Bone remodeling in sigmoid sinus diverticulum after stenting for transverse sinus stenosis in pulsatile tinnitus: A case report

Endovascular vs surgical treatment of sigmoid sinus diverticulum causing pulsatile tinnitus: A systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Sigmoid sinus diverticulum (SSD) has been increasingly reported as a cause of pulsatile tinnitus (PT). While both endovascular and surgical treatments have been used, there is a lack of consensus on the treatment modality to treat SSD. We conducted a systematic review of the available literature to compare the clinical outcomes and safety of endovascular versus surgical approaches for treating SSD.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses to identify studies encompassing the management of SSD. Studies reporting the clinical outcomes and safety of endovascular or surgical treatments for SSD between January 2000 and January 2023 were included. Results were characterized using descriptive statistics.

RESULTS

Endovascular treatment (EVT) was reported by 17 articles, yielding 26 patients with 27 diverticula. Surgical treatment was reported by 20 articles, yielding 105 patients with 107 diverticula. EVT led to complete or near-complete resolution in all patients with SSD and PT. Complications occurred in 3.7% (1/27) with a return to baseline after 2 months. There were no permanent complications from EVT. Surgical treatment resulted in complete resolution in 77.6% (83/107) of cases, incomplete resolution in 11.2% (12/107), and no resolution in 11.2% (12/107). Significant complications occurred in 9.3% (10/107) of the surgical-treated patients.

CONCLUSION

EVT in patients with PT and venous diverticulum appears more effective and safer than surgical treatment, but large studies are lacking. Studies directly comparing endovascular and surgical treatment are needed.

Fluid-structure interaction study on the causes of mending material damage after sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Sigmoid Sinus (SS) Wall Reconstruction (SSWR) is the mainstream treatment for pulsatile tinnitus (PT), but it has a high risk of recurrence. The damage of mending material is the key cause of recurrence, and its hemodynamic mechanism is still unclear. The purpose of this study was to investigate the hemodynamic causes of mending material breakage.

METHODS

In this study, six patient-specific geometric models were reconstructed based on the data of the computed tomography angiography (CTA). The transient fluid-structure coupling method was performed to clarify the hemodynamic state of sigmoid sinus and the biomechanical state of the mending material. The distribution of stress and displacement and the flow pattern were calculated to evaluate the hemodynamic and biomechanics difference at the mending material area.

RESULTS

The area of blood flow impact in some patients (2/6) was consistent with the damaged location of the mending material. The average stress (6/6) and average displacement (6/6) of damaged mending material were higher than those of complete mending material. All (6/6) patients showed that the high-stress and high-displacement proportion of the DMM region was higher than that of the CMM region. Moreover, the average stress fluctuation (6/6) and average displacement (6/6) fluctuation degree of damaged mending material is larger than that of complete mending material.

CONCLUSIONS

The impact of blood and the uneven stress and displacement fluctuation of the mending material may be the causes of mending material damage. High stress and high displacement might be the key causes of the mending material damage.

Resurfacing Dehiscence(s) Without Reducing Diverticulum Effectively Silences Pulsatile Tinnitus: Novel Surgical Techniques for Diverticulum and Intraoperative Microphone Monitoring

OBJECTIVE

To emphasize the surgical importance of addressing dehiscence over diverticulum in resolving pulsatile tinnitus (PT) in patients with sigmoid sinus wall anomalies (SSWAs) and investigate anatomical differences.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective data analysis.

SETTING

Multi-institutional tertiary university medical centers.

PATIENTS

Fifty participants (dehiscence/diverticulum, 29:21 cases) with SSWA-associated PT were included in the study. All 21 diverticulum participants underwent surgical intervention.

INTERVENTIONS

1) Surgical intervention with novel techniques monitored by intraoperative microphone. 2) Radiologic and ophthalmologic imaging methods.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Quantitative and qualitative preoperative and postoperative alterations of PT and anatomical differences between dehiscence and diverticulum.

