Intrathecal immunoglobulin A and G antibodies to synapsin in a patient with limbic encephalitis

Interest of rare autoantibodies in autoimmune encephalitis and paraneoplastic neurological syndromes: the utility (or futility) of rare antibody discovery

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The increasing recognition and diagnosis of autoimmune encephalitis (AE) and paraneoplastic neurological syndromes (PNS) is partly due to neural autoantibody testing and discovery. The past two decades witnessed an exponential growth in the number of identified neural antibodies. This review aims to summarize recent rare antibody discoveries in the context of central nervous system (CNS) autoimmunity and evaluate the ongoing debate about their utility.

RECENT FINDINGS

In the last 5 years alone 15 novel neural autoantibody specificities were identified. These include rare neural antibody biomarkers of autoimmune encephalitis, cerebellar ataxia or other movement disorders, including multifocal presentations.

SUMMARY

Although the clinical applications of these rare antibody discoveries may be limited by the low number of positive cases, they still provide important diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic insights.

Human serum-derived α-synuclein auto-antibodies mediate NMDA receptor-dependent degeneration of CNS neurons

BACKGROUND

Presence of autoantibodies against α-synuclein (α-syn AAb) in serum of the general population has been widely reported. That such peripheral factors may be involved in central nervous system pathophysiology was demonstrated by detection of immunoglobulins (IgGs) in cerebrospinal fluid and brain of Parkinson's disease (PD) patients. Thus, blood-borne IgGs may reach the brain parenchyma through an impaired blood-brain barrier (BBB).

FINDINGS

The present study aims to evaluate the patho-physiological impact of α-syn AAbs on primary brain cells, i.e., on spontaneously active neurons and on astrocytes. Exposure of neuron-astrocyte co-cultures to human serum containing α-syn AAbs mediated a dose-dependent reduction of spontaneous neuronal activity, and subsequent neurodegeneration. Removal specifically of α-syn AAbs from the serum prevented neurotoxicity, while purified, commercial antibodies against α-syn mimicked the neurodegenerative effect. Mechanistically, we found a strong calcium flux into neurons preceding α-syn AAbs-induced cell death, specifically through NMDA receptors. NMDA receptor antagonists prevented neurodegeneration upon treatment with α-syn (auto)antibodies. α-syn (auto)antibodies did not affect astrocyte survival. However, in presence of α-syn, astrocytes reacted to α-syn antibodies by secretion of the chemokine RANTES.

CONCLUSION

These findings provide a novel basis to explain how a combination of BBB impairment and infiltration of IgGs targeting synuclein may contribute to neurodegeneration in PD and argue for caution with α-syn immunization therapies for treatment of PD.

Immunoreactivity to astrocytes in different forms of dementia: High prevalence of autoantibodies to GFAP

Objective

To study the prevalence of autoantibodies to glial and neuronal antigens with a focus on glial acidic fibrillary protein (GFAP) in patients with dementia.

Methods

Sera of 127 patients with different forms of dementia and sera of 82 age-matched patients with various neurological diseases except for dementia, as well as sera from 15 age-matched healthy controls were analyzed for anti-glial or anti-neuronal IgG using 1) primary murine embryonic hippocampus cell cultures, 2) murine brain sections, 3) immunoblotting on mouse brain homogenates and 4) astrocyte cultures. Sera reacting with astrocytes in hippocampus cell cultures were further analyzed using HEK293 cells transfected with human GFAP.

Results

IgG in serum from 45 of 127 (35.5%) patients with dementia but only 8 of 97 (8.2%, p ≤ 0.001) controls bound to either glial or neuronal structures in cultured murine hippocampus cells. In these cultures antibodies to astrocytes were detected in 35 of 127 (27.5%) of the dementia patients, whereas in controls antibodies to astrocytes were detected in 4 sera only (4.1%, p ≤ 0.001). Among the sera exhibiting reactivity to astrocytes, 14 of 35 (40%) showed immunoreaction to HEK293 cells transfected with GFAP in dementia patients, representing 11% of all sera. Within the 4 immunoreactive control sera reacting with astrocytes one reacted with GFAP (1.0% of total immunoreactivity, p = 0.003).

Conclusions

Autoantibodies to glial epitopes in general and to GFAP in particular are more frequent in patients with dementia than in age-matched controls without dementia, thus indicating the need for further investigations regarding the potential pathophysiological relevance of these antibodies.

