Frequency of cardiac contusion in nonpenetrating chest injury

Diagnostic approach for myocardial contusion: a retrospective evaluation of patient data and review of the literature

Purpose

Myocardial contusion can be a life-threatening condition in patients who sustained blunt thoracic trauma. The diagnostic approach remains a subject of debate. The aim of this study was to determine the sensitivity and specificity of echocardiography, electrocardiography, troponins T and I (TnT and TnI), and creatine kinase muscle/brain (CK-MB) for identifying patients with a myocardial contusion following blunt thoracic trauma.

Methods

Sensitivity and specificity were first determined in a 10-year retrospective cohort study and second by a systematic literature review with meta-analysis.

Results

Of the 117 patients in the retrospective study, 44 (38%) were considered positive for myocardial contusion. Chest X-ray, chest CT scan, electrocardiograph, and echocardiography had poor sensitivity (< 15%) but good specificity (≥ 90%). Sensitivity to cardiac biomarkers measured at presentation ranged from 59% for TnT to 77% for hs-TnT, specificity ranged from 63% for CK-MB to 100% for TnT. The systematic literature review yielded 28 studies, with 14.5% out of 7242 patients reported as positive for myocardial contusion. The pooled sensitivity of electrocardiography, troponin I, and CK-MB was between 62 and 71%, versus only 45% for echocardiography and 38% for troponin T. The pooled specificity ranged from 63% for CK-MB to 85% for troponin T and 88% for echocardiography.

Conclusion

The best diagnostic approach for myocardial contusion is a combination of electrocardiography and measurement of cardiac biomarkers. If abnormalities are found, telemonitoring is necessary for the early detection of life-threatening arrhythmias. Chest X-ray and CT scan may show other thoracic injuries but provide no information on myocardial contusion.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s00068-020-01305-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Role of Transesophageal Echocardiography in Blunt Chest Trauma

Patients who suffer blunt chest trauma are at risk for injury to the heart, and the thoracic aorta and its branch vessels. Unrecognized injury to the heart or aorta may lead to life threatening complications. Therefore, the physician caring for the trauma patient must be able to accurately and rapidly diagnose cardiac and thoracic aortic injury. Transesophageal echocardiography is an ideal tool to diagnose cardiac and aortic injury in the patient with blunt chest trauma because it provides high quality images of the heart and thoracic aorta and can safely and rapidly be performed in the emergency department, operating suite or intensive care unit. To utilize transesophageal echocardiography most effectively, the echocardiographer must be familiar with the indications, limitations, and piffalls of transesophageal echocardiography in patients with blunt chesttrauma. This review describes the role of transesophageal echocardiography in evaluating the patient with blunt chest trauma for cardiac, thoracic aortic, and mediastinal injury.

Initial management and resuscitation of severe chest trauma

Severe chest trauma, blunt or penetrating, is responsible for up to 25% of traumatic deaths in North America. Respiratory compromise is the most frequent dramatic presentation in blunt trauma, while injuries to the heart and great vessels pose the greatest risk of immediate death following penetrating trauma. More than 80% of patients will be managed with interventions that can be performed in the emergency department. This article reviews the presentation, diagnosis, and management of the most important thoracic injuries. A structured approach to the acutely unstable patient is proposed to guide resuscitation decisions.

Blunt cardiac injury

In summary, the incidence of BCI following blunt thoracic trauma patients has been reported between 20% and 76%, and no gold standard exists to diagnose BCI. Diagnostic tests should be limited to identify those patients who are at risk of developing cardiac complications as a result of BCI. Therapeutic interventions should be directed to treat the complications of BCI. Finally, the prognosis and outcome of BCI patients is encouraging

Correlation of clinical characteristics and outcomes with injury scoring in blunt cardiac trauma

BACKGROUND

Clinical sequelae from blunt cardiac trauma (BCT) may range from minor electrocardiographic abnormalities to death from free-wall rupture. There are no established clinical characteristics or injury scoring systems that are able to predict survival in these patients.

METHODS

A retrospective review of medical records from a Level I trauma center identified 47 patients with BCT. A grade assigned on the basis of the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma Organ Injury Scale (OIS) was assigned to each case studied. Clinical data, including the Injury Severity Score (ISS), and outcomes were analyzed for association with OIS grade.

RESULTS

The average ISS was 27.9, and the overall mortality rate was 31.9%. The majority of patients were either grade II or IV, with the latter having the highest mortality. Hypotension at admission, cardiac arrest, lack of vital signs at admission, ISS, hours to diagnosis, and death all had significant association with assigned OIS grade. Factors associated with mortality included ISS; OIS grade; shorter time to diagnosis; cardiac tamponade; cardiac rupture; lack of vital signs at admission; and concomitant injury to either the thoracic aorta or to the liver, spleen, or kidneys.

