pathology workflow. The recently commercialized highly sensitive and fusion-specific SS18-SSX antibody has significantly improved the approach to these tumors, representing a relatively cheap and easy to access tool for synovial sarcoma diagnosis. Through a retrospective analysis of 79 synovial sarcomas and histological mimickers, this study confirms the usefulness of the SS18-SSX antibody in the diagnosis of synovial sarcoma, particularly focusing on its application in the pathological response evaluation after neoadjuvant treatment as well as its time- and cost-saving advantages. Finally, we here propose a new diagnostic algorithm to apply into the routine practice.

Synovial sarcoma: cytopathology of 51 cases highlighting the application of ancillary molecular testing

INTRODUCTION

Among sarcomas, synovial sarcoma (SS) is defined by its unique SS18 cytogenetic translocation. Fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy is in a key position to exploit this uniqueness for diagnostic purposes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our cytopathology files were searched for examples of SS with histopathologic verification. FNA biopsy, imprint smears, and core needle biopsy (CNB) were performed using standard techniques.

RESULTS

Fifty-one cases from 49 patients (male/female ratio, 1:1; age range, 12-79 years; mean age, 40 years) met the inclusion criteria. Of the 51 cases, 44 (86%) were FNAs, 6 were cytology imprints, and 1 was pleural fluid. Eleven aspirates had concurrent CNB. All cases had tissue confirmation. The biopsy sites included extremities (n = 24; 47%), trunk (n = 12; 24%), lung (n = 8; 16%), head or neck (n = 6; 12%), and pleural fluid (n = 1; 2%). The aspirates were from primary (n = 36; 71%), metastatic (n = 12; 24%), and recurrent (n = 3; 5%) neoplasms. The cytologic diagnoses were SS (69%), suspicious for SS (12%), malignancy (10%), spindle cell neoplasm (4%), and malignancy other than SS (6%). In general, smears and imprints contained dense cell aggregates and single cells composed of a monotonous population having fusiform, rounded, or ovoid banal nuclei and scant cytoplasm. Poorly differentiated SS showed both large epithelioid cell and small cell cytomorphology. When performed, SS18 immunohistochemical and genetic testing was positive in all 19 FNA and 3 CNB cases.

CONCLUSIONS

When coupled with appropriate ancillary testing, FNA biopsy allows for a specific, accurate diagnosis of SS in most cases.

Expanding the Use of an SS18-SSX Antibody for Molecular Assays in Synovial Sarcoma

Synovial sarcoma is an aggressive malignancy that generally affects adolescents and young adults and is characterized by high rates of recurrence and metastasis, with a 10-year survival rate of about 50%. The fusion oncoprotein SS18-SSX, the product of a pathognomonic chromosomal translocation t(X;18), is the oncogenic driver of this sarcoma, disrupting differentiation through widespread epigenetic dysregulation. Experimental research into SS18-SSX biology has been limited by the lack of an antibody that specifically detects the endogenous fusion oncoprotein as opposed to its native SS18 or SSX components. Recently, a rabbit monoclonal antibody was developed and made commercially available, which specifically detects the fusion junction site epitope of SS18-SSX as found in at least 95% of synovial sarcomas. Here, we characterize a suite of molecular biology assays using this new antibody, both confirming existing and reporting on novel applications. We demonstrate its high sensitivity and specificity for synovial sarcoma diagnosis on patient samples through positive immunohistochemical staining on synovial sarcoma, tissue microarray, and full face sections. In addition, we demonstrate detection of the human SS18-SSX protein when expressed in a genetically engineered mouse model of synovial sarcoma. We also demonstrate nuclear staining of SS18-SSX in synovial sarcoma cells using immunofluorescence, and visualize the interaction between SS18-SSX and the BAF complex member BRG1 through a proximity ligation assay. Lastly, we confirm the interaction between SS18-SSX and promoter regions of target genes through chromatin immunoprecipitation. This antibody represents a breakthrough in sarcoma research and has value in multiple applications to expand the knowledge of synovial sarcoma biology.