Fetal Growth and the Fetal Origins Hypothesis in Twins — Problems and Perspectives

Fetal Body Composition in Twins and Singletons

Importance

An emerging paradigm attributes third-trimester fetal growth deceleration in uncomplicated twin pregnancies to an evolutionary adaptive process. Evaluating longitudinal fetal soft-tissue development may provide important insights into differential fetal growth trajectories between twins and singletons.

Objective

To compare twin vs singleton lean and fat tissue growth across pregnancy.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Prospective cohort study of dichorionic twins and singletons with serial ultrasound scans to chart fetal growth (2009-2013) and collect fetal volume data to measure fat and lean tissue (2015-2019) in 12 US clinical centers. Participants were individuals with singleton (n = 2802 enrolled) and twin (n = 171 pairs enrolled) pregnancies who generally had no chronic disease. Data analysis was performed from September 2023 to June 2024.

Exposure

Twin status.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Abdominal area, maximum abdominal subcutaneous tissue thickness, fractional thigh volume, fractional lean thigh volume, fractional fat thigh volume, midthigh area (including lean and fat components), ratio of fractional fat thigh volume to fractional thigh volume, and ratio of midthigh fat area to midthigh area, measured up to 6 times between 15 and 37 weeks' gestation.

Results

Analyses included 315 twin and 2604 singleton fetuses. The mean (SD) maternal age at delivery was 31.3 (6.1) years for twins and 28.2 (5.5) years for singletons, with a mean (SD) gestational age at delivery of 35.2 (4.2) weeks for twins and 39.2 (1.7) weeks for singletons. Mean twin abdominal measurements were significantly smaller than those of singletons between 25 and 37 weeks' gestation for area (difference at 25 weeks, -48.6 [95% CI, -102.2 to -5.1] mm2; difference at 37 weeks, -480.5 [95% CI, -677.2 to -283.5] mm2) and between 27 and 37 weeks for maximum abdominal subcutaneous tissue thickness (difference at 27 weeks, -0.13 [95% CI, -0.24 to -0.02] mm; difference at 37 weeks, -0.40 [95% CI, -0.68 to -0.13] mm). Beginning at 15 weeks, fractional thigh volumes were significantly smaller for twins (mean fractional thigh volume difference, -0.11 [95% CI, -0.16 to -0.07] cm3; mean fractional fat thigh volume difference, -0.08 [95% CI,-0.12 to -0.05] cm3) relative to singletons, persisting through 37 weeks (mean fractional thigh volume difference, -7.55 [95% CI, -11.76 to -3.34] cm3; mean fractional fat thigh volume difference, -5.60 [95% CI, -8.37 to -2.82] cm3). Mean fractional lean thigh volume was significantly smaller for twins at 15 to 16 and 23 to 36 weeks. For the ratio of fractional fat thigh volume to fractional thigh volume, twins had a 2.7% to 4.2% smaller fat percentage between 15 and 37 weeks compared with singletons.

Conclusions and Relevance

Twins had proportionally less fat tissue accumulation in utero compared with singletons as early as 15 weeks' gestation, when competition for nutritional resources was low. Persistent findings of smaller twin sizes and less fat accumulation across pregnancy support the concept of an early evolutionary adaptive process in otherwise uncomplicated dichorionic twin growth.

Twins in Guinea-Bissau have a ‘thin-fat’ body composition compared to singletons

The ‘thrifty phenotype’ hypothesis proposed that fetal undernutrition increases risk of diabetes in later life. Undernourished low birthweight Indian babies are paradoxically more adipose compared to well-nourished European babies, and are at higher risk of diabetes in later life. Twin pregnancies are an example of in utero growth restrictive environment due to shared maternal nutrition. There are few studies of body composition in twins. We performed secondary analysis of anthropometric body composition of twins and singletons in Guinea-Bissau, an economically deprived African country.

Anthropometric data were available on 7–34 year-old twins (n = 209, 97 males) and singletons (n = 182, 86 males) in the Guinea-Bissau Twin Registry at the Bandim Health Project. Twins had lower birthweight (2420 vs 3100 g, p < 0.001); and at follow-up, lower height (HAZ mean Z-score difference, −0.21, p = 0.055), weight (WAZ −0.73, p = 0.024) and BMI (BAZ −0.22, p = 0.079) compared to singletons but higher adiposity (skinfolds: +0.33 SD, p = 0.001). Twins also had higher fasting (+0.38 SD, p < 0.001) and 2-hour OGTT glucose concentrations (+0.29 SD, p < 0.05). Linear mixed-effect model accounting for intrapair correlations and interactions confirmed that twins were thinner but fatter across the age range. Data on maternal morbidity and prematurity were not available in this cohort.

African populations are known to have a muscular (less adipose) body composition. Demonstration of a thin-fat phenotype in twins in a low socio-economic African country supports the thesis that it could be a manifestation of early life undernutrition and not exclusive to Indians. This phenotype could increase risk of diabetes and related conditions.

Should twin-specific growth charts be used to assess fetal growth in twin pregnancies?

