Interactive effects of ZnO nanoparticles and temperature on molecular and cellular stress responses of the blue mussel Mytilus edulis

Exposure to nanopollutants (nZnO) enhances the negative effects of hypoxia and delays recovery of the mussels' immune system

Aquatic environments face escalating challenges from multiple stressors like hypoxia and nanoparticle exposure, with impact of these combined stressors on mussel immunity being poorly understood. We investigated the individual and combined effects of short-term and long-term hypoxia and exposure to zinc oxide nanoparticles (nZnO) on immune system of the mussels (Mytilus edulis). Hemocyte functional traits (mortality, adhesion capacity, phagocytosis, lysosomal abundance, and oxidative burst), and transcript levels of immune-related genes involved in pathogen recognition (the Toll-like receptors, the complement system components, and the adaptor proteins MyD88) were assessed. Short-term hypoxia minimally affected hemocyte parameters, while prolonged exposure led to immunosuppression, impacting hemocyte abundance, viability, phagocytosis, and defensin gene expression. Under normoxia, nZnO stimulated immune responses of mussel hemocytes. However, combined nZnO and hypoxia induced more pronounced and rapid immunosuppression than hypoxia alone, indicating a synergistic interaction. nZnO exposure hindered immune parameter recovery during post-hypoxic reoxygenation, suggesting persistent impact. Opposing trends were observed in pathogen-sensing and pathogen-elimination mechanisms, with a positive correlation between pathogen-recognition system activation and hemocyte mortality. These findings underscore a complex relationship and potential conflict between pathogen-recognition ability, immune function, and cell survival in mussel hemocytes under hypoxia and nanopollutant stress, and emphasize the importance of considering multiple stressors in assessing the vulnerability and adaptability of mussel immune system under complex environmental conditions of anthropogenically modified coastal ecosystems.

Combined effects of organic and mineral UV-filters on the lugworm Arenicola marina

Pollution from personal care products, such as UV-filters like avobenzone and nano-zinc oxide (nZnO), poses a growing threat to marine ecosystems. To better understand this hazard, especially for lesser-studied sediment-dwelling marine organisms, we investigated the physiological impacts of simultaneous exposure to nZnO and avobenzone on the lugworm Arenicola marina. Lugworms were exposed to nZnO, avobenzone, or their combination for three weeks. We assessed pollutant-induced metabolic changes by measuring key metabolic intermediates in the body wall and coelomic fluid, and oxidative stress by analyzing antioxidant levels and oxidative lesions in proteins and lipids of the body wall. Exposure to UV filters resulted in shifts in the concentrations of Krebs' cycle and urea cycle intermediates, as well as alterations in certain amino acids in the body wall and coelomic fluid of the lugworms. Pathway enrichment analyses revealed that nZnO induced more pronounced metabolic shifts compared to avobenzone or their combination. Exposure to avobenzone or nZnO alone prompted an increase in tissue antioxidant capacity, indicating a compensatory response to restore redox balance, which effectively prevented oxidative damage to proteins or lipids. However, co-exposure to nZnO and avobenzone suppressed superoxide dismutase and lead to accumulation of lipid peroxides and methionine sulfoxide, indicating oxidative stress and damage to lipids and proteins. Our findings highlight oxidative stress as a significant mechanism of toxicity for both nZnO and avobenzone, especially when combined, and underscores the importance of further investigating the fitness implications of oxidative stress induced by these common UV filters in benthic marine organisms.

Ecotoxicity of doped zinc oxide nanoparticles: Perspectives on environmental safety

