Combined aerobic training and dichloroacetate improve exercise capacity and indices of aerobic metabolism in muscle cytochrome oxidase deficiency

The pyruvate dehydrogenase complex: Life's essential, vulnerable and druggable energy homeostat

Found in all organisms, pyruvate dehydrogenase complexes (PDC) are the keystones of prokaryotic and eukaryotic energy metabolism. In eukaryotic organisms these multi-component megacomplexes provide a crucial mechanistic link between cytoplasmic glycolysis and the mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle. As a consequence, PDCs also influence the metabolism of branched chain amino acids, lipids and, ultimately, oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). PDC activity is an essential determinant of the metabolic and bioenergetic flexibility of metazoan organisms in adapting to changes in development, nutrient availability and various stresses that challenge maintenance of homeostasis. This canonical role of the PDC has been extensively probed over the past decades by multidisciplinary investigations into its causal association with diverse physiological and pathological conditions, the latter making the PDC an increasingly viable therapeutic target. Here we review the biology of the remarkable PDC and its emerging importance in the pathobiology and treatment of diverse congenital and acquired disorders of metabolic integration.

Dichloroacetate improves mitochondrial function, physiology, and morphology in FBXL4 disease models

Pathogenic variants in the human F-box and leucine-rich repeat protein 4 (FBXL4) gene result in an autosomal recessive, multisystemic, mitochondrial disorder involving variable mitochondrial depletion and respiratory chain complex deficiencies with lactic acidemia. As no FDA-approved effective therapies for this disease exist, we sought to characterize translational C. elegans and zebrafish animal models, as well as human fibroblasts, to study FBXL4^–/– disease mechanisms and identify preclinical therapeutic leads. Developmental delay, impaired fecundity and neurologic and/or muscular activity, mitochondrial dysfunction, and altered lactate metabolism were identified in fbxl-1(ok3741) C. elegans. Detailed studies of a PDHc activator, dichloroacetate (DCA), in fbxl-1(ok3741)C. elegans demonstrated its beneficial effects on fecundity, neuromotor activity, and mitochondrial function. Validation studies were performed in fbxl4^sa12470 zebrafish larvae and in FBXL4^–/– human fibroblasts; they showed DCA efficacy in preventing brain death, impairment of neurologic and/or muscular function, mitochondrial biochemical dysfunction, and stress-induced morphologic and ultrastructural mitochondrial defects. These data demonstrate that fbxl-1(ok3741) C. elegans and fbxl4^sa12470 zebrafish provide robust translational models to study mechanisms and identify preclinical therapeutic candidates for FBXL4^–/– disease. Furthermore, DCA is a lead therapeutic candidate with therapeutic benefit on diverse aspects of survival, neurologic and/or muscular function, and mitochondrial physiology that warrants rigorous clinical trial study in humans with FBXL4^–/– disease.

Exercise Training and Neurodegeneration in Mitochondrial Disorders: Insights From the Harlequin Mouse

Aim

Cerebellar neurodegeneration is a main phenotypic manifestation of mitochondrial disorders caused by apoptosis-inducing factor (AIF) deficiency. We assessed the effects of an exercise training intervention at the cerebellum and brain level in a mouse model (Harlequin, Hq) of AIF deficiency.

Methods

Male wild-type (WT) and Hq mice were assigned to an exercise (Ex) or control (sedentary [Sed]) group (n = 10-12/group). The intervention (aerobic and resistance exercises) was initiated upon the first symptoms of ataxia in Hq mice (∼3 months on average) and lasted 8 weeks. Histological and biochemical analyses of the cerebellum were performed at the end of the training program to assess indicators of mitochondrial deficiency, neuronal death, oxidative stress and neuroinflammation. In brain homogenates analysis of enzyme activities and levels of the oxidative phosphorylation system, oxidative stress and neuroinflammation were performed.

Results

The mean age of the mice at the end of the intervention period did not differ between groups: 5.2 ± 0.2 (WT-Sed), 5.2 ± 0.1 (WT-Ex), 5.3 ± 0.1 (Hq-Sed), and 5.3 ± 0.1 months (Hq-Ex) (p = 0.489). A significant group effect was found for most variables indicating cerebellar dysfunction in Hq mice compared with WT mice irrespective of training status. However, exercise intervention did not counteract the negative effects of the disease at the cerebellum level (i.e., no differences for Hq-Ex vs. Hq-Sed). On the contrary, in brain, the activity of complex V was higher in both Hq mice groups in comparison with WT animals (p < 0.001), and post hoc analysis also revealed differences between sedentary and trained Hq mice.

