From Western Asia to the Mediterranean Basin: Diversification of the Widespread Euphorbia nicaeensis Alliance (Euphorbiaceae)

Integrative taxonomy reveals cryptic diversity within the Euphorbia nicaeensis alliance (Euphorbiaceae) in the central Balkan Peninsula

The Eurasian steppes are the second-largest continuous biome on Earth. Euphorbia glareosa, a member of the Euphorbia nicaeensis alliance, is a widespread species in the macroclimatically defined zonal Pontic steppes and westerly and southerly adjacent extrazonal steppe outposts determined by local climatic, topographic, and edaphic conditions. In the extrazonal steppes, in particular within the Anatolian, Danubian, Thracian, and Pannonian grasslands, it is more or less continuously distributed, but with several disjunct occurrences in the central Balkan Peninsula, which is renowned for its high biodiversity. Several (infra)specific taxa have been recognised within E. glareosa s.l., but relationships among them remain elusive. We applied an integrative approach ranging from cytogenetics (relative genome size and ploidy estimation, chromosome counting) and morphometrics to phylogenetics (internal ribosomal transcribed spacer sequencing and amplified length polymorphism fingerprinting), with geographic focus on the central and eastern Balkan Peninsula. We inferred multiple polyploidisations within the group and complex phylogenetic patterns. We uncovered cryptic lineages in the central Balkan Peninsula, where the description of two new species, diploid E. balcanica, and tetraploid E. skopjensis was necessary. In addition, we revealed high diversity, partly related to polyploidisations, among the populations from the eastern Balkan and Pontic steppes, likely pertaining to different species. Finally, the main phylogeographic split within E. glareosa is between (1) Pannonian, central and eastern Balkan populations, and (2) the easternmost Balkan, Pontic, and Anatolian populations. Our results thus highlight the outstanding conservation value of the extrazonal European steppes that are not just an outpost of zonal Eurasian steppes. We also point to the remarkable biodiversity of the central and eastern Balkan Peninsula and the need for further in-depth studies of this biodiversity hotspot.

Evolution, range formation and a revised taxonomy of the disjunctly distributed European members of Astragalus sect. Caprini, an intricate group including highly endangered species of dry grasslands

The Eurasian steppes are among the largest and most threatened biomes on Earth. During cold periods of the Pleistocene, the zonal Eurasian steppes had a much larger extent as compared to interglacial periods, and repeatedly expanded into large areas of present-day forested temperate Europe. Conversely, during warm periods, forest expansion recurrently forced Eurasian steppe biota into disjunct and small warm-stage refugia, i.e. today's extrazonal steppes. The rare, threatened and disjunctly distributed northwestern African and European members of Astragalus sect. Caprini constitute an ideal model for gaining insights into the evolutionary dynamics of typical steppe biota. Here, we reconstructed the spatiotemporal diversification of northwestern African and European members of Astragalus sect. Caprini based on a combination of RADseq data, single gene markers (internal transcribed spacer, plastid ycf1), genome size measurements and multivariate morphometrics. We outline an evolutionary scenario in which the group originated in the Irano-Turanian region and started to diversify shortly after the Mid-Pleistocene-Transition (ca. 0.5 to 0.7 Ma). While lineages occurring in (sub-)mediterranean mountain ranges diverged early, lineages occurring in northern lowland steppes are much younger (ca. 0.2 to 0.3 Ma), emphasizing the importance of southern European mountain ranges as long-term refugia. Recurrent colonization of the western Mediterranean region by eastern Mediterranean lineages and secondary contacts of currently spatially isolated lineages have significantly (co-)shaped the genetic structure within the group; we assume that these events may be a consequence of cold-stage range expansions. Based on combined genetic and morphometric data, we suggest treating the ten lineages introduced in this study as independent species, contrasting previous taxonomic treatments.

Genome-Wide Data Uncover Cryptic Diversity With Multiple Reticulation Events in the Balkan-Anatolian Cardamine (Brassicaceae) Species Complex

Plant species diversity may be considerably underestimated, especially in evolutionarily complex genera and in diversity hotspots that have enabled long-term species persistence and diversification, such as the Balkan Peninsula. Here, we address the topic of underexplored plant diversity and underlying evolutionary and biogeographic processes by investigating the hygrophytic mountain species complex of Cardamine acris s.l. distributed in the Balkans (three subspecies within C. acris) and northwestern Anatolia (C. anatolica). We performed a series of phylogenetic and phylogeographic analyses based on restriction-site associated DNA sequencing (RADseq) and target enrichment (Hyb-Seq) data in combination with habitat suitability modelling. We found C. anatolica as a clade nested within the Balkan C. acris, probably resulting from a founder event, and uncovered three allopatric cryptic lineages within C. acris subsp. acris, allowing us to recognise a total of six entities in this complex. We observed the deepest genetic split within C. acris subsp. acris in the western Balkans, which was at odds with taxonomy and showed no distribution gap. We inferred vicariance as the most likely process for population divergence in the Balkans, accompanied by gene flow between the recognised entities, which was consistent with the modelled habitat suitability dynamics. Furthermore, we discovered several polyploid populations in C. acris, representing both pure intra- and inter-lineage hybrid polyploids, but detected only minor traces of hybridization with related congeners. Overall, our results illustrate that diverse evolutionary processes may influence the history of mountain plant species in the Balkan Peninsula, including vicariance, reticulation, polyploidization and cryptic diversification.

