Comparison of technetium 99m-tetrofosmin and thallium-201 single photon emission computed tomographic imaging for the assessment of viable myocardium in patients with left ventricular dysfunction

Taxonomy of segmental myocardial systolic dysfunction

The terms used to describe different states of myocardial health and disease are poorly defined. Imprecision and inconsistency in nomenclature can lead to difficulty in interpreting and applying trial outcomes to clinical practice. In particular, the terms ‘viable’ and ‘hibernating’ are commonly applied interchangeably and incorrectly to myocardium that exhibits chronic contractile dysfunction in patients with ischaemic heart disease. The range of inherent differences amongst imaging modalities used to define myocardial health and disease add further challenges to consistent definitions. The results of several large trials have led to renewed discussion about the classification of dysfunctional myocardial segments. This article aims to describe the diverse myocardial pathologies that may affect the myocardium in ischaemic heart disease and cardiomyopathy, and how they may be assessed with non-invasive imaging techniques in order to provide a taxonomy of myocardial dysfunction.

Monocationic radiotracer kinetics and myocardial infarct size: a perfused rat heart study

OBJECTIVE

To compare the myocardial kinetics of three (99m)technetium-labeled monocationic tracers [methoxy-isobutylisonitrile (MIBI), tetrofosmin, and Q12] in a model of ischemia-reperfusion (IR) to determine their abilities to assess myocardial viability.

METHODS

Isolated perfused rat hearts (n = 30) were studied in control and IR groups for each tracer. IR hearts were treated with 120 min global no-flow followed by 5 min reflow, then 60 min tracer uptake/clearance. Tracer kinetics were monitored using a scintillation detector.

RESULTS

This model produced significant myocardial injury, without significant differences in the percentage of injured myocardium by triphenyltetrazolium chloride (TTC) staining and creatine kinase (CK) assay. Transmission electron microscopy analysis also confirmed necrosis with abundant mitochondrial damage in the IR hearts. All three IR groups exhibited significantly less mean (+/-standard error of the mean) tracer retention than matched controls (MIBI 73.4 +/- 4.9% vs. 96.9 +/- 1.76%, tetrofosmin 38.7 +/- 4.6% vs. 82.2 +/- 3.5%, and Q12 23.0 +/- 2.5% vs. 43.8 +/- 1.8%, respectively; P < 0.05). Tetrofosmin IR hearts exhibited 54 +/- 9% of control myocardial retention, which was significantly less than either MIBI (86 +/- 5%, P < 0.05) or Q12 (63 +/- 6%, P < 0.05); thus, tetrofosmin provided the best differentiation between nonviable and normal myocardium. Furthermore, tetrofosmin end activity (%id/g) in controls was significantly higher than Q12 (4.09 +/- 0.04 vs. 1.71 +/- 0.06, respectively, P < 0.05), and tetrofosmin end activity (%id/g) in IR hearts was significantly higher than Q12 (2.19 +/- 0.37 vs. 1.06 +/- 0.12, respectively, P < 0.05). The correlation between end activity and viable myocardium determined by TTC staining was r = 0.66 (P < 0.05) for MIBI, r = 0.94 (P < 0.05) for tetrofosmin, and r = 0.91 (P < 0.05) for Q12. The correlation between myocardial end activity and myocardial CK leak was r = -0.62 (P < 0.05) for MIBI, r = -0.87 (P < 0.05) for tetrofosmin, and r = -0.89 (P < 0.05) for Q12.

CONCLUSIONS

Nonviable myocardium can be distinguished from normal myocardium by the retention kinetics of all three monocationic tracers studied. Tetrofosmin and Q12 end activities demonstrate the best correlation with infarct size. However, tetrofosmin kinetics may combine the greatest differentiation between nonviable and normal myocardium, while still retaining adequate activity for imaging.

