Atypical presentation of dopa-responsive dystonia: generalized hypotonia and proximal weakness

Biallelic SHQ1 variants in early infantile hypotonia and paroxysmal dystonia as the leading manifestation

Biallelic SHQ1 variant-related neurodevelopmental disorder is extremely rare. To date, only six affected individuals, from four families, have been reported. Here, we report eight individuals, from seven unrelated families, who exhibited neurodevelopmental disorder and/or dystonia, received whole-genome sequencing, and had inherited biallelic SHQ1 variants. The median age at disease onset was 3.5 months old. All eight individuals exhibited normal eye contact, profound hypotonia, paroxysmal dystonia, and brisk deep tendon reflexes at the first visit. Varying degrees of autonomic dysfunction were observed. One individual had cerebellar atrophy at the initial neuroimaging study, however, three individuals showed cerebellar atrophy at follow-up. Seven individuals who underwent cerebral spinal fluid analysis all had a low level of homovanillic acid in neurotransmitter metabolites. Four individuals who received 99mTc-TRODAT-1 scan had moderate to severe decreased uptake of dopamine in the striatum. Four novel SHQ1 variants in 16 alleles were identified: 9 alleles (56%) were c.997C > G (p.L333V); 4 (25%) were c.195T > A (p.Y65X); 2 (13%) were c.812T > A (p.V271E); and 1 (6%) was c.146T > C (p.L49S). The four novel SHQ1 variants transfected into human SH-SY5Y neuronal cells resulted in a retardation in neuronal migration, suggestive of SHQ1 variant correlated with neurodevelopmental disorders. During the follow-up period, five individuals still exhibited hypotonia and paroxysmal dystonia; two showed dystonia; and one had hypotonia only. The complex interactions among movement disorders, dopaminergic pathways, and the neuroanatomic circuit needs further study to clarify the roles of the SHQ1 gene and protein in neurodevelopment.

Ending diagnostic odyssey using clinical whole-exome sequencing (CWES)

Objectives

Most rare diseases are genetic diseases. Due to the diversity of rare diseases and the high likelihood of patients with rare diseases to be undiagnosed or misdiagnosed, it is not unusual that these patients undergo a long diagnostic odyssey before they receive a definitive diagnosis. This situation presents a clear need to set up a dedicated clinical service to end the diagnostic odyssey of patients with rare diseases.

Methods

Therefore, in 2014, we started an Undiagnosed Diseases Program in Hong Kong with the aim of ending the diagnostic odyssey of patients and families with rare diseases by clinical whole-exome sequencing (CWES), who have not received a definitive diagnosis after extensive investigation.

Results

In this program, we have shown that genetic diseases diagnosed by CWES were different from that using traditional approaches indicating that CWES is an essential tool to diagnose rare diseases and ending diagnostic odysseys. In addition, we identified several novel genes responsible for monogenic diseases. These include the TOP2B gene for autism spectrum disorder, the DTYMK gene for severe cerebral atrophy, the KIF13A gene for a new mosaic ectodermal syndrome associated with hypomelanosis of Ito, and the CDC25B gene for a new syndrome of cardiomyopathy and endocrinopathy.

Conclusions

With the incorporation of CWES in an Undiagnosed Diseases Program, we have ended diagnostic odysseys of patients with rare diseases in Hong Kong in the past 7 years. In this program, we have shown that CWES is an essential tool to end diagnostic odysseys. With the declining cost of next-generation sequencers and reagents, CWES set-ups are now affordable for clinical laboratories. Indeed, owing to the increasing availability of CWES and treatment modalities for rare diseases, precedence can be given to both common and rare medical conditions.

Early-onset autosomal dominant GTP-cyclohydrolase I deficiency: Diagnostic delay and residual motor signs

OBJECTIVE

Autosomal dominant (AD) guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase 1 (GCH1) deficiency is the most common cause of dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD). Patients with GCH1 deficiency are likely to experience diagnostic delay, but its consequences have not been described thoroughly in patients with early-onset disease. We describe the diagnostic delay and residual motor signs (RMS) observed in patients with early-onset (before 15 years of age) disease.

METHODS

Twelve patients with early-onset AD GCH1 deficiency from a single center were included in the case series analysis. For the meta-analysis, the PubMed database was searched for articles on early-onset AD GCH1 deficiency published from 1995 to 2019.

