Inhibitory and stimulatory influences on mesodermal erythropoiesis in the early chick blastoderm

Ontogeny of the hematopoietic system

Blood cells are constantly produced in the bone marrow (BM) of adult mammals. This constant turnover ultimately depends on a rare population of progenitors that displays self-renewal and multilineage differentiation potential, the hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). It is generally accepted that HSCs are generated during embryonic development and sequentially colonize the fetal liver, the spleen, and finally the BM. Here we discuss the experimental evidence that argues for the extrinsic origin of HSCs and the potential locations where HSC generation might occur. The identification of the cellular components playing a role in the generation process, in these precise locations, will be important in understanding the molecular mechanisms involved in HSC production from undifferentiated mesoderm.

Emergence of haematopoietic stem cells during development

Self-renewable haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) become segregated during development into a finite pool, from which they are mobilized upon physiological requirement. A central feature characterizing developmental haematopoiesis is that definitive organs become colonized by HSCs originating from a central source. The emission of HSCs occurs more or less continuously during a protracted period in parallel or successive sites. The most recently discovered of these sites is the placenta. The allantois, which is one of the components of the placenta, probed before it becomes vascularised, turns out to be a location where clonogenic precursors become committed. The placenta is thus a site of intrinsic haematopoiesis. Until this finding, the aorta and periaortic tissues were held to be the sites of definitive HSC commitment. The haematopoietic process in the aorta is prominent, particularly in avian embryos, and displays striking anatomical relationships between endothelial and haematopoietic cells. This made it possible to investigate the cytological and molecular relationship between the two types of cells. Somite exchanges between quail and chicken disclosed two distinct lineages, a dorsal one, purely endothelial, and a ventral one, hemangioblastic. The latter, also termed hemogenic endothelium, builds at first the whole inside lining of the aorta, and is then progressively replaced by cells of somitic origin, beginning with the aortic roof; it emits haematopoietic cells when located in the floor of the aorta and disappears. These events involve a changing molecular pattern, with expressions of transcription factor Runx1 and receptor VEGF-R2 as faithful markers of the lineage switch. Taking advantage of the stereotyped anatomical arrangement at the aortic level, which is favourable to dissect the mechanisms of HSC commitment, the analysis of developmental haematopoiesis should progress still further.

In the absence of Rauber's sickle material, no blood islands are formed in the avian blastoderm

Using the quail-chick chimera technique, we followed the fate of Rauber's sickle cells in older whole blastoderms (cultured for approximately 2 days): after removal of the autochthonous Rauber's sickle from an unincubated chicken blastoderm, a quail Rauber's sickle was grafted isotopically and isochronically in its place. In transverse sections through these chimeras, the grafted quail Rauber's sickle cells were seen to have transformed into a broad row or ridge of quail junctional endoblast cells extending at the inner border of the area containing blood islands. After unilateral removal of the junctional endoblast from an intermediate streak chicken blastoderm (Stage 3; Hamburger and Hamilton [1951] J Morphol 88:49-92), we observed during further in vitro culture that at the operated side, in the area previously occupied by this junctional endoblast, blood islands no longer developed. If after such a unilateral removal of the chicken junctional endoblast quail junctional endoblast was apposed in its place, then blood islands reappeared in the operated area. The intimate contact between the apposed quail junctional endoblast and the recently formed blood islands, derived from peripherally migrating mesoderm, was very obvious on sections through such chimeras. We further demonstrate that Rauber's sickle vs. junctional endoblast is indispensable for the anlage of blood islands in avian blastoderms. Indeed, in the absence of Rauber's sickle material no blood islands develop (even when mesoderm is present after ingression of the upper layer via a primitive streak) in the isolated central region of the area centralis of unincubated chicken blastoderms after culture in vitro. Also, no junctional endoblast and no sickle canal appear in these explants. By contrast, if a Rauber's sickle fragment is placed on such an isolated central blastoderm region, then blood islands develop. These blood islands start to develop from peripherally migrating mesoderm in the neighborhood of the Rauber's sickle-derived junctional endoblast.