One of the hallmarks of twin pregnancies is the slower rate of fetal growth when compared with singleton pregnancies during the third trimester. The mechanisms underlying this phenomenon and whether it represents pathology or benign physiological adaptation are currently unclear. One important implication of these questions relates to the type growth charts that should be used by care providers to monitor growth of twin fetuses. If the slower growth represents pathology (ie, intrauterine growth restriction caused uteroplacental insufficiency), it would be preferable to use a singleton growth chart to identify a small twin fetus that is at risk for perinatal mortality and morbidity. If, however, the relative smallness of twins is the result of benign adaptive mechanisms, it is likely preferable to use a twin-based charts to avoid overdiagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction in twin pregnancies. In the current review, we addressed this question by describing the differences in fetal growth between twin and singleton pregnancies, reviewing the current knowledge regarding the mechanisms responsible for slower fetal growth in twins, summarizing available empirical evidence on the diagnostic accuracy of the 2 types of charts for intrauterine growth restriction in twin pregnancies, and addressing the question of whether uncomplicated dichorionic twins are at an increased risk for fetal death when compared with singleton fetuses. We identified a growing body of evidence that shows that the use of twin charts can reduce the proportion of twin fetuses identified with suspected intrauterine growth restriction by up to 8-fold and can lead to a diagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction that is more strongly associated with adverse perinatal outcomes and hypertensive disorders than a diagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction based on a singleton-based chart without compromising the detection of twin fetuses at risk for adverse outcomes caused by uteroplacental insufficiency. We further found that small for gestational age twins are less likely to experience adverse perinatal outcomes or to have evidence of uteroplacental insufficiency than small for gestational age singletons and that recent data question the longstanding view that uncomplicated dichorionic twins are at an increased risk for fetal death caused by placental insufficiency. Overall, it seems that, based on existing evidence, the of use twin charts is reasonable and may be preferred over the use of singleton charts when monitoring the growth of twin fetuses. Still, it is important to note that the available data have considerable limitations and are primarily derived from observational studies. Therefore, adequately-powered trials are likely needed to confirm the benefit of twin charts before their use is adopted by professional societies.

Special Considerations Regarding Antenatal Care and Pregnancy Complications in Dichorionic Twin Pregnancies

Twin pregnancies account for about 3.3% of all deliveries in the United States with the majority of them being dichorionic diamniotic (DCDA). Maternal physiological adaption in twin pregnancies is exaggerated and the rate of almost every maternal and fetal complication is higher when compared to singleton pregnancies. Therefore, twin pregnancies necessitate closer antenatal surveillance by care providers who are familiar with the specific challenges unique to these pregnancies, and there is evidence that following women with twins in a specialized twin clinic can result in improved obstetrical outcomes. The importance of the first antenatal visit in twin pregnancies cannot be over emphasized and should preferably take place early in gestation as it is the optimal period to correctly identify the number of fetuses and the type of placentation (chorionicity and amnionicity). This will allow the patients, families, and caregivers to make the appropriate modifications and to tailor an optimal antenatal follow-up plan. This plan should focus on general recommendations such as weight gain and level of activity, education regarding complications specific to twin pregnancies along with the relevant symptoms and indications to seek care, as well as on close maternal and fetal monitoring. In this review, we summarize available evidence and current guidelines regarding antenatal care in DCDA twin pregnancies.

Twin gestation and the burden of adult cardio-renal disease

The rate of twin births has increased by nearly 80% in recent decades largely due to advanced reproductive technologies. Twins are often born preterm and/or growth restricted which are independently associated with impaired renal and vascular development. Many preterm and twin infants are surviving into adulthood, albeit with an increased burden of chronic health conditions. Twinning as a research tool offers the unique opportunity to investigate the impact of genetics versus the environment on clinical outcomes. This educational review will focus on delineating our current understanding of the renal and cardiovascular development and long-term outcomes among twin born individuals. Specifically, existing literature regarding how twins differ in kidney size and function as well as vascular stiffness and hypertension profiles from singletons will be discussed. The unique situation of twin-twin transfusion syndrome which is associated with distinct short- and long-term cardio-renal disease will be highlighted. Ultimately, the ability to stratify risk of future cardio-renal disease at birth for infants born preterm and/or growth restricted, including twins, is important to guide clinical follow up. In addition, this early risk stratification could direct research efforts to better understand the mechanisms driving impaired organogenesis and allow for discovery of therapeutic interventions aimed at modifying disease progression and improving longevity in the most vulnerable infant subgroups.

Association between hypertensive disorders and fetal growth restriction in twin compared with singleton gestations

BACKGROUND

Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (including preeclampsia or gestational hypertension) are associated with fetal growth restriction in singleton pregnancies, an association that may be attributed to abnormal placentation as the shared etiology between these conditions. Given that the pathogenesis of these conditions in twin pregnancies may involve mechanisms other than abnormal placentation, it is unclear whether a similar association between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction is present in twins. Data on the relationship between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction in twins are limited and conflicting. This controversy may be attributed to limitations of existing studies including the use of a singleton-based birthweight reference to define fetal growth restriction in twins and the lack of a positive control group of singleton gestations.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to determine the association between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction in dichorionic twin gestations, using both a singleton- and a twin-based birthweight reference, and to compare this association with that observed in singleton gestations.

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a retrospective cohort study of all women with dichorionic twin or singleton gestations giving birth in a single tertiary center during 2003-2015. Fetal growth restriction was defined in separate analyses as birthweight <10th percentile for gestational age using either a singleton- or a twin-based birthweight reference. The association between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction was determined separately for twin and singleton gestations and was expressed as adjusted relative risk with 95% confidence interval.