CONCLUSION

The OIS grade, assigned on the basis of anatomic site of injury and electrocardiographic abnormalities, appears to correlate with severity of injury and survival. Although injury scoring should not be used exclusively to guide management in trauma patients, the grading system studied may be useful in predicting outcomes in patients with BCT.

Acute and long-term clinical significance of myocardial contusion following blunt thoracic trauma: results of a prospective study

BACKGROUND

The clinical significance of myocardial contusion (MC) following blunt thoracic trauma is still unknown. Accordingly, in this prospective study in a regional trauma center we investigated the acute and long-term clinical significance of MC.

METHODS

One-hundred eighteen patients with manifest or suspected blunt thoracic trauma were evaluated for cardiac injury. Initial assessment was based on results of electrocardiographic, echocardiographic, and serial enzyme measurements. A follow-up (FU) assessment conducted at 3 and 12 months, respectively, was performed using electrocardiography, echocardiography, and a bicycle ergometry exercise test.

RESULTS

Of the 118 patients in the total sample, 67 (56.8%) required admission to the surgical intensive care unit (SICU) because of the severity of their noncardiac injuries. Fourteen patients of the total sample (11.8%) were diagnosed with MC and 13 of these (92.9%) belonged to the intensive care admissions, thus representing an incidence of 19.4% in this patient group. During the hospitalization period none of the patients with MC experienced acute cardiac complications. Eighty-six patients (72.0%) were assessed at FU. No new pathologies were found except in one patient. Exercise testing revealed no ECG abnormalities and none of the patients experienced limitations on the bicycle ergometer due to a cardiac cause.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of 19.7% of MC in our patients with blunt chest injury requiring intensive care treatment indicates that this condition is frequent in polytraumatized patients. Outcome and prognosis in patients with MC is favorable and, thus, routine cardiac work-up is not indicated. Specific diagnostic and therapeutic measures should be limited to cases where cardiac complications develop.

Ventricular fibrillation in the patient with blunt trauma: not always exsanguination

Three cases of successful prehospital resuscitation of blunt trauma patients sustaining cardiac arrest resulting from ventricular fibrillation are reported. Although probably uncommon, ventricular fibrillation not caused by severe hypovolemia, exsanguination, or severe hypoxia in the setting of blunt trauma might be a treatable cause of cardiac arrest. Early electrocardiographic monitoring of patients with blunt trauma, including those with cardiac arrest, can detect this small, yet easily salvageable group of patients.

A meta-analysis of blunt cardiac trauma: ending myocardial confusion

The purpose of this study was to use a meta-analysis of the current literature to identify which patients with blunt cardiac trauma develop complications. All studies on myocardial contusion since 1967 were reviewed. Three separate meta-analyses were performed: one with only prospective studies, one with only retrospective studies, and one with all studies combined. Data on electrocardiogram (ECG), creatine phosphokinase-MB isoenzyme (CPK-MB), radionuclide scans, and echocardiogram were analyzed using the Mantel-Haenszel procedure. Results of the three meta-analyses were similar. Abnormal ECG and abnormal CPK-MB were found to correlate directly with complications requiring treatment. Conversely, normal ECG and CPK-MB correlated with the lack of clinically significant complications. Radionuclide scans did not correlate with complications. The results for echocardiogram were not congruent between the prospective and retrospective studies. The data support the use of ECG and CPK-MB in the diagnosis of clinically significant myocardial contusion. Radionuclide scanning is not useful in the evaluation of patients with blunt cardiac trauma. Further studies need to define the role of echocardiography.

Improved detection of cardiac contusion with cardiac troponin I

Detecting cardiac injury in patients with chest trauma is difficult because the level of the MB isoenzyme of creatine kinase (MBCK) can be elevated from skeletal muscle injury alone. However, the level of cardiac troponin I (cTnl) is not elevated by skeletal muscle injury. To determine whether its measurement would improve the ability to detect cardiac injury in patients with blunt chest trauma, 44 patients were studied. Serial echocardiograms and serial blood samples were obtained. Six patients had evidence of cardiac injury by echocardiography; all had elevations of MBCK and cTnl. One patient had elevations of both MBCK and cTnl with only a pericardial effusion. Twenty-six of the 37 patients without contusion had elevations of MBCK; none had elevations of cTnl. The ratio of MBCK to total creatine kinase improved specificity at the expense of sensitivity. Measurement of cTnl accurately detects cardiac injury in patients with blunt chest trauma and should facilitate the diagnosis and management of such patients.