RESULTS

In the case series, the mean duration of diagnostic delay was 5.6 years. Two patients exhibited RMS, and four patients underwent orthopedic surgery. The literature search yielded 137 AD GCH1 deficiency cases for review; gait disturbance was reported in 92.7% of patients, diurnal fluctuation of symptoms in 91.9%, and RMS in 39%. The mean duration of diagnostic delay was 14.6 years overall: 12.0 years in RMS-negative patients and 21.2 years in RMS-positive patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Diagnostic delay in early-onset AD GCH1 deficiency is more closely associated with later RMS. Early clinical suspicion, timely diagnosis, and levodopa treatment may reduce the occurrence of RMS in patients with early-onset AD GCH1 deficiency.

Dopa-responsive dystonia, DRD-plus and DRD look-alike: a pragmatic review

Dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) and DRD plus are diseases of the dopamine pathway with sizeable genetic diversity and myriad presentations. DRD has onset in childhood or adolescence with focal dystonia, commonly affecting lower limb, diurnal fluctuations with evening worsening of symptoms and a demonstrable sleep benefit. DRD "plus" has "atypical features" which include infantile onset, psychomotor delay, cognitive abnormalities, oculogyric crisis, seizures, irritability, spasticity, hypotonia, ptosis, hyperthermia and cerebellar dysfunction. Neurodegeneration, however, is not a feature of either DRD or DRD-plus disorders. Tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4), a key cofactor, deficiency leads to inadequate dopamine and serotonin synthesis. Norepinephrine deficiency may coexist, depending on the enzyme defect. Hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) is a clue for BH4 paucity. However, HPA is conspicuously absent in autosomal-dominant guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase 1 deficiency and sepiapterin reductase deficiency. DRD look-alike is a group of neurodegenerative disorders involving the nigrostriatal dopaminergic system, which could present with dystonia responsive to dopaminergic drugs or neurodegenerative or non-neurodegenerative disorders without involving the nigrostriatal dopaminergic system yet responsive to levodopa. Although levodopa is the mainstay of therapy, response to this drug can be unsatisfactory in DRD plus and DRD look-alike and other drugs are tried. Simultaneous management of HPA leads to remarkable improvement in both motor and cognitive functions. The aim of this review is to help neurology practitioners in treating patients with DRD, DRD-plus and DRD look-alike as many of them have excellent outcome with appropriate therapy.

Atypical presentation of dopa-responsive dystonia in Taiwan

The typical clinical presentation of dopa-responsive dystonia, which is also called Segawa disease, is a young age of onset, with predominance in females, diurnal fluctuation of lower limb dystonia, and fair response to low-dose levodopa. This disease has both autosomal dominant and autosomal recessive inheritance. Autosomal dominant Segawa disease is caused by GCH1 mutation on chromosome 14q22.1-q22.2. Here, we report the case of a male patient with genetically confirmed Segawa disease and atypical presentations including no diurnal symptom fluctuation and insufficient response to levodopa. The patient's father who had the same mutation presented parkinsonism in old age. We also review the literature to address the broad clinical heterogeneity of Segawa disease and the influence of onset age on clinical presentation.

Nonmotor Symptoms in Dopa-Responsive Dystonia

Background

Dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) is a rare inherited dystonia, caused by an autosomal dominantly inherited defect in the gene GCH1 that encodes guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase 1. It catalyzes the first and rate-limiting enzyme in the biosynthesis of tetrahydrobiopterin, which is the essential co-factor for aromatic amino acid hydroxylases. Mutation results in the typical scenario of a young-onset lower-limb dystonia with diurnal fluctuations, concurrent or subsequent development of parkinsonism and excellent response to levodopa. Given the myriad functions of tetrahydrobiopterin, it is reasonable that other systems, apart from motor, would also be impaired. So far, non-motor symptoms have been overlooked and very few and often contrasting data are currently available on the matter.

Methods

Here by searching the Medline database for publications between 1971 to March 2015, we render an in-depth analysis of all published data on non-motor symptoms in DRD.

Results

Depression and subtle sleep quality impairment have been reported among the different cohorts, while current data do not support any alterations of the cardiologic and autonomic systems. However, there is debate about the occurrence of sleep-related movement disorders and cognitive function. Non-motor symptoms are instead frequently reported among the clinical spectrum of other neurotransmitter disorders which may sometimes mimic DRD phenotype, ie, DRD plus diseases.