Influence of polyploidy on morphology and distribution of the Cypress Spurge (Euphorbia cyparissias, Euphorbiaceae)

Polyploidy can cause differences in phenotypic and physiological traits among different cytotypes of the same species. Polyploids may have larger organs or occupy different ecological niches than their diploid counterparts, therefore they are hypothesized to have larger distributions or prosper in stressful environments, such as higher elevations. The Cypress spurge (Euphorbia cyparissias L.; Euphorbiaceae) is a widespread European heteroploid species including di- (2x), tetra- (4x) and hexaploid (6x) cytotypes. We tested the hypotheses that polyploids are more widespread and more abundant at higher elevations and have larger organs than their diploid ancestors in the case of E. cyparissias. We also analysed whether genome downsizing had occurred after polyploidisation. We conducted a comprehensive geographic sampling of 617 populations of E. cyparissias throughout Europe. We estimated their relative genome size using flow cytometry and inferred ploidy level of each population. We scored 13 morphological traits of vegetative and seed characters and performed statistical analyses. The study indicates that polyploidisation facilitated colonisation of new areas in E. cyparissias, where the tetraploids are most widespread, whereas the diploids are limited to putative Pleistocene refugia, mostly in southern Europe. On the other hand, the three ploidies do not differ in their elevational distribution. Although some quantitative morphological traits exhibited an increasing trend with increasing ploidy, most traits did not differ significantly among the three ploidies, and there was no overall phenotypic differentiation among them. Given that individuals of different ploidies thrive in similar habitats across the same elevations, we suggest that ecological segregation following polyploidisation is a more important trigger for morphological differentiation than polyploidisation itself in autopolyploid plants. The study demonstrates that polyploidisation can be crucial for the colonisation of new areas and for range expansion, but it does not necessarily influence elevational distribution nor confer a different phenotype.

Evolutionary dynamics of Euphorbia carniolica suggest a complex Plio-Pleistocene history of understorey species of deciduous forest in southeastern Europe

Deciduous forests form the dominant natural vegetation of Europe today, but were restricted to small refugia during Pleistocene cold stages, implying an evolutionary past shaped by recurrent range contractions and expansions. Cold-stage forest refugia were probably widespread in southern and central Europe, with the northwestern Balkan Peninsula being of particular importance. However, the actual number and location of deciduous forest refugia, as well as the connections between them, remain disputed. Here, we address the evolutionary dynamics of the deciduous forest understorey species Euphorbia carniolica as a proxy for past forest dynamics. To do so, we obtained genomic and morphometric data from populations representing the species' entire range, investigated phylogenetic position and intraspecific genetic variation, tested explicit demographic scenarios and applied species distribution models. Our data support two disjoint groups linked to separate refugia on the northwestern and central Balkan Peninsula. We find that genetic differentiation between groups started in the early Pleistocene via vicariance, suggesting a larger distribution in the past. Both refugia acted as sources for founder events to the southeastern Alps and the Carpathians; the latter were likely colonised before the last cold stage. In line with traditional views on the pre-Pleistocene origin of many southeastern European deciduous forest species, the origin of E. carniolica was dated to the late Pliocene. The fact that E. carniolica evolved at a time when a period of continuous forestation was ending in much of Eurasia provides an interesting biogeographical perspective on the past links between Eurasian deciduous forests and their biota.

Meeting in Liguria: hybridisation between Apennine endemic Euphorbia barrelieri and western Mediterranean E. nicaeensis led to the allopolyploid origin of E. ligustica

The Mediterranean Basin is renowned for its extremely rich biota and is considered as one of the 25 Global Biodiversity Hotspots, but its diversity is not homogeneously distributed. Outstanding in the number of (endemic) species are the Ligurian Alps (Italy). At the foot of the Ligurian Alps, little above the Mediterranean Sea, a disjunct occurrence of Italian endemic Euphorbia barrelieri was reported. Using an array of integrative methods ranging from cytogenetic (chromosome number and relative genome size estimation), over phylogenetic approaches (plastid, ITS and RAD sequencing) to multivariate morphometrics we disentangled the origin of these populations that were shown to be tetraploid. We performed phylogenetic analyses of the nuclear ITS and plastid regions of a broad taxonomic sampling of Euphorbia sect. Pithyusa to identify possible species involved in the origin of the tetraploid populations and then applied various analyses of RADseq data to identify the putative parental species. Our results have shown that the Ligurian populations of E. barrelieri are of allotetraploid origin that involved E. barrelieri and western Mediterranean E. nicaeensis as parental species. We thus describe a new species, E. ligustica, and hypothesise that its adaptation to similar environments in which E. barrelieri occurs, triggered development of similar morphology, whereas its genetic composition appears to be closer to that of E. nicaeensis. Our study emphasises the importance of polyploidisation for plant diversification, highlights the value of the Ligurian Alps as a hotspot of biodiversity and endemism and underlines the importance of integrative taxonomic approaches in uncovering cryptic diversity.