Generating Expectations: What Pediatric Rehabilitation Can Learn From Mental Health Literature

What makes Indonesian government officials believe in and implement evidence-based policy: The mediating role of religion-science compatibility beliefs

This research is aimed at examining the relationship between religion-science compatibility belief (RSCB) and evidence-based policy (EBP) belief and implementation in Indonesia, a country with the biggest Muslim population in the world. A dataset containing responses to a questionnaire completed by 499 government officials in Indonesia was collected for the partial least square structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM). This study finds a relationship between RSCB and EBP belief and implementation. In addition, EBP belief also affected the implementation of EBP. The effect that RSCB has on EBP implementation was partially mediated by EBP belief. Studying how these beliefs relate to the attitude of policy makers toward science in a sociocultural context is important, considering that the focus of previous research is on different contexts pertaining to levels of education, industrialization, wealth, and democratization. This is important to encourage a more comprehensive understanding of the public about science globally. This study responds to the need for the literature to examine factors influencing EBP beliefs and implementation at the individual level in non-health contexts and developing countries.

Strategies Used by Professionals in Pediatric Rehabilitation to Engage the Child in the Intervention Process: A Scoping Review

AIM

To investigate strategies used by professionals in pediatric rehabilitation to engage children in every step of the intervention process, including assessment, goal setting, planning and implementation of the intervention, and results evaluation.

METHODS

A scoping literature review was conducted, and seven databases were searched, including CINAHL and MEDLINE, ProQuest Central, PsycINFO, Social Science Premium Collection, PubMed, and Web of Science. A citation search of included articles was completed. Predetermined criteria, quality standards, and PIO framework guided the selection process. Results were presented in relation to Self-Determination Theory (SDT) and the contextual model of therapeutic change.

RESULTS

In total, 20 studies were included in the review. Pediatric professionals reported that therapeutic use of self and their own engagement in the intervention facilitated the establishment of a supportive relationship. Providing clear explanations about their role and therapy rationale developed positive expectations. By making the child feel successful within-session and outside-session activities, professionals enhanced child mastery. Professionals' strategies were abstractly described.

CONCLUSIONS

Further research is needed to investigate strategies that are effective in the different steps of the intervention. More observational, longitudinal studies are required to capture fluctuations in in-session engagement.

Negotiating expectations for therapy between mothers and service providers: a narrative analysis

PURPOSE

To use stories about mothers and service providers negotiating expectations for therapy to illuminate processes contributing to power differences within partnerships.

METHODS

This narrative study presented stories from three mothers and three service providers. Stories were co-constructed between participants and researchers and analyzed using narrative analysis. Building on An and Palisano's (2014) Model of Family-Professional Collaboration, stories were organized into the stages of goal setting, planning, and doing therapy.

RESULTS

Each story illuminated a process unique to that story that can redistribute power between mothers, service providers, and therapy environments while negotiating expectations: protecting sacred issues, facilitating knowledge exposure, filling voids/vacuums, recognizing cultural conditioning, re-discovering eclipsed roles, and connecting relay teams. We propose including three additional strategies to An and Palisano's model to increase the readiness of mothers and service providers to negotiate expectations for therapy and collaborate fully as the model intends: 1) exploring power-sharing conversations; 2) looking for social context clues; and 3) adopting a humility stance.

CONCLUSION

Information on the six illuminated processes can help structure a client story grounded in optimal negotiation of expectations and equal partnerships.Implications for RehabilitationKnowledge of diverse stories about mothers and service providers negotiating expectations for therapy can be a resource to guide actions in related situations.Leaving the topic of expectations for therapy implicit or unchallenged increases the risks that negotiations remain unbalanced and unproductive.Service providers may enhance collaboration with mothers in paediatric rehabilitation by exploring power-sharing conversations, looking for social context clues, and adopting a humility stance.

