Perspectives for the creation of a new type of vaccine preparations based on pseudovirus particles using polio vaccine as an example

Traditional antiviral vaccines are currently created by inactivating the virus chemically, most often using formaldehyde or β-propiolactone. These approaches are not optimal since they negatively affect the safety of the antigenic determinants of the inactivated particles and require additional purification stages. The most promising platforms for creating vaccines are based on pseudoviruses, i.e., viruses that have completely preserved the outer shell (capsid), while losing the ability to reproduce owing to the destruction of the genome. The irradiation of viruses with electron beam is the optimal way to create pseudoviral particles. In this review, with the example of the poliovirus, the main algorithms that can be applied to characterize pseudoviral particles functionally and structurally in the process of creating a vaccine preparation are presented. These algorithms are, namely, the analysis of the degree of genome destruction and coimmunogenicity. The structure of the poliovirus and methods of its inactivation are considered. Methods for assessing residual infectivity and immunogenicity are proposed for the functional characterization of pseudoviruses. Genome integrity analysis approaches, atomic force and electron microscopy, surface plasmon resonance, and bioelectrochemical methods are crucial to structural characterization of the pseudovirus particles.

Structural basis for genome packaging, retention, and ejection in human cytomegalovirus

How the human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) genome—the largest among human herpesviruses—is packaged, retained, and ejected remains unclear. We present the in situ structures of the symmetry-mismatched portal and the capsid vertex-specific components (CVSCs) of HCMV. The 5-fold symmetric 10-helix anchor—uncommon among known portals—contacts the portal-encircling DNA, which is presumed to squeeze the portal as the genome packaging proceeds. We surmise that the 10-helix anchor dampens this action to delay the portal reaching a “head-full” packaging state, thus facilitating the large genome to be packaged. The 6-fold symmetric turret, latched via a coiled coil to a helix from a major capsid protein, supports the portal to retain the packaged genome. CVSCs at the penton vertices—presumed to increase inner capsid pressure—display a low stoichiometry, which would aid genome retention. We also demonstrate that the portal and capsid undergo conformational changes to facilitate genome ejection after viral cell entry.

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) is the prototypical member of the β-herpesvirinae subfamily and the leading viral cause of congenital infections that can lead to birth defects and it can also cause life-threatening disease in immunocompromised individuals. Here, the authors present the in-situ cryo-EM structures of the symmetry-mismatched portal and the capsid vertex-specific components (CVSCs) of HCMV and discuss the mechanistic implications for genome package, retention and ejection.

High resolution imaging of viruses: Scanning probe microscopy and related techniques

Scanning probe microscopy is a group of measurements that provides 3D visualization of viruses in different environmental conditions including liquids and air. Besides 3D topography it is possible to measure the properties like mechanical rigidity and stability, adhesion, tendency to crystallization, surface charge, etc. Choosing the right substrate and scanning parameters makes it much easier to obtain reliable data. Rational interpretation of experimental results should take into account possible artifacts, proper filtering and data presentation using specially designed software packages. Animal and human virus characterization is in the focus of many intensive studies because of their potential harm to higher organisms. The article focuses on high-resolution visualization of plant viruses. Tobacco mosaic virus, potato viruses X and B and others are not dangerous for the human being and are widely used in different applications such as vaccine preparation, construction of building units in nanotechnology and material science applications, nanoparticle production and delivery, and even metrology. The methods of virus's deposition, visualization, and consequent image processing and interpretation are described in details. Specific examples of viruses imaging are illustrated using the FemtoScan Online software, which has typical and all the necessary built-in functions for constructing three-dimensional images, their processing and analysis. Despite visible progress in visualizing the viruses using probe microscopy, many unresolved problems still remain. At present time the probe microscopy data on viruses is not systemized. There is no descriptive atlas of the images and morphology as revealed by this type of high resolution microscopy. It is worth emphasizing that new virus investigation methods will appear due to the progress of science.

Imaging aquatic animal cells and associated pathogens by atomic force microscopy in air

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a sophisticated imaging tool with nanoscale resolution that is widely used in structural biology, cell biology, and material science, among other fields. However, to date it has rarely been applied to the study of aquatic animals, especially on one of the main cultured species, shrimp. One reason for this is that no shrimp cell line established until now, primary cell is fragile and difficult to be studied under AFM. In this study, we used AFM to image three different types of biological material from shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) in air, including hemocytes and two associated pathogens. Without obvious deformations when the cells were imaged in air and in the case for the haemocytes and the cells were fixed as well. The result suggests hydrophobic glass coverslips are a suitable substrate for adhesion of these samples. The method described here can be applied to the preparation of other fragile biological samples from aquatic animals for high-resolution analyses of host-pathogen interactions and other basic physiological processes.

