One-week treatment of tinea corporis and tinea cruris with terbinafine (Lamisil) 1% cream: a placebo-controlled study

Topical antifungal treatments for tinea cruris and tinea corporis

BACKGROUND

Tinea infections are fungal infections of the skin caused by dermatophytes. It is estimated that 10% to 20% of the world population is affected by fungal skin infections. Sites of infection vary according to geographical location, the organism involved, and environmental and cultural differences. Both tinea corporis, also referred to as 'ringworm' and tinea cruris or 'jock itch' are conditions frequently seen by primary care doctors and dermatologists. The diagnosis can be made on clinical appearance and can be confirmed by microscopy or culture. A wide range of topical antifungal drugs are used to treat these superficial dermatomycoses, but it is unclear which are the most effective.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the effects of topical antifungal treatments in tinea cruris and tinea corporis.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the following databases up to 13th August 2013: the Cochrane Skin Group Specialised Register, CENTRAL in The Cochrane Library (2013, Issue 7), MEDLINE (from 1946), EMBASE (from 1974), and LILACS (from 1982). We also searched five trials registers, and checked the reference lists of included and excluded studies for further references to relevant randomised controlled trials. We handsearched the journal Mycoses from 1957 to 1990.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials in people with proven dermatophyte infection of the body (tinea corporis) or groin (tinea cruris).

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two review authors independently carried out study selection, data extraction, assessment of risk of bias, and analyses.

MAIN RESULTS

Of the 364 records identified, 129 studies with 18,086 participants met the inclusion criteria. Half of the studies were judged at high risk of bias with the remainder judged at unclear risk. A wide range of different comparisons were evaluated across the 129 studies, 92 in total, with azoles accounting for the majority of the interventions. Treatment duration varied from one week to two months, but in most studies this was two to four weeks. The length of follow-up varied from one week to six months. Sixty-three studies contained no usable or retrievable data mainly due to the lack of separate data for different tinea infections. Mycological and clinical cure were assessed in the majority of studies, along with adverse effects. Less than half of the studies assessed disease relapse, and hardly any of them assessed duration until clinical cure, or participant-judged cure. The quality of the body of evidence was rated as low to very low for the different outcomes.Data for several outcomes for two individual treatments were pooled. Across five studies, significantly higher clinical cure rates were seen in participants treated with terbinafine compared to placebo (risk ratio (RR) 4.51, 95% confidence interval (CI) 3.10 to 6.56, number needed to treat (NNT) 3, 95% CI 2 to 4). The quality of evidence for this outcome was rated as low. Data for mycological cure for terbinafine could not be pooled due to substantial heterogeneity.Mycological cure rates favoured naftifine 1% compared to placebo across three studies (RR 2.38, 95% CI 1.80 to 3.14, NNT 3, 95% CI 2 to 4) with the quality of evidence rated as low. In one study, naftifine 1% was more effective than placebo in achieving clinical cure (RR 2.42, 95% CI 1.41 to 4.16, NNT 3, 95% CI 2 to 5) with the quality of evidence rated as low.Across two studies, mycological cure rates favoured clotrimazole 1% compared to placebo (RR 2.87, 95% CI 2.28 to 3.62, NNT 2, 95% CI 2 to 3).Data for several outcomes were pooled for three comparisons between different classes of treatment. There was no difference in mycological cure between azoles and benzylamines (RR 1.01, 95% CI 0.94 to 1.07). The quality of the evidence was rated as low for this comparison. Substantial heterogeneity precluded the pooling of data for mycological and clinical cure when comparing azoles and allylamines. Azoles were slightly less effective in achieving clinical cure compared to azole and steroid combination creams immediately at the end of treatment (RR 0.67, 95% CI 0.53 to 0.84, NNT 6, 95% CI 5 to 13), but there was no difference in mycological cure rate (RR 0.99, 95% CI 0.93 to 1.05). The quality of evidence for these two outcomes was rated as low for mycological cure and very low for clinical cure.All of the treatments that were examined appeared to be effective, but most comparisons were evaluated in single studies. There was no evidence for a difference in cure rates between tinea cruris and tinea corporis. Adverse effects were minimal - mainly irritation and burning; results were generally imprecise between active interventions and placebo, and between different classes of treatment.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