Efficiency of embryoid body formation and hematopoietic development from embryonic stem cells in different culture systems

Embryonic stem (ES) cells have tremendous potential as a cell source for cell-based therapies. Realization of that potential will depend on our ability to understand and manipulate the factors that influence cell fate decisions and to develop scalable methods of cell production. We compared four standard ES cell differentiation culture systems by measuring aspects of embryoid body (EB) formation efficiency and cell proliferation, and by tracking development of a specific differentiated tissue type-blood-using functional (colony-forming cell) and phenotypic (Flk-1 and CD34 expression) assays. We report that individual murine ES cells form EBs with an efficiency of 42 +/- 9%, but this value is rarely obtained because of EB aggregation-a process whereby two or more individual ES cells or EBs fuse to form a single, larger cell aggregate. Regardless of whether EBs were generated from a single ES cell in methylcellulose or liquid suspension culture, or aggregates of ES cells in hanging drop culture, they grew to a similar maximum cell number of 28,000 +/- 9,000 cells per EB. Among the three methods for EB generation in suspension culture there were no differences in the kinetics or frequency of hematopoietic development. Thus, initiating EBs with a single ES cell and preventing EB aggregation should allow for maximum yield of differentiated cells in the EB system. EB differentiation cultures were also compared to attached differentiation culture using the same outputs. Attached colonies were not similarly limited in cell number; however, hematopoietic development in attached culture was impaired. The percentage of early Flk-1 and CD34 expressing cells was dramatically lower than in EBs cultured in suspension, whereas hematopoietic colony formation was almost completely inhibited. These results provide a foundation for development of efficient, scalable bioprocesses for ES cell differentiation, and inform novel methods for the production of hematopoietic tissues.

WNT signaling modulates the diversification of hematopoietic cells

WNT proteins compose a family of secreted signaling molecules that regulate cell fate and behavior. The possible influence of WNTs on hematopoietic cell fate was examined. Both hematopoietic progenitor cell (HPC)–enriched embryonic avian bone marrow cells and the quail mesodermal stem cell line QCE6 were used for these studies. Under optimized conditions, the bone marrow and QCE6 cells behaved identically and developed into red blood cells (RBCs), monocytes, macrophages, granulocytes, and thrombocytes. This broad range of blood cell phenotypes exhibited by QCE6 cells was dependent on their active expression of WNT11. However, when QCE6 cells were prevented from producing WNT11—by expression of a stably transfected WNT11 antisense transgene—the cultures were dominated by highly vacuolated macrophages. RBCs were absent from these cultures, and the presence of monocytes was greatly diminished. Exposure of these WNT11 antisense cells to soluble WNT11 or WNT5a restored the broad range of blood cell phenotypes exhibited by parental QCE6 cells. Overexpression of WNT protein in QCE6 cells further increased the prevalence of RBCs and monocytes and greatly diminished the appearance of macrophages. Accordingly, treatment of HPC-enriched bone marrow cultures with soluble WNT11 or WNT5a inhibited macrophage formation. Instead, monocytes and RBCs were the prevalent cells displayed by WNT-treated bone marrow cultures. Together, these data indicate that WNTs may play a major role in regulating hematopoietic cell fate.

WNT signaling modulates the diversification of hematopoietic cells

WNT proteins compose a family of secreted signaling molecules that regulate cell fate and behavior. The possible influence of WNTs on hematopoietic cell fate was examined. Both hematopoietic progenitor cell (HPC)–enriched embryonic avian bone marrow cells and the quail mesodermal stem cell line QCE6 were used for these studies. Under optimized conditions, the bone marrow and QCE6 cells behaved identically and developed into red blood cells (RBCs), monocytes, macrophages, granulocytes, and thrombocytes. This broad range of blood cell phenotypes exhibited by QCE6 cells was dependent on their active expression of WNT11. However, when QCE6 cells were prevented from producing WNT11—by expression of a stably transfected WNT11 antisense transgene—the cultures were dominated by highly vacuolated macrophages. RBCs were absent from these cultures, and the presence of monocytes was greatly diminished. Exposure of these WNT11 antisense cells to soluble WNT11 or WNT5a restored the broad range of blood cell phenotypes exhibited by parental QCE6 cells. Overexpression of WNT protein in QCE6 cells further increased the prevalence of RBCs and monocytes and greatly diminished the appearance of macrophages. Accordingly, treatment of HPC-enriched bone marrow cultures with soluble WNT11 or WNT5a inhibited macrophage formation. Instead, monocytes and RBCs were the prevalent cells displayed by WNT-treated bone marrow cultures. Together, these data indicate that WNTs may play a major role in regulating hematopoietic cell fate.

