Commentary on tumor heterogeneity

Liquid biopsy for the assessment of adrenal cancer heterogeneity: where do we stand?

Almost 10 years have passed since the first attempts of liquid biopsy aimed at the characterisation of tumor cells present in the bloodstream from a regular sample of peripheral blood were performed. Liquid biopsy has been used to characterise tumor heterogeneity in various types of solid tumors including adrenocortical carcinoma. The development of molecular biology, genetics, and methodological advances such as digital PCR and next-generation sequencing allowed us to use besides circulating tumor cells a variety of circulating cell-free nucleic acids, DNAs, RNAs and microRNAs secreted by tumors into blood and other body fluids as specific molecular markers. These markers are used for diagnosis, to check tumor development, selecting efficient therapies, therapy monitoring and even possess prognostic power. In adrenocortical carcinoma, there are some studies reporting analysis of circulating tumor cells, circulating cell free DNA and microRNAs for assessing tumor heterogeneity. Among microRNAs, hsa-miR-483-5p seems to be the most important player. Combined with other microRNAs like hsa-miR-195, their expression correlates with recurrence-free survival. Most studies support the applicability of liquid biopsy for assessing temporal tumor heterogeneity (i.e. tumor progression) in adrenocortical cancer. In this mini-review, the available findings of liquid biopsy for assessing tumor heterogeneity in adrenocortical cancer are presented.

Using Circulating Tumor DNA in Colorectal Cancer: Current and Evolving Practices

There exists a tremendous opportunity in identifying and determining the appropriate predictive and prognostic biomarker(s) for risk stratification of patients with colorectal cancers (CRCs). Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has emerged as a promising prognostic and possibly predictive biomarker in the personalized management of patients with CRCs. The disease is particularly suited to a liquid biopsy-based approach since there is a great deal of shedding of circulating tumor fragments (cells, DNA, methylation markers, etc). ctDNA has been shown to have several potential applications, including detecting minimal residual disease (MRD), monitoring for early recurrence, molecular profiling, and therapeutic response prediction. The utility of ctDNA has broadened from its initial use in the advanced/metastatic setting for molecular profiling and detection of acquired resistance mechanisms, toward identifying MRD, as well as early detection. Prospective studies such as CIRCULATE, COBRA, Dynamic II/III, and ACT3 are underway in the MRD setting to further understand how ctDNA may be used to inform clinical decision making using both tumor-informed and tumor-agnostic platforms. These prospective studies use ctDNA to guide management of patients with CRC and will be critical to help guide how and where ctDNA should or should not be used in clinical decision making. It is also important to understand that there are different types of ctDNA liquid biopsy platforms, each with advantages and disadvantages in different clinical indications. This review provides an overview of the current and evolving use of ctDNA in CRC.

Genomic Alteration Spectrum of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer Patients in East-China Characterized by Tumor Tissue DNA and Cell-Free DNA

Introduction

From an oncologic perspective, genetic detection is becoming a frontline clinical test, used to identify actionable alterations for targeted therapy, monitor molecular clonal tumor evolution, indicate disease progression and prognosis, and predict medication efficacy and resistance. From analysis of both tumor tissue and cell-free DNA from a large cohort of non-small cell lung cancer patients in East-China, we characterized the full spectrum of genomic alterations.

Methods

The study comprised 3000 unpaired samples including 1351 tumor tissue DNA (tDNA) and 1649 cell-free circulating tumor DNA (cfDNA) samples, from which 67 cancer-related genes were sequenced and the genetic alteration profiles were depicted. Integrative molecular analyses identified the frequently mutated genes, uncovered co-occurring somatic alterations, described the distribution of hotspot variants, analyzed the frequency of variant alleles, and notably distinguished actionable, novel variants.

