Nerve growth factor preserves behavioral visual acuity in monocularly deprived kittens

Molecular substrates of plasticity in the developing visual cortex

Ocular dominance plasticity may be the paradigmatic in vivo model of activity-dependent plasticity. More than four decades of intense research has delineated the network-level rules that govern synaptic change in this model. The recent characterization of a murine model for ocular dominance plasticity has facilitated rapid progress on a new front, extending our understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying ocular dominance plasticity. In this review, we highlight recent advances in this research effort, focusing in particular on signaling pathways mediating shifts in ocular dominance, and mechanisms underlying the timing of the critical period.

Acute and long-term synaptic modulation by neurotrophins

While it has now been well accepted that neurotrophins play an important role in synapse development and plasticity, the specific effects of each neurotrophin on different populations of neurons at different developmental stages have just begun to be worked out. Moreover, the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying the synaptic function of neurotrophins remain poorly understood. In general, synaptic effects of neurotrophins could be divided into two categories: acute effect on synaptic transmission and plasticity occurring within seconds or minutes after cells are exposed to a neurotrophin, and long-term effect on synaptic structures and function that takes days to accomplish. In this review I have considered the previous findings on neurotrophic regulation of synapses in view of these two categories. Acute and long-term effects of neurotrophins are reexamined in detail in three model systems: the neuromuscular junction, the hippocampus and the visual cortex. Potential molecular mechanisms that mediate the acute or long-term neurotrophic regulation are discussed. Efforts are made to understand the mechanistic differences between the two effects and their relationships. Further study of these mechanisms will help us better understand how neurotrophins can achieve diverse and synapse-specific modulation.

Neurotrophins and plasticity in the visual cortex

The visual cortex is one of the favorite models for the study of experience-dependent changes in neuronal structure and function. A number of recent investigations indicate that the neurotrophic factors of the nerve growth factor family (neurotrophins) play a pivotal role in visual cortical plasticity. Neurotrophins and their receptors are present in the cortex during the critical period for plasticity, and neurotrophin levels are regulated by electrical activity. Neurotrophins modulate synaptic transmission and patterns of neuronal connectivity in the cortex. This review summarizes the in vivo and in vitro data that demonstrate the involvement of neurotrophins in visual cortical plasticity and discusses the possible mechanisms of their action.

Infusion of nerve growth factor (NGF) into kitten visual cortex increases immunoreactivity for NGF, NGF receptors, and choline acetyltransferase in basal forebrain without affecting ocular dominance plasticity or column development

Intracerebroventricular or intracortical administration of nerve growth factor (NGF) has been shown to block or attenuate visual cortical plasticity in the rat. In cats and ferrets, the effects of exogenous NGF on development and plasticity of visual cortex have been reported to be small or nonexistent. To determine whether locally delivered NGF affects ocular dominance column formation or the plasticity produced by monocular deprivation in cats at the height of the critical period, we infused recombinant human NGF into the primary visual cortex of kittens using an implanted cannula minipump. NGF had no effect on the normal developmental segregation of geniculocortical afferents into ocular dominance columns as determined both physiologically and anatomically. The plasticity of binocular visual cortical responses induced by monocular deprivation was also normal in regions of immunohistochemically detectable NGF infusion, as measured using intrinsic signal optical imaging and single-unit electrophysiology. Immunohistochemical analysis of the basal forebrain regions of the same animals demonstrated that the NGF infused into cortex was biologically active, producing an increase in the number of NGF-, TrkA-, p75(NTR)-, and choline acetyltransferase-positive neurons in basal forebrain nuclei in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the NGF minipump compared to the contralateral basal forebrain neurons. We conclude that NGF delivered locally to axon terminals of cholinergic basal forebrain neurons resulted in increases in protein expression at the cell body through retrograde signaling.

Behavioural visual acuity of wild type and bcl2 transgenic mouse

Since the advent of gene manipulating techniques, it has become increasingly important to study the neural functional properties of the mouse. The bcl2 gene has a powerful inhibitory action on naturally occurring cell death. As a consequence the brain of bcl2 overexpressing mouse is 1.5 times bigger than the brain of a wild type animal and the retina has more than twice the ganglion cells than normal (Martinou, Dubois-Dauphin, Staple, Rodriguez, Frankowski, Missotten, Albertini, Talabot, Catsicas, Pietra, & Huarte (1994). Neuron, 13: 1017-1030). Since in most mammals the upper limit of behavioural visual acuity is imposed by ganglion cells density, the visual acuity should be higher in bcl2 mice than in wild type mice. We measured behavioural visual acuity in wild type and transgenic mice and, contrary to the expectation, we found it to be of the same order (0.5-0.6 c/deg) in the two groups of animals, indicating that an increase in ganglion cells density is not effective in improving visual resolution.