Studies on the ecotoxicity of doped zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs) are recent, with the first publications starting in 2010. In this sense, this is the first study that comprehensively reviews the ecotoxicological effects of ZnO NPs doped with lanthanide elements to fill this literature gap. This research explores a multifaceted question at the intersection of nanotechnology, toxicology, and environmental science. Different types of dopants commonly used for ZnO doping were investigated in this review, focusing on the ecotoxicological effects of lanthanides as dopants. Bacteria were the main class of organisms used in ecotoxicological studies, since antimicrobial activity of these nanomaterials is extensively explored to combat the imminent problem of resistant bacteria, in addition to enabling the safe use of these nanomaterials for biomedical applications. Doping appears to exhibit greater efficacy when compared to undoped ZnO NPs in terms of antimicrobial effects; however, it cannot be said that it has no impact on non-target organisms. An extensive examination of the literature also establishes the importance and need to evaluate the effects of doped ZnO NPs on organisms from different environmental compartments in order to identify their potential impacts. We underscore the dearth of research information regarding the environmental toxicity/ecotoxicity of doped ZnO nanoparticles across various ecological levels, thereby limiting the extrapolation of findings to humans or other complex models. Therefore, we emphasize the urgency of a multi-parameter assessment for the development of sanitary and environmentally safe nanotechnologies.

Effects of elevated temperature and different crystal structures of TiO2 nanoparticles on the gut microbiota of mussel Mytilus coruscus

Coastal habitats are exposed to increasing pressure of nanopollutants commonly combined with warming due to the seasonal temperature cycles and global climate change. To investigate the toxicological effects of TiO2 nanoparticles (TiO2 NPs) and elevated temperature on the intestinal health of the mussels (Mytilus coruscus), the mussels were exposed to 0.1 mg/L TiO2 NPs with different crystal structures for 14 days at 20 °C and 28 °C, respectively. Compared to 20 °C, the agglomeration of TiO2 NPs was more serious at 28 °C. Exposure to TiO2 NPs led to elevated mortality of M. coruscus and modified the intestinal microbial community as shown by 16S rRNA sequence analysis. Exposure to TiO2 NPs changed the relative abundance of Bacteroidetes, Proteobacteria and Firmicutes. The relative abundances of putative mutualistic symbionts Tenericutes and Fusobacteria increased in the gut of M. coruscus exposed to anatase, which have contributed to the lower mortality in this group. LEfSe showed the combined stress of warming and TiO2 NPs increased the risk of M. coruscus being infected with potential pathogenic bacteria. This study emphasizes the toxicity differences between crystal structures of TiO2 NPs, and will provides an important reference for analyzing the physiological and ecological effects of nanomaterial pollution on bivalves under the background of global climate change.

Ecotoxicological effects of zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO-NPs) on aquatic organisms: Current research and emerging trends

The rapid advancement of nanotechnology has contributed to the development of several products that are being released to the consumer market without careful analysis of their potential impact on the environment. Zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO-NPs) are used in several fields and are applied in consumer products, technological innovations, and biomedicine. In this sense, this study aims to compile existing knowledge regarding the effects of ZnO-NPs on non-target organisms, with the goal of ensuring the safety of human health and the environment. To achieve this objective, a systematic review of the available data on the toxicity of these nanomaterials to freshwater and marine/estuarine aquatic organisms was carried out. The findings indicate that freshwater invertebrates are the most commonly used organisms in ecotoxicological tests. The environmental sensitivity of the studied species was categorized as follows: invertebrates > bacteria > algae > vertebrates. Among the most sensitive species at each trophic level in freshwater and marine/estuarine environments are Daphnia magna and Paracentrotus lividus; Escherichia coli and Vibrio fischeri; Scenedesmus obliquus and Isochrysis galbana; and Danio rerio and Rutilus caspicus. The primary mechanisms responsible for the toxicity of ZnO-NPs involve the release of Zn2+ ions and the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Thus, the biosynthesis of ZnO-NPs has been presented as a less toxic form of production, although it requires further investigation. Therefore, the synthesis of the information presented in this review can help to decide which organisms and which exposure concentrations are suitable for estimating the toxicity of nanomaterials in aquatic ecosystems. It is expected that this information will serve as a foundation for future research aimed at reducing the reliance on animals in ecotoxicological testing, aligning with the goal of promoting the sustainable advancement of nanotechnology.