Conclusions

Further studies in larger and treatment-naïve cohorts are needed to better elucidate the extend of non-motor symptoms in DRD and also to consider treatment for these.

Milestones in dystonia

The last 25 years have seen remarkable advances in our understanding of the genetic etiologies of dystonia, new approaches into dissecting underlying pathophysiology, and independent progress in identifying effective treatments. In this review we highlight some of these advances, especially the genetic findings that have taken us from phenomenological to molecular-based diagnoses. Twenty DYT loci have been designated and 10 genes identified, all based on linkage analyses in families. Hand in hand with these genetic findings, neurophysiological and imaging techniques have been employed that have helped illuminate the similarities and differences among the various etiological dystonia subtypes. This knowledge is just beginning to yield new approaches to treatment including those based on DYT1 animal models. Despite the lag in identifying genetically based therapies, effective treatments, including impressive benefits from deep brain stimulation and botulinum toxin chemodenervation, have marked the last 25 years. The challenge ahead includes continued advancement into understanding dystonia's many underlying causes and associated pathology and using this knowledge to advance treatment including preventing genetic disease expression.

Expanding phenotype and clinical analysis of tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency

This study included 12 Chinese patients with a wide spectrum of phenotypes of tyrosine hydroxylase deficiency. Seven females and 5 males, aged 2.2 to 41 years, had phenotypes ranging from severe type with onset at infancy to mild type with onset after 3 years of age. Patients with the severe type had encephalopathy with poor treatment response or infantile parkinsonism with motor delay. Patients with the less common mild type had dopa-responsive dystonia or a newly recognized predominant symptom of myopathy. Female siblings had more severe phenotypes. The phenotype and treatment outcomes were strongly related to a homovanillic acid level and homovanillic acid/5-hydroxyindolacetic acid ratio of less than 1 in the cerebrospinal fluid. Hyperprolactinemia was found in 50% of the severe cases. Levodopa was the mainstay of treatment, and early addition of selegiline resulted in a remarkable response in some patients. Treatment response for mild-type patients is universally good even with a treatment delay of 10 years after onset of neurological symptoms.

Genetics and treatment of dystonia

The torsion dystonias encompass a broad collection of etiologic subtypes, often divided into primary and secondary classes. Tremendous advances have been made in uncovering the genetic basis of dystonia, including discovery of a gene causing early onset primary torsion dystonia-a GAG deletion in exon 5 of the DYT1 gene that encodes torsinA. Although the exact function of torsinA remains elusive, evidence suggests aberrant localization and interaction of mutated protein; this may result in an abnormal response to stress or interference with cytoskeletal events and the development of neuronal brain pathways. Breakthroughs include the discovery of a genetic modifier that protects against clinical expression in DYT1 dystonia and the identification of the gene causing DYT6, THAP1. The authors review genetic etiologies and discuss phenotypes as well as counseling of patients regarding prognosis and progression of the disease. They also address pharmacologic and surgical treatment options for various forms of dystonia.

What is a waddling gait?

PURPOSE

A patient's gait can provide important diagnostic and functional information. Though 'waddling gait' is a long-established concept, we question whether this description is precise or clinically useful.

METHODS

We searched 'waddling gait' in all main medical specialties core textbooks, in animal locomotion books and in Medline, Healthstar and Embase. Further we obtained expert advice on the gait of ducks.

RESULTS

Many names are used for 'waddling gait', and its description is imprecise and inconsistent. Trendelenburg described it as a pelvic drop on the side of the swinging leg and compensatory lateral trunk bending towards the side of the standing leg. Many conditions have been described as producing a waddling gait. We accepted the gait pattern of ducks as being true waddling. This often-used comparison does not accurately reflect the gait pattern seen in humans with a range of medical disorders; nor is it the same as a Trendelenburg gait.

CONCLUSIONS

As we have found no condition in which patients have a truly duck-like gait, we propose that the phrase 'waddling gait' should be abandoned. We suggest that for clarity and good communication, clinicians should describe the observed elements of the gait rather than using imprecise and unhelpful terms such as 'waddling gait'.

Movement disorder emergencies

Movement disorder emergencies include any movement disorder which evolves over hours to days, in which failure to appropriately diagnose and manage can result in patient morbidity or mortality. It is crucial that doctors recognize these emergencies with accuracy and speed by obtaining the proper history and by being familiar with the phenomenology of frequently encountered movements. These disorders will be discussed based on the most common associated involuntary movement, either parkinsonism, dystonia, chorea, tics or myoclonus, and, when available, review the workup and treatment options based on the current literature.

