Antibodies to acetylcholine receptor in patients with thymoma but without myasthenia gravis

Seropositive myasthenia and autoimmune autonomic ganglionopathy: cross reactivity or subclinical disease?

Autoimmune autonomic ganglionopathy (AAG) and myasthenia gravis (MG) are both autoimmune channelopathies mediated by antibodies directed against nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. While both diseases target acetylcholine receptors, skeletal muscle and ganglionic receptor subtypes have key immunologic and genetic distinctions, and reports of patients with both AAG and MG are rare. We report a patient with antibody-confirmed AAG and elevated levels of ACh binding antibodies that did not meet clinical or electrodiagnostic criteria for MG. We presume that his skeletal muscle nAChR seropositivity was a false positive, perhaps due to the cross reactivity of the patient's ganglionic nAChR antibodies with skeletal nAChR subtypes.

Autoantibody Profiles and Neurological Correlations of Thymoma

PURPOSE

Determine muscle and neuronal autoantibody frequencies in patients with thymoma, with and without paraneoplastic neurological accompaniments.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Analysis of IgG autoantibodies in stored serum collected between 1985 and 2003 from 201 patients with histologically diagnosed thymoma (including six with thymic carcinoma). Contemporary assays quantitated antibodies reactive with muscle and neuronal cation channels, muscle sarcomeric proteins and neuronal cytoplasmic, and nuclear proteins.

RESULTS

Neurological diagnoses included myasthenia gravis (MG), myositis, encephalitis, neuromuscular hyperexcitability, autonomic neuropathy, and subacute hearing loss, a previously unrecognized accompaniment of thymoma. Muscle acetylcholine receptor (AChR) binding antibodies were found in all patients with a diagnosis of MG. Muscle autoantibodies (AChR-binding, AChR-modulating, or striational) were also found in 59% of patients without any neurological disorder. One or more neuronal autoantibodies were found in 41% of patients without any neurological disorder, 43% of patients with MG only, and 78% of patients with other neurological disorders. Neuronal autoantibody specificities were, in descending order of frequency, as follows: glutamic acid decarboxylase, voltage-gated potassium channel, collapsin response-mediator protein-5, ganglionic AChR, and antineuronal nuclear antibody-type 1 (ANNA-1).

CONCLUSIONS

Neuronal autoantibodies complement skeletal muscle autoantibodies as serological markers of thymoma in patients with and without clinical evidence of a neurological disorder. The high prevalence of glutamic acid decarboxylase autoantibody, not previously considered a paraneoplastic marker, justifies its consideration as a marker of thymoma-related neurological autoimmunity. Serological evaluation of a patient's profile of neuronal and muscle autoantibodies may aid in preoperative identification of an indeterminate mediastinal mass.

Fulminant autoimmune cortical encephalitis associated with thymoma treated with plasma exchange

A 55-year-old man presented with fever, malaise, dysarthria, and intermittent twitching of his right hand. He progressed rapidly to aphasia, intractable myoclonic seizures, and unresponsiveness. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the head demonstrated multiple nonenhancing areas of signal abnormality involving the cortex of both cerebral hemispheres. Extensive evaluation revealed no infectious cause for his symptoms. Muscle acetylcholine receptor binding and modulating antibodies, striational antibodies, and a neuronal autoantibody specific for collapsin response-mediator protein were detected. An invasive thymoma was discovered and resected. Brain biopsy revealed microglial activation, gliosis, and scant perivascular lymphocytic inflammation. His condition worsened despite treatment with anticonvulsants, intravenous corticosteroids, and antimicrobials. Plasma exchange was performed. The myoclonus stopped; he regained consciousness and gradually improved to the point that he could talk and ambulate with assistance. An MRI revealed regression of the lesions with residual cortical atrophy. This case demonstrates that paraneoplastic encephalitis may occur with thymoma and may extend to cortical regions outside the limbic system.