TrkA activation in the rat visual cortex by antirat trkA IgG prevents the effect of monocular deprivation

It has been recently shown that intraventricular injections of nerve growth factor (NGF) prevent the effects of monocular deprivation in the rat. We have tested the localization and the molecular nature of the NGF receptor(s) responsible for this effect by activating cortical trkA receptors in monocularly deprived rats by cortical infusion of a specific agonist of NGF on trkA, the bivalent antirat trkA IgG (RTA-IgG). TrkA protein was detected by immunoblot in the rat visual cortex during the critical period. Rats were monocularly deprived for 1 week (P21-28) and RTA-IgG or control rabbit IgG were delivered by osmotic minipumps. The effects of monocular deprivation on the ocular dominance of visual cortical neurons were assessed by extracellular single cell recordings. We found that the shift towards the ipsilateral, non-deprived eye was largely prevented by RTA-IgG. Infusion of RTA-IgG combined with antibody that blocks p75NTR (REX), slightly reduced RTA-IgG effectiveness in preventing monocular deprivation effects. These results suggest that NGF action in visual cortical plasticity is mediated by cortical TrkA receptors with p75NTR exerting a facilitatory role.

Environmental enrichment results in higher levels of nerve growth factor mRNA in the rat visual cortex and hippocampus

Evidence for structural modifications in the brain following environmental changes have been provided during the last decades. The most pronounced alterations following environmental manipulations have been found in the visual cortex. These plastic changes are supposed to reflect reorganization of neuronal connections involved in postnatal development and adult adjustments of connections involved in sensori-perceptual processing and learning. Potential candidates to mediate these changes are neurotrophins. Nerve growth factor (NGF) has been associated with cognitive functions and shown to improve the performance of aged rats in spatial learning and memory task. In the central nervous system, NGF is of importance for development and maintenance of cholinergic neurons and atrophy of cholinergic neurons is strongly correlated with learning and memory impairments. Exposure to enriched environmental conditions improves learning and problem-solving ability and results in plastic changes in the brain. This study examined the effect of environmental enrichment on expression of NGF mRNA in the rat visual cortex and hippocampus. Rats housed in groups in a stimulus-rich environment for 30 days had significantly higher levels of NGF mRNA than rats housed individually in single cages without stimulus-enrichment. We have recently presented results showing higher levels of neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) mRNA and improved spatial learning following environmental enrichment, and suggest that an interplay involving the neurotrophins NGF and NT-3 may be mediating experience-induced structural changes.

Equivalence of a sprouting-and-retraction model and correlation-based plasticity models of neural development

A simple model of correlation-based synaptic plasticity via axonal sprouting and retraction (Elliott, Howarth, & Shadbolt, 1996a) is shown to be equivalent to the class of correlation-based models (Miller, Keller, & Stryker, 1989), although these were formulated in terms of weight modification of anatomically fixed synapses. Both models maximize the same measure of synaptic correlation, subject to certain constraints on connectivity. Thus, the analyses of the correlation-based models suffice to characterize the behavior of the sprouting-and-retraction model. More detailed models are needed for theoretical distinctions to be drawn between plasticity via sprouting and retraction, weight modification, or a combination. The model of Elliott et al. involves stochastic search through allowed weight patterns for those that improve correlations. That of Miller et al. instead follows dynamical equations that determine continuous changes of the weights that improve correlations. The identity of these two approaches is shown to depend on the use of subtractive constraint enforcement in the models of Miller et al. More generally, to model the idea that neural development acts to maximize some measure of correlation subject to a constraint on the summed synaptic weight, the constraint must be enforced subtractively in a dynamical model.

Transplant of Schwann cells allows normal development of the visual cortex of dark-reared rats

Visual experience is necessary for the correct development of the visual cortex. Dark-rearing from birth affects normal maturation of the functional properties of mammalian visual cortex: cortical cells show rapid habituation to repeated stimulation, decreased orientation selectivity, and enlarged receptive fields. Spatial resolution and response latency are also impaired. Recent experiments have demonstrated that visual deprivation reduces the expression of neurotrophins in the visual cortex. We formulated the hypothesis that visual experience drives the maturation of functional properties of the visual cortex by regulating cortical levels of neurotrophins. If this hypothesis is correct, exogenous supply of neurotrophins during dark-rearing from birth should prevent, or at least ameliorate, the effects of a lack of visual experience. Since Schwann cells are efficient biological minipumps of neurotrophic factors, we transplanted 1.0 or 1.5 x 10(6) Schwann cells or infused vehicle solution as a control into the lateral ventricles of 13 day old rats reared in total darkness from birth until the end of the critical period (postnatal day 45). Single-cell responses and visual-evoked potentials were recorded from the binocular zone of the primary visual cortex of each group. We found that in Schwann cell-transplanted animals all parameters tested were significantly improved upon those of dark-reared control rats and were in the range of normal adult values. Thus, Schwann cell transplant contributed to the normal development of visual response properties in the visual cortex, compensating for a complete absence of visual experience.

