Sensitivity and specificity of potassium hydroxide and calcofluor white stain to differentiate between fungal and Pythium filaments in corneal scrapings from patients of Pythium keratitis

A masked study to differentiate in vivo confocal microscopic features of Pythium insidiosum and fungal filaments

PURPOSE

To describe in vivo confocal microscopic features of Pythium insidiosum in patients with Pythium keratitis and compare with those observed in fungal keratitis.

METHOD

We collected in vivo confocal images of the cornea from patients with microbiologically confirmed Pythium and fungal keratitis, analysing five putative distinguishing features: filament width (broad or thin), granularity within the filament (present or absent), filament continuity or traceability, the presence or absence of loops, and the double track sign. Three masked observers were shown images with concealed identities and tasked with detecting Pythium filaments. After initial assessment and training, their detection rates were calculated and compared before and after training. We did perform imageJ (Open Source software project Fiji) analysis of all the images for objectively assessment.

RESULTS

Sixty confocal images of Pythium (n = 32,15 patients) and fungal (n = 28,12 patients) keratitis were analysed. The continuity of filaments and the presence of loops emerged as strong predictors of Pythium, with adjusted odds ratios (OR) of 18.1 and 19.29, respectively, based on multivariate logistic regression and decision tree splits. Pre-training accuracy was 0.51, 0.52, and 0.56, but post-training (95 % CI) improved to 0.75 (0.62-0.85), 0.80 (0.67-0.89), and 0.86 (0.75-0.94). Correct identification rates for Pythium were 27, 28, and 29 (84-89 %) out of 32, and for fungus were 16, 21, and 24 (57.4-85.7 %) out of 28 images with sensitivity and specificity ranging from 70.7 to 87.5 % and 80-85 % respectively. ImageJ analysis revealed a significant difference between Pythium and fungal filaments in both width (9.30 ± 1.21 μ vs. 6.20 ± 0.88 μ, p < 0.001) and branching angle (83.92 ± 13.57° vs. 55.10 ± 6.03°, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Based on our analysis, these features may be indicative of Pythium and could serve as a helpful reference for future prospective studies. However, further large scale studies and validation are needed to strengthen these observations.

The 2023 Doyne Lecture-a cornea care system: evolution

Blindness and visual impairment affect the quality of life of the individual and their family members. Corneal opacities are a key cause of vision loss around the world, especially in low-income and middle-income countries (LMIC). Corneal blindness and vision loss impacts every age group, and the risk factors and the causes are also varied. Socio-economic factors also play a significant role in its prevalence. Preventing, treating, and managing corneal conditions in LMIC contexts can therefore be quite complex and challenging. A model of eye care delivery developed and refined over the past four decades, the L V Prasad Eye Institute's cornea care system presents an example and a sense of hope. The model takes corneal care from world-class facilities in urban locations to rural locations, overcoming a variety of challenges. The initial breakthrough came with solving and ensuring a steady supply of corneal tissue. Then to training high-quality resources, building capacity, and investing in research that translates from the bench to the bedside. A variety of innovations, both in diagnosis and the operating theatre, have paved for improved outcomes that are tailored for the contexts in which this system operates. The institute envisions a future where its work further narrows the gap in eye care disparities and leads to life-changing impact in ophthalmic care of the cornea.

Anti-infective therapies for Pythium insidiosum keratitis

INTRODUCTION

Pythium insidiosum keratitis (PIK) is a rapidly progressing ocular disease predominantly found in tropical and subtropical regions. Characterized by severe corneal damage and high morbidity, this infection poses significant challenges in diagnosis and management, necessitating effective anti-infective therapies.

AREAS COVERED

This report delves into the pathophysiology, clinical and microbiological diagnosis, and detailed insights into the anti-infective therapy for PIK, outlining current diagnostic challenges that complicate treatment. We review existing anti-infective therapies, including their efficacy and limitations, and discuss the role of surgical interventions in managing advanced cases. The report also highlights ongoing research into novel treatment approaches and the critical need for developing targeted therapies.

