A Combined Phenotypic-Genotypic Predictive Algorithm for In Vitro Detection of Bicarbonate: β-Lactam Sensitization among Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA)

Phenotypic and genotypic correlates of the sodium bicarbonate-responsive phenotype among methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus isolates from skin and soft-tissue infections

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to assess the frequency of the novel sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3)-responsive phenotype, wherein clinical methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) isolates are rendered susceptible to standard-of-care β-lactams in the presence of NaHCO3, in a collection of 103 clinical U.S. MRSA skin and soft-tissue infection (SSTI) isolates and 22 clinical European SSTI isolates. This study determined the correlation between specific phenotypic and genotypic metrics and the NaHCO3-responsive phenotype among U.S. SSTI isolates.

METHODS

Antimicrobial susceptibility testing was performed to determine susceptibility phenotypes. Targeted and whole-genome sequencing with a genome-wide sequence analysis were conducted to identify specific and novel genotypes of interest that may be associated with the NaHCO3-responsive phenotype. Gene expression analysis and targeted gene deletion were performed to assess the role of a specific novel genetic locus in the NaHCO3-responsive phenotype.

RESULTS

The NaHCO3-responsive phenotype was identified in 78/103 U.S. isolates and 4/22 UK isolates to cefazolin (CFZ), and in 17/103 U.S. isolates and 1/22 UK isolates to oxacillin. In U.S. isolates, a significant association was identified between NaHCO3-responsiveness to CFZ and: (a) susceptibility to amoxicillin-clavulanate; (b) a specific mecA genotype; (c) clonal complex type 8; and (d) spa type t008. Genome-wide sequence analysis identified single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in an AraC family regulator (SAUSA300_RS00540) to be exclusively found in NaHCO3-non-responsive SSTI strains. In vitro HCO3 exposures of NaHCO3-responsive strains, but not -non-responsive strains, caused >2-fold upregulated expression of this gene. Deletion of this gene rendered NaHCO3-responsive strain MRSA 11/11 no longer NaHCO3-responsive to CFZ; we have termed this gene the staphylococcal AraC bicarbonate-response regulator.

DISCUSSION

NaHCO3-responsiveness is highly associated with clonal complex type 8/spa type t008, a commonly circulating genetic background in North America. The AraC bicarbonate-response regulator, staphylococcal AraC bicarbonate-response regulator, appears to be associated with the mechanism of NaHCO3-responsiveness, but more work is needed to verify.

Prophage ϕSA169 Enhances Vancomycin Persistence in Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA)

Background: Persistent methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) endovascular infections present a significant clinical therapeutic challenge. Prophages are increasingly recognized as important genetic factors influencing the pathogenicity of S. aureus, yet their role in antibiotic persistence in MRSA remains underexplored. Our previous work demonstrated that prophage ϕSA169 promotes vancomycin (VAN) persistence in an experimental model of endocarditis caused by MRSA strains with a clonal complex (CC) 45 genetic background. However, it is unknown whether this persistence-promoting effect of ϕSA169 extends to other clinically relevant MRSA lineages. This study aims to elucidate the role of ϕSA169 in influencing VAN persistence across diverse MRSA genetic backgrounds. Methods: A pilot analysis of clinical data suggested that patients infected by MRSA containing ϕSA169-like prophage appear to have worse clinical outcomes. Thus, we lysogenized representative clinical resolving bacteremia (RB) MRSA strains with ϕSA169 and evaluated phenotypes closely associated with VAN persistence, including VAN susceptibility, biofilm formation, and the efficacy of VAN treatment in an experimental infective endocarditis (IE) model. Each ϕSA169 lysogenic strain was compared to its isogenic MRSA parental counterpart. Results: ϕSA169 lysogeny significantly promotes biofilm formation and enhances survival to VAN exposure under human-mimicking conditions for RB strains from CC5 and CC30. ϕSA169 lysogeny significantly reduces VAN effectiveness in the IE model due to RB lysogen from CC5 despite no detectable impact on VAN MICs. Conclusions: These results indicate that ϕSA169 promotes VAN persistence across clonal backgrounds, likely through biofilm formation and VAN tolerance. Targeting prophage could provide new strategies to combat persistent MRSA infections.

