Interstitial photodynamic therapy and glioblastoma: Light fractionation in a preclinical model

Enhancing Fractionated Cancer Therapy: A Triple-Anthracene Photosensitizer Unleashes Long-Persistent Photodynamic and Luminous Efficacy

Conventional photodynamic therapy (PDT) is often limited in treating solid tumors due to hypoxic conditions that impede the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which are critical for therapeutic efficacy. To address this issue, a fractionated PDT protocol has been suggested, wherein light irradiation is administered in stages separated by dark intervals to permit oxygen recovery during these breaks. However, the current photosensitizers used in fractionated PDT are incapable of sustaining ROS production during the dark intervals, leading to suboptimal therapeutic outcomes (Table S1). To circumvent this drawback, we have synthesized a novel photosensitizer based on a triple-anthracene derivative that is designed for prolonged ROS generation, even after the cessation of light exposure. Our study reveals a unique photodynamic action of these derivatives, facilitating the direct and effective disruption of biomolecules and significantly improving the efficacy of fractionated PDT (Table S2). Moreover, the existing photosensitizers lack imaging capabilities for monitoring, which constraints the fine-tuning of irradiation parameters (Table S1). Our triple-anthracene derivative also serves as an afterglow imaging agent, emitting sustained luminescence postirradiation. This imaging function allows for the precise optimization of intervals between PDT sessions and aids in determining the timing for subsequent irradiation, thus enabling meticulous control over therapy parameters. Utilizing our novel triple-anthracene photosensitizer, we have formulated a fractionated PDT regimen that effectively eliminates orthotopic pancreatic tumors. This investigation highlights the promise of employing long-persistent photodynamic activity in advanced fractionated PDT approaches to overcome the current limitations of PDT in solid tumor treatment.

Systematic Review of Photodynamic Therapy in Gliomas

Over the last 20 years, gliomas have made up over 89% of malignant CNS tumor cases in the American population (NIH SEER). Within this, glioblastoma is the most common subtype, comprising 57% of all glioma cases. Being highly aggressive, this deadly disease is known for its high genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity, rendering a complicated disease course. The current standard of care consists of maximally safe tumor resection concurrent with chemoradiotherapy. However, despite advances in technology and therapeutic modalities, rates of disease recurrence are still high and survivability remains low. Given the delicate nature of the tumor location, remaining margins following resection often initiate disease recurrence. Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a therapeutic modality that, following the administration of a non-toxic photosensitizer, induces tumor-specific anti-cancer effects after localized, wavelength-specific illumination. Its effect against malignant glioma has been studied extensively over the last 30 years, in pre-clinical and clinical trials. Here, we provide a comprehensive review of the three generations of photosensitizers alongside their mechanisms of action, limitations, and future directions.

Interstitial Photodynamic Therapy for Glioblastomas: A Standardized Procedure for Clinical Use

Simple Summary

The most frequent primary high-grade brain tumors are glioblastomas (GBMs). The current standard of care for GBM is maximal surgical resection followed by radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Despite all these treatments, the overall survival is still limited, with a median of 15 months. The challenge is to improve the local control of this infiltrative disease. Interstitial photodynamic therapy (iPDT) is a minimally invasive treatment relying on the interaction of light, a photosensitizer and oxygen. It consists of introducing optical fibers inside the tumor to illuminate the cancer cells which have been sensitized to light thanks to a natural photosensitizer agent. Herein, we propose a standardized and reproducible workflow for the clinical application of iPDT to GBM. This workflow, which involves intraoperative imaging, a dedicated treatment planning system (TPS) and robotic assistance for the implantation of stereotactic optical fibers, represents a key step in the deployment of iPDT for the treatment of GBM.

