Predictors of Informal Caregiver Burden in Parkinson's Disease: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Caregivers of people with Parkinson's disease are at risk of experiencing caregiver burden. Understanding contributing factors is required to develop appropriate targeted interventions and support for this group. This systematic review provides an updated appraisal and synthesis of quantitative studies assessing predictors of burden among informal caregivers of people with Parkinson's.

METHOD

Five electronic databases (APA PsycINFO, CINAHL, MEDLINE, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library) were systematically searched (from inception until July 2024), supplemented by hand-searches. Study quality was assessed using the cross-sectional JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist. Results were synthesized narratively.

RESULTS

Forty-one studies were included. Predictors of increased burden included greater impact of motor symptoms on activities of daily living, greater severity of neuropsychiatric symptoms, poorer quality of life of the person with Parkinson's, and poorer caregiver mental health. Demographics, presence of motor symptoms, motor complications, and general cognitive function did not predict burden. Evidence was inconclusive for several variables including disease stage and duration, motor symptom severity, functional ability, overall non-motor symptoms, mental health of the person with Parkinson's, and caregivers' involvement and protective factors.

CONCLUSION

Several areas for potential future intervention are indicated, although methodological weaknesses within the literature constrain the robustness of conclusions. Key areas for future research include exploring understudied variables (caregiver personality and coping style, relationship quality, and positive aspects of caregiving) that may be important predictors of burden, specifying and utilizing a more consistent definition of "informal caregiver," and recruiting younger and non-spousal caregivers and more diverse samples regarding disease severity.

Predictors of Burden in Carers of Patients with Impulse Control Behaviors in Parkinson's Disease

Background

Impulse control behaviors (ICBs) are problematic, reward-based behaviors, affecting 15% to 35% of patients with Parkinson's disease. Evidence exists of increased carer burden as a result of these behaviors; however, little is known about the variables mediating this effect and their management.

Objective

To identify factors predictive of carer burden in a cohort of patients with Parkinson's disease with ICBs to enable the development of targeted therapeutic interventions for carers.

Methods

Data were collected from 45 patients with clinically significant ICBs and their carers, including levodopa equivalent daily dosage, motor and neuropsychiatric symptoms, cognitive function, and ICB severity. Carer burden was quantified by Zarit Burden Interview (ZBI). Univariate analyses were performed using the Spearman rank correlation. Linear regression was used to create a multivariate model for predicting ZBI.

Results

Univariate analysis identified significant correlations between ZBI and patient total Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI) (r s = 0.50), 4 NPI subscores (agitation/aggression, r s = 0.41; depression/dysphoria, r s = 0.47; apathy/indifference, r s = 0.49; and irritability/lability, r s = 0.38; all P < 0.02), and the carer 28-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-28) (r s = 0.52, P < 0.0005). Multivariate linear regression retained total NPI and GHQ-28 scores and were collectively predictive of 36.6% of the variance in the ZBI.

Conclusions

Our study suggests that depressive symptoms and aspects of executive dysfunction (apathy and disinhibition) in the patient are potential drivers of carer burden in patients with ICBs. Such findings suggest the presence of executive difficulties and/or mood disturbance should point the clinician to inquire about burden in the caring role and encourage the carer to seek help for any of their own general health problems, which may compound carer burden.

Health-related quality-of-life and burden for caregivers of individuals with neurogenic orthostatic hypotension

Aim: This study explores the burden of caring for an individual with neurogenic orthostatic hypotension (nOH) and an underlying neurodegenerative disease (Parkinson's disease, multiple system atrophy, pure autonomic failure or dementia with Lewy bodies). Materials & methods: A survey including several validated instruments was conducted with informal caregivers of individuals with Parkinson's disease, multiple system atrophy, pure autonomic failure or dementia with Lewy bodies. Results: Caregivers of patients with nOH (n = 60) reported greater burden across all outcomes compared with those without nOH (n = 60). Receiving pharmacological treatment for nOH was the variable most consistently associated with significantly better caregiver health-related quality-of-life (p < 0.05). Conclusion: This study demonstrates the burden of nOH on informal caregivers and highlights the potential benefit of pharmacological treatment not only for patients but also indirectly, their caregivers.