Bicarbonate Within: A Hidden Modulator of Antibiotic Susceptibility

Since its standardization, clinical antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) has relied upon a standard medium, Mueller-Hinton Broth/Agar (MHB/A), to determine antibiotic resistance. However, this microbiologic medium bears little resemblance to the host milieu, calling into question the physiological relevance of resistance phenotypes it reveals. Recent studies investigating antimicrobial susceptibility in mammalian cell culture media, a more host-mimicking environment, demonstrate that exposure to host factors significantly alters susceptibility profiles. One such factor is bicarbonate, an abundant ion in the mammalian bloodstream/tissues. Importantly, bicarbonate sensitizes methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) to early-generation β-lactams used for the treatment of methicillin-susceptible S. aureus (MSSA). This "NaHCO3-responsive" phenotype is widespread among US MRSA USA300/CC8 bloodstream and skin and soft tissue infection isolates. Translationally, β-lactam therapy has proven effective against NaHCO3-responsive MRSA in both ex vivo simulated endocarditis vegetation (SEV) and in vivo rabbit infective endocarditis (IE) models. Mechanistically, bicarbonate appears to influence mecA expression and PBP2a production/localization, as well as key elements for PBP2a functionality, including the PBP2a chaperone PrsA, components of functional membrane microdomains (FMMs), and wall teichoic acid (WTA) synthesis. The NaHCO3-responsive phenotype highlights the critical role of host factors in shaping antibiotic susceptibility, emphasizing the need to incorporate more physiological conditions into AST protocols.

Staphylococcus pseudintermedius ST2660 isolated from a cat has strong biofilm-forming ability and increases biofilm formation at cat's normal body temperature

Staphylococcus pseudintermedius has been isolated from dogs, cats, and horses and is also known as an emergent zoonotic agent. We administered orbifloxacin, a fluoroquinolone, to treat bacterial infections of cutaneous wounds caused by excessive grooming of the skin in contact with the subcutaneous port of the subcutaneous ureteral bypass (SUB) system in a cat. However, after 80 days of treatment, a severe abscess was observed in the wound and fluoroquinolone-resistant S. pseudintermedius was isolated from the abscess. The isolate was identified as a novel sequence type (ST) 2660 and contained genes for leukocidins (lukS and lukF), exfoliative toxin (siet), and biofilm regulation (icaA and icaD). The isolate was resistant to macrolide, lincosamide, fluoroquinolone, and tetracycline classes. In addition, the isolate had strong biofilm-forming ability which significantly increased with culturing at 39 °C compared with that at 37 °C, suggesting that the isolate prefers a cats' body temperature as the optimal biofilm growth condition. Notably, the biofilms were increased in the presence of doxycycline with culturing at 39 °C. This study is the first report in Japan on the new sequence type of S. pseudintermedius isolated from a companion animal and clarifies the distinctive virulence of S. pseudintermedius.

Genomic investigation and clinical correlates of the in vitro β-lactam: NaHCO3 responsiveness phenotype among methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus isolates from a randomized clinical trial

NaHCO3 responsiveness is a novel phenotype where some methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) isolates exhibit significantly lower minimal inhibitory concentrations (MIC) to oxacillin and/or cefazolin in the presence of NaHCO3. NaHCO3 responsiveness correlated with treatment response to β-lactams in an endocarditis animal model. We investigated whether treatment of NaHCO3-responsive strains with β-lactams was associated with faster clearance of bacteremia. The CAMERA2 trial (Combination Antibiotics for Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus) randomly assigned participants with MRSA bloodstream infections to standard therapy, or to standard therapy plus an anti-staphylococcal β-lactam (combination therapy). For 117 CAMERA2 MRSA isolates, we determined by broth microdilution the MIC of cefazolin and oxacillin, with and without 44 mM of NaHCO3. Isolates exhibiting ≥4-fold decrease in the MIC to cefazolin or oxacillin in the presence of NaHCO3 were considered "NaHCO3-responsive" to that agent. We compared the rate of persistent bacteremia among participants who had infections caused by NaHCO3-responsive and non-responsive strains, and that were assigned to combination treatment with a β-lactam. Thirty-one percent (36/117) and 25% (21/85) of MRSA isolates were NaHCO3-responsive to cefazolin and oxacillin, respectively. The NaHCO3-responsive phenotype was significantly associated with sequence type 93, SCCmec type IVa, and mecA alleles with substitutions in positions -7 and -38 in the regulatory region. Among participants treated with a β-lactam, there was no association between the NaHCO3-responsive phenotype and persistent bacteremia (cefazolin, P = 0.82; oxacillin, P = 0.81). In patients from a randomized clinical trial with MRSA bloodstream infection, isolates with an in vitro β-lactam-NaHCO3-responsive phenotype were associated with distinctive genetic signatures, but not with a shorter duration of bacteremia among those treated with a β-lactam.

