The utility of next-generation sequencing technologies in diagnosis of Mendelian mitochondrial diseases and reflections on clinical spectrum

Critically unwell infants and children with mitochondrial disorders diagnosed by ultrarapid genomic sequencing

PURPOSE

To characterize the diagnostic and clinical outcomes of a cohort of critically ill infants and children with suspected mitochondrial disorders (MD) undergoing ultrarapid genomic testing as part of a national program.

METHODS

Ultrarapid genomic sequencing was performed in 454 families (genome sequencing: n = 290, exome sequencing +/- mitochondrial DNA sequencing: n = 164). In 91 individuals, MD was considered, prompting analysis using an MD virtual gene panel. These individuals were reviewed retrospectively and scored according to modified Nijmegen Mitochondrial Disease Criteria.

RESULTS

A diagnosis was achieved in 47% (43/91) of individuals, 40% (17/43) of whom had an MD. Seven additional individuals in whom an MD was not suspected were diagnosed with an MD after broader analysis. Gene-agnostic analysis led to the discovery of 2 novel disease genes, with pathogenicity validated through targeted functional studies (CRLS1 and MRPL39). Functional studies enabled diagnosis in another 4 individuals. Of the 24 individuals ultimately diagnosed with an MD, 79% had a change in management, which included 53% whose care was redirected to palliation.

CONCLUSION

Ultrarapid genetic diagnosis of MD in acutely unwell infants and children is critical for guiding decisions about the need for additional investigations and clinical management.

Concordance Between Biochemical and Molecular Diagnosis Obtained by WES in Mexican Patients with Inborn Errors of Intermediary Metabolism: Utility for Therapeutic Management

Biochemical phenotyping has been the milestone for diagnosing and managing patients affected by inborn errors of intermediary metabolism (IEiM); however, identifying the genotype responsible for these monogenic disorders greatly contributes to achieving these goals. Herein, whole-exome sequencing (WES) was used to determine the genotypes of 95 unrelated Mexican pediatric patients suspected of having IEiM. They were classified into those bearing specific biochemical abnormalities (Group 1), and those presenting unspecific biochemical profiles (Group 2). The overall concordance between the initial biochemical diagnosis and final genotypic diagnoses was 72.6% (N = 69/95 patients), with the highest concordance achieved in Group 1 (91.3%, N = 63/69), whereas the concordance was limited in Group 2 (23.07%). This finding suggests that previous biochemical phenotyping correlated with the high WES diagnostic success. Concordance was high for urea cycle disorders (94.1%) and organic acid disorders (77.4%). The identified mutational spectrum comprised 83 IEiM-relevant variants (pathogenic, likely pathogenic, and variants of uncertain significance or VUS), including three novel ones, distributed among 29 different genes responsible for amino acid, organic acid, urea cycle, carbohydrate, and lipid disorders. Inconclusive WES results (7.3%, N = 7/95) relied on monoallelic pathogenic genotypes or those involving two VUS for autosomal-recessive IEiMs. A second monogenic disease was observed in 10.5% (N = 10/95) of the patients. According to the WES results, modifications in treatment had to be made in 33.6% (N = 32/95) of patients, mainly attributed to the presence of a second monogenic disease, or to an actionable trait. This study includes the largest cohort of Mexican patients to date with biochemically suspected IEiM who were genetically diagnosed through WES, underscoring its importance in medical management.

Inborn errors of the malate aspartate shuttle - Update on patients and cellular models

The malate aspartate shuttle (MAS) plays a pivotal role in transporting cytosolic reducing equivalents - electrons - into the mitochondria for energy conversion at the electron transport chain (ETC) and in the process of oxidative phosphorylation. The MAS consists of two pairs of cytosolic and mitochondrial isoenzymes (malate dehydrogenases 1 and 2; and glutamate oxaloacetate transaminases 1 and 2) and two transporters (malate-2-oxoglutarate carrier and aspartate glutamate carrier (AGC), the latter of which has two tissue-dependent isoforms AGC1 and AGC2). While the inner mitochondrial membrane is impermeable to NADH, the MAS forms one of the main routes for mitochondrial electron uptake by promoting uptake of malate. Inherited bi-allelic pathogenic variants in five of the seven components of the MAS have been described hitherto and cause a wide spectrum of symptoms including early-onset epileptic encephalopathy. This review provides an overview of reported patients suffering from MAS deficiencies. In addition, we give an overview of diagnostic procedures and research performed on patient-derived cellular models and tissues. Current cellular models are briefly discussed and novel ways to achieve a better understanding of MAS deficiencies are highlighted.