Prospective predictors of care partner burden and depression in Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVES

Care partners who provide informal care to individuals with Parkinson's disease (PD) report higher levels of burden and depression; however, longitudinal research on these symptoms is scarce. The current study assessed changes in care partner burden and depression, and patient and care partner predictors of these symptoms over time. Such knowledge may provide important information for assessment and treatment of depression and burden in care partners of individuals with PD.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Participants were 88 PD patients without dementia and their self-identified care partner (n = 88). Care partners completed the Geriatric Depression Scale and Zarit Burden Interview. PD participants completed mood questionnaires and a motor exam at baseline and 2 year follow-up. Relationships among care partner burden and depression over time with patient and care partner predictors (i.e., demographic, mood, and disease characteristics) were assessed using correlations and regression analyses.

RESULTS

Care partner burden and depression significantly increased over an approximate 2 year period. Greater baseline disease severity predicted worsening of care partner burden (p = 0.028), while baseline patient depression predicted worsening of care partner depression (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Results highlight differential impacts of specific PD symptoms on worsening care partner burden compared to depression; increased PD disease severity predicts increased burden, while patient mood predicts worsening of depression over time. Targeting PD disease severity and mood symptoms may prevent the progression of care partner burden and depression.

Understanding Caregiver Strain in Parkinsonism-A Mixed Methods Approach

BACKGROUND

Parkinsonism, including Parkinson's disease (PD) are progressive neurological conditions. As these condition progress, individuals will need more support with their care needs to maintain independent community-living. Care needs are mainly met by unpaid, informal caregivers, usually close family members or friends. Caregiver strain is thought to lead to the need for care home placement when the caregiver can no longer cope.

OBJECTIVE

To understand predictors of caregiver strain and its influence on care home placement for people with moderate to advanced Parkinsonism.

METHODS

This is a convergent mixed methods study. Quantitative data, following an adapted stress-appraisal model, were collected on caregiver profile, tasks performed and causes of caregiver strain. Semi-structured, in-depth interviews were conducted with caregivers of people with PD (PwP) who went into a care home during the study period, to develop a deeper understanding of the caregiver role and the factors influencing caregiver strain.

RESULTS

Quantitative data were collected from 115 patient caregiver dyads. Interviews were conducted with 10 caregivers. A model to predict caregiver strain was developed and predictors of caregiver strain were identified, such as functional disability and poor caregiver sleep.

CONCLUSION

Our findings further demonstrate the complexity of carer strain. Particular dimensions are identified that need to be addressed within clinical practice to reduce carer strain and support people with Parkinsonism to remain within their own home for as long as possible.

Perceptions and meanings of living with Parkinson's disease: an account of caregivers lived experiences

Purpose: Current study looked into caregiving process of those dealing with family members suffering from Parkinson’s disease, within the changing social milieu in India. It aimed to understand the experiential and existential impact on the lifeworld of caregivers.

Method: Narrative interviews of 10 female caregivers referred by neurologists were gathered. Employing Existential Phenomenological Analysis, the caregiver experiences were understood phenomenologically within an existential framework, six themes were generated.

Results: Themes were – Becoming a caregiver: Undertaking immeasurable and unrelenting responsibilities; Rising patient-hood of one’s family member: pain of losing the person in the patient; Experience of altered temporality: living in pain with the uncertainty and duration of the disease; Encountering meaninglessness: dwindling faith in principles of life; Existing as a “Being For” and not “Being With”: a caregiver’s self-estrangement and blurring of Identity and lastly Self-Preservation through brief moments of respite: coping with caregiving.

Conclusion: The study illuminated how caregiving is experienced by an individual at a process and psychic level by shedding light on the conflicts, concerns and exhaustions endured by them. Adopting an existential approach in healthcare setups can aid in moving closer to felt experiences of these caregivers and in developing integrative and meaningful interventions for enhancing their well-being.

Care Burden and Mental Ill Health in Spouses of People With Parkinson Disease Dementia and Lewy Body Dementia

OBJECTIVES

To explore and compare levels of mental health, care burden, and relationship satisfaction among caregiving spouses of people with mild cognitive impairment or dementia in Parkinson disease (PD-MCI or PDD) or dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB).

METHODS

Spouses (n = 136) completed measures of mood, stress, resilience, general health, quality of life, care burden, and relationship satisfaction, as well as sociodemographic factors. Additionally, data on motor and neuropsychiatric symptom severity of people with PD-MCI, PDD, or DLB were obtained in a subsample.

RESULTS

Most spouses were married women (>85%) who provided a median of 4 years of care and 84 hours of weekly care. Among these, relationship dissatisfaction, stress, anxiety, care burden, and feelings of resentment were common. Spouses of people with PDD and DLB had significantly higher rates of burden, resentment, and depression compared to spouses of people with PD-MCI. Furthermore, unique group differences emerged whereby spouses of people with PDD had significantly longer duration of care provision, higher stress, more relationship dissatisfaction, and fewer positive interactions, compared to PD-MCI group, whereas anxiety and lower levels of mental health were prominent in spouses of people with DLB, compared to PD-MCI group. Despite this, the majority of spouses reported good quality of life, resilience, and satisfaction with the caring role.