Conclusion

A combined training program initiated when neurological symptoms and neuron death are already apparent is unlikely to promote neuroprotection in the cerebellum of Hq model of mitochondrial disorders, but it induces higher complex V activity in the brain.

Aerobic Exercise Training in Patients With mtDNA-Related Mitochondrial Myopathy

In patients with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutation, a pathogenic mtDNA mutation is heteroplasmically distributed among tissues. The ratio between wild-type and mutated mtDNA copies determines the mtDNA mutation load of the tissue, which correlates inversively with oxidative capacity of the tissue. In patients with mtDNA mutation, the mutation load is often very high in skeletal muscle compared to other tissues. Additionally, skeletal muscle can increase its oxygen demand up to 100-fold from rest to exercise, which is unmatched by any other tissue. Thus, exercise intolerance is the most common symptom in patients with mtDNA mutation. The impaired oxidative capacity in skeletal muscle in patients with mtDNA mutation results in limitation in physical capacity that interferes with daily activities and impairs quality of life. Additionally, patients with mitochondrial disease due to mtDNA mutation often live a sedentary lifestyle, which further impair oxidative capacity and exercise tolerance. Since aerobic exercise training increase mitochondrial function and volume density in healthy individuals, studies have investigated if aerobic training could be used to counteract the progressive exercise intolerance in patients with mtDNA mutation. Overall studies investigating the effect of aerobic training in patients with mtDNA mutation have shown that aerobic training is an efficient way to improve oxidative capacity in this condition, and aerobic training seems to be safe even for patients with high mtDNA mutation in skeletal muscle.

Neuromuscular and Muscle Metabolic Functions in MELAS Before and After Resistance Training: A Case Study

Mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis, and recurrent stroke-like episodes syndrome (MELAS) is a rare degenerative disease. Recent studies have shown that resistant training (RT) can ameliorate muscular force in mitochondrial diseases. However, the effects of RT in MELAS are unknown. The aim of this case report was to investigate the effects of RT on skeletal muscle and mitochondrial function in a 21-years old patient with MELAS. RT included 12 weeks of RT at 85% of 1 repetition maximum. Body composition (DXA), in vivo mitochondrial respiration capacity (mVO₂) utilizing Near-infrared spectroscopy on the right plantar-flexor muscles, maximal voluntary torque (MVC), electrically evoked resting twitch (EET) and maximal voluntary activation (VMA) of the right leg extensors (LE) muscles were measured with the interpolated twitch technique. The participant with MELAS exhibited a marked increase in body mass (1.4 kg) and thigh muscle mass (0.3 kg). After the training period MVC (+5.5 Nm), EET (+2.1 N⋅m) and VMA (+13.1%) were ameliorated. Data of mVO₂ revealed negligible changes in the end-exercise mVO₂ (0.02 mM min^-1), Δ mVO₂ (0.09 mM min^-1), while there was a marked amelioration in the kinetics of mVO₂ (τ mVO₂; Δ70.2 s). This is the first report of RT-induced ameliorations on skeletal muscle and mitochondrial function in MELAS. This case study suggests a preserved plasticity in the skeletal muscle of a patient with MELAS. RT appears to be an effective method to increase skeletal muscle function, and this effect is mediated by both neuromuscular and mitochondrial adaptations.

Dichloroacetate Prevents Cisplatin-Induced Nephrotoxicity without Compromising Cisplatin Anticancer Properties

Cisplatin is an effective anticancer drug; however, cisplatin use often leads to nephrotoxicity, which limits its clinical effectiveness. In this study, we determined the effect of dichloroacetate, a novel anticancer agent, in a mouse model of cisplatin-induced AKI. Pretreatment with dichloroacetate significantly attenuated the cisplatin-induced increase in BUN and serum creatinine levels, renal tubular apoptosis, and oxidative stress. Additionally, pretreatment with dichloroacetate accelerated tubular regeneration after cisplatin-induced renal damage. Whole transcriptome sequencing revealed that dichloroacetate prevented mitochondrial dysfunction and preserved the energy-generating capacity of the kidneys by preventing the cisplatin-induced downregulation of fatty acid and glucose oxidation, and of genes involved in the Krebs cycle and oxidative phosphorylation. Notably, dichloroacetate did not interfere with the anticancer activity of cisplatin in vivo. These data provide strong evidence that dichloroacetate preserves renal function when used in conjunction with cisplatin.