Myocardial technetium-99m-tetrofosmin single-photon emission computed tomography compared with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose imaging to assess myocardial viability

Technetium-99m-tetrofosmin single-photon emission computed tomography at rest is practical for routine assessment of viability in patients with ischemic cardiomyopathy. However, underestimation of viability may occur compared with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose single-photon emission computed tomography, especially in the inferoposterior and septal regions.

Detection and characterization of hibernating myocardium

Since Tennant and Wiggers observed that coronary occlusion caused a reduction in cardiac contractile function, a lot has been written about the concept of hibernating myocardium. Known as the 'smart heart', hibernating myocardium is characterized by a persistent ventricular myocardial dysfunction with preserved viability, which improves with the relief of the ischaemia; this chronic downregulation in contractile function being a protective mechanism to reduce oxygen demand and thus ensure myocyte survival. This improvement usually results in an enrichment in the quality of life as well as enhanced ventricular function. In fact, it has been observed that the cardiac event rate in patients with viable dysfunctional left ventricular segments who are medically treated, is higher than the event rate in patients with comparable viability who are revascularized. Different degrees of histological alteration have been seen in hibernating myocardium, ranging from cellular de-differentiation (fetal phenotype) to cellular degeneration. Cellular de-differentiation has been associated with repetitive stunning. On the other hand, cellular degeneration (with more extensive fibrosis) has been associated with chronic low myocardial blood flow and a longer time to recovery after revascularization. These histological patterns may suggest an evolution from cellular de-differentiation to degeneration, which ends in scar formation if no revascularization is performed. In fact, several studies have described the clinical value of identifying and revascularizing hibernating segments as early as possible, to minimize fibrosis and morbidity from adverse events. Detection of hibernating myocardium still remains an important clinical problem. Imaging modalities to assess myocardial viability must differentiate potentially functional tissue from myocardium with no potential for functional recovery. These techniques fall into three broad categories: ventricular function assessment, myocardial perfusion imaging and myocardial metabolic imaging. PET imaging with fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose (18F-FDG) and 11C-acetate, single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) with thallium and 99mTc-sestamibi, dobutamine echocardiograpy, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and fast computed tomography (CT) have been used for this purpose. PET imaging, in both perfusion and glucose metabolic activity, has become a standard for myocardial viability assessment, however, similar information may be available from carefully performed studies with perfusion tracers alone.

[Prognostic value of myocardial perfusion SPECT in multivessel coronary disease patients with left ventricular dysfunction, comparing revascularized and non-revascularized patients]

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the prognostic value of 99mTc-Tetrofosmin myocardial SPECT (99mTc-TF) in dysfunctional multivessel coronary disease patients who underwent revascularization (RV) or only medical treatment (MT).

METHODS

In 78 coronary patients with 2-3 diseased vessels and left ventricular ejection fraction (EF) <= 40% (24 10%), we have assessed the extension of the stress perfusion defect, and percent of reversibility (R) by quantification of stress-rest myocardial SPECT 99mTc-TF bull's eyes (2 days-protocol), lung/heart ratio (LH) calculated in the original stress SPECT images, and EF by equilibrium radionuclide ventriculography obtained at 24 h. A R value >= 8% was used to identify viable (V) patients. A total of 28 patients underwent RV and 50 only received MT. After a mean follow-up of 22.9 20 months (3-60), they were considered as coronary events (CE): cardiac death, non-fatal infarction and heart transplant. CE rate was 20.5% (16/78).

RESULTS

No significant differences were found in the pre-revascularization study characteristics, except a significantly higher mean R value in RV (10.6 9.5%) than in MT patients (6.4 7.8%) p: 0.03, and the main difference was that RV patients showed less CE 2/28 (7%) than the MT group 14/50 (28%) p: 0.02. The CE rate was lower in V patients who underwent RV (6%) than in V patients with MT (45%) p: 0.03, but no significant difference was obtained in non-V patients between RV (7%) and MT (16%) groups. In viable patients, the corresponding survival curves (Kaplan-Meier) showed a CE-free survival at 5 years of 79% in patients RV and of 42% in MT patients, p: 0.03, without significant difference in non-V patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with viable myocardium by myocardial SPECT have a good prognosis after revascularization, and show higher risk of CE if they are only medically treated. Myocardial viability is an indispensable assessment in prognosis evaluation and, above all, in therapeutic decision making in dysfunctional multivessel coronary disease patients.

