Association of Persistent Symptoms after Lyme Neuroborreliosis and Increased Levels of Interferon-α in Blood

Persistent self-reported health complaints in Norwegians who attribute their symptoms to tick bites or tick-borne disease- a cross-sectional controlled study

BACKGROUND

The frequency and mechanisms of persistent health complaints attributed to tick bites or tick-borne diseases are unknown. We evaluate such complaints in Norwegian cases and controls.

METHODS

People older than 18 years with persistent health complaints of six months or more attributed to tick bites or tick-borne diseases (cases) were recruited into a nationwide cross-sectional study between October 2016 and January 2021. Demographic data, tick bites, antibiotic use, and tick-borne pathogen serology were recorded. We evaluated somatic symptoms (PHQ-15), fatigue (Fatigue Severity Scale), mental and physical health (RAND-36), affective symptoms (HAD Scale) and modern health worries (MHW Scale) as outcome measures. Serological tests included IgG antibodies against B. burgdorferi (Bb) and other tick-borne pathogens. The control population (n = 2803) was recruited from a tick-endemic region in Søgne, southern Norway. Differences between cases and controls were evaluated.

RESULTS

A total of 500 responses were collected through general practitioners (n = 14), by invitation (n = 94), and by Short Message Service (SMS) (n = 392). The estimate of prevalence is based on 392 of 270.000 included by SMS (0.15%). The SMS cohort reported better physical health than those recruited by invitation. Cases had significantly more somatic and affective symptoms, fatigue, comorbidities, and reduced quality of life related to health than controls. The differences in fatigue and physical health between cases and controls were not related to previous tick exposures. Bb IgG and other antibodies against tick-borne pathogens were more prevalent in cases than controls. In multivariable analyses, cases that were never treated did not exhibit higher somatic symptom scores compared to those treated multiple times. Seropositive Bb cases had worse mental health (p < 0.001) and more depressive symptoms (p = 0.017) than seronegative cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The crude prevalence of persistent health complaints in Norway attributed to tick bites or tick-borne diseases is 0.15%. The cases reported significantly poorer physical health, including increased fatigue, when compared to the controls. These relationships were not affected by tick exposures. However, poorer mental health in cases may be associated with Bb seropositivity, especially for the ones with comorbidities. In conclusion, no clear associations were found between tick bites, tick-borne diseases and persistent health complaints.

The peptidoglycan of Borrelia burgdorferi can persist in discrete tissues and cause systemic responses consistent with chronic illness

Persistent symptoms after an acute infection is an emerging public health concern, but the pathobiology of such conditions is not well understood. One possible scenario involves the persistence of lingering antigen. We have previously reported that patients with postinfectious Lyme arthritis often harbor the peptidoglycan (PG) cell wall of Borrelia burgdorferi, the Lyme disease agent, in the synovial fluid of their inflamed joints after treatment. However, it is not yet known how B. burgdorferi PG persists, in what form, or if it may play a role in other postinfectious complications after Lyme disease. Using a murine model, we developed a real-time in vivo system to track B. burgdorferi PG as a function of cell wall chemistry and validated our findings using both molecular and cellular approaches. Unlike typical bacterial PG, the unique chemical properties of polymeric B. burgdorferi PG drive murine liver accumulation, where the cell wall material persists for weeks. Kupffer cells and hepatocytes phagocytose and retain B. burgdorferi PG and, although liver occupancy coincides with minimal pathology, both organ-specific and secreted protein profiles produced under these conditions bear some similarities to reported proteins enriched in patients with chronic illness after acute infection. Moreover, transcriptomic profiling indicated that B. burgdorferi PG affects energy metabolism in peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Our findings provide mechanistic insights into how a pathogenic molecule can persist after agent clearance, potentially contributing to illness after infection.

Symptoms after Lyme disease: What's past is prologue

Protracted fatigue and other symptoms can occur after Lyme disease and other infections, with numerous possible drivers. Studies on posttreatment Lyme disease have been inconclusive, with no confirmed biomarker emerging. Prolonged antibiotic therapy provides no benefit. Thus, a holistic approach toward understanding and treating this complex disease is necessary.

