Vibrio cholerae cytotoxin MakA induces noncanonical autophagy resulting in the spatial inhibition of canonical autophagy

Breaking the cellular defense: the role of autophagy evasion in Francisella virulence

Many pathogens have evolved sophisticated strategies to evade autophagy, a crucial cellular defense mechanism that typically targets and degrades invading microorganisms. By subverting or inhibiting autophagy, these pathogens can create a more favorable environment for their replication and survival within the host. For instance, some bacteria secrete factors that block autophagosome formation, while others might escape from autophagosomes before degradation. These evasion tactics are critical for the pathogens' ability to establish and maintain infections. Understanding the mechanisms by which pathogens avoid autophagy is crucial for developing new therapeutic strategies, as enhancing autophagy could bolster the host's immune response and aid in the elimination of pathogenic bacteria. Francisella tularensis can manipulate host cell pathways to prevent its detection and destruction by autophagy, thereby enhancing its virulence. Given the potential for F. tularensis to be used as a bioterrorism agent due to its high infectivity and ability to cause severe disease, research into how this pathogen evades autophagy is of critical importance. By unraveling these mechanisms, new therapeutic approaches could be developed to enhance autophagic responses and strengthen host defense against this and other similarly evasive pathogens.

V. cholerae MakA is a cholesterol-binding pore-forming toxin that induces non-canonical autophagy

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are important virulence factors produced by many pathogenic bacteria. Here, we show that the Vibrio cholerae toxin MakA is a novel cholesterol-binding PFT that induces non-canonical autophagy in a pH-dependent manner. MakA specifically binds to cholesterol on the membrane at pH < 7. Cholesterol-binding leads to oligomerization of MakA on the membrane and pore formation at pH 5.5. Unlike other cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs) which bind cholesterol through a conserved cholesterol-binding motif (Thr-Leu pair), MakA contains an Ile-Ile pair that is essential for MakA-cholesterol interaction. Following internalization, endosomal acidification triggers MakA pore-assembly followed by ESCRT-mediated membrane repair and V-ATPase-dependent unconventional LC3 lipidation on the damaged endolysosomal membranes. These findings characterize a new cholesterol-binding toxin that forms pores in a pH-dependent manner and reveals the molecular mechanism of host autophagy manipulation.

A Genomic Island of Vibrio cholerae Encodes a Three-Component Cytotoxin with Monomer and Protomer Forms Structurally Similar to Alpha-Pore-Forming Toxins

Alpha-pore-forming toxins (α-PFTs) are secreted by many species of bacteria, including Escherichia coli, Aeromonas hydrophila, and Bacillus thuringiensis, as part of their arsenal of virulence factors, and are often cytotoxic. In particular, for α-PFTs, the membrane-spanning channel they form is composed of hydrophobic α-helices. These toxins oligomerize at the surface of target cells and transition from a soluble to a protomer state in which they expose their hydrophobic regions and insert into the membrane to form a pore. The pores may be composed of homooligomers of one component or heterooligomers with two or three components, resulting in bi- or tripartite toxins. The multicomponent α-PFTs are often expressed from a single operon. Recently, motility-associated killing factor A (MakA), an α-PFT, was discovered in Vibrio cholerae. We report that makA is found on the V. cholerae GI-10 genomic island within an operon containing genes for two other potential α-PFTs, MakB and MakE. We determined the X-ray crystal structures for MakA, MakB, and MakE and demonstrated that all three are structurally related to the α-PFT family in the soluble state, and we modeled their protomer state based on the α-PFT AhlB from A. hydrophila. We found that MakA alone is cytotoxic at micromolar concentrations. However, combining MakA with MakB and MakE is cytotoxic at nanomolar concentrations, with specificity for J774 macrophage cells. Our data suggest that MakA, -B, and -E are α-PFTs that potentially act as a tripartite pore-forming toxin with specificity for phagocytic cells. IMPORTANCE The bacterium Vibrio cholerae causes gastrointestinal, wound, and skin infections. The motility-associated killing factor A (MakA) was recently shown to be cytotoxic against colon, prostate, and other cancer cells. However, at the outset of this study, the capacity of MakA to damage cells in combination with other Mak proteins encoded in the same operon had not been elucidated. We determined the structures of three Mak proteins and established that they are structurally related to the α-PFTs. Compared to MakA alone, the combination of all three toxins was more potent specifically in mouse macrophages. This study highlights the idea that the Mak toxins are selectively cytotoxic and thus may function as a tripartite toxin with cell type specificity.

Protein-lipid interaction at low pH induces oligomerization of the MakA cytotoxin from Vibrio cholerae

The α-pore-forming toxins (α-PFTs) from pathogenic bacteria damage host cell membranes by pore formation. We demonstrate a remarkable, hitherto unknown mechanism by an α-PFT protein from Vibrio cholerae. As part of the MakA/B/E tripartite toxin, MakA is involved in membrane pore formation similar to other α-PFTs. In contrast, MakA in isolation induces tube-like structures in acidic endosomal compartments of epithelial cells in vitro. The present study unravels the dynamics of tubular growth, which occurs in a pH-, lipid-, and concentration-dependent manner. Within acidified organelle lumens or when incubated with cells in acidic media, MakA forms oligomers and remodels membranes into high-curvature tubes leading to loss of membrane integrity. A 3.7 Å cryo-electron microscopy structure of MakA filaments reveals a unique protein-lipid superstructure. MakA forms a pinecone-like spiral with a central cavity and a thin annular lipid bilayer embedded between the MakA transmembrane helices in its active α-PFT conformation. Our study provides insights into a novel tubulation mechanism of an α-PFT protein and a new mode of action by a secreted bacterial toxin.