Clinical benefit of noninvasive viability studies of patients with severe ischemic left ventricular dysfunction

The population of patients who have congestive heart failure of ischemic origin is large and growing. It imposes a heavy burden on human suffering and economic costs such as the chronic use of costly medications, recurrent hospital admissions, and, eventually, death or the necessity of heart transplantation. Therefore, the development of methods for detecting viable myocardium may allow the accurate selection of those patients with coronary artery disease with severe left ventricular dysfunction who are most likely to benefit from revascularization, but also excludes patients who are unlikely to obtain any improvement with revascularization techniques. The presence of reversible dysfunctional myocardium that may improve after revascularization implies the concepts of stunned and hibernating myocardium. Recent evidence suggests that hibernation may not be a stable condition since it might evolve toward an irreversible dysfunction if it is not revascularized at the right moment. The techniques available for viability studies are single-photon emission computed tomography using thallium-201 or compounds labeled with technetium-99m, positron emission tomography, and dobutamine stress echocardiography. Newer and promising techniques are magnetic resonance imaging and contrast echocardiography, whose definitive roles are not clear yet. There is abundant evidence from several important studies showing that patients with a significant amount of viable myocardium have a poor outcome if they are treated medically. Conversely, if these patients are revascularized, their outcomes improve and their symptoms significantly decrease, with less necessity of medication, fewer admissions to the hospital, and even in some cases avoiding heart transplantation. On the other hand, patients with poor or no viability who are revascularized do not obtain significant benefit.

Technetium-99m-labeled myocardial perfusion agents: Are they better than thallium-201?

Currently, thallium-201 (201Tl)- and technetium-99m (99mTc)-labeled tracers are used interchangeably for the detection of coronary artery disease, the assessment of myocardial viability, and risk stratification. This article reviews some of the potential advantages and disadvantages of the 99mTc-labeled tracers relative to 201Tl. The basic myocardial kinetic properties and biodistribution of the commonly used 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers are compared with those of 201Tl. The clinical value of the 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers is then compared with that of 201Tl imaging. With regard to imaging physics and radiation safety, the 99mTc-labeled tracers are superior to 201Tl. Cost and tracer availability also may favor 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers rather than 201Tl imaging. However, the most widely used 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers currently approved for clinical use-99mTc-sestamibi and 99mTc-tetrofosmin-do not track myocardial flow as well as 201Tl does. This shortcoming of 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers may reduce the sensitivity of these agents in detecting subcritical coronary artery disease. The most notable new perfusion agent is 99mTc-labeled bis(N-ethoxy, N-ethyl dithiocarbamato) nitrido technetium(v), which is considered to be the 99mTc-labeled equivalent of 201Tl. However, 99mTc-labeled bis(N-ethoxy, N-ethyl dithiocarbamato) nitrido technetium(v) is a neutral compound with kinetic properties that are very different from those of 201Tl. Myocardial perfusion imaging is often conducted in conjunction with exercise or with different pharmacologic stressors, both of which augment regional flow heterogeneity. Each of these stressors has unique effects on the coronary vasculature and influences the behavior of the radiolabeled perfusion agents. The substantial differences in myocardial uptake, clearance kinetics, and biodistribution between each of the 99mTc-labeled perfusion tracers and 201Tl should be considered in the clinical application of perfusion imaging. The myocardial retention of all of the agents is affected by myocardial viability. However, 201Tl demonstrates greater differential clearance from normal and ischemic regions (redistribution), making 201Tl a better agent for assessment of viability, particularly in patients with extremely low flow. In contrast, agents that do not redistribute, such as 99mTc-tetrofosmin, might be better for acute assessment of "risk areas" or of chest pain. Each of the available perfusion tracers has unique advantages and disadvantages that must be considered to ensure its optimal application.