Repeated doxycycline treatment among patients with neuroborreliosis: a nationwide, population-based, registry-based, matched cohort study

OBJECTIVES

To investigate receipt of antibiotics among patients with neuroborreliosis after initial antibiotic treatment, likely attributable to posttreatment symptoms.

METHODS

We performed a nationwide, matched, population-based cohort study in Denmark (2009-2021). We included all Danish patients with neuroborreliosis, i.e. a positive Borrelia burgdorferi intrathecal antibody index test and a cerebrospinal fluid leukocyte count ≥10 × 106/l, and initially treated with doxycycline. To form a comparison cohort, we randomly extracted individuals from the general population matched 1:10 to patients with neuroborreliosis on date of birth and sex. The main outcome was receipt of doxycycline, and the secondary outcome was receipt of phenoxymethylpenicillin. We calculated short-term (<1 year) and long-term (≥1 year) hazard ratios (HR) with 95% confidence intervals (95%CI).

RESULTS

We included 463 patients with neuroborreliosis and 2,315 comparison cohort members. Compared with the comparison cohort members, patients with neuroborreliosis initially treated with doxycycline had increased receipt of additional doxycycline within 1 year (HR: 38.6, 95%CI: 17.5-85.0) and ≥1 years (HR: 3.5, 95%CI: 1.9-6.3). Compared with comparison cohort members, patients with neuroborreliosis had no increased receipt of phenoxymethylpenicillin (<1 year HR 1.0, 95%CI: 0.7-1.3; ≥1 years HR 1.2, 95%CI: 0.9-1.5).

CONCLUSIONS

After initial antibiotic treatment, patients with neuroborreliosis have increased receipt of doxycycline particularly within one year after initial antibiotic therapy but also subsequently. The lack of increased receipt of phenoxymethylpenicillin suggests that the receipt of doxycycline was not merely due to differences in healthcare-seeking behaviour, increased risk of early Lyme borreliosis due to exposure, or differences in antibacterial usage in general.

Persistent Symptoms After Lyme Disease: Clinical Characteristics, Predictors, and Classification

Persistent symptoms after an infection have been described for a number of infectious diseases, including Lyme disease. Studies have confirmed a moderate but consistent increase in the prevalence of such symptoms after Lyme disease, though the risk increase varies dependent on study design and the definition of persistent symptoms. Various possible predictors have been proposed, including a dysregulation of the immune system, metabolic changes, increased sensitization to pain signals, cognitive-behavioral factors, or-controversially-the persistence of the causative Borrelia bacteria or remnants thereof. Research on the precise roles of any of these factors is still ongoing. The lack of biological underpinning also makes it difficult to assess with certainty which patients' (generally nonspecific) persistent symptoms are etiologically related to the previous Lyme disease episode and which are not, particularly as these symptoms occur in the general population relatively frequently. The diagnostic criteria for posttreatment Lyme disease syndrome have shown their usefulness in both clinical and research settings but leave out a number of patients whose symptoms may fall just outside said criteria. Though the relationship between these symptoms and the previous Lyme disease episode may be very uncertain, we would argue that a uniform description and classification of these patients will aid in future research and patient management, regardless of the eventual underlying cause. Thus, we argue for an inclusive classification system for all persistent symptoms attributed to Lyme disease in order to promote validation of patient experiences and perspectives, while also maintaining scientific nuance regarding the very uncertain etiology of these patients' symptoms.

Treatment of post-treatment Lyme disease symptoms-a systematic review

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Residual symptoms after treatment of Lyme disease, sometimes called post-treatment Lyme disease symptoms (PTLDs), are a matter of ongoing controversy. To guide treatment recommendations, a systematic review was performed of the available literature on specific treatment for PTLDs.

METHODS

A systematic literature search of MEDLINE and CENTRAL was performed. No restrictions on case definitions, study types or specific interventions were applied to enable a comprehensive overview of the available literature. Risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tools for randomized controlled trials. Certainty of the evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach. Outcomes of interest were quality of life, fatigue, depression and cognition as well as adverse events.

RESULTS

After screening 1274 records, eight eligible randomized controlled trials were included. Heterogeneity was observed regarding inclusion criteria, intervention, length of treatment and outcome measures. For efficacy outcomes, results are presented narratively due to heterogeneity. Eligible studies show no statistically significant difference between antibiotics and placebo regarding quality of life, cognition and depression. Results for fatigue were inconsistent whilst studies with low risk of bias showed no statistically significant difference between antibiotics and placebo. Meta-analysis of safety outcomes showed statistically significantly more adverse events for antibiotics compared to placebo.