Angioblast differentiation is influenced by the local environment: FGF-2 induces angioblasts and patterns vessel formation in the quail embryo

The embryonic vasculature forms by the segregation, migration, and assembly of angioblasts from mesoderm, a process termed vasculogenesis. The initial role of fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) in vascular development appears to be in the induction of endothelial precursors, angioblasts. Quail somites transplanted into chick embryos will give rise to angioblasts of quail origin. The number of angioblasts present within the chimera is dependent on the host environment. Angioblast induction can be demonstrated in vitro by the addition of FGF-2 to cultures of dissociated somitic mesoderm, as assessed by QH-1 epitope expression. Manipulation of FGF-2 concentration in the quail/chick chimeras by FGF-2 peptide or neutralizing antibody injections increases or decreases angioblast induction in the predicted manner. To better control growth factor release in vivo we have implanted beads that release FGF-2 into the embryonic environment. FGF-2 beads implanted into the somite induce angioblast differentiation in the epithelial somite; whereas, beads lateral to the somitic mesoderm induce the formation of ectopic vessels. These studies suggest that FGF-2 is important for both the induction of angioblasts and the assembly of angioblasts into the initial vasculature pattern.

Lmo2 and GATA-3 associated expression in intraembryonic hemogenic sites

It is now widely accepted that hemopoietic cells born intraembryonically are the best candidates for the seeding of definitive hemopoietic organs. To further understand the mechanisms involved in the generation of definitive hemopoietic stem cells, we analysed the expression of the hemopoietic-related transcription factors Lmo2 and GATA-3 during the early steps of mouse development (7-12 dpc), with a particular emphasis on intraembryonic hemogenic sites. We show here that both Lmo2 and GATA-3 are present in the intraembryonic regions known to give rise to hemopoietic precursors in vitro and in vivo, suggesting that they act together at key points of hemopoietic development. (1) Lmo2 and GATA-3 are expressed in the caudal mesoderm during the phase of intraembryonic precursors determination. (2) A highly transient concomitant expression is observed in the caudal intraembryonic definitive endoderm, suggesting that these factors are involved in the specification of intraembryonic hemopoietic precursors. (3) Lmo2 and GATA-3 are expressed within the hemopoietic clusters located in the aortic floor during fetal liver colonisation. Furthermore, a strong GATA-3 signal allowed us to uncover previously unreported mesodermal aggregates beneath the aorta. A combined in situ and immunocytological analysis strongly suggests that ventral mesodermal GATA-3 patches are involved in the process of intraembryonic stem cell generation.

Stem cell emergence and hemopoietic activity are incompatible in mouse intraembryonic sites

In the mouse embryo, the generation of candidate progenitors for long-lasting hemopoiesis has been reported in the paraaortic splanchnopleura (P-Sp)/ aorta-gonad-mesonephros (AGM) region. Here, we address the following question: can the P-Sp/AGM environment support hemopoietic differentiation as well as generate stem cells, and, conversely, are other sites where hemopoietic differentiation occurs capable of generating stem cells? Although P-Sp/AGM generates de novo hemopoietic stem cells between 9.5 and 12.5 days post coitus (dpc), we show here that it does not support hemopoietic differentiation. Among mesoderm-derived sites, spleen and omentum were shown to be colonized by exogenous cells in the same fashion as the fetal liver. Cells colonizing the spleen were multipotent and pursued their evolution to committed progenitors in this organ. In contrast, the omentum, which was colonized by lymphoid-committed progenitors that did not expand, cannot be considered as a hemopoietic organ. From these data, stem cell generation appears incompatible with hemopoietic activity. At the peak of hemopoietic progenitor production in the P-Sp/AGM, between 10.5 and 11.5 dpc, multipotent cells were found at the exceptional frequency of 1 out of 12 total cells and 1 out of 4 AA4.1+ cells. Thus, progenitors within this region constitute a pool of undifferentiated hemopoietic cells readily accessible for characterization.

