Comparison of Synthetic Membranes to Heat-Separated Human Epidermis in Skin Permeation Studies In Vitro

Evaluation of Drug Permeation Enhancement by Using In Vitro and Ex Vivo Models

Drugs administered by means of extravascular routes of drug administration must be absorbed into the systemic circulation, which involves the movement of the drug molecules across biological barriers such as epithelial cells that cover mucosal surfaces or the stratum corneum that covers the skin. Some drugs exhibit poor permeation across biological membranes or may experience excessive degradation during first-pass metabolism, which tends to limit their bioavailability. Various strategies have been used to improve drug bioavailability. Absorption enhancement strategies include the co-administration of chemical permeation enhancers, enzymes, and/or efflux transporter inhibitors, chemical changes, and specialized dosage form designs. Models with physiological relevance are needed to evaluate the efficacy of drug absorption enhancement techniques. Various in vitro cell culture models and ex vivo tissue models have been explored to evaluate and quantify the effectiveness of drug permeation enhancement strategies. This review deliberates on the use of in vitro and ex vivo models for the evaluation of drug permeation enhancement strategies for selected extravascular drug administration routes including the nasal, oromucosal, pulmonary, oral, rectal, and transdermal routes of drug administration.

Hyaluronan-Cholesterol nanogels embedding betamethasone for the treatment of skin inflammatory conditions

Topical application of the glucocorticoid betamethasone (BM) is a common treatment for inflammatory-related skin diseases, such as psoriasis. However, enhancing its bioavailability remains challenging due to poor skin permeability. Herein, we developed and evaluated hyaluronan-cholesterol (HACH) based nanohydrogel systems (NHs) and NHs-Carbopol formulation for dermal delivery of BM. Various parameters were investigated including particle size, surface charge, encapsulation efficiency, in vitro drug release kinetics and stability. The HACH-based NHs demonstrated high encapsulation efficiency, with apparent solubility improved up to 9-fold, small size (∼190 nm) and good stability at 4 ℃ and during long-term storage. Besides, the NHs-Carbopol formulation exhibited excellent rheological properties and an occlusive effect suitable for cutaneous application. Both in-vitro (using Strat-M® membrane) and ex-vivo (using pig ear skin) permeation studies revealed that these formulations significantly improved skin permeation and drug retention in the deeper layers of the epidermis and dermis, making it advantageous for the topical delivery of BM in psoriasis treatment. Moreover, the NHs system demonstrated potential anti-psoriatic activity by downregulating the proinflammatory cytokines in vitro in human keratinocytes (HaCaT cell line) and in an ex vivo 3D skin tissue model (EpiDerm-FT™).

Are We Ready to Measure Skin Permeation of Modern Antiaging GHK-Cu Tripeptide Encapsulated in Liposomes?

Cosmetically active compounds (CACs), both of lipophilic and hydrophilic origin, have difficulty reaching the deeper layers of the skin, and this shortcoming significantly reduces their efficacy. One such CAC that occurs naturally in the human body and displays many beneficial properties (via reducing fine lines and wrinkles, tightening skin, improving its elasticity, etc.) is the glycyl-L-histidyl-L-lysine tripeptide complex of copper (GHK-Cu). GHK-Cu is a fairly hydrophilic compound with limited permeation through the lipophilic stratum corneum. On the other hand, liposomes capable of encapsulating GHK-Cu may improve its permeation potential. The present review discusses various issues related to obtaining insight into the permeation of CACs through the skin. Methods for studying the transport of CACs encapsulated by liposomes and free GHK-Cu across the skin barrier are summarized. An analysis of the literature data reveals that the transport of liposomes containing GHK-Cu received little attention. This research gap gives an impetus to the methodological developments for assessing the effect of liposomes on GHK-Cu transportation and trafficking.

