Clinical feasibility of NGS liquid biopsy analysis in NSCLC patients

Higher TP53 somatic mutation prevalence from liquid biopsy analysis in ever smoker non-small-cell lung cancer patients

OBJECTIVE

Cigarette smoking is a primary risk factor, linked to 80% of LC deaths. TP53, a key gene, is implicated in various cancers, with TP53 alterations in 36.7% of cancers. This research aims to investigate TP53 mutations detected in NSCLC patients by liquid biopsy and explore the relationship between these mutations and smoking history.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

The study enrolled a total of 340 patients diagnosed with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). For sequencing, the Illumina NextSeq 500 system was utilized. The oncogenicity of the variants was assessed according to the ClinGen/CGC/VICC SOP and the variants were categorized into four tiers according to AMP/ASCO/CAP.

RESULTS

The most common mutations were in TP53 (48.7%), followed by EGFR, PIK3CA, and PTEN. Missense mutations were frequent, with TP53 and EGFR having higher rates in ever-smokers. No indels or complex mutations were found in ever-smokers. Patient age ranged from 20 to 86 years. Tier I-II variants were more common in ever-smokers, while Tier III variants were prevalent in never-smokers. TP53 mutations were more frequent in ever-smokers, showing a strong association with smoking. Domain distribution showed differences in PIK3CA. Transversion/transition ratios varied by gene and smoking status.

DISCUSSION

The presence of TP53 mutations is strongly associated with both cigarette smoking and elevated Tv/Ti ratios. The tier status of TP53, EGFR, and PTEN variants does not show a specific domain distribution, but interesting associations are observed between the tier status and domain distribution in PIK3CA variants. Therefore, further comprehensive investigations are needed to explore this entity, as well as the underlying factors contributing to the increased Tv/Ti rates in the TP53 gene. Such research will provide deeper insights into the genetic alterations associated with smoking and tumor heterogeneity, ultimately aiding in the development of targeted therapies.

Liquid biopsy in non-small cell lung cancer: a meta-analysis of state-of-the-art and future perspectives

Introduction: To date, tissue biopsy represents the gold standard for characterizing non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC), however, the complex architecture of the disease has introduced the need for new investigative approaches, such as liquid biopsy. Indeed, DNA analyzed in liquid biopsy is much more representative of tumour heterogeneity. Materials and methods: We performed a meta-analysis of 17 selected papers, to attest to the diagnostic performance of liquid biopsy in identifying EGFR mutations in NSCLC. Results: In the overall studies, we found a sensitivity of 0.59, specificity of 0.96 and diagnostic odds ratio of 24,69. Since we noticed a high heterogeneity among different papers, we also performed the meta-analysis in separate subsets of papers, divided by 1) stage of disease, 2) experimental design and 3) method of mutation detection. Liquid biopsy has the highest sensitivity/specificity in high-stage tumours, and prospective studies are more reliable than retrospective ones in terms of sensitivity and specificity, both NGS and PCR-based techniques can be used to detect tumour DNA in liquid biopsy. Discussion: Overall, liquid biopsy has the potential to help the management of NSCLC, but at present the non-homogeneous literature data, lack of optimal detection methods, together with relatively high costs make its applicability in routine diagnostics still challenging.

Detection of KRAS mutation using plasma samples in non-small-cell lung cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

The aim of this study was to investigate the diagnostic accuracy of KRAS mutation detection using plasma sample of patients with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

Methods

Databases of Pubmed, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science were searched for studies detecting KRAS mutation in paired tissue and plasma samples of patients with NSCLC. Data were extracted from each eligible study and analyzed using MetaDiSc and STATA.

Results

After database searching and screening of the studies with pre-defined criteria, 43 eligible studies were identified and relevant data were extracted. After pooling the accuracy data from 3341 patients, the pooled sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic odds ratio were 71%, 94%, and 59.28, respectively. Area under curve of summary receiver operating characteristic curve was 0.8883. Subgroup analysis revealed that next-generation sequencing outperformed PCR-based techniques in detecting KRAS mutation using plasma sample of patients with NSCLC, with sensitivity, specificity, and diagnostic odds ratio of 73%, 94%, and 82.60, respectively.

Conclusion

Compared to paired tumor tissue sample, plasma sample showed overall good performance in detecting KRAS mutation in patients with NSCLC, which could serve as good surrogate when tissue samples are not available.

Surveillance of cfDNA Hot Spot Mutations in NSCLC Patients during Disease Progression

Non-small cell cancer (NSCLC) has been identified with a great variation of mutations that can be surveyed during disease progression. The aim of the study was to identify and monitor lung cancer-specific mutations incidence in cell-free DNA as well as overall plasma cell-free DNA load by means of targeted next-generation sequencing. Sequencing libraries were prepared from cell-free DNA (cfDNA) isolated from 72 plasma samples of 41 patients using the Oncomine Lung cfDNA panel covering hot spot regions of 11 genes. Sequencing was performed with the Ion Torrent™ Ion S5™ system. Four genes were detected with highest mutation incidence: KRAS (43.9% of all cases), followed by ALK (36.6%), TP53 (31.7%), and PIK3CA (29.3%). Seven patients had co-occurring KRAS + TP53 (6/41, 14.6%) or KRAS + PIK3CA (7/41, 17.1%) mutations. Moreover, the mutational status of TP53 as well an overall cell-free DNA load were confirmed to be predictors of poor progression-free survival (HR = 2.5 [0.8-7.7]; p = 0.029 and HR = 2.3 [0.9-5.5]; p = 0.029, respectively) in NSCLC patients. In addition, TP53 mutation status significantly predicts shorter overall survival (HR = 3.4 [1.2-9.7]; p < 0.001). We demonstrated that TP53 mutation incidence as well as a cell-free DNA load can be used as biomarkers for NSCLC monitoring and can help to detect the disease progression prior to radiological confirmation of the status.