A tripartite cytolytic toxin formed by Vibrio cholerae proteins with flagellum-facilitated secretion

Vibrio cholerae, responsible for outbreaks of cholera disease, is a highly motile organism by virtue of a single flagellum. We describe how the flagellum facilitates the secretion of three V. cholerae proteins encoded by a hitherto-unrecognized genomic island. The proteins MakA/B/E can form a tripartite toxin that lyses erythrocytes and is cytotoxic to cultured human cells. A structural basis for the cytolytic activity of the Mak proteins was obtained by X-ray crystallography. Flagellum-facilitated secretion ensuring spatially coordinated delivery of Mak proteins revealed a role for the V. cholerae flagellum considered of particular significance for the bacterial environmental persistence. Our findings will pave the way for the development of diagnostics and therapeutic strategies against pathogenic Vibrionaceae.

The protein MakA was discovered as a motility-associated secreted toxin from Vibrio cholerae. Here, we show that MakA is part of a gene cluster encoding four additional proteins: MakB, MakC, MakD, and MakE. MakA, MakB, and MakE were readily detected in culture supernatants of wild-type V. cholerae, whereas secretion was very much reduced from a flagellum-deficient mutant. Crystal structures of MakA, MakB, and MakE revealed a structural relationship to a superfamily of bacterial pore-forming toxins. Expression of MakA/B/E in Escherichia coli resulted in toxicity toward Caenorhabditis elegans used as a predatory model organism. None of these Mak proteins alone or in pairwise combinations were cytolytic, but an equimolar mixture of MakA, MakB, and MakE acted as a tripartite cytolytic toxin in vitro, causing lysis of erythrocytes and cytotoxicity on cultured human colon carcinoma cells. Formation of oligomeric complexes on liposomes was observed by electron microscopy. Oligomer interaction with membranes was initiated by MakA membrane binding followed by MakB and MakE joining the assembly of a pore structure. A predicted membrane insertion domain of MakA was shown by site-directed mutagenesis to be essential for toxicity toward C. elegans. Bioinformatic analyses revealed that the makCDBAE gene cluster is present as a genomic island in the vast majority of sequenced genomes of V. cholerae and the fish pathogen Vibrio anguillarum. We suggest that the hitherto-unrecognized cytolytic MakA/B/E toxin can contribute to Vibrionaceae fitness and virulence potential in different host environments and organisms.

Phosphatidic acid-mediated binding and mammalian cell internalization of the Vibrio cholerae cytotoxin MakA

Vibrio cholerae is a noninvasive intestinal pathogen extensively studied as the causative agent of the human disease cholera. Our recent work identified MakA as a potent virulence factor of V. cholerae in both Caenorhabditis elegans and zebrafish, prompting us to investigate the potential contribution of MakA to pathogenesis also in mammalian hosts. In this study, we demonstrate that the MakA protein could induce autophagy and cytotoxicity of target cells. In addition, we observed that phosphatidic acid (PA)-mediated MakA-binding to the host cell plasma membranes promoted macropinocytosis resulting in the formation of an endomembrane-rich aggregate and vacuolation in intoxicated cells that lead to induction of autophagy and dysfunction of intracellular organelles. Moreover, we functionally characterized the molecular basis of the MakA interaction with PA and identified that the N-terminal domain of MakA is required for its binding to PA and thereby for cell toxicity. Furthermore, we observed that the ΔmakA mutant outcompeted the wild-type V. cholerae strain A1552 in the adult mouse infection model. Based on the findings revealing mechanistic insights into the dynamic process of MakA-induced autophagy and cytotoxicity we discuss the potential role played by the MakA protein during late stages of cholera infection as an anti-colonization factor.

Vibrio cholerae is the cause of cholera, an infectious disease causing watery diarrhea that can lead to fatal dehydration. The bacteria can readily adapt to different environments, such as from its natural aquatic habitats to the human digestive system. Recently, we reported a novel V. cholerae cytotoxin, MakA that functions as a potent virulence factor in C. elegans and zebrafish. Here we identified phosphatidic acid as a lipid target for MakA interaction with mammalian cells. This interaction promoted macropinocytosis resulting in the formation of an endomembrane-rich aggregate in intoxicated cells that ultimately lead to activation of autophagy. Importantly, data from bacterial colonization in a mouse infection model suggested that MakA might act as an anti-colonization factor of V. cholerae, presumably expressed during later stage(s) of infection. MakA might be explored as a new target for diagnostics and therapeutic developments against V. cholerae infections. Our findings will contribute to further understanding of the virulence, colonization and post-infection spread of V. cholerae.