What guides early embryonic blood vessel formation?

Survival of vertebrate embryos depends on their ability to assemble a correctly patterned, integrated network of blood vessels to supply oxygen and nutrients to developing tissues. The arrangement of larger caliber intraembryonic vessels, specification of arterial-venous identity, and proper placement of major branch points and arterial-venous connections are all precisely determined. A number of recent studies in both mammalian and nonmammalian vertebrate species, reviewed here, have now begun to reveal the major role played by genetically predetermined extrinsic cues in guiding the formation of early embryonic blood vessels and determining the global pattern of the vasculature.

Manipulation of the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic commitment in the avian embryo

The hypothesis that the endothelial and hemopoietic lineages have a common ontogenic origin is currently being revived. We have shown previously by means of quail/chick transplantations that two subsets of the mesoderm give rise to endothelial precursors: a dorsal one, the somite, produces pure angioblasts (angiopoietic potential), while a ventral one, the splanchnopleural mesoderm, gives rise to progenitors with a dual endothelial and hemopoietic potential (hemangiopoietic potential). To investigate the cellular and molecular controls of the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic potential, we devised an in vivo assay based on the polarized homing of hemopoietic cell precursors to the floor of the aorta detectable in the quail/chick model. In the present work, quail mesoderm was grafted, after various pretreatments, onto the splanchnopleure of a chick host; the homing pattern and nature of graft-derived QH1(+) cells were analyzed thereafter. We report that transient contact with endoderm or ectoderm could change the behavior of cells derived from treated mesoderm, and that the effect of these germ layers could be mimicked by treatment with several growth factors VEGF, bFGF, TGFbeta1, EGF and TGF(α), known to be involved in endothelial commitment and proliferation, and/or hemopoietic processes. The endoderm induced a hemangiopoietic potential in the associated mesoderm. Indeed, the association of somatopleural mesoderm with endoderm promoted the ‘ventral homing’ and the production of hemopoietic cells from mesoderm not normally endowed with this potential. The hemangiopoietic induction by endoderm could be mimicked by VEGF, bFGF and TGFbeta1. In contrast, contact with ectoderm or EGF/TGF(α) treatments totally abrogated the hemangiopoietic capacity of the splanchnopleural mesoderm, which produced pure angioblasts with no ‘ventral homing’ behaviour. We postulate that two gradients, one positive and one negative, modulate the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic potential of the mesoderm.

Progressive lineage analysis by cell sorting and culture identifies FLK1+VE-cadherin+ cells at a diverging point of endothelial and hemopoietic lineages

Totipotent murine ES cells have an enormous potential for the study of cell specification. Here we demonstrate that ES cells can differentiate to hemopoietic cells through the proximal lateral mesoderm, merely upon culturing in type IV collagen-coated dishes. Separation of the Flk1+ mesoderm from other cell lineages was critical for hemopoietic cell differentiation, whereas formation of the embryoid body was not. Since the two-dimensionally spreading cells can be monitored easily in real time, this culture system will greatly facilitate the study of the mechanisms involved in the cell specification to mesoderm, endothelial, and hemopoietic cells. In the culture of ES cells, however, lineages and stages of differentiating cells can only be defined by their own characteristics. We showed that a combination of monoclonal antibodies against E-cadherin, Flk1/KDR, PDGF receptor(alpha), VE-cadherin, CD45 and Ter119 was sufficient to define most intermediate stages during differentiation of ES cells to blood cells. Using this culture system and surface markers, we determined the following order for blood cell differentiation: ES cell (E-cadherin+Flk1-PDGFRalpha-), proximal lateral mesoderm (E-cadherin-Flk1+VE-cadherin-), progenitor with hemoangiogenic potential (Flk1+VE-cadherin+CD45-), hemopoietic progenitor (CD45+c-Kit+) and mature blood cells (c-Kit-CD45+ or Ter119+), though direct differentiation of blood cells from the Flk1+VE-cadherin- stage cannot be ruled out. Not only the VE-cadherin+CD45- population generated from ES cells but also those directly sorted from the yolk sac of 9.5 dpc embryos have a potential to give rise to hemopoietic cells. Progenitors with hemoangiogenic potential were identified in both the Flk1+VE-cadherin- and Flk1+VE-cadherin+ populations by the single cell deposition experiment. This line of evidence implicates Flk1+VE-cadherin+ cells as a diverging point of hemopoietic and endothelial cell lineages.