Assessment of Barriers and Challenges to Screening, Diagnosis, and Biomarker Testing in Early-Stage Lung Cancer

Management of lung cancer has transformed over the past decade and is no longer considered a singular disease as it now has multiple sub-classifications based on molecular markers. The current treatment paradigm requires a multidisciplinary approach. One of the most important facets of lung cancer outcomes however relies on early detection. Early detection has become crucial, and recent effects have shown success in lung cancer screening programs and early detection. In this narrative review, we evaluate low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) screening and how this screening modality may be underutilized. The barriers to broader implementation of LDCT screening is also explored as well as approaches to address these barriers. Current developments in diagnosis, biomarkers, and molecular testing in early-stage lung cancer are evaluated as well. Improving approaches to screening and early detection can ultimately lead to improved outcomes for patients with lung cancer.

Feasibility of Comprehensive Genomic Profiling (CGP) in Real-Life Clinical Practice

In advanced or metastatic settings, Comprehensive Genomic Profiling (CGP) allows the evaluation of thousands of gene alterations with the goal of offering new opportunities for personalized treatment in solid tumors. This study evaluated the CGP Success Rate in a real-life cohort of 184 patients enrolled in a prospective clinical trial. CGP data were compared with the routine molecular testing strategy adopted in-house. Sample age, tumor area, and the percentage of tumor nuclei were recorded for CGP analysis. We found that 150/184 (81.5%) samples resulted in satisfying CGP reports. The CGP Success Rate was higher in samples from surgical specimens (96.7%) and in specimens that had been stored (sample age) for less than six months (89.4%). Among the inconclusive CGP reports, 7/34 (20.6%) were optimal samples, according to CGP sample requirements. Moreover, with the in-house molecular testing approach, we could obtain clinically relevant molecular data in 25/34 (73.5%) samples that had inconclusive CGP reports. In conclusion, despite the fact that CGP offers specific therapeutical options in selected patients, our data suggest that the standard molecular testing strategy should not be replaced in routine molecular profiling.

Sputum cell-free DNA for detection of alterations of multiple driver genes in lung adenocarcinoma

BACKGROUND

Sputum cell-free DNA (cfDNA) has been confirmed to be a valued surrogate sample for detection of EGFR mutations in patients with lung adenocarcinoma (LAC). Whether it is suitable for detection of mutations of multiple driver genes has not been reported.

METHODS

A total of 83 patients with LAC were enrolled and their sputum and paired tumor samples were collected. A next-generation sequencing (NGS)-based 10-gene panel was used to test sputum supernatant-derived cfDNA and paired tumor DNA. The sputum sediments were used for cytological evaluation.

RESULTS

The total positive rates of hotspot mutations of the 10 driver genes in sputum cfDNA and matched tissue samples were 65.1% and 77.1%, respectively. The overall detection sensitivity of variants in sputum cfDNA was 81.3% (95% confidence interval [CI], 69.2%, 89.5%) and the specificity was 100% (95% CI, 79.1%, 100%). The sensitivities of testing sputum cfDNA from patients with stage IIIB-IV was 87.0% (95% CI, 74.5%, 94.1%); the sensitivities of testing sputum cfDNA from patients with malignant sputum was 92.3% (95% CI, 78.0%, 98.0%); and the sensitivity of testing sputum cfDNA from patients with malignant sputum in stage IIIB-IV were 94.1% (95% CI, 78.9%, 99.0%).

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that sputum cfDNA were successfully used for the detection of multiple driver genes by NGS. Sputum cfDNA could be a valuable surrogate clinical sample for all-in-one test of mutations to guide target therapies, especially for patients with advanced LAC and malignant sputum.

Application of ddPCR in detection of the status and abundance of EGFR T790M mutation in the plasma samples of non-small cell lung cancer patients

Background/Objective

The third-generation epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) -tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKIs), such as osimertinib, designed for targeting the acquired drug-resistant mutation of EGFR T790M, was approved as the first-line therapy for advanced EGFR-mutated non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Thus, detection of the EGFR T790M mutation for NSCLC is crucial. However, tissue samples are often difficult to obtain, especially in patients at advanced stages. This study assessed the performances of droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) and next-generation sequencing (NGS) in detecting EGFR T790M status and abundance in the plasma ctDNA samples of patients with NSCLC. We also explored the association between T790M status and abundance and the response to third-generation EGFR-TKIs.

Methods

A total of 201 plasma samples with matched tissues, 821 plasma samples, and 56 patients who received third-generation EGFR-TKIs with response evaluation were included in this study. ddPCR and NGS were used to detect the mutation status and abundance of T790M in the tissues and/or blood samples.

Results

The results showed that the sensitivity and the specificity of EGFR T790M mutation status detected by ddPCR in plasma samples were 81.82% and 91.85%, respectively, compared with the tissue samples, with a consistency coefficient of 0.740. Among the 821 plasma samples, the positive rates of EGFR T790M detected by ddPCR and NGS were 34.2% (281/821) and 22.5% (185/821), respectively. With NGS results as the reference, the sensitivity and the specificity of ddPCR were 100% and 84.91%, respectively, and the consistency coefficient of the two methods was 0.717. In addition, we found that a higher EGFR T790M abundance was linked to a higher treatment response rate to the third-generation EGFR-TKIs regardless of the classification of the median value of 0.43% (P = 0.016) or average value of 3.16% (P = 0.010).

