Binding of d-tubocurarine to plasma proteins in normal man and in patients with hepatic or renal disease

Simulation of the kinetics of neuromuscular block: implications for speed of onset

BACKGROUND

The onset time for paralysis varies 3-fold among nondepolarizing muscle relaxants. Possible explanations include: (a) pharmacokinetic differences among drugs and (b) buffering of drug molecules by acetylcholine receptors as they diffuse into the neuromuscular junction. Although some pharmacokinetic models consider buffered diffusion, these models do not account for either the high density of receptors or synapse geometry. Here, I used computer simulations to calculate the kinetics of buffered diffusion. The goal was to determine the conditions under which buffered diffusion could account for differences in onset time among nondepolarizing muscle relaxants.

METHODS

Monte Carlo simulation was used along with a realistic 3-dimensional model of the rat neuromuscular junction. Simulations determined the time dependence of the number of drug-bound receptors. A 1000-fold range of drug potency was examined. In some simulations, the drug concentration outside the junction was changed instantaneously. In other simulations, the concentration changed according to predictions of pharmacokinetic models assuming time-dependent changes in plasma drug concentration. The rate constant for equilibration of drug between plasma and muscle, keo, was varied between 0.15 and 0.6 min(-1). Twitch amplitude was calculated from receptor occupancy assuming a high safety margin for neuromuscular transmission. Some simulations used a synaptic model with an increased nerve-muscle contact width.

RESULTS

Simulations with instantaneous changes in drug concentration at the synapse, indicated that the time to 50% twitch depression (onset time) was 0.1 to 30 seconds and was proportional to drug potency. This corresponds to iontophoretic application of drug to isolated neuromuscular junctions, but is too fast to explain onset times in humans. When pharmacokinetic models were used to calculate the drug concentration outside the synapse, buffered diffusion increased onset times of potent drugs (drugs for which the effective concentration at 50% twitch height is <600 nM). Simulations using keo = 0.6 min(-1) and a model with a 2- to 3-fold wider nerve-muscle contact width indicated that buffered diffusion could account for the differences in clinical onset times among the nondepolarizing muscle relaxants.

CONCLUSION

Monte Carlo simulation provides a biophysically appropriate way to incorporate buffered diffusion into pharmacokinetic modeling. The simulations indicated that buffered diffusion could account for differences in onset time among drugs. However, a better understanding of the geometry of the human neuromuscular junction is needed before the magnitude of the effect of buffered diffusion can be quantified.

Selecting neuromuscular-blocking drugs for elderly patients

The physiological changes that occur with increasing age can have significant effects on the pharmacokinetics of neuromuscular-blocking drugs. Changes in cardiac output can affect drug distribution and therefore the speed of onset of neuromuscular block. A decrease in muscle mass and increase in body fat with age can also affect their distribution. The deterioration in renal and hepatic function associated with aging affects the clearance and elimination of many neuromuscular-blocking drugs. The effects of these physiological changes on the pharmacokinetics of neuromuscular-blocking agents may not become apparent clinically in healthy individuals until the age of at least 75 years. There is very little evidence to suggest any alteration in the sensitivity of the neuromuscular junction to neuromuscular-blocking drugs with increasing age. Neuromuscular-blocking drugs that undergo a significant degree of organ-dependent elimination, such as pancuronium bromide, vecuronium bromide, rocuronium bromide and doxacurium chloride, may have a significantly prolonged duration of action in elderly patients. These drugs can be used safely in elderly patients if the anaesthetist is aware of their altered pharmacokinetics in this patient group. Appropriate changes must be made to drug dosage and dose intervals. As the pharmacokinetic changes can be unpredictable, monitoring of neuromuscular block is strongly advised when using these drugs in such patients. The risk of residual block occurring postoperatively after the use of pancuronium bromide increases with age. The duration of action of mivacurium chloride may also be prolonged in the elderly; this change has not been demonstrated to be a result of an alteration in plasma cholinesterase activity. In contrast, there is no evidence of an alteration in the action of suxamethonium chloride (succinylcholine chloride) with increasing age. Atracurium besilate and cisatracurium besilate undergo predominantly organ-independent elimination. Onset of block with these two drugs may be prolonged in the elderly, but their clinical duration of action does not alter significantly with age, making them particularly suitable for use in this patient group. Although atracurium besilate may cause histamine release, there is little evidence of it producing haemodynamic changes in the elderly. Its (1R,1R')-isomer, cisatracurium besilate, has very little direct or indirect cardiovascular effect and is, therefore, the most suitable nondepolarising agent to use in elderly patients.

