Results of irradiation of tumors in the region of the pineal body

Neurosurgical experience with tumours of the pineal region at Clinica Puerta de Hierro

The clinicopathological experience with 50 cases of pineal region tumours at Clinica Puerta de Hierro is presented. In this series, 88% of the patients were evaluated by CT-scan. Pineal region tumours make up approximately 0.7% of the intracranial expansive processes in the Spanish population. The largest group of lesions appearing in this localization is that of the germinomas (38%), followed by nontumoural lesions (20%) and tumours generally considered to be of the vicinity, such as meningiomas, gliomas and metastases (18%), tumours of the pineal parenchyma (14%), and non-germinoma germinal tumours (10%). In our series, in addition to an intracranial hypertension syndrome, an ophthalmological and, to a minor degree, an endocrinological syndrome predominate in germ-cell tumours, with a cerebellar syndrome appearing in gliomas of the pineal region. All the patients in the series diagnosed as having a germinoma and treated by irradiation are alive, and free of disease, after follow-up ranging from 2 to 20 years (mean: 8 years). The experience obtained with the present series supports the opinion that, in radiosensitive tumours, surgical resection adds no therapeutic benefit to treatment with radiotherapy alone. We suggest that when dealing with a tumour of the pineal region, CT-scan and clinical assessment now permit an initial selection of patients susceptible to surgery as a first therapeutic option, indicating those patients who, because they are considered to have either a "probable germinoma" or a "tumour of uncertain diagnosis", should undergo stereotaxic biopsy or trial radiotherapy and, only when this has proved a failure, should be subjected to open surgery.

Primary central nervous system germ cell tumors. Effect of histologic confirmation on radiotherapy

Primary malignant intracranial germ cell tumors are rare lesions responsible for only 0.5% of all central nervous system (CNS) malignancy. With stereotactic localization these lesions can be safely biopsied, and histologic confirmation will affect the ultimate prognosis. This report is a multi-institutional retrospective analysis of 33 patients diagnosed with a primary CNS germ cell tumor. Tumors in 14 patients (42%) were histologically confirmed (13 germinoma and one embryonal cell carcinoma); 19 patients were treated with a presumptive diagnosis. All patients were irradiated with a dose range of 3950 cGy to 6000 cGy to the primary lesions. Eight patients received craniospinal irradiation, and 25 patients were locally treated. The 5-year actuarial survival for the entire population was 64%. The survival rate in patients with histologic confirmation was 79% versus 53% in the unbiopsied population. Radiation doses greater than 5000 cGy, radiotherapy volume, and age were prognostic factors in determining survival.

Mixed germ-cell tumor of the pineal region. Case report

The case is presented of a 15-year-old boy with a mixed nongerminomatous germ-cell tumor of the pineal region associated with elevated cerebrospinal fluid and serum levels of the beta subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin. Treatment consisted of initial subtotal resection followed by radiotherapy and systemic chemotherapy with cisplatin, vinblastine, and bleomycin. The patient is alive without evidence of tumor 37 months after his initial diagnosis. A literature review of intracranial embryonal carcinoma and choriocarcinoma provided the rationale for a combined-modality approach to this otherwise lethal neoplasm.

Radiation therapy for pineal and suprasellar germ cell tumors

Radiation therapy (XRT) was used in the treatment of 25 patients with tumors of the pineal and suprasellar locations. A tissue diagnosis was obtained before XRT in 5 patients, and 20 were irradiated without histologic verification. The overall survival rate is 80% (76% with no evidence of disease [NED]). Megavoltage XRT was delivered to the entire neuraxis in 22 patients, and 86% (19/22) are alive from 4 to 88 months (median, 30 months) after treatment. In two of three patients treated only to local fields, tumor recurred in the spine; both are dead of disease. Biopsy-proven germinomas and multiple midline tumors responded favorably to XRT, whereas solitary pineal tumors and teratomas with marker positivity (human chorionic gonadotropin, alpha-fetoprotein) did not respond as well. The endocrinologic presentation, tumor marker status, and early response to radiation measured on computed tomography are useful means for selecting patients for radiation therapy.

