Effects of hypoxia and hypercapnia on aerobic metabolic processes in northern elephant seals

Wake respirometry allows breath-by-breath assessment of ventilation and CO2 production in unrestrained animals

Quantifying stress and energetic responses in animals are major challenges, as existing methods lack temporal resolution and elevate animal stress. We propose “wake respirometry,” a new method of quantifying fine-scale changes in CO₂ production in unrestrained animals, using a nondispersive infrared CO₂ sensor positioned downwind of the animal, i.e., in its wake. We parameterize the dispersion of CO₂ in wakes using known CO₂ flow rates and wind speeds. Tests with three bird species in a wind tunnel demonstrated that the system can resolve breath-by-breath changes in CO₂ concentration, with clear exhalation signatures increasing in period and integral with body size. Changes in physiological state were detectable following handling, flight, and exposure to a perceived threat. We discuss the potential of wake respirometry to quantify stress and respiratory patterns in wild animals and provide suggestions for estimating behavior-specific metabolic rates via full integration of CO₂ production across the wake.

•

We use open-path nondispersive infrared spectroscopy CO₂ sensor technology

•

We measure ventilation rate and CO₂ production in the wake of unrestrained animals

•

Rapid responses to stressors and recovery from exercise can be measured

•

Metabolic rate could be calculated by full integration of the wake of exhaled CO₂

Sensitivity to hypercapnia and elimination of CO2 following diving in Steller sea lions (Eumetopias jubatus)

The diving ability of marine mammals is a function of how they use and store oxygen and the physiological control of ventilation, which is in turn dependent on the accumulation of CO2. To assess the influence of CO2 on physiological control of dive behaviour, we tested how increasing levels of inspired CO2 (hypercarbia) and decreasing inspired O2 (hypoxia) affected the diving metabolic rate, submergence times, and dive recovery times (time to replenish O2 stores and eliminate CO2) of freely diving Steller sea lions. We also measured changes in breathing frequency of diving and non-diving individuals. Our findings show that hypercarbia increased breathing frequency (as low as 2 % CO2), but did not affect metabolic rate, or the duration of dives or surface intervals (up to 3 % CO2). Changes in breathing rates indicated respiratory drive was altered by hypercarbia at rest, but blood CO2 levels remained below the threshold that would alter normal dive behaviour. It took the sea lions longer to remove accumulated CO2 than it did for them to replenish their O2 stores following dives (whether breathing ambient air, hypercarbia, or hypoxia). This difference between O2 and CO2 recovery times grew with increasing dive durations, increasing hypercarbia, and was greater for bout dives, suggesting there could be a build-up of CO2 load with repeated dives. Although we saw no evidence of CO2 limiting dive behaviour, the longer time required to remove CO2 may eventually exhibit control over the overall time they can spend in apnoea and overall foraging duration.

Development enhances hypometabolism in northern elephant seal pups (Mirounga angustirostris)

Investigation into the development of oxygen storage capacity in air-breathing marine predators has been performed, but little is known about the development of regulatory factors that influence oxygen utilization. Strategies for efficiently using oxygen stores should enable marine predators to optimize time spent foraging underwater.We describe the developmental patterns of oxygen use during voluntary breath-holds in northern elephant seals (Mirounga angustirostris) at 2 and 7 weeks post-weaning. We measured 1) changes in oxygen consumption (VO₂), and 2) changes in venous pH, partial pressure of oxygen (pO₂), haemoglobin saturation (sO₂), oxygen content (O₂ct), partial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO₂), haematocrit (Hct) and total haemoglobin (tHb). To examine the effect of the dive response on the development of oxygen utilization, voluntary breath-hold experiments were conducted in and out of water.Suppression of VO₂ during voluntary breath-holds increased significantly between 2 and 7 weeks post-weaning, reaching a maximum suppression of 53% below resting metabolic rate and 56% below Kleiber's standard metabolic rate. From 2 to 7 weeks post-weaning, breath-hold VO₂ was reduced by 52%. Between the two age classes, this equates to a mean breath-hold VO₂ reduction of 16% from resting VO₂. Breath-hold VO₂ also declined with increasing breath-hold duration, but there was no direct effect of voluntary submergence on reducing VO₂.Age did not influence rates of venous pO₂ depletion during breath-holds. However, voluntary submergence did result in slower pO₂ depletion rates when compared to voluntary terrestrial apnoeas. The differences in whole body VO₂ during breath-holds (measured at recovery) and venous pO₂ (reflective of tissue O₂-use measured during breath-holds), likely reflects metabolic suppression in hypoxic, vasoconstricted tissues.Consistent pCO₂ values at the end of all voluntary breath-holds (59.0 ± 0.7 mmHg) suggests the physiological cue for stimulating respiration in northern elephant seal pups is the accumulation of CO₂.Oxygen storage capacity and metabolic suppression directly limit diving capabilities and may influence foraging success in low-weaning weight seals forced to depart to sea prior to achieving full developmental diving capacity.

