Current Status, Goals, and Research Agenda for Outcome Measures Development in Behçet Syndrome: Report from OMERACT 2014

SER recommendations on treatment of refractory Behçet's syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To develop multidisciplinary recommendations based on available evidence and expert consensus for the therapeutic management of patients with refractory Behçet's syndrome (BS) (difficult to treat, severe resistant, severe relapse) to conventional treatment.

METHODS

A group of experts identified clinical research questions relevant to the objective of the document. These questions were reformulated in PICO format (patient, intervention, comparison and outcome). Systematic reviews of the evidence were conducted, the quality of the evidence was evaluated following the methodology of the international working group Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE). After that, the multidisciplinary panel formulated the specific recommendations.

RESULTS

4 PICO questions were selected regarding the efficacy and safety of systemic pharmacological treatments in patients with BS with clinical manifestations refractory to conventional therapy related to mucocutaneous and/or articular, vascular, neurological parenchymal and gastrointestinal phenotypes. A total of 7 recommendations were made, structured by question, based on the identified evidence and expert consensus.

CONCLUSIONS

The treatment of most severe clinical manifestations of BS lacks solid scientific evidence and, besides, there are no specific recommendation documents for patients with refractory disease. With the aim of providing a response to this need, here we present the first official Recommendations of the Spanish Society of Rheumatology for the management of these patients. They are devised as a tool for assistance in clinical decision making, therapeutic homogenisation and to reduce variability in the care of these patients.

Damage accrual in Behçet disease: Behçet's Syndrome Overall Damage Index (BODI) versus Behçet's Disease Damage Index (BDI)

OBJECTIVES

To assess the validity of Behçet's Syndrome Overall Damage Index (BODI) and Behçet's Disease Damage Index (BDI) as tools for the detection of damage accrual in Behçet's patients compared to Vasculitis Damage Index (VDI). Also, to evaluate the correlation and the interclass correlation among the 3 indices to find out their consistency.

METHOD

A prospective cohort study was carried out on 102 adult Behçet's disease (BD) patients who were diagnosed according to the International Study Group criteria for BD. Disease severity and organ damage were assessed for each patient by VDI, BDI and BODI at baseline and 1-year follow-up visits. Damage accrual for each index was defined when there was an increase of at least 1 point (∆ ≥ 1) among the baseline and the follow-up visits.

RESULTS

Correlations among the 3 indices were significant, with (r = 0.835, P < 0.001) between VDI and BODI, (r = 0.835, P < 0.001) between VDI and BDI, and (r = 0.844, P < 0.001) between BODI and BDI scores. A highly significant positive correlation existed between the 3 indices and age and disease duration. In contrast, the correlation with the BD Current Activity Form was non-significant, which indicates good discriminative validity of the 3 indices. Neuropsychiatric and ocular systems showed a strong interclass correlation among the 3 indices. Regarding detecting damage accrual, BDI was more sensitive than BODI and showed more agreement with VDI.

CONCLUSION

BD damage indices, VDI, BODI and BDI, had good convergent and discriminative validity for the assessment of BD damage. BDI had more sensitivity than BODI to the detection of damage accrual.

Outcome measures in Behçet syndrome

Disease assessment has been challenging in Behçet syndrome due to the heterogeneous disease course and multiorgan involvement with variable treatment response. There have been several recent improvements regarding outcome measures including development of a Core Set of Domains for Behçet syndrome and novel instruments for assessing specific organs and overall damage. This review focuses on the current state of outcome measures in Behçet syndrome, unmet needs, and a research agenda towards the development of standardized and validated outcome measure instruments.