EXPERT OPINION

Despite advances in understanding PIK, treatment remains complex due to pathogen resistance and diagnostic hurdles. Future research should focus on innovative anti-infective strategies, improved diagnostic techniques, and global surveillance to enhance therapeutic outcomes. Collaboration between ophthalmologists, microbiologists, and pharmacologists is essential to advance treatment protocols and improve patient prognosis.

Efficacy and Rapidity of Potassium Hydroxide Mount and Modified Chicago Sky Blue 6B Stain with Potassium Hydroxide in Fungal Keratitis Detection

PURPOSE

To compare the efficacy and rapidity of direct microscopic detection of fungal elements from corneal ulcers between 10% potassium hydroxide (KOH) and 1% Chicago Sky Blue 6B (CSB) in 10% KOH (CSB-KOH).

METHODS

Thirty patients with clinically suspected fungal keratitis were recruited. Participants with impending corneal perforation were excluded. Two slides were smeared with corneal ulcer scrapings from the ulcer's edge and base for comparison of fungal staining solutions. One slide was infused with KOH, and the other slide was filled with CSB-KOH. Additional scraping was collected for inoculation on Sabouraud dextrose agar for fungal culture. The sensitivity, specificity and rapidity of both stainings were analyzed.

RESULTS

The sensitivity of fungal culture, KOH, and CSB-KOH were 43.75% (95% confidence interval [CI], 19.75%-70.12%), 62.50% (95% CI, 35.43%-84.80%), and 87.50% (95% CI, 61.65%-98.45%), respectively. The specificity were 100% (95% CI, 69.15%-100%) of both stainings and fungal culture which analyzed from 16 fungal keratitis cases by laboratory and clinical diagnosis. Mean CSB-KOH examination time was quicker than KOH with the mean time difference of 5.6 minutes (95% CI, 3.22-7.98 minutes) and p-value < 0.001.

CONCLUSIONS

CSB-KOH was more effective and faster than KOH in detecting fungal elements from corneal ulcers. Therefore, CSB-KOH may be beneficial in diagnosing fungal keratitis and preventing blindness. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first use of CSB stain in fungal keratitis detection.

Understanding barriers, recommended solutions, and future prospects for the diagnosis and management of Pythium insidiosum keratitis

Pythium insidiosum keratitis (PIK) is a devastating corneal infection resulting in blindness in a large number of cases. Clinically and morphologically, it closely mimics fungal keratitis, and hence is also labeled as "parafungus." Although many clinical studies have documented evidence regarding the virulence of microorganism, and anatomical and functional outcomes, it remains a clinical challenge and diagnostic dilemma for most clinicians. Till today, PIK is being diagnosed and treated with certainty at only limited centers across the globe. But the question is why this is so? Taking this as the research question, this section on current ophthalmology aims to highlight the understanding of barriers to diagnosing and treating PIK, the suggestions to improve diagnosis and treatment, and the future prospects.

Case Series: Mixed Infectious Keratitis by Pythium insidiosum and Fungal Species

SIGNIFICANCE

This case series is the first to illustrate mixed infection from Pythium sp. and fungal species in corneal ulcer.

PURPOSE

This case series aimed to alert all toward the possibility of both Pythium sp. and fungal species infection in case of nonresponding corneal ulcer treated with either antifungals or antipythium drugs alone. Increased suspicion of mixed infection in case of nonresponding fungal/ Pythium keratitis may facilitate early and prompt management.