Acceptability of a Multimodal Telerehabilitation Intervention for Children Ages 3-8 Years with Motor Difficulties: Results of a Qualitative Study

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to explore the acceptability of a telerehabilitation intervention provided to parents of children with motor difficulties.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Sixteen parents of children were purposefully recruited to participate in semi-structured interviews aimed at assessing the acceptability of the telerehabilitation intervention. Interviews were analyzed thematically.

RESULTS

All participants described evolving acceptability associated with their interactions with the web platform. The opportunities generated, suitability in relation to families' values and perceived effects positively impacted acceptability. The understanding and consistency of intervention delivery, the child's level of involvement, the associated parental burden of the intervention and the therapeutic alliances created also affected acceptability.

CONCLUSION

Our study findings support the acceptability of a telerehabilitation intervention for families of children with motor difficulties. Telerehabilitation seems to be more acceptable to families with children without suspected or confirmed diagnoses.

Expectations for therapy in pediatric rehabilitation: reframing meaning through metaphor

PURPOSE

To propose a holistic approach and an accompanying tool to facilitate conversations about expectations of therapy in pediatric rehabilitation based on meanings generated through metaphor.

METHODS

In this study, five parents and nine service providers took part in narrative interviews. Topics included the content and development of expectations over time. Participants reviewed written summaries of their interviews and provided feedback. Data analysis was grounded in a narrative methodological approach. Multiple levels of meaning from participant experiences were constructed through a parallel thematic analysis and metaphor analysis, revealing meaning participants attributed to expectations directly, and inferred indirectly.

RESULTS

The thematic analysis produced three themes related to the difficult to define characteristics and mixed value of expectations. The metaphor analysis produced four metaphorical concepts related to how expectations affect the therapy process by adding a sense of Force (i.e., therapy momentum), Appreciation (i.e., understanding of the client), Illumination (i.e., envisioning new therapy activities), and Relationship (i.e., therapeutic rapport).

CONCLUSIONS

We propose the "F.A.I.R." approach and tool comprising terminology that can help reframe the meaning of expectations away from focusing on binary realistic or unrealistic outcomes, and toward focusing on a plurality of optimal therapy processes.Implications for RehabilitationMeaningful conversations about expectations for therapy between parents and service providers in pediatric rehabilitation can be challenging, one-sided, or missed.Attention to metaphors used to describe expectations for therapy introduces additional terminology parents and service providers may use to help facilitate conversations.Service providers are encouraged to use a resource proposed here to learn about parents' expectations for therapy through a collaborative process involving shared questioning, observation, and reflection.

Using the PODCI to Measure Motor Function and Parent Expectations in Children With Cerebral Palsy

OBJECTIVE

Involving parents in the evaluation of their child with cerebral palsy (CP) is associated with enhanced neurodevelopmental outcomes. The pediatric outcomes data collection instrument (PODCI) is a patient-reported outcome measure primarily used to assess motor function following orthopedic surgical intervention or for older children with more independent motor function. The PODCI expectations scale has infrequently been reported in previous studies. This study aims to determine the relationship between parent-reported motor performance using the PODCI and motor capacity assessed by pediatric therapists for young children with CP across all ability levels and to explore the use of the PODCI expectations scale for quantifying therapy-related parent expectations.

METHODS

This prospective cohort study included 108 participants with CP, 2 to 8 years of age, gross motor function classification systems (GMFCS) levels I to V. Measures included the PODCI, gross motor function measure (GMFM), and GMFCS.

RESULTS

There were moderate (r = 0.513) to large (r = 0.885) relationships between PODCI and GMFM scores. PODCI scores were significantly different across GMFCS levels. Weak, significant relationships (r = -0.28) were found between function expectations scores and measures of function.

CONCLUSION

The PODCI, GMFM, and GMFCS provide different, but strongly related, information about the abilities of young children. The GMFM measures motor capacity. Parents report daily function and health-related quality of life for their child using the PODCI. Parent expectations for intervention outcomes may relate to a child's motor function.

IMPACT

These study results are consistent with those for older children with greater independent mobility, indicating an opportunity for expanded use of the PODCI for measuring motor performance for younger children with CP across all ability levels. A strategy is provided for using the PODCI expectations scale to quantify parent therapy-related expectations in future research and clinical settings. Therapy-related expectations may relate to child outcomes.

