Clinical and molecular characterization of cystinuria in a French cohort: relevance of assessing large-scale rearrangements and splicing variants

The genetics of cystinuria - an update and critical reevaluation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

We aimed to critically evaluate how the establishment of genotype-based treatment for cystinuria has been hampered due to the large number of variants of unknown significance (VUS) within the disease causing genes as well as challenges in accessing a large enough sample size for systematic analysis of endpoint parameters that truly reflect disease severity. This review further discusses how to overcome these hurdles with the establishment of a cystinuria-specific refinement of the current American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)-criteria of variant interpretation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Novel tools such as AlphaMissense combined with the establishment of a refined ACMG criterion will play a significant role in classifying VUS within the responsible disease genes SLC3A1 (rBAT) and SLC7A9 (BAT1). This will also be essential in elucidating the role of promising candidate genes, such as SLC7A13 (AGT1), which have been derived from murine model systems and still need further research to determine if they are involved in human cystinuria.

SUMMARY

Cystinuria was one of the first disorders to receive a gene-based classification, nonetheless, the clinically actionable implications of genetic diagnostics is still minor. This is due to poorly characterized genotype-phenotype correlations which results in a lack of individualized (genotype-) based management and metaphylaxis.

Population genetics analysis of SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 revealed the etiology of cystine stone may be more than what our current genetic knowledge can explain

BACKGROUND

Cystine stone is a Mendelian genetic disease caused by SLC3A1 or SLC7A9. In this study, we aimed to estimate the genetic prevalence of cystine stones and compare it with the clinical prevalence to better understand the disease etiology.

METHODS

We analyzed genetic variants in the general population using the 1000 Genomes project and the Human Gene Mutation Database to extract all SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 pathogenic variants. All variants procured from both databases were intersected. Pathogenic allele frequency, carrier rate, and affected rate were calculated and estimated based on Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.

RESULTS

We found that 9 unique SLC3A1 pathogenic variants were carried by 26 people and 5 unique SLC7A9 pathogenic variants were carried by 12 people, all of whom were heterozygote carriers. No homozygote, compoun d heterozygote, or double heterozygote was identified in the 1000 Genome database. Based on the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, the calculated genetic prevalence of cystine stone disease is 1 in 30,585.

CONCLUSION

The clinical prevalence of cystine stone has been previously reported as 1 in 7,000, a notably higher figure than the genetic prevalence of 1 in 30,585 calculated in this study. This suggests that the etiology of cystine stone is more complex than what our current genetic knowledge can explain. Possible factors that may contribute to this difference include novel causal genes, undiscovered pathogenic variants, alternative inheritance models, founder effects, epigenetic modifications, environmental factors, or other modifying factors. Further investigation is needed to fully understand the etiology of cystine stone.

Interpretation of SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 variants in cystinuria patients: The significance of the PM3 criterion and protein stability

Cystinuria is a genetic disorder caused by defects in the b0,+ transporter system, which is composed of rBAT and b0,+AT coded by SLC3A1 and SLC7A9, respectively. Variants in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 follow autosomal recessive inheritance and autosomal dominant inheritance with reduced penetrance, respectively, which complicates the interpretation of cystinuria-related variants. Here, we report seven different SLC3A1 variants and six different SLC7A9 variants. Among these variants were two novel variants previously not reported: SLC3A1 c.223C > T and SLC7A9 c.404A > G. In silico analysis using REVEL correlated well with the functional loss upon SLC7A9 variants with scores of 0.8560-0.9200 and 0.4970-0.5239 for severe and mild decrease in transport activity, respectively. In addition, DynaMut2 was able to predict a decreased protein expression level resulting from the SLC7A9 variant c.313G > A with a ΔΔGStability -2.93 kcal/mol. Our study adds to the literature as additional cases of a variant allow applying the PM3 criterion with higher strength level. In addition, we suggest the clinical utility of REVEL and DynaMut2 in interpreting SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 variants. While a decreased protein expression level is not embraced in the current variant interpretation guidelines, we believe in silico protein stability predicting tools could serve as evidence of protein function loss.