Exacerbation of myasthenia gravis after removal of thymomas

It appeared from this prospective and non-randomized study, that the removal of thymomas in myasthenia gravis (MG) patients resulted in rapid exacerbation of the clinical severity of the disease and of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies titres, which peaked after about 300 days and continued for up to 2 years. Long-term follow-up after thymomectomy (mean duration +/- SEM after surgery 5.5 +/- 0.8 years) showed that the immunological and clinical state observed prior to surgery was eventually restored, but long-term benefit attributable to surgery could not be demonstrated. Non-thymoma MG cases, however, exhibited post-operative amelioration in clinical course and decreasing antibodies titres, both of which were already significant one year after surgery, and additional improvement was observed at the time of long-term follow-up (mean 4.3 +/- 0.5 years). Furthermore, the prognosis for MG patients not operated on was also favourable. It is suggested that the occurrence of thymomas is linked to genetic factors and that neoplasia of the thymus may be part of immunoregulatory mechanisms with predominance of inhibition.

Ocular myasthenia gravis. A critical review of clinical and pathophysiological aspects

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is probably the best studied autoimmune disease caused by autoantibodies against the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) at the neuromuscular junction, subsequently leading to abnormal fatigability and weakness of skeletal muscle. Extraocular muscle weakness with droopy eyelids and double vision is present in about 90% of MG patients, being the initial complaint in about 50%. In approximately 20% of the patients the disease will always be confined to the extraocular muscles. The single most important diagnostic test is the detection of serum antibodies against AChR which is positive in 90% of patients with generalized MG, but only in 65% with purely ocular MG. Electromyographic studies and the Tensilon test are of diagnostic value in clear-cut cases, but may be equivocal in purely ocular myasthenia, especially the latter not rarely producing false-positive results. Treatment response to corticosteroids and anti-cholinesterase agents is satisfactory in many patients with ocular MG, however other immunosuppressive drugs may also be needed. Pathogenetically relevant steps of the underlying autoimmune process have been elucidated during the last few years; nevertheless a number of questions remain open, especially what starts off the autoimmune process, and why are eye muscles so frequently involved in MG?

T-helper epitopes on human nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in myasthenia gravis

The synthesis of AChR antibodies requires intervention of AChR-specific Th cells. Because of the paucity of anti-AChR Th cells in the blood of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients, direct studies of these autoimmune cells in the blood are seldom possible. Propagation in vitro of anti-AChR T cells from MG patients by cycles of stimulation with AChR antigens selectively enriches and expands the autoimmune T-cell clones, allowing investigation of their function and epitope specificity. Torpedo electroplax AChR was initially used for propagation of anti-AChR T-cell lines. Those studies demonstrated the feasibility of in vitro propagation of AChR-specific T cells. These are bona fide CD4+ Th cells, which stimulate production in vitro of anti-AChR antibodies by B cells of myasthenic patients and recognize equally well denatured and native AChR, suggesting the usefulness of synthetic human AChR sequences as antigens for propagation of the autoimmune Th cells. We used pools of overlapping synthetic peptides, corresponding to the complete sequences of the human AChR alpha-, beta-, gamma-, and delta-subunits, to propagate AChR-specific Th cells from the blood of MG patients. The AChR sequence regions forming epitopes recognized by the autoimmune T cells were determined by challenging the lines with individual synthetic peptides, 20 residues long, screening the AChR subunit sequences. Although each line had an individual pattern of epitope recognition--as expected from their different HLA-DR haplotype--some peptides were recognized by most of all the CD4+ T-cell lines, irrespective of their DR haplotype. The existence of immunodominant regions of the AChR sequence was verified by investigating the response of unselected CD4+ cells from the blood of a relatively large number of MG patients to the individual peptides screening the human alpha-, gamma-, and delta-subunit sequences. Those studies confirmed that each patient has an individual pattern of peptide recognition. The studies also identified a large number of T epitopes of the human AChR and verified the existence of sequence regions immunodominant for T-helper sensitization, because a limited number of sequence regions, including all those immunodominant for the T-helper lines, were recognized by most patients. Anti-AChR CD4+ T lines could be propagated from some healthy controls only for a brief period of time. They recognized AChR sequences poorly, suggesting a low affinity of their T-cell receptors for the corresponding AChR epitopes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Clinical implementation of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies

A multivariate analysis of anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies and clinical parameters other than treatment (modified Osserman groups, age, type of onset, sex, and thymus pathology) was performed for all incident (n = 366) myasthenia gravis (MG) cases in its white population in Denmark during the past 15 years. Sera from 244 healthy individuals and from 295 patients with diseases other than MG were analysed as controls. Formal statistics for the anti-AChR antibodies assay (immunoprecipitation RIA using crude human AChR extract) were calculated. The distribution of antibodies titres greater than 0.1 nMole/l was found to be approximately lognormal. For MG patients the 95% reference interval was 0.2-1549 nMoles/l, and in control sera the range was 0.0-0.4 nMole/l. Using 0.5 nMole/l as the cut-off level and regarding all results less than this value as normal titres, it appeared that the assay was highly specific (> 99.99%) for MG. In a population of MG patients significance should be attributed to values in the range 0.3-0.4 nMole/l. The overall diagnostic sensitivity was found to be 88%. The sensitivity appeared to be proportionate to clinical severity of MG. The percentage with a normal titre was higher (16%) for early onset of MG, compared with 7% for late onset. No significant difference in relation to the frequency of "negative titre" was found in relation to sex. Anti-AChR antibodies titre was found to correlate with clinical severity, female or male gender, and pathology of thymus. The groups of MG patients were not matched for the various clinical parameters but multiple regression analysis controlling for these variables revealed independent effects of clinical severity and sex though not of age. Normal thymus (including involuted gland) and thymoma were correlated with low to intermediate tires, and hyperplastic thymus with high level of antibodies. The clinical implementation of anti-AchR antibodies is reviewed from 1976 and up to the present. The problems with false positive results are thoroughly expounded.

Potential role of thymoma and other mediastinal tumors in the pathogenesis of myasthenia gravis

Ten non-myasthenic thymoma patients and 12 patients with other mediastinal tumors were compared with 19 myasthenic thymoma patients with regard to an increase in circulating CD4+CD8+ cells and the presence of anti-acetylcholine receptor and anti-skeletal muscle antibodies. Although seven non-myasthenic thymoma patients showed positive results, the proportion of myasthenic thymoma patients who were positive for more than one parameter was significantly larger than that of non-myasthenic thymoma patients (89% vs. 40%). Moreover, one patient with a non-thymomatous mediastinal tumor showing a high CD4+CD8+ cell level had a recent history of seronegative myasthenia gravis. The results indicate that measurements of these parameters may predict the risk of the development of MG in patients with thymoma and other mediastinal tumors.

Anti-skeletal muscle and anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies in patients with thymoma without myasthenia gravis: relation to the onset of myasthenia gravis

We measured the anti-skeletal muscle (SM) antibody titers in sera from 46 patients with thymoma but without Myasthenia gravis (MG) in order to determine whether the presence of anti-SM antibody is linked to the combination of thymoma-MG, or to thymoma alone. We detected anti-SM antibodies in 18 of these sera, of which 15 had concomitantly elevated titers of anti-AChR antibodies. Moreover, 9 of whom had experienced the onset of MG after surgery. In contrast, no patient without elevations in both antibodies developed MG during the followup. We conclude that the presence of anti-SM antibodies is linked strongly with thymoma associated with MG, but not with thymoma alone.

Neuromuscular disorders and thymoma

We describe a patient who had asymmetrical atrophy of limb muscles and myasthenic weakness of neck, facial, and bulbar muscles. Electrophysiological tests indicated myasthenia gravis of facial muscles and changes consistent with an asymmetrical motor neuropathy as a cause of the muscle atrophy. Both conditions occurred as complications of a locally invasive thymoma, and both failed to improve after surgery and radiation but substantially improved with subsequent treatment by corticosteroids, azathioprine, and plasmapheresis. Review of the literature disclosed that several neuromuscular conditions may be associated with thymoma, the commonest being myasthenia gravis. Muscle atrophy may occur in 10% of patients who have myasthenia gravis, whether associated with or without thymoma. Its mechanism is debated, and further studies are needed, but observations in our patient suggest the atrophy is due to a motor neuropathy. Primary treatment of the thymoma by surgery, irradiation if the tumor is invasive, and immunosuppressive therapy for neuromuscular complications offers a relatively good prognosis for this group of patients.