A scoping review of parental roles in rehabilitation interventions for children with developmental delay, disability, or long-term health condition

The importance of parental roles in rehabilitation interventions (i.e. the tasks and responsibilities assigned to parents in intervention) is widely reported but there is a paucity of information regarding the tasks linked with specific parental roles. A rigorous scoping review was conducted to understand the various roles that parents of children with developmental delays, disabilities, and long-term health conditions perform in intervention and the tasks and responsibilities associated with each role. The results confirm that parents take on distinct intervention roles which can be placed on a continuum from passive to active responsibility. Some parental roles are clearly associated with tasks completed in-session, some are linked with out-of-session tasks while others entail a combination of in-and out-of-session tasks. The in-session tasks linked with the Learner role emerged as central to enabling parents to assume other in-and out-of-session roles. The results also highlight the influence of the parent-professional relationship on the type of roles parents take on in their child's intervention. The findings of the scoping review serve as the initial step in generating items for a tool to measure the type of roles that parents assume in intervention to empirically test the relationship between these roles and parental engagement.

Exploring the complexity of how families are engaged in early speech-language pathology intervention using video-reflexive ethnography

BACKGROUND

Despite being an important aspect of effective early intervention service delivery, 'engagement' has been inconsistently defined in paediatric healthcare. Previous research has identified that engagement in early speech-language pathology intervention is complex and multifaceted. However, more research is needed to understand the ways that different families may engage with intervention in different settings.

AIMS

To explore the complexity of engagement in early speech-language pathology intervention from the perspectives of both families and their speech-language pathologists (SLPs).

METHOD & PROCEDURES

Video-reflexive ethnography was used to explore engagement with 21 matched SLP-family dyads in early intervention services. Up to three intervention appointments for each participating family were video recorded. Short video segments were selected and played to participants during individual semi-structured interviews where participants were invited to reflect on the interactions captured (i.e., 'video-reflexive sessions'). Interview data were analysed using thematic analysis.

OUTCOMES & RESULTS

Results from the interview data were organized into one overarching theme 'Families may have "different levels of engagement"', and four individual themes that reflected how families engage differently in various aspects of intervention, including (1) attending sessions and coming into the room; (2) actively participating in sessions; (3) continuing to actively participate outside sessions; and (4) having open and honest communication with their SLPs.

CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS

Families may have different levels of engagement in various aspects of intervention, which contribute to their unique profile of engagement. Findings of this study prompt SLPs to move beyond using blanket statements about whether or not families are engaged, to instead describing in detail how families are uniquely engaged. What this paper adds What is already known on the subject In early speech-language pathology intervention, the term 'engagement' refers to (1) a complex, multifaceted state of families 'being engaged' in intervention both inside and outside sessions; and (2) a relational, co-constructed process where many families 'become engaged' in intervention as they work together with SLPs. Although research has acknowledged engagement may look different for each parent and family, little is known about how families are uniquely engaged in early speech pathology intervention in different settings. What this paper adds to existing knowledge This study is the first to explore engagement from the perspectives of both families and SLPs working together in intervention. Both groups of participants described the complexity of engagement in this setting and acknowledged that families engage differently in different aspects of intervention, which contribute to their unique profile of engagement. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? Being able to identify potential indicators of engagement, such as the ones described in this study, provide opportunities for SLPs to take a reflexive approach to engaging with individual families, in line with principles of family-centred care. Findings of this study therefore prompt SLPs to reflect on how the families they work with are engaged in intervention, and to consider their own role in facilitating engagement. In addition, results highlight the importance of SLPs initiating open conversations with families themselves about how they would like to be engaged in intervention, and what support would be most beneficial to them.