Cell-permeable protein therapy for complex I dysfunction

Complex I deficiency is difficult to treat because of the size and complexity of the multi-subunit enzyme complex. Mutations or deletions in the mitochondrial genome are not amenable to gene therapy. However, animal studies have shown that yeast-derived internal NADH quinone oxidoreductase (Ndi1) can be delivered as a cell-permeable recombinant protein (Tat-Ndi1) that can functionally replace complex I damaged by ischemia/reperfusion. Current and future treatment of disorders affecting complex I are discussed, including the use of Tat-Ndi1.

Lactate metabolism during exercise in patients with mitochondrial myopathy

Patients with mitochondrial DNA mutations often have elevated plasma lactate at rest and during exercise, but it is unknown whether the high lactate levels are caused by a high production, an impaired oxidation or a combination. We studied lactate kinetics in 10 patients with mtDNA mutations and 10 matched healthy control subjects at rest and during cycle exercise with a combination of femoral arterio-venous differences of lactate, and lactate tracer dilution methodology. During exercise, lactate concentration and production rates were several-fold higher in patients, but despite mitochondrial dysfunction, lactate was oxidized in muscle to the same extent as in healthy control subjects. This surprisingly high ability to burn lactate in working muscle with defective mitochondria, probably relates to the variability of oxidative capacity among muscle fibers. The data suggests that lactate is not solely an indicator of impaired oxidative capacity, but an important fuel for oxidative metabolism, even in muscle with severely impaired mitochondrial function.

Exercise in neuromuscular diseases

This article reviews the current knowledge regarding the benefits and contraindications of exercise on individuals with neuromuscular diseases (NMDs). Specific exercise prescriptions for individuals with NMDs do not exist because the evidence base is limited. Understanding the effect of exercise on individuals with NMDs requires the implementation of a series of multicenter, randomized controlled trials that are sufficiently powered and use reliable and valid outcome measures to assess the effect of exercise interventions-a major effort for each NMD. In addition to traditional measures of exercise efficacy, outcome variables should include measures of functional status and health-related quality of life.

Rehabilitation management of neuromuscular disease: the role of exercise training

This paper summarizes the current state of knowledge regarding exercise and neuromuscular diseases/disorders (NMDs) and reviews salient studies in the literature. Unfortunately, there is inadequate evidence in much of the NMDs to make specific recommendations regarding exercise prescriptions. This review focuses on the role of exercise in a few of the specific NMDs where most research has taken place and recommends future research directions.

Experimental Strategies Towards Treating Mitochondrial DNA Disorders

An extensive range of molecular defects have been identified in the human mitochondrial genome (mtDNA), causing a range of clinical phenotypes characterized by mitochondrial respiratory chain dysfunction. Sadly, given the complexities of mitochondrial genetics, there are no available cures for mtDNA disorders. In this review, we consider experimental, genetic-based strategies that have been or are being explored towards developing treatments, focussing on two specific areas which we are actively pursuing—assessing the benefit of exercise training for patients with mtDNA defects, and the prevention of mtDNA disease transmission.

Functional Diagnostics in Mitochondrial Diseases

Mitochondrial diseases (MD) with respiratory chain defects are caused by genetic mutations that determine an impairment of the electron transport chain functioning. Diagnosis often requires a complex approach with measurements of serum lactate, magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS), muscle histology and ultrastructure, enzymology, genetic analysis, and exercise testing. The ubiquitous distribution of the mitochondria in the human body explains the multiple organ involvement. Exercise intolerance is a common symptom of MD, due to increased dependence of skeletal muscle on anaerobic metabolism, with an excess lactate generation, phosphocreatine depletion, enhanced free radical production, reduced oxygen extraction and electron flux through the respiratory chain. MD treatment has included antioxidants (vitamin E, alpha lipoic acid), coenzyme Q10, riboflavin, creatine monohydrate, dichloroacetate and exercise training. Exercise is a particularly important tool in diagnosis as well as in the management of these diseases.

