Vitamin C in the prevention of nitrate tolerance

The effect of vitamin C on nitroglycerin-mediated vasodilation in individuals with and without the aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 polymorphism

AIMS

To mediate its pharmacodynamic effects, glyceryl trinitrate (GTN) requires bioactivation, by which it releases nitric oxide or a nitric oxide moiety. The exact mechanism of GTN bioactivation remains uncertain. Mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH-2) has been proposed as the primary enzyme responsible for this bioactivation process. Evidence for the importance of ALDH-2 in GTN bioactivation has been inconsistent, particularly in human models. An alternative hypothesis suggests that decreased ALDH-2 activity leads to accumulation of reactive cytotoxic aldehydes, which either inhibit the vasoactive product(s) of GTN or impair other enzymatic pathways involved in the bioactivation of GTN. We investigated the effect of supplemental vitamin C on vascular responses to GTN in healthy volunteers of East Asian descent, of whom 12 with and 12 without the ALDH-2 polymorphism participated.

METHODS

Subjects underwent 2 sequential brachial artery infusions of GTN at rates of 5, 11 and 22 nmol/min, separated by a 30-min washout period. The GTN infusions were carried out in the presence and absence of vitamin C using a randomized, crossover design. Venous occlusion plethysmography was used to measure forearm blood flow responses to GTN.

RESULTS

Compared to subjects with functional ALDH-2, the variant group exhibited blunted hemodynamic responses to intra-arterial GTN infusions, although this reduction in response was not statically significant. Contrary to our hypothesis, vitamin C had an inhibitory effect on GTN mediated vasodilation as compared to GTN during saline in both groups.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that vitamin C did not augment the acute vascular response to GTN in those with the ALDH-2 polymorphism.

Berberine Reverses Nitroglycerin Tolerance through Suppressing Protein Kinase C Alpha Activity in Vascular Smooth Muscle Cells

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of berberine on nitroglycerin (NTG) tolerance and explore the underlying mechanism involved.

METHODS

NTG tolerance was induced by pre-exposure of Sprague-Dawley rat aortas to NTG in vitro or by pretreating Sprague-Dawley rats with an NTG patch in vivo. The aortas were pre-treated with berberine or PKC inhibitors for different durations of time before induction of NTG tolerance. NTG-induced vasorelaxations was measured on wire myograph. Primary vascular smooth cells (VSMCs) were used to dissect the underlying mechanism of berberine-induced inhibition of NTG tolerance.

RESULTS

NTG tolerance induced by either prior exposure of rat aortas to NTG in vitro or pretreatment with an NTG patch in vivo was reversed by co-treatment with berberine, as well as the inhibitors of protein kinase C (PKC) and protein kinase C alpha (PKCα). The mechanistic study revealed that PKCα participated in the development of NTG tolerance as NTG increased the activity of PKCα with enriched PKCα membrane localization and elevated phosphorylation of PKCα in VSMCs, which was reversed by berberine or PKCα inhibitors.

CONCLUSION

This study is probably the first demonstration that berberine reverses NTG tolerance through inhibiting PKCα activity in VSMCs and PKCα is an important contributor to the development of NTG tolerance. These new findings suggest that berberine could become a promising drug for prevention of NTG tolerance and that targeting PKCα in VSMCs is likely to be a potential therapeutic strategy for reversal of NTG tolerance in blood vessels.

Organic nitrates and nitrate tolerance--state of the art and future developments

The hemodynamic and antiischemic effects of nitroglycerin (GTN) are lost upon chronic administration due to the rapid development of nitrate tolerance. The mechanism of this phenomenon has puzzled several generations of scientists, but recent findings have led to novel hypotheses. The formation of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species in the mitochondria and the subsequent inhibition of the nitrate-bioactivating enzyme mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH-2) appear to play a central role, at least for GTN, that is, bioactivated by ALDH-2. Importantly, these findings provide the opportunity to reconcile the two "traditional" hypotheses of nitrate tolerance, that is, the one postulating a decreased bioactivation and the concurrent one suggesting a role of oxidative stress. Furthermore, recent animal and human experimental studies suggest that the organic nitrates are not a homogeneous group but demonstrate a broad diversity with regard to induction of vascular dysfunction, oxidative stress, and other side effects. In the past, attempts to avoid nitrate-induced side effects have focused on administration schedules that would allow a "nitrate-free interval"; in the future, the role of co-therapies with antioxidant compounds and of activation of endogeneous protective pathways such as the heme oxygenase 1 (HO-1) will need to be explored. However, the development of new nitrates, for example, tolerance-free aminoalkyl nitrates or combination of nitrate groups with established cardiovascular drugs like ACE inhibitors or AT(1)-receptor blockers (hybrid molecules) may be of great clinical interest.

