Monoclonal antithyroglobulin antibodies derived from immunizations of mice with human eye muscle and thyroid membranes

TSH-receptor-expressing fibrocytes and thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is a vexing and undertreated ocular component of Graves disease in which orbital tissues undergo extensive remodelling. My colleagues and I have introduced the concept that fibrocytes expressing the haematopoietic cell antigen CD34 (CD34(+) fibrocytes), which are precursor cells of bone-marrow-derived monocyte lineage, express the TSH receptor (TSHR). These cells also produce several other proteins whose expression was traditionally thought to be restricted to the thyroid gland. TSHR-expressing fibrocytes in which the receptor is activated by its ligand generate extremely high levels of several inflammatory cytokines. Acting in concert with TSHR, the insulin-like growth factor 1 receptor (IGF-1R) expressed by orbital fibroblasts and fibrocytes seems to be necessary for TSHR-dependent cytokine production, as anti-IGF-1R blocking antibodies attenuate these proinflammatory actions of TSH. Furthermore, circulating fibrocytes are highly abundant in patients with TAO and seem to infiltrate orbital connective tissues, where they might transition to CD34(+) fibroblasts. My research group has postulated that the infiltration of fibrocytes into the orbit, their unique biosynthetic repertoire and their proinflammatory and profibrotic phenotype account for the characteristic properties exhibited by orbital connective tissues that underlie susceptibility to TAO. These insights, which have emerged in the past few years, might be of use in therapeutically targeting pathogenic orbit-infiltrating fibrocytes selectively by utilizing novel biologic agents that interfere with TSHR and IGF-1R signalling.

Expression of thyrotropin receptor, thyroglobulin, sodium-iodide symporter, and thyroperoxidase by fibrocytes depends on AIRE

CONTEXT

CD34(+) fibrocytes, bone marrow-derived progenitor cells, infiltrate orbital connective tissue in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy, a manifestation of Graves' disease. In the orbit, they become CD34(+) fibroblasts and coexist with native CD34(-) fibroblasts. Fibrocytes have been shown to express TSH receptor and thyroglobulin.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to determine whether a broader repertoire of thyroid protein expression can be detected in fibrocytes and whether a common factor is responsible.

DESIGN/SETTING/PARTICIPANTS

Fibrocytes and fibroblasts were collected and analyzed from healthy individuals and those with Graves' disease in an academic clinical practice.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Real-time PCR, Western blot analysis, gene promoter analysis, cell transfections, and flow cytometric cell sorting were performed.

RESULTS

We detect two additional thyroid proteins expressed by fibrocytes, namely sodium-iodide symporter and thyroperoxidase. The autoimmune regulator (AIRE) protein appears necessary for this expression. AIRE expression in fibrocytes results from an active AIRE gene promoter and stable AIRE mRNA. Knocking down AIRE with a targeting small interfering RNA reduces the expression of these thyroid proteins in fibrocytes as well as the transcription factors paired box-8 and thyroid transcription factor-1. When compared with an unaffected first-degree relative, levels of these proteins are substantially reduced in fibrocytes from an individual with an inactivating AIRE mutation. Levels of AIRE and the thyroid proteins are lower in orbital fibroblasts from patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy than in fibrocytes. However, when mixed fibroblast populations are sorted into pure CD34(+) and CD34(-) subsets, the levels of these proteins are dramatically increased selectively in CD34(+) fibroblasts.

CONCLUSIONS

Fibrocytes express four proteins, the aggregate expression of which was previously thought to be restricted to thyroid epithelium. These proteins represent the necessary molecular biosynthetic machinery necessary for thyroid hormone production. Our findings implicate AIRE in the promiscuous expression of thyroid proteins in fibrocytes.

Human fibrocytes coexpress thyroglobulin and thyrotropin receptor

Thyroglobulin (Tg) is the macromolecular precursor of thyroid hormones and is thought to be uniquely expressed by thyroid epithelial cells. Tg and the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) are targets for autoantibody generation in the autoimmune disorder Graves disease (GD). Fully expressed GD is characterized by thyroid overactivity and orbital tissue inflammation and remodeling. This process is known as thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO). Early reports suggested that in TAO, both Tg and TSHR become overexpressed in orbital tissues. Previously, we found that CD34(+) progenitor cells, known as fibrocytes, express functional TSHR, infiltrate the orbit, and comprise a large subset of orbital fibroblasts in TAO. We now report that fibrocytes also express Tg, which resolves as a 305-kDa protein on Western blots. It can be immunoprecipitated with anti-Tg Abs. Further, (125)iodine and [(35)S]methionine are incorporated into Tg expressed by fibrocytes. De novo Tg synthesis is attenuated with a specific small interfering RNA targeting the protein. A fragment of the Tg gene promoter fused to a luciferase reporter exhibits substantial activity when transfected into fibrocytes. Unlike fibrocytes, GD orbital fibroblasts, which comprise a mixture of CD34(+) and CD34(-) cells, express much lower levels of Tg and TSHR. When sorted into pure CD34(+) and CD34(-) subsets, Tg and TSHR mRNA levels become substantially higher in CD34(+) cells. These findings indicate that human fibrocytes express multiple "thyroid-specific" proteins, the levels of which are reduced after they infiltrate tissue. Our observations establish the basis for Tg accumulation in orbital GD.

