Caregivers' assessment of meaningful and relevant clinical outcome assessments for Sanfilippo syndrome

Friedreich Ataxia Caregiver-Reported Health Index: Development of a Novel, Disease-Specific Caregiver-Reported Outcome Measure

Background and Objectives

The Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) scientific community needs access to patient-centered outcome measures that satisfy regulatory guidelines and are capable of tracking clinically meaningful changes in FRDA disease burden. The objective of this research was to develop a novel, disease-specific caregiver-reported outcome measure for use in FRDA research and clinical care.

Methods

In prior work, we conducted qualitative interviews and a cross-sectional study of FRDA caregivers and patients to determine the symptoms of greatest importance to individuals with FRDA. We designed the Friedreich Ataxia Caregiver-Reported Health Index (FACR-HI) to serially measure the symptoms of greatest importance to patients and utilized factor analysis, beta testing, reliability testing, and cross-sectional subgroup analysis to further evaluate and optimize this disease-specific outcome measure.

Results

The FACR-HI was designed to measure total disease burden and disease burden in 18 symptomatic domains. The FACR-HI total score demonstrated high internal consistency (Cronbach's α = 0.98) and test-retest reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.96). Beta interview participants found the FACR-HI to be highly relevant, comprehensive, and easy to use. FACR-HI total and subscale scores were associated with functional staging for ataxia scores and speech impairment.

Discussion

Initial evaluation of the FACR-HI supports its content validity, test-retest reliability, and construct validity as a caregiver-reported outcome measure for assessing how pediatric individuals with FRDA feel and function. The FACR-HI provides a potential mechanism to quantify changes in multifactorial FRDA disease burden during future clinical trials.

Video-based assessments of activities of daily living: generating real-world evidence in pediatric rare diseases

INTRODUCTION

Preserving function and independence to perform activities of daily living (ADL) is critical for patients and carers to manage burden of care and improve quality of life. In children living with rare diseases, video recording ADLs offer the opportunity to collect the patients' experience in a real-life setting and accurately reflect treatment effectiveness on outcomes that matter to patients and families.

AREAS COVERED

We reviewed the measurement of ADL in pediatric rare diseases and the use of video to develop at home electronic clinical outcome assessments (eCOA) by leveraging smartphone apps and artificial intelligence-based analysis. We broadly searched PubMed using Boolean combinations of the following MeSH terms "Rare Diseases, 'Quality of Life,' 'Activities of Daily Living,' 'Child,' 'Video Recording,' 'Outcome Assessment, Healthcare,' 'Intellectual disability' and 'Genetic Diseases, Inborn.' Non-controlled vocabulary was used to include human pose estimation in movement analysis.Expert opinion: Broad uptake of video eCOA in drug development is linked to the generation of technical and clinical validation evidence to confidently assess patient's functional abilities. Software platforms handling video data must align to quality regulations to ensure data integrity, security and privacy. Regulatory flexibility and optimized validation processes should facilitate video eCOA to support benefit/risk drug assessment.

Ability change across multiple domains in mucopolysaccharidosis (Sanfilippo syndrome) type IIIA

The objective of this paper is 1) to expand the scope of the domains previously published in a natural history study of Mucopolysaccharidosis IIIA (Sanfilippo syndrome type A) (MPS IIIA) and 2) to present evidence regarding the capacity of a new metric, Growth Scale Values (GSVs), in comparison with traditional metrics, to show changes in skills as assessed by the Bayley Scales of Infant Development -III (BSID-III) and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Second Edition (VABS-II). We re-analyzed a cohort of 25 children, 20 with rapid progressing disease and 5 with slow progression, who had been followed over two years using the BSID-III, and the VABS-II. Previously findings were reported using age equivalent scores; now we are also presenting findings with GSVs. For the re-analysis, Language and Motor scores were added to the Cognitive scale on the BSID-III, and Domain- and Subdomain-level scores added to the Total VABS-II score (i.e., ABC Composite). We evaluated raw scores, age equivalent scores, and GSVs (and standard scores for the VABS-II only). Individual patient data can be found in the appendices to this publication. Results indicate that 1) Cognition as measured by GSVs was the most sensitive to decline; 2) GSVs showed significant decline in the range of 4 to 6 years of age; 3) For children under 4 years of age, positive growth occurs on most scales and most metrics, with the exception of language which slows somewhat earlier; 4) Other than the Cognitive scale, Receptive Language on the BSID-III and Receptive Communication on the VABS-II showed the most sensitivity to change; 5) Gross Motor skills showed the least decline over time and appeared to lack sensitivity to MPS IIIA motor concerns; and 6) No evidence for sensitivity to change for any metric was found in time intervals less than one year. We conclude that GSVs are a precise measurement of change to detect decline in function, and they are a valuable method for future clinical trials in MPS IIIA. Evidence continues to support cognition as a primary endpoint. Additional work is needed to identify sensitive measures of meaningful endpoints to families.