Cardiac enzymes are irrelevant in the patient with suspected myocardial contusion

BACKGROUND

Myocardial contusion is commonly diagnosed following blunt chest trauma, and has potentially lethal complications. Cost-effective case management in patients with suspected myocardial contusion is confounded by the low incidence of complications and the lack of a reliable test to predict them. The clinical usefulness of elevated cardiac enzyme levels is controversial.

METHODS

We analyzed a 4-year experience of 359 patients with high-risk blunt chest trauma who were assessed using an established practice guideline. Our multivariate statistical model evaluated all of the early risk factors included in the guideline, specifically focusing on cardiac enzyme levels.

RESULTS

Myocardial contusion was diagnosed in 30% of patients, and complications (dysrhythmias and cardiogenic shock) occurred in 5%. In no case was cardiac enzyme elevation the sole predictor of a complication. The cost of routine cardiac enzyme assay was substantial.

CONCLUSION

Cardiac enzyme determinations have no useful role in the evaluation of patients with suspected myocardial contusion. They should be eliminated from current practice guidelines.

Trauma radiology: part II. Diagnostic imaging of thoracic trauma: review and update

Frontal chest radiographs are the principal diagnostic imaging study to detect, verify, or exclude acute thoracic injury after trauma, and they should be obtained as quickly as possible without compromising clinical assessment and resuscitation. Chest radiographs provide important information about potentially life-threatening conditions, such as tension pneumothorax, major hemothorax, and major arterial injury. In many patients, chest radiographs also provide helpful clues to the presence of such conditions as diaphragmatic rupture, pulmonary contusion/laceration, and tracheobronchial injury. In selected patients, computed tomography scans can supplement information provided by radiography, particularly for detection of mediastinal hemorrhage, aortic pseudoaneurysm, subtle pneumothorax, and delineation of complex pleuroparenchymal processes. On occasion, magnetic resonance imaging can be used to assess integrity of the hemidiaphragms and visceral herniation when other diagnostic studies are equivocal. We consider typical imaging findings associated with a variety of acute thoracic injuries, as well as the most appropriate use of available imaging techniques in different clinical scenarios.

[Role of isotopic imaging in intensive care]

The real place of isotopic imaging in intensive care patients remains still unclear. This review aimed to consider the indications of isotopic imaging for improved diagnosis and therapy and to specify its place among the other techniques of exploration. Pulmonary perfusion and ventilation scintigraphies are valuable for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism (PE). A "high probability" scintigraphy of the lungs ascertains the diagnosis of PE and allows to start a specific treatment without requiring a pulmonary angiography. This is not the case in the presence of a history of previous PE or if the arguments for a PE are only weak. A normal lung scintigraphy eliminates the diagnosis of a clinically significant PE all the more as an exploration of good quality of the lower limb veins remains negative. In the opposite a "non diagnostic" scintigraphy justifies a pulmonary angiography in intensive care patients. The diagnosis of myocardial contusion is made uneasy as the clinical symptoms, the ECG, the cardiac enzymes and the chest X-ray are only of limited value. Isotopic explorations of the heart could provide additional valuable data or be an alternative for 2 D echocardiography. The comparison of CPK-MB concentrations with a myocardial scintigraphy using thallium 201 is given as being very reliable, with positive and negative predictive values higher than 80%. An exploration restricted to the cardiac ejection fractions is only of limited value. In the future, an improvement will perhaps be obtained with tracers such as MIBI labelled with technetium 99m, which allow the simultaneous assessment of myocardial perfusion and the ventricular ejection fractions as well. The localisation of centres of infection, especially when intra-abdominal, remains difficult in intensive care patients. Isotopic imaging, especially the scintigraphies with labelled polynuclears, could allow in combination with conventional imaging techniques (computed tomography and 2 D echocardiography) to prevent from errors in diagnosis. An array of arguments is essential for ascertaining the presence of an abscess. Scintigraphies with leucocytes labelled with indium 111 or technetium 99m are qualified as having a sensitivity and a specificity greater than 90%. The conventional techniques of measurement of the cerebral blood flow (CBF) using xenon 133 require a special equipment or are invasive. Other cerebral tracers, such as cyclic amines (HMPAO) labelled with technetium 99m and administrable by i.v. route, allow the use of a standard tomo-gamma camera, and could be of help in various pathological conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Severe right ventricular contusion mimicking cardiac tamponade: the value of transesophageal echocardiography in blunt chest trauma

Clinically, severe right ventricular contusion may mimic cardiac tamponade. We report two cases of suspected cardiac tamponade after blunt chest trauma in which the diagnosis of severe right ventricular contusion was made only by transesophageal echocardiography, avoiding unnecessary and hazardous pericardiocentesis. These cases illustrate the value of transesophageal echocardiography in diagnosing blunt chest trauma.

Sternal fracture: what investigations are indicated?