RESULTS

A total of 1520 twin and 48,943 singleton gestations were included. In singleton gestations, hypertensive disorders of pregnancy were associated with an increased risk of fetal growth restriction (16.6% vs 7.4%, adjusted relative risk, 2.07, 95% confidence interval, 1.87-2.30). In twins, there was no association between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction when a singleton-based reference was used to define fetal growth restriction. However, when using a twin-based reference to define fetal growth restriction, hypertensive disorders of pregnancy in twin gestations were associated with a similar increase in the risk of fetal growth restriction to that seen in singletons (11.8% vs 4.7%, adjusted relative risk, 2.37, 95% confidence interval, 1.69-3.34). Findings were similar with regard to the reverse association between fetal growth restriction and hypertensive disorders of pregnancy: in women with twin gestations, the increase in the risk of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy in pregnancies complicated by fetal growth restriction of 1 twin was similar to that observed in singletons only when a twin-based reference was used to define fetal growth restriction (twins: 21.3% vs 9.8%, adjusted relative risk, 2.15, 95% confidence interval, 1.63-3.06; singletons: 8.8% vs 3.7%, adjusted relative risk, 2.19, 95% confidence interval, 1.95-2.44).

CONCLUSION

The association between hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and fetal growth restriction in dichorionic twins is similar in magnitude to that observed in singletons so long as appropriate birthweight references are applied. Therefore, women with a twin gestation complicated by one of these conditions should be closely monitored for the other. Our findings suggest that the use of a twin-based reference to diagnose fetal growth restriction in twin gestations may be more informative and clinically relevant than using a singleton-based reference.

Risk of metabolic syndrome and diabetes among young twins and singletons in Guinea-Bissau

OBJECTIVE

Twins in Africa may be at increased risk of metabolic disorders due to strained conditions in utero, including high exposure to infections. We studied metabolic syndrome (MS) and diabetes mellitus (DM) among young twins and singletons in Guinea-Bissau.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

The study was cross-sectional and occurred from October 2009 until August 2011 at the Bandim Health Project, a demographic surveillance site in the capital Bissau. Twins and singleton controls between 5 and 32 years were visited at home. Fasting blood samples for metabolic measurements were collected. Zygosity was established genetically for a subset. DM was defined as HbA1c ≥6.5% (48 mmol/mol) and MS by the International Diabetes Federation criteria.

RESULTS

HbA1c was available for 574 twins and 463 singletons. Mean age was 15.3 years versus 15.8 years, respectively. Eighteen percent of twins were monozygotic. There were no DM cases among twins but one among singletons. A total of 1.4% (8 of 574) of twins had elevated HbA1c (6.0-6.4%, 42-46 mmol/mol) compared with 2.4% (11 of 463) of singletons (P = 0.28). Mean HbA1c was 5.3% (34 mmol/mol) for both groups. MS data were available for 364 twins and 360 singletons. The MS prevalence was 3.0% (11 of 364) among twins and 3.6% (13 of 360) among singletons (P = 0.66). The prevalence of fasting blood glucose (F-glucose) ≥5.6 mmol/L was 34.9% (127 of 364) for twins versus 24.7% (89 of 360) for singletons (P = 0.003). Median homeostasis model assessment-insulin resistance did not differ (P = 0.34).

CONCLUSIONS

The MS and DM prevalences among young individuals in Guinea-Bissau were low. Twins did not have a higher MS and DM burden than singletons, though elevated F-glucose was more common among twins.

Selective intrauterine growth restriction in monochorionic twin pregnancies: markers of endothelial damage and metabolomic profile

The aim of this study was to assess the aorta-intima thickness (aIT) and serum metabolomic profile in selective intrauterine growth-restricted (sIUGR) monochorionic diamniotic (MCDA) twin fetuses presenting Doppler velocimetry alterations. Fetal abdominal aIT was measured by ultrasound at 32 weeks of gestation, enrolling 24 MCDA twin fetuses (8 sIUGR and 16 controls). sIUGR twin fetuses were classified into two groups: Group 1 consisted of sIUGR with abnormal umbilical artery (UA) Doppler waveforms and Group 2 included sIUGR with normal UA Doppler. Group 3 were control fetuses appropriate for gestational age (AGA). Fetal blood samples were obtained from the umbilical vein immediately after fetal extraction. A non-targeted metabolomic profiling investigated fetal metabolism alterations by using liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS). Median fetal aIT was significantly larger in Group 1 (median value = 0.9 mm; range = 0.8-1.0 mm; p < .002) and Group 2 (median value = 0.8 mm; range = 0.7-0.8 mm; p < .002) than in AGA Group 3 (median value = 0.5 mm; range = 0.4-0.6 mm; p < .002). Metabolomic analyses, performed on four sIUGR cases (Group 1) compared with four AGA co-twins, showed an upregulation of phenylalanine, sphingosine, glycerophosphocholine, and choline, and a downregulation of valine, tryptophan, isoleucine, and proline sIUGR Group 1 compared with AGA. Although for metabolomics data only a statistical tendency (and not a statistical significance) was reached due to the small sample size, we believe that our results represent a valid starting point for further in-depth metabolomic and proteomic investigations of sIUGR in MCDA fetuses.

