Tolerance of protein folding to a circular permutation in a PDZ domain

Protein engineering using circular permutation - structure, function, stability, and applications

Protein engineering is important for creating novel variants from natural proteins, enabling a wide range of applications. Approaches such as rational design and directed evolution are routinely used to make new protein variants. Computational tools like de novo design can introduce new protein folds. Expanding the amino acid repertoire to include unnatural amino acids with non-canonical side chains in vitro by native chemical ligation and in vivo via codon expansion methods broadens sequence and structural possibilities. Circular permutation (CP) is an invaluable approach to redesigning a protein by rearranging the amino acid sequence, where the connectivity of the secondary structural elements is altered without changing the overall structure of the protein. Artificial CP proteins (CPs) are employed in various applications such as biocatalysis, sensing of small molecules by fluorescence, genome editing, ligand-binding protein switches, and optogenetic engineering. Many studies have shown that CP can lead to either reduced or enhanced stability or catalytic efficiency. The effects of CP on a protein's energy landscape cannot be predicted a priori. Thus, it is important to understand how CP can affect the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of a protein. In this review, we discuss the discovery and advancement of techniques to create protein CP, and existing reviews on CP. We delve into the plethora of biological applications for designed CP proteins. We subsequently discuss the experimental and computational reports on the effects of CP on the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities of proteins of various topologies. An understanding of the various aspects of CP will allow the reader to design robust CP proteins for their specific purposes.

Circular permutation at azurin's active site slows down its folding

Circular permutation (CP) is a technique by which the primary sequence of a protein is rearranged to create new termini. The connectivity of the protein is altered but the overall protein structure generally remains unperturbed. Understanding the effect of CP can help design robust proteins for numerous applications such as in genetic engineering, optoelectronics, and improving catalytic activity. Studies on different protein topologies showed that CP usually affects protein stability as well as unfolding rates. Though a significant number of proteins contain metals or other cofactors, reports of metalloprotein CPs are rare. Thus, we chose a bacterial metalloprotein, azurin, and its CP within the metal-binding site (cpF114). We studied the stabilities, folding, and unfolding rates of apo- and Zn2+-bound CP azurin using fluorescence and circular dichroism. The introduced CP had destabilizing effects on the protein. Also, the folding of the Zn2+-CP protein was much slower than that of the Zn2+-WT or apo-protein. We compared this study to our previously reported azurin-cpN42, where we had observed an equilibrium and kinetic intermediate. cpF114 exhibits an apparent two-state equilibrium unfolding but has an off-pathway kinetic intermediate. Our study hinted at CP as a method to modify the energy landscape of proteins to alter their folding pathways. WT azurin, being a faster folder, may have evolved to optimize the folding rate of metal-bound protein compared to its CPs, albeit all of them have the same structure and function. Our study underscores that protein sequence and protein termini positions are crucial for metalloproteins. TOC Figure. (Top) Zn2+-azurin WT structure (PDB code: 1E67) and 2-D topology diagram of Zn2+-cpF114 azurin. (Bottom) Cartoon diagram representing folding (red arrows) and unfolding (blue arrows) of apo- and Zn2+- WT and cpF114 azurins. The width of the arrows represents the rate of the corresponding processes.

Metal-binding and circular permutation-dependent thermodynamic and kinetic stability of azurin

Native topology is known to determine the folding kinetics and the energy landscape of proteins. Furthermore, the circular permutation (CP) of proteins alters the order of the secondary structure connectivity while retaining the three-dimensional structure, making it an elegant and powerful approach to altering native topology. Previous studies elucidated the influence of CP in proteins with different folds such as Greek key β-barrel, β-sandwich, β-α-β, and all α-Greek key. CP mainly affects the protein stability and unfolding kinetics, while folding kinetics remains mostly unaltered. However, the effect of CP on metalloproteins is yet to be elaborately studied. The active site of metalloproteins poses an additional complexity in studying protein folding. Here, we investigate a CP variant (cpN42) of azurin-in both metal-free and metal-bound (holo) forms. As observed earlier in other proteins, apo-forms of wild-type (WT) and cpN42 fold with similar rates. In contrast, zinc-binding accelerates the folding of WT but decelerates the folding of cpN42. On zinc-binding, the spontaneous folding rate of WT increases by >250 times that of cpN42, which is unprecedented and the highest for any CP to date. On the other hand, zinc-binding reduces the spontaneous unfolding rate of cpN42 by ~100 times, making the WT and CP azurins unfold at similar rates. Our study demonstrates metal binding as a novel way to modulate the unfolding and folding rates of CPs compared to their WT counterparts. We hope our study increases the understanding of the effect of CP on the folding mechanism and energy landscape of metalloproteins.