Thermoregulatory and metabolic responses to hypoxia in the oviparous lizard, Phrynocephalus przewalskii

The effects of hypoxia on behavioral thermoregulation, rate of heating and cooling, hysteresis of heart rate, and standard metabolic rate (SMR) were investigated in Phrynocephalus przewalskii, a small size toad headed lizard. Preferred temperature (T(b)) descended when lizards were exposed to severe hypoxia (8% O(2) and 6% O(2)) for 22 h, and lizards were able to maintain preferred T(b) after one week at 12% and 8% O(2) respectively. The period of heating increased after being treated with hypoxia (12% and 8% O(2)) for one week. Hysteresis of heart rate appeared at any given body temperature and oxygen level except at 39 °C and 40 °C at 8% O(2). SMR significantly increased after one-week acclimatization to 12% and 8% O(2) when ambient temperature (T(a)) was 25 °C, however, it did not change at 35 °C. Thus, we suggest that P. przewalskii has special thermoregulatory and metabolic mechanisms to acclimatize to the hypoxic environment.

Gluconeogenesis is associated with high rates of tricarboxylic acid and pyruvate cycling in fasting northern elephant seals

Animals that endure prolonged periods of food deprivation preserve vital organ function by sparing protein from catabolism. Much of this protein sparing is achieved by reducing metabolic rate and suppressing gluconeogenesis while fasting. Northern elephant seals (Mirounga angustirostris) endure prolonged fasts of up to 3 mo at multiple life stages. During these fasts, elephant seals maintain high levels of activity and energy expenditure associated with breeding, reproduction, lactation, and development while maintaining rates of glucose production typical of a postabsorptive mammal. Therefore, we investigated how fasting elephant seals meet the requirements of glucose-dependent tissues while suppressing protein catabolism by measuring the contribution of glycogenolysis, glycerol, and phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) to endogenous glucose production (EGP) during their natural 2-mo postweaning fast. Additionally, pathway flux rates associated with the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle were measured specifically, flux through phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK) and pyruvate cycling. The rate of glucose production decreased during the fast (F(1,13) = 5.7, P = 0.04) but remained similar to that of postabsorptive mammals. The fractional contributions of glycogen, glycerol, and PEP did not change with fasting; PEP was the primary gluconeogenic precursor and accounted for ∼95% of EGP. This large contribution of PEP to glucose production occurred without substantial protein loss. Fluxes through the TCA cycle, PEPCK, and pyruvate cycling were higher than reported in other species and were the most energetically costly component of hepatic carbohydrate metabolism. The active pyruvate recycling fluxes detected in elephant seals may serve to rectify gluconeogeneic PEP production during restricted anaplerotic inflow in these fasting-adapted animals.