Conclusion

Taking these data together, this study reveals that ddPCR is an alternatively potent method for the detection of EGFR T790M in the plasma samples of NSCLC patients.

Diagnostic accuracy of circulating free DNA testing for the detection of KRAS mutations in non-small cell lung cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog (KRAS) gene encodes a GTPase that acts as a molecular switch for intracellular signal transduction, promoting cell growth and proliferation. Mutations in the KRAS gene represent important biomarkers for NSCLC targeted therapy. However, detection of KRAS mutations in tissues has shown some limitations. During the last years, analyses of circulating free DNA (cfDNA) has emerged as an alternative and minimally invasive, approach to investigate tumor molecular changes. Here, we assessed the diagnostic performance of cfDNA analysis, compared to tissues through a meta-analysis and systematic review of existing literature. From 561 candidate papers, we finally identified 40 studies, including 2,805 NSCLC patients. We extracted values relating to the number of true-positive, false-positive, false-negative, and true-negative. Pooled sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio, and diagnostic odds ratio, each with 95% CI, were calculated. A summary receiver operating characteristic curve and the area under curve (AUC) were used to evaluate the overall diagnostic performance. The pooled sensitivity was 0.71 (95% CI 0.68–0.74) and the specificity was 0.93 (95% CI 0.92–0.94). The diagnostic odds ratio was 35.24 (95% CI 24.88–49.91) and the area under the curve was 0.92 (SE = 0.094). These results provide evidence that detection of KRAS mutation using cfDNA testing is of adequate diagnostic accuracy thus offering to the clinicians a new promising screening test for NSCLC patients.

The Overview of Perspectives of Clinical Application of Liquid Biopsy in Non-Small-Cell Lung Cancer

The standard diagnostics procedure for non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) requires a pathological evaluation of tissue samples obtained by surgery or biopsy, which are considered invasive sampling procedures. Due to this fact, re-sampling of the primary tumor at the moment of progression is limited and depends on the patient’s condition, even if it could reveal a mechanism of resistance to applied therapy. Recently, many studies have indicated that liquid biopsy could be provided for the noninvasive management of NSCLC patients who receive molecularly targeted therapies or immunotherapy. The liquid biopsy of neoplastic patients harbors small fragments of circulating-free DNA (cfDNA) and cell-free RNA (cfRNA) secreted to the circulation from normal cells, as well as a subset of tumor-derived circulating tumor cells (CTCs) or circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). In NSCLC patients, a longitudinal assessment of genetic alterations in “druggable” genes in liquid biopsy might improve the follow-up of treatment efficacy and allow for the detection of an early progression before it is detectable in computed tomography or a clinical image. However, a liquid biopsy may be used to determine a variety of relevant molecular or genetic information for understanding tumor biology and its evolutionary trajectories. Thus, liquid biopsy is currently associated with greater hope for common diagnostic and clinical applications. In this review, we would like to highlight diagnostic challenges in the application of liquid biopsy into the clinical routine and indicate its implications on the metastatic spread of NSCLC or monitoring of personalized treatment regimens.

Resistance to TKIs in EGFR-Mutated Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: From Mechanisms to New Therapeutic Strategies

Simple Summary

Resistance to tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) in advanced mutant non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) constitutes a therapeutic challenge. Resistance may occur as a result of EGFR-dependent and independent molecular pathways. The first commonly includes T790M, C797S, L792X and L718X mutations, while the latter pertains to HER2 and MET amplifications, gene rearrangements, disruption in PIK3CA, MAPK signaling and SCLC and epithelial–mesenchymal cells transformation. Liquid biopsies detecting mutant cell-free DNA (cfDNA) have a major potential in the detection of mutant clones before they become clinically apparent. Newer-generation TKIs, bispecific antibodies and antibody-drug conjugates or combinations of TKIs with other TKIs or chemotherapy, immunotherapy and anti-vascular endothelial growth factors (anti-VEGFs) are currently in use or under investigation in EGFR mutant NSCLC. In EGFR mutant NSCLC metastatic to the brain, the blood–brain barrier (BBB) decreases the ability of TKIs to reach the central nervous system (CNS), acting as an additional resistance factor, which can presently be addressed with osimertinib. The potential of rechallenging EFGR TKIs after chemotherapy and combining it with anti-PD-1 immunotherapeutics remains ambivalent. Harnessing nanocarriers to improve drug delivery in EGFR TKIs-resistant NSCLC has been promising in preclinical settings, but it is yet to be determined in a clinical context.

Abstract

Resistance to tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) in advanced mutant Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) constitutes a therapeutic challenge. This review intends to summarize the existing knowledge about the mechanisms of resistance to TKIs in the context of EGFR mutant NSCLC and discuss its clinical and therapeutic implications. EGFR-dependent and independent molecular pathways have the potential to overcome or circumvent the activity of EGFR-targeted agents including the third-generation TKI, osimertinib, negatively impacting clinical outcomes. CNS metastases occur frequently in patients on EGFR-TKIs, due to the inability of first and second-generation agents to overcome both the BBB and the acquired resistance of cancer cells in the CNS. Newer-generation TKIs, TKIs targeting EGFR-independent resistance mechanisms, bispecific antibodies and antibody-drug conjugates or combinations of TKIs with other TKIs or chemotherapy, immunotherapy and Anti-Vascular Endothelial Growth Factors (anti-VEGFs) are currently in use or under investigation in EGFR mutant NSCLC. Liquid biopsies detecting mutant cell-free DNA (cfDNA) provide a window of opportunity to attack mutant clones before they become clinically apparent. Overall, EGFR TKIs-resistant NSCLC constitutes a multifaceted therapeutic challenge. Mapping its underlying mutational landscape, accelerating the detection of resistance mechanisms and diversifying treatment strategies are essential for the management of the disease.