Nerve growth factor and the neurotrophic factor hypothesis

The discovery of nerve growth factor (NGF) over 40 years ago led to the formulation of the "Neurotrophic Factor Hypothesis". This hypothesis states that developing neurons compete with each other for a limited supply of a neurotrophic factor (NTF) provided by the target tissue. Successful competitors survive; unsuccessful ones die. Subsequent research on NTFs has shown that NTF expression and actions are considerably more complex and diverse than initially predicted. Even for NGF, different regulatory patterns are seen for different neuronal populations. As would be predicted by the "Neurotrophic Factor Hypothesis", NGF levels critically regulate basal forebrain cholinergic neuron size and neurochemical differentiation. In contrast, the level of trkA, the NGF receptor, regulates these properties in caudate-putamen cholinergic neurons. Understanding NTF regulation and actions on neurons has led to their use in clinical trials of human neurological diseases. NTFs may emerge as important therapies to prevent neuronal dysfunction and death.

TRK and p75 neurotrophin receptor systems in the developing human brain

The prenatal development of the neurons immunoreactive for high-affinity tropomycin-related kinase (trk) receptor (pan trk which recognizes trkA, trkB, and trkC) and low-affinity p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75NTR) was examined in the human brain from embryonic weeks 10 to 34 of gestation. In the embryonic week 10 specimen in which only brainstem regions were available for evaluation, trk immunoreactivity (trk-ir) was observed in the ventral cochlear, solitary, raphe, spinal trigeminal, and hypoglossal nuclei, as well as the vestibular complex and medullary reticular formation. At this time point of gestation, p75ntr-immunoreactive (p75NTR-ir) staining was observed within these same regions plus the inferior olivary and ambiguus nuclei. At embryonic week 14, trk-ir neurons were seen within the subplate zone of the entorhinal cortex, basal forebrain, caudate nucleus, putamen, external segment of the globus pallidus, specific thalamic nuclei, lateral mammillary nucleus, habenula nucleus, select brainstem nuclei, and the dentate nucleus of cerebellum. At this gestational time point, p75NTR-ir neurons were observed in each of these structures, with the exception of the caudate nucleus, specific thalamic nuclei, lateral mammillary nucleus, and habenula nucleus. Additionally, p75NTR-ir neurons were observed within the corpus callosum. The staining pattern for both trk and p75NTR remained unchanged at embryonic weeks 15 to 16 except for the addition of trk-ir and p75NTR-ir within the cortical subplate zone, hippocampus, and subthalamic nucleus. By embryonic week 18, trk-ir neurons were widely expressed within mostly all thalamic nuclei. In contrast, trk-ir was no longer seen within the hypoglossal, cuneate, and gracile nuclei at this time point. This staining pattern for trk and p75NTR remained virtually unchanged from embryonic weeks 19 to 20 and embryonic weeks 16 to 20, respectively. From embryonic weeks 22 to 34, the distribution of both trk-ir and p75NTR-ir neurons changed gradually. During this period, neurons in most thalamic and some brainstem nuclei became progressively immunonegative for trk, whereas neurons in the neocortical subplate zone, corpus callosum, and hilar region of dentate gyrus gradually lost immunoreactivity for p75NTR. These data demonstrate an important and complex role for both the high-(trk) and low- (p75) affinity neurotrophin receptors during the development of multiple neuronal systems in the human brain.

The action of neurotrophins in the development and plasticity of the visual cortex

Nerve growth factor (NGF) and the other members of the NGF gene family have been extensively characterized as neurotrophic factors. Recently a modulatory action of these neurotrophic factors on synapse efficacy has emerged. The developing visual system has provided a convenient model to test the role of neurotrophins on neural plasticity in vivo.

Neurotrophins and activity-dependent development of the neocortex

A number of recent results suggest that neurotrophins play an important role in early development as well as in the later, activity-dependent processes important for the final shaping of cortical connections. Many neurotrophins and their receptors are regulated in parallel with the 'critical period' in development, and their application to the neocortex can dramatically alter the functional organization of the cortex, as well as the morphological properties of neocortical neurons. In addition, recent data show that a different phenomenon of synaptic plasticity, hippocampal long-term potentiation, also critically depends on neurotrophins. Thus, neurotrophins may play a role in linking functional modifications of synapses to the morphological effects of synaptic stabilization and rearrangement, as observed in the neocortex.