Mixed cultures of avian blastoderm cells and the quail mesoderm cell line QCE-6 provide evidence for the pluripotentiality of early mesoderm

During the early stages of embryogenesis, the mesoderm gives rise to cells of the cardiovascular system which include cardiac myocytes and vascular endothelial and red blood cells. We have investigated the development of these cell phenotypes using aggregate cultures of avian blastoderm cells, which replicated mesodermal cell diversification. The cell phenotypes expressed by the blastoderm cells were dependent upon the age of the blastoderm cells, with Hamburger-Hamilton stage 3 or 4 cells giving rise to endothelial and red blood cells and stage 5 cells producing endothelial and myocardial cells. To begin to understand the stage dependency of the cellular diversification of these aggregate cultures, we treated the cultures with various signaling factors that have been shown to be present in the early avian embryo. These experiments showed that stem cell factor and TGF alpha altered cell phenotypes by stimulating red blood cell and myocardial differentiation, respectively. The ability of these growth factors to shift the differentiation profile of aggregate cultures demonstrated the plasticity of early embryonic cells. To explore the diversification of individual mesodermal cells, labeled QCE-6 cells were incorporated within these blastoderm aggregate cultures. Previous studies have shown that this quail mesodermal cell line possesses characteristics of early nondifferentiated mesodermal cells and can be induced to express either myocardial or endothelial cell phenotypes (C. A. Eisenberg and D. M. Bader, 1996, Circ. Res. 78, 205-216). In the present study, we show that when these cells were cultured as a component of blastoderm cell aggregates, they differentiated into fully contractile cardiomyocytes or endothelial or red blood cells. Moreover, QCE-6 cell differentiation was in accordance with that displayed by the blastoderm cells. Specifically, QCE-6 cells differentiated into red blood cells when cultured within stage 3 or stage 4, but not stage 5, blastoderm cell aggregates. Accordingly, the differentiation of QCE-6 cells into beating cardiomyocytes only occurred when these cells were incorporated into stage 5 blastoderm cell aggregates. The identical sorting and differentiation patterns that were exhibited by QCE-6 and blastoderm cells suggest that expression of differentiated cell types within the early mesoderm is directed by the surrounding environment without immediate cellular commitment. In addition, these results provide further evidence that QCE-6 cells are representative of a multipotential mesodermal stem cell and that they possess the potential to exhibit fully differentiated cell phenotypes.

Two distinct endothelial lineages in ontogeny, one of them related to hemopoiesis

We have shown previously by means of quail/chick transplantations that external and visceral organs, i.e., somatopleural and splanchnopleural derivatives, acquire their endothelial network through different mechanisms, namely immigration (termed angiogenesis) versus in situ emergence of precursors (or vasculogenesis). We have traced the distribution of QH1-positive cells in chick hosts after replacement of the last somites by quail somites (orthotopic grafts) or lateral plate mesoderm (heterotopic grafts). The results lead to the conclusion that the embryo becomes vascularized by endothelial precursors from two distinct regions, splanchnopleural mesoderm and paraxial mesoderm. The territories respectively vascularized are complementary, precursors from the paraxial mesoderm occupy the body wall and kidney, i.e., they settle along with the other paraxial mesoderm derivatives and colonize the somatopleure. The precursors from the two origins have distinct recognition and potentialities properties: endothelial precursors of paraxial origin are barred from vascularizing visceral organs and from integrating into the floor of the aorta, and are never associated with hemopoiesis; splanchnopleural mesoderm grafted in the place of somites, gives off endothelial cells to body wall and kidney but also visceral organs. It gives rise to hemopoietic precursors in addition to endothelial cells.