Abstract

Glioblastomas (GBMs) are high-grade malignancies with a poor prognosis. The current standard of care for GBM is maximal surgical resection followed by radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Despite all these treatments, the overall survival is still limited, with a median of 15 months. For patients harboring inoperable GBM, due to the anatomical location of the tumor or poor general condition of the patient, the life expectancy is even worse. The challenge of managing GBM is therefore to improve the local control especially for non-surgical patients. Interstitial photodynamic therapy (iPDT) is a minimally invasive treatment relying on the interaction of light, a photosensitizer and oxygen. In the case of brain tumors, iPDT consists of introducing one or several optical fibers in the tumor area, without large craniotomy, to illuminate the photosensitized tumor cells. It induces necrosis and/or apoptosis of the tumor cells, and it can destruct the tumor vasculature and produces an acute inflammatory response that attracts leukocytes. Interstitial PDT has already been applied in the treatment of brain tumors with very promising results. However, no standardized procedure has emerged from previous studies. Herein, we propose a standardized and reproducible workflow for the clinical application of iPDT to GBM. This workflow, which involves intraoperative imaging, a dedicated treatment planning system (TPS) and robotic assistance for the implantation of stereotactic optical fibers, represents a key step in the deployment of iPDT for the treatment of GBM. This end-to-end procedure has been validated on a phantom in real operating room conditions. The thorough description of a fully integrated iPDT workflow is an essential step forward to a clinical trial to evaluate iPDT in the treatment of GBM.

Is interstitial photodynamic therapy for brain tumors ready for clinical practice? A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Interstitial photodynamic therapy (iPDT), inserting optical fibers inside brain tumors, has been proposed for more than 30 years. While a promising therapeutic option, it is still an experimental treatment, with different ways of application, depending on the team performing the technique.

OBJECTIVE

In this systematic review, we reported the patient selection process, the treatment parameters, the potential adverse events and the oncological outcomes related to iPDT treatment applied to brain tumors.

METHODS

We performed a search in PubMed, Embase and Medline based on the following Mesh terms: "interstitial" AND "photodynamic therapy" AND "brain tumor" OR "glioma" OR glioblastoma" from January 1990 to April 2020. We screened 350 studies. Twelve matched all selection criteria.

RESULTS

251 patients underwent iPDT. Tumors were mainly de novo or recurrent high-grade gliomas (171 (68%) of glioblastomas), located supratentorial, with a median volume of 12 cm³. Hematoporphyrin derive agent (HpD) or protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) induced by 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) was used as a photosensitizer. Up to 6 optical fibers were introduced inside the tumor, delivering 200 mW/cm at a wavelength of 630 nm. Overall mortality was 1%. Transient and persistent morbidity were both 5%. No permanent deficit occurred using 5-ALA PDT. Tumor response rate after iPDT was 92% (IQR, 67; 99). Regarding glioblastomas, progression-free-survival was respectively 14.5 months (IQR, 13.8; 15.3) for de novo lesions and 14 months (IQR, 7; 30) for recurrent lesions, while overall survival was respectively 19 months (IQR, 14; 20) and 8 months (IQR, 6.3; 8.5). In patients harboring high-grade gliomas, 33 (13%) were considered long-term survivors (> 2 years) after iPDT.

CONCLUSION

Regardless of heterogeneity in its application, iPDT appears safe and efficient to treat brain tumors, especially high-grade gliomas. Stand-alone iPDT (i.e., without combined craniotomy and intracavitary PDT) using 5-ALA appears to be the best option in terms of controlling side effects: it avoids the occurrence of permanent neurological deficits while reducing the risks of hemorrhage and sepsis.

Standardized intraoperative 5-ALA photodynamic therapy for newly diagnosed glioblastoma patients: a preliminary analysis of the INDYGO clinical trial

PURPOSE

Glioblastoma (GBM) is the most aggressive malignant primary brain tumor. The unfavorable prognosis despite maximal therapy relates to high propensity for recurrence. Thus, overall survival (OS) is quite limited and local failure remains the fundamental problem. Here, we present a safety and feasibility trial after treating GBM intraoperatively by photodynamic therapy (PDT) after 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) administration and maximal resection.

METHODS

Ten patients with newly diagnosed GBM were enrolled and treated between May 2017 and June 2018. The standardized therapeutic approach included maximal resection (near total or gross total tumor resection (GTR)) guided by 5-ALA fluorescence-guided surgery (FGS), followed by intraoperative PDT. Postoperatively, patients underwent adjuvant therapy (Stupp protocol). Follow-up included clinical examinations and brain MR imaging was performed every 3 months until tumor progression and/or death.

RESULTS

There were no unacceptable or unexpected toxicities or serious adverse effects. At the time of the interim analysis, the actuarial 12-months progression-free survival (PFS) rate was 60% (median 17.1 months), and the actuarial 12-months OS rate was 80% (median 23.1 months).