Nitrite anion: the key intermediate in alkyl nitrates degradative mechanism

Alkyl nitrates are metabolized in vitro to yield nitric oxide, and thiol groups have long been considered necessary cofactors. Here, we report evidence that no reaction between thiols and alkyl nitrates takes place in vitro, but stronger reducing agents, such as iron(II) derivatives, are necessary; alkoxy radicals and nitrite anions are the reaction intermediates. The latter, in slightly acidic conditions, can nitrosate thiols to the corresponding S-nitrosothiols, the real NO releasers.

Role of endogenous hydrogen peroxide in the development of nitrate tolerance

The present study was designed to test the hypothesis that hydrogen peroxide plays a role in the development of nitrate tolerance. Isolated rat aortic rings were suspended in organ chambers for isometric tension recording. The rings were incubated with (tolerant) and without (control) nitroglycerin (10(-4) M) for 90 min, followed by repeated rinsing for 1 h. Hydrogen peroxide release in control and tolerant tissues was measured fluorimetrically using amplex red. Nitroglycerin (10(-9)-10(-4) M) caused concentration-dependent relaxations in control (-logEC50=7.15+/-0.1) and tolerant rings (-logEC50=5.83+/-0.1) contracted with norepinephrine. Nitrate tolerance was evident by a >20-fold rightward shift in the nitroglycerin concentration-response curve in tissues exposed previously to nitroglycerin for 90 min. Incubation of the rings with the superoxide dismutase (SOD)-mimetic, tempol (10(-4) M), during the 90-min exposure period to nitroglycerin caused a leftward shift in the nitroglycerin concentration-response curve in tolerant rings (-logEC50=6.84+/-0.2), but had no effect on the response to nitroglycerin in control rings. Treatment of the rings with catalase (1200 U/ml) or ebselen (1.5x10(-5) M), a glutathione peroxidase-mimetic, during the 90-min exposure period to nitroglycerin resulted in a further rightward shift in the nitroglycerin concentration-response curve in tolerant rings (-logEC50=5.41+/-0.1 and 4.98+/-0.1; catalase and ebselen respectively), without altering the response to nitroglycerin in control rings. In the presence of catalase, the effect of tempol on nitrate tolerance was abolished (-logEC50=5.46+/-0.1). Hydrogen peroxide release was reduced by approximately 64% in nitrate tolerant tissues when compared to control. The decrease in hydrogen peroxide release was completely reversed by treatment with tempol, whereas treatment with ebselen caused a further decrease in hydrogen peroxide release in nitrate tolerant tissues. Addition of hydrogen peroxide (3x10(-5) M) to nitrate tolerant rings caused a leftward shift in the nitroglycerin concentration-response curve in tolerant rings (-logEC50=7.18+/-0.3), but had no effect on the response to nitroglycerin in control rings. These results suggest that nitrate tolerance is associated with decreased endogenous formation of hydrogen peroxide, which attenuates nitrate tolerance development. SOD-mimetics may reduce nitrate tolerance, in part, by increasing the formation of hydrogen peroxide.

Vitamin E deficiency accelerates nitrate tolerance via a decrease in cardiac P450 expression and increased oxidative stress