Intrinsic and extrinsic pathways of apoptosis induced by multiple antibiotics residues and ocean acidification in hemocytes of scallop Argopecten irradians irradians: An interactionist perspective

The increasing prevalence of antibiotics in seawater across global coastal areas, coupled with the ocean acidification induced by climate change, present a multifaceted challenge to marine ecosystems, particularly impacting the key physiological processes of marine organisms. Apoptosis is a critical adaptive response essential for maintaining cellular homeostasis and defending against environmental threats. In this study, bay scallops Argopecten irradians irradians were exposed to multiple antibiotics (sulfamethoxazole, tetracycline, oxytetracycline, norfloxacin, and erythromycin, each at a concentration of 1 μg/L) combined with/without acidic seawater (pH 7.6) for 35 days. The single and interactive effects of the two stressors on apoptosis and the underlying mechanisms in hemocytes of A. irradians irradians were determined through flow cytometry analysis, comet assay, oxidative stress biomarkers analysis, and transcriptome analysis. Results showed that apoptosis could be triggered by either AM exposure or OA exposure, but through different pathways. Exposure to AM leads to mitochondrial dysfunction and oxidative damage, which in turn triggers apoptosis via a series of cellular events in both intrinsic and extrinsic pathways. Conversely, while OA exposure similarly induced apoptosis, its effects are comparatively subdued and are predominantly mediated through the intrinsic pathway. Additionally, the synergistic effects of AM and OA exposure induced pronounced mitochondrial dysfunction and oxidative damages in the hemocytes of A. irradians irradians. Despite the evident cellular distress and the potential initiation of apoptotic pathways, the actual execution of apoptosis appears to be restrained, which might be attributed to an energy deficit within the hemocytes. Our findings underscore the constrained tolerance capacity of A. irradians irradians when faced with multiple environmental stressors, and shed light on the ecotoxicity of antibiotic pollution in the ocean under prospective climate change scenarios.

Compensatory response of Hong Kong oysters to co-occurring stressors: Zinc oxide nanoparticles and low salinity exposure

Zinc Oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs), due to their ubiquitous use in industrial and consumer applications, present potential risks to marine ecosystems and biota, especially oysters. The physiological and immunological health of marine species is highly dependent on salinity levels. However, the combined impact of lowered salinity and exposure to ZnO NPs, particularly on key marine species like oysters, is an area that requires more research. Our study aimed to examine these concurrent stressors' impacts on phenotypic markers, gill and hepatopancreas physiological indices, and hemocyte immune parameters of Crassostrea hongkongensis. We subjected six oyster cohorts to varied ZnO NPs concentrations and salinity levels over 21 days. Our findings reveal that individual exposure to ZnO NPs or diminished salinity disrupts oyster physiology, impacting metabolism, antioxidant capacity, immune response, and energy distribution through distinct mechanisms. Remarkably, low salinity constituted a more significant threat than isolated ZnO NPs. However, when confronted with combined stressors, oysters exhibited a compensatory response, attenuating individual stressors' detrimental effects. This adaptation was characterised by reduced apoptosis rates, increased calcium ion concentration in mature hemocytes, and a restoration of conditioned indices, hepatopancreas alkaline phosphatase, and gill catalase activity to baseline levels. Principal Component Analysis and Integrated Biomarker Responses validated this compensatory phenomenon. Partial Least Squares Pathway Model analysis underscored these stressors' profound implications on oyster health, primarily driven by stressor exposure rather than mere zinc concentrations, despite acknowledging zinc's immunosuppressive impact on oyster immunity. Our research emphasises the importance of assessing multiple stressors' cumulative effects on aquatic species' ecological resilience, accentuating the need for comprehensive analyses incorporating functional specificity among diverse organs and immune components, including gill, hepatopancreas, and the critical hemocytes.

Insights into the Response in Digestive Gland of Mytilus coruscus under Heat Stress Using TMT-Based Proteomics

Ocean warming can cause injury and death in mussels and is believed to be one of the main reasons for extensive die-offs of mussel populations worldwide. However, the biological processes by which mussels respond to heat stress are still unclear. In this study, we conducted an analysis of enzyme activity and TMT-labelled based proteomic in the digestive gland tissue of Mytilus coruscus after exposure to high temperatures. Our results showed that the activities of superoxide dismutase, acid phosphatase, lactate dehydrogenase, and cellular content of lysozyme were significantly changed in response to heat stress. Furthermore, many differentially expressed proteins involved in nutrient digestion and absorption, p53, MAPK, apoptosis, and energy metabolism were activated post-heat stress. These results suggest that M. coruscus can respond to heat stress through the antioxidant system, the immune system, and anaerobic respiration. Additionally, M. coruscus may use fat, leucine, and isoleucine to meet energy requirements under high temperature stress via the TCA cycle pathway. These findings provide a useful reference for further exploration of the response mechanism to heat stress in marine mollusks.

