Insights into the Cellular and Molecular Mechanisms That Govern the Fracture-Healing Process: A Narrative Review

4-Aminopyridine Promotes BMP2 Expression and Accelerates Tibial Fracture Healing in Mice

BACKGROUND

Delayed bone healing is common in orthopaedic clinical care. Agents that alter cell function to enhance healing would change treatment paradigms. 4-aminopyridine (4-AP) is a U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drug shown to improve walking in patients with chronic neurological disorders. We recently showed 4-AP's positive effects in the setting of nerve, wound, and even combined multi-tissue limb injury. Here, we directly investigated the effects of 4-AP on bone fracture healing, where differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells into osteoblasts is crucial.

METHODS

All animal experiments conformed to the protocols approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Arizona and Pennsylvania State University. Ten-week-old C57BL/6J male mice (22 to 28 g), following midshaft tibial fracture, were assigned to 4-AP (1.6 mg/kg/day, intraperitoneal [IP]) and saline solution (0.1 mL/mouse/day, IP) treatment groups. Tibiae were harvested on day 21 for micro-computed tomography (CT), 3-point bending tests, and histomorphological analyses. 4-AP's effect on human bone marrow mesenchymal stem cell (hBMSC) and human osteoblast (hOB) cell viability, migration, and proliferation; collagen deposition; matrix mineralization; and bone-forming gene/protein expression analyses was assessed.

RESULTS

4-AP significantly upregulated BMP2 gene and protein expression and gene expression of RUNX2, OSX, BSP, OCN, and OPN in hBMSCs and hOBs. 4-AP significantly enhanced osteoblast migration and proliferation, collagen deposition, and matrix mineralization. Radiographic and micro-CT imaging confirmed 4-AP's benefit versus saline solution treatment in mouse tibial fracture healing (bone mineral density, 687.12 versus 488.29 mg hydroxyapatite/cm 3 [p ≤ 0.0021]; bone volume/tissue volume, 0.87 versus 0.72 [p ≤ 0.05]; trabecular number, 7.50 versus 5.78/mm [p ≤ 0.05]; and trabecular thickness, 0.08 versus 0.06 mm [p ≤ 0.05]). Three-point bending tests demonstrated 4-AP's improvement of tibial fracture biomechanical properties versus saline solution (stiffness, 27.93 versus 14.30 N/mm; p ≤ 0.05). 4-AP also increased endogenous BMP2 expression and matrix components in healing callus.

CONCLUSIONS

4-AP increased the healing rate, biomechanical properties, and endogenous BMP2 expression of tibiae following fracture.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic Level III . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

A material dynamically enhancing both load-bearing and energy dissipation capability under cyclic loading

Material properties gradually degrade under cyclic loading, leading to catastrophic failure. It results in large costs for inspection, maintenance, and downtime. Besides, materials require combinations of performance such as load bearing and energy dissipation. However, improving one performance of a material often sacrifices another performance, making it difficult to create materials with optimal performance profiles. Here we report a liquid-infused porous piezoelectric scaffold (LIPPS) that simultaneously enhances its load-bearing and energy dissipation capability under cyclic loading. For example, after 12 million loading cycles, LIPPS increases its modulus by 3600% and hysteresis by 3000%. From a CT study, this behavior is attributed to the self-recoverable mineralization under mechanical loading. Moreover, LIPPS shows a reprogrammable stiffness distribution based on the loading distribution, which enables the material to generate multiple shapes by self-folding. Our findings can contribute toward unprecedented opportunities in soft robotics, vehicles, infrastructure, and tissue engineering and contribute to the new paradigm of material selection with improved resilience and sustainability.