AFM Nanoindentation Experiments on Protein Shells: A Protocol

Proteinaceous assemblies are ubiquitous in nature. One important form of these assemblies are protein nanoshells such as viruses; however, a variety of other protein shells exist. To deepen our knowledge on the structure and function of protein shells, a profound insight into their mechanical properties is required. Nanoindentation measurements with an atomic force microscope (AFM) are increasingly being performed to probe such material properties. This single particle approach allows us to determine the spring constant, the Young's modulus, as well as the force and deformation at which failure occurs of the nanoshells. The experimental procedures for these mechanical measurements are described here in detail, focusing on surface preparation, AFM imaging and nanoindentation, and the subsequent data analysis of the force-distance curves. Whereas AFM can be operated in air and in liquid, the described methods are for probing single particles in liquid to enable studies in close to physiological environments.

Structure of the herpes simplex virus type 2 C-capsid with capsid-vertex-specific component

Herpes simplex viruses (HSVs) cause human oral and genital ulcer diseases. Patients with HSV-2 have a higher risk of acquiring a human immunodeficiency virus infection. HSV-2 is a member of the α-herpesvirinae subfamily that together with the β- and γ-herpesvirinae subfamilies forms the Herpesviridae family. Here, we report the cryo-electron microscopy structure of the HSV-2 C-capsid with capsid-vertex-specific component (CVSC) that was determined at 3.75 Å using a block-based reconstruction strategy. We present atomic models of multiple conformers for the capsid proteins (VP5, VP23, VP19C, and VP26) and CVSC. Comparison of the HSV-2 homologs yields information about structural similarities and differences between the three herpesviruses sub-families and we identify α-herpesvirus-specific structural features. The hetero-pentameric CVSC, consisting of a UL17 monomer, a UL25 dimer and a UL36 dimer, is bound tightly by a five-helix bundle that forms extensive networks of subunit contacts with surrounding capsid proteins, which reinforce capsid stability.

Herpes simplex virus type-2 (HSV-2) belongs to the α-herpesvirinae subfamily and is a sexually transmitted virus that causes genital ulcer disease. Here the authors present the 3.75 Å cryo-EM structure of the HSV-2 C-capsid with capsid-vertex-specific component and describe α-herpesvirus-specific structural features.

Viral nanomechanics with a virtual atomic force microscope

One of the most important components of a virus is the protein shell or capsid that encloses its genetic material. The main role of the capsid is to protect the viral genome against external aggressions, facilitating its safe and efficient encapsulation and delivery. As a consequence, viral capsids have developed astonishing mechanical properties that are crucial for viral function. These remarkable properties have started to be unveiled in single-virus nanoindentation experiments, and are opening the door to the use of viral-derived artificial nanocages for promising bio- and nano-technological applications. However, the interpretation of nanoindentation experiments is often difficult, requiring the support of theoretical and simulation analysis. Here we present a 'Virtual AFM' (VAFM), a Brownian Dynamics simulation of a coarse-grained model of virus aimed to mimic the standard setup of atomic force microscopy (AFM) nanoindentation experiments. Despite the heavy level of coarse-graining, these simulations provide valuable information which is not accessible in experiments. Rather than focusing on a specific virus, the VAFM will be used to analyze how the mechanical response and breaking of viruses depend on different parameters controlling the effective interactions between capsid's structural units. In particular, we will discuss the influence of adsorption, the tip radius, and the rigidity and shape of the shell on its mechanical response.

Compressive Force Spectroscopy: From Living Cells to Single Proteins

One of the most successful applications of atomic force microscopy (AFM) in biology involves monitoring the effect of force on single biological molecules, often referred to as force spectroscopy. Such studies generally entail the application of pulling forces of different magnitudes and velocities upon individual molecules to resolve individualistic unfolding/separation pathways and the quantification of the force-dependent rate constants. However, a less recognized variation of this method, the application of compressive force, actually pre-dates many of these "tensile" force spectroscopic studies. Further, beyond being limited to the study of single molecules, these compressive force spectroscopic investigations have spanned samples as large as living cells to smaller, multi-molecular complexes such as viruses down to single protein molecules. Correspondingly, these studies have enabled the detailed characterization of individual cell states, subtle differences between seemingly identical viral structures, as well as the quantification of rate constants of functionally important, structural transitions in single proteins. Here, we briefly review some of the recent achievements that have been obtained with compressive force spectroscopy using AFM and highlight exciting areas of its future development.