Vascular Behçet syndrome: from pathogenesis to treatment

Behçet syndrome is a rare, chronic inflammatory disease of unknown aetiopathogenesis, most commonly presenting with mucocutaneous and ocular manifestations. Vascular involvement, most frequently superficial vein and deep vein thrombosis, can occur in up to 50% of patients with Behçet syndrome. Venous thrombosis at atypical sites (inferior and superior vena cava, suprahepatic veins with Budd-Chiari syndrome, portal vein, cerebral sinuses and right atrium and/or ventricle) and arterial involvement (mostly in situ thrombosis and aneurysms of the pulmonary arteries, as well as aneurysms of the abdominal aorta, and peripheral and visceral arteries) are also unique features of Behçet syndrome. Behçet syndrome is considered a natural model of inflammation-induced thrombosis in humans, with an impaired immune-inflammatory response rather than traditional cardiovascular risk factors contributing to thrombogenesis. Specifically, neutrophil hyperactivation and neutrophil-mediated mechanisms of damage directly promote endothelial dysfunction, platelet activation and thrombogenesis in Behçet syndrome. This unusual pathogenesis directly determines the treatment approach, which relies mostly on immunosuppressants rather than anticoagulants for treatment of thrombosis and for secondary prevention. This Review discusses the main histopathological, pathogenetic and clinical aspects of vascular Behçet syndrome, addressing their implications for therapeutic management. Future perspectives in terms of pathogenetic studies, disease monitoring and treatment strategies are also discussed.

Development and preliminary validation of the Behçet's syndrome Overall Damage Index (BODI)

Objective

To develop and validate the evidence-based and consensus-based Behçet’s Syndrome Overall Damage Index (BODI).

Methods

Starting from 120 literature-retrieved preliminary items, the BODI underwent multiple Delphi rounds with an international multidisciplinary panel consisting of rheumatologists, internists, ophthalmologists, neurologists, and patient delegates until consensus was reached on the final content. The BODI was validated in a cross-sectional multicentre cohort of 228 patients with Behçet’s syndrome (BS) through the study of (a) correlation between BODI and Vasculitis Damage Index (VDI) and (b) correlation between BODI and disease activity measures (ie, Behçet’s Disease Current Activity Form (BDCAF), Physician Global Assessment (PGA), Patient Global Assessment (PtGA)), c) content and face validity and (d) feasibility.

Results

The final BODI consists of 4 overarching principles and 46 unweighted-items grouped into 9 organ domains. It showed good to excellent reliability, with a mean Cohen’s k of 0.84 (95% CI 0.78 to 0.90) and a mean intra-class correlation coefficient of 0.88 (95% CI 0.80 to 0.95). Overall, 128 (56.1%) patients had a BODI score ≥1, with a median score of 1.0 (range 0–14). The BODI significantly correlated with the VDI (r=0.693, p<0.001), demonstrating to effectively measure damage (construct validity), but had greater sensitivity in identifying major organ damage and did not correlate with disease activity measures (ie, BDCAF: p=0.807, PGA: p=0.820, PtGA: p=0.794) discriminating damage from the major confounding factor. The instrument was deemed credible (face validity), complete (content validity) and feasible by an independent group of clinicians.

Conclusions

Pending further validation, the BODI may be used to assess organ damage in patients with BS in the context of observational and controlled trials.

The OMERACT Core Set of Domains for Outcome Measures in Behçet Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

There is an unmet need for reliable, validated, and widely-accepted outcome measures for randomized clinical trials in Behçet syndrome (BS). The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology Clinical Trials (OMERACT) BS Working Group, a large, multi-disciplinary group of experts in BS and patients with BS, worked to develop a Core Set of data-driven outcome measures for use in all clinical trials of BS.

METHODS

The Core Domain Set was developed through a comprehensive, iterative, multi-stage project which included a systematic review, a focus group meeting and qualitative patient interviews, a survey among experts in BS, a Delphi exercise involving both patients and physician-experts in BS, and utilization of the data, insight, and feedback generated by these processes to develop a final Core Domain Set.

RESULTS

All steps were completed and domains were delineated across the organ systems involved in this disease. Since trials in BS often focus on specific manifestations and not the disease in its entirety, the final proposed Core Set includes 5 domains mandatory for study in all trials in BS (disease activity, new organ involvement, quality of life, adverse events, and death) with additional sub-domains mandatory for study of specific organ-systems. The final Core Set was endorsed at the 2018 OMERACT meeting.

CONCLUSION

The Core Set of Domains in BS provides the foundation through which the international research community, including clinical investigators, patients, biopharmaceutical industry, and government regulatory bodies can harmonize the study of this complex disease, compare findings across studies, and advance development of effective therapies.

