Calculus attachment. Review of the literature and new findings

Subgingival scaling and root planing during minimally invasive periodontal surgery: A randomized controlled split-mouth trial

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this randomized, controlled split-mouth study was to evaluate a videoscope as a visual adjunct to scaling and root planing when utilized in combination with minimally invasive surgery.

METHODS

Twenty-five pairs (89 interproximal surfaces) of periodontally hopeless teeth planned for extraction were scaled and root planed with minimal surgical access using surgical loupes (control) or adjunctive use of a videoscope (test). Teeth were extracted with minimal trauma, stained with methylene blue, and photographed with a digital microscope for analysis. The primary outcome of residual calculus was calculated as a percentage of the total interproximal area of interest. Secondary outcomes included treatment time, as well as residual calculus according to probing depth, tooth location, and treatment date. Data were analyzed using Student's paired t-tests, two-way analyses of variance, and Spearman's correlation tests.

RESULTS

Residual calculus area was 2.61% on control and 2.71% on test surfaces with no significant difference between groups. Subgroup analysis showed no difference in residual calculus between groups at moderate or deep sites. Treatment time per surface was significantly longer in the test group compared to the control group. Treatment order, tooth location, and operator experience did not significantly affect the primary outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

Though the videoscope provided excellent visual access, it did not improve the efficacy of root planing for flat interproximal surfaces during minimally invasive periodontal surgery. Small amounts of calculus remain after instrumentation even with minimal surgical access and when root surfaces appear visually clean and tactilely smooth.

Accuracy of dental calculus detection using digital radiography and image manipulation

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to determine if image enhancement improves a clinician's ability to identify the presence of calculus on digital radiographs.

METHODS

Seventy-one hopeless teeth were collected from 34 patients. Teeth were stained with 1% methylene blue, the largest interproximal calculus deposit was scored, and photographs of each interproximal root surface were taken. The surface area of calculus deposit was determined as a percentage of the total interproximal root surface area. Digital radiographs of teeth taken before extraction were modified using the following enhancements: auto-contrast, emboss, invert, and sharpen. Radiographic presence of calculus was determined by two examiners. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were calculated for each examiner and enhancement. A receiver operating characteristic curve was used to compare differences between the image enhancements in the detection of dental calculus. The kappa statistic was used to compare ratings between examiners.

RESULTS

None of the enhanced images were statistically superior to original images in identifying radiographic calculus (P > 0.05). The average sensitivity of digital radiography was 50%, average specificity was 82.2%, PPV was 94%, and NPV 23.2%. A threshold of >30% of interproximal root surface covered with calculus and increasing size of deposits were associated with improved detection (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Digital enhancements do not significantly improve radiographic detection of dental calculus. As area of calculus on the root surface and size of calculus deposits increased, sensitivity of detection also increased.

Comparison of Root Surface Roughness Produced By Hand Instruments and Ultrasonic Scalers: An Invitro Study

BACKGROUND

Instrumentation on tooth surface for debridement of hard and soft debris forms the basis of periodontal therapy. This involves periodic removal of accumulated material using different methods of instrumentation. An ideal instrument should eliminate all the deposits from the root surfaces with no or minimal alteration of the natural morphology.

AIM

To compare the root surface roughness after root planing performed with gracey curette and by ultrasonic scalers (Satelec P-5 Booster) set at different power modes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The root surface roughness and its surface microtopography resulting from the use of Gracey curette, ultrasonic instrument at low, medium and high power setting on 35 healthy premolars extracted for orthodontic treatment purpose were examined using Optical Profilometer and the surface topography was assessed using Field Emission Microscope.

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) test was used to observe the variance in a particular variable is partitioned into components attributable to different sources of variation. Duncan multiple range tests were used to determine whether three or more means differ significantly.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

The mean roughness was found to be the highest in group where Scaling and Root Planing (SRP) was performed using ultrasonic scaler at low power mode (3.03±1.54 μm) whereas the lowest surface roughness was seen on the samples where SRP was performed using ultrasonic scaler at medium power mode. The surface roughness in group where SRP was performed with ultrasonic scaler at high power mode (2.22±0.74μm) was found to be similar to that of group in which root planing was carried out using curette (2.24±1.71μm).

Ultrastructural study of calculus–enamel and calculus–root interfaces

The attachment of dental calculus to the tooth (enamel or cementum) surface affects the ease or difficulty of its removal. Understanding the ultrastructural features of the calculus-tooth interface will help in the development of efficient strategies for efficient removal of dental calculus.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine the ultrastructural characteristics of the calculus-tooth interface in relation to the occurrence of calculus fracture.