AFM nanoindentation of protein shells, expanding the approach beyond viruses

The archetypical protein nanoshell is the capsid that surrounds viral genomes. These capsids protect the viral RNA or DNA and function as transport vehicle for their nucleic acid. The material properties of a variety of viral capsids have been probed by Atomic Force Microscopy. In particular nanoindentation measurements revealed the complex mechanics of these shells and the intricate interplay of the capsid with its genomic content. Furthermore, effects of capsid protein mutations, capsid maturation and the effect of environmental changes have been probed. In addition, biological questions have been addressed by AFM nanoindentation of viruses and a direct link between mechanics and infectivity has been revealed. Recently, non-viral protein nanoshells have come under intense scrutiny and now the nanoindentation approach has been expanded to such particles as well. Both natural as well as engineered non-viral protein shells have been probed by this technique. Next to the material properties of viruses, therefor also the mechanics of encapsulins, carboxysomes, vault particles, lumazine synthase and artificial protein nanoshells is discussed here.

Vertex-Specific Proteins pUL17 and pUL25 Mechanically Reinforce Herpes Simplex Virus Capsids

Using atomic force microscopy imaging and nanoindentation measurements, we investigated the effect of the minor capsid proteins pUL17 and pUL25 on the structural stability of icosahedral herpes simplex virus capsids. pUL17 and pUL25, which form the capsid vertex-specific component (CVSC), particularly contributed to capsid resilience along the 5-fold and 2-fold but not along the 3-fold icosahedral axes. Our detailed analyses, including quantitative mass spectrometry of the protein composition of the capsids, revealed that both pUL17 and pUL25 are required to stabilize the capsid shells at the vertices. This indicates that herpesviruses withstand the internal pressure that is generated during DNA genome packaging by locally reinforcing the mechanical sturdiness of the vertices, the most stressed part of the capsids.IMPORTANCE In this study, the structural, material properties of herpes simplex virus 1 were investigated. The capsid of herpes simplex virus is built up of a variety of proteins, and we scrutinized the influence of two of these proteins on the stability of the capsid. For this, we used a scanning force microscope that makes detailed, topographic images of the particles and that is able to perform mechanical deformation measurements. Using this approach, we revealed that both studied proteins play an essential role in viral stability. These new insights support us in forming a complete view on viral structure and furthermore could possibly help not only to develop specific antivirals but also to build protein shells with improved stability for drug delivery purposes.

In search for effective and definitive treatment of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) infections

Herpes Simplex Virus type 1 (HSV-1) is a nuclear replicating enveloped virus.

Fluorescence Tracking of Genome Release during Mechanical Unpacking of Single Viruses

Viruses package their genome in a robust protein coat to protect it during transmission between cells and organisms. In a reaction termed uncoating, the virus is progressively weakened during entry into cells. At the end of the uncoating process the genome separates, becomes transcriptionally active, and initiates the production of progeny. Here, we triggered the disruption of single human adenovirus capsids with atomic force microscopy and followed genome exposure by single-molecule fluorescence microscopy. This method allowed the comparison of immature (noninfectious) and mature (infectious) adenovirus particles. We observed two condensation states of the fluorescently labeled genome, a feature of the virus that may be related to infectivity. Beyond tracking the unpacking of virus genomes, this approach may find application in testing the cargo release of bioinspired delivery vehicles.

How cells tune viral mechanics--insights from biophysical measurements of influenza virus

During replication, the physical state of a virus is controlled by assembly and disassembly processes, when particles are put together and dismantled by cellular cues, respectively. A fundamental question has been how a cell can assemble an infectious virus, and dismantle a virus entering an uninfected cell and thereby trigger a new round of infection. This apparent paradox might be explained by considering that infected and uninfected cells are functionally different, or that assembly and disassembly take place along different cellular pathways. A third possibility is that the physical properties of newly assembled viruses are different from the infection-ready viruses. Recent biophysical experiments measured the stiffness of single Influenza viruses and combined this with biochemical measurements and cell biological assays. Besides inducing the fusogenic state of hemagglutinin, low pH cues softened the virus and precluded aggregation of viral ribonucleoprotein particles with the matrix protein M1. The recent experiments suggest a two-step model for Influenza virus entry and uncoating involving low pH in early and late endosomes, respectively. I conclude with a short outlook into how combined biophysical and cell biological approaches might lead to the identification of new cellular cues controlling viral uncoating and infection.

