Surgical management of thrombotic disc valve

Thrombolytic therapy or surgery for valve prosthesis thrombosis: systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Prosthetic heart valve thrombosis is a life-threatening condition for which treatment has not been evaluated by randomized trials.

OBJECTIVES

To compare surgery with thrombolytic therapy for the treatment of prosthetic valve thrombosis.

METHODS

A comprehensive systematic review was carried out by independent researchers using PubMed, Web of Knowledge, HINARI, LILACS and EMBASE, including papers indexed up to 23 October 2013 with at least 10 patients, evaluating one or both treatment options. Outcomes of interest were death, stroke, bleeding, embolic events and success. Study quality was assessed by the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (ranges from 0 to 9). Comprehensive Meta Analysis Software was used to pool study results, for publication bias analysis and for meta-regression.

RESULTS

Forty-eight studies were included (2302 patients). No randomized study was identified, and all were observational in design. Study quality varied from 4 to 6 stars using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. Mortality for surgery was 18.1% (95%CI, 14.6-22.1; I(2) , 62% [42-75]), while mortality for thrombolytic therapy was 6.6% (95% CI, 4.8-8.9; I(2) , 0% [0-13]). Surgical mortality appeared to increase with NYHA-class, according to meta-regression. Other results related to surgery and thrombolytic therapy, respectively, were: embolic events, 4.6% (2.9-7.3) and 12.8% (10.8-15.2); stroke, 4.3%,(2.7-6.6%) and 5.6%,(4.3-7.4%); success rate, 81.9% (77.2-85.8) and 80.7% (75.6-85.0); bleeding, 4.6% (2.9-7.1) and 6.8% (5.4-8.6); and death or stroke, 19.0% (14.8-24.2) and 11.4% (8.7-14.7).

CONCLUSION

Mortality in patients treated by thrombolytic therapy for valve prosthesis thrombosis is significantly lower than in patients treated surgically. As we cannot yet ascertain whether this difference is due to the treatment alone, more studies are now necessary to further clarify these findings.

Surgical management of mechanical valve thrombosis: twenty-six years' experience

In the present study, the authors investigated the management of mechanical valve thrombosis (MVT). From January 1981 through March 2006, 2,908 mechanical valve replacements were performed in 2,298 patients at our institution. Twenty (0.87%) patients presented with MVT, 14 (70.0%) were women, and the mean age of the patients was 42.0+/-14.0 (27-66) yr. Thrombosis involved mitral in 14 (70.0%), aortic in 2 (10.0%), tricuspid/aortic in 1 (5%), and tricuspid in 3 (15%). The interval from first operation to valve thrombosis was 121.8+/-75.4 (0.9-284.7) months. The most frequent clinical presentation was heart failure (13/20, 65%), and predisposing causes of MVT were: poor compliance with warfarin (7), pregnancy (5), drug interaction (2), and unknown (6). All 20 patients underwent valve replacement: mitral (14, 70.0%), tricuspid (3, 15.0%), aortic (2, 10%) and tricuspid/aortic (1, 5%). One early death occurred due to left ventricular failure, but no late mortality occurred during 63.3+/-49.9 (0.5-165.1) months of follow-up. MVT was treated successfully, and pregnancy and inadequate anticoagulation were found to influence the occurrence of this rare complication.

The blower: a useful tool to complete thrombectomy of the mechanical prosthetic valve

Thrombectomy could be an excellent approach on one condition (ie, that all parts of the thrombus are removed). We propose to use a tool (ie, the blower) to complete thrombectomy of the prosthetic mechanical valve. The blower is a vaporizer that mixes air and heparinized saline with regulator of flow and proportion used in beating heart surgery. For thrombectomy, we have modified the air-water mixing part and intensity until we obtained a jet that enabled us to remove the micro thrombus that covered the prosthetic valve and surrounding tissues. The blower completely cleaned the prosthetic valve. With this tool, thrombectomy seems easier, more complete, and more reliable with the advantages of short cross-clamping time.