Circulating Tumor DNA-Based Genomic Profiling Assays in Adult Solid Tumors for Precision Oncology: Recent Advancements and Future Challenges

Genomic profiling using tumor biopsies remains the standard approach for the selection of approved molecular targeted therapies. However, this is often limited by its invasiveness, feasibility, and poor sample quality. Liquid biopsies provide a less invasive approach while capturing a contemporaneous and comprehensive tumor genomic profile. Recent advancements in the detection of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) from plasma samples at satisfactory sensitivity, specificity, and detection concordance to tumor tissues have facilitated the approval of ctDNA-based genomic profiling to be integrated into regular clinical practice. The recent approval of both single-gene and multigene assays to detect genetic biomarkers from plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) as companion diagnostic tools for molecular targeted therapies has transformed the therapeutic decision-making procedure for advanced solid tumors. Despite the increasing use of cfDNA-based molecular profiling, there is an ongoing debate about a 'plasma first' or 'tissue first' approach toward genomic testing for advanced solid malignancies. Both approaches present possible advantages and disadvantages, and these factors should be carefully considered to personalize and select the most appropriate genomic assay. This review focuses on the recent advancements of cfDNA-based genomic profiling assays in advanced solid tumors while highlighting the major challenges that should be tackled to formulate evidence-based guidelines in recommending the 'right assay for the right patient at the right time'.

Utility of Next-Generation Sequencing in the Reconstruction of Clonal Architecture in a Patient with an EGFR Mutated Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Case Report

EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors (EGFR-TKIs) have revolutionized the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients with activating EGFR mutations. However, targeted therapies impose a strong selective pressure against the coexisting tumor populations that lead to the emergence of resistant clones. Molecular characterization of the disease is essential for the clinical management of the patient, both at diagnosis and after progression. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) has been established as a technique capable of providing clinically useful molecular profiling of the disease in tissue samples and in non-invasive liquid biopsy samples (LB). Here, we describe a case report of a patient with metastatic NSCLC harboring EGFR mutation who developed two independent resistance mechanisms (EGFR-T790M and TP53 + RB1 mutations) to dacomitinib. Osimertinib given as a second-line treatment eliminated the EGFR-T790M population and simultaneously consolidated the proliferation of the TP53 + RB1 clone that eventually led to the histologic transformation to small-cell lung cancer (SCLC). Comprehensive NGS profiling revealed the presence of the TP53 + RB1 clone in the pretreatment biopsy, while EGFR-T790M was only detected after progression on dacomitinib. Implementation of NGS studies in routine molecular diagnosis of tissue and LB samples provides a more comprehensive view of the clonal architecture of the disease in order to guide therapeutic decision-making.

Clinical Applications of Circulating Tumour Cells and Circulating Tumour DNA in Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer-An Update

Despite efforts to improve earlier diagnosis of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), most patients present with advanced stage disease, which is often associated with poor survival outcomes with only 15% surviving for 5 years from their diagnosis. Tumour tissue biopsy is the current mainstream for cancer diagnosis and prognosis in many parts of the world. However, due to tumour heterogeneity and accessibility issues, liquid biopsy is emerging as a game changer for both cancer diagnosis and prognosis. Liquid biopsy is the analysis of tumour-derived biomarkers in body fluids, which has remarkable advantages over the use of traditional tumour biopsy. Circulating tumour cells (CTCs) and circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA) are two main derivatives of liquid biopsy. CTC enumeration and molecular analysis enable monitoring of cancer progression, recurrence, and treatment response earlier than traditional biopsy through a minimally invasive liquid biopsy approach. CTC-derived ex-vivo cultures are essential to understanding CTC biology and their role in metastasis, provide a means for personalized drug testing, and guide treatment selection. Just like CTCs, ctDNA provides opportunity for screening, monitoring, treatment evaluation, and disease surveillance. We present an updated review highlighting the prognostic and therapeutic significance of CTCs and ctDNA in NSCLC.

Analytic and Clinical Validation of a Pan-Cancer NGS Liquid Biopsy Test for the Detection of Copy Number Amplifications, Fusions and Exon Skipping Variants

Liquid biopsies are an integral part of the diagnosis of cancer. Here, we have extended previous validation studies of a new targeted NGS panel to include the detection of copy number amplifications (CNAs), fusions, and exon skipping variants. Detection of these gene classes included specimens from clinical and healthy donors and cell lines (fusions: ROS1, EML4-ALK, NTRK1; exon skipping: MET exon 14; CNAs: HER2, CDK6, EGFR, MYC, and MET). The limit of detection (LOD) for fusion/skipping was 42 copies (QC threshold was three copies) and was verified using three additional fusion/skipping variants. LOD for CNAs was 1.40-fold-change (QC threshold = 1.15-fold change) and was verified with three additional CNAs. In repeatability and intermediate precision (within lab) studies, all fusion/skipping variants were detected in all runs and all days of testing (n = 18/18; 100%); average CV for repeatability was 20.5% (range 8.7–34.8%), and for intermediate precision it was 20.8% (range 15.7–30.5%). For CNAs, 28/29 (96.6%) copy gains were detected. For CNAs, the average CV was 1.85% (range 0% to 5.49%) for repeatability and 6.59% (range 1.65% to 9.22%) for intermediate precision. The test panel meets the criteria for being highly sensitive and specific and extends its utility for the serial detection of clinically relevant variants in cancer.