Results

The most commonly affected genes were EGFR, TP53, KRAS, CDKN2A, and PIK3CA in both tDNA and cfDNA samples. EGFR and CTNNB1, PIK3CA and PTEN, ERBB2 and SMO were found to have frequent co-occurring alterations in tDNA samples, while EGFR and SMO, KRAS and PDGFRA, PIK3CA and KDR were in cfDNA samples. A large number of primary druggable variants were identified in tDNA samples, while numerous drug-resistance variants, rare actionable variants, and non-EGFR actionable variants were detected in cfDNA samples. Novel variants were enriched in KDR, KIT, TP53, ABL1, FGFR1 in tDNA samples while the majority of novel variants were distributed in PDGFRA, EGFR, KIT, ROS1, BRCA2 in cfDNA samples. Variant allele frequency in tDNA samples was significantly (P < 0.001) higher than that in cfDNA samples.

Conclusion

The results revealed considerable differences in the alteration characteristics between the two kinds of specimens. To date, this study represents the largest real-world investigation of its kind, derived from the largest number of patients in East-China. It reinforced and expanded the mechanism of molecular analysis of neoplastic genetic profiles.

Prediction of the treatment response in ovarian cancer: a ctDNA approach

Ovarian cancer is the eighth most commonly occurring cancer in women. Clinically, the limitation of conventional screening and monitoring approaches inhibits high throughput analysis of the tumor molecular markers toward prediction of treatment response. Recently, analysis of liquid biopsies including circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) open new way toward cancer diagnosis and treatment in a personalized manner in various types of solid tumors. In the case of ovarian carcinoma, growing pre-clinical and clinical studies underscored promising application of ctDNA in diagnosis, prognosis, and prediction of treatment response. In this review, we accumulate and highlight recent molecular findings of ctDNA analysis and its associations with treatment response and patient outcome. Additionally, we discussed the potential application of ctDNA in the personalized treatment of ovarian carcinoma. ctDNA-monitoring usage during the ovarian cancer treatments procedures.

Construction of a reference material panel for detecting KRAS/NRAS/EGFR/BRAF/MET mutations in plasma ctDNA

Background

The absence of high-quality next-generation sequencing (NGS) reference material (RM) has impeded the clinical use of liquid biopsies with plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) in China.

Objective

This study aimed to develop a national RM panel for external quality assessment and performance evaluation during kit registration of non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC)-related Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene (KRAS)/neuroblastoma ras oncogene (NRAS)/epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR)/B-type Raf kinase (BRAF)/mesenchymal–epithelial transition factor (MET) genetic assays using plasma circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA).

Methods

Mutation cell lines detected by NGS and validated by Sanger sequencing were selected to establish the RM. Cell line genomic DNA was sheared and used to spike basal plasma cfDNA at 10% concentration. Then, the calibration accuracy was determined by four sequencing platforms. Average values were adopted and diluted to 0.1%, 0.3%, 1% and 3% concentrations with basal plasma as the RM panel. Then, five manufacturers were invited to evaluate the performance of the RM panel.

Results

20 cell lines with 23 clinically important mutations were selected, including six mutations in KRAS, two mutations in NRAS, three in BRAF, four in phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate 3-kinase catalytic subunit alpha (PIK3CA), six in EGFR, one EGFR Gain (4-5 copy) and one MET Gain (2-5 copy). The RM panel consisted of 87 samples, including these 21 mutations at four concentrations (0.1%, 0.3%, 1% and 3%), one MET gain, one EGFR gain and one wild type. The detection rate was 100% for the 3%, 1% and 0.3% samples at all five companies. For the 0.1% concentration, 15 samples had inconsistent results, but at least three companies had correct results for each mutation.

Conclusion

RM for a KRAS/NRAS/EGFR/BRAF/MET mutation panel for plasma ctDNA was developed, which will be essential for quality control of the performance of independent laboratories.

Prospective study of the efficacy and utility of TP53 mutations in circulating tumor DNA as a non-invasive biomarker of treatment response monitoring in patients with high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

Somatic TP53 mutation (TP53^mut) is a characteristic finding in high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC). The aim of this study was to assess the clinical efficacy and utility of TP53^mut circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) monitoring as a biomarker for managing HGSOC.