CONCLUSIONS

This trial assessed the feasibility and the safety of intraoperative 5-ALA PDT as a novel approach for treating GBM after maximal tumor resection. The current standard of care remains microsurgical resection whenever feasible, followed by adjuvant therapy (Stupp protocol). We postulate that PDT delivered immediately after resection as an add-on therapy of this primary brain cancer is safe and may help to decrease the recurrence risk by targeting residual tumor cells in the resection cavity. Trial registration NCT number: NCT03048240. EudraCT number: 2016-002706-39.

Survival Outcomes Among Patients With High-Grade Glioma Treated With 5-Aminolevulinic Acid-Guided Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Background: High-grade glioma (HGG) is associated with a dismal prognosis despite significant advances in adjuvant therapies, including chemotherapy, immunotherapy, and radiotherapy. Extent of resection continues to be the most important independent prognosticator of survival. This underlines the significance of increasing gross total resection (GTR) rates by using adjunctive intraoperative modalities to maximize resection with minimal neurological morbidity. 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) is the only US Food and Drug Administration–approved intraoperative optical agent used for fluorescence-guided surgical resection of gliomas. Despite several studies on the impact of intra-operative 5-ALA use on the extent of HGG resection, a clear picture of how such usage affects patient survival is still unavailable.

Methods: A systematic review was conducted of all relevant studies assessing the GTR rate and survival outcomes [overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS)] in HGG. A meta-analysis of eligible studies was performed to assess the influence of 5-ALA-guided resection on improving GTR, OS, and PFS. GTR was defined as >95% resection.

Results: Of 23 eligible studies, 19 reporting GTR rates were included in the meta-analysis. The pooled cohort had 998 patients with HGG, including 796 with newly diagnosed cases. The pooled GTR rate among patients with 5-ALA–guided resection was 76.8% (95% confidence interval, 69.1–82.9%). A comparative subgroup analysis of 5-ALA–guided vs. conventional surgery (controlling for within-study covariates) showed a 26% higher GTR rate in the 5-ALA subgroup (odds ratio, 3.8; P < 0.001). There were 11 studies eligible for survival outcome analysis, 4 of which reported PFS. The pooled mean difference in OS and PFS was 3 and 1 months, respectively, favoring 5-ALA vs. control (P < 0.001).

Conclusions: This meta-analysis shows a significant increase in GTR rate with 5-ALA–guided surgical resection, with a higher weighted GTR rate (~76%) than the pivotal phase III study (~65%). Pooled analysis showed a small yet significant increase in survival measures associated with the use of 5-ALA. Despite the statistically significant results, the low level of evidence and heterogeneity across these studies make it difficult to conclusively report an independent association between 5-ALA use and survival outcomes in HGG. Additional randomized control studies are required to delineate the role of 5-ALA in survival outcomes in HGG.

5-aminolevulinic acid photodynamic therapy for the treatment of high-grade gliomas

INTRODUCTION

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a two-step treatment involving the administration of a photosensitive agent followed by its activation at a specific light wavelength for targeting of tumor cells.

MATERIALS/METHODS

A comprehensive review of the literature was performed to analyze the indications for PDT, mechanisms of action, use of different photosensitizers, the immunomodulatory effects of PDT, and both preclinical and clinical studies for use in high-grade gliomas (HGGs).

RESULTS

PDT has been approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the treatment of premalignant and malignant diseases, such as actinic keratoses, Barrett's esophagus, esophageal cancers, and endobronchial non-small cell lung cancers, as well as for the treatment of choroidal neovascularization. In neuro-oncology, clinical trials are currently underway to demonstrate PDT efficacy against a number of malignancies that include HGGs and other brain tumors. Both photosensitizers and photosensitizing precursors have been used for PDT. 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA), an intermediate in the heme synthesis pathway, is a photosensitizing precursor with FDA approval for PDT of actinic keratosis and as an intraoperative imaging agent for fluorescence-guided visualization of malignant tissue during glioma surgery. New trials are underway to utilize 5-ALA as a therapeutic agent for PDT of the intraoperative resection cavity and interstitial PDT for inoperable HGGs.

CONCLUSION

PDT remains a promising therapeutic approach that requires further study in HGGs. Use of 5-ALA PDT permits selective tumor targeting due to the intracellular metabolism of 5-ALA. The immunomodulatory effects of PDT further strengthen its use for treatment of HGGs and requires a better understanding. The combination of PDT with adjuvant therapies for HGGs will need to be studied in randomized, controlled studies.