DESIGN

Investigation of the ultrastructural characteristics of the calculus-tooth interface was made on eight human molars with mature supragingival and subgingival calculus using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and fourier transform infra-red (FT-IR) spectroscopy.

RESULTS

Fractures were shown by SEM to consistently occur within the calculus itself, but not at the calculus-tooth interface. Higher magnification revealed that the enamel apatite crystals (in the case of supragingival calculus) or the cementum apatite crystals (in the case of subgingival calculus) appeared intimately connected with the calculus crystals at the calculus-enamel or calculus-cementum interface. TEM micrographs confirmed this intimate direct connection or fusion (epitaxial growth) of calculus crystals with enamel and cementum apatite crystals. FT-IR showed lower concentrations of organic phase attributed to microorganisms and higher concentrations of collagen at the calculus-cementum interface compared to that in the calculus away from the interface.

CONCLUSION

Difficulty in complete calculus removal from tooth surfaces (especially from cementum or dentin) may be due in part to the intimate contact between the calculus and the tooth, due to the chemical bonding between the calculus crystals and the tooth apatite crystals and occasional fusion (i.e., epitaxial growth) of the calculus calcium phosphate crystals with the enamel, dentin or apatite crystals. This cohesive bonding results in fracture planes occurring within the calculus instead of at the calculus-tooth interface.

Safety and efficiency of novel sonic scaler tips in vitro

BACKGROUND

The aim of the study was to evaluate a novel sonic scaler tip for subgingival root surface instrumentation combining high efficiency in calculus removal with minimized risk of root damage through subgingival debridement.

METHODS

A metal sonic scaler tip with a paddle-like working end covered with spheroid convexities of 0.8 mm diameter and 0.3 mm height was designed from the aspect of optimized adaptation to the root anatomy (tip-end dimension: 3.0 x 1.5 x 0.6 mm). Using a customary sonic scaler tip as control, instrument efficiency was quantified by measuring the time needed to completely remove calculus on extracted teeth (n=52) under standardized conditions. To quantify the amount of calculus removed, the mean calculus area per tooth was measured on photographs taken before instrumentation. The tips safety was evaluated instrumenting calculus-free root surfaces in vitro (n=18, lateral forces 0.5, 1, 2 N, 20 s instrumentation time, tip angulation 0 degrees ) with subsequent laser-optical determination of resulting root substance loss.

RESULTS

Debridement efficiency was significantly higher for the novel tip (0.78+/-0.81 mm2/s completely debrided) than for the conventional tip (0.42+/-0.33 mm2) (Mann-Whitney test, p<0.05). Concerning instrument safety, the novel tip caused significantly less root substance loss than the conventional tip.

CONCLUSION

The novel scaler tip appears to be significantly more efficient in calculus removal and less damaging to the root surface than the assessed conventional tip.

Effectiveness of a prescale gel on subgingival calculus

A prescale gel product, designed to facilitate the removal of calculus, has recently been introduced and marketed to the dental profession. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of this gel on the removal of subgingival calculus. 10 patients, each with 5 periodontally diseased teeth scheduled for extraction, participated in this in vivo/in vitro study. 4 teeth per patient were randomly assigned using a 2-by-2 block design and treated in vivo with either active or placebo gel, with or without scaling, prior to extraction. To assess possible overexposure to the product, 10 selected teeth from the sample were treated with active gel for an extended exposure time. Standardized scaling was performed on a 4x4 mm treated root area in vitro on groups as assigned. Quantification of residual calculus was determined by one examiner blind to treatment group assignment using SEM photomicrograph montages and the Java image analysis computer system. Repeated measures ANOVA showed no statistically significant treatment effect for gel (p > 0.05) in the scaled and no-scaled groups. The 5th group exposed to the prescale gel for an extended time was evaluated descriptively for root surface morphological changes with no noticeable effect. Based on the results of this investigation, treatment of subgingival calculus with prescale gel offers no advantage for calculus removal over scaling alone. The findings suggest no significant clinical impact of product use.

The hard tissue lesion revisited

Recent research indicates that the thorough removal of calculus is still a critical step in the treatment of periodontal disease. Surgical access facilitates this in deep pockets. Repair is mediated by a long junctional epithelium as microscopically total calculus removal is rarely achieved. In intrabony defects the apical portion of the root surface which has not attracted deposits of calculus has the potential for connective tissue reattachment and regeneration if care is taken to preserve collagen fibres still attached to the root.