A retrospective study of 55 patients with sternal fractures is presented in an attempt to determine which investigations are predictive of complications. We conclude that isolated sternal fractures, in the absence of clinical evidence of cardiac or respiratory complications, and with a normal electrocardiogram and postero-anterior chest radiograph, require no further investigation.

Focal myocardial injury following blunt chest trauma: a comparison of indium-111 antimyosin scintigraphy with other noninvasive methods

The diagnosis of myocardial contusion is often difficult, as traditional methods such as serial electrocardiograms, cardiac enzyme (creatine kinase [CK-MB]) analysis, and echocardiography lack sensitivity and specificity. Recent reports have shown that 111In labelled antimyosin scanning has high sensitivity for detecting cardiac injury. However, no prior studies have been reported for antimyosin imaging with patients suspected of sustaining a cardiac contusion. Accordingly, 17 patients with severe multisystem trauma (intrathoracic vascular injury in eight patients, pneumothorax and pulmonary contusion in 13) underwent antimyosin scintigraphy, echocardiography, 12-lead electrocardiograms, and CK-MB determinations. Arrhythmias were noted in seven patients, four of whom died. All patients has elevated CK levels but CK-MB isoenzyme was greater than 4% in only three. Abnormal ST segments were noted in nine subjects, only one of whom had CK-MB elevation. Echocardiography revealed pericardial effusions in four patients but was technically suboptimal in 53% of the studies. Blinded interpretation of the antimyosin scans revealed only one with focal myocardial uptake; this same patient had the only discrete wall motion abnormality on the echocardiogram and also had ST depression with ectopy but normal CK-MB. Thus in patients with suspected myocardial contusion, echocardiography is frequently limited technically and the electrocardiogram and CK analysis appear to lack diagnostic accuracy. In contrast, monoclonal antimyosin imaging may be performed in patients with trauma without limitation and yields results that are concordant with echocardiograms. In patients with suspected myocardial contusion, focal antimyosin uptake is uncommon despite severe thoracic injury, which suggests that extensive myocardial necrosis is not the primary method of injury.

A rational screening and treatment strategy based on the electrocardiogram alone for suspected cardiac contusion

The charts of 71 patients admitted to one teaching institution over a 4-year period with a primary or secondary diagnosis of "rule out cardiac contusion" and of another 62 admitted to a second institution with more severe injuries and suspicion of cardiac contusion were reviewed to determine if mortality or morbidity would have occurred if all patients with normal electrocardiograms (EKGs) in the emergency department (ED) were discharged (or admitted to unmonitored beds for other injuries). Only 13 patients developed cardiac problems: two elderly patients died in the ED, while the others experienced arrhythmias or, less commonly, pump failure requiring treatment or observation. All 13 had EKG changes present while still undergoing evaluation in the ED: 11 had a specific problem on arrival, 1 developed a problem while still being evaluated in the ED, and the 13th had what was probably an iatrogenic problem. Importantly, 5 of 12 patients had normal creatine phosphokinase-MB fractions, and 5 of 9 had normal echocardiograms. No patient with a normal EKG had subsequent cardiac problems. Operative intervention for other injuries was necessary in 26 patients overall, and there was no cardiac morbidity. We conclude that had the EKG been used as the sole screening tool, approximately 25% of these patients could have been discharged from the ED without missing problems. In addition, management would have been greatly simplified, and the hospital would have realized substantial savings, both in terms of direct costs and in the freeing of valuable and scarce resources.

Suspected myocardial contusion. Triage and indications for monitoring

Although many different tests are used to diagnose myocardial contusion, the clinical implications of the diagnosis are unclear. This makes it difficult to decide which patients require admission to a monitored bed. During 16 months, 3010 patients with blunt trauma were reviewed for evidence of sequelae attributable to myocardial contusion. None of 2204 admissions to unmonitored beds had evidence of serious arrhythmias or heart failure. No patient who died after admission had myocardial contusion at autopsy. Of the 644 admissions to monitored beds, 95 had workups for suspected contusion. Heart failure not obvious on admission did not occur and there were only four arrhythmias that required treatment. Conduction abnormalities on admission electrocardiogram predicted serious arrhythmias. Echocardiography and creatine phosphokinase isoenzyme levels, although frequently positive, did not predict morbidity. Clinically significant myocardial contusions are rare. Patients who will develop life-threatening complications from blunt cardiac injury can be identified in an emergency room setting.

Advanced techniques in thoracic trauma

Technologic aid is available for the three central problems of hemorrhage, lung damage, and cardiac damage. Autotransfusion, new modes of ventilator support, extracorporeal oxygenation, balloon pumping, and left ventricular assist are available for the trauma patient. The author explains these new devices and their role in thoracic trauma cases.