Technetium 99m furifosmin regional myocardial uptake in patients with previous myocardial infarction: relation to thallium-201 activity and left ventricular function

BACKGROUND

This study was designed to compare the results of rest-redistribution thallium-201 imaging with those of rest technetium 99m furifosmin single photon emission computed tomography in the same patients with chronic ischemic left ventricular (LV) dysfunction.

METHODS

Twenty-one patients (mean age 62 +/- 9 years) with chronic myocardial infarction and LV dysfunction (mean LV ejection fraction 34% +/- 8%) underwent rest-redistribution thallium imaging and resting furifosmin single photon emission computed tomography on the same day. In each patient, regional thallium and furifosmin activity was quantitatively measured in 13 myocardial segments. Regional LV function was assessed in corresponding segments by echocardiography.

RESULTS

At thallium imaging, 91 (33%) segments had normal uptake, 16 (6%) showed reversible defects, and the remaining 166 (61%) irreversible defects. Of these 166 irreversible defects, 74 (45%) had moderate (> or =58% of peak activity) and 92 (55%) severe (<58% of peak activity) reduction of thallium uptake. Regional furifosmin uptake was significantly related to both rest (r = 0.87, P < .0001) and redistribution (r = 0.90, P < .0001) thallium activity. Agreement in the evaluation of regional perfusion status between thallium and furifosmin imaging was observed in 70% of the 84 hypokinetic segments (kappa = 0.54) and in 76% of the 78 akinetic or dyskinetic segments (kappa = 0.60). Concordance in the detection of myocardial viability between thallium and furifosmin imaging was observed in 69 (82%) of hypokinetic regions (kappa = 0.60) and in 65 (83%) of akinetic or dyskinetic regions (kappa = 0.67).

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that in patients with chronic coronary artery disease and LV dysfunction, quantitative rest-redistribution thallium scintigraphy and furifosmin tomography at rest provide similar results in the evaluation of perfusion status and in the detection of myocardial viability.

Exercise-test Tc-99m tetrofosmin SPECT in patients with chronic ischemic left ventricular dysfunction: direct comparison with Ti-201 reinjection

BACKGROUND

This study was designed to compare the results of exercise-rest technetium-99m tetrofosmin single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) with those of thallium-201 reinjection at rest after exercise-redistribution imaging in the same patients with chronic ischemic left ventricular (LV) dysfunction.

METHODS

Within 1 week, 33 patients with chronic myocardial infarction and LV dysfunction underwent exercise-rest tetrofosmin SPECT and Tl-201 reinjection at rest after exercise-redistribution imaging. In each patient, regional tetrofosmin and Tl-201 activity was quantitatively measured in 22 myocardial segments. Regional LV function was assessed in corresponding segments by echocardiography.

RESULTS

Agreement in the evaluation of regional perfusion status between tetrofosmin and Tl-201 imaging was observed in 78% of the 726 total segments, with a kappa value of 0.61. In segments with normal function at echocardiography (n = 436), no difference between Tl-201 and tetrofosmin uptake was observed. In hypokinetic segments (n = 138), exercise tetrofosmin uptake was lower (P < .01) as compared with exercise Tl-201 activity, whereas no difference was observed between tetrofosmin uptake at rest as compared with Tl-201 activity on redistribution and reinjection images. In segments with severe functional impairment (akinetic or dyskinetic, n = 152), tetrofosmin uptake on exercise images was reduced (P < .01) as compared with exercise Tl-201 activity; furthermore, tetrofosmin uptake at rest was lower (P < .01) as compared with Tl-201 activity on both redistribution and reinjection images. In these segments, concordance in the detection of myocardial viability between tetrofosmin and Tl-201 imaging was observed in 138 (91%) of the 152 segments, with a kappa value of 0.77.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with chronic coronary artery disease and LV dysfunction quantitative exercise-rest tetrofosmin and Tl-201 reinjection SPECT provide similar information in the assessment of perfusion status and in the detection of myocardial viability.