Replacement of the anterior cruciate ligament. A comparison of autografts and allografts in dogs

Mechanical strength of four allograft fixation techniques for ruptured cranial cruciate ligament repair in dogs

OBJECTIVE

To test ex vivo mechanical properties of 4 allograft fixation techniques for cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) replacement.

SAMPLE

30 stifle joints from canine cadavers.

PROCEDURES

CCL-deficient stifle joints repaired by 1 of 4 techniques (n = 6/group) and CCL-intact stifle joints (control group; 6) were mechanically tested. Three repair techniques involved a patella-patella ligament segment (PPL) allograft: a tibial and femoral interference screw (PPL-2S), a femoral interference screw and the patella seated in a tapering bone tunnel in the tibia (PPL-1S), or addition of a suture and a bone anchor to the PPL-1S (PPL-SL). The fourth technique involved a deep digital flexor tendon (DDFT) allograft secured with transverse femoral fixation and stabilized with a tibial interference screw and 2 spiked washers on the tibia (DDFT-TF). The tibia was axially loaded at a joint angle of 135°. Loads to induce 3, 5, and 10 mm of femoral-tibia translation; stiffness; and load at ultimate failure with the corresponding displacement were calculated. Group means were compared with a multivariate ANOVA.

RESULTS

Mean ± SD load for the intact (control) CCL was 520.0 ± 51.3 N and did not differ significantly from the load needed to induce 3 mm of femoral-tibial translation for fixation techniques PPL-SL (422.4 ± 46.3 N) and DDFT-TF (654.2 ± 117.7 N). Results for the DDFT-TF were similar to those of the intact CCL for all outcome measures.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The DDFT-TF yielded mechanical properties similar to those of intact CCLs and may be a viable technique to test in vivo.

Human flexor tendon tissue engineering: decellularization of human flexor tendons reduces immunogenicity in vivo

BACKGROUND

In mutilating hand injuries, tissue engineered tendon grafts may provide a reconstructive solution. We have previously described a method to decellularize cadaveric human flexor tendons while preserving mechanical properties and biocompatibility. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the immunogenicity and strength of these grafts when implanted into an immunocompetent rat model.

METHODS

Cadaveric human flexor tendons were divided into two groups. Group 1 was untreated, and Group 2 was decellularized by treatment with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), and peracetic acid (PAA). Both groups were then analyzed for the presence of major histocompatibility complexes by immunohistochemistry (IHC). Pair-matched tendons from each group were then placed into the dorsal subcutaneous tissue and anchored to the spinal ligaments of Wistar rats for 2 or 4 weeks, and harvested. The infiltration of B-cells and macrophages was determined using IHC. The explants where then subjected to mechanical testing to determine the ultimate tensile stress (UTS) and elastic modulus (EM). Statistical analysis was performed using a paired Student's t-test.

RESULTS

The decellularization protocol successfully removed cells and MHC-1 complexes. At 2 weeks after implantation, there was increased infiltration of B-cells in Group 1 (untreated) compared with Group 2 (acellular), both in the capsule and tendon substance. There was improved ultimate tensile stress (UTS, 42.7 ± 8.3 vs. 22.8 ± 7.8 MPa, p<0.05) and EM (830.2 ± 206.7 vs. 421.2 ± 171.3 MPa, p<0.05) in tendons that were decellularized. At 4 weeks, there was continued B-cell infiltration in Group 1 (untreated) compared with Group 2 (acellular). There was no appreciable difference in macrophage infiltration at both time points. At 4 weeks Group 2 (acellular) demonstrated persistently greater UTS (40.5 ± 9.1 vs. 14.6 ± 4.2 MPa, p<0.05) and EM (454.05 ± 101.5 vs. 204.6 ± 91.3 MPa, p<0.05) compared with Group 1 (untreated).

CONCLUSIONS

Human flexor tendons that were decellularized with SDS, EDTA, and PAA resulted in removal of cellular antigens and a decreased immune response when placed into Wistar rats. These grafts showed better mechanical properties at 2 and 4 weeks when compared with control tendons. Decellularization is an important step toward the use of tissue engineered flexor tendons in upper extremity reconstruction.