[Role of genetic and environmental factors in the development of polycystic ovary syndrome]

Polycystic ovary syndrome is the most common heterogeneous endocrine abnormality in women in the reproductive age. The syndrome remains an enigmatic disorder because the aetiology is still unclear. Familial aggreagation is relatively common among patients with polycystic ovary syndrome suggesting a significant genetic component, although the way of inheritance has not been established firmly. The authors review the relevant medical literature and suggest that genetic and environmental factors play a role in the development of polycystic ovary syndrome. To date, no gene has been identified that causes or contributes substantially to the development of a polycystic ovary syndrome phenotype. Polycystic ovarian syndrome is considered to be an oligogenic disorder in which the interaction of a number of genetic and environmental factors determines the heterogeneous clinical and biochemical phenotype. To summarize current evidence the authors conclude, that when we are able to identify and then modify environmental determinants, then we will be able to safeguard better the health of those patients who are predisposed to disease development due to genotype or previous environmental effects.

Aortic wall thickness and amniotic fluid albuminuria in growth-restricted twin fetuses

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) may be associated with significantly higher aortic intima-media thickening (aIMT) values. It is unknown if fetal aIMT is associated with glomerulosclerosis and amniotic albuminuria in utero.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, AND MEASUREMENTS

Fetal abdominal aIMT and amniotic albumin/creatinine ratio (ACR) were measured in 126 individual twin fetuses, recruited by the Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clinics of the University of Padua (Italy) Medical Center. The IUGR twin fetuses were classified into two groups: Group A were those fetuses whose estimated fetal weight (EFW) was <10th percentile with pulsatility index >2 SD and Group B were those fetuses whose EFW was <10th percentile and had no velocimetry abnormalities.

RESULTS

The median fetal aIMT was significantly different in the three groups (Group A = 0.9 mm; Group B = 0.7 mm; and appropriate for gestational age (AGA) = 0.5 mm; p < .0001). It was significantly higher in Group A than in the AGA group (p < .0001) and than in the Group B fetuses (p = .003), respectively. In addition, ACR was different in the three groups (Group A = 183,500 mg/g; Group B = 6,4720 mg/g; and AGA = 8,2750 mg/g; p = .0002). It was significantly higher in Group A than in the AGA group (p = .03) and than in Group B (p = .02), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Growth-restricted twin fetuses with velocimetry abnormalities present are associated with aIMT and higher ACR levels in amniotic fluid, which could be possible markers in utero of preclinical atherosclerosis, and early glomerulosclerosis.

The Norwegian Twin Registry from a Public Health Perspective: A Research Update

We describe the importance of the Norwegian Twin Registry (NTR) for research in public health and provide examples from several programs of twin research at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health (NIPH), including the Nordic Twin Study of Cancer, our epigenetics platform, and our large program of research in mental health. The NTR has become an integral component of a national strategy for maximizing the research potential from Norwegian registries and biobank-based studies. The information provided herein builds upon and complements our recent report describing the establishment of the NTR and the cohorts comprising it. Although Norway has a long tradition in twin research, the centralization and administration of the twin data through a single register structure is fairly recent. The NTR was established in 2009 and currently includes 47,989 twins covering birth years 1895–1960 and 1967–1979; 31,440 of these twins have consented to participate in medical research (comprising 5,439 monozygotic pairs, 6,702 dizygotic same-sexed pairs, and 1,655 dizygotic opposite-sexed pairs). DNA from approximately 4,800 twins is banked at the NIPH biobank and new studies continuously add new data to the registry. The value of NTR data is greatly enhanced through record linkage possibilities offered by Norway's many nation-wide registries (medical, demographic, and socio-economic) and several studies are already taking advantage of these linkage opportunities for research.

A Twin-Singleton Comparison of Developmental Trajectories of Externalizing and Internalizing Problems in 6- to 12-Year-Old Children

Research on twin-singleton differences in externalizing and internalizing problems in childhood is largely cross-sectional and yields contrasting results. The goal of this study was to compare developmental trajectories of externalizing and internalizing problems in 6- to 12-year-old twins and singletons. Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) maternal reports of externalizing and internalizing problems were obtained for a sample of 9651 twins from the Netherlands Twin Register and for a representative general population sample of 1351 singletons. Latent growth modeling was applied to estimate growth curves for twins and singletons. Twin-singleton differences in the intercepts and slopes of the growth curves were examined. The developmental trajectories of externalizing problems showed a linear decrease over time, and were not significantly different for twins and singletons. Internalizing problems seem to develop similarly for twins and singletons up to age 9. After this age twins' internalizing symptoms start to decrease in comparison to those of singletons, resulting in less internalizing problems than singletons by the age of 12 years. Our findings confirm the generalizability of twin studies to singleton populations with regard to externalizing problems in middle and late childhood. The generalizability of studies on internalizing problems in early adolescence in twin samples should be addressed with care. Twinship may be a protective factor in the development of internalizing problems during early adolescence.

The Foetal Origins of Adult Disease: Interpreting the Evidence From Twin Studies

Twin studies have a contribution to make to the debate concerning the foetal origins of adult disease. Twins are growth retarded compared to singletons and experience post-natal catch-up growth. However, there is no evidence that twins are at increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Studying whether discordance in size at birth within monozygotic twin pairs is predictive of discordance in later life disease should help resolve whether the association between size at birth and later disease is due to common genetic factors. Results from studies of blood pressure in childhood and adult life looking at these within twin effects are far from conclusive. There are, however, methodological problems in the interpretation of these results, not least of which is the relatively small numbers of twin pairs studied. Studies exploring the effect of zygosity and chorion type on later disease provide may provide a useful extension of the research agenda. In summary, twin studies to date have raised more questions about the foetal origins hypothesis than they have resolved.