Sensitizing methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) to cefuroxime: the synergic effect of bicarbonate and the wall teichoic acid inhibitor ticlopidine

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) strains are a major challenge for clinicians due, in part, to their resistance to most β-lactams, the first-line treatment for methicillin-susceptible S. aureus. A phenotype termed "NaHCO3-responsiveness" has been identified, wherein many clinical MRSA isolates are rendered susceptible to standard-of-care β-lactams in the presence of physiologically relevant concentrations of NaHCO3, in vitro and ex vivo; moreover, such "NaHCO3-responsive" isolates can be effectively cleared by β-lactams from target tissues in experimental infective endocarditis (IE). One mechanistic impact of NaHCO3 exposure on NaHCO3-responsive MRSA is to repress WTA synthesis. This NaHCO3 effect mimics the phenotype of tarO-deficient MRSA, including sensitization to the PBP2-targeting β-lactam, cefuroxime (CFX). Herein, we further investigated the impacts of NaHCO3 exposure on CFX susceptibility in the presence and absence of a WTA synthesis inhibitor, ticlopidine (TCP), in a collection of clinical MRSA isolates from skin and soft tissue infections (SSTI) and bloodstream infections (BSI). NaHCO3 and/or TCP enhanced susceptibility to CFX in vitro, by both minimum inhibitor concentration (MIC) and time-kill assays, as well as in an ex vivo simulated endocarditis vegetations (SEV) model, in NaHCO3-responsive MRSA. Furthermore, in experimental IE (presumably in the presence of endogenous NaHCO3), pre-exposure to TCP prior to infection sensitized the NaHCO3-responsive MRSA strain (but not the non-responsive strain) to enhanced clearances by CFX in target tissues. These data support the notion that NaHCO3 is acting similarly to WTA synthesis inhibitors, and that such inhibitors have potential translational applications in the treatment of certain MRSA strains in conjunction with specific β-lactam agents.

Role of the NaHCO3 Transporter MpsABC in the NaHCO3-β-Lactam-Responsive Phenotype in Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infections are an increasing concern due to their intrinsic resistance to most standard-of-care β-lactam antibiotics. Recent studies of clinical isolates have documented a novel phenotype, termed NaHCO3 responsiveness, in which a substantial proportion of MRSA strains exhibit enhanced susceptibility to β-lactams such as cefazolin and oxacillin in the presence of NaHCO3. A bicarbonate transporter, MpsAB (membrane potential-generating system), was recently found in S. aureus, where it plays a role in concentrating NaHCO3 for anaplerotic pathways. Here, we investigated the role of MpsAB in mediating the NaHCO3 responsiveness phenotype. Radiolabeled NaH14CO3 uptake profiling revealed significantly higher accumulation in NaHCO3-responsive vs nonresponsive MRSA strains when grown in ambient air. In contrast, under 5% CO2 conditions, NaHCO3-responsive (but not nonresponsive) strains exhibited repressed uptake. Oxacillin MICs were measured in four prototype strains and their mpsABC deletion mutants in the presence of NaHCO3 supplementation under 5% CO2 conditions. NaHCO3-mediated reductions in oxacillin MICs were observed in the responsive parental strains but not in mpsABC deletion mutants. No significant impact on oxacillin MICs was observed in the nonresponsive strains under the same conditions. Transcriptional and translational studies were carried out using both quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) and mpsA-green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusion constructs; these investigations showed that mpsA expression and translation were significantly upregulated during mid-exponential-phase growth in oxacillin-NaHCO3-supplemented medium in responsive versus nonresponsive strains. Taken together, these data show that the NaHCO3 transporter MpsABC is a key contributor to the NaHCO3-β-lactam responsiveness phenotype in MRSA. IMPORTANCE MRSA infections are increasingly difficult to treat, due in part to their resistance to most β-lactam antibiotics. A novel and relatively common phenotype, termed NaHCO3 responsiveness, has been identified in which MRSA strains show increased susceptibility in vitro and in vivo to β-lactams in the presence of NaHCO3. A recently described S. aureus NaHCO3 transporter, MpsAB, is involved in intracellular NaHCO3 concentration for anaplerotic pathways. We investigated the role of MpsAB in mediating the NaHCO3 responsiveness phenotype in four prototype MRSA strains (two responsive and two nonresponsive). We demonstrated that MpsABC is an important contributor to the NaHCO3-β-lactam responsiveness phenotype. Our study adds to the growing body of well-defined characteristics of this novel phenotype, which could potentially translate to alternative targets for MRSA treatment using β-lactams.