Measurements of the volume and density of intracerebral tumors by CT following therapy

For the interpretation of curative measures in patients with cerebral tumors CT is of increasing importance. The therapeutic effects can be demonstrated by close follow-up studies without any of the disadvantage of invasive neuroradiological methods. Our investigations of 125 patients with cerebral tumors are based on volume and density determinations. The CT studies of removed or inoperable tumors followed by radiation and/or cytostatic therapy prove that the best results follow a combination of both. In the present cases however, if CT proves postoperatively, at the end of radiation or at the beginning of the application of cytostatics that there is a residual mass, a complete remission cannot be obtained.

Pineal and ectopic pineal tumors: the role of radiation therapy

Seventeen patients wih pineal tumors and one ectopic (suprasellar) germinoma were treated with radiation therapy. Surgery was restricted to decompression in 16 patients, and only two patients had resection of the tumor. Thirteen of 18 patients are alive without evidence for disease with a ten-year survival rate of 88%. The tumor dose ranged from 4000 rads to 6000 rads. No age or dose dependence in survival was noted, but patients with whole brain irradiation or generous volume to include ventricular system had better survival. No case of spinal metastasis was noted. The possibility of increased incidence of meningeal seeding following surgical intervention is considered. From their data, the authors feel that radiation therapy with or without surgical decompression should be the primary treatment for pinealoma. Surgery can be used for diagnosis and/or treatment of patients who show delayed response to radiation. Recommendation is made for the use of whole brain irradiation to 4000 rads followed by a boost to the tumor area to 5000 rads.

The management of pineal area tumors: a recent reappraisal

This study concerns our experience with 22 pineal area tumors from 1972 through 1977. Eleven identified tumors included: three gliomas, three pineoblastomas, two endodermal sinus tumors, one germinoma, one epidermoid, and one metastasis. Three others were presumptively germinomas. Twelve cases were treated by means of radiation and shunting if necessary. Eight patients had pineoblastomas and 2, endodermal sinus tumors. Death occurred in spite of radiologic evidence of radiation response. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cytology was positive in 2 of 7 cases involving potentially disseminating tumors and negative in 2 cases involving spinal metastases. We conclude that radiation response and CSF cytology are insufficient to determine optimum treatment. Direct operations, which were not associated with mortality or serious morbidity were most useful for providing a tissue diagnosis.

Malignant pineal region tumors. A clinico-pathological study

Eight patients with primary malignant pineal tumors have been seen at this institution over the past 6 years; six of them underwent definitive surgical exploration. Complete gross microsurgical excision of well encapsulated tumors was possible in four of these patients. In two cases of pineal germinomas, a biopsy and a subtotal resection were carried out because of the known radiosensitivity of this tumor. These six surgical patients all received postoperative craniospinal radiation and continue to do well up to 6 years postoperatively. Two nonoperative patients were initially treated at other institutions by ventriculoperitoneal shunt and radiation and were the only ones to develop metastatic disease. One patient had metastasis of her pineoblastoma to her unirradiated spinal canal and the other patient had metastasis of his germinoma to the peritoneum. The former patient was quadriplegic on admission, although her pineal tumor was no longer visible on computerized tomography (CT), and she died of pneumonia. The latter patient's tumor secreted the beta chain of human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG). This patient's massive metastatic tumor burden completely regressed as determined by body CT scan and HCG levels after four courses of chemotherapy with bleomycin, vinblastine, and cis-platinum. In 20 patients with lesions of the pineal region, craniotomy was associated with only one death (a patient with metastatic adenocarcinoma). Thus, microsurgery for pineal tumors provides either a reasonably safe potential for complete tumor extirpation and possible cure, or a tissue diagnosis which is necessary for appropriate therapeutic planning for radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy. The traditional therapeutic approach of empiric radiotherapy without a tissue diagnosis for pineal lesions may no longer be warranted.