Failure of combined costimulatory blockade in animal transplant model

Transplant tolerance: models, concepts and facts

Despite extensive research, our understanding of immunological tolerance to self-antigens is incomplete, and the goal of achieving tolerance to allogeneic transplanted tissue remains elusive. Currently, it is generally believed that the blockade of T cell co-stimulation offers considerable potential for achieving tolerance in the clinical setting. However, the recent finding that CD154-specific antibody may act through the depletion of activated T cells rather than co-stimulation blockade alone highlights the need for a re-evaluation of published data and the role of co-stimulation blockade in transplant tolerance. Activated T cells are programmed to die unless they receive sufficient survival signals in the form of inflammatory and lymphotropic cytokines produced by activated antigen-presenting cells or the T cells themselves. In conditions where the threshold for surviving activation is not reached, for example when a small number of responder T cells are activated in the absence of substantial injury or inflammation, the ensuing death of all activated T cells can result in deletional tolerance. Therefore, we propose that tolerance represents a failure of T cells to survive activation and develop into memory cells. This concept is likely to apply in the transplant setting, where the strength of the alloresponse depends on both the number/phenotype of the recipients' alloreactive T cells and immunogenicity of the transplanted tissue. Hence, in some rodent donor-recipient strain combinations that instigate a weak alloresponse, many treatments that only modestly decrease the alloresponse can achieve tolerance. In contrast, clinical transplantation is characterised by a strong alloresponse and highly immunogenic allografts, and thus, most treatments fail to control allograft rejection, and tolerance is difficult to achieve.

Renal allograft rejection is prevented by adoptive transfer of anergic T cells in nonhuman primates

Anergic T cells generated ex vivo are reported to have immunosuppressive effects in vitro and in vivo. Here, we tested this concept in nonhuman primates. Alloreactive T cells were rendered anergic ex vivo by coculture with donor alloantigen in the presence of anti-CD80/CD86 mAbs before adoptive transfer via renal allograft to rhesus monkey recipients. The recipients were briefly treated with cyclophosphamide and cyclosporine A during the preparation of the anergic cells. Thirteen days after renal transplantation, the anergic T cells were transferred to the recipient, after which no further immunosuppressive agents were administered. Rejection-free survival was prolonged in all treated recipients, and 3 of 6 animals survived long term (410-880 days at study's end). In the long-surviving recipients, proliferative responses against alloantigen were inhibited in a donor-specific manner, and donor-type, but not third-party, skin allografts were also accepted, which demonstrated that antigen-specific tolerance had been induced. We conclude that anergic T cells generated ex vivo by blocking CD28/B7 costimulation can suppress renal allograft rejection after adoptive transfer in nonhuman primates. This strategy may be applicable to the design of safe clinical trials in humans.

Fc-dependent depletion of activated T cells occurs through CD40L-specific antibody rather than costimulation blockade

Although the underlying mechanisms are not well understood, it is generally believed that antigen recognition by T cells in the absence of costimulation may alter the immune response, leading to anergy or tolerance. Further support for this concept comes from animal models of autoimmunity and transplantation, where treatments based on costimulation blockade, in particular CD40 ligand (CD40L)-specific antibodies, have been highly effective. We investigated the mechanisms of action of an antibody to CD40L and provide evidence that its effects are dependent on the constant (Fc) region. Prolongation of graft survival is dependent on both complement- and Fc receptor-mediated mechanisms in a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-mismatched skin transplant model. These data suggest that antibodies to CD40L act through selective depletion of activated T cells, rather than exerting immune modulation by costimulation blockade as currently postulated. This finding opens new avenues for treatment of immune disorders based on selective targeting of activated T cells.

Inhibition of natural killer cells results in acceptance of cardiac allografts in CD28-/- mice

Successful transplantation of allogeneic organs is an important objective in modern medicine. However, sophisticated immune defense mechanisms, primarily evolved to combat infections, often work against medical transplantation. To investigate the roles of natural and adaptive immune responses in transplant rejection, we functionally inactivated key effector systems of the innate (NK cells) and the adaptive immune system (CD28-mediated costimulation of T cells) in mice. Neither of these interventions alone led to acceptance of allogeneic vascularized cardiac grafts. In contrast, inhibition of NK-receptor-bearing cells combined with CD28-costimulation blockade established long-term graft acceptance. These results indicate a concerted interplay between innate and adaptive immune surveillance for graft rejection. Thus we suggest that inactivation of NK-receptor-bearing cells could be a new strategy for successful survival of solid-organ transplants.