In vitro skin permeation of flavonoid esters enzymatically derived from natural oils: release mechanism from gel emulsion, stability, and dermatological compatibility

Due to their broad spectrum of biological activities and attractive pharmacological properties, flavonoids are very promising molecules for application in skin care products. In this study, phloridzin and naringin medium- and long-chain fatty acid esters were enzymatically synthesized in reaction with natural oils (coconut and linseed oil) and in vitro transdermal delivery of synthesized esters through artificial Strat-M® membrane was investigated. Experimental results were succesfully fitted using Peppas and Sahlin model which includes the lag phase. Release kinetics of all examined flavonoid esters from gel emulsions through the membrane depended on both diffusion and polymer relaxation effect (0.5 Collapse

Key Words

• Flavonoids
• Strat® M
• enzymatic esterification
• natural oils
• skin permeation

Collapse

MESH Headings

• Emulsions
• Skin Absorption/drug effects
• Esters/chemistry
• Flavonoids/administration & dosage
• Flavonoids/pharmacokinetics
• Flavonoids/chemistry
• Gels
• Skin/metabolism
• Administration, Cutaneous
• Plant Oils/chemistry
• Animals

Collapse

Grants Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Ana Milivojević Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Biochemical Engineering and Biotechnology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Marija Ćorović Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Biochemical Engineering and Biotechnology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Anja Petrov Ivanković Innovation Center of Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Belgrade, Serbia
Milica Simović Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Biochemical Engineering and Biotechnology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Katarina Banjanac Innovation Center of Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Belgrade, Serbia
Rada Pjanović Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Dejan Bezbradica Faculty of Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Biochemical Engineering and Biotechnology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia

Collapse

In vitro assessment of skin permeation properties of enzymatically derived oil-based fatty acid esters of vitamin C

Current topical formulations containing vitamin C face limitations in therapeutic effectiveness due to the skin's selective properties that impede drug deposition. Consequently, the widespread use of toxic and irritating chemical permeation enhancers is common. Hereby, we investigated enzymatically derived fatty acid ascorbyl esters (FAAEs) obtained using natural oils for their skin permeation properties using the Strat-M® skin model in a Franz cell diffusion study. By evaluating various cosmetic formulations without added enhancers, we found that emulgel is most suitable for enhancing the cutaneous and transdermal delivery of FAAEs. Furthermore, medium-chain coconut oil-derived FAAEs exhibited faster diffusion rates compared to sunflower oil-based FAAEs with long-side acyl residues, including the commonly applied ascorbyl palmitate. Experimental data were successfully fitted using the Peppas and Sahlin model, which accounted for a lag phase and the combined effect of Fickian diffusion and polymer relaxation. In the case of long-chain esters, the lag phase was prolonged, and the calculated effective diffusion coefficients (Deff) were lower compared to medium-chain FAAEs. Accordingly, the highest Deff value was observed for ascorbyl caprylate, being even 60 times higher than for ascorbyl palmitate. These results suggest the emerging potential of emulgel with incorporated coconut oil-derived FAAEs for efficiently delivering vitamin C into the skin.

The effect of skin diffusion kinetics of isopropyl ester permeation enhancers on drug permeation: Role of lateral spread and penetration characteristics

The purpose of present work was to study the effects of permeation enhancers' two kinetic behaviors of simultaneous lateral diffusion and vertical penetration in the skin on its enhancing effect. The skin diffusion kinetics of isopropyl ester permeation enhancers were characterized by the innovative concentric tape peeling study and Raman imaging, which were quantitatively assessed through innovative parameters, namely, lateral-to-vertical penetration amount (CL-V) and lateral-to-vertical penetration distance (DL-V). The enhancement effect of permeation enhancers on drug flurbiprofen (FLU) was assessed by in vitro skin permeation tests, which were confirmed by transdermal water loss and skin resistance study. The relationship between kinetic parameters of permeation enhancers and permeation parameters of FLU was carried out by correlation analysis. The molecular mechanisms of effect of skin diffusion kinetics of permeation enhancers on drug permeation were characterized by molecular docking, modulated-temperature differential scanning calorimetry (MTDSC), Raman spectra, solid-state NMR and molecular dynamic simulation. The results indicated skin diffusion kinetics of short-chain (C8-C12) isopropyl ester permeation enhancers were governed by vertical penetration, while long-chain (C14-C18) ones were characterized by lateral spread. Quadratic correlation between CL-V and enhancement ratio of permeation-retention ratio of FLU (ERQ/R) (R2 = 0.95), DL-V and enhancement ratio of permeation area (ERA) of FLU (R2 = 0.98) indicating that varied skin diffusion kinetics of permeation enhancers directly influenced the barrier function of stratum corneum (SC) and further enhancing drug permeation. In terms of molecular mechanism, long-chain isopropyl ester enhancers had good miscibility with SC, leading to their high CL-V and DL-V, and causing strong interaction strength with SC and resulting in weaker skin barrier function for drug permeation. In summary, in comparison to short-chain isopropyl ester enhancers that relied on penetration, long-chain ones that depended on lateral spread exhibited greater enhancement efficacy, which guided the application of enhancers in transdermal formulations.