Clinical Characteristics and In Silico Analysis of Cystinuria Caused by a Novel SLC3A1 Mutation

Cystinuria is a genetically inherited disorder of renal and intestinal transport, featured as a high concentration of cystine in the urine. Cumulative cystine in urine would cause the formation of kidney stones, which further leads to renal colic and dysfunction. Gene screens have found that mutations in SLC3A1 or SLC7A9 gene are responsible for most cases of cystinuria, for encoding defective cystine transporters. Here, we presented the genotypic and phenotypic characteristics of one unique case of a three-generation Chinese family. The proband developed severe urolithiasis combined with renal damage. The radiography and computed tomography (CT) scan showed calculus in the left pelvic kidney. Postoperative stone analysis revealed that the stones were mainly composed of cystine. Therefore, to explore its pathogenesis, next-generation Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) and Sanger sequencing identify the proband mutated gene of the proband’s family. In this article, we reported novel compound heterozygous mutations (c.818G>A and c.1011G>A) of the SLC3A1 gene in a 5-year-old child suffering from a cystine stone from a three-generation family. Bioinformatic analysis was used to predict the pathogenicity and conservation of the target mutation. Conservative sequence and evolutionary conservation analysis indicated that cystine273 and proline337 were highly conserved among species, and both mutations listed here (Cys273Tyr and Pro337Pro) were pathogenic. To conclude, our study expands the phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of SLC3A1 and indicates that genetic screening should be considered in the clinic to provide more effective and precise treatment for cystinuria.

Phenotypic characterization of a pediatric cohort with cystinuria and usefulness of newborn screening

BACKGROUND

Cystinuria is an inherited metabolic disease involving the defective transport of cystine and the dibasic amino acids in the renal proximal tubules that causes the formation of stones in the urinary system. In our regional child health program, cystinuria is included in newborn metabolic screening. Our objectives are the phenotypic characterization of our cystinuric pediatric cohort and to present our experience in neonatal cystinuria screening.

METHODS

The study of clinical cases of pediatric patients diagnosed with cystinuria over a period of 32 years. All patients were studied at demographic, clinical, laboratory, radiological, and therapeutic levels.

RESULTS

We diagnosed 86 pediatric patients with cystinuria; 36% of them had the homozygous biochemical phenotype. 95.3% of the patients were detected by neonatal metabolic screening. We performed urine biochemical analyses of parents with additional diagnoses of 63 adult patients. The mean follow-up time was 16.8 ± 8.5 years. 11.6% of patients developed one or more episodes of urinary tract infection during that period. Chronic kidney disease, proteinuria, and hypertension were uncommon (1.2%). 10.5% developed kidney stones at the mean age of presentation of 7.78 ± 7.6 years; 33% were recurrent. The risk of developing lithiasis was higher for homozygous biochemical-phenotype patients. Hypercalciuria was a significant risk factor in the development of lithiasis.

CONCLUSIONS

Our clinical data suggest that diagnosing cystinuria through neonatal screening could be a useful strategy for the detection of presymptomatic cases, in order to establish preventive measures, as well as for the detection of relatives at risk. A higher resolution version of the Graphical abstract is available as Supplementary information.

Clinical profile of a Polish cohort of children and young adults with cystinuria

Background

Cystinuria is an inherited disorder that results in increased excretion of cystine in the urine. It accounts for about 1–2% of pediatric kidney stones. In this study, we sought to identify the clinical characteristics of patients with cystinuria in a national cohort.

Methods

This was a retrospective study involving 30 patients from the Polish Registry of Inherited Tubulopathies. Initial data and that from a 6-month follow-up were analyzed. Mutational analysis was performed by targeted Sanger sequencing and, if applicable, MLPA analysis was used to detect large rearrangements.

