An audit of the accuracy of fine needle aspiration using a liquid-based cytology system in the setting of a rapid access breast clinic

Role of Pathologist in the Era of Image-Guided and EUS-Guided Aspirations: A 10-Year Study at a Single Tertiary Care Oncology Institute in North India

BACKGROUND

With improved and readily accessible imaging techniques, the shift in fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) from palpation-guided FNA (PGFNA) to image-guided FNA (IGFNA) and endoscopic ultrasound-guided FNA (EUS-FNA) became evident in last few decades. The present study evaluates the impact of IGFNA and EUS-FNA on the practice of cytopathology at our 300-bedded oncology institute.

STUDY DESIGN

A 10-year audit of three aspiration modalities PGFNA, IGFNA, and EUS-FNA was done. The number of aspirates, inadequacy rates, new patient registration numbers, and tissue biopsy numbers were compared.

RESULTS

A total of 29,610 FNAC were evaluated against a total 141,333 new patient registrations over a period of 10 years. The new cancer patient registration over last 10 years showed a 56% increase, with a comparable increase of 60% in diagnostic biopsies; whereas, the number of FNAC increased by only 6%. This reduction in the number of aspirates was mainly due to fall in the number of PGFNA to 18% of all procedures in the year of 2019 from a high of 44% in 2011. Further, PGFNA showed a reduction by 50% over 3 years. The inadequacy rates of PGFNA increased to 9.1% (in 2019) from 1.6% (in 2012). The IGFNA constituted 46%-60% of procedures, with inadequacy varying from 8.5% to 12.1% over years. The EUS-FNAC gradually increased from 3% to 22% from 2013, and the inadequacy rates were variable overtime showing parallelism with the use of rapid on-site adequacy evaluation (ROSE) by the endoscopist. Inadequacy rates ranged from 7.1% (2013) to 2.6% (2016), 7.7% (2017), and 5.4% (2019).

CONCLUSION

The utility of ROSE and diminishing role of pathologist is highlighted in our study. Judicious ROSE improves diagnostic accuracy, decreases the rate of missed diagnosis and the repetition of procedures. The study sheds light on the ever-increasing lacuna in the training of pathologists for blind as well as in image-guided FNAC. Further, it enumerates the factors leading to the underutilization of ROSE, its undisputed advantages, operator variations in procedure, smear preparation, and screening.

Usefulness of Cytological Scoring Method by Breast Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology on Breast Duct Dilatation and Cystic Lesions

Aim

The objective of this study was to apply a scoring method to fine needle aspiration cytology on breast duct dilatation and cystic lesions, to set an optimum cut-off value to differentiate between benign and malignant cases, and to identify features useful for cell judgment.

Materials and Methods

Samples were 23 preparations of specimens (12 benign and 11 malignant cases) suspected with intraductal lesions or cystic change by ultrasonography or mammography and cytology. The scoring system comprised the following 10 items, and each item was scored 1-3, with a total score of 10-30. Three items were concerning structural atypia: 1, scattered epithelial cells; 2, uneven irregular cluster edge; and 3, overlapping nuclei of epithelial cells, and seven items were concerning cellular atypia: 4, irregular nuclear size; 5, irregular nuclear morphology; 6, deep dyeing chromatin; 7, chromatin granularity; 8, chromatin distribution; 9, nucleolus; and 10, absence of myoepithelial cells.

Results

(1) Scoring cut-off value: malignancy is to be suspected when the score is 20.75 or higher (diagnostic accuracy: 95.7%). (2) Findings useful for cancer judgment: the sensitivity of the following four findings was high: uneven irregular cluster edge, irregular nuclear overlapping, chromatin granularity, and absence of myoepithelial cells. (3) Correlation among the findings: the findings correlated with malignancy were as follows: scattered epithelial cells versus uneven irregular cluster edge (rs = 0.8).

Conclusion

Cytological evaluation by scoring lesions accompanied by intraductal dilatation and cystic change was a useful method capable of differentiating between benign and malignant cases at a high accuracy.

Introduction and utility of liquid-based cytology on aspiration biopsy of peripheral nodular lesions of the lung

In the present study, aspiration biopsy cytology (ABC) was used for the diagnosis of peripheral nodular lesions in the lung (PNLL), and liquid-based cytology (LBC) was carried out on the material collected to evaluate it in comparison with the conventional method (CM). The subjects comprised 130 cases that underwent computed tomography (CT)-guided ABC for PNLL. A total of 73 cases received a tumor resection, with a diagnosis based on the pathology, while 57 cases were followed up, as the tumor showed no change on the radiological examinations. Biopsy samples from these patients and lavage fluid from the aspiration needles were used for analysis. Cellular material was obtained by centrifugation of the lavage fluid, and samples were prepared by two methods, direct smearing and LBC according to the ThinPrep method. The samples were categorized into three diagnoses: i) Benign, ii) suspicion of malignancy and iii) malignant. Appropriate samples were collected in 72% of cases by LBC, but only in 36% of cases by the CM. There was no marked difference in cellular images between the two methods, with the exception of a few specific cases. LBC on its own provided sensitivity at 68%, specificity at 61% and accuracy at 65%, while a combination of LBC and biopsy markedly improved these figures to 94, 81 and 84%, respectively. The introduction of LBC is considered useful for the cytopathological diagnosis of PNLL by CT-guided ABC. LBC enables the examination of appropriate samples rich in cellular components and supports a biopsy-based diagnosis. A combination of these two methods provides even higher diagnostic accuracy, and LBC is considered an excellent method to evaluate these pathological samples.