Pathological mutations promote proteolysis of mitochondrial tRNA-specific 2-thiouridylase 1 (MTU1) via mitochondrial caseinolytic peptidase (CLPP)

MTU1 controls intramitochondrial protein synthesis by catalyzing the 2-thiouridine modification of mitochondrial transfer RNAs (mt-tRNAs). Missense mutations in the MTU1 gene are associated with life-threatening reversible infantile hepatic failure. However, the molecular pathogenesis is not well understood. Here, we investigated 17 mutations associated with this disease, and our results showed that most disease-related mutations are partial loss-of-function mutations, with three mutations being particularly severe. Mutant MTU1 is rapidly degraded by mitochondrial caseinolytic peptidase (CLPP) through a direct interaction with its chaperone protein CLPX. Notably, knockdown of CLPP significantly increased mutant MTU1 protein expression and mt-tRNA 2-thiolation, suggesting that accelerated proteolysis of mutant MTU1 plays a role in disease pathogenesis. In addition, molecular dynamics simulations demonstrated that disease-associated mutations may lead to abnormal intermolecular interactions, thereby impairing MTU1 enzyme activity. Finally, clinical data analysis underscores a significant correlation between patient prognosis and residual 2-thiolation levels, which is partially consistent with the AlphaMissense predictions. These findings provide a comprehensive understanding of MTU1-related diseases, offering prospects for modification-based diagnostics and novel therapeutic strategies centered on targeting CLPP.

Clinical and bi-genomic DNA findings of patients suspected to have mitochondrial diseases

Background: Mitochondrial diseases are the most common group of inherited metabolic disorders, causing difficulties in definite diagnosis due to clinical and genetic heterogeneity. Clinical components are predominantly associated with pathogenic variants shown in nuclear or mitochondrial genomes that affect vital respiratory chain function. The development of high-throughput sequencing technologies has accelerated the elucidation of the genetic etiology of many genetic diseases that previously remained undiagnosed. Methods: Thirty affected patients from 24 unrelated families with clinical, radiological, biochemical, and histopathological evaluations considered for mitochondrial diseases were investigated. DNA isolated from the peripheral blood samples of probands was sequenced for nuclear exome and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analyses. MtDNA sequencing was also performed from the muscle biopsy material in one patient. For segregation, Sanger sequencing is performed for pathogenic alterations in five other affected family members and healthy parents. Results: Exome sequencing revealed 14 different pathogenic variants in nine genes encoding mitochondrial function peptides (AARS2, EARS2, ECHS1, FBXL4, MICOS13, NDUFAF6, OXCT1, POLG, and TK2) in 12 patients from nine families and four variants in genes encoding important for muscle structure (CAPN3, DYSF, and TCAP) in six patients from four families. Three probands carried pathogenic mtDNA variations in two genes (MT-ATP6 and MT-TL1). Nine variants in five genes are reported for the first time with disease association: (AARS2: c.277C>T/p.(R93*), c.845C>G/p.(S282C); EARS2: c.319C>T/p.(R107C), c.1283delC/p.(P428Lfs*); ECHS1: c.161G>A/p.(R54His); c.202G>A/p.(E68Lys); NDUFAF6: c.479delA/p.(N162Ifs*27); and OXCT1: c.1370C>T/p.(T457I), c.1173-139G>T/p.(?). Conclusion: Bi-genomic DNA sequencing clarified genetic etiology in 67% (16/24) of the families. Diagnostic utility by mtDNA sequencing in 13% (3/24) and exome sequencing in 54% (13/24) of the families prioritized searching for nuclear genome pathologies for the first-tier test. Weakness and muscle wasting observed in 17% (4/24) of the families underlined that limb-girdle muscular dystrophy, similar to mitochondrial myopathy, is an essential point for differential diagnosis. The correct diagnosis is crucial for comprehensive genetic counseling of families. Also, it contributes to making treatment-helpful referrals, such as ensuring early access to medication for patients with mutations in the TK2 gene.

Genotypic and phenotypic spectrum of infantile liver failure due to pathogenic TRMU variants

PURPOSE

This study aimed to define the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum of reversible acute liver failure (ALF) of infancy resulting from biallelic pathogenic TRMU variants and determine the role of cysteine supplementation in its treatment.

METHODS

Individuals with biallelic (likely) pathogenic variants in TRMU were studied within an international retrospective collection of de-identified patient data.