Deer antler velvet (Cervus elaphus sibiricus) promotes fracture healing via partial BMP2-Smad mediated osteoblast differentiation

BACKGROUND CERVUS ELAPHUS SIBIRICUS: (CES) has been traditionally used in Korean clinics to promote fracture healing based on its function of tonifying the kidneys and strengthening bones. However, experimental data supporting its efficacy are still insufficient. The aim of this study investigated the bone-union properties of CES in a femoral fracture animal model and its corresponding molecular mechanisms.

METHODS

Fifty-four C57BL/6 male mice underwent femoral shaft fracture by Bonnarens and Einhorn's method, subsequently receiving a water extract of CES (200 mg/kg/day, daily) for 7 and 14 days. Safranin O staining and immunohistochemistry of the fracture region were conducted against transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β), bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP2), and osterix. MG63 cells used to examine the underlying mechanisms of CES focused on BMP2-Smad pathway-related osteogenesis.

RESULTS

CES administration led to earlier union of the fractured bones, supported by Safranin O staining of the fracture region, demonstrating significantly increased cartilage formation day on 7 and a rapidly decreased cartilage area due to callus formation day on 14. CES administration also significantly upregulated the expression of TGF-β1 day 7, BMP 2, and osterix day 14 at the fracture site and also up-regulated alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, calcium deposition, and the phosphorylation of Smad in MG63 cells.

CONCLUSIONS

CES promotes fracture healing by promoting osteoblastogenesis via a partial BMP2-Smad pathway.

Osseointegration-Related Exosomes for Surface Functionalization of Titanium Implants

Despite that the clinical application of titanium-based implants has achieved great success, patients' own diseases and/or unhealthy lifestyle habits often lead to implant failure. Many studies have been carried out to modify titanium implants to promote osseointegration and implant success. Recent studies showed that exosomes, proactively secreted extracellular vesicles by mammalian cells, could selectively target and modulate the functions of recipient cells such as macrophages, nerve cells, endothelial cells, and bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells that are closely involved in implant osseointegration. Accordingly, using exosomes to functionalize titanium implants has been deemed as a novel and effective way to improve their osseointegration ability. Herein, recent advances pertaining to surface functionalization of titanium implants with exosomes are analyzed and discussed, with focus on the role of exosomes in regulating the functions of osseointegration-related cells, and their immobilization strategies as well as resultant impact on osseointegration ability.

Nanoparticle-Mediated Gene Delivery for Bone Tissue Engineering

Critical-sized bone defects represent an urgent clinical problem, necessitating innovative treatment approaches. Gene-activated grafts for bone tissue engineering have emerged as a promising solution. However, traditional gene delivery methods are constrained by limited osteogenic efficacy and safety concerns. Recently, organic and inorganic nanoparticle (NP) vectors have attracted significant attention in bone tissue engineering for their safe, stable, and controllable gene delivery. Targeted gene delivery guided by insights into bone healing mechanisms, coupled with the multifunctional design of NPs, is crucial for enhancing therapeutic outcomes. Here, the theoretical foundations underlying NP-mediated gene therapy for enhancing bone healing across different histological stages are elucidated. Furthermore, the distinct attributes of functionalized NP vectors are discussed, and cutting-edge strategies aimed at optimizing gene delivery efficiency throughout the therapeutic process are highlighted. Additionally, the review addresses the unresolved challenges and prospects of this technology. This review may contribute to the continued development and clinical application of NP-mediated gene delivery for treating critical-sized bone defects.

Progress in Dentin-Derived Bone Graft Materials: A New Xenogeneic Dentin-Derived Material with Retained Organic Component Allows for Broader and Easier Application