CONCLUSION

Both PDD and DLB significantly contribute to poorer mental health and higher levels of care burden in spouses. Clinicians should actively screen the risk of burden, stress, depression, and anxiety among caregiving spouses of people with these conditions.

Perceived stress, resilience, and health-related quality of life among Parkinson's disease caregivers in Mexico

The stress process model of caregiving posits that caregivers' internal psychosocial resources may serve as buffers between the stress associated with caregiving and well-being. Empirical support for the stress process model exists for several caregiving contexts, but little research has investigated the Parkinson's disease caregiving experience in Mexico. Using a cross-sectional, correlational design, the objective of this study was to examine whether resilience moderates the relation between perceived stress and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) among Parkinson's disease caregivers in Mexico. Data were collected from April 2015 to February 2016 during outpatient neurology appointments in Mexico City, Mexico. Participants included informal caregivers (N = 95) for a family member with Parkinson's disease. Participants completed a battery of questionnaires assessing their level of perceived stress, resilience, and HRQOL. Regression analyses indicated that resilience moderated the inverse relation between perceived stress and mental HRQOL. However, contrary to hypotheses, resilience did not moderate the relation between stress and physical HRQOL. Findings shed light on resilience as a potential protective factor for mental HRQOL among Parkinson's disease caregivers in Mexico and indicate that resilience may be beneficial to target in mental health promotion interventions.

The mediating roles of caregiver social support and self-efficacy on caregiver burden in Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

Most studies in Parkinson's disease (PD) have focused on the direct effects of social support and self-efficacy on caregiver burden. This study aimed to test our prediction that caregiver self-efficacy and social support were two chaining mediator variables on the paths for patient factors affecting caregiver burden, caregiver anxiety, and depression.

METHOD

We enrolled patients with PD and their caregivers from the First Affiliated Hospital of Shanxi Medical University in China between July and December 2017. Patients completed scales evaluating their cognition, motor function, and depression. Caregivers completed scales evaluating social support, self-efficacy, anxiety, depression, and caregiver burden. We applied Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to analyze the mediating effects.

RESULTS

Caregiver self-efficacy was a partial mediator on the path of patient motor function effects on caregiver burden (Variance Accounted For, VAF = 0.741), caregiver anxiety (VAF = 0.498) and caregiver depression (VAF = 0.471). Social support for caregivers was a partial mediator on the path for patient motor function effects on caregiver self-efficacy (VAF = 0.247). Caregiver social support and self-efficacy were two chaining mediator variables on the pathway for patient motor function effects on caregiver burden (VAF = 0.768) and caregiver depression (VAF = 0.510).

LIMITATIONS

Our sample only met the minimum sample size requirement for the PLS-SEM and we only focused on a part of variables we collected.

CONCLUSIONS

Our prediction has been validated in this study. And this work supports the decision-making of health authorities and policymakers in managing caregiver social support and caregiver self-efficacy with the aim of reducing caregiver burden in PD.

The role and profile of the informal carer in meeting the needs of people with advancing Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

Many people with Parkinson's disease (PD) (PwP) require care from either informal or formal carers, due to worsening symptoms. Carer strain is a recognised consequence of caring. However there are few data on the role and profile of informal carers and if this impacts on carer strain.

METHOD

People with moderate to advanced PD, with an informal carer were invited to participate. Data regarding motor and non-motor symptoms of the participant, along with demographics, tasks and duration of caring and health issues of the carer were collected.

RESULTS

One-hundred and fifteen participants and their carer were recruited. Mean carer age was 70.7 years, 66.1% were female caring for a median of 16 hours per day. Over 80% provided help in housework and companionship activities, 63.2% with dressing and 49.1% with feeding. There was a significant relationship between disease stage and level of strain. Participant age, physical and cognitive disability were significantly associated with greater care need. High care need was associated with poor carer quality of life.

CONCLUSIONS

The care needs of PwP are considerable. To reduce carer strain and improve quality of life, carers' needs must be considered to enable them to carry on with their vital role.