The Conformational Plasticity Vista of PDZ Domains

The PDZ domain (PSD95-Discs large-ZO1) is a widespread modular domain present in the living organisms. A prevalent function in the PDZ family is to serve as scaffolding and adaptor proteins connecting multiple partners in signaling pathways. An explanation of the flexible functionality in this domain family, based just on a static perspective of the structure-activity relationship, might fall short. More dynamic and conformational aspects in the protein fold can be the reasons for such functionality. Folding studies indeed showed an ample and malleable folding landscape for PDZ domains where multiple intermediate states were experimentally detected. Allosteric phenomena that resemble energetic coupling between residues have also been found in PDZ domains. Additionally, several PDZ domains are modulated by post-translational modifications, which introduce conformational switches that affect binding. Altogether, the ability to connect diverse partners might arise from the intrinsic plasticity of the PDZ fold.

Specificity in PDZ-peptide interaction networks: Computational analysis and review

Globular PDZ domains typically serve as protein-protein interaction modules that regulate a wide variety of cellular functions via recognition of short linear motifs (SLiMs). Often, PDZ mediated-interactions are essential components of macromolecular complexes, and disruption affects the entire scaffold. Due to their roles as linchpins in trafficking and signaling pathways, PDZ domains are attractive targets: both for controlling viral pathogens, which bind PDZ domains and hijack cellular machinery, as well as for developing therapies to combat human disease. However, successful therapeutic interventions that avoid off-target effects are a challenge, because each PDZ domain interacts with a number of cellular targets, and specific binding preferences can be difficult to decipher. Over twenty-five years of research has produced a wealth of data on the stereochemical preferences of individual PDZ proteins and their binding partners. Currently the field lacks a central repository for this information. Here, we provide this important resource and provide a manually curated, comprehensive list of the 271 human PDZ domains. We use individual domain, as well as recent genomic and proteomic, data in order to gain a holistic view of PDZ domains and interaction networks, arguing this knowledge is critical to optimize targeting selectivity and to benefit human health.

Structural Basis of Design and Engineering for Advanced Plant Optogenetics

In optogenetics, light-sensitive proteins are specifically expressed in target cells and light is used to precisely control the activity of these proteins at high spatiotemporal resolution. Optogenetics initially used naturally occurring photoreceptors to control neural circuits, but has expanded to include carefully designed and engineered photoreceptors. Several optogenetic constructs are based on plant photoreceptors, but their application to plant systems has been limited. Here, we present perspectives on the development of plant optogenetics, considering different levels of design complexity. We discuss how general principles of light-driven signal transduction can be coupled with approaches for engineering protein folding to develop novel optogenetic tools. Finally, we explore how the use of computation, networks, circular permutation, and directed evolution could enrich optogenetics.

Structural Determinants of Misfolding in Multidomain Proteins

Recent single molecule experiments, using either atomic force microscopy (AFM) or Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) have shown that multidomain proteins containing tandem repeats may form stable misfolded structures. Topology-based simulation models have been used successfully to generate models for these structures with domain-swapped features, fully consistent with the available data. However, it is also known that some multidomain protein folds exhibit no evidence for misfolding, even when adjacent domains have identical sequences. Here we pose the question: what factors influence the propensity of a given fold to undergo domain-swapped misfolding? Using a coarse-grained simulation model, we can reproduce the known propensities of multidomain proteins to form domain-swapped misfolds, where data is available. Contrary to what might be naively expected based on the previously described misfolding mechanism, we find that the extent of misfolding is not determined by the relative folding rates or barrier heights for forming the domains present in the initial intermediates leading to folded or misfolded structures. Instead, it appears that the propensity is more closely related to the relative stability of the domains present in folded and misfolded intermediates. We show that these findings can be rationalized if the folded and misfolded domains are part of the same folding funnel, with commitment to one structure or the other occurring only at a relatively late stage of folding. Nonetheless, the results are still fully consistent with the kinetic models previously proposed to explain misfolding, with a specific interpretation of the observed rate coefficients. Finally, we investigate the relation between interdomain linker length and misfolding, and propose a simple alchemical model to predict the propensity for domain-swapped misfolding of multidomain proteins.

The Chlamydia trachomatis Protease CPAF Contains a Cryptic PDZ-Like Domain with Similarity to Human Cell Polarity and Tight Junction PDZ-Containing Proteins

The need for more effective anti-chlamydial therapeutics has sparked research efforts geared toward further understanding chlamydial pathogenesis mechanisms. Recent studies have implicated the secreted chlamydial serine protease, chlamydial protease-like activity factor (CPAF) as potentially important for chlamydial pathogenesis. By mechanisms that remain to be elucidated, CPAF is directed to a discrete group of substrates, which are subsequently cleaved or degraded. While inspecting the previously solved CPAF crystal structure, we discovered that CPAF contains a cryptic N-terminal PSD95 Dlg ZO-1 (PDZ) domain spanning residues 106–212 (CPAF^106-212). This PDZ domain is unique in that it bears minimal sequence similarity to canonical PDZ-forming sequences and displays little sequence and structural similarity to known chlamydial PDZ domains. We show that the CPAF^106-212 sequence is homologous to PDZ domains of human tight junction proteins.