Characterization of percutaneous absorption of calcium, magnesium, and potentially toxic elements in two tailored sulfurous therapeutic peloids: a comprehensive in vitro pilot study

Pelotherapy treatments in thermal spas, which utilize peloids composed of clay minerals mixed with saltwater or mineral-medicinal water, can have various effects on spa users, ranging from therapeutic to potential adverse reactions. Despite the widespread use of peloids, comprehensive information on the penetration and permeation of essential and potentially toxic elements into deeper layers of the skin during pelotherapy is limited. Understanding the concentrations of these elements is crucial for evaluating therapeutic benefits and ensuring safety. This study investigates the in vitro availability and absorption of calcium, magnesium, and potentially toxic elements in two peloids, considering their formulation matrix. To replicate the pelotherapy methodology, an in vitro permeation experiment was conducted using a vertical diffusion chamber (Franz cells) and a biological system with human skin membranes from five Caucasian women, age range between 25 and 51 years. The experiment involved heating the peloids to 45℃. The results emphasize the possible transport properties of chemical elements in peloids, providing valuable information related to potential therapeutic efficacy and safety considerations. Despite no apparent differences between peloids' chemical composition, the method identified permeation variations among chemical elements. The methodology employed in this study adheres to the guidelines outlined by OECD for analyzing skin absorption through an in vitro approach. Furthermore, it aligns with the associated OECD guidance document for conducting skin absorption studies. The replicability of this methodology not only facilitates the analysis of peloids pre-formulation but also provides a robust means to evaluate the effectiveness of therapeutic elements during topical administration, particularly those with potential toxicity concerns.

3D Bioprinted Human Skin Model Recapitulating Native-Like Tissue Maturation and Immunocompetence as an Advanced Platform for Skin Sensitization Assessment

Physiologically-relevant in vitro skin models hold the utmost importance for efficacy assessments of pharmaceutical and cosmeceutical formulations, offering valuable alternatives to animal testing. Here, an advanced immunocompetent 3D bioprinted human skin model is presented to assess skin sensitization. Initially, a photopolymerizable bioink is formulated using silk fibroin methacrylate, gelatin methacrylate, and photoactivated human platelet releasate. The developed bioink shows desirable physicochemical and rheological attributes for microextrusion bioprinting. The tunable physical and mechanical properties of bioink are modulated through variable photocuring time for optimization. Thereafter, the bioink is utilized to 3D bioprint "sandwich type" skin construct where an artificial basement membrane supports a biomimetic epidermal layer on one side and a printed pre-vascularized dermal layer on the other side within a transwell system. The printed construct is further cultured in the air-liquid interface for maturation. Immunofluorescence staining demonstrated a differentiated keratinocyte layer and dermal extracellular matrix (ECM)-remodeling by fibroblasts and endothelial cells. The biochemical estimations and gene-expression analysis validate the maturation of the printed model. The incorporation of macrophages further enhances the physiological relevance of the model. This model effectively classifies skin irritative and non-irritative substances, thus establishing itself as a suitable pre-clinical screening platform for sensitization tests.