Multidimensional Care Burden in Parkinson-Related Dementia

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Providing care to people with Parkinson-related dementia (PwPRD) may result in significant stress, strain, and burden for life partners. A common measurement of life partner burden is the Zarit Burden Interview (ZBI), which considers "burden" as a unitary concept; however, burden is highly complex and most likely comprises several dimensions. This study aimed to explore the factor structure of the ZBI in life partners of PwPRD and to examine the relationships among the emerging factors and the demographic and clinical features.

METHODS

Life partners of PwPRD participated in home-based quantitative assessments and self-completed postal questionnaires. The assessment battery included ZBI, measures of relationship satisfaction, mood, stress, resilience, health, quality of life, feelings related to care provision, and sociodemographic questions. Data on PwPRDs' motor and neuropsychiatric symptom severity were also elicited in home-based assessments.

RESULTS

An exploratory factor analysis (principal axis factoring) of ZBI, conducted with 127 life partners, revealed five burden dimensions: social and psychological constraints, personal strain, interference with personal life, concerns about future, and guilt. These burden factors were associated with lower relationship satisfaction, mental health, and resilience, and higher stress, anxiety, depression, resentment, negative strain, and PwPRD motor severity. In multiple linear regression analyses, where each factor score was the dependent variable, stress, negative strain, and resentment emerged as significant predictors of specific burden dimensions.

CONCLUSIONS

Burden is a complex and multidimensional construct. Interventions should address specific types of burden among life partners of PwPRD to support couples' relationships and maintain quality of life.

The Association between Deliberate Self-Harm and School Bullying Victimization and the Mediating Effect of Depressive Symptoms and Self-Stigma: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Identifying deliberate self-harm in the young and its relationship with bullying victimization is an important public health issue.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed to explore evidence of the association between deliberate self-harm and school bullying victimization in young people, as well as the mediating effect of depressive symptoms and self-stigma on this association. An advanced search in the following electronic databases was conducted in January 2018: PubMed/Medline; CINAHL; PsycINFO; PsycARTICLES; Science Direct; Scopus, and Cochrane Library. Studies that fulfilled the inclusion criteria were further assessed for their methodological integrity. The Norwegian Knowledge Centre for Health Services tool was applied for cross-sectional studies and the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme instrument for the cohort studies. Only empirical quantitative studies published in the English language in peer reviewed journals during the last decade (2007-2018) aimed at exploring the association between deliberate self-harm and school bullying victimization in community-based schoolchildren with a mean age of under 20 years were included.

RESULTS

The reviewed cross-sectional and cohort studies (22) revealed a positive association between school bullying victimization and deliberate self-harm, including nonsuicidal self-injury, which remained statistically significant when controlled for the main confounders. The mediating role of depressive symptoms in the association between deliberate self-harm and school bullying victimization was confirmed. A dose-response effect was shown in the association between nonsuicidal self-injury and school bullying victimization, whilst the mediating effect of depressive symptoms needs to be further explored. No studies were found directly exploring the mediating effect of self-stigma in the association between deliberate self-harm and bullying victimization.

CONCLUSION

Targeted interventions aimed at eliminating victimization behaviours within the school context are therefore proposed, as well as interventions to promote healthy parenting styles for the parents of schoolchildren. Moreover, school healthcare professionals should screen students involved in bullying for self-injury, and vice versa.

Caregiver burden in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Informal caregivers of patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis experience increased levels of caregiver burden as the disease progresses. Insight in the factors related to caregiver burden is needed in order to develop supportive interventions.

AIM

To evaluate the evidence on patient and caregiver factors associated with caregiver burden in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis informal caregivers.

DESIGN

A systematic review.

DATA SOURCES

Four electronic databases were searched up to 2017. Studies that investigated quantitative relations between patient or caregiver factors and caregiver burden were included. The overall quality of evidence for factors was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach.

RESULTS

A total of 25 articles were included. High quality of evidence was found for the relation between caregiver burden and the factor "behavioral impairments." Moderate quality of evidence was found for the relations between caregiver burden and the factors "feelings of depression" of the caregiver and "physical functioning" of the patient. The remaining rated caregiver factors-"feelings of anxiety," "distress," "social support," "family functioning," and "age"-and patient factors-"bulbar function," "motor function," "respiratory function," "disease duration," "disinhibition," "executive functioning," "cognitive functioning," "feelings of depression," and "age"-showed low to very low quality of evidence for their association with caregiver burden.

CONCLUSION

Higher caregiver burden is associated with greater behavioral and physical impairment of the patient and with more depressive feelings of the caregiver. This knowledge enables the identification of caregivers at risk for caregiver burden and guides the development of interventions to diminish caregiver burden.