Brain blood vessel autoantibodies in patients with NMDA and GABAA receptor encephalitis: identification of unconventional Myosin-X as target antigen

Introduction: The antibody repertoire from CSF-derived antibody-secreting cells and memory B-cells in patients with encephalitis contains a considerable number of antibodies that do not target the disease-defining autoantigen such as the GABA or NMDA receptors. This study focuses on the functional relevance of autoantibodies to brain blood vessels in patients with GABA_A and NMDA receptor encephalitis. Methods: We tested 149 human monoclonal IgG antibodies from the cerebrospinal fluid of six patients with different forms of autoimmune encephalitis on murine brain sections for reactivity to blood vessels using immunohistochemistry. Positive candidates were tested for reactivity with purified brain blood vessels, effects on transendothelial electrical resistance (TEER), and expression of tight junction proteins as well as gene regulation using human brain microvascular endothelial hCMEC/D3 cells as in vitro blood-brain barrier model. One blood-vessel reactive antibody was infused intrathecally by pump injection in mice to study in vivo binding and effects on tight junction proteins such as Occludin. Target protein identification was addressed using transfected HEK293 cells. Results: Six antibodies reacted with brain blood vessels, three were from the same patient with GABA_AR encephalitis, and the other three were from different patients with NMDAR encephalitis. One antibody from an NMDAR encephalitis patient, mAb 011-138, also reacted with cerebellar Purkinje cells. In this case, treatment of hCMEC/D3 cells resulted in decreased TEER, reduced Occludin expression, and mRNA levels. Functional relevance in vivo was confirmed as Occludin downregulation was observed in mAb 011-138-infused animals. Unconventional Myosin-X was identified as a novel autoimmune target for this antibody. Discussion: We conclude that autoantibodies to blood vessels occur in autoimmune encephalitis patients and might contribute to a disruption of the blood-brain barrier thereby suggesting a potential pathophysiological relevance of these antibodies.

Maternal synapsin autoantibodies are associated with neurodevelopmental delay

Maternal autoantibodies can be transmitted diaplacentally, with potentially deleterious effects on neurodevelopment. Synapsin 1 (SYN1) is a neuronal protein that is important for synaptic communication and neuronal plasticity. While monoallelic loss of function (LoF) variants in the SYN1 gene result in X-linked intellectual disability (ID), learning disabilities, epilepsy, behavioral problems, and macrocephaly, the effect of SYN1 autoantibodies on neurodevelopment remains unclear. We recruited a clinical cohort of 208 mothers and their children with neurologic abnormalities and analyzed the role of maternal SYN1 autoantibodies. We identified seropositivity in 9.6% of mothers, and seropositivity was associated with an increased risk for ID and behavioral problems. Furthermore, children more frequently had epilepsy, macrocephaly, and developmental delay, in line with the SYN1 LoF phenotype. Whether SYN1 autoantibodies have a direct pathogenic effect on neurodevelopment or serve as biomarkers requires functional experiments.

Autoantibodies in neurological disease

The realization that autoantibodies can contribute to dysfunction of the brain has brought about a paradigm shift in neurological diseases over the past decade, offering up important novel diagnostic and therapeutic opportunities. Detection of specific autoantibodies to neuronal or glial targets has resulted in a better understanding of central nervous system autoimmunity and in the reclassification of some diseases previously thought to result from infectious, 'idiopathic' or psychogenic causes. The most prominent examples, such as aquaporin 4 autoantibodies in neuromyelitis optica or NMDAR autoantibodies in encephalitis, have stimulated an entire field of clinical and experimental studies on disease mechanisms and immunological abnormalities. Also, these findings inspired the search for additional autoantibodies, which has been very successful to date and has not yet reached its peak. This Review summarizes this rapid development at a point in time where preclinical studies have started delivering fundamental new data for mechanistic understanding, where new technologies are being introduced into this field, and - most importantly - where the first specifically tailored immunotherapeutic approaches are emerging.