Physiological response to extreme fasting in subantarctic fur seal (Arctocephalus tropicalis) pups: metabolic rates, energy reserve utilization, and water fluxes

Surviving prolonged fasting requires various metabolic adaptations, such as energy and protein sparing, notably when animals are simultaneously engaged in energy-demanding processes such as growth. Due to the intermittent pattern of maternal attendance, subantarctic fur seal pups have to repeatedly endure exceptionally long fasting episodes throughout the 10-mo rearing period while preparing for nutritional independence. Their metabolic responses to natural prolonged fasting (33.4 ± 3.3 days) were investigated at 7 mo of age. Within 4–6 fasting days, pups shifted into a stage of metabolic economy characterized by a minimal rate of body mass loss (0.7%/day) and decreased resting metabolic rate (5.9 ± 0.1 ml O2·kg−1·day−1) that was only 10% above the level predicted for adult terrestrial mammals. Field metabolic rate (289 ± 10 kJ·kg−1·day−1) and water influx (7.9 ± 0.9 ml·kg−1·day−1) were also among the lowest reported for any young otariid, suggesting minimized energy allocation to behavioral activity and thermoregulation. Furthermore, lean tissue degradation was dramatically reduced. High initial adiposity (>48%) and predominant reliance on lipid catabolism likely contributed to the exceptional degree of protein sparing attained. Blood chemistry supported these findings and suggested utilization of alternative fuels, such as β-hydroxybutyrate and de novo synthesized glucose from fat-released glycerol. Regardless of sex and body condition, pups tended to adopt a convergent strategy of extreme energy and lean body mass conservation that appears highly adaptive for it allows some tissue growth during the repeated episodes of prolonged fasting they experience throughout their development.

Resting breathing frequency in aquatic mammals: A comparative analysis with terrestrial species

Several species of aquatic mammals, while resting at the water surface, breathe with a low frequency (f). We asked if this was a general characteristic of mammals adapted to life in water. Measurements of f were obtained in 42 aquatic mammals of 19 species, during resting conditions. Data of additional 10 species were available from the literature. The allometric function for aquatic mammals was f=33W(-0.42) (f, breaths/min; W, kg; N=29, one data point per species, from six mammalian orders). This exponent was significantly different from that of the allometric curve of terrestrial mammals (W(-0.25)). The difference between aquatic and terrestrial species was small up to about 10kg, and widened with the increase in W. Out of several possibilities, it seems that the breath-holding response to favour buoyancy at the water surface could have contributed to the evolution of the low-f breathing, but a satisfactory explanation for the allometric pattern of f is still unavailable. In semi-aquatic mammals the low-f pattern observed at the water surface was maintained ashore, with no difference in the allometric function. As in the adult, also in the newborn of aquatic species f was low, compared to same-size neonates of terrestrial species. Hence, the low f has evolved to be part of the genetic makeup of aquatic mammals, retained when the animal is ashore, and already expressed at birth.

Physiological control of diving behaviour in the Weddell sealLeptonychotes weddelli: a model based on cardiorespiratory control theory

Despite being obligate air breathers, many species of marine mammal are capable of spending most of their lives submerged in water. How they do this has been a subject of intense interest to physiologists for over a century,yet we still do not have a detailed understanding of the physiological mechanisms underlying this behaviour. What are the proximate mechanisms that trigger the 'decisions' to submerge and return to the surface? The present study proposes a model intended to address this question, based on fundamental concepts of cardiorespiratory control. Two basic hypotheses are examined by computer simulation, using a mathematical model of the mammalian cardiorespiratory control system with parameter values for an adult Weddell seal: (1) that the control of diving can be considered to be a respiratory control problem, and (2) that dives are initiated and maintained by disfacilitation of respiratory drive, not inhibition. Computer simulations confirmed the plausibility of these hypotheses. Simulated diving behaviour and physiological responses (ventilation, cardiac output, blood and tissue gas tensions) were consistent with published data from freely diving Weddell seals. Dives up to the estimated aerobic dive limit (ADL, 18-25 min) could be simulated without the need for active inhibition of breathing in this model. This theoretical analysis suggests that the most important physiological adjustments occur during the surface interval phase of the dive cycle and include hyperventilation accompanied by high cardiac output, appropriate regulation of cerebral blood flow and central chemoreceptor threshold shifts. During dives, cardiac output, distribution of peripheral blood flow, splenic contraction and peripheral chemoreflex drives were found to modulate physiological and behavioural responses, but were not essential for simulated dives to occur. The main conclusion from this study is that the central chemoreceptor may be an important mechanism involved in the regulation of diving behaviour, implying that CO2, not O2, is the key regulatory variable in this model. This model includes and extends the ADL concept and suggests an explicit mechanism by which the respiratory control system may play a central role in the regulation of diving behaviour. It is likely that respiratory mechanisms are an important component of a hierarchical behavioural control system and further studies are required to test the qualitative and quantitative validity of the model.