Organic nitrates, such as nitroglycerin (NTG), have been used to relieve the symptoms of angina pectoris. However, their biochemical mechanisms of action, particularly in relation to the development of tolerance, are incompletely defined. It has been reported that supplemental antioxidants such as vitamin E attenuate the development of nitrate tolerance. Therefore, we examined the role of vitamin E in the regulation of nitrate tolerance. Continuous NTG infusion induced nitrate tolerance in rats after 48 h, and vitamin E concentrations decreased in a time-dependent manner in tissues and plasma. Vitamin E supplementation (0.5 g/kg diet) maintained higher concentrations of vitamin E during NTG infusion. The onset and extent of the tolerance, estimated by the decrease in blood pressure following NTG bolus injection during the infusion of NTG, were accentuated in the vitamin E-deficient group. Vitamin E supplementation inhibited nitrate tolerance 48 h after NTG infusion. Cardiac P450 expression (CYP1A2) assessed by immunoblotting, markedly decreased 48 h after NTG administration in control rats. The supplementation of vitamin E significantly attenuated the decrease in P450. Treatment of NTG enhanced vascular superoxide production (L-012 chemiluminescence, DHE fluorescence). The peak of lipid peroxidation and free radical generation in the heart was reached before tolerance developed. In contrast, vitamin E-deficient hearts had lower P450 expression and higher free radical generation than control hearts. To evaluate other vitamin E-inhibitable mechanisms of nitrate tolerance, we studied the NO-cGMP pathway. NTG markedly reduced the vasodilator-stimulated phosphoprotein (VASP) serine 239 phosphorylation (specific substrate of cGMP-activated protein kinase I; cGK-I) in tolerant hearts. Vitamin E inhibited the depletion of pVASP. In conclusion, because continuous NTG infusion causes vitamin E depletion as well as nitrate tolerance, vitamin E deficiency may further accelerate nitrate tolerance via an increase in oxidative stress, the reduced bioconversion because of decreased P450 expression, and impairment of the NO/cGMP pathway in tolerant heart tissues.

Oxidative stress and mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase activity: a comparison of pentaerythritol tetranitrate with other organic nitrates

Mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH-2) was recently identified to be essential for the bioactivation of glyceryl trinitrate (GTN). Here we assessed whether other organic nitrates are bioactivated by a similar mechanism. The ALDH-2 inhibitor benomyl reduced the vasodilator potency, but not the efficacy, of GTN, pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN), and pentaerythritol trinitrate in phenylephrine-constricted rat aorta, whereas vasodilator responses to isosorbide dinitrate, isosorbide-5-mononitrate, pentaerythritol dinitrate, pentaerythritol mononitrate, and the endothelium-dependent vasodilator acetylcholine were not affected. Likewise, benomyl decreased GTN- and PETN-elicited phosphorylation of the cGMP-activated protein kinase substrate vasodilator-stimulated phosphoprotein (VASP) but not that elicited by other nitrates. The vasodilator potency of organic nitrates correlated with their potency to inhibit ALDH-2 dehydrogenase activity in mitochondria from rat heart and increase mitochondrial superoxide formation, as detected by chemiluminescence. In contrast, mitochondrial ALDH-2 esterase activity was not affected by PETN and its metabolites, whereas it was inhibited by benomyl, GTN applied in vitro and in vivo, and some sulfhydryl oxidants. The bioactivation-related metabolism of GTN to glyceryl-1,2-dinitrate by isolated RAW macrophages was reduced by the ALDH-2 inhibitors benomyl and daidzin, as well as by GTN at concentrations >1 microM. We conclude that mitochondrial ALDH-2, specifically its esterase activity, is required for the bioactivation of the organic nitrates with high vasodilator potency, such as GTN and PETN, but not for the less potent nitrates. It is interesting that ALDH-2 esterase activity was inhibited by GTN only, not by the other nitrates tested. This difference might explain why GTN elicits mitochondrial superoxide formation and nitrate tolerance with the highest potency.

Escape from tolerance of organic nitrate by induction of cytochrome P450

The mechanism of organic nitrate tolerance is poorly defined. We studied the rat P450-catalyzed conversion of organic nitrate to nitric oxide (NO) by purified P450 isoforms relationship between P450 expression and nitrate tolerance following continuous infusion of organic nitrates in rats. The hypotensive effect of an nitroglycerin (NTG) bolus injection was abolished in rats that had been previously provided a continuous 48 h infusion of NTG. This effect was accompanied by a gradual but marked decrease in plasma and urinary nitrate levels following a peak at 18-24 h. Nitrate tolerance was reversible; the decline in the hypotensive effect and P450 levels observed after 2 d of continuous infusion was followed by restoration to control levels 2 d after cessation of the infusion. Similarly, the hypotensive action disappeared in P450-depleted, and -inhibited rats. At 48 h after infusion, NTG-induced NO generation of the vessels increased in acetone (a P450 inducer) -pretreated rats. The appearance and disappearance of P450 paralleled the conversion of organic nitrates to NO. Our observations indicate that nitrate tolerance is in large part the result of decreased P450 expression and activity. Interventions that maintain or increase P450 activity may be a strategy to provide relief from ischemic conditions in humans.