Case Report: Patient With Lung Adenocarcinoma With ALK-HLA-DRB1 Rearrangement Shows Impressive Progression-Free Survival After Sequential Crizotinib and Ceritinib Treatment

The anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) gene rearrangement is a driving mutation that underlies about 5-6% of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cases. Lung cancers that are ALK gene rearrangement-positive can be effectively treated with ALK inhibitors. However, the response of patients with rarer ALK gene rearrangements to ALK inhibitors remains unknown. Herein, we described a case of lung adenocarcinoma carrying ALK-HLA-DRB1 fusion in a 48-year-old nonsmoking woman. A similar case of ALK-HLA-DRB1 rearrangement in NSCLC has not been described previously neither in NSCLC nor in other disease. The patient achieved a progression-free survival of 18 months after sequential therapy consisting of crizotinib and then ceritinib during the follow-up. These findings provide basis for the application of ALK inhibitors in patients carrying the rare ALK-HLA-DRB1 fusion.

Recommendations for a practical implementation of circulating tumor DNA mutation testing in metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer

Background

Liquid biopsy (LB) is a rapidly evolving diagnostic tool for precision oncology that has recently found its way into routine practice as an adjunct to tissue biopsy (TB). The concept of LB refers to any tumor-derived material, such as circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) or circulating tumor cells that are detectable in blood. An LB is not limited to the blood and may include other fluids such as cerebrospinal fluid, pleural effusion, and urine, among others.

Patients and methods

The objective of this paper, devised by international experts from various disciplines, is to review current challenges as well as state-of-the-art applications of ctDNA mutation testing in metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). We consider pragmatic scenarios for the use of ctDNA from blood plasma to identify actionable targets for therapy selection in NSCLCs.

Results

Clinical scenarios where ctDNA mutation testing may be implemented in clinical practice include complementary tissue and LB testing to provide the full picture of patients’ actual predictive profiles to identify resistance mechanism (i.e. secondary mutations), and ctDNA mutation testing to assist when a patient has a discordant clinical history and is suspected of showing intertumor or intratumor heterogeneity. ctDNA mutation testing may provide interesting insights into possible targets that may have been missed on the TB. Complementary ctDNA LB testing also provides an option if the tumor location is hard to biopsy or if an insufficient sample was taken. These clinical use cases highlight practical scenarios where ctDNA LB may be considered as a complementary tool to TB analysis.

Conclusions

Proper implementation of ctDNA LB testing in routine clinical practice is envisioned in the near future. As the clinical evidence of utility expands, the use of LB alongside tissue sample analysis may occur in the patient cases detailed here.

•

LB is a rapidly evolving diagnostic tool that may be an adjunct or an alternative to TB in clinic.

•

Pragmatic scenarios for ctDNA mutation testing to identify actionable targets in NSCLC are explored.

•

ctDNA mutation testing may identify resistance mechanisms, discordant clinical history, and intertumor/intratumor heterogeneity.

•

ctDNA mutation testing may be useful if the tumor location is hard to biopsy or if an insufficient tumor sample was taken.

•

Proper implementation of ctDNA mutation testing in routine clinical practice is envisioned in the near future.

The value of cell-free circulating tumour DNA profiling in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) management

Liquid biopsy (LB) has boosted a remarkable change in the management of cancer patients by contributing to tumour genomic profiling. Plasma circulating cell-free tumour DNA (ctDNA) is the most widely searched tumour-related element for clinical application. Specifically, for patients with lung cancer, LB has revealed valuable to detect the diversity of targetable genomic alterations and to detect and monitor the emergence of resistance mechanisms. Furthermore, its non-invasive nature helps to overcome the difficulty in obtaining tissue samples, offering a comprehensive view about tumour diversity. However, the use of the LB to support diagnostic and therapeutic decisions still needs further clarification. In this sense, this review aims to provide a critical view of the clinical importance of plasma ctDNA analysis, the most widely applied LB, and its limitations while anticipating concepts that will intersect the present and future of LB in non-small cell lung cancer patients.

Graphical Abstract

Molecular Genetic Techniques in Biomarker Analysis Relevant for Drugs Centrally Approved in Europe

On the basis of scientific evidence, information on the option, recommendation or requirement to test for pharmacogenetic or pharmacogenomic biomarkers is incorporated in the Summary of Product Characteristics of an increasing number of drugs in Europe. A screening of the Genetic Testing Registry (GTR) showed that a variety of molecular genetic testing methods is currently offered worldwide in testing services with regard to according drugs and biomarkers. Thereby, among the methodology indicated in the screened GTR category ‘Molecular Genetics’, next-generation sequencing is applied for identification of the largest proportion of evaluated biomarkers that are relevant for therapeutic management of centrally approved drugs in Europe. However, sufficient information on regulatory clearances, clinical utility, analytical and clinical validity of applied methods is rarely provided.

Diagnostic and economic value of biomarker testing for targetable mutations in non-small-cell lung cancer: a literature review

We aimed to assess the diagnostic and economic value of next-generation sequencing (NGS) versus single-gene testing, and of liquid biopsy (LBx) versus tissue biopsy (TBx) in non-small-cell lung cancer biomarker testing through literature review. Embase and MEDLINE were searched to identify relevant studies (n = 43) from 2015 to 2020 in adults with advanced non-small-cell lung cancer. For NGS versus single-gene testing, concordance was 70-99% and sensitivity was 86-100%. For LBx versus TBx, specificity was 43-100% and sensitivity was ≥60%. Turnaround times were longer for NGS versus single-gene testing (but not vs sequential testing) and faster for LBx versus TBx. NGS was cost-effective, and LBx reduced US per-patient costs. NGS versus single-gene testing and LBx versus TBx were concordant. NGS and LBx may be cost-effective for initial screening.