Autoimmune encephalitis with psychiatric features in adults: historical evolution and prospective challenge

Our review aims to delineate the psychiatric spectrum of autoantibody-associated autoimmune encephalitis over time through its discoveries of antibodies. We searched in PubMed for appropriate articles depicting the first appearance and spectrum of psychiatric symptomatology in autoantibody-positive encephalitis for this narrative review. Memory impairment was first associated with autoantibodies against intracellular antigens such as anti-HuD antibodies in 1993. 8 years later, autoantibodies against cell membrane surface antigens such as voltage-gated potassium channels were described in conjunction with memory dysfunction. The spectrum of psychiatric syndromes was amplified between 1990 and 2020 to include disorientation, behavior, cognitive dysfunction, obsessive compulsive behavior and suicidality in encephalitis patients occurring together mainly with antibodies against surface antigens, less so against intracellular antigens. In general, we found no specific psychiatric symptoms underlying specific autoantibody-associated encephalitis. As fundamental data on this issue have not been systemically assessed to date, we cannot know whether our specific findings would remain from systematic studies, i.e., on the association between cerebrospinal fluid N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antibodies in catatonia. The psychiatric symptomatology overlaps between psychiatric domains and occurs frequently in antibody-positive encephalitis. No specific psychiatric symptoms imply an underlying, specifically autoantibody-associated encephalitis. The psychiatric phenotypology associated with antibody-positive encephalitis has evolved tremendously recently, and this new evidence reveals its relevance for future diagnostic and treatment aspects of autoimmune encephalitis patients.

Autoimmune psychosis: an international consensus on an approach to the diagnosis and management of psychosis of suspected autoimmune origin

There is increasing recognition in the neurological and psychiatric literature of patients with so-called isolated psychotic presentations (ie, with no, or minimal, neurological features) who have tested positive for neuronal autoantibodies (principally N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antibodies) and who have responded to immunotherapies. Although these individuals are sometimes described as having atypical, mild, or attenuated forms of autoimmune encephalitis, some authors feel that that these cases are sufficiently different from typical autoimmune encephalitis to establish a new category of so-called autoimmune psychosis. We briefly review the background, discuss the existing evidence for a form of autoimmune psychosis, and propose a novel, conservative approach to the recognition of possible, probable, and definite autoimmune psychoses for use in psychiatric practice. We also outline the investigations required and the appropriate therapeutic approaches, both psychiatric and immunological, for probable and definite cases of autoimmune psychoses, and discuss the ethical issues posed by this challenging diagnostic category.

Autoantibodies to synapsin I sequestrate synapsin I and alter synaptic function

Synapsin I is a phosphoprotein that coats the cytoplasmic side of synaptic vesicles and regulates their trafficking within nerve terminals. Autoantibodies against Syn I have been described in sera and cerebrospinal fluids of patients with numerous neurological diseases, including limbic encephalitis and clinically isolated syndrome; however, the effects and fate of autoantibodies in neurons are still unexplored. We found that in vitro exposure of primary hippocampal neurons to patient’s autoantibodies to SynI decreased the density of excitatory and inhibitory synapses and impaired both glutamatergic and GABAergic synaptic transmission. These effects were reproduced with a purified SynI antibody and completely absent in SynI knockout neurons. Autoantibodies to SynI are internalized by FcγII/III-mediated endocytosis, interact with endogenous SynI, and promote its sequestration and intracellular aggregation. Neurons exposed to human autoantibodies to SynI display a reduced density of SVs, mimicking the SynI loss-of-function phenotype. Our data indicate that autoantibodies to intracellular antigens such as SynI can reach and inactivate their targets and suggest that an antibody-mediated synaptic dysfunction may contribute to the evolution and progression of autoimmune-mediated neurological diseases positive for SynI autoantibodies.

Subtle Phenotype Differences in Psychiatric Patients With and Without Serum Immunoglobulin G Antibodies to Synapsin

The discovery that antibodies targeting neuronal antigens can induce severe psychiatric symptoms has been a significant progress in the understanding of psychiatric disorders. Antibodies targeting synapsin I in serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) were first reported in 2015 in a patient with limbic encephalitis. Because of its regulatory function for neurotransmitter release, synapsin I has been suggested to play a role in psychiatric disorders. It is, however, unknown whether or not synapsin antibodies are of clinical significance in patients with psychiatric disorders. In the present study, we aimed to investigate if synapsin I immunoglobulin (Ig)G serum antibody positive patients admitted to acute psychiatric care have a different psychiatric phenotype than synapsin IgG antibody negative patients. A total of 13 anti-synapsin positive patients were matched for age, sex, and psychiatric diagnosis with 39 anti-synapsin negative patients from the same cohort. The groups were compared regarding 11 clinical features frequently seen in anti-neuronal antibody associated disorders. Anti-synapsin positive patients had higher agitation scores as measured with the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale Excited Component [median (interquartile range) 11 (8) versus 7 (7), p = 0.04] compared to controls. However, the absolute scores were low in both groups, and the difference may not be clinically significant. Other clinical features assessed (e.g. hallucinations, delusions) did not differ between groups. We conclude that synapsin serum IgG antibodies lack syndrome specificity in patients admitted to acute psychiatric inpatient care. However, further studies addressing functional effects of synapsin antibodies are needed to conclude whether or not they have a pathophysiological relevance.