The optimal repair of rigid mineralized tissues, such as bone, in cases of fracture, surgical resection, or prosthetic placement, is a complex process often necessitating the use of bone graft materials. Autogenous bone from the patient is generally the gold standard in terms of outcomes but also has disadvantages, which have resulted in extensive research in the field of tissue engineering to develop better and more convenient alternatives. In the dental field, several initiatives have demonstrated that the dentin material derived from extracted teeth produces excellent results in terms of repairing bone defects and supporting dental implants. Dentin is acellular and thus, in contrast to autogenous bone, cannot provide osteoblasts or other cellular elements to the grafted region, but it does contain growth and differentiation factors, and has other properties that make it an impressive material for bone repair. In this review, the beneficial properties of dentin and the ways it interacts with the host bone are described in the context of bone graft materials. Autogenous tooth material has limitations, particularly in terms of the need for tooth extraction and the limited amount available, which currently restrict its use to particular dental procedures. The development of a xenograft dentin-derived material, which retains the properties of autogenous dentin, is described. Such a material could potentially enable the use of dentin-derived material more widely, particularly in orthopedic indications where its properties may be advantageous.

Activation of Wnt signaling in human fracture callus and nonunion tissues

The Wnt signaling pathway is a key molecular process during fracture repair. Although much of what we now know about the role of this pathway in bone is derived from in vitro and animal studies, the same cannot be said about humans. As such, we hypothesized that Wnt signaling will also be a key process in humans during physiological fracture healing as well as in the development of a nonunion (hypertrophic and oligotrophic). We further hypothesized that the expression of Wnt-signaling pathway genes/proteins would exhibit a differential expression pattern between physiological fracture callus and the pathological nonunion tissues. We tested these two hypotheses by examining the mRNA levels of key Wnt-signaling related genes: ligands (WNT4, WNT10a), receptors (FZD4, LRP5, LRP6), inhibitors (DKK1, SOST) and modulators (CTNNB1 and PORCN). RNA sequencing from calluses as well as from the two nonunion tissue types, revealed that all of these genes were expressed at about the same level in these three tissue types. Further, spatial expression experiments identified the cells responsible of producing these proteins. Robust expression was detected in osteoblasts for the majority of these genes except SOST which displayed low expression, but in contrast, was mostly detected in osteocytes. Many of these genes were also expressed by callus chondrocytes as well. Taken together, these results confirm that Wnt signaling is indeed active during both human physiological fracture healing as well as in pathological nonunions.

Fluoride-treated rare earth-free magnesium alloy ZK30: An inert and bioresorbable material for bone fracture treatment devices

Bone fractures represent a common health problem, particularly in an increasingly aging population. Bioresorbable magnesium (Mg) alloy-based implants offer promising alternatives to traditional metallic implants for the treatment of bone fractures because they eliminate the need for implant removal after healing. The Mg-Y-rare-earth (RE)-Zr alloy WE43, designed for orthopedic implants, has received European Conformity mark approval. However, currently, WE43 is not clinically used in certain countries possibly because of concerns related to RE metals. In this study, we investigated the use of a RE-free alloy, namely, Mg-Zn-Zr alloy (ZK30), as an implant for bone fractures. Hydrofluoric acid (HF) treatment was performed to improve the corrosion resistance of ZK30. HF-treated ZK30 (HF-ZK30) exhibited lower corrosion rate and higher biocompatibility than those of WE43 in in vitro experiments. After implanting a rod of HF-ZK30 into the fractured femoral bones of mice, HF-ZK30 held the bones and healed the fracture without deformation. Treatment results of HF-ZK30 were comparable to those of WE43, indicating the potential of HF-ZK30 as a bioresorbable and safe implant for bone repair.

Regulation of metabolic microenvironment with a nanocomposite hydrogel for improved bone fracture healing