Moderation analysis exploring associations between age and mucocutaneous activity in Behçet's syndrome: A multicenter study from Turkey

The aim of the present study was to examine the effects of age on mucocutaneous activity by using moderation analysis in Behçet's syndrome (BS). In this cross-sectional study, 887 BS patients (female : male, 481:406; mean age, 38.4 ± 10.9 years) followed in 13 tertiary centers in Turkey were included. Mucocutaneous activity was evaluated by using the Mucocutaneous Index (MI) according to sex and disease course. Moderation analysis was performed to test the effect of age on mucocutaneous activity. A moderator variable is a third variable and affects the relationship between independent and outcome variables. Age was chosen as a potential moderator variable (interaction effect), MI score as the outcome variable and sex as an independent variable in the analysis. The moderation analysis tested the effects of age in three steps: whole BS patient group, patients without systemic involvement and those with systemic involvement. The moderation model was only significant in BS patients with systemic involvement (P = 0.0351), and a significant relationship was observed between female sex and MI score (P = 0.0156). In addition, the interaction plot showed that female patients had increased MI scores compared with male patients, especially in the 28-year-old age group (P = 0.0067). Moreover, major organ involvement was newly diagnosed in the majority of these young female BS patients. Our results suggest that the relationship between sex and mucocutaneous activity was moderated by age in the systemic involvement group. Also, increased mucocutaneous activity may be associated with new major organ involvement in young female BS patients with systemic involvement.

Predictive factors for work-day loss in Behçet's syndrome: A multi-center study

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this multi-center study was to assess predictive factors for work-day loss as an indirect cost element in Behçet's syndrome (BS).

METHODS

In this cross-sectional, multi-center study, 834 BS patients (F/M: 441/393, age mean: 38.4 ± 10.9 years) were included. Data were collected by a questionnaire regarding treatment protocols, disease duration, smoking pattern, frequency of medical visits during the previous year and self-reported work-day loss during the previous year.

RESULTS

Work-day loss was observed in 16.2% of patients (M/F: 103/32). The percentages of being a smoker (81.8%), using immunosuppressive (IS) medications (82%), and having disease duration <5 years (74%) were higher in male patients with work-day loss (P < .05). The majority of males (90.9%) had more than four clinic visits during the previous year. Moreover, the mean work-day loss (30.8 ± 57.7 days) was higher in patients with vascular involvement (56.1 ± 85.9) than those without (26.4 ± 50.6 days) (P = .046). In addition, increased frequency of ocular involvement (25.9%) was also observed in patients with work-day loss compared to others (8.6%) (P = .059).

CONCLUSION

Work-day loss was associated with both vascular and ocular involvement. Close associations were observed among male gender, early period of the disease, frequent medical visits, being a smoker and treatment with IS medications in patients with work-day loss.

Does illness perception associate with disease symptoms in Behçet's disease?

This study aims to assess the relationship between illness perception and disease course and symptoms in Behçet disease (BD). One hundred ten consecutive BD patients (F/M 50/60, mean age 38.5 ± 9.88 years) and 57 patients with Psoriasis as a disease control group (F/M 28/29, mean age 48.12 ± 15.52) are included in this cross-sectional study. Illness perception is evaluated using a revised version of the Illness Perception Questionnaire (IPQ-R). In IPQ-R, the identity score reflecting the number of symptoms is higher in BD patients with musculoskeletal involvement than the others (6.77 ± 2.91 vs. 5.08 ± 3.3, respectively, p = 0.007). The consequences score for musculoskeletal involvement (19.52 ± 7.03) and timeline (acute/chronic) score for eye involvement (26.67 ± 4.32) are also higher compared to patients without them (16.37 ± 5.82 and 22.09 ± 8.68) (p = 0.011 and p = 0.038), reflecting negative beliefs about the illness. The score of psychological attribution is higher in patients with psoriasis than BD (p = 0.039), whereas the other subgroup scores are lower in patients with psoriasis compared to those of BD (p < 0.05). This study provides a patient's perspective in the disease management process of BD using the IPQ-R questionnaire. A patient's own personal beliefs and emotional responses to their symptoms might affect the outcome measures, especially with musculoskeletal symptoms and eye involvement in BD. However, psychological attribution is found to be a prominent issue in psoriasis.

Decreased expression of A20 is associated with ocular Behcet's disease (BD) but not with Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada (VKH) disease

PURPOSE

A20 is a ubiquitously expressed and inducible cytosolic protein, which plays an important role in the negative regulation of inflammation and immunity. In this study, we investigated the role of A20 in Behcet's disease (BD) and Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada (VKH) disease.