Effects of nanoplastics on clam Ruditapes philippinarum at environmentally realistic concentrations: Toxicokinetics, toxicity, and gut microbiota

Nanoplastics are ubiquitous in marine environments, understanding to what extent nanoplastics accumulate in bivalves and the adverse effects derived from their retention is imperative for evaluating the detrimental effects in the benthic ecosystem. Here, using palladium-doped polystyrene nanoplastics (139.5 nm, 43.8 mV), we quantitatively determined nanoplastic accumulation in Ruditapes philippinarum and investigated its toxic effects by combining physiological damage assessments with a toxicokinetic model and 16 S rRNA sequencing. After a 14 days exposure, significant nanoplastic accumulation was observed, up to 17.2 and 137.9 mg·kg^-1 for the environmentally realistic (0.02 mg·L^-1) and ecologically (2 mg·L^-1) relevant groups, respectively. Ecologically relevant nanoplastic concentrations evidently attenuated the total antioxidant capacity and stimulated excessive reactive oxygen species, which elicited lipid peroxidation, apoptosis, and pathological damage. The modeled uptake (k₁) and elimination (k₂) rate constants (from physiologically based pharmacokinetic model) were significantly negatively correlated with short-term toxicity. Although no obvious toxic effects were found, environmentally realistic exposures notably altered the intestinal microbial community structure. This work increases our understanding of how the accumulation of nanoplastics influences their toxic effects in terms of the toxicokinetics and gut microbiota, providing further evidence of their potential environmental risks.

Changes in energy reserves and responses of some biomarkers in freshwater mussels exposed to metal-oxide nanoparticles

In this study, responses of various biomarkers in the digestive gland and foot muscle of freshwater mussels (Unio tigridis) were investigated following exposure to Al₂O₃, CuO and TiO₂ nanoparticles (NPs) for 14 days at different concentrations (0, 1, 3 and 9 mg NP/L). Mussels were fed on unicellular algae (Chlorella vulgaris) cultured in the laboratory. NP exposures caused significant increases (p < 0.05) in the levels of total glutathione (GSH), reduced-glutathione (rGSH), oxidized-glutathione (GSSG) and malondialdehyde (MDA) in the digestive gland. Oppositely, there were significant (p < 0.05) decreases in acetylcholinesterase activity in the foot muscles. Total energy reserves of the digestive gland and foot muscle significantly (p < 0.05) decreased, but only at the highest NP exposures. Nevertheless, NP exposures did not alter (p > 0.05) the algae filtering capacity of mussels. This study demonstrated that the biomarkers belonging to different metabolic systems responded to NP exposures, suggesting their usage in the monitoring studies for freshwater systems.

Metabolomics-based assessment of nanoparticles (nZnO) toxicity in an infaunal marine annelid, the lugworm Arenicola marina (Annelida: Sedentaria)

Nanopollutants such as nZnO gain importance as contaminants of emerging concern due to their high production volume and potential toxicity. Coastal sediments serve as sinks for nanoparticles but the impacts and the toxicity mechanisms of nZnO in sediment-dwelling organisms are not well understood. We used metabolomics to assess the effects of nZnO-contaminated sediments on a benthic ecosystem engineer, an infaunal polychaete Arenicola marina. The worms were exposed to unpolluted (control) sediment or to the sediment spiked with 100 or 1000 μg Zn kg^-1 of nZnO. Oxidative lesions (lipid peroxidation and protein carbonyls) were measured in the body wall as traditional biomarkers of nanopollutant toxicity. Metabolite profiles (including amino acids, tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle and urea cycle intermediates) were determined in the body wall and the coelomic fluid. Exposure to nZnO altered metabolism of the lugworms via suppression of the metabolism of gluconeogenic and aromatic amino acids, and altered the TCA cycle likely via suppression of fumarase activity. These metabolic changes may negatively affect carbohydrate metabolism and energy storage, and impair hormonal signaling in the worms. The total pool of free amino acids was depleted in nZnO exposures with potentially negative consequences for osmoregulation and protein synthesis. Exposure to nZnO led to accumulation of the lipid peroxidation products demonstrating high susceptibility of the cellular membranes to nZnO-induced oxidative stress. The nZnO-induced shifts in the metabolite profiles were more pronounced in the coelomic fluid than the body wall. This finding emphasizes the important metabolic role of the coelomic fluid as well as its suitability for assessing the toxic impacts of nZnO and other metabolic disruptors. The metabolic disruptions caused by environmentally relevant concentrations of nZnO can have negative effects on the organisms' fitness impairing growth and reproduction of the populations of marine bioturbators like the lugworms in nanoparticle-polluted sediments.