Prosthetic valve thrombosis: twenty-year experience at the montreal heart institute

BACKGROUND

Prosthetic valve thrombosis is a life-threatening complication. We reviewed the incidence, risk factors, and treatment strategies of this rare complication.

METHODS

From February 1981 through January 2001, 5430 valve operations were performed in 4924 patients at the Montreal Heart Institute. Of this cohort, 39 patients presented with prosthetic valve thrombosis and had complete follow-up data obtained from our prospective valve clinic database.

RESULTS

In this series 82% of patients were women, and the mean age was 58 +/- 11 years. The underlying pathology involved the mitral valve in 75% of cases. Most prosthetic valve thromboses occurred with mechanical prostheses (95%). The time interval from first valve replacement to prosthetic valve thrombosis was 39 +/- 42 months. The most frequent clinical presentation was severe congestive heart failure (44%). On prosthetic valve thrombosis presentation, the international normalized ratio was less than 2.5 in 54%, with inadequate anticoagulation management in 26% and poor compliance in 26%. Eighty-two percent of patients underwent a surgical procedure, consisting of thrombectomy in 47%, mitral valve replacement in 47%, and aortic valve replacement in 6% of patients. The 30-day operative mortality and total in-hospital mortality after prosthetic valve thrombosis were 25% and 41%, respectively. The 10-year actuarial survival after prosthetic valve thrombosis was 46% +/- 10%.

CONCLUSION

Inadequate level of anticoagulation is the most important factor involved in the pathogenesis of prosthetic valve thrombosis. The overall mortality rate despite surgical treatment remains high. This study underscores the importance of meticulous surveillance of anticoagulation therapy in patients with prosthetic valves.

Cardiopulmonary bypass before general anesthesia in prosthetic valve thrombosis

Valve obstruction is a lifethreatening complication of mechanical valve prostheses. Emergency operation is mandatory for patients who subsequently develop cardiogenic shock and severe pulmonary edema. In this severely compromised hemodynamic condition, cardiac arrest develops in most of the patients before surgery and just after general anesthesia induction. In one such case, we performed femorofemoral cardiopulmonary bypass with local anesthesia before general anesthesia induction and successfully replaced the thrombosed prosthetic valve, thus avoiding a catastrophic outcome.

[Prosthetic valve thrombosis: which is the most appropriate initial therapy?]

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

This study aims to investigate what is the best initial therapy for patients with obstructive prosthetic valve thrombosis.

METHODS

Data from 47 patients diagnosed with prosthetic valve thrombosis in two tertiary hospitals during an 8-years period were analyzed.

RESULTS

The involved prostheses were in mitral position in 34 cases (2 biological valves), in aortic position in 12, and in double mitral and aortic position in one. The thrombosis was not obstructive in 12 patients. In the remaining 35 patients, the prosthetic obstruction was treated by heparin (n = 2), thrombolysis (n = 19), or direct surgery (n = 14). There was no mortality in the thrombolytic group, although 6 patients needed surgery before discharge because of an abnormal prosthetic residual gradient (n = 5) or a persisting abnormal disc valve motion (n = 1). Five out of 14 patients of direct surgery died, 2 before the planned operation could be performed. Thus, mortality rate, in an intention to treat analysis, was very favourable to thrombolytic therapy (p = 0.008); and this, despite the higher index of clinical severity (on a scale from 0 to 4) was superior in this group of thrombolyzed patients: 3.3 0.6 vs. 2.1 0.9 in those who underwent surgery; p < 0.0001.

CONCLUSIONS

In terms of mortality rate, thrombolysis is a better alternative than direct surgery to fight against obstructive prosthetic valve thrombosis. Even if the result is suboptimal, it allows the performance of surgery in better clinical conditions and, thus, with minor risk.