METHODS

The levels of A20 in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) and dendritic cells (DCs) were detected in BD patients with active and inactive uveitis, VKH patients with active and inactive uveitis, and normal subjects, respectively, by real-time PCR. The effect of A20 silencing was performed by transduction of DCs with adenovirus containing an A20 shRNA vector. The effect of A20 silencing on the maturation of DCs was measured by flow cytometry. The effect of A20 silencing of DCs on cytokine production by DCs and CD4⁺ T cells was analysed by ELISA. The phosphorylation levels of JNK, p38 and ERK1/2 were detected by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

The expression of A20 was markedly decreased in PBMCs and DCs obtained from BD patients with active uveitis, but not in patients with VKH disease as compared with normal controls. Silencing of A20 significantly increased the levels of interleukin (IL)-1β and IL-6 and suppressed the expression of the anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-10 and IL-27. Downregulation of A20 also led to an increase in IL-17 production by CD4⁺ T cells. However, downregulation of A20 in DCs did not have an effect on cell surface markers such as CD40, CD80, CD83, CD86 and HLA-DR. Silencing of A20 caused an increased expression of phospho-JNK and phospho-MAPK p38 but not phospho-ERK1/2.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed that the expression of A20 was decreased in BD patients with active uveitis but not in VKH disease. Decreased expression of A20 may lead to an enhanced activation of proinflammatory Th17 cells, causing a reactivation of BD.

Incorporating the patient's perspective in outcomes research

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Incorporation of the patients' perspective in clinical research is critical to ensure that outcomes measured reflect those, which matter most to patients. This review summarizes recent efforts to include the patients' perspective in the development of outcome measures and the importance of encouraging patient participation in decision-making and self-management.

RECENT FINDINGS

Since the inclusion of fatigue as a patient-endorsed core outcome measure in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) trials, OMERACT has been instrumental in advocating for patient involvement in the development of core domains and instruments; current endeavors include cultivating an understanding of remission through the eyes of patients and gaining a sense of how to measure features of pain and 'stiffness' deemed as important to patients. The concept of remission was further explored in RA patients, highlighting a common goal of returning to normality; additionally, various tools have been developed to assess for unmet needs in rheumatology patients. Advances have also been made in the development and revision of patient-centered core measures in rheumatologic diagnoses outside of RA.

SUMMARY

Incorporating the patients' perspective is now considered an essential feature in outcomes research. Future research should focus on how best to involve patients in specific research activities.

Developing a Core Set of Outcome Measures for Behçet Disease: Report from OMERACT 2016

OBJECTIVE

The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) Vasculitis Working Group has been working toward developing a data-driven core set of outcome measures for use in clinical trials of Behçet's syndrome [Behçet disease (BD)]. This paper summarizes the group's work through OMERACT 2016, discussions during the meeting, and the future research agenda.

METHODS

Qualitative patient interviews were conducted among 20 patients with BD who have different types of organ involvement. A 3-round Delphi among BD experts and patients was initiated to identify domains, subdomains, and outcomes to be assessed in clinical trials of BD. The results of these studies were discussed during OMERACT 2016 and next steps were planned.

RESULTS

Patients' perspectives and priorities were identified through qualitative interviews that identified candidate domains and subdomains for inclusion in the Delphi and characterized some shortcomings of the currently used patient-reported outcomes in BD. The first round of the Delphi was completed and several domains or subdomains were endorsed by the experts and/or the patients. Because many more items were endorsed than would be feasible to assess during a clinical trial, rating and ranking of items by physicians and patients was planned as a next critical step. The challenges of assessing specific organ system involvement was also discussed.

CONCLUSION

The OMERACT Behçet Syndrome Working Group research program will identify core domains for assessment in BD with the goal of developing a core set of outcome measures for use in all trials of BD with the option to incorporate additional outcomes for specific organ involvement.

Treatment of mucocutaneous manifestations in Behçet's disease with anakinra: a pilot open-label study

BACKGROUND

The effect of IL-1 blocking therapy on mucocutaneous manifestations of Behçet's disease is incompletely understood.