Hereditary spastic paraparesis in adults associated with inborn errors of metabolism: a diagnostic approach

Spastic paraparesis is a general term describing progressive stiffness and weakness in the lower limbs caused by pyramidal tract lesions. This clinical situation is frequently encountered in adult neurology. The diagnostic survey is usually limited to searching for acquired causes (spinal cord compression, inflammatory, metabolic, infectious diseases) and the so-called 'hereditary spastic paraparesis'. Although poorly recognized by neurologists, spastic paraparesis is also one of the multiple presentations of inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) in children and adults. Pyramidal signs are usually included in a diffuse neurological or systemic clinical picture; however, in some cases spastic paraparesis remains the only symptom for years. Since these metabolic causes are often treatable, it is essential to include them in the general diagnostic approach to spastic paraparesis. Here we review IEMs causing paraparesis in adults.

Skeletal dysplasia presenting as a neuromuscular disorder - report of three children

Three pediatric patients were investigated because of suspected muscle disorder. They were clumsy with an awkward looking waddling gait and had increasing muscle weakness and pain in the legs. Serum CK-values, electroneuromyography (ENMG) and muscle biopsy were all normal. A post-traumatic X-ray of the ankle of one of them showed epiphyseal changes and his condition was diagnosed as Camurati-Engelmann disease. Because of similarities in the clinical presentation of these boys, bone changes were looked for in the two other patients and a diagnosis of multiple epiphyseal dysplasia was made. Skeletal dysplasia should be considered as a diagnostic alternative when a child presents with an unexplained muscle weakness accompanied with pain in the limbs. Specific treatment for bone dysplasias can alleviate symptoms and prevent fractures.

Movement disorder emergencies

For the past 4 years, Dr. Stanley Fahn and I have given a course at the American Academy of Neurology annual meeting on the topic of movement disorder emergencies. The purpose of this review article is to summarize the topic and to present it to readers of this journal. The text of this article has appeared in nearly the same form as the Academy syllabus accompanying our course. It is being presented here so that readers of the journal may review the material.

Gowers' sign in children with discitis of the lumbar spine

Gowers' sign is pathognomonic in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy. These patients, when rising, 'climb up' their thighs using their hands in order to overcome the weakness of the pelvic girdle and paravertebral muscles. We report on four children in the age range of 3.3-8 years with disc space infection in the lumbar region, who demonstrated the sign in the early stages of the disease. Following treatment, Gowers' sign disappeared in all of these patients. We therefore conclude that the presence of Gowers' sign in small children must alert the examiner to the possibility of infection in the lumbar spine. These children use this maneuver in order to avoid painful motion of the lumbar spine.

Wide expressivity variation and high but no gender-related penetrance in two dopa-responsive dystonia families with a novel GCH-I mutation

We describe the clinical and molecular correlates in two Italian families with dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) and the same novel mutation of GTP-cyclohydrolase I (GCH-I) gene. Thirty-five subjects were examined and the genotype correlated to phenotype. Childhood onset foot dystonia is present in 7 subjects currently under the age of 40. In 1 patient bilateral foot dystonia was evident at birth suggesting that dystonia may be active as early as in utero. In another patient, dystonia spontaneously remitted in adolescence, to relapse 8 years later, as writer's cramp. Dystonia and parkinsonian signs are present in 5 other patients. In 2 subjects an isolated parkinsonism started over the age of 45. A 5-base pair insertion at codon 242 within exon 6 of GTP-cyclohydrolase I (GCH-I) gene that shifts the reading frame and results in a premature stop at codon 247 with truncation of the polypeptide has been detected in 21 subjects. Considering dystonia and parkinsonism the overall penetrance is 0.71 and not significantly different in men (0.69) and women (0.75). Genealogical studies seem to exclude that these families are related but haplotype analysis suggests a single founder. Our findings in subjects with the same mutation indicate a wide intrafamilial variation in expressivity and high penetrance in DRD but do not confirm the reported influence of gender on GCH-I gene mutation penetrance.