Formulation and investigation of hydrogels containing an increased level of diclofenac sodium using risk assessment tools

Transdermal delivery of active ingredients is a challenge for pharmaceutical technology due to their inadequate penetration properties and the barrier function of the skin. The necessity of painless, effective, topical therapy for the aging population is growing, and a variety of diclofenac sodium-containing semi-solid preparations are available to alleviate the symptoms of these ailments. Our purpose was to formulate a novel composition with higher drug content to enhance drug release and permeation, thereby providing more effective therapy. Another goal was to maintain the concentration of the organic solvent mixture below 30%, to protect the skin barrier. Firstly, literature and market research were conducted, based on which the appropriate excipients for the target formulation were selected. Solubility tests were conducted with binary and ternary mixtures. As a result, the optimal ternary mixture was chosen. Hydrogels containing 1, 5, and 7% of diclofenac sodium were prepared and the stability of the formulations were studied by microscopic measurements and cytotoxicity test were carried out of the components also. The release and permeation of diclofenac sodium were investigated in different concentrations. It can be concluded that we have succeeded in preparing a topically applicable stable diclofenac sodium hydrogel with higher concentration, drug release, and improved skin permeation than the formulations available on the market.

Methods for the characterisation of dermal uptake: Progress and perspectives for organophosphate esters

Organophosphate esters (OPEs) are a group of pollutants that are widely detected in the environment at high concentrations. They can adversely affect human health through multiple routes of exposure, including dermal uptake. Although attention has been paid to achieving an accurate and complete quantification of the dermal uptake of OPEs, existing evaluation methods and parameters have obvious weaknesses. This study reviewed two main categories of methodologies, namely the relative absorption (RA) model and the permeability coefficient (PC) model, which are widely used to assess the dermal uptake of OPEs. Although the PC model is more accurate and is increasingly used, the most important parameter in this model, the permeability coefficient (Kp), has been poorly characterised for OPEs, resulting in considerable errors in the estimation of the dermal uptake of OPEs. Thus, the detailed in vitro methods for the determination of Kp are summarised and sorted. Furthermore, the commonly used skin membranes are identified and the factors affecting Kp and corresponding mechanisms are discussed. In addition, the experimental conditions, conclusions, and available data on Kp values of the OPEs are thoroughly summarised. Finally, the corresponding knowledge gaps are proposed, and a more accurate and sophisticated experimental system and unknown Kp values for OPEs are suggested.

Study of the permeation-promoting effect and mechanism of solid microneedles on different properties of drugs

In transdermal drug delivery systems, the physicochemical properties of the drug affect its percutaneous permeability. However, whether the physicochemical properties of drugs change their transdermal permeability in the presence of pores in the presence of solid microneedles (MNs) has been less studied in this area. In this project, cinnamaldehyde, curcumin, ferulic acid and geniposide were selected as model drugs for the study of their transdermal permeability under the action of MNs, and a combination of classical experiments and visualization means such as scanning electron microscopy and laser confocal was used to investigate the permeation-promoting mechanism of MNs. The results showed that the MNs had significant permeation-promoting effects on different properties of drugs, with the permeation-promoting effects on cinnamaldehyde, curcumin, ferulic acid and geniposide being 6.36, 17.43, 29.54 and 8.91 times, respectively, and the permeation-promoting effects were more pronounced for lipid-soluble and amphiphilic drugs. Using scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy and other means to confirm that MNs can promote the penetration by acting on the skin to produce pores, and their effect on skin structure is greater than that of drugs. In addition, the existence of pores increases the amount of drug transdermal, which may enhance the diffusion of drug on the skin, and has no effect on lipid exchange and transdermal route. Through the research, it has been found that MNs is equivalent to direct peeling of the stratum corneum (SC), but it is simpler and safer for the patient.