Role of thyroglobulin in the pathogenesis of Graves' ophthalmopathy: the hypothesis of Kriss revisited

One of the hypothesis to explain the pathogenesis of Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO) was formulated by Joseph P. Kriss in the early 1970s. He postulated that the initiating event in the pathogenesis of GO is the deposition and accumulation of thyroglobulin (Tg) in orbital tissues, followed by an autoimmune reaction against Tg. In the last 30 yrs several studies have addressed this hypothesis, through various, different experimental approaches, raising results that are both in favor and against the possibility that Tg plays a role in the pathogenesis of GO. The finding that intact Tg is present in orbital tissues of GO patients supports Kriss' hypothesis, although the role of Tg as an autoantigen seems to be unlikely, as GO is not significantly associated with serum TgAb and mice immunized with Tg do not develop GO. Whether Tg is indeed involved in the pathogenesis of GO remains to be established. Our current view is that, provided that Tg plays a role, it is unlikely the only factor involved and Tg in orbital tissues may rather reinforce or worsen a damage initiated by other mechanisms.

Identification of thyroglobulin in orbital tissues of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is thought to have an autoimmune pathogenesis because of its association with autoimmune thyroid disease, in particular with Graves' disease. Nevertheless, the nature of the autoimmune reaction is unclear, and a target orbital autoantigen has not been conclusively identified. A widely discussed hypothesis is that antigens constitutively shared by the thyroid and orbital tissues are targets of an autoimmune reaction. It has been also postulated that a thyroid-soluble antigen, namely thyroglobulin (Tg), is transported to orbital tissues through the lymphatics, where it accumulates and elicits autoimmune damages in susceptible individuals. Here we have investigated whether Tg is present in orbital tissues from patients with TAO. Retrobulbar tissue specimens were obtained from three patients with Graves' disease and TAO who underwent decompressive orbitotomy, and at autopsy from two patients with no thyroid or eye disease. All patients with TAO had been previously treated with radioiodine to control Graves' hyperthyroidism. Western blot analysis with a monoclonal anti-Tg antibody showed the presence of intact Tg, both in soluble and membrane-associated fractions of orbital tissue extracts from the patients with TAO, in amounts estimated to range from approximately 320 to approximately 900 pg/microg of tissue protein. In contrast, Tg was not detected in orbital tissue extracts from patients with no thyroid or eye disease. Tg was also demonstrated in orbital tissue extracts from two of three patients with TAO by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), in amounts estimated to range from approximately 450 to approximately 1000 pg/microg of protein. In addition, Tg in orbital tissue extracts from patients with TAO was immunoprecipitated by a rabbit anti-Tg antibody, suggesting that it retained its native conformation. An anti-thyroxine (T4) antibody captured in solid-phase Tg from orbital tissue extracts, showing that it contained thyroid hormone residues and had therefore originated in the thyroid. Tg-anti-Tg immune complexes were not found in orbital tissues, suggesting that if an autoimmune reaction to Tg occurs in TAO, it is likely to be cell mediated.

Antibodies to acetylcholinesterase cross-reacting with thyroglobulin in myasthenia gravis and Graves's disease

In the present study we analysed by ELISA the ability of sera from 50 patients with myasthenia gravis (MG), 20 with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), 53 with Graves' disease (GD) and 36 healthy controls (CR) to react with acetylcholinesterase (AChE) from Electrophorus electricus and human thyroglobulin (Tg). Significantly increased anti-AChE activity was exhibited by a high proportion of MG (IgG 36%) and GD (IgG 21%) sera, while increased anti-Tg activity was detected in all three patient groups (MG, IgG 26% and IgA 26%; HT, IgG 85% and IgA 40%; and GD, IgG 51%). Interestingly, a significant proportion of MG and GD sera exhibited both IgG anti-AChE and anti-Tg activities (MG, 18%; P < 0.001; and GD, 15%; P < 0.001, versus CR, 0%). This bi-reactivity was exhibited by anti-AChE antibodies cross-reacting with Tg (anti-AChE/Tg activity); (i) serum anti-AChE activity was effectively inhibited by soluble Tg, and (ii) affinity-purified anti-Tg antibodies cross-reacted with AChE. Cross-reactivity seems to be a property of pathological (auto)antibodies; induced (rabbit) antibodies to AChE or Tg were highly monospecific. Analysis of clinical data showed that increased IgG anti-AChE/Tg activity was well associated with: (i) overlapping GD in MG (P < 0.02), and (ii) ophthalmopathy in GD (P < 0.01). In contrast, no correlation was noted in MG between anti-AChE activity units and anti-Tg activity units or acetylcholine receptor antibody titres. The clinical significance of anti-AChE/Tg antibodies remains to be elucidated.

Autoimmunity in Graves' ophthalmopathy: a review

Images

Definition, at the molecular level, of a thyroglobulin-acetylcholinesterase shared epitope: study of its pathophysiological significance in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy

The nature of the putative autoantigen in Graves' ophthalmopathy (Go) remains an enigma but the sequence similarity between thyroglobulin (Tg) and acetylcholinesterase (ACHE) provides a rationale for epitopes which are common to the thyroid gland and the eye orbit. In an attempt to define the shared epitope, we have screened a lambda gt 11 human thyroid cDNA library using a polyclonal antibody to Torpedo ACHE and isolated two clones, which upon sequencing, were shown to contain Tg segments, corresponding to portions of the C terminal part of the molecule which has a high similarity with ACHE. Having demonstrated the existence of an epitope common to Tg and ACHE, the clones have been further tested and found to be positive in lysis plaque assays with 1/10 sera from patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), 8/8 from patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy and 0/8 normal sera. We have investigated the physiological significance of this common epitope by in situ immunolocalization studies in which the polyclonal antibody to Torpedo ACHE (which was used for screening the library) and immunoglobulins (Igs) from 6 Go patients tested were shown to bind to end plate regions of human foetal muscle fibres which were concurrently shown to be rich in cholinesterase activity: Igs from 3 normal individuals and 2 patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis did not bind. The results demonstrate and characterize an epitope which is common to Tg and ACHE and show that Go patients Igs contain antibodies which bind to muscle end plates rich in cholinesterase. The significance of these findings to the pathogenesis of Go is discussed.