CONCLUSIONS

Available literature on treatment of PTLDs is heterogeneous, but overall shows evidence of no effect of antibiotics regarding quality of life, depression, cognition and fatigue whilst showing more adverse events. Patients with suspected PTLDs should not be treated with antibiotics.

Annexin A2 antibodies in post-treatment Lyme disease

Background

Anti-annexin A2 (AA2) antibodies have been described in Lyme arthritis and erythema migrans, although they have not been described in post-treatment Lyme disease (PTLD).

Objectives

Determine whether anti-AA2 antibodies are present among patients with PTLD and determine the clinical relevance of these antibodies.

Design and methods

Anti-AA2 levels were tested serially in a longitudinal cohort of 44 patients with acute Lyme disease, 22 with a return to health (EM RTH), and 22 with PTLD. Anti-AA2 antibodies were also assessed in a cross-sectional group of 281 patients with PTLD.

Results

Anti-AA2 antibodies were highest after antimicrobial therapy in both the EM RTH and PTLD cohorts. By 6 months, there was no difference between EM RTH and healthy controls. Anti-AA2 antibodies were higher in the cross-sectional PTLD group (79.69 versus 48.22 units, p < 0.0001), though with no difference in total symptom burden.

Conclusion

Anti-AA2 persists in PTLD, though did not identify a clinical phenotype.

Determinants of persistent symptoms after treatment for Lyme borreliosis: a prospective observational cohort study

BACKGROUND

Patients treated for Lyme borreliosis (LB) frequently report persistent symptoms. Little is known about risk factors and etiology.

METHODS

In a prospective observational cohort study with a follow-up of one year, we assessed a range of microbiological, immunological, genetic, clinical, functional, epidemiological, psychosocial and cognitive-behavioral variables as determinants of persistent symptoms after treatment for LB. Between 2015 and 2018 we included 1135 physician-confirmed LB patients at initiation of antibiotic therapy, through clinical LB centers and online self-registration. Two reference cohorts of individuals without LB (n = 4000 and n = 2405) served as a control. Prediction analyses and association studies were used to identify determinants, as collected from online questionnaires (three-monthly) and laboratory tests (twice).

FINDINGS

Main predictors of persistent symptoms were baseline poorer physical and social functioning, higher depression and anxiety scores, more negative illness perceptions, comorbidity, as well as fatigue, cognitive impairment, and pain in 295 patients with persistent symptoms. The primary prediction model correctly indicated persistent symptoms in 71.0% of predictions (AUC 0.79). In patients with symptoms at baseline, cognitive-behavioral responses to symptoms predicted symptom persistence. Of various microbiological, immunological and genetic factors, only lower IL-10 concentrations in ex vivo stimulation experiments were associated with persistent symptoms. Clinical LB characteristics did not contribute to the prediction of persistent symptoms.

INTERPRETATION

Determinants of persistent symptoms after LB were mainly generic, including baseline functioning, symptoms and cognitive-behavioral responses. A potential role of host immune responses remains to be investigated.

FUNDING

Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development (ZonMw); the Dutch Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport (VWS).

Single-cell RNA sequencing of murine ankle joints over time reveals distinct transcriptional changes following Borrelia burgdorferi infection

Lyme disease is caused by the bacterial pathogen Borrelia burgdorferi, which can be readily modeled in laboratory mice. In order to understand the cellular and transcriptional changes that occur during B. burgdorferi infection, we conducted single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) of ankle joints of infected C57BL/6 mice over time. We found that macrophages/monocytes, T cells, synoviocytes and fibroblasts all showed significant differences in gene expression of both inflammatory and non-inflammatory genes that peaked early and returned to baseline before the typical resolution of arthritis. Predictions of cellular interactions showed that macrophages appear to communicate extensively between different clusters of macrophages as well as with fibroblasts and synoviocytes. Our data give unique insights into the interactions between B. burgdorferi and the murine immune system over time and allow for a better understanding of mechanisms by which the dysregulation of the immune response may lead to prolonged symptoms in some patients.