In vitro plasma protein binding of neuromuscular blocking agents in different subpopulations of patients

In vitro protein binding of several neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs) was measured by ultrafiltration in plasma from patients susceptible to demonstrate changes in their protein constituents. First, the relationship between the free fraction of atracurium and plasma lipoproteins levels in young volunteers (22-32 yr old, n = 6) and hyperlipidemic patients (44-68 yr old, n = 13) was studied, and second, the free fraction of atracurium, mivacurium, doxacurium, and vecuronium was determined in plasma of healthy young (27-47 yr old, n = 10), elderly (72-89 yr old, n = 11) and obese (21-57 yr old, n = 9, 200%-360% ideal body weight) patients scheduled for elective surgery. In hyperlipidemic patients, atracurium free fraction was significantly less than in young volunteers (40% +/- 5% vs 50% +/- 5%, mean +/- SD), and decreased as total cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol and triglycerides increased (P < 0.05). In young individuals, NMBA free fraction was 25% +/- 5% for vecuronium, 58% +/- 8% for doxacurium, 52% +/- 6% for atracurium, and 72% +/- 3%, 70% +/- 3%, 70% +/- 4% for mivacurium trans-trans, cis-trans, and cis-cis isomers, respectively. Higher triglyceride concentrations in obese patients and lower high-density-lipoprotein cholesterol concentrations in both obese and elderly patients were observed when compared with young subjects. However, there was no significant difference in protein binding of NMBAs among these three groups. We conclude that, in otherwise healthy patients, age and weight are not likely to alter the free fraction of NMBAs.

Mivacurium in special patient groups

In special patient groups, drug response may be different from that in the healthy adult patient. Mivacurium dose requirements vary with age, and children require larger doses to obtain any given degree of block, but the elderly often require smaller doses. However, the dose requirements of the neonate do not necessarily differ greatly from those of the adult. There is a relationship between the duration of action of a bolus dose as well as infusion requirements to maintain block and the plasma cholinesterase activity. Patients with renal disease may have a decreased cholinesterase activity and may require smaller doses of mivacurium. Patients with severe liver disease may have a marked decrease in cholinesterase activity, and in these patients a substantially smaller dose of the drug may be needed to obtain and maintain any given degree of block. If the variation in dose requirements is kept in mind and the degree of block appropriately monitored, mivacurium may be used with safety in special patient groups, such as children, the elderly, or those with renal or hepatic impairment.

Muscle relaxants in renal disease

The use of neuromuscular blocking drugs during anaesthesia for patients with chronic renal failure is discussed. The disadvantages of the older non-depolarizing agents, such as tubocurarine, alcuronium, and pancuronium are outlined, as are the significant benefits of the use of atracurium or vecuronium in these patients. Preliminary reports on the new non-depolarizing drugs, pipecuronium, mivacurium, doxacurium, and rocuronium are also noted.

Clinical pharmacology of the neuromuscular blocking agents

Neuromuscular blocking agents are among the most commonly used drugs during general anesthesia. They compete with acetylcholine and interfere with the transmission of nerve impulses resulting in skeletal muscle relaxation. Based on their mechanism of action, neuromuscular blocking agents are classified as either depolarizing or nondepolarizing. Succinylcholine is a short-acting depolarizing agent. Commonly used nondepolarizing agents are curare (long-acting), pancuronium (long-acting), atracurium (intermediate-acting), and vecuronium (intermediate-acting). Neuromuscular blocking agents are used clinically to facilitate endotracheal intubation and to provide skeletal muscle relaxation during surgery. This article provides an overview of the physiology of the neuromuscular transmission and summarizes our current knowledge on the use of these agents during general anesthesia.