Speech-language-hearing therapy and clinical listening in a mental health team: perception of parents of children with autism spectrum disorder

ABSTRACT Purpose: to analyze the effects of clinical listening in the discourse of parents of children with autism about the speech-language-hearing work in the team of a Children and Youth Psychosocial Attention Center (Centro de Atenção Psicossocial Infanto-Juvenil). Methods: a descriptive case study research with nine parents of children with autism. Results: the parents recognize, in the therapeutic experience with the speech-language-hearing therapist, changes in the quality of communication and relationship with their children, becoming more linguistically open and interesting figures to their children, because they understand the communication dynamics and feel ready to develop it. The parents incorporated the idea that it is through a shared playing that their children develop both subjectively and cognitively. They realize that the change and interaction with and between their children, as proposed by the speech-language-hearing therapy, generate care and enlarge the social repertoire of communication. Conclusion: speech-language-hearing therapy was considered as belonging and fundamental to the field of mental health in the work with children with autism, which reinforces the listening offered to the parents by the team.

'I Didn't Know What to Expect': Describing Parents' Expectations in Children's Rehabilitation Services

Aims: The aim of this paper is to provide a holistic description of the nature, formation and impact of parents' therapy related expectations.Methods: This qualitative descriptive study drew from initial and follow up interviews with 20 parents of children ≤ 6 years who had a developmental disability or delay and used therapy services at a children's treatment center in Ontario, Canada. Conventional content analysis was used to inductively generate themes and investigator triangulation was completed.Results: Parent's child related expectations focused on whether the child would receive a diagnosis and what they might achieve. Parents held expectations about the availability of service and how it would be offered. Parents' expectations of service providers included their knowledge, skills, relationships and communication with the children and parents. Parents held expectations of themselves related to attendance and roles in therapy sessions and home practice. These expectations are described according to how they are shaped and changed them over time. The impact of matched/mismatched expectations is explored.Conclusion: Service providers can improve family-centred care and collaboration with parents by explicitly discussing parents' expectations when beginning, and throughout, therapy. Parent satisfaction and therapy engagement may improve if parents and service providers negotiate and agree upon expectations.

The complexities and synergies of engagement: an ethnographic study of engagement in outpatient pediatric rehabilitation sessions

PURPOSE

To investigate client (youth/caregiver) and service provider engagement in outpatient pediatric rehabilitation therapy sessions.

METHODS

In an ethnographic study, five research assistants attended 28 outpatient sessions, mostly delivered by occupational, physical, and speech-language therapists, and rated signs of client, provider, and relational engagement using the Pediatric Rehabilitation Intervention Measure of Engagement - Observation version. Post-session interviews were conducted individually with 13 youth, 15 caregivers, and 26 providers.

RESULTS

Overall, there was a moderate to great extent of engagement. Provider engagement was rated as higher than client engagement, particularly in sessions with activities focusing on body structure/function. The interviews indicated associations among engagement-related constructs: (a) expectations influenced engagement/disengagement and therapy progress, (b) engagement was associated with positive affect and relationships, and (c) engagement was strongly associated with relationships and collaboration.

CONCLUSIONS

Engagement is a central process within a complex system of psychosocial constructs operating in therapy. Engagement is emergent, synergistic, and change-inducing - it emanates from, involves, and influences multiple aspects of therapy. Notably, engagement ties two pivotal elements - positive expectations and positive affect - to positive relationships, collaboration, and therapy progress. Implications for practice include an understanding of how providers manage the therapeutic context and work to foster engagement.Implications for rehabilitationEngagement, and its various elements, plays a central role in shaping how clients, parents, and clinicians value therapeutic encounters.Optimal therapy is often thought to include engagement, relationships, and collaboration; the importance of therapy expectations, positive affect, and perceptions of progress are frequently overlooked.Engagement and motivation may be maximized when youth and caregivers are asked explicitly about how they view their engagement in therapy.In addition to clarifying and aligning expectations with youth and caregivers, service providers can enhance engagement and motivation by intentionally creating enjoyable and meaningful interactions, developing relationships, negotiating consensus on goals and plans, and demonstrating therapy progress.Service providers can harness engagement and the system of related constructs by listening and communicating effectively, by entering the world of the client and family, and by being aware of, anticipating, and responding to engagement and disengagement.