BSCC Code of Practice--fine needle aspiration cytology

The British Society for Clinical Cytology Code of Practice on fine needle aspiration cytology complements that on exfoliative cytopathology, which was published in the last issue (Cytopathology 2009;20:211-23). Both have been prepared with wide consultation within and outside the BSCC and have been endorsed by the Royal College of Pathologists. A separate code of practice for gynaecological cytopathology is in preparation. Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology is an accepted first line investigation for mass lesions, which may be targeted by palpation or a variety of imaging methods. Although FNA cytology has been shown to be a cost-effective, reliable technique its accurate interpretation depends on obtaining adequately cellular samples prepared to a high standard. Its accuracy and cost-effectiveness can be seriously compromised by inadequate samples. Although cytopathologists, radiologists, nurses or clinicians may take FNAs, they must be adequately trained, experienced and subject to regular audit. The best results are obtained when a pathologist or an experienced and trained biomedical scientist (cytotechnologist) provides immediate on-site assessment of sample adequacy whether or not the FNA requires image-guidance. This COP provides evidence-based recommendations for setting up FNA services, managing the patients, taking the samples, preparing the slides, collecting material for ancillary tests, providing rapid on-site assessment, classifying the diagnosis and providing a final report. Costs, cost-effectiveness and rare complications are taken into account as well as the time and resources required for quality control, audit and correlation of cytology with histology and outcome. Laboratories are expected to have an effective quality management system conforming to the requirements of a recognised accreditation scheme such as Clinical Pathology Accreditation (UK) Ltd.

The role of laboratory processing in determining diagnostic conclusiveness of breast fine needle aspirations: conventional smearing versus a monolayer preparation

Aim:

To compare breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) specimens prepared by conventional smearing (CS) versus monolayer preparation (MP), with respect to the conclusiveness of the cytopathological diagnosis.

Methods:

From 1992 to 1996, aspirators prepared aspirates themselves by direct smearing onto 2–4 slides. From 1999 to 2003, aspirate preparation was performed in the laboratory, creating a MP, using a Hettich cytocentrifuge. FNA diagnoses were categorised into inadequate (C1), benign (C2), atypical (C3), suspicious for malignancy (C4) and malignant (C5). The reference standard constituted histological follow-up. A conclusive FNA diagnosis was defined as C2 in lesions benign on follow-up and C5 in lesions malignant on histology.

Results:

From 1992 to 1996, 692 aspirates were processed by CS, whereas from 1999 to 2003, 1301 aspirates were processed by MP. More FNA were ultrasound-guided in the MP group (85.6% versus 21.5%, p<0.001). When compared with CS, MP-prepared FNA had conclusive diagnoses significantly more often (72.8% versus 58.5%, p<0.001). This effect remained significant when corrected for the difference in ultrasound guidance (adjusted odds ratio 1.7, 95% confidence interval 1.3 to 2.2, p<0.001), and was larger for malignant lesions than for benign lesions (51.7% versus 79.9%, p<0.001).

Conclusion:

Patients presenting with breast lesions can more often be offered a same-day, conclusive cytopathological diagnosis when FNA are prepared by a manual MP processing technique.

[Fine-needle aspiration cytology. Aspects of a minimally invasive diagnostic procedure]

All practicable applications of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) for palpable tumors or non-palpable lesions guided with endoscopic and imaging procedures are presented. Multidisciplinary procedures and the technical and biological aspects of FNAC are presented. Indications and diagnostic challenges of FNAC on selected organs and neoplasms are discussed based on personal experience and the literature. Skilled and well-trained cytopathologists, the quality of the aspirate and the cytological preparation as well as supplementary immunocytochemical and molecular genetic analyses are mandatory for reliable diagnostic results. The indications and advantages of liquid-based techniques are discussed.

Fine-needle aspiration cytology of medullary breast carcinoma: report of two cases and review of the literature with emphasis on differential diagnosis

Medullary carcinoma is a rare variant of breast carcinoma with a relatively good clinical prognosis as strictly defined. Characteristic features on fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) allow medullary carcinoma to be considered in the cytologic differential diagnosis. We present two FNAC cases with such features, including high cellularity with clusters and single intact malignant cells, bizarre stripped nuclei with prominent nucleoli in a lymphoplasmacytic background, and illustrate one case in liquid-based preparation. Surgical excision revealed that one patient had medullary carcinoma, while the second patient had high-grade infiltrating ductal carcinoma. Breast FNAC samples with syncytial fragments, bizarre nuclei with prominent nucleoli, and a chronic inflammatory infiltrate should raise the possibility of medullary carcinoma. However, the differential diagnosis also includes high-grade ductal carcinoma, lymphoma, or metastasis to breast or intramammary lymph nodes; thus, histopathologic analysis is required for definitive diagnosis.

Inadequate rates are lower when FNAC samples are taken by cytopathologists

Inadequate rates (IR) in FNAC from different sources were compared. The rates were lowest when FNAC was performed by a cytopathologist (12%) and highest when done by a non-cytopathologist (32%). These differences were mirrored in high IRs in breast cancer cases. IR was not significantly improved when non-cytopathologist FNAC was attended by a cytotechnician.