Dose-response of tubocurarine in patients with and without renal failure

Different initial doses of tubocurarine (0.1, 0.2, 0.3 and 0.4 mg kg-1) were given to 20 patients with and 20 patients without renal failure (RF) during standard anaesthesia. Neuromuscular blockade was registered with a device based on electromyography. A fluorescent technique was used to measure plasma tubocurarine concentrations, for which blood samples were drawn during induction and at reversal of neuromuscular block. The dose-response curves for the induction period were slightly steeper in patients with RF. A linear correlation between tubocurarine concentration and twitch response was found in both groups, although the curve had shifted to the left in RF patients. The total amount of tubocurarine used for surgical relaxation was lower in the RF than in the non-RF patients.

Alteration of drug-protein binding in renal disease

The protein binding of acidic drugs but not basic drugs is decreased in serum from patients with poor renal function. This decreased binding is due to the retention of compounds that displace drugs from their binding sites on albumin. Phenytoin and valproic acid are the 2 drugs that require a change in the values for therapeutic levels to allow for this decreased binding.

Anaesthesia for the patient with impaired renal function

Patients with renal disease are at risk of further deterioration of renal function and acute tubular necrosis when subjected to anaesthesia and surgery. Optimal fluid loading and careful selection of anaesthetic techniques and agents, appropriate monitoring and the use of mannitol and dopamine assist in the maintenance of renal blood flow and help preserve renal function in these patients. In association with renal failure, physiological changes in other systems result in reduced oxygen supply to the tissues, metabolic disturbances, impairment of the coagulation and immune defence mechanisms and an increased risk of cardiac and cerebrovascular catastrophe. Although many anaesthetic techniques including regional analgesia may be used successfully in these patients caution with most drugs, especially pethidine, phenoperidine, suxamethonium and all non-depolarising neuromuscular relaxants is recommended. Of the volatile anaesthetics currently available, halothane is the agent of choice. Oxygen therapy and close monitoring of cardiorespiratory function are necessary postoperatively.

Gallamine disposition in surgical patients with chronic renal failure

1 Plasma levels of gallamine and the elicited neuromuscular response have been measured in seven patients with compromised renal function who received a single 2 mg/kg dose and in a further patient who received an initial dose of 2 mg/kg followed by two additional doses of 1 mg/kg. 2 The plasma level-time data from all patients was adequately explained by a biexponential equation interpreted as a two-compartment open mammillary model. 3 Comparison of the model-independent pharmacokinetic parameters for gallamine between these patients and a group of normal patients revealed that the elimination phase half-life (T and one-half beta) was significantly prolonged in renal failure with a marked reduction in the plasma clearance of gallamine. 4 Gallamine had larger apparent volumes of distribution in the presence of renal failure than those found in normal patients. 5 The peak paralysis levels attained and the associated plasma concentrations of gallamine were similar in patients with and without renal failure. 6 At this low dosage the rate of recovery from paralysis in renal failure patients, though similar to that noted normally, appeared to be somewhat slower in some patients. 7. The results suggest that gallamine is not to be preferred to other nondepolarizing muscle relaxants in patients with renal failure.