[Life course genetic epidemiologic study based on longitudinal twin-family data: a new perspective]

Family-based life course epidemiology is the approach to clarify long-term effects of accumulations and chains of biological and social risk exposures in one's life trajectory, namely, before and during conception, infancy, childhood, young adulthood and later adult life. Both genetic and environmental factors are considered. One of the theoretical rationales is the 'developmental origin of health and disease (DOHaD)' hypothesis. According to this theory, the causes of adult diseases are attributed to predictive adaptive responses and biological programming or epigenetic changes during a critical period of early life. If the environment later in life after birth is different from what is predicted, a mismatch has happened, leading to the development of a disease. This theory is supported by many epidemiologic studies, animal experiments, and evolution theory of biology. Longitudinal twin-family data are very powerful and useful information in the family-based life course genetic epidemiologic study.

Heritability of childhood weight gain from birth and risk markers for adult metabolic disease in prepubertal twins

OBJECTIVE

Associations between size at birth, postnatal weight gain, and potential risk for adult disease have been variably explained by in utero exposures or genetic risk that could affect both outcomes. We utilized a twin model to explore these hypotheses.

METHODS

One hundred pairs of healthy twins aged 8.9 yr (range, 7.2-10.9 yr) had fasting blood samples collected, blood pressure (BP) measured, and anthropometry assessed. All measurements were converted to sd scores (SDS) to adjust for age and sex.

RESULTS

Mean birth weights in both monozygotic and dizygotic twins were -0.90 SDS lower than the UK reference. In postnatal life, 58% of monozygotic twins and 59% of dizygotic twins showed rapid weight gain (a change of more than +0.67 in weight SDS) from birth. Postnatal weight gain was positively associated with sum of skinfolds (r = 0.51; P < 0.0005), fasting insulin levels (r = 0.35; P < 0.0005), systolic BP (r = 0.30; P < 0.0005), and diastolic BP (r = 0.15; P < 0.05) at follow-up. Heritability estimates (additive genetic components) were calculated using variance components models for: birth weight, 44%; postnatal weight gain, 80%; childhood height, 89%; body mass index, 72%; sum of skinfolds, 89%; waist circumference, 74%; fasting insulin, 65%; systolic BP, 33%; and diastolic BP, 29%.

CONCLUSIONS

Postnatal weight gain from birth, rather than birth weight, was associated with childhood risk markers for adult metabolic disease. Childhood weight gain was highly heritable, and genetic factors associated with postnatal weight gain are likely to also contribute to risks for adult disease.

Effect of birth parameters on retinal vascular caliber: the Twins Eye Study in Tasmania

Recent studies reported an association between smaller birth size and narrower retinal vascular caliber, but it remains unclear whether this association is attributed to confounding by shared environment or genetic factors. At a mean age of 9.3 years, 266 twins (49 monozygotic and 84 dizygotic pairs) in the Twins Eye Study in Tasmania underwent an ophthalmic examination including retinal photography. Retinal vascular caliber was measured using a validated protocol. The majority of these twins were also in the Tasmanian Infant Health Study, which prospectively collected data on birth parameters and antenatal maternal factors. We conducted the main analysis using linear mixed models, accounting for birth set clustering. Both the within-pair (-9.73; 95% CI: -14.68 to -4.77 microm per 5-cm decrease in birth length) and between-pair associations (-7.15; 95% CI: -11.54 to -3.01) with retinal arteriolar caliber were significant and of similar magnitude (difference in effect, P=0.61), after adjusting for age, sex, maternal smoking, mean arterial blood pressure, and other confounders. These associations remained within dizygotic and monozygotic pairs. Analyses of head circumference and retinal arteriolar caliber were similar to those of birth length (within-pair regression coefficient: -2.41; 95% CI: -5.09 to 0.28; between-pair regression coefficient: -2.60; 95% CI: -5.00 to -0.19). For birth weight, only a between-pair association was evident (-7.28; 95% CI: -13.07 to -1.48). This study demonstrates a consistent association between smaller birth size and narrower retinal arterioles in twins. The independent effect of shorter birth length on retinal arteriolar caliber supports a role for twin-specific supply line factors affecting fetal growth on vascular structure.

Effects of twinning and periconceptional undernutrition on late-gestation hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis function in ovine pregnancy

The relationships between reduced size at birth, increased activity of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, and increased risk of disease in adulthood are well described in singletons but are much less clear in twins. This may be because the physiological processes underlying reduced size at birth are different in singletons and twins. Periconceptional undernutrition can cause altered activity of the fetal and postnatal HPA axis without altering size at birth. However, the independent effects of periconceptional undernutrition and twinning on activity of the maternal and fetal HPA axes are not well described. We therefore studied maternal and fetal HPA axis function during late gestation in twin and singleton sheep pregnancies, either undernourished around conception or fed ad libitum. We found that twinning led to suppressed baseline HPA axis function and decreased adrenal sensitivity to ACTH stimulation but increased fetal pituitary ACTH response both to direct stimulation by CRH (ACTH area under the curve response: 29.7 +/- 2.2 vs. 17.1 +/- 1.6 ng/min x ml, P < 0.01) and to decreased cortisol negative feedback. In contrast, periconceptional undernutrition resulted in a decreased pituitary response (ACTH area under the curve response: 19.4 +/- 1.6 vs. 26.1 +/- 2.2 ng/min x ml, P = 0.02) but no difference in adrenal response. Thus, the HPA axis function of twin sheep fetuses in late gestation is very different from that of control and undernourished singletons. If the HPA axis is an important mediator between fetal adaptations and adult disease, these data may help explain why the relationship between fetal growth and postnatal physiology and disease risk is inconsistent in twins.