METHODS

Six patients with Behçet's disease and ongoing oral/genital ulcers for ≥1 month were enrolled into an adaptive, two-phase clinical trial and included in the analysis. Study duration was 6 months with extension up to 16 months. All were treated non-blinded with anakinra 100 mg subcutaneous daily with the option to escalate the dose to 200 mg in partial responders after 1 month and 300 mg after 6 months. Patients recorded the number and severity of ulcers in daily diaries. The primary outcome was remission defined as no ulcers on physical exam for two consecutive monthly visits between months 3 and 6. Secondary outcomes included the number and severity of patient-reported ulcers, patient/physician global scores, and standardized disease activity scores.

RESULTS

Two of six patients achieved the primary outcome. Five of six patients had improvement in the number and severity of ulcers. Non-statistically significant improvements were seen in secondary outcomes. Over the entire study, patients reported ≥1 oral and ≥1 genital ulcer on 665 (66%) and 139 (14%) days, respectively. On anakinra 200 mg vs 100 mg, patients reported fewer days with oral ulcers (65% vs 74% of days, p = 0.01) and genital ulcers (10% vs 22% of days, p < 0.001) and milder oral ulcer severity (p < 0.001). Increase of anakinra to 300 mg did not result in further improvements. Adverse events were notable for mild infections.

CONCLUSION

Anakinra at an optimal dose of 200 mg daily had an acceptable safety profile and was partially effective in the treatment of resistant oral and genital ulcers in Behçet's disease.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Clinicaltrials.gov. NCT01441076 . Registered on 24 September 2011.

Incorporating the patient's perspective in outcomes research

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Incorporation of the patients' perspective in clinical research is critical to ensure that outcomes measured reflect those, which matter most to patients. This review summarizes recent efforts to include the patients' perspective in the development of outcome measures and the importance of encouraging patient participation in decision-making and self-management.

RECENT FINDINGS

Since the inclusion of fatigue as a patient-endorsed core outcome measure in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) trials, OMERACT has been instrumental in advocating for patient involvement in the development of core domains and instruments; current endeavors include cultivating an understanding of remission through the eyes of patients and gaining a sense of how to measure features of pain and 'stiffness' deemed as important to patients. The concept of remission was further explored in RA patients, highlighting a common goal of returning to normality; additionally, various tools have been developed to assess for unmet needs in rheumatology patients. Advances have also been made in the development and revision of patient-centered core measures in rheumatologic diagnoses outside of RA.

SUMMARY

Incorporating the patients' perspective is now considered an essential feature in outcomes research. Future research should focus on how best to involve patients in specific research activities.

Efficacy and safety of adalimumab in Behçet's disease-related uveitis: a multicenter retrospective observational study

The study aim was to evaluate the efficacy of adalimumab (ADA) in a large series of Behçet's disease (BD)-related uveitis. We performed a multicenter retrospective observational study including 40 selected patients (66 eyes) receiving ADA. Clinical data were retrospectively analyzed at baseline, at 3 and 12 months of treatment. Primary end point was reduction of ocular inflammatory flares. Secondary end points were improvement of best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), reduction of macular thickness measured by optical coherence tomography (OCT), reduction in the occurrence of vasculitis assessed by fluorescein angiography (FA), and evaluation of statistically significant differences between patients treated with ADA monotherapy and those undergoing ADA plus DMARDs and in patients firstly treated with ADA compared to patients previously administered with other biologics; ADA steroid sparing effect was also evaluated. During the first 12 months of ADA therapy, the number of flares significantly decreased from 200 flares/100 patients/year to 8.5 flares/100 patients/year (p < 0.0001). Similarly, BCVA improved if compared to baseline (7.4 ± 2.9 versus 8.5 ± 2.1, p = 0.03). OCT findings significantly improved showing a mean reduction of central macular thickness (CMT) of 27.27 ± 42.8 μm at the end of follow-up (p < 0.006). FA identified retinal vasculitis in 22 cases at baseline (55%), 8 (20%) cases after 3 months, and in only one (2.5%) case at 12-month follow-up. FA improvement was highly significant at 3- and 12-month follow-up if compared to baseline (p < 0.0001 and p = 0.006, respectively). ADA is highly effective and safe for the treatment of BD-related uveitis, providing a long-term control of ocular inflammation.