Bone nonunion poses an urgent clinical challenge that needs to be addressed. Recent studies have revealed that the metabolic microenvironment plays a vital role in fracture healing. Macrophages and bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cells (BMSCs) are important targets for therapeutic interventions in bone fractures. Itaconate is a TCA cycle metabolite that has emerged as a potent macrophage immunomodulator that limits the inflammatory response. During osteogenic differentiation, BMSCs tend to undergo aerobic glycolysis and metabolize glucose to lactate. Copper ion (Cu2+) is an essential trace element that participates in glucose metabolism and may stimulate glycolysis in BMSCs and promote osteogenesis. In this study, we develop a 4-octyl itaconate (4-OI)@Cu@Gel nanocomposite hydrogel that can effectively deliver and release 4-OI and Cu2+ to modulate the metabolic microenvironment and improve the functions of cells involved in the fracture healing process. The findings reveal that burst release of 4-OI reduces the inflammatory response, promotes M2 macrophage polarization, and alleviates oxidative stress, while sustained release of Cu2+ stimulates BMSC glycolysis and osteogenic differentiation and enhances endothelial cell angiogenesis. Consequently, the 4-OI@Cu@Gel system achieves rapid fracture healing in mice. Thus, this study proposes a promising regenerative strategy to expedite bone fracture healing through metabolic reprogramming of macrophages and BMSCs.

Efficacy and safety of Osteoking on fracture healing: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

Osteoking (OK) is prescribed in traditional Chinese medicine to accelerate fracture healing. Although some studies suggest the potential efficacy of OK for fracture healing, the evidence remains inconclusive.

Aim

To systematically evaluate the safety of OK and its effect on fracture healing.

Methods

Relevant authoritative databases were searched until 25 August 2023. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of patients with fractures treated with Osteoking were included. We evaluated the risk of bias using the Cochrane tool and performed a meta-analysis using the Review Manager 5.4 software package.

Results

13 studies involving 1123 participants were included. This meta-analysis showed that compared with observations in the control group, the OK group showed a shortened fracture healing time, increased fracture healing rate, reduced swelling regression time and ecchymosis regression time, and improved bone metabolism. In addition, the included studies did not report any serious side effects associated with the use of OK, and the mild side effects resolved without treatment.

Conclusion

OK therapy is beneficial and safe for accelerating fracture healing, reducing swelling, eliminating ecchymosis, and improving bone metabolism. However, the meta-analysis results do not support OK treatment for improving the fracture healing rate at all fracture sites and reducing pain across all fracture sites. Further original, high-quality studies are needed to validate these findings.

Systematic Review Registration: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?RecordID=452430, identifier CRD42023452430.

Latest Progress of LIPUS in Fracture Healing: A Mini-Review

The use of low-intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS) for promoting fracture healing has been Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved since 1994 due to largely its non-thermal effects of sound flow sound radiation force and so on. Numerous clinical and animal studies have shown that LIPUS can accelerate the healing of fresh fractures, nonunions, and delayed unions in pulse mode regardless of LIPUS devices or circumstantial factors. Rare clinical studies show limitations of LIPUS for treating fractures with intramedullary nail fixation or low patient compliance. The biological effect is achieved by regulating various cellular behaviors involving mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSCs), osteoblasts, chondrocytes, and osteoclasts and with dose dependency on LIPUS intensity and time. Specifically, LIPUS promotes the osteogenic differentiation of MSCs through the ROCK-Cot/Tpl2-MEK-ERK signaling. Osteoblasts, in turn, respond to the mechanical signal of LIPUS through integrin, angiotensin type 1 (AT1), and PIEZO1 mechano-receptors, leading to the production of inflammatory factors such as COX-2, MCP-1, and MIP-1β fracture repair. LIPUS also induces CCN2 expression in chondrocytes thereby coordinating bone regeneration. Finally, LIPUS suppresses osteoclast differentiation and gene expression by interfering with the ERK/c-Fos/NFATc1 cascade. This mini-review revisits the known effects and mechanisms of LIPUS on bone fracture healing and strengthens the need for further investigation into the underlying mechanisms.

