Allocating resources: community involvement is not easy

Economic assessment on the management of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

In the last decade, several new promising treatments for chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) have been developed. Healthcare costs are increasing and new treatments tend to be very expensive; therefore, information about the cost effectiveness in treatments for CLL is urgently needed. The authors performed a literature review on the currently available economic evaluations on CLL treatments. A total of 65 articles were found, of which 11 could be included. These articles were evaluated on the basis of six methodological requirements for economic evaluations, enabling readers to judge the value of the studies. Only a small amount of information was available on the costs of CLL treatments. Future economic evaluations should be performed according to the methodological requirements for these studies, which should also be properly documented.

[Citizens opinions, experiences and perceptions about waiting lists for elective cataract surgery and hip and knee replacement. ]

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study is to describe the views, perceptions and personal experience around elective cataract and hip and knee replacement waiting lists in Catalonia in order to improve their management.

DESIGN

Qualitative methodology: four focus groups for each procedure.

PLACE

Conducted between February-March 2000 at the Catalan Health Services headquarters.

PARTICIPANTS

Each focus group included consultants (ophtalmologists, orthopedic surgeons, rheumatologists, rehabilitators, GPs), other related health professionals (nurses, social workers, physiotherapists, opticians/optometrist, GPs), patients and relatives and general population. Participants were selected through researchers and the clinical scientific committees. All of them followed a pre-established inclusion criteria.

MAIN MEASURES

The analysis of the information was performed using the content analysis technique (contents of sessions were transcripted and information classified according to themes).

RESULTS

Ten themes were identified. Waiting lists were argued to be a consequence of lack of resources, bad management and conflict of interest among consultants. Overall, the health care authority responsibility for the solution was acknowledged, although some participants claim more citizen participation. Among proposed solutions, prevention and education, more resources and improved management were found. Furthermore, a better physician-patient communication was considered essential. All the groups disagreed with the implicit current prioritisation system, however none wanted to assume the responsibility.

CONCLUSIONS

Citizen's perceptions and personal experiences point to a multifactorial approach to waiting lists management, which would ameliorate the problem and lead to a better social acceptance.

Challenges of citizen participation in regional health authorities

Citizen participation has been included as part of health reform, often in the form of lay health authorities. In Canada, these authorities are variously known as regional health boards or councils. A set of challenges is associated with citizen participation in regional health authorities. These challenges relate to: differences in opinion about whether there should be citizen participation at all; differences in perception of the levels and processes of participation; differences in opinion with respect to the roles and responsibilities of health authority members; differences in opinion about the appropriate composition of the authorities; differences in opinion about the requisite skills and attributes of health authority members; having a good support base (staff, good information, board development); understanding and operationalizing various roles of the board (governance and policy setting) versus the board staff (management and administration); difficulties in ensuring the accountability of the health authorities; and measuring the results of the work and decisions of the health authorities. Despite these challenges, regional health authorities are gaining support as both theoretically sound and pragmatically based approaches to health-system reform. This review of the above challenges suggests that each of the concerns remains a significant threat to meaningful public participation.

Acute health-related quality of life in children undergoing stem cell transplant: II. Medical and demographic determinants

Medical and demographic variables were examined as predictors of acute health-related quality of life (HRQL), specifically, somatic distress, mood disturbance and activity levels, during the period of bone marrow transplant (BMT) hospitalization, and the transition phase in the months following hospital discharge. The responses of 153 children undergoing BMT were assessed by both parent report and patient self-report in a prospective longitudinal design. Type of transplant, diagnosis, age, gender, and socio-economic status (SES) were examined as predictor variables of patient outcome. Type of transplant, patient age, and SES emerged as significant determinants of patient response. Children undergoing unrelated donor (MUD) transplants experiencing the highest levels of distress, followed by those undergoing matched-sibling BMT, while those undergoing autologous transplant experienced the lowest levels of distress. Younger patients experienced lower levels of distress and better HRQL than older children and adolescents. Although patients from different SES backgrounds appeared very similar at the time of hospital admission, those from lower SES backgrounds demonstrated greater distress and disturbance in HRQL subsequently, and throughout the first 6 months post BMT. These findings help to target specific subgroups of patients that may be in greater need of preventive interventions or more aggressive supportive care.

The many meanings of deinsuring a health service: the case of in vitro fertilization in Ontario

There is currently much international interest in principles and processes for determining which services should qualify for health insurance packages. However, there has yet been little analysis of the implications of actual deinsurance decisions made by such priority-setting exercises. This paper reports experience from the case of in vitro fertilization (IVF) deinsurance in Ontario, Canada. The analysis addresses some of the more social aspects of financial incentives by characterizing funding structures as means of communicating complex policy objectives, rather than mechanistic reward-penalty systems. Deinsuring IVF was intended to support several policy goals, including: controlling public expenditures, restricting public coverage to 'medically necessary' services, applying evidence of effectiveness as a criterion for medical necessity and implementing part of a policy program to control new reproductive technologies. It may seem a modest step to remove one dubious service from public insurance coverage. Nevertheless, as interpreted by stakeholders, deinsurance of IVF may inadvertently promote the opposite of what policy makers intended. This case suggests that priority-setting decisions based on incomplete information, inconsistently applied principles and too little attention to health system dynamics (perhaps the norm in 'real-world' priority-setting) can have the perverse effect of undermining progress toward health reform goals of improved health, reduced expenditures and more rigorously evaluated services. The case of IVF in Ontario offers several lessons for other jurisdictions engaged in priority-setting and service deinsurance: (1) individual services interact with the rest of the system and cannot be removed without systemic effects, (2) inconsistent use of coverage principles can undermine legitimacy of both priority-setting principles and processes and (3) 'evidence-based' decisions can founder on differing stakeholder ideas about appropriate evidence and on the inconsistent message given by commercializing ineffective or unproven care.