Fisioterapia após substituição artroscópica do ligamento cruzado cranial em cães: II - avaliação artroscópica e anatomopatológica

Avaliou-se o enxerto da fascia lata na substituição artroscópica do ligamento cruzado cranial (LCC), realizou-se a caracterização histológica do enxerto e da interface enxerto-osso e avaliou-se, por meio de exames artroscópicos e anatomopatológicos, o efeito da fisioterapia pós-operatória. Foram utilizados 16 cães, sem raça definida, machos, pesando entre 19,2 e 26,3kg, submetidos à ruptura experimental do LCC e subsequente substituição artroscópica desse ligamento pelo enxerto autógeno da fascia lata. Os animais foram distribuídos em dois grupos de oito cada: no grupo I, os cães foram submetidos ao programa de fisioterapia pós-operatória e, no grupo II, à imobilização temporária do membro. Os exames artroscópicos e histológicos mostraram alterações articulares sugestivas de processo degenerativo aos 60 dias após a cirurgia, que se apresentavam mais acentuadas nos cães do grupo II. Na análise histológica do enxerto, observou-se reorganização das fibras colágenas, que ocorreu de forma mais intensa e precoce nos animais do grupo I. Houve progressiva integração das fibras colágenas na interface enxerto-osso. Conclui-se que é viável utilizar a fascia lata como substituto do LCC por cirurgia artroscópica, que o enxerto sofre processos de ligamentação e de osteointegração, e que a fisioterapia reduz a progressão das alterações degenerativas e incentiva o processo de ligamentação do enxerto.

Fisioterapia após substituição artroscópica do ligamento cruzado cranial em cães: I - avaliação clínica, radiográfica e ultrassonográfica

Foram avaliadas a aplicabilidade da cirurgia artroscópica na substituição do ligamento cruzado cranial (LCC) e o efeito da fisioterapia pós-operatória, por meio de exames clínicos, radiográficos e ultrassonográficos, em 16 cães sem raça definida, machos, com pesos entre 19,2 e 26,3kg, submetidos à ruptura experimental do LCC e subsequente substituição deste ligamento pelo enxerto autógeno da fascia lata. Os animais foram distribuídos em dois grupos de oito cada: no grupo I os cães foram submetidos ao programa de fisioterapia pós-operatória e no grupo II à imobilização temporária do membro. Por meio dos exames citados, não foram verificadas diferenças significativas entre os dois grupos, e ambos demonstraram sinais de processo articular degenerativo. A função do membro foi avaliada com auxílio da plataforma de força, e os animais do grupo I apresentaram melhor apoio do membro operado durante o período de reabilitação. Conclui-se que a cirurgia artroscópica é uma técnica eficaz para substituição do LCC em cães, apesar de não impedir o desenvolvimento da doença articular degenerativa, e que a fisioterapia permite recuperação mais rápida no apoio do membro durante o período de reabilitação.

A meta-analysis of stability of autografts compared to allografts after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Allografts have recently become increasingly popular for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in the United States even though many studies have shown high allograft failure rates (Gorschewsky et al. in Am J Sports Med 33:1202, 2005; Pritchard et al. in Am J Sports Med 23:593, 2005; Roberts et al. in Am J Sports Med 19:35, 2006) and no meta-analysis or systematic review of allograft clinical stability rates in comparison to autog rafts has previously been performed. We hypothesized that allografts would demonstrate overall lower objective stability rates compared to autografts. To test this hypothesis we performed a meta-analysis of autograft and allograft stability data. A pubmed literature search of all allograft series in humans published in English was performed. Articles were then bibliographically cross-referenced to identify additional studies. Series inclusion criteria were arthrometric follow-up data using at least 30 lb or maximum manual force, stratified presentation of stability data and minimum two-year follow-up. Twenty allograft series were thus selected and compared to a previously published data set of all BPTB and Hamstring (HS) autograft ACLR series using the same study inclusion criteria and analytic and statistical methodology. IKDC standards of 0-2 mm (normal) and >5 mm (abnormal) side-to-side differences were adopted to compare studies. Normal stability for all autografts was 72 versus 59% for all allografts (P < 0.01). Abnormal stability was 5% for all autografts versus 14% for all allografts (P < 0.01). Bone-patellar-tendon-bone (BPTB) autograft normal stability was 66% versus 57% for BPTB allografts (P < 0.01). Abnormal BPTB autograft stability was 6 versus 16% for BPTB allograft. Hamstring autograft normal or abnormal stability rates were 77% and 4% and were compared to soft tissue allografts as a group which were 64% and 12% (P < 0.01). This is the first meta-analysis comparing autograft to allograft stability in ACLR. Allografts had significantly lower normal stability rates than autografts. The allograft abnormal stability rate, which usually represents graft failure, was significantly higher than that of autografts: nearly three times greater. It would therefore appear that autografts are the graft of choice for routine ACLR with allografts better reserved for multiple ligament-injured knees where extra tissue may be required.