The effectiveness of the Titan-S sonic scaler versus curettes in the removal of subgingival calculus. A human surgical evaluation

This study evaluated clinically the effectiveness of hand versus sonic subgingival scaling and root planing in the removal of calculus by visually examining the root surface at the time of periodontal flap surgery. Consideration was given to the method of instrumentation, probing depth, number of roots, and type of tooth surface. Eleven patients with moderate to advanced periodontal disease were evaluated. Four subjects were scaled and root planed with the Titan-S only, four with curettes only, and three with the Titan-S + curettes. At reevaluation 3 to 6 weeks after scaling and root planing, the decision to perform periodontal flap surgery was made based upon probing depth, bleeding upon probing, previous access to the root surface, furcation involvement, and the patient's level of oral hygiene. A full thickness mucoperiosteal flap was elevated to gain access to the root surface and measure the distance from the cementoenamel junction to the residual calculus. A total of 690 surfaces were evaluated surgically. The percentage of surfaces with residual calculus for each method of instrumentation was: Titan-S only (31.9%), curettes only (26.8%), and Titan-S + curettes (16.9%). Overall, 15.7% of the surfaces probing 0 to 3 mm, 29.3% of the surfaces probing 4 to 5 mm, and 44.4% of the surfaces probing 6 to 12 mm had residual calculus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Surface coatings on dental cementum incident to periodontal disease. (II). Scanning electron microscopic confirmation of a mineralized cuticle

Root surfaces, exposed by periodontal disease, were studied after treatment with sodium hypochlorite. Observations of the anorganic specimens demonstrated that substantial changes occur in root surfaces incident to periodontal disease. A mineralized surface coating was seen in all areas of the involved root surface, although local regions occurred where the coating was apparently unmineralized. These findings generally confirmed the results of a previous study where the same specimens were studied without hypochlorite treatment. It is concluded that the coating is probably identical to the dental cuticle, and stems from adsorption of components of the gingival inflammatory exudate to the root surface. The coating may also be the carrier matrix for exogenous cytotoxic substances, previously thought to be located in the cementum. The findings may have implications for the way of treating periodontitis-involved root surfaces.

Histological assessment of periodontally involved cementum

Contamination of periodontally involved cementum by bacterial substances such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) is considered a major reason for root planing. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the presence and location of lipid and polysaccharide within involved cementum as compared with uninvolved cementum. Frozen sections were prepared from the decalcified roots of 36 periodontally diseased and two control teeth. Serial sections were stained for either lipid (Oil-Red-O) or polysaccharide (Alcian Blue - PAS) and also with haematoxylin & eosin (H & E) or Huberstone's gram stain. Specimens of involved and uninvolved cementum were then examined under the light microscope for assessment of differences. Involved cementum from 12 of the periodontally diseased teeth exhibited strongly PAS-positive stained processes penetrating 3-7 mum into the surface of cementum from overlying plaque. Such processes were not observed in uninvolved cementum, suggesting a possible bacterial origin. Lipid granules were noted in only one involved specimen where they were situated up to 10 mum beneath the cemental surface. Similar granules were observed within plaque deposits but never in uninvolved cementum, again suggesting a possible bacterial origin. H & E and gram-stained specimens revealed the presence of microbial deposits in surface defects and within defects at the cemento-dentinal junction (CDJ), as well as penetration of micro-organisms into cementum in the absence of any surface defects. The results indicate that although lipid and polysaccharide of possible bacterial origin may be present within the 10 mum surface zone of involved cementum, the finding of microbial deposits down to the level of the CDJ suggests that all periodontally involved cementum should be removed during root planing, in order to achieve a root surface free of bacterial contamination.

A comparative, scanning electron microscopic study of supragingival and subgingival calculus

The morphology of supragingival and subgingival calculus on extracted teeth was studied with the scanning electron microscope. Oral, crevicular, and fracture surfaces were examined. Both subgingival and supragingival calculus had a heterogenous core covered by a soft, loose layer of microorganisms. On supragingival calculus this layer was dominated by filamentous microorganisms while subgingival calculus was covered by a mixture of cocci, rods and filaments. The supragingival covering of filaments was oriented with the filaments approximately perpendicular to and in direct contact with the underlying dense calculus. This arrangement was rarely seen subgingivally where there was no distinct pattern of orientation. Some of the specimens of sub- and supragingival calculus were treated with sodium-hypochlorite. These lost the soft covering, and channels the same size as the filamentous organisms were found penetrating into the calculus. They were oriented prependicular to the surface in supragingival calculus but had no specific direction in subgingival calculus. The appearance of the channels supports the concept that calcification starts between the microorganisms in both subgingival and supragingival calculus.