RESULTS

In 62 individuals, including 30 previously unreported cases, we described 47 (likely) pathogenic TRMU variants, of which 17 were novel, and 1 intragenic deletion. Of these 62 individuals, 42 were alive at a median age of 6.8 (0.6-22) years after a median follow-up of 3.6 (0.1-22) years. The most frequent finding, occurring in all but 2 individuals, was liver involvement. ALF occurred only in the first year of life and was reported in 43 of 62 individuals; 11 of whom received liver transplantation. Loss-of-function TRMU variants were associated with poor survival. Supplementation with at least 1 cysteine source, typically N-acetylcysteine, improved survival significantly. Neurodevelopmental delay was observed in 11 individuals and persisted in 4 of the survivors, but we were unable to determine whether this was a primary or a secondary consequence of TRMU deficiency.

CONCLUSION

In most patients, TRMU-associated ALF was a transient, reversible disease and cysteine supplementation improved survival.

Whole genome sequencing diagnostic yield for paediatric patients with suspected genetic disorders: systematic review, meta-analysis, and GRADE assessment

BACKGROUND

About 80% of the roughly 7,000 known rare diseases are single gene disorders, about 85% of which are ultra-rare, affecting less than one in one million individuals. NGS technologies, in particular whole genome sequencing (WGS) in paediatric patients suffering from severe disorders of likely genetic origin improve the diagnostic yield allowing targeted, effective care and management. The aim of this study is to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis to assess the effectiveness of WGS, with respect to whole exome sequencing (WES) and/or usual care, for the diagnosis of suspected genetic disorders among the paediatric population.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was conducted querying relevant electronic databases, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, ISI Web of Science, and Scopus from January 2010 to June 2022. A random-effect meta-analysis was run to inspect the diagnostic yield of different techniques. A network meta-analysis was also performed to directly assess the comparison between WGS and WES.

RESULTS

Of the 4,927 initially retrieved articles, thirty-nine met the inclusion criteria. Overall results highlighted a significantly higher pooled diagnostic yield for WGS, 38.6% (95% CI: [32.6 - 45.0]), in respect to WES, 37.8% (95% CI: [32.9 - 42.9]) and usual care, 7.8% (95% CI: [4.4 - 13.2]). The meta-regression output suggested a higher diagnostic yield of the WGS compared to WES after controlling for the type of disease (monogenic vs non-monogenic), with a tendency to better diagnostic performances for Mendelian diseases. The network meta-analysis showed a higher diagnostic yield for WGS compared to WES (OR = 1.54, 95%CI: [1.11 - 2.12]).

CONCLUSIONS

Although whole genome sequencing for the paediatric population with suspected genetic disorders provided an accurate and early genetic diagnosis in a high proportion of cases, further research is needed for evaluating costs, effectiveness, and cost-effectiveness of WGS and achieving an informed decision-making process.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

This systematic review has not been registered.

Challenges of genetic diagnosis of inborn errors of metabolism in a major tertiary care center in Lebanon

Background: Inborn errors of metabolism are rare genetic disorders; however, these are prevalent in countries with high consanguinity rates, like Lebanon. Patients are suspected, based on a combination of clinical and biochemical features; however, the final confirmation relies on genetic testing. Using next generation sequencing, as a new genetic investigational tool, carries several challenges for the physician, the geneticist, and the families. Methods: In this retrospective study, we analyzed the clinical, biochemical, and genetic profile of inborn errors of metabolism suspected patients, seen at a major tertiary care center in Lebanon, between 2015 and 2018. Genetic testing was performed using next generation sequencing. Genotype-phenotype correlation and diagnostic yield of each testing modality were studied. Results: Out of 211 patients genetically tested, 126 were suspected to have an inborn error of metabolism. The diagnostic yield of next generation sequencing reached 64.3%. Single gene testing was requested in 53%, whole exome sequencing in 36% and gene panels in 10%. Aminoacid disorders were mostly diagnosed followed by storage disorders, organic acidemias and mitochondrial diseases. Targeted testing was performed in 77% of aminoacid and organic acid disorders and half of suspected storage disorders. Single gene sequencing was positive in 75%, whereas whole exome sequencing diagnostic yield for complex cases, like mitochondrial disorders, reached 49%. Good clinical and biochemical correlation allowed the interpretation of variants of unknown significance and negative mutations as well as therapeutic management of most patients. Conclusion: Tailoring the choice of test modality, by next generation sequencing, to the category of suspected inborn errors of metabolism may lead to rapid diagnosis, shortcutting the cost of repeated testing. Whole exome sequencing as a first-tier investigation may be considered mainly for suspected mitochondrial diseases, whereas targeted sequencing can be offered upon suspicion of a specific enzyme deficiency. Timing and modality of gene test remain challenging, in view of the cost incurred by families.