Effect of extraction protocols and epidermal growth factor on the cellular repopulation of decellularized anterior cruciate ligament allografts

We are developing a decellularized bone-anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-bone allograft for treatment of ACL disruption in young or active patients. This study demonstrates the feasibility of seeding decellularized ACL tissue with primary ligament fibroblasts. Porcine ACLs were decellularized by one of three protocols, each differing only by the detergent/solvent used during the second wash (SDS, Triton-X, or TnBP). Porcine ACL fibroblasts were obtained by explant and seeded onto tissue samples of decellularized ACL. Culture conditions were varied to compare the relative effect of three different decellularization protocols on cellular repopulation. Culture condition variables included (1) the number of cells used for seeding, (2) the addition of epidermal growth factor (EGF), and (3) culture duration. Cellular ingrowth was assessed by metabolic activity (MTT assay), DNA quantification (Hoescht dye), and histology (H&E staining). Cell counting on histological sections demonstrated that Triton-X-and TnBP-treated ligaments were more receptive to cellular ingrowth than SDS-treated samples. The addition of EGF to culture medium did not significantly increase cellular ingrowth. Both the Triton-X and TnBP decellularization treatments provide suitable, naturally derived scaffolds for the ingrowth of primary ACL fibroblasts, and should be further investigated in the development of an allograft-derived bone-ACL-bone graft.

Effectiveness of three extraction techniques in the development of a decellularized bone–anterior cruciate ligament–bone graft

In this study, porcine bone-anterior cruciate ligament-bone (B-ACL-B) grafts were decellularized using one of three protocols incorporating surfactants lauryl sulfate (SDS), Triton X-100, and/or an organic solvent (tributyl phosphate (TnBP)). The effectiveness of Triton-SDS, Triton-Triton or Triton-TnBP treatments in removing cellular materials was determined and possible changes in biochemical composition and mechanical properties due to each treatment were investigated. Treatment with Triton-SDS was most effective at removing cell nuclei and intracellular protein (vimentin) from the ACL but affected both the collagen and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) components of the extracellular matrix while increasing the tensile stiffness of the ligament. Triton-Triton was the least effective of the three treatments in terms of cellular extraction, but did not significantly change the mechanical and biochemical properties of the ACL. Triton-TnBP matched the level of decellularization achieved by Triton-SDS in terms of visible cell nuclei; however, the extraction of intracellular vimentin was less consistent. TnBP treatment also slightly decreased the collagen content of the ACL but did not alter its mechanical properties. Overall, all three decellularization treatments maintained adequate mechanical and biochemical properties of B-ACL-B grafts to justify the further investigation of all three decellularization protocols. The selection of a superior treatment will depend on future studies of the propensity of treated tissues for repopulation by host ACL fibroblasts and, ultimately, on any immunogenic and/or remodeling host response induced in vivo.