The pooled data suggest that the individual treatments terbinafine and naftifine are effective. Adverse effects were generally mild and reported infrequently. A substantial number of the studies were more than 20 years old and of unclear or high risk of bias; there is however, some evidence that other topical antifungal treatments also provide similar clinical and mycological cure rates, particularly azoles although most were evaluated in single studies.There is insufficient evidence to determine if Whitfield's ointment, a widely used agent is effective.Although combinations of topical steroids and antifungals are not currently recommended in any clinical guidelines, relevant studies included in this review reported higher clinical cure rates with similar mycological cure rates at the end of treatment, but the quality of evidence for these outcomes was rated very low due to imprecision, indirectness and risk of bias. There was insufficient evidence to confidently assess relapse rates in the individual or combination treatments.Although there was little difference between different classes of treatment in achieving cure, some interventions may be more appealing as they require fewer applications and a shorter duration of treatment. Further, high quality, adequately powered trials focusing on patient-centred outcomes, such as patient satisfaction with treatment should be considered.

Efficacy and tolerability of terbinafine 1% topical solution used for 1 week compared with 4 weeks clotrimazole 1% topical solution in the treatment of interdigital tinea pedis: a randomized, double-blind, multi-centre, 8-week clinical trial

In this double-blind clinical trial 429 patients (217 terbinafine and 212 clotrimazole) were randomized to receive twice daily terbinafine 1% topical solution for 1 week followed by a vehicle application for 3 weeks, or 1% clotrimazole solution for 4 weeks. Patients were evaluated clinically and mycologically at baseline and then at weeks one, two, four (end of treatment), and eight (end of follow-up). To be evaluable the patient needed to have a positive culture for a dermatophyte and positive KOH microscopy and a clinical diagnosis of tinea pedis (interdigital type) at baseline. Effective treatment of tinea pedis was recorded in 181 of 217 (83%) of patients treated for 1 week with terbinafine 1% solution and 174 of 212 (82%) of patients treated for 4 weeks with clotrimazole 1% solution. Mycological cure and disappearance of signs and symptoms were similar at each assessment visit in the two groups. In the subgroup of patients without any protocol violation the mycological cure rate was 95% (164 of 173) with terbinafine solution and 91% (159 of 174) with clotrimazole solution (P = 0.05). Adverse events believed to be drug-related occurred in 13 patients in the terbinafine group and 11 in the clotrimazole group (4 to 5% in each group). The events were primarily local skin reactions of mild to moderate intensity. It can be concluded that terbinafine 1% solution used for 1 week to treat tinea pedis is well tolerated and at least as effective as clotrimazole 1% solution used for 4 weeks.

Open clinical study of the efficacy and safety of terbinafine cream 1% in children with tinea corporis and tinea cruris

BACKGROUND

Topical application of antifungal agents is considered the treatment of choice for dermatomycoses. Most of the available drugs are fungistatic, requiring long term treatment to prevent relapses. Terbinafine is a synthetic antifungal agent that, because of its fungicidal action, provides high cure rates and low relapse rates after short periods of treatment.

METHODS

Ninety-seven children ages 2 to 15 years with a suspected diagnosis of tinea corporis and/or tinea cruris were enrolled in this open trial. After mycologic assessment to confirm diagnosis (culture and direct microscopy) terbinafine 1% cream was applied once daily during 1 week. Clinical and mycologic assessments were made at the baseline visit and on Days 7, 14 and 21. Efficacy assessment was based on 88 children (9 patients excluded by protocol violation).

RESULTS

Therapy was considered effective in 92.0% (81 of 88) of patients (complete clinical and mycologic cure or mycologic cure with minimum signs and symptoms or clinical improvement, > or = 50%). Tolerability was assessed in 97 patients on an intention-to-treat basis. Adverse reactions were itching 3% (3 of 97), itching associated with erythema exacerbation 1% (1 of 97) and contact dermatitis 1% (1 of 97).

CONCLUSION

Terbinafine 1% cream appears to be an effective and well-tolerated treatment for tinea corporis and tinea cruris in children.