Epitope specificity of anti-synapsin autoantibodies: Differential targeting of synapsin I domains

OBJECTIVE

To identify the specific domains of the presynaptic protein synapsin targeted by recently described autoantibodies to synapsin.

METHODS

Sera of 20 and CSF of two patients with different psychiatric and neurological disorders previously tested positive for immunoglobulin (Ig)G antibodies to full-length synapsin were screened for IgG against synapsin I domains using HEK293 cells transfected with constructs encoding different domains of rat synapsin Ia. Additionally, IgG subclasses were determined using full-length synapsin Ia. Serum and CSF from one patient were also screened for IgA autoantibodies to synapsin I domains. Sera from nine and CSF from two healthy subjects were analyzed as controls.

RESULTS

IgG in serum from 12 of 20 IgG synapsin full-length positive patients, but from none of the healthy controls, bound to synapsin domains. Of these 12 sera, six bound to the A domain, five to the D domain, and one to the B- (and possibly A-), D-, and E-domains of synapsin I. IgG antibodies to the D-domain were also detected in one of the CSF samples. Determination of IgG subclasses detected IgG1 in two sera and one CSF, IgG2 in none of the samples, IgG3 in two sera, and IgG4 in eight sera. One patient known to be positive for IgA antibodies to full-length synapsin had IgA antibodies to the D-domain in serum and CSF.

CONCLUSIONS

Anti-synapsin autoantibodies preferentially bind to either the A- or the D-domain of synapsin I.

High prevalence and functional effects of serum antineuronal antibodies in patients with gastrointestinal disorders

BACKGROUND

Antineuronal antibodies can be associated with both gastrointestinal (GI) and brain disorders. For example, antibodies against the potassium channel subunit dipeptidyl-peptidase-like protein-6 (DPPX) bind to neurons in the central nervous system (CNS) and myenteric plexus and cause encephalitis, commonly preceded by severe unspecific GI symptoms. We therefore investigated the prevalence of antineuronal antibodies indicative of treatable autoimmune CNS etiologies in GI patients.

METHODS

Serum samples of 107 patients (Crohn's disease n = 42, ulcerative colitis n = 16, irritable bowel syndrome n = 13, others n = 36) and 44 healthy controls were screened for anti-DPPX and further antineuronal antibodies using immunofluorescence on rat brain and intestine and cell-based assays. Functional effects of high-titer reactive sera were assessed in organ bath and Ussing chamber experiments and compared to non-reactive patient sera.

KEY RESULTS

Twenty-one of 107 patients (19.6%) had antibodies against the enteric nervous system, and 22 (20.6%) had anti-CNS antibodies, thus significantly exceeding frequencies in healthy controls (4.5% each). Screening on cell-based assays excluded established antienteric antibodies. Antibody-positive sera were not associated with motility effects in organ bath experiments. However, they induced significant, tetrodotoxin (TTX)-insensitive secretion in Ussing chambers compared to antibody-negative sera.

CONCLUSIONS & INFERENCES

Antineuronal antibodies were significantly more frequent in GI patients and associated with functional effects on bowel secretion. Future studies will determine whether such antibodies indicate patients who might benefit from additional antibody-directed therapies. However, well-characterized encephalitis-related autoantibodies such as against DPPX were not detected, underlining their rarity in routine cohorts.

Estimation of intrathecal IgG synthesis: simulation of the risk of underestimation

Objective

The low level of passively diffused IgG through the blood–brain barrier is sufficient to blur the estimation of intrathecal IgG synthesis (ITS). Therefore, this estimation requires a mathematical calculation derived from empirical laws, but the range of normal values in healthy controls is wide enough to prevent a precise calculation. This study investigated the precision of various methods of ITS estimations and their application to two clinical situations: plasma exchange and immune suppression targeting ITS.