Is birth weight a risk factor for ischemic heart disease in later life?

BACKGROUND

An inverse association between birth weight and ischemic heart disease (IHD) has been seen in observational studies.

OBJECTIVE

We wanted to determine the strength and consistency of the association between birth weight and subsequent IHD.

DESIGN

We conducted a systematic review of observational studies.

RESULTS

Seventeen published studies of birth weight and subsequent IHD were identified that included a total of 144,794 singletons. Relative risk estimates for the association between birth weight and IHD were available from 16 of these studies. Additional data from 2 unpublished studies of 3801 persons were also included. In total, the analyses included data from 18 studies on 4210 nonfatal and 3308 fatal IHD events in 147,009 persons. The mean weighted estimate for the association between birth weight and the combined outcome of nonfatal and fatal IHD was 0.84 (95% CI: 0.81, 0.88) per kilogram of birth weight (P<0.0001). No significant heterogeneity was observed between estimates in different studies (P=0.09), nor was there evidence of publication bias (P=0.3, Begg test). Neither restricting the analysis to fatal IHD events nor adjusting for socioeconomic status had any appreciable effect on the findings.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings are consistent with a 1 kg higher birth weight being associated with a 10-20% lower risk of subsequent IHD. However, even if causal, interventions to increase birth weight are unlikely to reduce the incidence of IHD materially. Further studies are needed to determine whether the observed association reflects a stronger underlying association with a related exposure or is due (at least in part) to residual confounding.

The influence of birth weight and genetic factors on lipid levels: a study in adult twins

Twins can be used to investigate the biological basis for observed associations between birth weight and later disease risk, as they experiencein uterogrowth restriction compared with singletons, which can differ in magnitude within twin pairs despite partial or total genetic identity. In the present study, sixty monozygotic and seventy-one dizygotic same-sex twin pairs aged 19–50 years and eighty-nine singleton controls matched for age, gestational age, sex, maternal age and parity were recruited from an obstetric database. Associations between fasting lipid levels and birth weight were assessed by linear regression with adjustment for possible confounding factors. Twins were significantly lighter at birth but were not significantly different in adult height, weight or lipid levels from the singleton controls. There was a significant inverse association between birth weight and both total and LDL-cholesterol levels among singleton controls (−0·53mmol/l per kg (95% CI −0·97, −0·09),P=0·02 and −0·39mmol/l per kg (95% CI −0·76, −0·02),P=0·04, respectively), but there was no significant association between birth weight and lipid levels in either unpaired or within-pair analysis of twins. The results suggest that thein uterogrowth restriction and early catch-up growth experienced by twins does not increase the risk of an atherogenic lipid profile in adult life.

Associations of gestational age and intrauterine growth with systolic blood pressure in a family-based study of 386,485 men in 331,089 families

BACKGROUND

We conducted a family-based study to explore mechanisms underlying the associations of birth weight and gestational age with systolic blood pressure measured at 17 to 19 years of age.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A record linkage study of 386,485 singleton-born men from 331,089 families was undertaken. Birth weight was inversely associated with systolic blood pressure within siblings, with a mean difference (adjusted for age at examination, examination center, and year of examination) within siblings per 1-SD difference in birth weight of -0.21 mm Hg (95% CI, -0.33 to -0.08) and between nonsiblings of -0.12 (95% CI, -0.16 to -0.08). Gestational age was inversely associated with systolic blood pressure within siblings (-0.18 mm Hg; 95% CI, -0.25 to -0.11, per week of gestational age) and between nonsiblings (-0.26 mm Hg; 95% CI, -0.29 to -0.24). Adjustment for socioeconomic position and maternal characteristics did not alter these within- or between-family associations. Furthermore, the associations were not affected by adjustment for paternal height, body mass index, or systolic blood pressure.

CONCLUSIONS

Our present findings suggest that the inverse associations of birth weight and gestational age with systolic blood pressure are not explained by confounding resulting from family socioeconomic position or other factors that are shared by siblings. Variations in maternal metabolic or vascular health during pregnancy or placental implantation and function may explain these associations.

Low birth weight is not associated with thyroid autoimmunity: a population-based twin study

CONTEXT

Low birth weight has been proposed as a risk factor for the development of antibodies toward thyroid peroxidase (TPOAb) and thyroglobulin (TgAb) in adult life. However, the association could also be due to genetic or environmental factors affecting both birth weight and the development of thyroid autoantibodies. The effect of these confounders can be minimized through investigation of twin pairs.

OBJECTIVE AND DESIGN

To examine the impact of low birth weight on the development of thyroid autoimmunity, we studied whether within-twin-cohort and within-twin-pair differences in birth weight are associated with differences in the serum concentration of TPOAb and TgAb in adult life.

PARTICIPANTS

We studied 1024 euthyroid twin individuals who were distributed in 512 same-sex twin pairs.