Unravelling crucial biomechanical resilience of myelinated peripheral nerve fibres provided by the Schwann cell basal lamina and PMP22

There is an urgent need for the research of the close and enigmatic relationship between nerve biomechanics and the development of neuropathies. Here we present a research strategy based on the application atomic force and confocal microscopy for simultaneous nerve biomechanics and integrity investigations. Using wild-type and hereditary neuropathy mouse models, we reveal surprising mechanical protection of peripheral nerves. Myelinated peripheral wild-type fibres promptly and fully recover from acute enormous local mechanical compression while maintaining functional and structural integrity. The basal lamina which enwraps each myelinated fibre separately is identified as the major contributor to the striking fibre's resilience and integrity. In contrast, neuropathic fibres lacking the peripheral myelin protein 22 (PMP22), which is closely connected with several hereditary human neuropathies, fail to recover from light compression. Interestingly, the structural arrangement of the basal lamina of Pmp22^−/− fibres is significantly altered compared to wild-type fibres. In conclusion, the basal lamina and PMP22 act in concert to contribute to a resilience and integrity of peripheral nerves at the single fibre level. Our findings and the presented technology set the stage for a comprehensive research of the links between nerve biomechanics and neuropathies.

Structural transitions and energy landscape for Cowpea Chlorotic Mottle Virus capsid mechanics from nanomanipulation in vitro and in silico

Physical properties of capsids of plant and animal viruses are important factors in capsid self-assembly, survival of viruses in the extracellular environment, and their cell infectivity. Combined AFM experiments and computational modeling on subsecond timescales of the indentation nanomechanics of Cowpea Chlorotic Mottle Virus capsid show that the capsid's physical properties are dynamic and local characteristics of the structure, which change with the depth of indentation and depend on the magnitude and geometry of mechanical input. Under large deformations, the Cowpea Chlorotic Mottle Virus capsid transitions to the collapsed state without substantial local structural alterations. The enthalpy change in this deformation state ΔHind = 11.5-12.8 MJ/mol is mostly due to large-amplitude out-of-plane excitations, which contribute to the capsid bending; the entropy change TΔSind = 5.1-5.8 MJ/mol is due to coherent in-plane rearrangements of protein chains, which mediate the capsid stiffening. Direct coupling of these modes defines the extent of (ir)reversibility of capsid indentation dynamics correlated with its (in)elastic mechanical response to the compressive force. This emerging picture illuminates how unique physico-chemical properties of protein nanoshells help define their structure and morphology, and determine their viruses' biological function.

Virus strategies for passing the nuclear envelope barrier

Viruses that replicate in the nucleus need to pass the nuclear envelope barrier during infection. Research in recent years indicates that the nuclear envelope is a major hurdle for many viruses. This review describes strategies to overcome this obstacle developed by seven virus families: herpesviridae, adenoviridae, orthomyxoviridae, lentiviruses (which are part of retroviridae), Hepadnaviridae, parvoviridae and polyomaviridae. Most viruses use the canonical nuclear pore complex (NPC) in order to get their genome into the nucleus. Viral capsids that are larger than the nuclear pore disassemble before or during passing through the NPC, thus allowing genome nuclear entry. Surprisingly, increasing evidence suggest that parvoviruses and polyomaviruses may bypass the nuclear pore by trafficking directly through the nuclear membrane. Additional studies are required for better understanding these processes. Since nuclear entry emerges as the limiting step in infection for many viruses, it may serve as an ideal target for antiviral drug development.

Nuclear delivery mechanism of herpes simplex virus type 1 genome

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) is a widespread human pathogen infecting more than 80% of the population worldwide. Its replication involves an essential, poorly understood multistep process, referred to as uncoating. Uncoating steps are as follows: (1) The incoming capsid pinpoints the nuclear pore complex (NPC). (2) It opens up at the NPC and releases the highly pressurized viral genome. (3) The viral genome translocates through the NPC. In the present review, we highlight recent advances in this field and propose mechanisms underlying the individual steps of uncoating. We presume that the incoming HSV-1 capsid pinpoints the NPC by hydrophobic interactions and opens up upon binding to NPC proteins. Genome translocation is initially pressure-driven.