Hemodynamic stabilization of acute prosthetic valve thrombosis using percutaneous catheter manipulation

Thrombosis of a tilting-disk prosthetic heart valve can be an acute and potentially life-threatening problem. Surgical thrombectomy, valve replacement, or systemic thrombolytic agents have been successfully employed in the management of such cases. Some patients, however, may not survive the acute episode long enough to receive definitive surgical therapy. For such patients, temporary hemodynamic stabilization might be achieved by re-establishing partial valve disk mobility. This report describes a technique for re-establishing valve disk mobility in an acutely compromised patient by using a percutaneously introduced "rigid" catheter to manipulate an entrapped tilting-disk valve in the aortic position.

Video-assisted mitral valve operations

BACKGROUND

Video-assisted endoscopy has been applied frequently in the management of a variety of surgical diseases. However, it has rarely been applied in mitral valve surgery.

METHODS

We report 2 patients who received emergency operations for thrombosis of a mitral prosthesis (patient 1, a 68-year-old man) and acute mitral regurgitation due to rupture of anterior chordae (patient 2, a 75-year-old woman). They both had severe congestive heart failure. Cardiogenic shock was noted in patient 2. The mitral valve was approached through a right anterior minithoracotomy with the aid of an endoscope by means of projected images on the video monitor under femorofemoral cardiopulmonary bypass. The aorta was not cross-clamped, and the myocardium was protected by continuous coronary perfusion with hypothermic fibrillatory arrest. The left atrium was entered posterior to the interatrial groove. Thrombectomy and mitral valve repair were performed successfully.

RESULTS

The duration of extracorporeal circulation was 204 and 147 minutes, respectively. Both patients recovered from the operation rapidly with uneventful postoperative courses.

CONCLUSIONS

Our preliminary results suggest that video-assisted endoscopic cardiac surgery is technically feasible and could be performed in the milieu of open heart surgery.

Reoperation in biological and mechanical valve populations: fate of the reoperative patient

From 1975 through 1992 inclusive, reoperative valve replacement (REOP) was required by 12.9% of patients (708/5,499). Of 1,355 patients with mechanical prostheses (MP), 46 (3.4%) came to REOP versus 662 of 4,144 patients (16%) with biological prostheses (BP). Early REOP mortality rate was 17.4% (8/46) for MP and 10.6% (70/662) for BP (p = not significant). It was higher with age greater than 75 years (p < 0.05) and trended higher with concomitant procedures and with increasing number of REOPs (p = not significant). The percentage freedom from REOP at 5 and 10 years for all BP was 96.0% +/- 0.4% and 74.9% +/- 1.1% compared with 93.6% +/- 1.2% and 87.9% +/- 2.5% for MP. The most common cause of REOP in the BP patients was structural valve deterioration, which was uncommon in patients with MP (72% versus 2% of REOP but only 15% versus 0.1% of initial implants). Nonstructural dysfunction was the leading cause of REOP in the MP group (65% versus 11%). Prosthetic valve endocarditis (18% versus 10%) and thromboembolic complications (10% versus 1%) were also more frequent causes of REOP in MP patients. However, the increased relative role of these factors with MP is due to the minimal incidence of structural valve deterioration. When related to the original choice of MP versus BP, only thromboembolic complication (3.8 times) was more prevalent as a cause of REOP in patients receiving MP at their previous procedure (p = not significant). For patients who previously received BP, structural valve deterioration (69 times) was more likely to lead to REOP than with MP (p < 0.01).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Detection of acute thrombosis of mitral tilting disk prosthesis by transesophageal echocardiography

Acute thrombosis is a very severe complication in the replacement of mechanical prostheses and most often fatal if immediate treatment is not implemented. We describe a case in which an acute thrombosis of a mitral tilting disk prosthesis was adequately diagnosed by transesophageal echocardiography and immediate surgical replacement of the dysfunctioning device was possible without catheterizing the patient.