METHODS

Original midwife protocols were traced manually through the Provincial Archives of Denmark. TPOAb and TgAb were measured using solid-phase time-resolved fluoroimmunometric assays.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant associations between birth weight and serum concentrations of TPOAb [regression coefficient (beta) = 0.003 (95% confidence interval, -0.010 to 0.015); P = 0.67] or TgAb [beta = 0.002 (-0.010 to 0.014); P = 0.77]. When restricting the analysis to twin pairs with a within-pair difference in birth weight of 500 g or greater or to twin pairs born 4 wk or more before term, the regression coefficients were almost unchanged. Controlling for potential confounders (sex, zygosity, gestational age, TSH, and smoking) did not change the findings of nonsignificant regression coefficients.

CONCLUSION

Low birth weight per se has no evident role in the etiology of thyroid autoimmunity.

Intrauterine growth and intelligence within sibling pairs: findings from the Aberdeen children of the 1950s cohort

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to examine whether the established positive association between birth weight and childhood psychometric intelligence is seen within singleton sibling pairs from the same family as well as between nonsiblings.

METHODS

We examined the association of intrauterine growth (measured as birth weight standardized for gender and gestational age) with psychometric intelligence (measured using the Moray House picture test) at 7 years old in a birth cohort of 9792 individuals who were singleton births occurring in Aberdeen, Scotland, between 1950 and 1956. We further compared this association within siblings with that between nonsiblings in the cohort; this family-based analysis included 1645 sibling pairs (N = 3290 individuals).

RESULTS

There was a positive linear association between birth weight and childhood psychometric intelligence at age 7 in the whole cohort, which remained with adjustment for a range of potential confounding factors. A one standard deviation increase in birth weight for gestational age z score was associated with a greater intelligence score in a regression model adjusting for sex, year of birth, paternal social class, maternal height, age, gravidity, and birth outside of marriage. The mean age difference between the siblings within each family pair was 2.2 years. In the family-based analysis there was no strong association between birth weight for gestation age z score and intelligence within sibling pairs from the same family, but there was a positive association between nonsiblings; the difference in these effects being unlikely to be due to chance. With additional adjustment for social class, maternal height, age, gravidity, and birth outside of marriage, the within-sibling pair effect was unaltered and the nonsibling effect attenuated, although an apparently robust positive association remained. In these adjusted analyses there was still evidence that the within-sibling effect differed from that between nonsiblings. We found no evidence that the main effects or the family-based analyses differed between males and females.

DISCUSSION

Our family-based analyses are consistent with one previous large family-based study that included >2500 sibling pairs and found no within-sibling-pairs association between birth weight and childhood intelligence, but did not make a direct statistical comparison between the within-sibling-pairs association and that between nonsiblings. In a second large study that included only sibling pairs of the same sex, in males there was a within-sibling-pairs association between birth weight and childhood intelligence. However, for females there was no within-sibling-pairs association. The authors commented that this sex difference was puzzling and needed replication. Although we had less power than this earlier study to assess sex differences, the point estimates and statistical tests in our study suggested that there was no sex difference.

CONCLUSIONS

The lack of any association within sibling pairs from the same family suggests that the association between birth weight and childhood intelligence in the general population of singletons is largely explained by fixed family factors that are closely matched in siblings of a similar age. These factors include family socioeconomic characteristics, parental education and intelligence, genetic factors and fixed maternal factors, such as her behaviors, size, and metabolic and cardiovascular health that are constant from one pregnancy to the next and could therefore affect her offspring growth and intelligence across all pregnancies.

Birth weight is associated with salivary cortisol responses to psychosocial stress in adult life

Fetal programming of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis was proposed as one mechanism underlying the link between prenatal stress, adverse birth outcomes (particularly low birth weight) and an enhanced vulnerability for several diseases later in life. In recent studies, birth weight was significantly related to basal cortisol levels as well as to cortisol responses to pharmacological stimulation. In order to investigate the association between cortisol responses to psychological challenge, birth weight and length of gestation, 106 young healthy males were exposed to the 'Trier Social Stress Test'. Salivary cortisol responses to the stress exposure were significantly and inversely related to the subjects' birth weight, while the analysis of the impact of gestational age yielded inconsistent results. This finding is consistent with the concept of fetal programming of the HPA axis and provides the first preliminary evidence for an association between birth weight and adrenocortical responses to psychosocial stress. As the investigated subjects were twins, possible implications of this sample characteristic for the present findings are discussed.

Genetic and environmental influences on birthweight in a sample of Korean twins

This study is the first report of genetic and environmental influences on birthweight using Korean twins. The sample consisted of 255 monozygotic (MZ) and 178 dizygotic (DZ) twin pairs drawn from the Seoul Twin Family Study. Intraclass twin correlations were computed for the twins' birthweights obtained from parents (typically mothers) of the twins. To estimate genetic and shared and nonshared environmental influences on birthweight, standard univariate model-fitting analyses were performed using a software, Mx. For each gender, MZ twin correlations were higher than DZ twin correlations, suggesting existence of genetic influences on birthweight; however, DZ twin correlations were higher than half the MZ twin correlations, indicating that shared environmental factors are also important. For each zygosity, twin correlations were not significantly different between males and females, implicating that genes and environments that cause individual differences in birthweight may not vary between males and females. Model-fitting analyses based on the data pooled across gender yielded estimates of 17% for genetic, 60% for shared environmental, and 23% for nonshared environmental influences on birthweight.