Ketogenic Diet Treatment of Defects in the Mitochondrial Malate Aspartate Shuttle and Pyruvate Carrier

The mitochondrial malate aspartate shuttle system (MAS) maintains the cytosolic NAD+/NADH redox balance, thereby sustaining cytosolic redox-dependent pathways, such as glycolysis and serine biosynthesis. Human disease has been associated with defects in four MAS-proteins (encoded by MDH1, MDH2, GOT2, SLC25A12) sharing a neurological/epileptic phenotype, as well as citrin deficiency (SLC25A13) with a complex hepatopathic-neuropsychiatric phenotype. Ketogenic diets (KD) are high-fat/low-carbohydrate diets, which decrease glycolysis thus bypassing the mentioned defects. The same holds for mitochondrial pyruvate carrier (MPC) 1 deficiency, which also presents neurological deficits. We here describe 40 (18 previously unreported) subjects with MAS-/MPC1-defects (32 neurological phenotypes, eight citrin deficiency), describe and discuss their phenotypes and genotypes (presenting 12 novel variants), and the efficacy of KD. Of 13 MAS/MPC1-individuals with a neurological phenotype treated with KD, 11 experienced benefits-mainly a striking effect against seizures. Two individuals with citrin deficiency deceased before the correct diagnosis was established, presumably due to high-carbohydrate treatment. Six citrin-deficient individuals received a carbohydrate-restricted/fat-enriched diet and showed normalisation of laboratory values/hepatopathy as well as age-adequate thriving. We conclude that patients with MAS-/MPC1-defects are amenable to dietary intervention and that early (genetic) diagnosis is key for initiation of proper treatment and can even be lifesaving.

AGC1 Deficiency: Pathology and Molecular and Cellular Mechanisms of the Disease

AGC1/Aralar/Slc25a12 is the mitochondrial carrier of aspartate-glutamate, the regulatory component of the NADH malate-aspartate shuttle (MAS) that transfers cytosolic redox power to neuronal mitochondria. The deficiency in AGC1/Aralar leads to the human rare disease named "early infantile epileptic encephalopathy 39" (EIEE 39, OMIM # 612949) characterized by epilepsy, hypotonia, arrested psychomotor neurodevelopment, hypo myelination and a drastic drop in brain aspartate (Asp) and N-acetylaspartate (NAA). Current evidence suggest that neurons are the main brain cell type expressing Aralar. However, paradoxically, glial functions such as myelin and Glutamine (Gln) synthesis are markedly impaired in AGC1 deficiency. Herein, we discuss the role of the AGC1/Aralar-MAS pathway in neuronal functions such as Asp and NAA synthesis, lactate use, respiration on glucose, glutamate (Glu) oxidation and other neurometabolic aspects. The possible mechanism triggering the pathophysiological findings in AGC1 deficiency, such as epilepsy and postnatal hypomyelination observed in humans and mice, are also included. Many of these mechanisms arise from findings in the aralar-KO mice model that extensively recapitulate the human disease including the astroglial failure to synthesize Gln and the dopamine (DA) mishandling in the nigrostriatal system. Epilepsy and DA mishandling are a direct consequence of the metabolic defect in neurons due to AGC1/Aralar deficiency. However, the deficits in myelin and Gln synthesis may be a consequence of neuronal affectation or a direct effect of AGC1/Aralar deficiency in glial cells. Further research is needed to clarify this question and delineate the transcellular metabolic fluxes that control brain functions. Finally, we discuss therapeutic approaches successfully used in AGC1-deficient patients and mice.

A novel compound heterozygous mutation of the MTO1 gene associated with complex oxidative phosphorylation deficiency type 10

BACKGROUND

The mitochondrial tRNA translation optimization 1 (MTO1) gene, which is closely related to defective mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation, is an evolutionarily conserved protein expressed in high energy-demanding tissues and is associated with complex oxidative phosphorylation deficiency type 10 (COXPD10) in humans. Related cases and studies are still scarce and have not been reported in the Chinese region.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Detailed clinical assessment was applied to the patient. Based on next-generation sequencing technology, we performed whole-exome sequencing of the patient and the parents. Sanger sequencing was used for validation. Bioinformatics software and protein simulations were used to predict the pathogenicity of the variants.

RESULTS

The patient was diagnosed with a possible association with mitochondrial disease according to the clinical manifestations and physical examination. A novel frameshift mutation c.344delA (p. Asn115Thrfs*11) and a novel point mutation c.1055C > T (p. Thr352Met) in the MTO1 gene were identified. They were found to cause abnormal changes in amino acids and the protein by biochemical tools, indicating it may be pathogenic.

CONCLUSION

We present two novel and possibly pathogenic variants in the MTO1 gene in a Chinese Han family.