Results

SLC7A9 mutations were detected in 15 children (50%; 10 males, 5 females), SLC3A1 mutations in 14 children (47%; 5 males, 9 females), and bigenic mutations in one male patient. The first clinical symptoms of the disease were detected at a median of 48 months of age (range 3–233 months). When individuals with different mutations were compared, there were no differences identified in gender, age of diagnosis, presence of UTI or urolithiasis, eGFR, calcium, or cystine excretion. The most common initial symptoms were urolithiasis in 26 patients (88%) and urinary tract infections in 4 patients (13%). Urological procedures were performed in 18 out of 30 (60%).

Conclusions

The clinical course of cystinuria is similar among patients, regardless of the type of genetic mutation. Most patients require surgery before diagnosis or soon after it. Patients require combined urological and pharmacological treatment for prevention of stone recurrence and renal function preservation.

[Cystinuria]

Cystinuria is the most common monogenic nephrolithiasis disorder. Because of its poor solubility at a typical urine pH of less than 7, cystine excretion results in recurrent urinary cystine stone formation. A high prevalence of high blood pressure and of chronic kidney disease has been reported in these patients. Alkaline hyperdiuresis remains the cornerstone of the preventive medical treatment. To reach a urine pH between 7.5 and 8 and a urine specific gravity less than or equal to 1.005 should be the goal of medical treatment. D-penicillamine and tiopronin, two cysteine-binding thiol agents, should be considered as second line treatments with frequent adverse events that should be closely monitored.

Heteromeric Solute Carriers: Function, Structure, Pathology and Pharmacology

Solute carriers form one of three major superfamilies of membrane transporters in humans, and include uniporters, exchangers and symporters. Following several decades of molecular characterisation, multiple solute carriers that form obligatory heteromers with unrelated subunits are emerging as a distinctive principle of membrane transporter assembly. Here we comprehensively review experimentally established heteromeric solute carriers: SLC3-SLC7 amino acid exchangers, SLC16 monocarboxylate/H⁺ symporters and basigin/embigin, SLC4A1 (AE1) and glycophorin A exchanger, SLC51 heteromer Ost α-Ost β uniporter, and SLC6 heteromeric symporters. The review covers the history of the heteromer discovery, transporter physiology, structure, disease associations and pharmacology - all with a focus on the heteromeric assembly. The cellular locations, requirements for complex formation, and the functional role of dimerization are extensively detailed, including analysis of the first complete heteromer structures, the SLC7-SLC3 family transporters LAT1-4F2hc, b^0,+AT-rBAT and the SLC6 family heteromer B⁰AT1-ACE2. We present a systematic analysis of the structural and functional aspects of heteromeric solute carriers and conclude with common principles of their functional roles and structural architecture.

A no-nonsense approach to hereditary kidney disease

The advent of a new class of aminoglycosides with increased translational readthrough of nonsense mutations and reduced toxicity offers a new therapeutic strategy for a subset of patients with hereditary kidney disease. The renal uptake and retention of aminoglycosides at a high intracellular concentration makes the kidney an ideal target for this approach. In this review, we explore the potential of aminoglycoside readthrough therapy in a number of hereditary kidney diseases and discuss the therapeutic window of opportunity for subclasses of each disease, when caused by nonsense mutations.

Cystinuria: clinical practice recommendation

Cystinuria (OMIM 220100) is an autosomal recessive hereditary disorder in which high urinary cystine excretion leads to the formation of cystine stones because of the low solubility of cystine at normal urinary pH. We developed clinical practice recommendation for diagnosis, surgical and medical treatment, and follow-up of patients with cystinuria. Elaboration of these clinical practice recommendations spanned from June 2018 to December 2019 with a consensus conference in January 2019. Selected topic areas were chosen by the co-chairs of the conference. Working groups focusing on specific topics were formed. Group members performed systematic literature review using MEDLINE, drafted the statements, and discussed them. They included geneticists, medical biochemists, pediatric and adult nephrologists, pediatric and adult urologists experts in cystinuria, and the Metabolic Nephropathy Joint Working Group of the European Reference Network for Rare Kidney Diseases (ERKNet) and eUROGEN members. Overall 20 statements were produced to provide guidance on diagnosis, genetic analysis, imaging techniques, surgical treatment (indication and modalities), conservative treatment (hydration, dietetic, alkalinization, and cystine-binding drugs), follow-up, self-monitoring, complications (renal failure and hypertension), and impact on quality of life. Because of the rarity of the disease and the poor level of evidence in the literature, these statements could not be graded. This clinical practice recommendation provides guidance on all aspects of the management of both adults and children with cystinuria, including diagnosis, surgery, and medical treatment.