A comparison of terbinafine (Lamisil) 1% cream given for one week with clotrimazole (Canesten) 1% cream given for four weeks, in the treatment of tinea pedis

Terbinafine (Lamisil) is a synthetic allylamine antifungal which has been shown to be fungicidal against dermatophytes and a number of yeasts and moulds. Topical application of terbinafine 1% cream has been shown to be a highly effective short-duration therapy for dermatophytosis of the skin. The aim of this multicentre, double-blind, parallel-group study was to compare the safety and efficacy of terbinafine 1% cream, applied twice daily for 1 week, with clotrimazole (Canesten) 1% cream, applied twice daily for 4 weeks, in the treatment of tinea pedis. One hundred and seven patients with mycologically proven tinea pedis received 1 week of terbinafine 1% cream, followed by 3 weeks of placebo, and 104 patients received clotrimazole 1% cream for 4 weeks. Mycological cure (negative microscopy and culture) and effective treatment (mycological cure with no or minimal signs and symptoms) were assessed 4 and 6 weeks after commencing therapy. Mycological cure rates were 93.5% for terbinafine and 73.1% for clotrimazole (P = 0.0001) at 4 weeks. Effective treatment rates at 4 weeks were 89.7% for terbinafine and 58.7% for clotrimazole (P = 0.0001), and 89.7% for terbinafine and 73.1% for clotrimazole (P = 0.002) at 6 weeks. The results show that 1 week of terbinafine b.d. is more effective than 4 weeks of clotrimazole b.d., in terms of both mycological cure and effective treatment.

Short-duration therapy with terbinafine 1% cream in dermatophyte skin infections

In a multicentre, double-blind, parallel-group study, the efficacy and safety of a single application of terbinafine 1% cream was compared with 3, 5 and 7 days' once-daily therapy in the treatment of tinea pedis and tinea corporis/cruris. Seventy-eight patients with tinea pedis (58 male, 20 female; mean age 36, range 19-80) and 21 patients with tinea corporis or tinea cruris (16 male, 5 female; mean age 37, range 22-72), presenting in general practice, were entered into the study. Of these, 65 patients with tinea pedis and 14 with tinea corporis or cruris completed the study and were evaluable. Twenty-eight days after commencing therapy 78, 83, 82 and 83% of patients with tinea pedis in the 1-, 3-, 5-, and 7-day treatment groups, respectively, were mycologically cured, and 61, 78, 71 and 67%, respectively, were 'effectively treated'. There was no statistically significant difference between treatment groups. Similarly high cure rates were seen in patients with tinea corporis and tinea cruris. Three months after commencing therapy there was little evidence of relapse. The study shows that there is a significant potential for short-duration therapy with terbinafine 1% cream in tinea infections of the skin, emphasized here by the high cure rates obtained following a single application.

Comparison of terbinafine and clotrimazole in treating tinea pedis

OBJECTIVE

To compare the efficacy and safety of terbinafine 1% cream and clotrimazole 1% cream in the treatment of tinea pedis.

DESIGN

Multicentre, double blind parallel group study.

SETTING

32 general practices and one hospital.

PATIENTS

256 patients with mycologically confirmed tinea pedis. Of the 211 patients evaluable, 107 were randomised to terbinafine (75 male, 32 female; mean (range) age 40 (12-81) years) and 104 to clotrimazole (79 male, 25 female; mean (range) age 36 (12-71) years).

INTERVENTIONS

Terbinafine 1% cream applied twice daily for one week and inert cream applied twice daily for the next three weeks. Clotrimazole 1% cream applied twice daily for four weeks.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Mycological cure (negative results on microscopy and culture) and effective treatment (mycological cure plus no or minimal signs and symptoms) measured at weeks 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6.

RESULTS

At week four rates of mycological cure were 93.5% for terbinafine and 73.1% for clotrimazole (p = 0.0001); and at week six 97.2% for terbinafine and 83.7% for clotrimazole (p = 0.001). Rates of effective treatment at week 4 were 89.7% for terbinafine and 58.7% for clotrimazole (p = 0.0001); and 89.7% for terbinafine and 73.1% for clotrimazole (p = 0.002) at week 6.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that a one week course of terbinafine 1% cream is more effective in the treatment of tinea pedis than a four week course of clotrimazole 1% cream, both in terms of mycological cure and effective treatment.