Developmental origins of the metabolic syndrome: prediction, plasticity, and programming

The "fetal" or "early" origins of adult disease hypothesis was originally put forward by David Barker and colleagues and stated that environmental factors, particularly nutrition, act in early life to program the risks for adverse health outcomes in adult life. This hypothesis has been supported by a worldwide series of epidemiological studies that have provided evidence for the association between the perturbation of the early nutritional environment and the major risk factors (hypertension, insulin resistance, and obesity) for cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and the metabolic syndrome in adult life. It is also clear from experimental studies that a range of molecular, cellular, metabolic, neuroendocrine, and physiological adaptations to changes in the early nutritional environment result in a permanent alteration of the developmental pattern of cellular proliferation and differentiation in key tissue and organ systems that result in pathological consequences in adult life. This review focuses on those experimental studies that have investigated the critical windows during which perturbations of the intrauterine environment have major effects, the nature of the epigenetic, structural, and functional adaptive responses which result in a permanent programming of cardiovascular and metabolic function, and the role of the interaction between the pre- and postnatal environment in determining final health outcomes.

Fetal programming: the perspective of single and twin pregnancies

Multiple pregnancy is associated with increased risk of adverse consequences for both mother and fetus(es), including increased rates of maternal hypertension and pre-eclampsia, spontaneous abortion, Caesarean delivery, low birthweight, birth prematurity, perinatal mortality, admission to neonatal intensive care and extended length of care, respiratory distress, cerebral palsy, developmental delay, contact with disability services and mortality to age 5 years. Premature birth, which affects 97% of triplets and 53.3% of twins in Australia, is not the sole factor involved. The rate of multiple pregnancy in Australia is 1.7%. This compares to 22.1% for pregnancies resulting from assisted reproduction technology (ART). As a result, 21.8% of babies born from ART are from a multiple pregnancy, in comparison to the USA where the majority of babies born from ART are from a multiple pregnancy. Additionally, the population rate of multiple births is rising due to the more frequent use of ART and continued multi-embryo transfers, which is operating against a background of rising implantation rates within ART clinics. Twins have been of interest from a programming perspective. However, analysis of associations between crude birthweight and subsequent metabolic risk factors or mortality in adulthood from chronic disease indicate that adaptations in pregnancy to support multi-fetal growth are not identical to fetal growth restriction in singleton pregnancies. Indeed, the process of ‘maternal constraint’ is incompletely understood and confounds such comparisons. From a programming perspective, it is a challenge to identify in twin pregnancies the transition from physiological adaptation to pathological growth restriction. Growth disparity between twins has been more illuminating of subtle adverse effects for the smaller of twin pairs in both blood pressure and insulin resistance in adulthood. Interestingly, these effects can be observed in both dizygotic and to a lesser degree in monozygotic twins, which indicates a role for both genetic and environmental factors in these measures. This suggests that, consistent with experimental studies in other species, the relationship between impaired growth in utero and chronic disease in later life is not simply mediated by a common genetic pathway.

Maternal antenatal anxiety and behavioural/emotional problems in children: a test of a programming hypothesis

BACKGROUND

Previous animal investigations link antenatal stress with a range of persistent behavioural abnormalities in the offspring. The current study examined if the effect was also found in humans through middle childhood.

METHODS

The current study is based on the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC), a prospective, community-based study that has followed a cohort of women from pregnancy. Self-report measures of maternal anxiety and depression were assessed at repeated intervals in pregnancy and the postnatal period. Children's behavioural/emotional problems were assessed by parent report at age 47 and 81 months. Information on obstetric and psychosocial factors was obtained at several points in pregnancy and the postnatal period.

RESULTS

Children whose mothers experienced high levels of anxiety in late pregnancy exhibited higher rates of behavioural/emotional problems at 81 months of age after controlling for obstetric risks, psychosocial disadvantage, and postnatal anxiety and depression (for girls, OR = 1.91, 95%CI = 1.26-2.89; for boys, OR = 2.16, 95%CI = 1.41-3.30). Furthermore, the effect at 81 months was comparable to what was previously obtained at 47 months, suggesting the kind of persistent effect proposed in the animal literature.

CONCLUSIONS

There is evidence that antenatal stress/anxiety has a programming effect on the fetus which lasts at least until middle childhood.

The influence of maternal BMI and age in twin pregnancies on insulin resistance in the offspring

OBJECTIVE

There is strong evidence that low birth weight is associated with glucose intolerance and diabetes in adults. We have carried out a twin study to distinguish among maternal influences, which affect both twins; fetoplacental influences, which are unique to each twin; and the genetic factors that may underlie this association.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

We identified a sample of 423 twin pairs (250 monozygotic and 173 dizygotic) from the East Flanders Prospective Twin Survey who were born between 1964 and 1982. Data collected in this study included the mother's body composition and weight gain during pregnancy, the twins' birth weights, and gestational age. The twins (aged 18-34 years) attended a research center for measurement of height, weight, and waist-to-hip ratio as well as fasting glucose, proinsulin, and insulin concentrations.

RESULTS

Among twin pairs discordant for birth weight, we found little evidence that the lighter twin had abnormal glucose-insulin metabolism in adult life. However, both a low prepregnancy maternal BMI and older maternal age at delivery were associated with hyperinsulinemia and evidence of insulin resistance in the offspring. Fasting insulin increased by 1.3% (95% CI 0.1-2.6%) per unit fall in maternal BMI and by 1.1% (0.02-2.0%) per year increase in maternal age. These associations were independent of the twins' BMI and waist-to-hip ratio and their zygosity.

CONCLUSIONS

These novel findings suggest that in twin pregnancies, maternal factors are more important than fetoplacental factors in determining glucose-insulin metabolism in the offspring.