RESULTS

Addressing dehiscence overlying diverticulum and sigmoid sinus wall dehiscences significantly reduced visual analog score and Tinnitus Handicap Inventory ( p < 0.01). Sinus wall reconstruction led to substantial PT sound intensity reduction in the frequency range of 20 to 1000 Hz and 20 to 500 Hz (paired-sample t test, p < 0.01). Diploic vein analysis showed a significant positive correlation in 85.7% of the diverticulum cohort compared with the dehiscence cohort ( p < 0.01). Eight percent of the participants exhibited papilledema, which was limited to the dehiscence cohort.

CONCLUSION

1) Effective reduction of PT can be achieved by addressing all dehiscences, including those overlying the diverticulum, without the need to exclude the diverticulum. 2) Diploic vein may involve in the formation of diverticulum, and loss of dura mater and vascular wall thickness are observed at the SSWA locations.

Hemodynamic assessments of unilateral pulsatile tinnitus with jugular bulb wall dehiscence using 4D flow magnetic resonance imaging

Background

Pulsatile tinnitus (PT) is a type of tinnitus characterized by a rhythmic sound that is synchronous with the heartbeat. One of the possible causes of PT is the jugular bulb wall dehiscence (JBWD). However, the hemodynamics of this condition are not well understood. To elucidate this issue, the present study aimed to compare the blood flow of PT patients with JBWD, PT patients with sigmoid sinus wall dehiscence (SSWD), and volunteers.

Methods

A retrospective case-control study was conducted, which enrolled patients with unilateral PT who had undergone both computed tomography angiography (CTA) and four-dimensional (4D) flow magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) examinations at the Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery of Beijing Friendship Hospital affiliated to Capital Medical University between January 2019 and July 2023. After excluding the possible causes of PT, the patients were divided into the JBWD group and SSWD group according to the presence or absence of JBWD and/or SSWD. Finally, 11 female unilateral PT patients with JBWD (JBWD group, 11sides), 22 age- and side-matched female patients with SSWD (SSWD group, 22 sides), and 22 age-matched female volunteers (volunteer group, 36 sides) were enrolled. The area, maximum voxel velocity (Vv-max), maximum velocity (Vmax), average velocity (Vavg), and average blood flow rate (Q) were measured in the transverse sinuses (TSs), sigmoid sinuses (SSs), and jugular bulb (JB). The vortex flow pattern was also assessed. Fisher's exact test and Bonferroni correction were used for count data, with P<0.017 was considered statistically significant. Shapiro-Wilk test, one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Kruskal-Wallis H test, paired-samples t-test, and Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-rank test were used for continuous variables depending on the distribution and variance of the data. The P<0.05 and corrected P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

The area and Q of TSs and JB on the symptomatic side were higher than those on the contralateral side in the JBWD group (TSs: Parea=0.004, Pflow=0.002; JB: Parea=0.034, Pflow=0.018). The area was larger and velocities were lower in the JBWD group at the TSs than the SSWD group (Parea=0.004, PVv-max=0.009, PVmax=0.021, PVavg=0.026), and velocities were higher at the distal TSs and SSs than the volunteer group (TSs: PVv-max=0.042, PVmax=0.046, PVavg=0.040; SSs: PVv-max=0.007, PVmax=0.001, PVavg=0.001). At the JB, the JBWD group also had higher Vv-max than the volunteer group (P=0.012). The occurrence rate of vortex at JB in the JBWD group was higher than both the JBWD and the volunteer groups (P=0.002<0.017 and P=0.009<0.017, respectively).

Conclusions

The blood flow of the intracranial venous sinus was different between the JBWD group and the SSWD group. The indicators that can differentiate include Vv-max, Vmax, Vavg, vortex, and TSs cross-sectional area.

Multiphysics Interaction Analysis of the Therapeutic Effects of the Sigmoid Sinus Wall Reconstruction in Patients with Venous Pulsatile Tinnitus