Perspectives of adult patients with lysosomal storage diseases on the transition from pediatric to adult healthcare in Turkey

AIM

In many countries, adult clinics specifically dedicated to adult patients with lysosomal storage diseases (LSDs) do not exist. In Turkey, these patients are managed either by pediatric metabolic specialists or adult physicians who do not specifically specialize in LSDs. In this study, we aimed to identify the unmet clinical needs of these adult patients and their suggestions.

METHODS

The focus group participants were 24 adult LSD patients. Interviews were conducted in person.

RESULTS

A total of 23 LSD patients and parents of a patient with mucopolysaccharidosis type-3b with intellectual deficit were interviewed, with 84.6% of patients diagnosed after the age of 18 years and 18% of patients diagnosed before the age of 18 years desiring management by adult physicians. Patients with particular physical characteristics or severe intellectual deficit declined the transition. Patients reported structural problems in the hospital and social problems associated with pediatric clinics. They made suggestions to facilitate the possible transition.

CONCLUSION

With improved care, more patients with LSDs survive into adulthood or receive the diagnosis in adulthood. Children with chronic diseases need to transition to the care of adult physicians when they reach adulthood. Thus, there is an increasing need for adult physicians to manage these patients. In this study, most LSD patients accepted a well-planned and organized transition. Problems were related to stigmatization and social isolation in the pediatric clinic or adult issues with which pediatricians are not familiar. There is a need for adult metabolic physicians. Thus, health authorities should adopt necessary regulations for training of physicians in this field.

Sanfilippo Syndrome: Optimizing Care with a Multidisciplinary Approach

Sanfilippo syndrome, or mucopolysaccharidosis type III (MPS III), is a disease grouping five genetic disorders, four of them occurring in humans and one known to date only in a mouse model. In every subtype of MPS III (designed A, B, C, D or E), a lack or drastically decreased activity of an enzyme involved in the degradation of heparan sulfate (HS) (a compound from the group of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs)) arises from a genetic defect. This leads to primary accumulation of HS, and secondary storage of other compounds, combined with changes in expressions of hundreds of genes and many defects in organelles and various biochemical processes in the cell. As a result, dysfunctions of tissues and organs occur, leading to severe symptoms in patients. Although changes in somatic organs are considerable, the central nervous system is especially severely affected, and neurological, cognitive and behavioral disorders are the most significant changes, making the disease enormously burdensome for patients and their families. In the light of the current lack of any registered therapy for Sanfilippo syndrome (despite various attempts of many research groups to develop effective treatment, still no specific drug or procedure is available for MPS III), optimizing care with a multidisciplinary approach is crucial for managing this disease and making quality of patients’ life passable. This includes efforts to make/organize (i) accurate diagnosis as early as possible (which is not easy due to various possible misdiagnosis events caused by similarity of MPS III symptoms to those of other diseases and variability of patients), (ii) optimized symptomatic treatment (which is challenging because of complexity of symptoms and often untypical responses of MPS III patients to various drugs), and (iii) psychological care (for both patients and family members and/or caregivers). In this review article, we focus on these approaches, summarizing and discussing them.