CASE REPORTS

Six patients presented with signs of either fungal or Pythium keratitis. They underwent ophthalmological examinations, smear examinations, cultures, and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty was performed in cases where symptoms worsened after treatment with either antifungal or antipythium drugs. The half corneal button (HCB) was shared for histopathological and microbiological examinations. In the first case, smear examination from corneal scraping (CS) revealed Pythium -like filaments, which were confirmed with PCR; however, Aspergillus nidulans grew in culture. In the second case, iodine-potassium iodide (IKI) staining was positive for Pythium ; however, PCR was positive for both Pythium and fungus, which was further confirmed by DNA sequencing. In the third case, IKI staining and HCB were positive for Pythium ; however, PCR was positive for fungus, which was identified as Candida saitoana with DNA sequencing. In the fourth case, Pythium grew in the CS culture; however, Candida sp. grew in the HCB culture. In the fifth case, Cladosporium sp. grew in culture from CS; however, Pythium insidiosum grew from the anterior chamber exudate after therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty. In the sixth case, smear examination revealed septate fungal filaments, and Cladosporium sp. grew in culture; however, HCB on histopathological examination showed features of Pythium keratitis.

CONCLUSIONS

In unresponsive cases of Pythium or fungal keratitis, diagnostic modalities such as IKI and PCR should be implemented as a routine practice, in addition to smears and cultures.

Randomized Double-Masked Placebo-Controlled Trial for the Management of Pythium Keratitis: Combination of Antibiotics Versus Monotherapy

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of monotherapy (topical linezolid 0.2%) versus a combination of antibiotics (topical linezolid 0.2% and topical azithromycin 1%) for the treatment of Pythium insidiosum keratitis.

METHODS

Cases of P. insidiosum keratitis were prospectively randomized into group A on topical 0.2% linezolid along with topical placebo (sodium carboxymethyl cellulose [CMC] 0.5%) and group B on a combination of topical 0.2% linezolid and topical 1% azithromycin. Both groups were compared by proportion of both clinical resolution and worsening of keratitis along with the number of therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty (TPK) performed at 3 months.

RESULTS

We initially planned N = 66 patients but later limited to 20 (N = 10 in each group) patients owing to one interim analysis. The average size of the infiltrate in group A and B was 5.6 ± 1.5 mm and 4.8 ± 2.0 mm, respectively, with a mean Logarithm of the Minimum Angle of Resolution (logMAR) visual acuity of 2.74 ± 0.55 and 1.79 ± 1.19. At 3 months, from group A, 7 (70%) patients needed TPK and 2 patients had signs of resolution, whereas from group B, 6 (60%) patients achieved complete resolution ( P = 0.0003) and 2 were improving while only 1 needed TPK ( P = 0.02). The median duration of treatment in group A and B, with the study drugs, was 31 days (17.8-47.8) and 101.5 days (80-123.3), P value = 0.003, respectively. Final visual acuity at 3 months was 2.50 ± 0.81 and 0.75 ± 0.87, P = 0.02, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A combination of topical linezolid and topical azithromycin was found to have superior efficacy than the monotherapy with topical linezolid for the management of Pythium keratitis.

Outcomes of therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty in Pythium insidiosum keratitis managed with a combination of antibiotics

Purpose

To describe the clinical outcomes of therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty (TPK) in patients with Pythium insidiosum keratitis following treatment with anti-pythium therapy (APT) consisting of linezolid and azithromycin.

Methods

A retrospective review of medical records from May 2016 to December 2019 of patients with P. insidiosum keratitis was carried out. Patients who were treated with APT for a minimum of 2 weeks and then subsequently underwent TPK were included in the study. Data on demographic characteristics, clinical features, microbiology characteristics, and intraoperative details, postoperative outcomes were documented.

Results

A total of 238 cases of Pythium keratitis were seen during the study period and 50 cases that satisfied the inclusion criteria were included. The median of the geometric mean of the infiltrate was 5.6 mm (IQR 4.0-7.2 mm). The patients received topical APT for a median of 35 days (IQR 25-56) prior to surgery. The most common indication of TPK was worsening keratitis (41/50, 82%). No recurrence of infection was observed. An anatomically stable globe was noted in 49/50 eyes (98%). The median graft survival rate was 2.4 months. A clear graft was present in 10 eyes (20%) with a final median visual acuity of 20/125 after a median follow-up period of 18.4 months (IQR 11-26 months). Graft size of less than 10 mm [OR: 5.824 (CI:1.292-41.6), P = 0.02] was found to be significantly associated with a clear graft.

