Adult and fetal hemoglobin production in erythroid colonies from subjects with beta-thalassemia or with hereditary persistance of fetal hemoglobin (HPFH)

Concise Review: Advanced Cell Culture Models for Diamond Blackfan Anemia and Other Erythroid Disorders

In vitro surrogate models of human erythropoiesis made many contributions to our understanding of the extrinsic and intrinsic regulation of this process in vivo and how they are altered in erythroid disorders. In the past, variability among the levels of hemoglobin F produced by adult erythroblasts generated in vitro by different laboratories identified stage of maturation, fetal bovine serum, and accessory cells as "confounding factors," that is, parameters intrinsically wired in the experimental approach that bias the results observed. The discovery of these factors facilitated the identification of drugs that accelerate terminal maturation or activate specific signaling pathways for the treatment of hemoglobinopathies. It also inspired studies to understand how erythropoiesis is regulated by macrophages present in the erythroid islands. Recent cell culture advances have greatly increased the number of human erythroid cells that can be generated in vitro and are used as experimental models to study diseases, such as Diamond Blackfan Anemia, which were previously poorly amenable to investigation. However, in addition to the confounding factors already identified, improvement in the culture models has introduced novel confounding factors, such as possible interactions between signaling from cKIT, the receptor for stem cell factor, and from the glucocorticoid receptor, the cell proliferation potential and the clinical state of the patients. This review will illustrate these new confounding factors and discuss their clinical translation potential to improve our understanding of Diamond Blackfan Anemia and other erythroid disorders. Stem Cells 2018;36:172-179.

Erythropoiesis following bone marrow transplantation from donors heterozygous for beta-thalassaemia

This study shows a marked and protracted activation of HbF synthesis in homozygous beta.-thalassaemia patients transplanted from HLA identical siblings heterozygous for beta-thalassaemia, as compared to patients transplanted from normal donors. HbF synthesis in recipients was much higher in relation to the corresponding bone marrow donor values either normal or heterozygous for beta thalassaemia. gamma-chain synthesis and G gamma/A gamma ratio were also studied in peripheral blood BFU-E from recipients and their donors. BFU-E from donors heterozygous for beta-thalassaemia showed higher gamma chain synthesis as compared to normal donors. Peripheral blood BFU-E gamma/beta + gamma ratios and G gamma percentage were higher in recipients than in their corresponding donors both normal or heterozygotes. The marked and protracted reactivation of HbF synthesis in recipients of heterozygous beta-thalassaemia bone marrow most likely results from an increased erythropoietic stress on erythroid progenitors. In order to obtain adequate Hb levels heterozygous beta-thalassaemia bone marrow should produce more red blood cells to compensate for the low MCH. The magnitude of activation of HbF synthesis was very variable. This variability may result from inherited differences in the capacity of reactivation of HbF synthesis of red cell progenitors from heterozygous beta-thalassaemia under stressed erythropoiesis.

Adult 'fetal-like' erythropoiesis characterizes recovery from bone marrow transplantation

The transient fetal-like erythropoiesis which appears during recovery from bone marrow transplantation has now been examined at the level of erythroid progenitor cells. A 7-year-old boy with beta +-thalassaemia major was studied during engraftment from his beta-thalassaemia trait sister. Hb F and i antigen rose as expected. Macrocytosis never developed, but red cell size distribution became very heterogeneous. Bone marrow CFU-E and BFU-E were detected by 30 d, prior to the appearance of reticulocytes. Marrow erythroid progenitor cell numbers were normal by 146 d, while those in the blood became normal by 360 d. After transplantation globin synthesis ratios in erythroid colonies were diagnostic of thalassaemia trait, indicating engraftment. Individual erythroid colonies derived from both blood and marrow at all times during reconstitution showed no correlation of G gamma and gamma. Thus the fetal-like stress erythropoiesis of marrow expansion following transplantation was derived from adult and not fetal progenitor cells.