A comparative study of the in vitro permeation of 2-phenoxyethanol in the skin PAMPA model and mammalian skin

For permeation studies that use excised skin, experimental data may show variability associated with the use of biological tissues. As a consequence, achieving reproducible results and data interpretation may be challenging. The skin parallel artificial membrane permeability assay (skin PAMPA) model has been proposed as a high-throughput tool for predicting skin permeation of chemicals. A number of skin cleansing wipe formulations for the diaper area of infants contain 2-phenoxyethanol (PE) as a preservative and cetylpyridinium chloride (CPC) as a surfactant with antimicrobial activity. However, information regarding cutaneous absorption of PE and CPC in the scientific literatures is remarkably limited. The main aim of the present study was to assess the suitability of the skin PAMPA model for prediction of skin permeation of PE. A secondary aim was to investigate the influence of CPC on the dermal absorption of PE. PE (1 % w/w) was prepared in two vehicles, namely propylene glycol (PG) and water-PG (WP). Permeability of PE was investigated in vitro using the skin PAMPA membrane, porcine skin and human skin under finite dose conditions. The highest permeation of PE was observed for the water-PG preparation with 0.2 % w/w of CPC. This finding was consistently observed in the skin PAMPA model and in Franz cell studies using porcine skin and human skin. Permeation of CPC was not detected in the three permeation models. However, permeation of PE increased significantly (p < 0.05) in the presence of CPC compared with formulations without CPC. When comparing the skin PAMPA data and the mammalian skin data for the cumulative amount of PE permeated, the r² values for PAMPA-porcine skin and PAMPA-human skin were 0.84 and 0.89, respectively. The findings in this study demonstrate the capability of the skin PAMPA model to differentiate between various doses and formulations and are encouraging for further applications of this model as a high throughput screening tool in topical formulation development.

A skin pharmacokinetics study of permeation enhancers: The root cause of dynamic enhancement effect on in vivo drug permeation

Skin pharmacokinetics (SPK) of permeation enhancers can answer the question of why enhancement effects different at the kinetic level. Herein, SPK of permeation enhancers were classified into two categories, namely, lateral elimination (elimination to surrounding stratum corneum (SC)) and longitudinal elimination (elimination to deep epidermal (EP)). They were evaluated with a specific parameter for permeation enhancers, diffusion ratio (DR_SC-EP), according to results of tissue-distribution test, molecular dynamic (MD) simulation, and confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM). The linear relationship between k_e-enahcer and Δ C_max-drug (R² = 0.92), MRT_enhancer and Δ T_max-drug (R² = 0.97), AUC_t-enhancer and Δ AUC_t-drug (R² = 0.90) suggesting that SPK of permeation enhancers precisely controlled dynamic process of drug permeation in vivo. The molecular mechanisms of the dynamic effect of SPK process on drug transdermal behaviors were characterized by modulated-temperature differential scanning calorimetry (MTDSC), dielectric spectroscopy, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), solid-state NMR. Permeation enhancers with high molecular weight (M.W.) and high polar surface area (P.S.A.) had good compatibility and strong interaction strength with SC, leading their lateral-elimination behavior, causing their low DR_SC-EP and resulting in low k_e-enhancer, long MRT_enhancer, and large AUC_t-enhancer. Consequently, skin barrier can be rapidly opened fast and to a great extent. In summary, compared with SPK of permeation enhancers with longitudinal elimination, SPK of permeation enhancers with lateral elimination can enable more sustainable and greater drug permeation. The information about SPK of permeation enhancers offered a criterion to estimate its permeation-enhancement effect on the drug and its subsequent application in transdermal formulations.

The ROC skin model: a robust skin equivalent for permeation and live cell imaging studies

Rat Epidermal Keratinocyte (REK) Organotypic Culture (ROC) is an epidermis model that is robust and inexpensive to develop and maintain, and it has in previous studies been shown to have permeability characteristics close to those of human skin. Here, we characterize the model further by structural comparison to native human and rat skin and by investigating functional characteristics of lipid packing, polarity, and permeability coefficients. We show that the ROC model has structural similarities to native human skin and observe human skin-like permeability coefficients for testosterone and mannitol. We develop a transwell device that allows live cell microscopy of the tissue at the air-liquid interface and establish transgenic cell lines expressing different fluorescently tagged proteins. This enables showing the migration of keratinocytes during the first days after seeding, finding that keratinocytes have a higher mean migration rate in the earlier days of development. Collectively, our results show that the ROC model is an inexpensive and robust epidermis model that works reproducibly across laboratories.