Development of cell-seeded patellar tendon allografts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Patellar tendon (PT) allografts for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction are potentially immunogenic and incorporate slowly compared with autografts. Our tissue-engineering approach to improve allograft efficacy is to (1) remove intrinsic cells from the graft to reduce antigenicity and then (2) seed the graft with extrinsic cells to improve ligamentization. To remove cells, tendons were soaked in 1% extraction solutions of tri(n-butyl)phosphate (TBP) or sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) for various time periods (24-72 h) and rinsed exhaustively. After treatment, we measured tendon cellularity, crimp structure, and mechanical properties. Treatment with either SDS or TBP removed approximately 70-90% of the intrinsic PT cells. Mechanical properties of treated PTs were similar to those of controls, despite changes in appearance. TBP- and SDS-treated PTs were then seeded with fibroblasts and cultured for up to 2 weeks in vitro. Fibroblast proliferation was retarded on SDS-treated PTs; in contrast, TBP-treated PTs supported cell proliferation similar to that of untreated controls. Extrinsic fibroblasts were successfully cultured on the TBP-treated PTs in vitro, creating viable tissue-engineered grafts potentially useful for ACL reconstruction. These modified allografts have the potential to be developed into mechanically functional delivery vehicles for cells, gene therapy vectors, or other biological agents.

Tibial tunnel area changes following arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions with autogenous patellar tendon graft

We investigated radiographic changes in tibial tunnel area after ACL reconstructions with autogenous patellar tendon grafts on anteroposterior and lateral radiographs over 3 years. Fifty patients followed up for at least 1 year were included in the study. Radiographs were taken on the day of surgery and 3, 6, 9, 12, 24, and 36 months postoperatively. Tibial tunnels on both radiographs were divided into proximal, middle, and distal one-third. The area of each one-third and the greatest diameter of the tibial tunnel on both radiographs was measured using an image-processing software. According to the tunnel area changes, the shape of tibial tunnel was classified into one of four shapes; cylinder, mallet, reverse bottle, and reverse triangle. The correlations between area, diameter and shape of the tunnel, and clinical variables including arthrometer measurement and clinical score were determined. The areas of each one-third of the tibial tunnels on lateral radiographs was always greater than that on anteroposterior radiographs, although the diameters on the two radiographs did not differ significantly. The area of proximal one-third largest and that of distal one-third smallest on both radiographs at any time point. The enlargement and reduction occurred within 3 months and tended to continue for 9 months. Thereafter the tunnel change stabilized on both radiographs. The most common shape of the enlarged tunnels was cylindrical on anteroposterior radiographs reverse triangle on lateral radiographs. No negative effects of enlarged area, diameter, or tunnel shape on clinical results were found in our study.

The role of periosteal flap in the prevention of femoral widening in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using hamstring tendons

Tunnel widening in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction has been reported for many years, whatever the type of plasty (allo- or autograft) or graft (patellar or hamstring tendons). Recently, the hypothesis has been formulated that widening would be responsible for later laxity of the knees. Micromobility of the graft or biological factors are classically responsible for the enlargement. In order to improve the biological conditions around the graft within the tunnel, we have developed a surgical technique using a periosteal flap. The periosteal flap is harvested at the superior and medial metaphysis of the tibia and wrapped around the proximal part of the four strands of gracilis and semitendinosus tendons near the outlet of the femoral tunnel. Forty-one patients with isolated rupture of the ACL were included in a prospective and randomized study: the first group of 20 patients had femoral fixation by Transfix and resorbable screw, the second group of 21 patients had femoral fixation by Transfix and periosteal flap. The diameters of the tunnel were measured between the sclerotic margins at the tunnel entrance and 1 cm above, and compared to the peroperative drill size. The percentage change in diameter was calculated as: (tunnel diameter-drill size)/drill size. The two groups of patients were comparable as to gender, side, age, KT-1000 side to side difference, femoral tunnel diameter and follow-up. At 2.5 months and 11 months postoperatively on average, there was a significant reduction of enlargement at the outlet of the tunnel with the use of a periosteal flap but widening was constant.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: allograft versus autograft

PURPOSE

This study was performed to compare the minimal 2-year outcome of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction using bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allografts versus autografts, both augmented with an iliotibial band tenodesis.

TYPE OF STUDY

Retrospective review.