Disulfide bond formation contributes to herpes simplex virus capsid stability and retention of pentons

Disulfide bonds reportedly stabilize the capsids of several viruses, including papillomavirus, polyomavirus, and simian virus 40, and have been detected in herpes simplex virus (HSV) capsids. In this study, we show that in mature HSV-1 virions, capsid proteins VP5, VP23, VP19C, UL17, and UL25 participate in covalent cross-links, and that these are susceptible to dithiothreitol (DTT). In addition, several tegument proteins were found in high-molecular-weight complexes, including VP22, UL36, and UL37. Cross-linked capsid complexes can be detected in virions isolated in the presence and absence of N-ethylmaleimide (NEM), a chemical that reacts irreversibly with free cysteines to block disulfide formation. Intracellular capsids isolated in the absence of NEM contain disulfide cross-linked species; however, intracellular capsids isolated from cells pretreated with NEM did not. Thus, the free cysteines in intracellular capsids appear to be positioned such that disulfide bond formation can occur readily if they are exposed to an oxidizing environment. These results indicate that disulfide cross-links are normally present in extracellular virions but not in intracellular capsids. Interestingly, intracellular capsids isolated in the presence of NEM are unstable; B and C capsids are converted to a novel form that resembles A capsids, indicating that scaffold and DNA are lost. Furthermore, these capsids also have lost pentons and peripentonal triplexes as visualized by cryoelectron microscopy. These data indicate that capsid stability, and especially the retention of pentons, is regulated by the formation of disulfide bonds in the capsid.

How to perform a nanoindentation experiment on a virus

To broaden our knowledge on virus structure and function, a profound insight into their mechanical properties is required. Nanoindentation measurements with an atomic force microscope (AFM) are increasingly being performed to probe such material properties. This single-particle approach allows for determining the viral spring constant, their Young's modulus, as well as the force and deformation at which failure occurs. The experimental procedures for viral nanoindentation experiments are described here in detail, focusing on surface preparation, AFM imaging and nanoindentation, and the subsequent data analysis of the force-distance curves. Whereas AFM can be operated in air and in liquid, the described methods are for probing single viruses in liquid to enable working in a physiologically relevant environment.

Squeezing protein shells: how continuum elastic models, molecular dynamics simulations, and experiments coalesce at the nanoscale

The current rapid growth in the use of nanosized particles is fueled in part by our increased understanding of their physical properties and ability to manipulate them, which is essential for achieving optimal functionality. Here we report detailed quantitative measurements of the mechanical response of nanosized protein shells (viral capsids) to large-scale physical deformations and compare them with theoretical descriptions from continuum elastic modeling and molecular dynamics (MD). Specifically, we used nanoindentation by atomic force microscopy to investigate the complex elastic behavior of Hepatitis B virus capsids. These capsids are hollow, approximately 30 nm in diameter, and conform to icosahedral (5-3-2) symmetry. First we show that their indentation behavior, which is symmetry-axis-dependent, cannot be reproduced by a simple model based on Föppl-von Kármán thin-shell elasticity with the fivefold vertices acting as prestressed disclinations. However, we can properly describe the measured nonlinear elastic and orientation-dependent force response with a three-dimensional, topographically detailed, finite-element model. Next, we show that coarse-grained MD simulations also yield good agreement with our nanoindentation measurements, even without any fitting of force-field parameters in the MD model. This study demonstrates that the material properties of viral nanoparticles can be correctly described by both modeling approaches. At the same time, we show that even for large deformations, it suffices to approximate the mechanical behavior of nanosized viral shells with a continuum approach, and ignore specific molecular interactions. This experimental validation of continuum elastic theory provides an example of a situation in which rules of macroscopic physics can apply to nanoscale molecular assemblies.

Sampling protein form and function with the atomic force microscope

To study the structure, function, and interactions of proteins, a plethora of techniques is available. Many techniques sample such parameters in non-physiological environments (e.g. in air, ice, or vacuum). Atomic force microscopy (AFM), however, is a powerful biophysical technique that can probe these parameters under physiological buffer conditions. With the atomic force microscope operating under such conditions, it is possible to obtain images of biological structures without requiring labeling and to follow dynamic processes in real time. Furthermore, by operating in force spectroscopy mode, it can probe intramolecular interactions and binding strengths. In structural biology, it has proven its ability to image proteins and protein conformational changes at submolecular resolution, and in proteomics, it is developing as a tool to map surface proteomes and to study protein function by force spectroscopy methods. The power of AFM to combine studies of protein form and protein function enables bridging various research fields to come to a comprehensive, molecular level picture of biological processes. We review the use of AFM imaging and force spectroscopy techniques and discuss the major advances of these experiments in further understanding form and function of proteins at the nanoscale in physiologically relevant environments.