The involvement of brain-derived neurotrophic factor in hippocampal long-term potentiation revealed by gene targeting experiments

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is a member of the NGF gene family, which has been shown to influence the survival and differentiation of specific classes of neurons in vitro and in vivo. The possibility that neurotrophins are also involved in processes of neuronal plasticity has only recently begun to receive attention. To determine whether BDNF has a function in processes like long-term potentiation (LTP), we produced a strain of mice with a deletion in the coding sequence of the BDNF-gene. We then used hippocampal slices from these mice to investigate whether LTP is affected by this mutation. Mutant mice showed significantly weaker LTP in the CA1 region. The magnitude of the potentiation as well as the percentage of cases in which LTP could be induced successfully was clearly reduced whereas important pharmacological and morphological control parameters in the hippocampus of these animals were unaffected. Adenoviral vectors were used to re-express BDNF in acute slices of BDNF-knock-out mice. In most cases LTP could be rescued with this approach. These results suggest that BDNF has an important functional role in the expression of LTP in the hippocampus.

Monocular deprivation decreases the expression of messenger RNA for brain-derived neurotrophic factor in the rat visual cortex

We found that deprivation of pattern vision in one eye, that leaves luminance detection performance unaffected, is sufficient to reduce brain-derived neurotrophic factor (but not trkB) messenger RNA in the visual cortex of young and adult rats. Monocular deprivation by means of eyelids' suture was performed during or after the critical period and the cortical amount of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA was analysed by in situ hybridization and RNAase protection after 15-30 days of deprivation. A reduction of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA was observed in the visual cortex contralateral to the deprived eye in rats monocularly deprived during the critical period. The same reduction was also found in rats monocularly deprived after the end of the critical period, when anatomical or physiological signs of monocular deprivation are absent. The pharmacological blockade of retinal activity equally affected the expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA in young and adults. Quantitative RNAase protection assays revealed that the cortical level of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA was reduced to the same extent when intraocular injections of tetrodotoxin were performed within or after the critical period. A developmental study of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA expression in rat visual cortex showed a marked increase around the time of natural eye-opening followed by a plateau from postnatal day 20 until adult age. Messenger RNA for the kinasic domain of brain-derived neurotrophic factor receptor (trkB) was found in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus and the visual cortex during development and in adults. Our results suggest that the reduction of brain-derived neurotrophic factor messenger RNA induced by monocular deprivation is related to the absence of pattern vision rather than to the competitive interactions that underlie the effects of monocular deprivation during the critical period.

Neurotrophins and neuronal plasticity

There is increasing evidence that neurotrophins (NTs) are involved in processes of neuronal plasticity besides their well-established actions in regulating the survival, differentiation, and maintenance of functions of specific populations of neurons. Nerve growth factor, brain-derived neurotrophic factor, NT-4/5, and corresponding antibodies dramatically modify the development of the visual cortex. Although the neuronal elements involved have not yet been identified, complementary studies of other systems have demonstrated that NT synthesis is rapidly regulated by neuronal activity and that NTs are released in an activity-dependent manner from neuronal dendrites. These data, together with the observation that NTs enhance transmitter release from neurons that express the corresponding signal-transducing Trk receptors, suggest a role for NTs as selective retrograde messengers that regulate synaptic efficacy.

Involvement of nerve growth factor in visual cortex plasticity

The physiological role of nerve growth factor (NGF), the prototype member of the neurotrophin family, has been widely studied. NGF has been shown to promote survival, sprouting and differentiation of sympathetic ganglion cells and sensory neurons in the peripheral nervous system; it has also been shown to support survival and regeneration of cholinergic neurons in the central nervous system. Recent evidence indicates that NGF is also involved in the neuronal plasticity of the visual cortex. Exogenous supplies of NGF have been shown to interfere with normal processes underlying activity- and age-dependent synaptic modifications in both developing and adult visual cortex. In parallel to these physiological effects, numerous neuronal markers in the visual cortex have been found to be influenced by NGF. Several proposals have been introduced to explain the physiological role of NGF in visual cortex plasticity. Although the mechanisms underlying NGF effects in the visual cortex are still under active investigation, current evidence implies that NGF, and perhaps other neurotrophins as well, may be useful for preventing or correcting inappropriate or anomalous connections in the visual cortex, and thus for treating visual dysfunctions such as amblyopia and strabismus.