Gene-Guided Treatment Decision-Making in Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer - A Systematic Review

Decision-making in cancer treatment is part of clinicians’ everyday work, and it is especially challenging in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients, for whom decisions are clearly dependent on gene alterations or the lack of them. The multimodality of treatments, involvement of gene alterations in defining systemic cancer therapies, and heterogeneous nature of tumors and their responsiveness provide extra challenges. This article reviews the existing literature to 2021 with extra effort to explore the role of genes and gene-driven therapies as part of decision-making. The process and elements in this decision-making participation are recognized and discussed comprehensively. Genetic health literacy aids are provided as a part of the review. Our systematic review, data extraction and analysis found that with current methods and broad gene panels, patients benefit from early molecular testing of liquid biopsy samples. An estimated 79% of liquid biopsy samples showed somatic mutations based on 8 original studies included in the systematic review. When both liquid biopsy samples and tissue samples are evaluated, the sensitivity to detect targetable mutations in NSCLC increases. We recommend early testing with liquid biopsy. Additional effort is needed for the logistics of obtaining and evaluating samples, and tissue samples should be saved and stored for tests that are not possible from liquid biopsy.

Implementation of Next Generation Sequencing-Based Liquid Biopsy for Clinical Molecular Diagnostics in Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) Patients

Genetic screening of somatic mutations in circulating free DNA (cfDNA) opens up new opportunities for personalized medicine. In this study, we aim to illustrate the implementation of NGS-based liquid biopsy in clinical practice for the detection of somatic alterations in selected genes. Our work is particularly relevant for the diagnosis and treatment of NSCLC. Beginning in 2020, we implemented the use of Roche’s Avenio ctDNA expanded panel in our diagnostic routine. In this study, we retrospectively review NGS-based clinical genetic tests performed in our laboratory, focusing on key analytical parameters. Avenio ctDNA kits demonstrated 100% sensitivity in detecting single nucleotide variants (SNVs) at >0.5% variant allele frequency (VAF), and high consistency in reproducibility. Since 2020, we performed cfDNA genotyping test in 86 NSCLC patients, and we successfully sequenced 96.5% (83/86) of samples. We observed consistency in sequencing performance based upon sequencing depth and on-target rate. At least one gene variant was identified in 52 samples (63%), and one or more actionable variants were detected in 21 out of 83 (25%) of analysed patients. We demonstrated the feasibility of implementing an NGS-based liquid biopsy assay for routine genetic characterization of metastatic NSCLC patients.

The Liquid Biopsy for Lung Cancer: State of the Art, Limitations and Future Developments

Simple Summary

During the development and progression of lung tumors, processes such as necrosis and vascular invasion shed tumor cells or cellular components into various fluid compartments. Liquid biopsies consist of obtaining a bodily fluid, typically peripheral blood, in order to isolate and investigate these shed tumor constituents. Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) are one such constituent, which can be isolated from blood and can act as a diagnostic aid and provide valuable prognostic information. Liquid-based biopsies may also have a potential future role in lung cancer screening. Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is found in small quantities in blood and, with the recent development of sensitive molecular and sequencing technologies, can be used to directly detect actionable genetic alterations or monitor for resistance mutations and guide clinical management. While potential benefits of liquid biopsies are promising, they are not without limitations. In this review, we summarize the current state and limitations of CTCs and ctDNA and possible future directions.

Abstract

Lung cancer is a leading cause of cancer-related deaths, contributing to 18.4% of cancer deaths globally. Treatment of non-small cell lung carcinoma has seen rapid progression with targeted therapies tailored to specific genetic drivers. However, identifying genetic alterations can be difficult due to lack of tissue, inaccessible tumors and the risk of complications for the patient with serial tissue sampling. The liquid biopsy provides a minimally invasive method which can obtain circulating biomarkers shed from the tumor and could be a safer alternative to tissue biopsy. While tissue biopsy remains the gold standard, liquid biopsies could be very beneficial where serial sampling is required, such as monitoring disease progression or development of resistance mutations to current targeted therapies. Liquid biopsies also have a potential role in identifying patients at risk of relapse post treatment and as a component of future lung cancer screening protocols. Rapid developments have led to multiple platforms for isolating circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and detecting circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA); however, standardization is lacking, especially in lung carcinoma. Additionally, clonal hematopoiesis of uncertain clinical significance must be taken into consideration in genetic sequencing, as it introduces the potential for false positives. Various biomarkers have been investigated in liquid biopsies; however, in this review, we will concentrate on the current use of ctDNA and CTCs, focusing on the clinical relevance, current and possible future applications and limitations of each.

The Opportunities and Challenges of Molecular Tagging Next-Generation Sequencing in Liquid Biopsy

Liquid biopsy (LB) is a promising tool that is rapidly evolving as a standard of care in early and advanced stages of cancer settings. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) methods have become essential in molecular diagnostics and clinical laboratories dealing with LB analytes, i.e., cell-free DNA and RNA. The sensitivity and high-throughput capacity of NGS enable us to overcome technical issues that are mainly attributable to low-abundance (below 1% mutated allelic frequency) tumour genetic material circulating within biological fluids. In this context, the introduction of unique molecular identifiers (UMIs), also known as molecular barcodes, applied to various NGS platforms greatly improved the characterization of rare genetic alterations, as they resulted in a drastic reduction in background noise while maintaining high levels of positive predictive value and sensitivity. Different UMI strategies have been developed, such as single (e.g., safe-sequencing system, Safe-SeqS) or double (duplex-sequencing system, Duplex-Seq) strand-based labelling, and, currently, considerable results corroborate their potential implementation in a routine laboratory. Recently, the US Food and Drug Administration approved the clinical use of two comprehensive UMI-based NGS assays (FoundationOne Liquid CDx and Guardant360 CDx) in cfDNA mutational assessment. However, to definitively translate LB into clinical practice, UMI-based NGS protocols should meet certain feasibility requirements in terms of cost-effectiveness, wet laboratory performance and easy access to web-source and bioinformatic tools for downstream molecular data.