[Non-invasive investigation of muscle function using 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy and 1H MR imaging]

31P MRS and 1H MRI of skeletal muscle have become major new tools allowing a complete non invasive investigation of muscle function both in the clinical setting and in basic research. The comparative analysis of normal and diseased muscle remains a major requirement to further define metabolic events surrounding muscle contraction and the metabolic anomalies underlying pathologies. Also, standardized rest-exercise-recovery protocols for the exploration of muscle metabolism by P-31 MRS in healthy volunteers as well as in patients with intolerance to exercise have been developed. The CRMBM protocol is based on a short-term intense exercise, which is very informative and well accepted by volunteers and patients. Invariant metabolic parameters have been defined to characterize the normal metabolic response to the protocol. Deviations from normality can be directly interpreted in terms of specific pathologies in some favorable cases. This protocol has been applied to more than 4,000 patients and healthy volunteers over a period of 15 years. On the other hand, MRI investigations provide anatomical and functional information from resting and exercising muscle. From a diagnostic point of view, dedicated pulse sequences can be used in order to detect and quantify muscle inflammation, fatty replacement, muscle hyper and hypotrophy. In most cases, MR techniques provide valuable information which has to be processed in conjunction with traditional invasive biochemical, electrophysiological and histoenzymological tests. P-31 MRS has proved particularly useful in the therapeutic follow-up of palliative therapies (coenzyme Q treatment of mitochondriopathies) and in family investigations. It is now an accepted diagnostic tool in the array of tests which are used to characterize muscle disorders in clinical routine. As a research tool, it will keep bringing new information on the physiopathology of muscle diseases in animal models and in humans and should play a role in the metabolic characterization of gene and cell therapy.

What can metabolic myopathies teach us about exercise physiology?

Exercise physiologists are interested in metabolic myopathies because they demonstrate how knocking out a component of a specific biochemical pathway can alter cellular metabolism. McArdle's disease (myophosphorylase deficiency) has often been studied in exercise physiology to demonstrate the influence of removing the major anaerobic energy supply to skeletal muscle. Studies of patients with McArdle's disease have shown the increased reliance on blood-borne fuels, the importance of glycogen to maximal aerobic capacity, and the use of nutritional strategies to bypass metabolic defects. Myoadenylate deaminase deficiency is the most common metabolic enzyme deficiency in human skeletal muscle. It is usually compensated for endogenously and does not have a major influence on high-energy power output. Nutritional interventions such as carbohydrate loading and carbohydrate supplementation during exercise are essential components of therapy for patients with fatty acid oxidation defects. Cases of mitochondrial myopathies illustrate the importance of peripheral oxygen extraction for maximal aerobic capacity and show how both exercise and nutritional interventions can partially compensate for these mutations. In summary, metabolic myopathies provide important insights into regulatory and nutritional aspects of the major biochemical pathways of intermediary metabolism in human skeletal muscle. Key words: myoadenylate deaminase deficiency, MELAS syndrome, McArdle's disease, mitochondrial disease, inborn errors of metabolism.

Exercise and Training in Mitochondrial Myopathies

The intriguing concept of exercise training as therapy for mitochondrial disease is currently unsettled: in the unique setting of mitochondrial heteroplasmy, what are the effects of chronic exercise on skeletal muscle containing a mixture of mutated and wild-type mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)? Furthermore, what are the consequences of habitual physical inactivity on mitochondrial heteroplasmy? In patients with mtDNA defects, deleterious effects of limited physical activity likely magnify the mitochondrial oxidative impairment contributing to varying degrees of exercise intolerance. Normal adaptive responses to endurance training offer the potential to increase levels of functional mitochondria, improving exercise tolerance. The few clinical studies assessing such training effects in patients with mtDNA defects have unequivocally demonstrated physiologic and biochemical adaptations that improve exercise tolerance and quality of life. Uncertain, however, is the training effect on mitochondrial heteroplasmy. To determine therapeutic advisability of endurance training, it remains imperative to establish whether: reported increases in mutant mtDNA levels can be offset by increases in absolute wild-type mtDNA levels; and chronic physical inactivity leads to a selective down-regulation of wild-type mtDNA. Resistance exercise training offers an alternate, innovative therapeutic approach in patients with sporadic mtDNA mutations; exercise-induced transfer of normal mtDNA templates from muscle satellite cells to mature myofibers, thereby lowering mutation load (increasing functional mitochondrial load). Efficacy and safety of this approach needs to be replicated in a larger group of patients. Currently, appropriate recommendation (either in support or against) exercise training in mitochondrial disease is lacking, which is frustrating for physicians and disheartening for patients. Although considerable progress has been made, an immediate urgency exists to resolve the effects of chronic exercise on skeletal muscle in patients with heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations.