Respiratory chemosensitivity during wake and sleep in harbour seal pups (Phoca vitulina richardsii)

In this study, we examined the cardiorespiratory patterns of harbour seal pups under normoxic/normocarbic (air), hypoxic/normocarbic (15%, 12%, and 9% O2 in air), and normoxic/hypercarbic (2%, 4%, and 6% CO2 in air) conditions while awake and sleeping on land. Animals were chronically instrumented to record electroencephalogram (EEG), electromyogram (EMG), and electrocardiogram (EKG) signals, which, along with respiration (whole-body plethysmography) and oxygen consumption (VO2), were recorded from animals breathing each gas mixture for 2-4 h on separate days. Our results show that for animals breathing air, VO2 was not significantly lower during slow-wave sleep (SWS; 7.71 +/- 0.39 mL O2 min(-1) kg(-1); all measurements are mean +/- SEM) than during wakefulness (WAKE; 8.80 +/- 0.25 mL O2 min(-1) kg(-1)) and was unaffected by changes in respiratory drive. Although there was no significant fall in VO2 associated with a decrease in arousal state, breathing frequency (f(R)) did decrease (from 18.80 +/- 1.50 breaths min(-1) in WAKE to 10.40 +/- 0.49 breaths min(-1) in SWS), while the incidence of long apneas (>20 s) increased (12.76 +/- 4.06 apneas h(-1) in WAKE and 31.95 +/- 2.37 apneas h(-1) in SWS). Breathing was rarely seen during rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. Tachypnea was present at all levels of increased respiratory drive; however, hypoxia induced a dramatic bradycardia regardless of arousal state, while hypercarbia produced a tachycardia in SWS only. The hypoxic and hypercarbic chemosensitivities of harbour seal pups were similar to those of terrestrial mammals; however, unlike terrestrial mammals, where hypoxic and hypercarbic sensitivities are often reduced during SWS, the sensitivity of harbour seal pups to hypoxia and hypercarbia remained unchanged during the decrease in arousal state from WAKE to SWS.

Developmental changes in cardiorespiratory patterns associated with terrestrial apnoeas in harbour seal pups

During the nursing period seals undergo several physiological and behavioural changes. A key component of development is increased cardiorespiratory control, fundamental for breath-holding and thus diving. This study focused on the ontogenetic changes in cardiac responses to respiration in quietly resting, pre-weaned harbour seal pups (Phoca vitulina). During periods of quiet rest, breathing became episodic, eupnoea interspersed with periods of apnoea. Little change was observed in respiration (approximately 35 breaths min(-1)) and eupnoeic heart rate (approximately 160 beats min(-1)) throughout the nursing period. However, apnoea duration increased (from approximately 20 to 40 s), while apnoeic heart rate decreased with age (from approximately 150 to 90 beats min(-1)). The observed decline in apnoeic heart rate resulted from an increase in cardiorespiratory control as pups approached weaning, evident by the ability to maintain a lower heart rate more consistently. Similar changes in cardiorespiratory patterns have been reported for elephant and Weddell seals. Due to the early onset of independent foraging, however, the rate of cardiorespiratory control development was more rapid in harbour seals. Our findings suggest that by 1 month of age, harbour seal pups possess the cardiorespiratory control necessary to sustain long-duration apnoeas, fundamental for proficient diving and successful foraging upon weaning.

