The differential effect of clarithromycin and azithromycin on induction of macrolide resistance in Mycobacterium abscessus

Atypical mycobacterial infections - management and when to treat

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Infections caused by nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) are increasing for several reasons, including diagnostic advances, increased awareness and a larger at-risk population. NTM pulmonary disease is surpassing tuberculosis (TB) in some low incidence areas. This review summarizes the latest literature and guidelines and aims to be a concise source outlining treatment and management of NTM lung infections, integrating established treatment paradigms with novel pharmacological interventions.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent additions to NTM treatment are inhaled liposomal amikacin and the anti-TB drug bedaquiline. Several other new or repurposed treatments are being explored in vitro, in animal models and in clinical trials, including novel beta-lactamase inhibitor/lactam combinations, dual-lactam combinations, efflux pump inhibitors, novel antimicrobials, inhaled clofazimine suspension and bacteriophages.

SUMMARY

Patients with NTM pulmonary disease are mainly female and older with significant delay between diagnosis and treatment being common. Treatment varies according to causative organism, drug susceptibilities, radiological type and disease severity. Underlying chronic conditions, drug intolerances and interactions require careful consideration. In all cases, at least three drugs should be used to minimize acquisition of drug resistance, and all patients should receive a minimum of 12 months of treatment. Expert advice should be taken. NTM treatment is longer than TB treatment, more likely to fail and more likely to cause toxicity. The relatively small numbers of patients affected by each NTM species has limited research. Novel treatments hold promise; nevertheless, it is likely that new solutions for NTM management will stem from the TB pipeline for the foreseeable future.

Rifabutin Suppresses Inducible Clarithromycin Resistance in Mycobacterium abscessus by Blocking Induction of whiB7 and erm41

Clarithromycin (CLR) is the corner stone in regimens for the treatment of lung disease caused by Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab). However, many strains harbor the CLR-inducible CLR resistance gene erm41, encoding a ribosome methylase. Induction of erm41 is mediated by the transcription factor whiB7. We hypothesized that an inhibitor of RNA synthesis should be able to block the whiB7-erm41 induction response to CLR exposure and thus suppress CLR resistance. Recently, we discovered that the rifampicin analog rifabutin (RFB) shows attractive potency against Mab. To determine whether RFB-CLR combinations are synergistic, a checkerboard analysis against a collection of erm41 positive and negative Mab strains was carried out. This revealed synergy of the two drugs for erm41 positive but not for erm41 negative strains. To determine whether RFB's potentiation effect was due to inhibition of the transcriptional induction of the whiB7-erm41 resistance system, we measured the effect of CLR alone and in combination with RFB on whiB7 and erm41 mRNA levels. CLR alone strongly induced whiB7 and erm41 expression as expected. The synergistic, growth-inhibiting combination of RFB with CLR blocked induction of both genes. These results suggest that RFB suppresses inducible CLR resistance by preventing induction of whiB7 and erm41 expression.

Dissecting erm(41)-Mediated Macrolide-Inducible Resistance in Mycobacterium abscessus

Macrolides are the cornerstone of Mycobacterium abscessus multidrug therapy, despite that most patients respond poorly to this class of antibiotics due to the inducible resistance phenotype that occurs during drug treatment. This mechanism is driven by the macrolide-inducible ribosomal methylase encoded by erm(41), whose expression is activated by the transcriptional regulator WhiB7. However, it has been debated whether clarithromycin and azithromycin differ in the extent to which they induce erm(41)-mediated macrolide resistance. Herein, we show that macrolide resistance is induced more rapidly in various M. abscessus isolates upon exposure to azithromycin than to clarithromycin, based on MIC determination. Macrolide-induced expression of erm(41) was assessed in vivo using a strain carrying tdTomato placed under the control of the erm(41) promoter. Visualization of fluorescent bacilli in infected zebrafish demonstrates that azithromycin and clarithromycin activate erm(41) expression in vivo That azithromycin induces a more rapid expression of erm(41) was confirmed by measuring the β-galactosidase activity of a reporter strain in which lacZ was placed under the control of the erm(41) promoter. Shortening the promoter region in the lacZ reporter plasmid identified DNA elements involved in the regulation of erm(41) expression, particularly an AT-rich motif sharing partial conservation with the WhiB7-binding site. Mutation of this motif abrogated the macrolide-induced and WhiB7-dependent expression of erm(41). This study provides new mechanistic information on the adaptive response to macrolide treatment in M. abscessus.