Amino Acid Transport Defects in Human Inherited Metabolic Disorders

Amino acid transporters play very important roles in nutrient uptake, neurotransmitter recycling, protein synthesis, gene expression, cell redox balance, cell signaling, and regulation of cell volume. With regard to transporters that are closely connected to metabolism, amino acid transporter-associated diseases are linked to metabolic disorders, particularly when they involve different organs, cell types, or cell compartments. To date, 65 different human solute carrier (SLC) families and more than 400 transporter genes have been identified, including 11 that are known to include amino acid transporters. This review intends to summarize and update all the conditions in which a strong association has been found between an amino acid transporter and an inherited metabolic disorder. Many of these inherited disorders have been identified in recent years. In this work, the physiological functions of amino acid transporters will be described by the inherited diseases that arise from transporter impairment. The pathogenesis, clinical phenotype, laboratory findings, diagnosis, genetics, and treatment of these disorders are also briefly described. Appropriate clinical and diagnostic characterization of the underlying molecular defect may give patients the opportunity to avail themselves of appropriate therapeutic options in the future.

Adverse events associated with currently used medical treatments for cystinuria and treatment goals: results from a series of 442 patients in France

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate medical treatments, in terms of adverse events (AEs) and therapeutic goals, in a large series of patients with cystinuria.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Data from 442 patients with cystinuria were recorded retrospectively. Crystalluria was studied in 89 patients. A mixed-effects logistic regression model was used to estimate how urine pH, specific gravity and cysteine-binding thiols (CBT) correlate with risk of cystine crystalluria.

RESULTS

Alkalizing agents and CBT agents were given to 88.8% (n = 381) and 55.3% (n = 238) of patients, respectively. Gastrointestinal AEs were reported in 12.3%, 10.4% and 2.6% of patients treated with potassium bicarbonate, potassium citrate and sodium bicarbonate, respectively (P = 0.008). The percentages of patients who experienced at least one AE with tiopronin (24.6%) and with D-penicillamine (29.5%) were similar (P = 0.45). Increasing urine pH and decreasing urine specific gravity significantly reduced the risk of cystine crystalluria, whereas D-penicillamine and tiopronin treatments did not reduce this risk (odds ratio [OR] 1 for pH ≤6.5; OR 0.52 [95% confidence interval {95% CI} 0.28-0.95] for 7.0 <pH ≤7.5, P = 0.03; OR 0.26 [95% CI 0.13-0.53] for 7.5 < pH ≤8.0, P <0.001; OR 1 for specific gravity ≤1.005 OR 5.76 [95% CI 1.45-22.85] for 1.006 ≤ specific gravity ≤1.010, P = 0.01; and OR 11.06 [95% CI 2.76-44.26] for 1.011 ≤ specific gravity ≤ 1.014, P < 0.001). Increased urine pH significantly increased the risk of calcium phosphate crystalluria (OR 1 for pH≤ 6.5; OR 6.09 [95% CI 2.15-17.25] for pH >8.0, P <0.001).

CONCLUSION

Adverse events were frequent with D-penicillamine and tiopronin. Alkaline hyperdiuresis was well tolerated and reduced cystine crystalluria. Urine specific gravity ≤1.005 and urine pH >7.5, while warning about calcium-phosphate crystallization, should be the goals of medical therapy.