Conclusion

Performing TPK following the administration of APT has good anatomical outcomes. A smaller graft of <10 mm was associated with a higher chance of graft survival.

The Case for Fungal Keratitis to Be Accepted as a Neglected Tropical Disease

Amongst the treatable cause of blindness among young people, fungal keratitis ranks high. There are an estimated 1,051,787 to 1,480,916 eyes affected annually, with 8–11% of patients having to have the eye removed. Diagnosis requires a corneal scraping, direct microscopy and fungal culture with a large number of airborne fungi implicated. Treatment involves the intensive application of antifungal eye drops, preferably natamycin, often combined with surgery. In low-resource settings, inappropriate corticosteroid eye drops, ineffective antibacterial therapy, diagnostic delay or no diagnosis all contribute to poor ocular outcomes with blindness (unilateral or bilateral) common. Modern detailed guidelines on fungal keratitis diagnosis and management are lacking. Here, we argue that fungal keratitis should be included as a neglected tropical disease, which would facilitate greater awareness of the condition, improved diagnostic capability, and access to affordable antifungal eye medicine.

Pythium insidiosum Keratitis: Past, Present, and Future

Pythium insidiosum (PI) is an oomycete, a protist belonging to the clade Stramenopila. PI causes vision-threatening keratitis closely mimicking fungal keratitis (FK), hence it is also labeled as "parafungus". PI keratitis was initially confined to Thailand, USA, China, and Australia, but with growing clinical awareness and improvement in diagnostic modalities, the last decade saw a massive upsurge in numbers with the majority of reports coming from India. In the early 1990s, pythiosis was classified as vascular, cutaneous, gastrointestinal, systemic, and ocular. Clinically, morphologically, and microbiologically, PI keratitis closely resembles severe FK and requires a high index of clinical suspicion for diagnosis. The clinical features such as reticular dot infiltrate, tentacular projections, peripheral thinning with guttering, and rapid limbal spread distinguish it from other microorganisms. Routine smearing with Gram and KOH stain reveals perpendicular septate/aseptate hyphae, which closely mimic fungi and make the diagnosis cumbersome. The definitive diagnosis is the presence of dull grey/brown refractile colonies along with zoospore formation upon culture by leaf induction method. However, culture is time-consuming, and currently polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method is the gold standard. The value of other diagnostic modalities such as confocal microscopy and immunohistopathological assays is limited due to cost, non-availability, and limited diagnostic accuracy. PI keratitis is a relatively rare disease without established treatment protocols. Because of its resemblance to fungus, it was earlier treated with antifungals but with an improved understanding of its cell wall structure and absence of ergosterol, this is no longer recommended. Currently, antibacterials have shown promising results. Therapeutic keratoplasty with good margin (1 mm) is mandated for non-resolving cases and corneal perforation. In this review, we have deliberated on the evolution of PI keratitis, covered all the recently available literature, described our current understanding of the diagnosis and treatment, and the potential future diagnostic and management options for PI keratitis.

Clinical differentiation of Pythium keratitis from fungal keratitis and development of a scoring system

Purpose

To differentiate Pythium keratitis from fungal keratitis using clinical signs, to explore usefulness of various signs as diagnostic prognosticators, and develop a clinical scoring system.

Methods

A retrospective review of medical records and archived clinical photographs of patients with culture-positive Pythium keratitis and hyaline filamentous fungal keratitis was conducted at a tertiary eye institute to explore characteristics of ulcers that may aid diagnosis.