The local and systemic effects of immune function on fracture healing

The immune system plays an integral role in the regulation of cellular processes responsible for fracture healing. Local and systemic influences on fracture healing correlate in many ways with fracture-related outcomes, including soft tissue healing quality and fracture union rates. Impaired soft tissue healing, restricted perfusion of a fracture site, and infection also in turn affect the immune response to fracture injury. Modern techniques used to investigate the relationship between immune system function and fracture healing include precision medicine, using vast quantities of data to interpret broad patterns of inflammatory response. Early data from the PRECISE trial have demonstrated distinct patterns of inflammatory response in polytrauma patients, which thereby directly and indirectly regulate the fracture healing response. The clearly demonstrated linkage between immune function and fracture healing suggests that modulation of immune function has significant potential as a therapeutic target that can be used to enhance fracture healing.

A Comprehensive Review of Platelet-Rich Plasma and Its Emerging Role in Accelerating Bone Healing

This comprehensive review delves into the emerging role of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) in accelerating bone healing. PRP, a blood-derived product rich in platelets and growth factors, has garnered attention for its regenerative potential. The review begins by defining PRP and providing a historical background, highlighting its significance in expediting bone healing. PRP's composition and preparation methods, including centrifugation techniques and commercial kits, are explored. Mechanistically, PRP operates by releasing growth factors, chemotaxis, and angiogenesis, elucidating its cellular effects. Applications in fracture healing and orthopaedic surgeries, such as joint arthroplasty and spinal fusion, are discussed, emphasising the promising outcomes in clinical trials. Safety considerations, patient selection criteria, and the need for PRP preparation and application standardisation are underscored. The review outlines ongoing research trends, potential technological advancements, and unexplored areas in paediatric applications and inflammatory bone disorders. The implications for clinical practice involve informed decision-making, optimised protocols, and interdisciplinary collaboration. In conclusion, the future of PRP in bone healing holds exciting prospects, with the potential for precision medicine, integration with emerging therapies, expanded applications, and enhanced technological innovations shaping its trajectory in orthopaedics and regenerative medicine.

Special at-rich sequence-binding protein 2 and its role in healing of the experimental mandible bone tissue defect filling with a synthetic bone graft material and electrical stimulation impact

OBJECTIVE

Aim: The purpose of the study was to identify the role of SATB2 in healing of the experimental mandible bone tissue defect filling with a synthetic bone graft material and electrical stimulation impact.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Materials and Methods: An experiment was carried out on 48 mature male rats of the WAG population, which were divided into 4 groups. Each group included 12 experimental animals. Group 1 included rats that were modeled with a perforated defect of the lower jaw body. Group 2 included animals that were modeled with a perforated defect similar to group 1. In animals, a microdevice for electrical action was implanted subcutaneously in the neck area on the side of the simulated bone defect. The negative electrode connected to the negative pole of the battery was in contact with the bone defect. The battery and electrode were insulated with plastic heat shrink material. Group 3 included rats that were modeled with a perforated defect similar to previous groups, the cavity of which was filled with synthetic bone graft "Biomin GT" (RAPID, Ukraine). Group 4 included animals that were modeled with a perforated defect similar to groups 1-3, the cavity of which was filled with synthetic bone graft "Biomin GT" (RAPID, Ukraine). The simulation of electrical stimulation was the same as in group 2. The material for the morphological study was a fragment of the body of the lower jaw from the zone of the perforated defect. Immunohistochemical study was performed using rabbit anti-human SATB2 monoclonal antibody.

RESULTS

Results: In the regenerate filling the defect in the bone tissue of the lower jaw of rats, there was an increase in SATB2 expression under conditions of electrical stimulation; filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material; simultaneous filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material and electrical stimulation. The most pronounced expression of SATB2 was observed under conditions of simultaneous filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material and electrical stimulation; minimally expressed - in conditions of filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material; moderately expressed - under conditions of electrical stimulation. In the regenerate, in cases of all treatment methods, SATB2 was expressed by immune cells, fibroblastic differon cells, osteoblasts, and in case of electrical stimulation, also by adipocytes, vascular pericytes and endothelial cells, epidermis.