A Real-World, Observational, Prospective Study to Assess the Molecular Epidemiology of Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (EGFR) Mutations upon Progression on or after First-Line Therapy with a First- or Second-Generation EGFR Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitor in EGFR Mutation-Positive Locally Advanced or Metastatic Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: The 'LUNGFUL' Study

Simple Summary

Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) accounts for approximately 85% of lung cancer cases, with few patients carrying driver mutations in the gene encoding for epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Advances in translational research have established EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) as the standard first-line therapy for NSCLC patients with activating EGFR mutations. The aim of our observational study was to assess the frequency of T790M acquired resistance and predictors of its presence, in patients with EGFR-mutated locally advanced or metastatic NSCLC who have progressed in the first-line EGFR-TKI treatment setting with first- or second-generation TKIs and have undergone molecular testing in tissue and/or plasma biopsy. The study highlights the challenges of performing tissue re-biopsy in routine care settings, which can lead to patients considered non-eligible for certain therapies from which they can benefit, and merits further actions from the healthcare community, in order to establish re-biopsy as a standard procedure.

Abstract

Background: Real-world data on the molecular epidemiology of EGFR resistance mutations at or after progression with first- or second-generation EGFR-TKIs in patients with advanced NSCLC are lacking. Methods: This ongoing observational study was carried out by 23 hospital-based physicians in Greece. The decision to perform cobas^®EGFR Mutation Test v2 in tissue and/or plasma at disease progression was made before enrollment. For patients with negative/inconclusive T790M plasma-based results, tissue re-biopsy could be performed. Results: Ninety-six (96) eligible patients were consecutively enrolled (median age: 67.8 years) between July-2017 and September-2019. Of the patients, 98% were tested upon progression using plasma and 2% using tissue/cytology biopsy. The T790M mutation was detected in 16.0% of liquid biopsies. Tissue re-biopsy was performed in 22.8% of patients with a T790M-negative plasma result. In total, the T790M positivity rate was 21.9%, not differing between patients on first- or second-generation EGFR-TKI. Higher (≥2) ECOG performance status and longer (≥10 months) time to disease progression following EGFR-TKI treatment initiation were associated with T790M positivity. Conclusions: Results from plasma/tissue-cytology samples in a real-world setting, yielded a T790M positivity rate lower than previous reports. Fewer than one in four patients with negative plasma-based testing underwent tissue re-biopsy, indicating the challenges in routine care settings.

Current Achievements and Applications of Transcriptomics in Personalized Cancer Medicine

Over the last decades, transcriptome profiling emerged as one of the most powerful approaches in oncology, providing prognostic and predictive utility for cancer management. The development of novel technologies, such as revolutionary next-generation sequencing, enables the identification of cancer biomarkers, gene signatures, and their aberrant expression affecting oncogenesis, as well as the discovery of molecular targets for anticancer therapies. Transcriptomics contribute to a change in the holistic understanding of cancer, from histopathological and organic to molecular classifications, opening a more personalized perspective for tumor diagnostics and therapy. The further advancement on transcriptome profiling may allow standardization and cost reduction of its analysis, which will be the next step for transcriptomics to become a canon of contemporary cancer medicine.

Next Generation Sequencing-Based Profiling of Cell Free DNA in Patients with Advanced Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: Advantages and Pitfalls

Lung cancer (LC) is the main cause of death for cancer worldwide and non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) represents the most common histology. The discovery of genomic alterations in driver genes that offer the possibility of therapeutic intervention has completely changed the approach to the diagnosis and therapy of advanced NSCLC patients, and tumor molecular profiling has become mandatory for the choice of the most appropriate therapeutic strategy. However, in approximately 30% of NSCLC patients tumor tissue is inadequate for biomarker analysis. The development of highly sensitive next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies for the analysis of circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is emerging as a valuable alternative to assess tumor molecular landscape in case of tissue unavailability. Additionally, cfDNA NGS testing can better recapitulate NSCLC heterogeneity as compared with tissue testing. In this review we describe the main advantages and limits of using NGS-based cfDNA analysis to guide the therapeutic decision-making process in advanced NSCLC patients, to monitor the response to therapy and to identify mechanisms of resistance early. Therefore, we provide evidence that the implementation of cfDNA NGS testing in clinical research and in the clinical practice can significantly improve precision medicine approaches in patients with advanced NSCLC.

Functional coding/non-coding variants in EGFR, ROS1 and ALK genes and their role in liquid biopsy as a personalized therapy

Personalized medicine holds promise to tailor the treatment options for patients' unique genetic make-up, behavioral and environmental background. Liquid biopsy is non-invasive technique and precise diagnosis and treatment approach. Significantly, NGS technologies have revolutionized the genomic medicine by novel identifying SNPs, indel mutations in both coding and non-coding regions and also a promising technology to accelerate the early detection and finding new biomarkers for diagnosis and treatment. The number of the bioinformatics tools have been rapidly increasing with the aim of learning more about the detected mutations either they have a pathogenic role or not. EGFR, ROS1 and ALK genes are members of the RTK family. Until now, mutations within these genes have been associated with many cancers and involved in resistance formation to TKIs. This review article summarized the findings about the mostly investigated variations in EGFR, ROS1 and ALK genes and their potential role in liquid biopsy approach.