Sigmoid sinus wall dehiscence (SSWD) is an important etiology of venous pulsatile tinnitus (VPT) and is treated by sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction (SSWR). This study aimed to investigate the therapeutic effects of the different degrees of SSWR and the prognostic effect in patients with VPT. Personalized models of three patients with SSWD (control), 3/4SSWD, 1/2SSWD, 1/4SSWD, and 0SSWD were reconstructed. A multiphysics interaction approach was applied to elucidate the biomechanical and acoustic changes. Results revealed that after SSWR, the average pressure of venous vessel on the SSWD region reduced by 33.70 ± 12.53%, 35.86 ± 12.39%, and 39.70 ± 12.45% (mean ± SD) in three patients with 3/4SSWD, 1/2SSWD, and 1/4SSWD. The maximum displacement of the SSWR region reduced by 25.91 ± 30.20%, 37.20 ± 31.47%, 52.60 ± 34.66%, and 79.35 ± 18.13% (mean ± SD) in three patients with 3/4SSWD, 1/2SSWD, 1/4SSWD, and 0SSWD, with a magnitude approximately 10^-3 times that of the venous vessel in the SSWD region. The sound pressure level at the tympanum reduced by 23.72 ± 1.91%, 31.03 ± 14.40%, 45.62 ± 19.11%, and 128.46 ± 15.46% (mean ± SD). The SSWR region was still loaded with high stress in comparison to the surrounding region. The SSWR region of the temporal bone effectively shielded the high wall pressure and blocked the transmission of venous vessel vibration to the inner ear. Patients with inadequate SSWR still had residual VPT symptoms despite the remission of VPT symptoms. Complete SSWR could completely solve VPT issues. High-stress distribution of the SSWR region may be the cause of the recurrence of VPT symptoms.

Outcomes in Managing Vascular Tinnitus: Institutional Experience and Review of 6-Year Literature

To evaluate the outcomes in patients of vascular tinnitus managed at our institute. The clinical data of all patients diagnosed with pulsatile tinnitus from January 2014 to April 2022 and managed at AIIMS, Bhubaneswar, was retrospectively reviewed. The diagnosis, treatment and outcomes were analyzed. A 6-year literature review was performed from March 2015 to April 2021. Our series discusses managing eleven cases of vascular tinnitus with varied aetiology and their outcomes. Out of the eleven cases, eight patients underwent surgical or radiological intervention, and seven had complete resolution of symptoms. Of the eleven patients, three had partial resolution. The 6-year literature review revealed sigmoid and transverse sinus as the most common causative anatomical sites for pulsatile tinnitus. Amongst those who received an intervention, 83.56% of the patients had complete resolution of symptoms. Vascular tinnitus can be cured if the exact vessel causing it is localized. Clinical suspicion is based on the character of tinnitus and patient history. A careful evaluation of the head and neck sites for any vascular anomaly that can cause pulsatile tinnitus must be done. Radiology demonstrates treatable causes of it. It delineates the aberrant anatomical variations that can lead to this disturbing aetiology. Treatable causes are best addressed, and pathology should be taken care of. A multidisciplinary team comprising ENT surgeons, audiologists and interventional radiologists must identify and treat the pathology.

Influence of sigmoid plate and dura mater on vascular wall displacement, vibroacoustic/hydroacoustic sources characteristics, and frequency-loudness assessments of venous pulsatile tinnitus: A coupled-computational fluid dynamics study combining transcanal recording investigation

Investigations of pulsatile tinnitus (PT) caused by sigmoid sinus wall anomalies (SSWAs) using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) have recently increased in prevalence. However, accurate modeling of anatomical structures regarding sigmoid plate dehiscence and acoustic sources of PT remains lacking. This study incorporates coupled CFD techniques, micro-computed tomography, and scanning electron microscope to reveal the vibroacoustic and hydroacoustic sources and displacement characteristics of the transverse-sigmoid sinus system. Furthermore, the in vivo transcanal-recording technique combined with ipsilateral internal jugular vein compression was implemented to cross-reference the captured acoustic profile of PT with the calculated results. In this study, the transient state coupled CFD technique was used to calculate the vibroacoustic and hydroacoustic sources. The dehiscent sigmoid plate and periosteal dura mater were then reconstructed. The displacement characteristics and acoustic results were analyzed. The displacement of the vascular wall underneath the dehiscent area was 9.6 times larger than that of the sigmoid plate and 3,617 times smaller than that of the vascular wall without the overlying osseous structures. The peak amplitude of flow-induced vibroacoustic noise was 119.3 dB at 20.2 Hz measured at the transverse sinus. Within the observed 20–1,000 Hz frequency range, the largest peak amplitude of hydroacoustic noise was 80.0 dB at 20.2 Hz located at the jugular bulb region. The simulated results conformed with the in vivo acoustic profile which the major frequency of PT falls within 1,000 Hz. In conclusion, 1) the sigmoid plate and dura mater greatly impact vascular wall displacement, which should not be overlooked in CFD simulations. 2) By incorporating the transcanal recording technique with IJV compression test, the primary frequency of PT was found fluctuating below 1,000 Hz, which matches the frequency component simulated by the current CFD technique; amplitude-wise, however, the peak amplitude of in vivo pulse-synchronous somatosound measures approximately 10 dB, which is comparatively lesser than the CFD results and the subjectively perceived loudness of PT. Thus, the transmission pathway, intramastoid acoustic impedance/amplification effect, and the perceptive threshold of PT require further investigations to minimize the incidence of surgical failure.