Disease-induced changes in the plasma binding of basic drugs

The plasma binding of basic (cationic) drugs differs from that of the more completely studied acidic drugs. Basic drugs associate with a number of plasma constituents. alpha 1-Acid glycoprotein, lipoprotein, and albumin all appear to play an important role in the binding of most of these drugs. Acidic drugs bind largely to albumin. The variation in plasma albumin is relatively narrow and is almost always in the direction of decreased concentrations. alpha 1-Acid glycoprotein and lipoproteins show large fluctuations due both to physiological and pathological conditions. Decreases and increases in concentration have been observed. Associated with these changes in binding proteins, both decreases and increases in plasma binding of basic drugs have been recorded. Increased binding with disease appears to be virtually unique to basic drugs. The implications of these newly described disease-induced increases in plasma binding have yet to be explored. With the limited information in hand the following consequences are predicted. Increased binding will tend to decrease the volume of distribution of total (bound plus free) drug. The clearance will be unchanged or decreased depending upon the initial clearance of the drug and the avidity of the protein binding. As the half-life depends upon both clearance and volume of distribution, changes in it will be variable, depending upon changes in these two parameters. It is predicted that the area under the free drug plasma concentration-time curve will decrease with increasing binding after an intravenous dose while it will be unchanged after an oral dose. The relationship of total drug plasma concentration to free drug concentration will change with changes in binding. Thus plasma concentration monitoring of drug therapy by use of total drug concentrations will be inaccurate in situations in which large variations in binding occur. Misinterpretations of both therapeutic monitoring and pharmacokinetics studies in disease states with altered binding are likely unless these changes are appreciated.

Tubocurarine and pancuronium: a pharmacokinetic view

This review is an attempt to bring together the pharmacokinetic data on d-tubocurarine and pancuronium with clinical observations on relaxant dosage and effect. The modelling techniques used here represent an oversimplification of the relationships between relaxant plasma concentration and response as they do not predict either the time of onset of paralysis or its peak intensity. However, they do enable calculation of a bolus dose of relaxant required to achieve a particular intensity of paralysis for the average patient once pseudo-distribution equilibrium has been achieved. This has been further extended to predict the cumulation of the relaxants with subsequent dosage in average patients. Suggested regimens incorporating bolus and infusion doses of the relaxants to achieve continuous neuromuscular blockade have been calculated also. Averaged pharmacokinetic parameters derived from patients with renal or hepatic dysfunction have been used to predict the likely duration and intensities of paralysis for the relaxants.

Studies on muscle relaxants during haemodialysis

Signs of neuromuscular block were evident more than 20 hours after the administration of alcuronium to an anuric patient. Complete recovery occurred during haemodialysis. We therefore decided to study the dialysance of three radioactive non-depolarising relaxants during haemodialysis of four patients with chronic renal failure. Although dimethyl tubocurarine and alcuronium were equal as regards dialysance, the concentration of the former, in plasma, falls faster than does alcuronium. It is believed that a larger volume of distribution occurs with dimethyl tubocurarine. In spite of the fact that the dialysance of muscle relaxants is small, haemodialysis might lower the concentration of these substances in the plasma to a level below the critical point which produces paralysis.

The binding of drugs to plasma proteins and the interpretation of measurements of plasma concentrations of drugs in patients with poor renal function

The intensity of a drug's action is related to its concentration in plasma water. Since the analytical methods for determining concentrations of drugs in plasma measure this as well as the drug bound to plasma proteins, evaluation of the binding of drugs to plasma proteins is needed for proper interpretation of drug level measurements. Anionic drugs have decreased binding in plasma from patients with renal failure. With some, such as phenytoin, a reduction is required in the levels usually considered "therapeutic" for uremic patients. Basic drugs may have normal or decreased binding. Propranolol, quinidine and tricyclic antidepressants are drugs in this class that have normal binding and that do not require changes in the plasma levels usually considered "therapeutic" for these patients.

Protein binding of salicylate and quinidine in plasma from patients with renal failure, chronic liver disease and chronic respiratory insufficiency

The plasma protein binding of a representative acidic drug, salicylate, and a representative basic drug, quinidine, has been studied in patients with several diseases that are sometimes associated with uraemia or a change in serum albumin level. Decreased plasma protein binding of salicylate was observed in plasma from patients with uraemia and liver disease. Low albumin levels in these patients could only account inpart for the decreased binding. On the other hand, salicylate binding to plasma proteins appeared to be increased in patients with hypoxia. Decreased plasma protein binding of quinidine was observed in some patients with uraemia and in the majority of patients with liver disease.