Egress of HSV-1 capsid requires the interaction of VP26 and a cellular tetraspanin membrane protein

HSV-1 viral capsid maturation and egress from the nucleus constitutes a self-controlled process of interactions between host cytoplasmic membrane proteins and viral capsid proteins. In this study, a member of the tetraspanin superfamily, CTMP-7, was shown to physically interact with HSV-1 protein VP26, and the VP26-CTMP-7 complex was detected both in vivo and in vitro. The interaction of VP26 with CTMP-7 plays an essential role in normal HSV-1 replication. Additionally, analysis of a recombinant virus HSV-1-UG showed that mutating VP26 resulted in a decreased viral replication rate and in aggregation of viral mutant capsids in the nucleus. Together, our data support the notion that biological events mediated by a VP26 - CTMP-7 interaction aid in viral capsid enveloping and egress from the cell during the HSV-1 infectious process.

Elucidating the mechanism behind irreversible deformation of viral capsids

Atomic force microscopy has recently provided highly precise measurements of mechanical properties of various viruses. However, molecular details underlying viral mechanics remain unresolved. Here we report atomic force microscopy nanoindentation experiments on T=4 hepatitis B virus (HBV) capsids combined with coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations, which permit interpretation of experimental results at the molecular level. The force response of the indented capsid recorded in simulations agrees with experimental observations. In both experiment and simulation, irreversible capsid deformation is observed for deep indentations. Simulations show the irreversibility to be due to local bending and shifting of capsid proteins, rather than their global rearrangement. These results emphasize the viability of large capsid deformations without significant changes of the mutual positions of HBV capsid proteins, in contrast to the stiffer capsids of other viruses, which exhibit more extensive contacts between their capsid proteins than seen in the case of HBV.

Scaffold expulsion and genome packaging trigger stabilization of herpes simplex virus capsids

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV1) capsids undergo extensive structural changes during maturation and DNA packaging. As a result, they become more stable and competent for nuclear egress. To further elucidate this stabilization process, we used biochemical and nanoindentation approaches to analyze the structural and mechanical properties of scaffold-containing (B), empty (A), and DNA-containing (C) nuclear capsids. Atomic force microscopy experiments revealed that A and C capsids were mechanically indistinguishable, indicating that the presence of DNA does not account for changes in mechanical properties during capsid maturation. Despite having the same rigidity, the scaffold-containing B capsids broke at significantly lower forces than A and C capsids. An extraction of pentons with guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) increased the flexibility of all capsids. Surprisingly, the breaking forces of the modified A and C capsids dropped to similar values as those of the GuHCl-treated B capsids, indicating that mechanical reinforcement occurs at the vertices. Nonetheless, it also showed that HSV1 capsids possess a remarkable structural integrity that was preserved after removal of pentons. We suggest that HSV1 capsids are stabilized after removal of the scaffold proteins, and that this stabilization is triggered by the packaging of DNA, but independent of the actual presence of DNA.

Model-independent analysis of QCM data on colloidal particle adsorption

Quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) is widely used for studying soft interfaces in liquid environment. Many of these interfaces are heterogeneous in nature, in the sense that they are composed of discrete, isolated entities adsorbed at a surface. When characterizing such interfaces, one is interested in determining parameters such as surface coverage and size of the surface-adsorbed entities. The current strategy is to obtain this information by fitting QCM data--shifts in resonance frequency, DeltaF, and bandwidth, DeltaGamma--with the model derived for smooth, homogeneous films using the film acoustic thickness and shear elastic moduli as fitting parameters. Investigating adsorption of liposomes and icosahedral virus particles on inorganic surfaces of titania and gold, we demonstrate that the predictions of this model are at variance with the experimental observations. In particular, while the model predicts that the ratio between the bandwidth and frequency shifts, DeltaGamma/DeltaF (the Df ratio), should increase with both surface coverage and particle size, we observe that this ratio increases with increasing particle size but decreases with increasing surface coverage, demonstrating that QCM response in heterogeneous films, such as those composed of adsorbed colloidal particles, does not conform with the predictions of the homogeneous film model. Employing finite element method (FEM) calculations, we show that hydrodynamic effects are the cause of this discrepancy. Finally, we find that the size of the adsorbed colloidal particles can be recovered from a model-independent analysis of the plot of the DeltaGamma/DeltaF ratio versus the frequency shift on many overtones.