Exercise training in mitochondrial myopathy: A randomized controlled trial

Patients with mitochondrial myopathies (MM) usually suffer from exercise intolerance due to their impaired oxidative capacity and physical deconditioning. We evaluated the effects of a 12-week supervised randomized rehabilitation program involving endurance training in patients with MM. Twenty MM patients were assigned to a training or control group. For three nonconsecutive days each week, patients combined cycle exercise at 70% of their peak work rate with three upper-body weight-lifting exercises performed at 50% of maximum capacity. Training increased maximal oxygen uptake (28.5%), work output (15.5%), and minute ventilation (40%), endurance performance (62%), walking distance in shuttle walking test (+95 m), and peripheral muscle strength (32%-62%), and improved Nottingham Health Profile scores (21.47%) and clinical symptoms. Control MM patients did not change from baseline. Results show that our exercise program is an adequate training strategy for patients with mitochondrial myopathy.

Implications of exercise training in mtDNA defects—use it or lose it?

Whether regular exercise is beneficial or should be avoided is a question currently unsettled in patients with heteroplasmic mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) disorders of skeletal muscle. Deleterious effects of habitual physical inactivity superimposed upon impaired mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation may contribute to varying degrees of exercise intolerance in these patients. Endurance exercise training is widely known to improve exercise capacity in healthy subjects and various chronic-disease patient populations. Although we have shown that beneficial physiological and biochemical responses to training increase exercise tolerance in patients with mtDNA defects, knowledge of the muscle adaptive response to endurance training within the setting of mitochondrial heteroplasmy remains limited. In order to determine advisability of endurance training as therapy, it remains to be established whether potential endurance training-induced increases in mutant mtDNA levels may be offset by increases in absolute wild-type mtDNA levels, and whether chronic inactivity leads to a selective down-regulation of wild-type mtDNA. Resistance training utilizes a different adaptive exercise approach to induce the transfer of normal mitochondrial templates from satellite cells to mature muscle fibers of patients with sporadic mtDNA disorders. The efficacy and safety of this approach needs to be further established. Our current inability to clearly advise patients to "use it or lose it" underscores the immediate urgency of studying the effects of exercise on skeletal muscle of patients with heteroplasmic mtDNA defects.

Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathies: Therapeutic Approach

Therapy for mitochondrial diseases is woefully inadequate. How-ever, lack of cure does not equate with lack of treatment. In this review, we consider sequentially several different therapeutic approaches. Palliative therapy is dictated by good medical practice and includes anticonvulsant medication, control of endocrine dysfunction, and surgical procedures. Removal of noxious metabolites is centered on combating lactic acidosis, but it extends to other metabolites, such as thymidine in patients with the mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy syndrome. Attempts to bypass blocks in the respiratory chain by administration of artificial electron acceptors have not been successful, but this concept may be amenable to genetic engineering. Administration of metabolites and cofactors is the mainstay of real-life therapy and includes both components of the respiratory chain and other natural compounds. There is increasing interest in the administration of reactive oxygen species scavengers both in primary mitochondrial diseases and in neurodegenerative diseases directly or indirectly related to mitochondrial dysfunction. Aerobic exercise and physical therapy prevent or correct deconditioning and improve exercise tolerance in patients with mitochondrial myopathies due to mtDNA mutations. Gene therapy is a challenge because of polyplasmy and heteroplasmy, but interesting experimental approaches are being pursued and include, for example, decreasing the ratio of mutant to wild-type mitochondrial genomes (gene shifting), converting mutated mtDNA genes into normal nDNA genes (allotropic expression), importing cognate genes from other species, or correcting mtDNA mutations with specific restriction endonucleases. Germline therapy raises ethical problems but is being seriously considered to prevent maternal transmission of mtDNA mutations. Preventive therapy through genetic counseling and prenatal diagnosis is still limited for mtDNA-related disorders but is becoming increasingly important for nDNA-related disorders.