Editorial for the Special Issue: "Current Technique for Antibiotic Susceptibility Test: Advantages and Limitations; Need for Next-Generation Test"

The overuse or misuse of antibiotics, either when recommended by physicians or administered through self-medication at the time of infection, has caused drug-resistant pathogens to become a major healthcare issue, with millions of reported cases every year [...].

Influence of Sodium Bicarbonate on Wall Teichoic Acid Synthesis and β-Lactam Sensitization in NaHCO3-Responsive and Nonresponsive Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) strains pose major treatment challenges due to their innate resistance to most β-lactams under standard in vitro antimicrobial susceptibility testing conditions. A novel phenotype among MRSA, termed "NaHCO3 responsiveness," where certain strains display increased susceptibility to β-lactams in the presence of NaHCO3, has been identified among a relatively large proportion of MRSA isolates. One underlying mechanism of NaHCO3 responsiveness appears to be related to decreased expression and altered functionality of several genes and proteins involved in cell wall synthesis and maturation. Here, we studied the impact of NaHCO3 on wall teichoic acid (WTA) synthesis, a process intimately linked to peptidoglycan (PG) synthesis and functionality, in NaHCO3-responsive versus -nonresponsive MRSA isolates. NaHCO3 sensitized responsive MRSA strains to cefuroxime, a specific penicillin-binding protein 2 (PBP2)-inhibitory β-lactam known to synergize with early WTA synthesis inhibitors (e.g., ticlopidine). Combining cefuroxime with ticlopidine with or without NaHCO3 suggested that these latter two agents target the same step in WTA synthesis. Further, NaHCO3 decreased the abundance and molecular weight of WTA only in responsive strains. Additionally, NaHCO3 stimulated increased autolysis and aberrant cell division in responsive strains, two phenotypes associated with disruption of WTA synthesis. Of note, studies of key genes involved in the WTA biosynthetic pathway (e.g., tarO, tarG, dltA, and fmtA) indicated that the inhibitory impact of NaHCO3 on WTA biosynthesis in responsive strains likely occurred posttranslationally. IMPORTANCE MRSA is generally viewed as resistant to standard β-lactam antibiotics. However, a NaHCO3-responsive phenotype is observed in a substantial proportion of clinical MRSA strains in vitro, i.e., isolates which demonstrate enhanced susceptibility to standard β-lactam antibiotics (e.g., oxacillin) in the presence of NaHCO3. This phenotype correlates with increased MRSA clearance in vivo by standard β-lactam antibiotics, suggesting that patients with infections caused by such MRSA strains might be amenable to treatment with β-lactams. The mechanism(s) behind this phenotype is not fully understood but appears to involve mecA-PBP2a production and maturation axes. Our study adds significantly to this body of knowledge in terms of additional mechanistic targets of NaHCO3 in selected MRSA strains. This investigation demonstrates that NaHCO3 has direct impacts on S. aureus wall teichoic acid biosynthesis in NaHCO3-responsive MRSA. These findings provide an additional target for new agents being designed to synergistically kill MRSA using β-lactam antibiotics.

The NaHCO3-Responsive Phenotype in Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) Is Influenced by mecA Genotype