Metabolic regulation in diving birds and mammals

Ducks, fur seals, Weddell seals and probably most cetaceans seem to be able to dive and remain aerobic for durations that are consistent with their elevated stores of usable oxygen and their metabolic rate while diving being similar to that when they are resting at the surface of the water. Ducks, in fact, have a high metabolic rate while diving, mainly because of their large positive buoyancy, but other species have relatively low buoyancy, are better streamlined and use lift-based rather than drag-based propulsion. However, species such as the larger penguins, grey seals and elephant seals seem to achieve the impossible by performing a substantial proportion of their dives for periods longer than would be expected on the above assumptions, and yet remaining aerobic. The logical conclusion is that during such dives these species reduce their metabolic rate below the resting level (hypometabolism) and, in some of them, there is a regional reduction in body temperature (hypothermia) which may contribute to the reduction in metabolic rate.

Thermoregulation of weaned northern elephant seal (Mirounga angustirostris) pups in air and water

Fasting weaned northern elephant seal pups (Mirounga angustirostris) experience diverse environmental conditions on land and in water on a daily basis. Each environment undoubtedly induces distinct energetic costs that may vary for pups of differing body condition. To determine the energetic costs associated with different environmental conditions and whether costs vary between individuals, body mass, surface area, volume, body composition, resting metabolic rate, and core body temperature were determined for 17 weaned northern elephant seal pups from Año Nuevo, California. Metabolic rate and body temperature were measured for pups resting in air (20.9 degrees +/-0.8 degrees C), cold water (3.8 degrees+/-0.4 degrees ;C), and warm water (14.5 degrees+/-0.2 degrees C). Resting metabolic rate increased with body mass (range: 62.0-108.0 kg) and was also correlated with lean mass and lipid mass. Metabolic rates ranged from 293.6 to 512.7 mL O(2) min(-1) and were lowest for pups resting in cold water. Thermal conductance, calculated from metabolic rate and core body temperature, ranged from 3.1 to 15.2 W degrees C(-1), with the highest values in air and the lowest values in cold water. Metabolic responses to the three environmental conditions did not differ with individual variation in body condition. For all elephant seal pups, a consequence of high lipid content is that thermoregulatory costs are greatest on land and lowest in cold water, a pattern that contrasts markedly with terrestrial mammals.

Effects of forced diving on the spleen and hepatic sinus in northern elephant seal pups

In phocid seals, an increase in hematocrit (Hct) accompanies diving and periods of apnea. The variability of phocid Hct suggests that the total red cell mass is not always in circulation, leading researchers to speculate on the means of blood volume partitioning. The histology and disproportionate size of the phocid spleen implicates it as the likely site for RBC storage. We used magnetic resonance imaging on Northern elephant seals to demonstrate a rapid contraction of the spleen and a simultaneous filling of the hepatic sinus during forced dives (P < 0.0001, R(2) = 0.97). The resulting images are clear evidence demonstrating a functional relationship between the spleen and hepatic sinus. The transfer of blood from the spleen to the sinus provides an explanation for the disparity between the timing of diving-induced splenic contraction ( approximately 1-3 min) and the occurrence of peak Hct (15-25 min). Facial immersion was accompanied by an immediate and profound splenic contraction, with no further significant decrease in splenic volume after min 2 (Tukey-Kramer HSD, P = 0.05). At the conclusion of the dive, the spleen had contracted to 16% of its predive volume (mean resting splenic volume = 3,141 ml +/- 68.01 ml; 3.54% of body mass). In the postdive period, the spleen required 18-22 min to achieve resting volume, indicating that this species may not have sufficient time to refill the spleen when routinely diving at sea, which is virtually continuous with interdive surface intervals between 1 and 3 min.