METHODS

Forty-six of 52 BPTB ACL reconstructions using allografts and 33 of 37 BPTB ACL reconstructions using autografts were followed up at a mean of 2.75 and 3.36 years, respectively. All patients had an iliotibial band tenodesis. Evaluations included the Lysholm II scale, a questionnaire, physical examination findings, and KT-1000 arthrometry.

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences were seen between groups in Lysholm II scores or in any subjective category. Most patients (91% allograft; 97% autograft) had good to excellent Lysholm II scores. Sixty-five percent of allograft patients and 73% of autograft patients returned to their preinjury activity level. More allograft patients complained of retropatellar pain (16% v 9% for autograft patients). Fifty-three percent of allograft patients versus 23% of autograft patients had a flexion deficit of 5 degrees or more when compared with the normal contralateral side. When comparing KT-1000 side-to-side differences, we found no significant differences between groups. Ninety-one percent of both groups had maximum side-to-side differences less than 5 mm. Three allograft patients (6.5%) had traumatic ruptures at 12, 19, and 43 months postoperatively versus none in the autograft group. All three allograft patients who sustained postoperative traumatic ruptures had received fresh frozen, nonirradiated allografts.

CONCLUSIONS

Results of ACL reconstruction using allografts or autografts augmented with an iliotibial band tenodesis were comparable. The BPTB autograft should remain the gold standard, although the BPTB allograft in ACL reconstruction is a reasonable alternative.

Radiographic and histologic analysis of the tibial tunnel after allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in goats

BACKGROUND

Several problems have been reported with use of allogenic grafts in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, including local immune response to allograft tendon within the synovial fluid, delayed maturation and ligamentization, and progressive tibial tunnel enlargement.

HYPOTHESIS

There is a correlation between the use of allograft and tibial tunnel enlargement.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Twenty healthy adult female goats underwent allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and were followed with serial radiographs at 6-week intervals. Animals were randomly chosen for sacrifice between 18 and 36 weeks for histologic assessment.

RESULTS

Significant radiographic increases in tunnel size were noted within the first 6 weeks of healing and remained up to 36 weeks with no further remodeling noted. Histologic analysis showed progressive ligamentization of the allografts with tendon-to-tunnel wall biologic fixation with dense connective tissue. Remodeling and incorporation of the bone plug was seen in all cases. The allograft tendon underwent early fibrous attachment within the tunnel and remodeled toward ligament histologic structure. Remodeling and incorporation of the bone plug was seen by 18 weeks.

CONCLUSION

Tibial tunnel enlargement, consistent with that seen in humans after allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, did not appear to affect the ultimate incorporation of the allograft on a histologic level.

The effects of graft width and graft laxity on the outcome of caprine anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

We studied how initial graft size and initial graft laxity affected the biomechanics of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction at six months. Sixteen goats had bilateral reconstructions staged eight weeks apart. Autografts 4 and 7 mm wide were taken from the central patellar tendon (PT). Lax grafts were created by adding 4 mm slack to the graft before fixing. We reconstructed each joint using a combination of width and laxity treatments. Both factors were changed for the contralateral joint and all combinations appeared with equal frequency. At six months we measured the joint extension limit, anterior-posterior (AP) translation, and osteoarthritic changes. The grafts were then tested to failure to determine their mechanical properties. After six months the difference in initial treatments had disappeared: there was no difference in graft cross-section due to the different initial widths and there was no difference in joint AP translation due to the initial graft laxity. We did observe that wide grafts were associated with a block to extension, decreased joint AP translation, and increased articular cartilage damage and osteophyte formation. While AP translation was reduced, it was correlated with decreased extension, possibly indicating an increase in scar tissue formation rather than a more functional graft. Neither graft width nor graft laxity produced differences in any graft mechanical properties. This suggests that the use of larger grafts to prevent increased AP translation has undesirable complications. Ultimately, we conclude that neither of these surgical treatments strongly affects the biomechanical result of caprine ACL reconstruction.