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) strains are a leading cause of many invasive clinical syndromes, and pose treatment difficulties due to their in vitro resistance to most β-lactams on standard laboratory testing. A novel phenotype frequently identified in MRSA strains, termed ‘NaHCO₃-responsiveness’, is a property whereby strains are susceptible in vitro to many β-lactams in the presence of NaHCO₃. Specific mecA genotypes, repression of mecA/PBP2a expression and perturbed maturation of PBP2a by NaHCO₃ have all been associated with this phenotype. The aim of this study was to define the relationship between specific mecA genotypes and PBP2a substitutions, on the one hand, with NaHCO₃-responsiveness in vitro. Mutations were made in the mecA ribosomal binding site (RBS -7) and at amino acid position 246 of its coding region in parental strains MW2 (NaHCO₃-responsive) and C36 (NaHCO₃- nonresponsive) to generate ‘swap’ variants, each harboring the other’s mecA-RBS/coding region genotypes. Successful swaps were confirmed by both sequencing, as well as predicted swap of in vitro penicillin-clavulanate susceptibility phenotypes. MW2 swap variants harboring the nonresponsive mecA genotypes became NaHCO₃-nonresponsive (resistant to the β-lactam, oxacillin [OXA]), in the presence of NaHCO₃. Moreover, these swap variants had lost NaHCO₃-mediated repression of mecA/PBP2a expression. In contrast, C36 swap variants harboring the NaHCO₃-responsive mecA genotypes remained NaHCO₃-nonresponsive phenotypically, and still exhibited nonrepressible mecA/PBP2a expression. These data demonstrate that in addition to the mecA genotype, NaHCO₃-responsiveness may also depend on strain-specific genetic backgrounds.

Impacts of NaHCO3 on β-Lactam Binding to PBP2a Protein Variants Associated with the NaHCO3-Responsive versus NaHCO3-Non-Responsive Phenotypes

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) regulates resistance to β-lactams via preferential production of an alternative penicillin-binding protein (PBP), PBP2a. PBP2a binds many β-lactam antibiotics with less affinity than PBPs which are predominant in methicillin-susceptible (MSSA) strains. A novel, rather frequent in vitro phenotype was recently identified among clinical MRSA bloodstream isolates, termed “NaHCO3-responsiveness”. This phenotype features β-lactam susceptibility of certain MRSA strains only in the presence of NaHCO3. Two distinct PBP2a variants, 246G and 246E, have been linked to the NaHCO3-responsive and NaHCO3-non-responsive MRSA phenotypes, respectively. To determine the mechanistic impact of PBP2a variants on β-lactam susceptibility, binding profiles of a fluorescent penicillin probe (Bocillin-FL) to each purified PBP2a variant were assessed and compared to whole-cell binding profiles characterized by flow cytometry in the presence vs. absence of NaHCO3. These investigations revealed that NaHCO3 differentially influenced the binding of the fluorescent penicillin, Bocillin-FL, to the PBP2a variants, with binding intensity and rate of binding significantly enhanced in the 246G compared to the 246E variant. Of note, the NaHCO3-β-lactam (oxacillin)-responsive JE2 strain, which natively harbors the 246G variant, had enhanced Bocillin-FL whole-cell binding following exposure to NaHCO3. This NaHCO3-mediated increase in whole-cell Bocillin-FL binding was not observed in the NaHCO3-non-responsive parental strain, COL, which contains the 246E PBP2a variant. Surprisingly, genetic swaps of the mecA coding sites between JE2 and COL did not alter the NaHCO3-enhanced binding seen in JE2 vs. COL. These data suggest that the non-coding regions of mecA may be involved in NaHCO3-responsiveness. This investigation also provides strong evidence that the NaHCO3-responsive phenotype in MRSA may involve NaHCO3-mediated increases in both initial cell surface β-lactam binding, as well as ultimate PBP2a binding of β-lactams.

Recent Developments in Phenotypic and Molecular Diagnostic Methods for Antimicrobial Resistance Detection in Staphylococcus aureus: A Narrative Review

Staphylococcus aureus is an opportunistic pathogen responsible for a wide range of infections in humans, such as skin and soft tissue infections, pneumonia, food poisoning or sepsis. Historically, S. aureus was able to rapidly adapt to anti-staphylococcal antibiotics and become resistant to several classes of antibiotics. Today, methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) is a multidrug-resistant pathogen and is one of the most common bacteria responsible for hospital-acquired infections and outbreaks, in community settings as well. The rapid and accurate diagnosis of antimicrobial resistance in S. aureus is crucial to the early initiation of directed antibiotic therapy and to improve clinical outcomes for patients. In this narrative review, I provide an overview of recent phenotypic and molecular diagnostic methods for antimicrobial resistance detection in S. aureus, with a particular focus on MRSA detection. I consider methods for resistance detection in both clinical samples and isolated S. aureus cultures, along with a brief discussion of the advantages and the challenges of implementing such methods in routine diagnostics.