METHODS

TP53^muts were evaluated in patients who received primary treatment for suspected ovarian cancer at Asan Medical Center. In patients diagnosed with HGSOC and with TP53^mut, ctDNA, cancer antigen 125 (CA 125), and computed tomography were followed up according to the treatment course.

RESULTS

Direct sequencing analysis of 103 tumor tissues from 61 HGSOC patients confirmed TP53^muts in 41 patients (67.2%). All these patient-specific somatic mutations were detected in plasma cell-free DNA. The mean value of preoperative TP53 mutant allele count (TP53MAC) in stage III patients was 12.2 copies/μL and in stage IV patients was 45.3 copies/μL. TP53MAC was significantly reduced by treatment and there was no significant difference in the rate of decrease compared to CA 125 by the generalized linear mixed model. When patients were divided into a low TP53MAC group (<0.2 copies/μL) and a high TP53MAC group (≥0.2 copies/μL) based on the TP53MAC value at 3 months after the end of chemotherapy, there was a significant difference in time to progression between the two groups (p=0.038).

CONCLUSION

TP53^mut ctDNA shows potential as a tumor-specific biomarker for treatment response monitoring in HGSOC. TP53^mut ctDNA levels at 3 months post treatment has a significant prognostic utility than that of CA 125.

Clinical utility of circulating tumor DNA for colorectal cancer

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is currently the most common type of cancer in Japan, and its prognosis has improved because of development of diagnosis and advancement in treatments including surgery and chemotherapy. However, because of intratumor heterogeneity and clonal evolution, tumors often develop resistance to treatment. Genotyping tumor tissue in search of somatic genetic alterations for actionable information has become routine examination in clinical practice. However, the inherent molecular heterogeneity of metastatic tumors and the ability of cancer genomes to dynamically evolve are not properly captured by tissue specimens only. Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) carrying tumor‐specific genetic or epigenetic alterations is released into the circulation from tumor cells undergoing apoptosis or necrosis. Analysis of ctDNA has the potential to change clinical practice by exploiting blood rather than tissue, as a source of information. Here, we provide an overview of the characteristics of ctDNA and focus on detection methods for ctDNA, and the feasibility of use of ctDNA to monitor tumor dynamics for patients with colorectal cancer.

Utility of circulating tumor DNA in cancer diagnostics with emphasis on early detection

Various recent studies have focused on analyzing tumor genetic material released into the blood stream, known as circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). Herein, we describe current research on the application of ctDNA to cancer management, including prognosis determination, monitoring for treatment efficacy/relapse, treatment selection, and quantification of tumor size and disease burden. Specifically, we examine the utility of ctDNA for early cancer diagnostics focusing on the development of a blood test to detect cancer in asymptomatic individuals by sequencing and analyzing mutations in ctDNA. Next, we discuss the prospect of using ctDNA to test for cancer, and present our calculations based on previously published empirical findings in cancer and prenatal diagnostics. We show that very early stage (asymptomatic) tumors are not likely to release enough ctDNA to be detectable in a typical blood draw of 10 mL. Data are also presented showing that mutations in circulating free DNA can be found in healthy individuals and will likely be very difficult to distinguish from those associated with cancer.We conclude that the ctDNA test, in addition to its high cost and complexity, will likely suffer from the same issues of low sensitivity and specificity as traditional biomarkers when applied to population screening and early (asymptomatic) cancer diagnosis.

Liquid biopsies come of age: towards implementation of circulating tumour DNA

Improvements in genomic and molecular methods are expanding the range of potential applications for circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA), both in a research setting and as a 'liquid biopsy' for cancer management. Proof-of-principle studies have demonstrated the translational potential of ctDNA for prognostication, molecular profiling and monitoring. The field is now in an exciting transitional period in which ctDNA analysis is beginning to be applied clinically, although there is still much to learn about the biology of cell-free DNA. This is an opportune time to appraise potential approaches to ctDNA analysis, and to consider their applications in personalized oncology and in cancer research.