Salinity variation modulates cellular stress response to ZnO nanoparticles in a sentinel marine bivalve, the blue mussel Mytilussp

Zinc oxide nanoparticles are released into marine environments from industrial, medical and consumer uses sparking concerns about their potential ecotoxicological effects. Ecological hazard assessment of nZnO in marine ecosystems is hindered by the lack of understanding of the potential interactive effects of nZnO toxicity with other common abiotic stressors, such as salinity fluctuations, in marine organisms. To close this gap in our knowledge, we carried out a comprehensive biomarker-based assessment of the combined effects of salinity and nZnO in a sentinel marine bivalve, the blue mussels Mytilus edulis. The mussels were exposed for 21 days to clean seawater (control), an environmentally relevant concentration (100 μg Zn l^-1) of nZnO or dissolved Zn (to identify the toxic effects attributable to Zn²⁺ toxicity) under the normal (15), low (5) and fluctuating (5-15) salinity regimes. The selected molecular and biochemical markers focused on the oxidative stress, apoptosis, detoxification system and inflammation in the gills and the digestive gland of the mussels. Biomarker analysis showed different effects of nZnO and dissolved Zn on biomarkers of oxidative stress, xenobiotic detoxification and apoptosis but similar effects of both pollutants on the levels of metallothioneins and inflammatory markers. Exposure to nZnO led to elevated levels of lipid peroxidation, upregulation of p53 and p38 stress kinases and apoptosis-related genes, most notably in the gills. Exposure to dissolved Zn led to accumulation of protein carbonyls and activated redox-sensitive detoxification enzymes (NADPH-P450 reductase and glutathione-S-transferase) in the mussels. The ambient salinity had significant effects the cellular adverse effects of nZnO in the mussels. The nZnO-induced cellular stress was detectable under the normal (15) and fluctuating (5-15) salinity conditions in the studied brackish water population of the mussels. At low salinity (5), nZnO toxicity signal was almost completely dampened. These findings indicate that chronic osmotic stress close to the tolerance limits of M. edulis prevails over the effects of the environmentally relevant nZnO and dissolved Zn concentrations in combined exposures. These stressor interactions might ameliorate the cellular toxicity of nZnO in the mussels but limit applicability of cellular stress biomarkers for detecting the toxic effects of nanopollutants in low salinity habitats.

Effects of temperature on the toxicity of waterborne nanoparticles under global warming: Facts and mechanisms

Global climate change is predicted to increase the average temperature of aquatic environments. Temperature changes modulate the toxicity of emerging chemical contaminants, such as nanoparticles (NPs). However, current hazard assessments of waterborne NPs seldom consider the influence of temperature. In this review, we gathered and analyzed the effects of temperature on the toxicity of waterborne NPs in different organisms. There was a general decrease in bioavailability with increasing temperature in algae and plants due to NPs aggregation, thus, reducing their toxicities. However, the agglomerated large particles caused by the increase in temperature induce a shading effect and inhibit algal photosynthesis. The toxicity of NPs in microorganisms and aquatic animals increases with increasing temperature. This may be due to the significant influence of high temperature on the uptake and excretion of chemicals across membranes, which increase the production of reactive oxygen species and enhance oxidative damage to organisms. High temperature also affect the formation and composition of a protein corona on NPs, altering their toxicity. Our results provide new insights into the toxicity of NPs in the context of global warming, and highlight the deficiencies of current research on NPs.