Retroauricular/Transcranial Color-Coded Doppler Ultrasound Approach in Junction With Ipsilateral Neck Compression on Real-Time Hydroacoustic Variation of Venous Pulsatile Tinnitus

Alterations in dural venous sinus hemodynamics have recently been suggested as the major contributing factors in venous pulsatile tinnitus (PT). Nevertheless, little is known about the association between real-time alterations in hemodynamics and the subjective perception of venous PT. This study aimed to investigate the hydroacoustic correlations among diverticular vortices, mainstream sinus flow, and PT using various Doppler ultrasound techniques. Nineteen venous PT patients with protrusive diverticulum were recruited. The mainstream sinus and diverticular hemodynamics before and after ipsilateral internal jugular vein (IJV) compression were investigated using an innovative retroauricular color-coded Doppler (RCCD) method to examine the correlation between the disappearance of PT and hemodynamic alterations. To reveal the hydroacoustic characteristics of disparate segments of venous return, a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) technique combined with the transcranial color-coded Doppler method was performed. When the ipsilateral IJV was compressed, PT disappeared, as the mean velocity of mainstream sinus flow and diverticular vortex decreased by 51.2 and 50.6%, respectively. The vortex inside the diverticulum persisted in 18 of 19 subjects. The CFD simulation showed that the flow amplitude generated inside the transverse–sigmoid sinus was segmental, and the largest flow amplitude difference was 20.5 dB. The difference in flow amplitude between the mainstream sinus flow and the diverticular flow was less than 1 dB. In conclusion, the sensation of PT is closely associated with the flow of kinetic energy rather than the formation of a vortex, whereby the amplitude of PT is correlated to the magnitude of the flow velocity and pressure gradient. Additionally, the range of velocity reduction revealed by the RCCD method may serve as a presurgical individual baseline curative marker that may potentially optimize the surgical outcomes.

Evidence of air-conduction transmission pathway and strategized transtemporal operative techniques for venous pulsatile tinnitus: Combining water occlusion test and operative sensing applications

OBJECTIVES

(1) To establish evidence of the transmission pathway of venous pulsatile tinnitus (PT) associated with sigmoid sinus wall anomalies (SSWAs) and (2) quantify the efficacy of transtemporal surgery.

METHODS

This retrospective study included 33 surgical cases of PT associated with SSWAs and 15 controls with venous PT without SSWAs. Quantitative water occlusion test (q-WOT) and imaging data were acquired for preoperative evaluation prior to strategized transtemporal osteovascular reconstruction surgery. A condenser microphone and hydrophone were intraoperatively deployed to assess and monitor in vivo amplitude variations of the PT in eight participants.

RESULTS

A total of 23 (69.6%) participants with SSWA responded to the q-WOT with a median solution volume of 1.3 (1.1/1.6), which significantly differed from that observed in controls (p < 0.01). The change in the operative peak amplitude of the acoustic data was statistically significant (p < 0.01), from a median of 57.6 (55.5/57.9) dB SPL to 34.3 (33.4/38.8) dB SPL.

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative application of acoustic sensors revealed that PT associated with SSWAs is predominantly transmitted via the air-conduction pathway. If objective findings such as q-WOT and sensing applications suggest that the transmission of venous PT is involved in middle ear air conduction, the reconstruction technique should be prioritized; if less involvement of middle ear air-conduction is indicated, addressing flow pathologies may be imperative for resolving venous PT.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4.