The response of Greek key proteins to changes in connectivity depends on the nature of their secondary structure

What governs the balance between connectivity and topology in regulating the mechanism of protein folding? We use circular permutation to vary the order of the helices in the all-α Greek key protein FADD (Fas-associated death domain) to investigate this question. Unlike all-β Greek key proteins, where changes in the order of secondary structure cause a shift in the folding nucleus, the position of the nucleus in FADD is unchanged, even when permutation reduces the complexity significantly. We suggest that this is because local helical contacts are so dominant that permutation has little effect on the entropic cost of forming the folding nucleus whereas, in all-β Greek key proteins, all interactions in the nucleus are long range. Thus, the type of secondary structure modulates the sensitivity of proteins to changes in connectivity.

Design of a PDZbody, a bivalent binder of the E6 protein from human papillomavirus

Chronic infection by high risk human papillomavirus (HPV) strains may lead to cancer. Expression of the two viral oncoproteins E6 and E7 is largely responsible for immortalization of infected cells. The HPV E6 is a small (approximately 150 residues) two domain protein that interacts with a number of cellular proteins including the ubiquitin ligase E6-associated protein (E6AP) and several PDZ-domain containing proteins. Our aim was to design a high-affinity binder for HPV E6 by linking two of its cellular targets. First, we improved the affinity of the second PDZ domain from SAP97 for the C-terminus of HPV E6 from the high-risk strain HPV18 using phage display. Second, we added a helix from E6AP to the N-terminus of the optimized PDZ variant, creating a chimeric bivalent binder, denoted PDZbody. Full-length HPV E6 proteins are difficult to express and purify. Nevertheless, we could measure the affinity of the PDZbody for E6 from another high-risk strain, HPV16 (Kd = 65 nM). Finally, the PDZbody was used to co-immunoprecipitate E6 protein from HPV18-immortalized HeLa cells, confirming the interaction between PDZbody and HPV18 E6 in a cellular context.

Network analysis of circular permutations in multidomain proteins reveals functional linkages for uncharacterized proteins

Various studies have implicated different multidomain proteins in cancer. However, there has been little or no detailed study on the role of circular multidomain proteins in the general problem of cancer or on specific cancer types. This work represents an initial attempt at investigating the potential for predicting linkages between known cancer-associated proteins with uncharacterized or hypothetical multidomain proteins, based primarily on circular permutation (CP) relationships. First, we propose an efficient algorithm for rapid identification of both exact and approximate CPs in multidomain proteins. Using the circular relations identified, we construct networks between multidomain proteins, based on which we perform functional annotation of multidomain proteins. We then extend the method to construct subnetworks for selected cancer subtypes, and performed prediction of potential link-ages between uncharacterized multidomain proteins and the selected cancer types. We include practical results showing the performance of the proposed methods.

Energetic pathway sampling in a protein interaction domain

The affinity and specificity of protein-ligand interactions are influenced by energetic crosstalk within the protein domain. However, the molecular details of such intradomain allostery are still unclear. Here, we have experimentally detected and computationally predicted interaction pathways in the postsynaptic density 95/discs large/zonula occludens 1 (PDZ)-peptide ligand model system using wild-type and circularly permuted PDZ proteins. The circular permutant introduced small perturbations in the tertiary structure and a concomitant rewiring of allosteric pathways, allowing us to describe how subtle changes may reshape energetic signaling. The results were analyzed in the context of other members of the PDZ family, which were found to contain distinct interaction pathways for different peptide ligands. The data reveal a fascinating scenario whereby several energetic pathways are sampled within one single domain and distinct pathways are activated by specific protein ligands.

Single molecule unfolding and stretching of protein domains inside a solid-state nanopore by electric field

Single molecule methods have provided a significantly new look at the behavior of biomolecules in both equilibrium and non-equilibrium conditions. Most notable are the stretching experiments performed by atomic force microscopes and laser tweezers. Here we present an alternative single molecule method that can unfold a protein domain, observed at electric fields greater than 10(6) V/m, and is fully controllable by the application of increasing voltages across the membrane of the pore. Furthermore this unfolding mechanism is characterized by measuring both the residence time of the protein within the nanopore and the current blockade. The unfolding data supports a gradual unfolding mechanism rather than the cooperative transition observed by classical urea denaturation experiments. Lastly it is shown that the voltage-mediated unfolding is a function of the stability of the protein by comparing two mutationally destabilized variants of the protein.