Motor disturbances in mice with deficiency of the sodium channel gene Scn8a show features of human dystonia

The med(J) mouse with twisting movements related to deficiency of the sodium channel Scn8a has been proposed as a model of kinesiogenic dystonia. This prompted us to examine the phenotype of these mice in more detail. By cortical electroencephalographic (EEG) recordings, we could not detect any changes, demonstrating that the motor disturbances are not epileptic in nature, an important similarity to human dystonia. The significantly decreased body weight of med(J) mice was related to reduced food intake. Observations in the open field and by video recordings revealed that the mice exhibit sustained abnormal postures and movements of limbs, trunk and tail not only during locomotor activity but also at rest. With the exception of the head tremor, the other motor impairments were persistent rather than paroxysmal. When several neurological reflexes were tested, alterations were restricted to the posture and righting reflexes. Results of the wire hang test confirmed the greatly reduced muscle strength in the med(J) mouse. In agreement with different types of human dystonia, biperiden, haloperidol and diazepam moderately reduced the severity of motor disturbances in med(J) mice. In view of the sodium channel deficiency in med(J) mice, the beneficial effects of the sodium channel blocker phenytoin was an unexpected finding. By immunohistochemical examinations, the density of nigral dopaminergic neurons was found to be unaltered, substantiating the absence of pathomorphological abnormalities within the brain of med(J) mice shown by previous studies. With the exception of muscle weakness, many of the features of the med(J) mouse are similar to human idiopathic dystonia.

[Movement disorders in childhood: classification and genetic update]

Abnormal movements are not unusual in childhood. Recent genetic progresses provide a new approach of childhood movement disorders. Several loci have been identified in paroxysmal dyskinesia, or in Gilles de la Tourette syndrome. A gene has been cloned in Hallervorden-Spatz syndrome, and a gene has recently been implicated in benign hereditary chorea. Considerable advances concern the genetic of dystonic syndromes: several chromosomal localizations have been identified, and several genes have been cloned. Genetic advances allow nosographic reclassification of some entities and offer new molecular tools for a more appropriate diagnosis. The increasing wealth of genetic knowledge will provide further insight in the understanding of abnormal movement disorders in childhood.

Classification and genetics of dystonia

Dystonia is a syndrome characterised by sustained muscle contractions, producing twisting, repetitive, and patterned movements, or abnormal postures. The dystonic syndromes include a large group of diseases that have been classified into various aetiological categories, such as primary, dystonia-plus, heredodegenerative, and secondary. The diverse clinical features of these disorders are reflected in the traditional clinical classification based on age at onset, distribution of symptoms, and site of onset. However, with an increased awareness of the molecular and environmental causes, the classification schemes have changed to reflect different genetic forms of dystonia. To date, at least 13 dystonic syndromes have been distinguished on a genetic basis and their loci are referred to as DYT1 to DYT13. This review focuses on the molecular and phenotypic features of the hereditary dystonias, with emphasis on recent advances.

Dystonia: clinical features, genetics, and treatment

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The present review covers recent advances in dystonia research related to dystonia genetics and treatment. These have led to the discovery of novel dystonia genes and loci, to changing classification schemes, and to the introduction of improved and new treatment options.

RECENT FINDINGS

Currently 13 different forms of dystonia can be distinguished on a genetic basis (dystonia types 1-13). Recently, a novel gene locus (DYT13) was detected in a family with segmental dystonia, and the gene causing myoclonus-dystonia was identified (SGCE). Furthermore, a novel mutation in the DYT1 gene is associated with a myoclonus-dystonia phenotype. Regarding dystonia treatment, patients refractory to botulinum toxin type A can now be treated with botulinum toxin type B. Selective peripheral denervation remains an effective form of treatment for patients with secondary, but probably not with primary botulinum toxin treatment failure. Finally, a renaissance of functional surgical ablative procedures has taken place, with high frequency deep brain stimulation being introduced in dystonia treatment. Bilateral pallidotomy or pallidal stimulation may provide major benefit especially in patients with generalized, disabling dystonia with the most dramatic improvements in dystonia type 1 patients. Neurostimulation may also be effective in primary segmental axial dystonia, myoclonus-dystonia, and tardive dystonia.

SUMMARY

The recent mapping of additional dystonia gene loci, the identification of novel dystonia genes, and the characterization of proteins encoded by these genes have enhanced our understanding of various forms and aspects of the dystonias and have opened up new avenues for research. Treatment options include both medical and surgical therapies, with deep brain simulation being the most recent development.