Comparison of different treatment schemes in 5-ALA interstitial photodynamic therapy for high-grade glioma in a preclinical model: An MRI study

BACKGROUND

There is currently no therapy that prevents high-grade glioma recurrence. Thus, these primary brain tumors have unfavorable outcomes. Recently, 5-ALA photodynamic therapy (PDT) has been proposed to delay relapse and is highly expected to have potential synergistic effects with the current standard of care. However, PDT treatment delivery needs to be optimized by evaluating the impact of both the number of fractions and the light power used.

OBJECTIVES

Previous studies have reported MRI examination-based outcomes for PDT in glioblastoma. Our study aimed to compare MRI markers across different treatment schemes that use interstitial PDT in high-grade glioma in a preclinical model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-eight "nude" rats were grafted with human U87 cells into the right putamen and subsequently submitted to interstitial PDT. The rats were randomized into six groups, including two different sham groups and four different treated groups (5 fractions at 5 mW or 30 mW and 2 fractions at 5 mW or 30 mW). After photosensitizer (PS) precursor (5-ALA) intake, an optical fiber was introduced into the tumor. Treatment effects were assessed with early high-field MRI to acquire T1 and T2 diffusion and perfusion images.

RESULTS

There was no difference in the variation of the diffusion coefficient among the six groups (p = 0.0549, Kruskal-Wallis test). However, a significant difference was identified among the six groups in terms of variation in perfusion (p = 0.048, Kruskal-Wallis test), supporting a lesional effect in the treated groups. Additionally, the sham groups had significantly smaller edema volumes than were observed in the treated groups. Moreover, the 5-fraction group treated with 30 mW was associated with edema volumes that were significantly greater than those in the 5-fraction group treated with 5 mW (p = 0.019).

CONCLUSION

Based on observations of MRI data and considering treatment effects, the 5-fraction group treated at 5 mW was not significantly different from the other treated groups in terms of cell deaths, characterized by diffusion imaging, or necrosis level. However, the significantly lower level of edema observed in this group indicated that this treatment scheme had limited toxicity.

MRI assessment of treatment delivery for interstitial photodynamic therapy of high-grade glioma in a preclinical model

BACKGROUND

High-grade gliomas are primary brain tumors that have shown increasing incidence and unfavorable outcomes. Local control is crucial to the management of this pathology. Photodynamic therapy (PDT), based on the light-induced activation of a photosensitizer (PS), achieves local treatment by inducing selective lesions in tumor tissue.

OBJECTIVES

Previous studies have reported the outcomes of PDT for glioblastoma via immunohistological data. Our study aimed to evaluate MRI findings, including diffusion, and perfusion sequences, compared with immunohistological data from the same population to address the efficiency of light fractionation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-six "nude" rats grafted with human U87 cells into the right putamen underwent PDT. After PS precursor (5-ALA) intake, an optical fiber was introduced into the tumor. The rats were randomized into the following groups: those without illumination and those that received two or five fractions of light. Treatment effects were assessed with early high-field MRI to measure the volume of necrosis and edema using diffusion and perfusion sequences; the MRI results were compared with immunohistology results, including necrosis and apoptosis markers.

RESULTS

Elevated diffusion values were observed on MRI in the centers of the tumors of the treated animals, especially in the 5-fraction group (P < 0.01). Perfusion was decreased around the treatment site, especially in the 5-fraction group (P = 0.024). The MRI findings were consistent with previously published histological data. The median volume of necrosis was significantly different between the sham group and treated groups, 0 mm³ versus 2.67 mm³ , P < 0.001. The same trend was previously observed in histology data when grading the absence or presence of necrosis and when the presence of necrosis was significantly more predominant for the treated group than for the untreated group (P < 001). Additionally, cell death represented by apoptosis marker data (TUNEL method) was significantly higher in the 5-fraction group than in the 2-fraction group (P = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Diffusion and perfusion MRI revealed histological lesions. Interstitial PDT (iPDT) induced specific lesions in the tumor tissue, which were observed with MRI and confirmed by histopathological analysis. Thus, MRI may provide a non-invasive and reliable tool to assess treatment outcomes after PDT. Lasers Surg. Med. 50:460-468, 2018. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.