Functional failure of fascia lata allografts

OBJECTIVES

Fascia lata allografts are commonly used in urogynecologic procedures. Functional failure of several grafts has occurred, and such failure has been recognized as a materials problem in 12 patients.

STUDY DESIGN

Twelve patients with failure of an initial urogynecologic procedure performed with irradiated and freeze-dried donor fascia lata grafts underwent reoperation. Portions of the implanted fascia lata grafts could be retrieved in 7 cases. Graft specimens underwent histologic processing followed by hematoxylin and eosin staining.

RESULTS

Histopathologic analyses of the retrieved material demonstrated several ongoing processes in the failed grafts. A few grafts showed areas of ideal remodeling. Most grafts, however, showed areas of disorganized remodeling and areas of graft degeneration. Evidence of immune reaction to the graft was observed in some cases.

CONCLUSION

The high materials failure rate associated with the use of irradiated and freeze-dried donor fascia lata grafts suggests that such tissue should not be used for urogynecologic procedures.

Central quadriceps tendon for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Part I: Morphometric and biomechanical evaluation

We examined the anatomic and biomechanical adequacy of the central quadriceps tendon as an alternative graft source for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Morphometry was performed on 15 preserved and 6 fresh-frozen specimens. Biomechanical testing was performed on the six fresh-frozen specimens. We initially used a triple suture through the tendon construction, and then clamping directly on the tendon. Morphometry yielded the following measurements: length, 6.1 +/- 1.0 cm; width, 2.7 cm (range, 2.1 to 3.7); and thickness, 7 mm (range, 6.4 to 7.8). The thickness was 1.8 times that of the patellar tendon. Biomechanical testing showed that suture failure occurred at 692 +/- 181 N, and tendon failure occurred at 1075 +/- 449 N. The load to tendon failure was 1.36 times that of a comparable-width patellar tendon graft, although the difference was not statistically significant. The failure mode was primarily through partial or complete tendinous avulsion, with only one specimen failing at midsubstance. These findings show the central quadriceps graft is of sufficient size and strength to be used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

Effect of tibial attachment location on the healing of the anterior cruciate ligament freeze model

We studied the healing response of a devitalized anterior cruciate ligament to a treatment of initial anterior-posterior joint translation in goats. Devitalization and devascularization were achieved by five successive freeze-thaw cycles. Anterior-posterior translation was surgically altered by an osteotomy of the tibial attachment of the devitalized ligament and its reattachment either in the anatomical position or in a position 5 mm posterior. Six weeks after the first surgery, the same procedure was performed on the contralateral limb, except that the ligament was reattached in the alternate position. Six months after the initial surgery, femur-anterior cruciate ligament-tibia specimens were tested to determine their structural and mechanical material properties. Anatomic ligament placement resulted in reduced anterior-posterior translation (p < 0.05) and greater anterior joint stiffness (p < 0.05). Maximum load (p < 0.05) and ligament stiffness (p < 0.01) also were greater for the anatomically placed anterior cruciate ligaments. The maximum load for anatomically placed ligaments averaged 1.625 +/- 211 N (SEM). The strength of the posteriorly placed anterior cruciate ligament, 895 +/- 164 N was similar to results of historical anterior cruciate autograft reconstructions. Ligament failure occurred near the tibial insertion in the posteriorly placed ligaments more often than in the anatomically placed ligaments (four of five times compared with one of five times). Ligament failure near the tibial insertion occurred with lower mean maximum load than failure at the midsubstance or by bone avulsion (796 compared with 1.592 N: p < 0.05). These data support the hypothesis that ligament laxity is important to the healing and remodeling of anterior cruciate ligament grafts.

