Long-Term Effects of Climate and Competition on Radial Growth, Recovery, and Resistance in Mongolian Pines

Biodiversity and Management as Central Players in the Network of Relationships Underlying Forest Resilience

Global change is threatening the integrity of forest ecosystems worldwide, amplifying the need for resilience-based management to ensure their conservation and sustain the services they provide. Yet, current efforts are still limited by the lack of implementation of clear frameworks for operationalizing resilience in decision-making processes. To overcome this limitation, we aim to identify reliable and effective drivers of forest resilience, considering their synergies and trade-offs. From a comprehensive review of 342 scientific articles addressing resilience in forests globally, we identified factors shaping forest resilience. We recognized them into two categories that influence forest responses to disturbances: resilience predictors, which can be modified through management, and codrivers, which are measurable but largely unmanageable (e.g., climate). We then performed network analyses based on predictors and codrivers underlying forest resilience. In total, we recognized 5332 such relationships linking predictors or codrivers with forest attributes resilience. Our findings support the central role of biodiversity, with mixed, non-planted, or functionally diverse forests promoting resilience across all contexts and biomes. While management also enhanced resilience, the success of specific interventions was highly context-dependent, suggesting that its application requires a careful analysis of trade-offs. Specifically, practices like cutting and prescribed burning generally enhanced resilience in terms of tree growth, plant diversity, landscape vegetation cover, and stand structure. In contrast, pest and herbivore control reduced the resilience of plant taxonomic diversity while offering only minimal gains for other variables. Even long-term restoration projects showed clear trade-offs in the resilience of different forest attributes, highlighting the need for careful consideration of these effects in practical management decisions. Overall, we emphasize that a reduced number of predictors can be used to effectively promote forest resilience across most attributes. Particularly, enhancing biodiversity and implementing targeted management strategies when biodiversity is impoverished emerge as powerful tools to promote forest resilience.

Wet events increase tree growth recovery after different drought intensities

Understanding the dynamics of tree recovery after drought is critical for predicting the state of tree growth in the context of future climate change. While there has been a great deal of researches showing that drought events can cause numerous significant negative effects on tree growth, the positive effects of post-drought wetting events on tree growth remain unclear. Therefore, we analyzed the effect of wet and dry events on the radial growth of trees in Central Asia using data on the width of tree rings. The results showed that 1) Drought is the main limiting factor for radial growth of trees in Central Asia, and that as the intensity and sensitivity of drought increases, tree resistance decreases and recovery rises, and more frequent droughts reduce tree resistance. 2) Tree radial growth varied significantly with wet and dry conditions, with wet events before and after drought events significantly enhancing tree radial growth. 3) When drought is followed by a wetting event, the relationship between tree resistance and recovery is closer to the "line of full resilience", with a significant increase in recovery, and compensatory growth is more likely to occur. Thus, wetting events have a significant positive effect on tree radial growth and are a key factor in rapid tree growth recovery after drought.

Tree characteristics and drought severity modulate the growth resilience of natural Mongolian pine to extreme drought episodes

Global climate change and the increase in the frequency and intensity of drought have led to widespread forest decline and tree mortality. Studying the resilience components of tree growth to drought, including resistance (R_t), recovery (R_c), and resilience (R_s) and the influencing factors, helps assess forests' production and ecological stability under a changing climate. This study analyzed the responses of three resilience components of natural Mongolian pine (Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica) to drought events by examining individual-tree characteristics in two sites of Hulunbuir using the linear mixed effect model. The result showed that drought severity, diameter at breast height (dbh), pre-drought growth, and growth variability prior to drought had significant effects on the three resilience components of Mongolian pine growth. Specifically, as drought severity, dbh and growth variability increased, the R_t and R_s decreased, but R_c increased, showing a trade-off relationship with R_t. However, the R_t, R_c, and R_s decreased with pre-drought growth. Inter-tree competition and tree age also significantly impacted two resilience components. Besides, the interaction term between tree competition and tree age negatively affects R_t and R_s but positively affects R_c. Our findings highlight the influence of drought severity and individual-tree characteristics on drought resilience components, which can serve the adaptive management of natural Mongolian pine forests in the future.