Determination of the hemoglobin F program in human progenitor-derived erythroid cells

The absolute adult and fetal hemoglobin (HbF) contents of the erythroid cells derived from the differentiation of normal human and simian erythroid progenitors and of the peripheral blood erythroid burst-forming units (BFU-E) of patients with nondeletion hemoglobinopathies have been measured with a sensitive radioligand immunoassay. The HbF content varied between 0.13 and 2.96 pg/cell, representing between 0.7% and 19.6% of the total hemoglobin with a mean value of 7.0%. The absolute content of HbF was indistinguishable in the well-hemoglobinized progeny of marrow erythroid colony-forming units, marrow or blood BFU-E, or of mixed colony-forming units. The term HbF program refers to this inherent capacity to produce fetal hemoglobin (HbF) in the erythroid cells derived from these progenitors in vitro. The HbF content of marrow erythroblasts as determined by the same radioligand immunoassay was similar to that found in the peripheral blood, suggesting that the switch off of gamma-chain production occurs after the erythroid colony-forming unit stage of maturation. Increasing concentrations of a crude erythropoietin-containing preparation induced higher numbers of erythroid colonies, which were larger in size, but the HbF program was unaffected. In contrast to the hemoglobin accumulation in human progenitor-derived colonies, simian progenitor-derived colonies produced considerably more HbF, and the amount of HbF was strongly influenced by progenitor maturity. Assays of the HbF content of erythroblasts derived from culture of the peripheral blood BFU-E of patients with nondeletion hemoglobinopathies and their parents showed that the HbF program in the progenitors of such patients is highly variable. Some produce only a slight excess of HbF in progenitor-derived erythroblasts, whereas others have extraordinarily high HbF programs. The molecular basis of this variability is presently unknown.

The percentages of Hb F and of G gamma and A gamma chains in the Hb F synthesized by reticulocytes and BFUe-derived colonies of patients with sickle cell anemia

The synthesis of Hb F was studied in the BFUe-derived colonies of 20 SS patients after incubation with 35S methionine for 24 hours, 13 days after the start of the experiments. Similar analyses were made for isolated reticulocytes from 28 SS patients; these cells were incubated for 2 hours and occasionally for 24 hours. The G gamma and A gamma percentages were determined in these two Hb F preparations and in the Hb F of circulating red cells using two different HPL chromatographic procedures. The data show an increased production of Hb F in the colonies mainly of patients with low blood Hb F values. A close correlation was present between the % G gamma chain in peripheral red cells and the G gamma percentages observed for the Hb F synthesized in the BFUe-derived colonies and that in reticulocytes. However, the values for the reticulocytes were significantly higher than those for the colonies. These data indicate a considerable variability among SS patients in their ability to produce Hb F in in vitro colonies which may in part be due to differences in the numbers of BFUe types in circulation. The variation in G gamma and A gamma levels in Hb F synthesized in reticulocytes and BFUe-derived colonies could be the result of slight differences in the stability of the corresponding mRNA's.

In vitro synthesis of hemoglobin and hemoglobin chains in the BFUe-derived colonies form person with alpha- or beta-thalassemia

The synthesis of alpha and non-alpha chains of human hemoglobin (Hb) was studied in reticulocytes and in BFUe-derived cell colonies from patients with alpha chain or beta chain deficiencies. The subjects included normal adults (alpha alpha/alpha alpha) with or without a beta chain variant (Hb S, Hb Leslie) or an alpha chain variant (Hb G-Georgia); alpha-thalassemia-2 heterozygotes (alpha 0 alpha/alpha alpha) with an alpha chain variant (G-Georgia or G-Philadelphia); an alpha-thalassemia-1 heterozygote (alpha 0 alpha 0/alpha alpha); alpha-thalassemia-2 homozygotes (alpha 0 alpha 0/alpha 0 alpha) with a beta chain variant (Hb S), an alpha chain variant (G-Philadelphia), a Hb S homozygosity with Hb G-Philadelphia, or a Hb G-Philadelphia homozygosity; and three black beta +-thalassemia homozygotes. Data from reticulocyte in vitro synthesis analysis showed the expected deficiencies. However, similar analyses of the Hb synthesized in cell colonies (even from the black beta-thalassemia homozygotes) gave (nearly) balanced sigma alpha/sigma non-alpha ratios. It is speculated that this balanced synthesis is due to a most effective proteolysis in the immature erythroblast which rapidly removes free alpha or beta chains. The levels of Hb F and Hb A2 were considerably increased in these proerythroblasts; a two- to threefold increase in the synthesis of Hb A2 was observed over that seen in the reticulocytes.