Dichloroacetate therapy attenuates the blood lactate response to submaximal exercise in patients with defects in mitochondrial energy metabolism

We determined acute and chronic effects of dichloroacetate (DCA) on maximal (MAX) and submaximal (SUB) exercise responses in patients with abnormal mitochondrial energetics. Subjects (n = 9) completed a MAX treadmill bout 1 h after ingesting 25 mg/kg DCA or placebo (PL). A 15-min SUB bout was completed the next day while receiving the same treatment. After a 1-d washout, MAX and SUB were repeated while receiving the alternate treatment (acute). Gas exchange and heart rate were measured throughout all tests. Blood lactate (Bla) was measured 0, 3, and 10 min after MAX, and 5, 10, and 15 min during SUB. MAX and SUB were repeated after 3 months of daily DCA or PL. After a 2-wk washout, a final MAX and SUB were completed after 3 months of alternate treatment (chronic). Average Bla during SUB was lower (P < 0.05) during both acute (1.99 +/- 1.10 vs. 2.49 +/- 1.52 mmol/liter) and chronic (1.71 +/- 1.37 vs. 2.39 +/- 1.32 mmol/liter) DCA vs. PL despite similar exercise intensities between conditions ( approximately 75 and 70% maximal exercise capacity during acute and chronic treatment). Thus, although DCA does not alter MAX responses, acute and chronic DCA attenuate the Bla response to moderate exercise in patients with abnormal mitochondrial energetics.

Mitochondria

Following the discovery in the early 1960s that mitochondria contain their own DNA (mtDNA), there were two major advances, both in the 1980s: the human mtDNA sequence was published in 1981, and in 1988 the first pathogenic mtDNA mutations were identified. The floodgates were opened, and the 1990s became the decade of the mitochondrial genome. There has been a change of emphasis in the first few years of the new millennium, away from the "magic circle" of mtDNA and back to the nuclear genome. Various nuclear genes have been identified that are fundamentally important for mitochondrial homeostasis, and when these genes are disrupted, they cause autosomally inherited mitochondrial disease. Moreover, mitochondrial dysfunction plays an important role in the pathophysiology of several well established nuclear genetic disorders, such as dominant optic atrophy (mutations in OPA1), Friedreich's ataxia (FRDA), hereditary spastic paraplegia (SPG7), and Wilson's disease (ATP7B). The next major challenge is to define the more subtle interactions between nuclear and mitochondrial genes in health and disease.

Nutritional and exercise-based therapies in the treatment of mitochondrial disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review will critically summarize the nutritional and exercise-based interventions that have been used to treat mitochondrial disease, with a focus on the biochemical or molecular rationale for their use as well as recent advances in the field.

RECENT FINDINGS

Many nutritional-based treatment strategies have been used in an attempt to target energy impairment and its sequelae. Recently, coenzyme Q10, idebenone and triacylglycerol have been shown to bypass defective respiratory enzymes or scavenge free radicals, whereas creatine monohydrate has provided an alternative energy source. Thiamine has been used to decrease lactate levels and increase flux through aerobic metabolism, and riboflavin has been used as a precursor to complexes I and II. Several therapies employing various antioxidants in combination with other supplements have been effective at targeting several of the final common pathways of mitochondrial disease. Miscellaneous supplements, such as L-arginine and uridine, have also had recent success. However, although positive responses have been reported with these agents, many reports have shown no benefit, and there is widespread disparity in the literature. An alternative approach to treatment is exercise training. Both resistance and endurance exercise training have had positive outcomes in patients with mitochondrial disease, although several questions remain to be answered.

SUMMARY

There is no currently recognized treatment for mitochondrial disease. Future clinical trials are needed, as well as research into the potential for in-vitro screening of various compounds within affected cells from patients. Until this time, an accurate diagnosis will facilitate treatment on a case-by-case basis.

Mitochondrial disease: a pulmonary and critical-care medicine perspective

The clinical spectrum of mitochondrial diseases has expanded dramatically in the last decade. Abnormalities of mitochondrial function are now thought to participate in a number of common adult diseases, ranging from exercise intolerance to aging. This review outlines the common presentations of mitochondrial disease in ICUs and in the outpatient setting and discusses current diagnostic and therapeutic options as they pertain to the pulmonary and critical-care physician.