Methods

Based on a mathematical model of ITS, we constructed a population of healthy controls and applied a tunable ITS.

Results

We demonstrate the following results: underestimation of ITS is common at individual level but true ITS is well fitted by cohorts; Q_IgG increases after plasma exchange; IgG_Loc calculation based on Qlim falsely increases when Q_Alb decreases; the sample size required to demonstrate a decrease in ITS increases exponentially with larger Q_Alb.

Interpretation

Studies evaluating changes in ITS level should be adjusted to Q_Alb. Low amounts of ITS could be largely underestimated.

Synapsin-antibodies in psychiatric and neurological disorders: Prevalence and clinical findings

OBJECTIVE

To study the prevalence of autoantibodies to synapsin in patients with psychiatric and neurological disorders and to describe clinical findings in synapsin antibody positive patients.

METHODS

Sera of 375 patients with different psychiatric and neurological disorders and sera of 97 healthy controls were screened (dilution 1:320) for anti-synapsin IgG using HEK293 cells transfected with rat synapsin Ia. Positive sera were further analyzed by immunoblots with brain tissue from wild type and synapsin knock out mice and with HEK293 cells transfected with human synapsin Ia and Ib. Binding of synapsin IgG positive sera to primary neurons was studied using murine hippocampal neurons.

RESULTS

IgG in serum from 23 (6.1%) of 375 patients, but from none of the 97 healthy controls (p=0.007), bound to rat synapsin Ia transfected cells with a median (range) titer of 1:1000 (1:320-1:100,000). Twelve of the 23 positive sera reacted with a protein of the molecular size of synapsin I in immunoblots of wild type but not of synapsin knock out mouse brain tissue. Out of 19/23 positive sera available for testing, 13 bound to human synapsin Ia and 16 to human synapsin Ib transfected cells. Synapsin IgG positive sera stained fixed and permeabilized murine hippocampal neurons. Synapsin IgG positive patients had various psychiatric and neurological disorders. Tumors were documented in 2 patients (melanoma, small cell lung carcinoma); concomitant anti-neuronal or other autoantibodies were present in 8 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Autoantibodies to human synapsin Ia and Ib are detectable in a proportion of sera from patients with different psychiatric and neurological disorders, warranting further investigation into the potential pathophysiological relevance of these antibodies.

High prevalence of neuronal surface autoantibodies associated with cognitive deficits in cancer patients

The recent discovery of neuronal cell-surface antibodies profoundly expanded the clinical spectrum of paraneoplastic neurological syndromes. Many of these syndromes are associated with impaired cognitive function, a clinical symptom that is of increasing concern in cancer patients. However, the frequency of these antibodies in cancer patients and their relation to clinical syndromes is currently unknown. Here, we investigated the prevalence of neuronal cell-surface antibodies and associated paraneoplastic neurological syndromes in 323 patients with different cancer types and in 105 controls. Cerebrospinal fluid and serum samples were analysed for a large panel of anti-neuronal antibodies and all patients were screened for cognitive deficits. Blood-brain barrier integrity was assessed using the age-normalized albumin cerebrospinal fluid/serum ratio. Anti-neuronal autoantibodies were observed in 24.5% of cancer patients (in contrast to 3.1% in neurological control patients without cancer and 2.5% in healthy controls) and were almost exclusively detected in serum. The majority of antibodies were directed against cell-surface antigens (75.9%), most frequently IgA/IgM isotypes targeting the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor. Cognitive deficits and cerebellar syndromes were significantly more prevalent in antibody-positive in comparison with antibody-negative patients (21 vs. 7%, p = 2.7 × 10^-4; 11 vs. 2%, p = 3.0 × 10^-3). Antibody-positive patients with cognitive deficits had a significantly increased albumin cerebrospinal fluid/serum ratio in comparison with antibody-positive patients with other neurological deficits, indicating blood-brain barrier dysfunction (49.1 × 10^-3 vs. 12.0 × 10^-3; p = 0.036). Our results show that anti-neuronal antibodies have a high prevalence in a wide range of different tumour types and are associated with distinct neurological deficits. Specifically, the results suggest a so far undefined cognitive paraneoplastic syndrome in patients with antibodies targeting neuronal surface antigens and concurrent blood-brain barrier dysfunction. Anti-neuronal antibodies might thus serve as a biomarker for potentially treatment-responsive cognitive impairments in cancer patients.