CONCLUSION

Conclusions: The activation of SATB2 expression identified by the authors is one of the mechanisms for stimulating reparative osteogenesis under the conditions of electrical stimulation; filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material; simultaneous filling the defect with a synthetic bone graft material and electrical stimulation.

MicroRNA-26 and Related Osteogenic Target Genes Could Play Pivotal Roles in Photobiomodulation and Adipose-Derived Stem Cells-Based Healing of Critical Size Foot Defects in the Rat Model

Objective: In this study, we aimed to explore the role of MicroRNA-26 in photobiomodulation (PBM)- and adipose-derived stem cell (ADS)-based healing of critical-sized foot fractures in a rat model. Background: PBM and ADS treatments are relatively invasive methods for treating bone defects. Specific and oriented cellular and molecular functions can be induced by applying an appropriate type of PBM and ADS treatment. Methods: A critical size foot defect (CSFD) is induced in femoral bones of 24 rats. Then, a human demineralized bone matrix scaffold (hDBMS) was engrafted into all CSFDs. The rats were randomly allocated into four groups (n = 6): (1) control (hDBMS); (2) hDBMS+human ADSs (hADSs), hADSs engrafted into CSFDs; (3) hDBMS+PBM, CSFD exposed to PBM (810 nm wavelength, 1.2 J/cm2 energy density); and (4) hDBMS+(hADSs+PBM), hADSs implanted into the CSFD and then exposed to PBM. At 42 days after CSFD induction, the rats were killed, and the left CSFD was removed for mechanical compression tests and the right CSFD was removed for molecular and histological studies. Results: The results indicate that miRNA-26a, BMP, SMAD, RUNX, and OSTREX had higher expression in the treated groups than in the control group. Further, the biomechanical and histological properties of CSFDs in treated groups were improved compared with the control group. Correlation tests revealed a positive relationship between microRNA and improved biomechanical and cellular parameters of CSFDs in the rat model. Conclusions: We concluded that the MicroRNA-26 signaling pathway probably plays a significant role in the hADS-, PBM-, and hADS+PBM-based healing of CSFDs in rats. Clinical Trial Registration number: IR.SBMU.MSP.REC.1398.980.

The bioelectrical properties of bone tissue

Understanding the bioelectrical properties of bone tissue is key to developing new treatment strategies for bone diseases and injuries, as well as improving the design and fabrication of scaffold implants for bone tissue engineering. The bioelectrical properties of bone tissue can be attributed to the interaction of its various cell lineages (osteocyte, osteoblast and osteoclast) with the surrounding extracellular matrix, in the presence of various biomechanical stimuli arising from routine physical activities; and is best described as a combination and overlap of dielectric, piezoelectric, pyroelectric and ferroelectric properties, together with streaming potential and electro-osmosis. There is close interdependence and interaction of the various electroactive and electrosensitive components of bone tissue, including cell membrane potential, voltage-gated ion channels, intracellular signaling pathways, and cell surface receptors, together with various matrix components such as collagen, hydroxyapatite, proteoglycans and glycosaminoglycans. It is the remarkably complex web of interactive cross-talk between the organic and non-organic components of bone that define its electrophysiological properties, which in turn exerts a profound influence on its metabolism, homeostasis and regeneration in health and disease. This has spurred increasing interest in application of electroactive scaffolds in bone tissue engineering, to recapitulate the natural electrophysiological microenvironment of healthy bone tissue to facilitate bone defect repair.