Mitochondrial Disease

Mitochondrial diseases are disorders of energy metabolism that include defects of pyruvate metabolism, Krebs cycle, respiratory chain (RC), and fatty acid oxidation (FAO). Treatment of pyruvate metabolism, Krebs cycle, and RC disorders is, in general, disappointing. Therapeutic approaches consist of electron acceptors, enzyme activators, vitamins, coenzymes, free-radical scavengers, dietary measures, and supportive therapy. These treatment assumptions are based on current understanding of the pathophysiology, on anecdotal clinical reports, and on a few controlled clinical trials, which have not been encouraging. Although it is difficult to perform clinical trials in these conditions due to their rarity and genotypic and phenotypic heterogeneity, there is a great need for well-performed double-blind placebo- controlled clinical trials with comparable groups of patients and with sufficient follow-up periods. Treatment options for FAO disorders are, in general, satisfactory and are mainly based on diet, lifestyle recommendations, and administration of L-carnitine and, in some cases, riboflavin. Special conditions that involve primary deficiencies of L-carnitine, coenzyme Q(10), and cofactor- and vitamin-responsive enzyme defects must be systematically considered, because supplementation with these substances may be curative or produce dramatic improvements. While awaiting more specific therapies for mitochondrial disorders, it is useful to reach a consensus regarding the management of these patients. The expected outcome is a slowing of the disease process and stabilization of the clinical syndrome. More definitive treatments hopefully will follow in the near future.

MR spectroscopy and imaging in metabolic myopathies

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy and imaging of muscle and brain offers new possibilities for noninvasive diagnosis of metabolic myopathies. These functional techniques allow assessment of the pathophysiology of these disorders and also can be used for monitoring disease evolution and response to therapy. In this article, the authors review the magnetic resonance spectroscopy and imaging features of mitochondrial encephalomyopathies, glycolytic disorders, and hypothyroidism.

Effects of aerobic training on lactate and catecholaminergic exercise responses in mitochondrial myopathies

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of an aerobic training program on the metabolic and sympathetic responses to exercise in 12 patients with mitochondrial myopathies. A 10-week course of aerobic training, consisting of supervised exercise every other day on an electrically braked pedal-rate bicycle ergometer was prescribed to each patient and four healthy controls. Venous lactate, epinephrine (EP) and norepinephrine (NEP) levels were assessed at baseline and after the aerobic training by means of constant-workload exercise performed at near lactate threshold (LT). In patients, a decrease in exercise peak values, significant for lactate (-38.6%, P < 0.01) but not for catecholamines (EP: -26.0%, NEP: -22.1%) was observed after training, findings confirmed by the lactate/EP and lactate/NEP area ratios. The results show that lactate accumulation during exercise is decreased after aerobic training in mitochondrial myopathies and that the effect is partially dissociated from the catecholaminergic response. This in turn suggests that the lactate decrease can be explained, at least in part, by the improved muscle oxidative metabolism consequent to the proposed training program.

Applications of magnetic resonance spectroscopy to diagnosis and monitoring of mitochondrial disease

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) can now be performed on routine high-field clinical magnetic resonance imaging systems. Over the last decade it has provided several useful insights into the pathophysiology of mitochondrial disorders. More recently, the feasibility of applications to clinical diagnosis and monitoring have been demonstrated. Exciting new work suggests that carefully supervised physical conditioning in conjunction with sodium dichloroacetate administration can markedly enhance both biochemical measures of aerobic metabolism and functional performance of patients with mitochondrial myopathies.

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy in vivo: applications in neurological disorders

Magnetic resonance (MR) spectroscopy (MRS) is performed using the same magnets and computers as conventional MR imaging (MRI). However, unlike conventional MRI, which provides structural information, MRS provides chemical information that represents pathologically specific measures useful for diagnosis and monitoring of patients affected by neurological disorders. This review will focus on selected clinical applications of MRS that have been demonstrated to have clinical use. These include phosphorus MRS of muscle to diagnose metabolic muscle disease, and proton MRS of brain to lateralize temporal lobe epilepsy, to classify brain tumors, and to evaluate the natural history and pathology of multiple sclerosis.

Abnormal oxidative metabolism in exercise intolerance of undetermined origin

Twenty-four patients with exercise intolerance of undetermined origin were examined by muscle phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (31P-MRS) to test for a possible underlying defect in oxidative metabolism. Results were compared to those of 37 normal controls and 22 patients with well-defined mitochondrial disorders. In 17 (71%) patients with exercise intolerance, ADP recovery after exercise, an index of mitochondrial function, was abnormally slow. The energy state of phosphate-containing metabolites at rest was abnormal in 33% of patients. In 17/22 patients with well-defined mitochondrial disorders, ADP recovery was similarly slow. Abnormalities at rest were slightly more prevalent (50%) in this group of patients. Other 31P-MRS measurements did not add to the overall sensitivity in detecting abnormalities in either of these groups. We suggest that many patients with exercise intolerance of undetermined cause may have impaired muscle oxidative metabolism, that is an important causative factor in the pathophysiology of their symptoms.