Hypoblastic tissue and fibroblast growth factor induce blood tissue (haemoglobin) in the early chick embryo

We have investigated the temporal and the causal basis of blood tissue specification in the chick embryo. Earlier workers have shown that the prospective blood-forming area is specified in a horseshoe-shaped area at the posterior side of the embryo. We found that cultured explants from the posterior marginal zone at stages XI to XIII (consisting of the posterior marginal zone and part of Koller's sickle) have a high propensity to form haemoglobin (Hb), which could be inhibited at stage XI by adding antibody against basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) to the neutral culture medium; this treatment had no effect from stage XII onwards. The same result was found when whole embryos were cultured with an antiserum raised against bFGF, or with heparin. In another series of experiments, we found that cultured pieces from the inner-core of stage XIII epiblasts (with or without hypoblast tissue) were able to form Hb, whereas inner-core pieces from the pre-hypoblast stages, namely stages X and XI, did not form Hb. The capacity to form Hb, however, could be conferred upon the inner-core pieces from stage X epiblasts if bFGF at a concentration of 75–150 ng/ml was added to the culture medium. Furthermore, and most pertinently, the capacity to form Hb could be conferred on stage X inner-core pieces when they were co-cultured with hypoblast from a stage XIII embryo in a sandwich explant. Thus the inductive role of the hypoblast appears to be mediated via bFGF.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Is extraembryonic angiogenesis in the chick embryo controlled by the endoderm? A morphology study

The area vasculosa of the chick embryo is subdivided into two concentric zones: the inner transparent area pellucida vasculosa (AVP) and the less transparent surrounding area opaca vasculosa (AOV). The different optical properties of these zones are caused by the different morphology of the endoderm, which consists of flat cells in the APV and of high-prismatic cells containing large yolk vacuoles in the AOV. The present study describes how this endodermal subdivision of the area vasculosa is related to the development of the extraembryonic vascular pattern. By injection of ink into the vascular system of chick embryos at stages 12 to 20 (Hamburger and Hamilton 1951 "HH"), it has been demonstrated that the vascular net of the area vasculosa from stage 14 (HH) onwards develops into different patterns in APV and AOV. The small loops of uniform capillary vessels of stage 13 (HH) are widened due to the rapid expansion of the extraembryonic mesoderm. In the AOV from stage 14 (HH) onwards numerous small blood vessels sprout into the enlarged intervascular spaces. This process is maximal at stage 17 (HH). In contrast, the blood vessels of the APV remain largely unbranched. These findings suggest that the development of the extraembryonic vascular pattern is controlled by the endodermal pattern. To test this hypothesis, both zones (APV and AOV) were examined by light microscopy, transmission and scanning electron microscopy, in vivo observations and by treatment with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). TEM examinations show that the ultrastructural organization of the APV mesoderm is different from that of the AOV: The splanchnopleuric cells of the APV form a continuous cover around the endothelial cells connected by numerous desmosomes, whereas the splanchnopleuric cells of the AOV are frequently separated by gaps. The largest gaps are seen in the small blood vessels at stage 17 (HH). These results should be considered in relation to the dynamic changes in the vascular pattern of the AOV. The endodermal cells of APV and AOV are two different populations. In vivo observation of the endodermal transition from APV to AOV detected no transformations of APV cells into AOV cells or vice versa. The borderline between the zones is stable. The AOV endoderm, having been overgrown by the expanding mesoderm, stops proliferating almost completely, whereas the proliferation of the APV endoderm is unaffected by contact with the mesoderm. The rate of its proliferation is approximately as high as that of the AOV prior to contact with the expanding mesoderm (results after treatment with BrdU).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)