Influence of Bone Substitutes on Mesenchymal Stromal Cells in an Inflammatory Microenvironment

Bone regeneration is driven by mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) via their interactions with immune cells, such as macrophages (MPs). Bone substitutes, e.g., bi-calcium phosphates (BCPs), are commonly used to treat bone defects. However, little research has focused on MSC responses to BCPs in the context of inflammation. The objective of this study was to investigate whether BCPs influence MSC responses and MSC-MP interactions, at the gene and protein levels, in an inflammatory microenvironment. In setup A, human bone marrow MSCs combined with two different BCP granules (BCP 60/40 or BCP 20/80) were cultured with or without cytokine stimulation (IL1β + TNFα) to mimic acute inflammation. In setup B, U937 cell-line-derived MPs were introduced via transwell cocultures to setup A. Monolayer MSCs with and without cytokine stimulation served as controls. After 72 h, the expressions of genes related to osteogenesis, healing, inflammation and remodeling were assessed in the MSCs via quantitative polymerase chain reactions. Additionally, MSC-secreted cytokines related to healing, inflammation and chemotaxis were assessed via multiplex immunoassays. Overall, the results indicate that, under both inflammatory and non-inflammatory conditions, the BCP granules significantly regulated the MSC gene expressions towards a pro-healing genotype but had relatively little effect on the MSC secretory profiles. In the presence of the MPs (coculture), the BCPs positively regulated both the gene expression and cytokine secretion of the MSCs. Overall, similar trends in MSC responses were observed with BCP 60/40 and BCP 20/80. In summary, within the limits of in vitro models, these findings suggest that the presence of BCP granules at a surgical site may not necessarily have a detrimental effect on MSC-mediated wound healing, even in the event of inflammation.

Synergistic Effect of Carbonate Apatite and Autogenous Bone on Osteogenesis

Bone augmentation using artificial bone is an important option in dental defect prostheses. A bone substitute using carbonate apatite (CO₃Ap), an inorganic component of bone, was reported to have promising bone formation and bone replacement ability. However, the osteoinductivity of artificial bone is less than autogenous bone (AB). In this study, CO₃Ap with AB is demonstrated as a clinically effective bone substitute. For in vitro experiments, an osteoclast-like cell (RAW-D) was cultured in the presence of AB, CO₃Ap, or both (Mix), and the number of osteoclasts was evaluated. Osteoblasts were also cultured under the same conditions, and the number of adherent cells was evaluated. For in vivo experiments, a few holes were created in the rat tibia and AB, CO₃Ap, or Mix were added. At 0, 14, and 21 days, the tissue morphology of the wound area was observed, and the thickness of the cortical bone was measured. In vitro, Mix did not increase the number of osteoclasts or osteoblasts. However, in vivo, the rate of bone replacement remarkably increased with Mix on dome-shape. A bone-grafting material combining osteoinductive AB with abundant artificial bone is expected to be clinically easy to use and able to form bone.

Criteria, Challenges, and Opportunities for Acellularized Allogeneic/Xenogeneic Bone Grafts in Bone Repairing

As bone grafts become more commonly needed by patients and as donors become scarcer, acellularized bone grafts (ABGs) are becoming more popular for restorative purposes. While autogeneic grafts are reliable as a gold standard, allogeneic and xenogeneic ABGs have been shown to be of particular interest due to the limited availability of autogeneic resources and reduced patient well-being in long-term surgeries. Because of the complete similarity of their structures with native bone, excellent mechanical properties, high biocompatibility, and similarities of biological behaviors (osteoinductive and osteoconductive) with local bones, successful outcomes of allogeneic and xenogeneic ABGs in both in vitro and in vivo research have raised hopes of repairing patients' bone injuries in clinical applications. However, clinical trials have been delayed due to a lack of standardized protocols pertaining to acellularization, cell seeding, maintenance, and diversity of ABG evaluation criteria. This study sought to uncover these factors by exploring the bone structures, ossification properties of ABGs, sources, benefits, and challenges of acellularization approaches (physical, chemical, and enzymatic), cell loading, and type of cells used and effects of each of the above items on the regenerative technologies. To gain a perspective on the repair and commercialization of products before implementing new research activities, this study describes the differences between ABGs created by various techniques and methods applied to them. With a comprehensive understanding of ABG behavior, future research focused on treating bone defects could provide a better way to combine the treatment approaches needed to treat bone defects.