Acetylcholine receptor antibody as a diagnostic test for myasthenia gravis: results in 153 validated cases and 2967 diagnostic assays

Anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibody was undetectable in 26/153 (17%) sera from myasthenia gravis patients assayed by standard RIA using human acetylcholine receptor. Eight of these were found to be positive with a modified protocol using a mixture of normal and denervated AChR, reducing the proportion of "negative" sera to 12%. Many of these were from patients with a short history; two such patients later developed low positive values. Anti-AChR without clinical evidence of myasthenia was found in one of three monozygotic twins of myasthenia gravis patients, and in one of thirty other first degree relatives of a further 17 patients. Anti-AChR is a valuable and highly specific diagnostic test which, with the assay used here, is positive in about 88% of patients with clinical features of myasthenia gravis.

Acetylcholine receptor antibodies in the elderly and in Down's syndrome

Serum antibodies to the acetylcholine receptor (anti-AChR) have been reported in Japanese individuals who were elderly or had Down's syndrome at frequencies of 18% and 24%, respectively. We have measured serum anti-AChR in 3 Caucasoid groups: 53 elderly patients (aged 65-92 years) with miscellaneous (non-myasthenic) disorders, 30 individuals with Down's syndrome, and 40 elderly patients (aged 71-93 years) known to have strongly positive thyroid autoantibodies. A raised titre (greater than 0.2 nmol/l) was confined to 3 patients in the third group (7.5%). We conclude that an increased frequency of anti-AChR antibodies is not a feature of Caucasians who are elderly or have Down's syndrome, and that, even in an elderly group with a high titre of another autoantibody, the frequency of anti-AChR is lower than in elderly Japanese individuals.

Acetylcholine receptor antibody in the diagnosis of myasthenia gravis

The acetylcholine receptor (AchR) antibody assay has a key role in the diagnosis of myasthenia gravis. In this article, the role of AchR antibody assay in the diagnosis of ocular and generalized myasthenia gravis is reviewed, and compared to standard means of diagnosing the disease by clinical and electrophysiological methods.

Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies in myasthenia gravis. Part 2. Clinical and serological follow-up of individual patients

Circulating antibodies to acetylcholine receptor protein (anti-AChR) were measured in the sera collected from 75 patients (53 women, 22 men, ages 9-83 year, 20 with a thymoma) with myasthenia gravis (MG) during 5-44 (mean 25) months. The clinical state of each patient was graded on a 6-point scale. Anti-AChR concentrations were measured by a radioimmunoassay with human antigen. We analysed the relation between the change in clinical state and the change in anti-AChR concentration in 155 periods (1-7, mean 2.1 per patient). The change in clinical state is given as the difference in score at the onset and at the end of this period. The change in anti-AChR concentration is expressed as the percentage of the original concentration at the onset of the period. The results were analysed in relation to the therapy and to the severity of the MG at the onset of each period. A strong correlation between a change in anti-AChR concentration and a change in clinical condition existed during treatment with prednisone or immunosuppression and in the period after thymectomy, while a weaker correlation was present in periods without immunosuppression. In only 3 patients did the changes in anti-AChR concentration precede the clinical change. No changes in anti-AChR concentrations were found if improvement was due to the effect of anticholinesterases or if deterioration was caused by infection or emotion. The serial measurement of anti-AChR may be a valuable method of following the basic trend of the MG in severely affected patients.

Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies in myasthenia gravis. Part 1. Relation to clinical parameters in 250 patients

We examined the significance of the presence or absence of anti-acetylcholine receptor (anti-AChR) antibodies in 250 myasthenia gravis (MG) patients and the relation between clinical features and anti-AChR levels. We found high anti-AChR levels in 2 out of 11 thymoma patients without MG, while 37 out of 250 MG patients had no detectable anti-AChR. The absence of these antibodies was related to purely ocular disease and to steroid therapy and/or thymectomy. Differences in anti-AChR levels did not correspond significantly to differences in disease activity when single measurements in patients were analysed. However, the results were influenced by both the presence or absence of a thymoma, the age at onset of disease and by steroid therapy. The thymic pathology and age at onset seemed to act independently. Early onset of disease was associated with high anti-AChR levels and absence of antibodies to striated muscle (anti-SM), whereas late onset was associated with low anti-AChR and the presence of anti-SM. Thymomas both have high anti-AChR and high anti-SM. The effect of steroid therapy on antibody levels was seen in all patient groups but was strongest in thymoma patients with early onset of disease.