Generic Protocols for the Analytical Validation of Next-Generation Sequencing-Based ctDNA Assays: A Joint Consensus Recommendation of the BloodPAC's Analytical Variables Working Group

Liquid biopsy, particularly the analysis of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA), has demonstrated considerable promise for numerous clinical intended uses. Successful validation and commercialization of novel ctDNA tests have the potential to improve the outcomes of patients with cancer. The goal of the Blood Profiling Atlas Consortium (BloodPAC) is to accelerate the development and validation of liquid biopsy assays that will be introduced into the clinic. To accomplish this goal, the BloodPAC conducts research in the following areas: Data Collection and Analysis within the BloodPAC Data Commons; Preanalytical Variables; Analytical Variables; Patient Context Variables; and Reimbursement. In this document, the BloodPAC's Analytical Variables Working Group (AV WG) attempts to define a set of generic analytical validation protocols tailored for ctDNA-based Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) assays. Analytical validation of ctDNA assays poses several unique challenges that primarily arise from the fact that very few tumor-derived DNA molecules may be present in circulation relative to the amount of nontumor-derived cell-free DNA (cfDNA). These challenges include the exquisite level of sensitivity and specificity needed to detect ctDNA, the potential for false negatives in detecting these rare molecules, and the increased reliance on contrived samples to attain sufficient ctDNA for analytical validation. By addressing these unique challenges, the BloodPAC hopes to expedite sponsors' presubmission discussions with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) with the protocols presented herein. By sharing best practices with the broader community, this work may also save the time and capacity of FDA reviewers through increased efficiency.

Comparison of liquid-based to tissue-based biopsy analysis by targeted next generation sequencing in advanced non-small cell lung cancer: a comprehensive systematic review

PURPOSE

To explore whether targeted next generation sequencing (NGS) of liquid biopsy in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) could potentially overcome the innate problems that arise with standard tissue biopsy, like intratumoral heterogeneity and the inability to obtain adequate samples for analysis.

METHODS

The Scopus, Cochrane Library, and MEDLINE (via PubMed) databases were searched for studies with matched tissue and liquid biopsies from advanced NSCLC patients, analyzed with targeted NGS. The number of mutations detected in tissue biopsy only, liquid biopsy only, or both was assessed and the positive percent agreement (PPA) of the two methods was calculated for every clinically relevant gene.

RESULTS

A total of 644 unique relevant articles were retrieved and data were extracted from 38 studies fulfilling the inclusion criteria. The sample size was composed of 2000 mutations tested in matched tissue and liquid biopsies derived from 1141 patients. No studies analyzed circulating tumor cells. The calculated PPA rates were 53.6% (45/84) for ALK, 53.9% (14/26) for BRAF, 56.5% (13/23) for ERBB2, 67.8% (428/631) for EGFR, 64.2% (122/190) for KRAS, 58.6% (17/29) for MET, 54.6% (12/22) for RET, and 53.3% (8/15) for ROS1. We additionally recorded data for 65 genes that are not recommended by current guidelines for mutational testing. An extra category containing results of unspecified genes was added, with a PPA rate of 55.7% (122/219).

CONCLUSION

Despite many advantages, liquid biopsy might be unable to fully substitute its tissue counterpart in detecting clinically relevant mutations in advanced NSCLC patients. However, it may serve as a helpful tool when making therapeutic decisions. More studies are needed to evaluate its role in everyday clinical practice.

Next Generation Sequencing for Gene Fusion Analysis in Lung Cancer: A Literature Review

Gene fusions have a pivotal role in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) precision medicine. Several techniques can be used, from fluorescence in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry to next generation sequencing (NGS). Although several NGS panels are available, gene fusion testing presents more technical challenges than other variants. This is a PubMed-based narrative review aiming to summarize NGS approaches for gene fusion analysis and their performance on NSCLC clinical samples. The analysis can be performed at DNA or RNA levels, using different target enrichment (hybrid-capture or amplicon-based) and sequencing chemistries, with both custom and commercially available panels. DNA sequencing evaluates different alteration types simultaneously, but large introns and repetitive sequences can impact on the performance and it does not discriminate between expressed and unexpressed gene fusions. RNA-based targeted approach analyses and quantifies directly fusion transcripts and is more accurate than DNA panels on tumor tissue, but it can be limited by RNA quality and quantity. On liquid biopsy, satisfying data have been published on circulating tumor DNA hybrid-capture panels. There is not a perfect method for gene fusion analysis, but NGS approaches, though still needing a complete standardization and optimization, present several advantages for the clinical practice.

Electric Field-Induced Release and Measurement (EFIRM): Characterization and Technical Validation of a Novel Liquid Biopsy Platform in Plasma and Saliva

Electric field-induced release and measurement (EFIRM) is a novel, plate-based, liquid biopsy platform capable of detecting circulating tumor DNA containing EGFR mutations directly from saliva and plasma in both early- and late-stage patients with non-small-cell lung cancer. We investigated the properties of the target molecule for EFIRM and determined that the platform preferentially detects single-stranded DNA molecules. We then investigated the properties of the EFIRM assay and determined the linearity, linear range, precision, and limit of detection for six different EGFR variants (the four most common g.Exon19del variants), p.T790M, and p.L858R). The limit of detection was in single-digit copy number for the latter two mutations, and the limit of detection for Exon19del was 5000 copies. Following these investigations, technical validations were performed for four separate EFIRM liquid biopsy assays, qualitative and quantitative assays for both saliva and plasma. We conclude that EFIRM liquid biopsy is an assay platform that interrogates a biomarker not targeted by any other extant platform (namely, circulating single-stranded DNA molecules). The assay has acceptable performance characteristics in both quantitative and qualitative assays on both saliva and plasma.