Why grafts fail

Significant advances in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery have been made in the past decade and, as a result, the number of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive procedures being done have increased. Unfortunately, graft failure continues to occur and has resulted in an emphasis on revision surgery. Successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is dependent on a number of factors including: patient selection, surgical technique, postoperative rehabilitation, and associated secondary restraint ligamentous instability. A particular emphasis both in scientific and clinical research has been placed on surgical technique. Errors in graft selection, tunnel placement, tensioning, or fixation methods chosen may lead to graft failure. Improper postoperative rehabilitation may lead to graft failure; however, current protocols seem to minimize its occurrence. Finally, failure to recognize or treat a significant secondary restraint instability can place excessive stress on the anterior cruciate ligament graft which may lead to failure. Care must be taken at every step of the process to ensure graft failure does not occur, because revision anterior cruciate ligament surgery results are not as predictable as primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with fresh-frozen patellar tendon allografts: sixty cases with 2 years' minimum follow-up

A prospective study was performed on 101 patients who underwent an arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with fresh-frozen patellar tendon allograft (bone-patellar tendon-bone). We present the results of the first 60 patients with a minimum follow-up of 2 years. Thirty-four were men and 26 women with a mean age of 23. In 45 patients, a postoperative arthroscopy was performed, and tissue biopsies of the reconstructed ACL were obtained. Patients were evaluated according to the International Knee Documentation Committee evaluation form. After a mean follow-up of 47 months, the overall results were normal or nearly normal in 85%. Under postoperative arthroscopy, the macroscopic appearance of the implant was similar to that of a normal ligament. The ACL allograft was covered with a normal, well-vascularized synovium. There were no cases of infection, disease transmission or tissue rejection. We conclude that the use of fresh-frozen patellar tendon allografts is a good method of ACL reconstruction.

Bone tunnel enlargement after anterior cruciate ligament replacement

Radiographic increase in the size of tibial and femoral tunnels has been observed. This retrospective study compared tibial tunnel diameter in 56 autograft and 87 allograft patellar tendon bone-tendon-bone anterior cruciate ligament replacements whose observed tunnel changes were correlated with clinical results at 1 year postoperatively. Tibial tunnel sclerotic margins were measured approximately 1 cm below the joint line. Exact tunnel dimension was calculated by using a magnification factor determined by the interference screw of known diameter within the same tunnel. Average allograft tunnel enlargement was 1.2 mm (-2.5 to 6.0) compared with the autograft tunnel enlargement of 0.26 mm (-2.5 to 2.7); the difference was significant (P > 0.0002). No significant difference was seen in KT-1000 arthrometer measurements between autograft or allograft groups, and no correlation was seen between increased tunnel size and clinical outcome as determined by the modified Hughston knee evaluation system. Tunnel measurement reproducibility was confirmed by independent repeated measurements. The significance of this tunnel enlargement is unknown and does not appear to adversely affect clinical outcome of allograft utilization. Possible explanations include an immune response with resorption, stress shielding proximal to the interference screw resulting in resorption, or an inflammatory response by synovium in the tunnel.

Achilles tendon allograft reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee

Thirty-five patients had reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with intraarticular fresh-frozen Achilles tendon allograft and extraarticular tibial band tenodesis. Patients were followed 2 to 4 years (mean, 2.5). Evaluation included clinical and functional examinations, measurement of tibiofemoral displacement, and anteroposterior and lateral radiographs. Clinical results were considered satisfactory in 85% of the patients; 16 had arthroscopic examination after the allograft; allograft biopsies in 9 at this time showed cellular and vascular tissue without evidence of immune reaction. Clinical, arthroscopic, and biopsy results were favorable, but radiologic results were not. In most patients there was a significant size increase in femoral and tibial bone tunnels, as measured from radiographs. In the 6 most extreme cases, bone tunnels measured 20 mm or more in diameter, twice the initial size. Etiology and clinical significance of these bone tunnel changes remain unknown. Enlargement appears to occur early after operation; it stabilizes within 2 years. No statistical correlation was seen between tunnel enlargement and results of clinical and functional examinations; nevertheless, unexplained tunnel enlargement is cause for concern, and allograft replacement of the anterior cruciate ligament with fresh-frozen Achilles tendon allograft should be considered a salvage procedure.

Tibial plateau leveling osteotomy for repair of cranial cruciate ligament rupture in the canine

A new technique for correcting the cranial cruciate deficient stifle, the tibial plateau leveling osteotomy, is introduced by the author. The technique is described and illustrated. Clinical results of 394 cases are described.