Acetylcholine receptors and myasthenia gravis

Recent years have seen considerable progress in understanding the nature of the molecular events involved in neuromuscular transmission. The acetylcholine receptor (AChR) has been purified to homogeneity and acetylcholine-induced ion transport has been reconstituted by incorporation of pure AChR into artificial membranes. Immunization against purified AChR induces a condition, clinically and physiologically similar to the human disease myasthenia gravis, which is due to circulating anti-AChR antibodies. This model, experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis, is proving useful for investigating the role of genetic factors in determining the immune response to AChRs and for testing various experimental approaches to specific treatment. Myasthenia gravis is an autoimmune disease in which there is loss of acetylcholine receptors at the neuromuscular junction. Anti-AChR antibodies can be detected in the majority of patients and they cause loss of AChR by a variety of mechanisms. Anti-AChR antibody is heterogeneous and not restricted in idiotype. The role of the thymus in MG is still uncertain, but recent experiments implicate the presence of a cell type in MG thymus which may be involved in autosensitization to AChR.

The diagnostic significance of autoantibodies to the acetylcholine receptor

The predictive value of the assay for antibodies to the acetylcholine receptor (anti-AChR) is dependent upon the reference range used and the question being asked by the clinician. A reference range has been established after assaying sera from 200 healthy individuals, 314 patients with diseases often considered in the differential diagnosis of myasthenia gravis (MG) or found in association with MG, and 72 patients with active adult onset MG. If the assay is to be used to screen an unselected population for MG a conservative cut off point (2 units) should be used. After establishment of a differential diagnosis more significant may be attributed to a lower result (1 unit or greater). A negative result does not exclude MG. In patients with Systemic Lupus Erythematosus. Graves' disease or thymoma anti-AChR has been demonstrated in the absence of signs of MG. Such patients may have latent or subclinical MG. Two such patients subsequently developed clinically evident MG concomitant with a rise in anti AChR titre above their particular 'biological threshold'.

Lymphocyte populations in patients with myasthenia gravis. Influence of thymectomy and immunosuppressive drugs

The T/B peripheral blood lymphocyte ratio was evaluated in 51 patients with myasthenia gravis by means of the rosette test and HTLA. Total T cells and T gamma and Tmu were decreased while B lymphocytes were increased. E-active rosettes were also above the normal range. The previous thymectomy and/or immunosuppressive treatment restored the T lymphocytes identified by HTLA to normal range while those identified by E rosettes were still reduced. This difference may be due to the different stages of T lymphocyte maturation.

Myasthenia gravis. A survey

Myasthenia gravis is a chronic disease characterized by a fluctuating weakness of voluntary muscle, with a preference for the muscles innervated by cranial nerves. The pathophysiological mechanism is a loss of postsynaptic acetylcholine receptors to less than 20-30% so that the safety margin of neuromuscular transmission is lost. It is probable that the function of the remaining acetylcholine receptors is impaired by antibodies against receptor proteïn, which can be demonstrated in the serum in 80-90% of the patients, and which are highly specific for the disease. An experimental autoimmune myasthenia can be induced in many animal species by immunization with purified receptor proteïn and this disease is remarkably similar to the human myasthenia with exception of the fluctuating course. The human disease has to be considered as an autoimmune disease, although the initiating mechanism is unknown. The occurrence of tumors of the thymus in 10-15% and the presence of germinal centres in about 70% of the thymus glands removed by operation are highly suggestive of the importance of the thymus in the pathogenesis, but the definite mechanism (harbouring of an abnormal antigen in myoid cells, or/and false instruction of thymocytes with lack of suppressor cells) is essentially unknown. In most patients the disease tends ot have a favourable course from 5-10 years after onset and complete remission occur in about 20% after 10-20 years. Therapy with anticholinesterases, providing an increase in acetylcholine, is of partial benefit in most patients. Thymectomy has an excellent effect in about 30% of the patients without thymoma under the age of 40 during the first three years of the disease, and is of benefit in still another 30-40%. The use of prednisone and immuno-suppressive drugs has improved the prognosis of the 20% of the patients with severe life threatening symptoms, half of whom have a thymoma.