Results

Full-thickness corneal stromal keratitis (P = 0.055), a dry ulcer surface (P = 0.010), tentacles (P < 0.0001), intrastromal dots (P < 0.0001), ring infiltrates (P = 0.024), reticular patterns (P < 0.0001), and peripheral furrows (P < 0.0001) were clinical signs associated with Pythium keratitis. Multiple regression analysis identified tentacles (odds ratio: 24.1, 95% confidence interval (CI): 3.8-158.1, P = 0.001) and peripheral furrows (odds ratio: 60.6, 95% CI: 5.1-712.3, P = 0.001) as independent diagnostic prognosticators for Pythium keratitis. The positive and negative likelihood ratios of a dry ulcer surface, tentacles, intrastromal dots, ring infiltrates, reticular patterns, and peripheral furrows predicting Pythium keratitis were 1.6, 13.6, 17.9, 4.3, 30.7, 15.3 and 0.4, 0.4, 0.7, 0.9, 0.6 and 0.8, respectively. The presence of two or more of these clinical signs (excluding a dry ulcer surface) had a sensitivity of 55.6% and a false positive rate of 1.4%.

Conclusion

Tentacles, intrastromal dots, ring infiltrates, reticular patterns, and peripheral furrows are clinical signs to be considered for the diagnosis of Pythium keratitis and the presence of two or more signs has a very low false positive rate.

Nested PCR Detection of Pythium sp. from Formalin-Fixed, Paraffin-Embedded Canine Tissue Sections

Simple Summary

Pythium insidiosum is a waterborne fungus-like organism commonly present in tropical and subtropical areas that causes a disease named pythiosis in dogs and other animals. This disease can cause inflammatory lesions on the skin and gastrointestinal tract and, if left untreated, may be fatal. Because this mold lacks the distinctive features of true fungi, it requires specific treatment. Diagnosis of pythiosis is commonly achieved by microscope visualization after staining the tissue sections (histopathology). Although some stains highlight hyphae, these techniques are challenging to distinguish P. insidiosum from other fungi. Our study aimed to develop a molecular technique (nested PCR) to specifically detect P. insidiosum DNA in biopsy specimens to aid in diagnosing this organism. Archived biopsies from 26 dogs suspected of pythiosis were examined by histopathology with special stains and tested by the novel nested PCR. Agreement between histopathology and nested PCR occurred in 18/26 cases. The microscopic examination identified hyphae consistent with Pythium sp. in 57.7% of the samples, whereas the nested PCR detected P. insidiosum DNA in 76.9% of samples, aiding in the sensitivity of the diagnosis of pythiosis in dogs. Using this combination of techniques, we report 20 canine cases of pythiosis over 18 years in Indiana and Kentucky, an unexpectedly high incidence for temperate climatic regions. Thus, we recommend using our nested PCR test in addition to the microscopic examination to increase the sensitivity of the diagnosis.

Abstract

Pythium insidiosum is an infectious oomycete affecting dogs that develop the cutaneous or gastrointestinal form of pythiosis with a poor prognosis. If left untreated, pythiosis may be fatal. This organism is not a true fungus because its cell wall and cell membrane lack chitin and ergosterol, respectively, requiring specific treatment. Identifying the organism is challenging, as a hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) stain poorly stain the P. insidiosum hyphae and cannot be differentiated conclusively from other fungal or fungal-like organisms (such as Lagenidium sp.) morphologically. Our study aimed to develop a nested PCR to detect P. insidiosum and compare it with the traditional histopathologic detection of hyphae. Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue scrolls from 26 dogs with lesions suggesting the P. insidiosum infection were assessed histologically, and DNA was extracted from the FFPE tissue sections for nested PCR. Agreement between the histologic stains, (H&E), periodic acid–Schiff (PAS), and/or Grocott methenamine silver (GMS) and the nested PCR occurred in 18/26 cases. Hyphae consistent with Pythium sp. were identified via histopathology in 57.7% of the samples, whereas the nested PCR detected P. insidiosum in 76.9% of samples, aiding in the sensitivity of the diagnosis of pythiosis in dogs. Using this combination of techniques, we report 20 canine cases of pythiosis over 18 years in Indiana and Kentucky, an unexpectedly high incidence for temperate climatic regions. Using a combination of histopathology evaluation and nested PCR is recommended to aid in the accurate diagnosis of pythiosis.