Cystinuria: genetic aspects, mouse models, and a new approach to therapy

Cystinuria, a genetic disorder of cystine transport, is characterized by excessive excretion of cystine in the urine and recurrent cystine stones in the kidneys and, to a lesser extent, in the bladder. Males generally are more severely affected than females. The disorder may lead to chronic kidney disease in many patients. The cystine transporter (b^0,+) is a heterodimer consisting of the rBAT (encoded by SLC3A1) and b^0,+AT (encoded by SLC7A9) subunits joined by a disulfide bridge. The molecular basis of cystinuria is known in great detail, and this information is now being used to define genotype-phenotype correlations. Current treatments for cystinuria include increased fluid intake to increase cystine solubility and the administration of thiol drugs for more severe cases. These drugs, however, have poor patient compliance due to adverse effects. Thus, there is a need to reduce or eliminate the risks associated with therapy for cystinuria. Four mouse models for cystinuria have been described and these models provide a resource for evaluating the safety and efficacy of new therapies for cystinuria. We are evaluating a new approach for the treatment of cystine stones based on the inhibition of cystine crystal growth by cystine analogs. Our ongoing studies indicate that cystine diamides are effective in preventing cystine stone formation in the Slc3a1 knockout mouse model for cystinuria. In addition to crystal growth, crystal aggregation is required for stone formation. Male and female mice with cystinuria have comparable levels of crystalluria, but very few female mice form stones. The identification of factors that inhibit cystine crystal aggregation in female mice may provide insight into the gender difference in disease severity in patients with cystinuria.

In silico analysis of SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 mutations in Iranian patients with Cystinuria

Cystinuria is an autosomal recessive defect in reabsorptive transport of cystine and the dibasic amino acids ornithine, arginine, and lysine from renal tubule and small intestine. Mutations in two genes: SLC3A1, encoding the heavy chain rbAT of the renal cystine transport system and SLC7A9, the gene of its light chain b^{0, +} AT have a crucial role in the diseases. In our previous studies from Iranian populations with Cystinuria totally six and eleven novel mutations respectively identified in SLC3A1 and SLC7A9 genes. In this study, we conducted an in silico functional analysis to explore the possible association between these genetic mutations and Cystinuria. MutationTaster, PolyPhen-2, PANTHER, FATHMM. PhDSNP and MutPred was applied to predict the degree of pathogenicity for the missense mutations. Furthermore, Residue Interaction Network (RIN) and Intron variant analyses was performed using Cytoscape and Human Slicing Finder softwares. These genetic variants can provide a better understanding of genotype-phenotype relationships in patients with Cystinuria. In the future, the findings may also facilitate the development of new molecular diagnostic markers for the diseases.

Journey of a cystinuric patient with a long-term follow-up from a medical stone clinic: necessity to be SaFER (stone and fragments entirely removed)

There is a lack of studies looking at the longitudinal follow-up of patients with cystine stones. We wanted to assess the journey of cystinuric patients through our specialist metabolic stone clinic to improve the understanding of episodes, interventions and current outcomes in this patient cohort. After ethical approval, all patients who attended our metabolic stone clinic from 1994 to 2014 with at least one cystine stone episode were included in our study. Data were retrospectively analysed for patient demographics, stone episodes or intervention, clinical parameters and patient compliance. Over a period of 21 years, 16 patients with a median age of 15.5 years underwent a mean follow-up of 8.6 years (1–21 years). The mean number of surgical interventions was 3.1 (1–8/patient), but patients who were stone free after their first treatment had lower recurrences (p = 0.91) and lower number of interventions during their follow-up (2.7/patient, compared to those who were not stone free at 4/patient). During their follow-up period, patients with < 3 interventions had a significantly better renal function than those with ≥ 3 surgical interventions (p = 0.04). Additionally, linear regression analysis showed that eGFR was demonstrated to decline with increasing numbers of stone episodes (r² = 0.169). It was also noted that patients who began early medical management remained stone free during follow-up compared to those who had medical management after ≥ 2 stone episodes, of whom all had a recurrent episode. Our long-term longitudinal study of cystine stone formers highlights that patients who are stone free and receive early metabolic stone screening and medical management after their initial presentation have the lowest recurrence rates and tend to preserve their renal function. Hence, prompt referral for metabolic assessment, and the stone and fragments entirely removed (SaFER) principles are key to preventing stone episodes and improving long-term function.